Indeed, and the people that are upset about it should just go watch other reaction channels, the analysis and explaining are what makes his videos perfect.
@@lorcan8484, well, if you don't want pausing then go watch the original video. As with all reactions, the point is also to support the original video. Watch D-low's reaction and then the original video or vice versa and you get both commentary and no pausing.
D-low is definitely going to be very shocked by who made it in and who didn't. At this point I can see half of who he put in the top 8 not in the top 8 based on who I know the judges put through.
Yeah, favoritism has always been a thing in beatbox sadly. It's understandable why it happens, as you would obviously want the most well known people there, but it makes it harder for newcomers too.
alex and julard shouldn't even get in they never deserves , feel bad for others like stitch and blackroll who didn't pass the eliminations cuz of these 2 french
03:24 Please tell this to the future GBB judging panel because i agree with this statement. Although, i wouldn't have placed Alexinho top 8 we still need constructive conversation about what power means in a competition.
I love Alexinho but this definitely gave a vibe of overconfidence. His cleanliness and inner metronome is undeniable but it’s just not enough. Can’t underestimate the new guys.
It's obvious, we have legend beatboxers but bad judges at this years, there was a huge mistakes in judging, stitch not in top 8, osis doesn't win GBB, undeserved win for Julard etc..
@@turkix57 My comment is not meant to say whether you're right or wrong. I just want to clarify that it's not the same to judge live on stage as it is through a video where the sound has been edited and adjusted. In fact, when Dlow was a judge during previous GBBs, viewers didn't always agree with his judgment, particularly during the Alem vs Elisii match, just to give you an example. I think it would be better to stop blaming the judges for their decisions. I believe they understand beatboxing far better than we do; let's not forget that almost all of them have been GBB champions, and as a result, they are legitimate to judge.
@@turkix57yall are jus following yall feelings ,if stitch made it in top 8 it would make sense but even if he didn’t it would also make sense stitch style is just not it especially if your the first one to do an elim,osis didn’t deserve to win the final jualrd was clear loud and efficient yall can’t accept that but i wonder if they wasn’t french what would be the next excuse 🤔
I really appreciate the polyrhythms and how he tights up the whole piece at the end, however I feel there were better structured eliminations than this one. Good to know I'm not completely deaf
I felt like that elimination was biased to french, Julard and Alexinho performance couldn't be compared to stitches and they passed and stitches didn't pass 😅
Some of the people on your list ranked quite a bit higher and made it in, simply because of how much power they have and how loud they were in the venue
this gives the same energy as PACMax's elim, and honestly PACMax did more. Idk how he ended up so high in the actual placements. I wrote this before seeing Dlow's ranking and its exactly where I would have put it wow. Sign me up as a GBB judge lol
Genuinely one of the worst elims in GBB history... insane. I think the only reason Stitch is hated and Alex got in is because Alex is good at battling, and stitch is kinda only know for elims... The decision should not be made on external biases like, "oh, well this guy can battle and we don't think this one can." It should be purely based on the Elimination.
@@felixschneider1398 I think he means Alex got in because of what the judges think he can do, not based on what he did in the moment. That's unfair to people like Stitch who may not have the best battle track record but had an amazing performance in the moment.
@@Neon1880 sounds werent consistent, the clickroll volume was inconsistent also and overall in the end the drops were easy and, at the same time, not as powerful or consistent as Heliums or Julards
@@roboket3524 true, but Stitch and DEN really stood out and went very off meta, but got scored down for it instead of scoring up... Stitch and Wing sounded VERY unique, even more unique than Alexinho (for example, Alexinho did sucker punch and clickroll drops just like almost everyone else)
I honestly feel like alex is in purely because of how entertaining his battles are and how long he has been in the game. Also I think he brought a fresh take later in the event which typically does very well vs someone like stitch doing something VERY different but before anyone else has performed. The psychology of humans and their bias is a metric that has both necessary and reductive qualities but thats life hey!
kind of surprised I haven't seen the comment yet- to me this seems to be a one huge reference to Fuga from Rofu (even the thumbnail has similar vibes) rather than a full-on competitive elimination. also would make great sense, as the GBB takes place in Japan where people could recognize the similar style.
i think it would be cool to see a polished list for these elims, just because you havent heard them before and you seem to have some thoughts on changes to the list already (regarding pacmax)
I think Alex profited from being a huge contrast to others (just like abo ice was). especially because everyone doing powerful beats after Julard just didnt compare so there was heavy bias (understandibly after this kid made the whole stage shake like a level 13 earthquake)
@@Jan-fe9vr Exactly. If Stitch didn't pass why did Alex? Alexinho wrote a comment on the original upload and said that he knew it was a controversial decision placing him 2nd in elims but he just wanted to do his own style which i respect. I really don't think Alexinho wanted to pass that much and it probably surprised him.
have you ever officially judged an online competition with recorded elims? Where you can actually pause and catch everything like you do in these videos but with a real ranking
The problem IMO isn't with the judges. It's the lack of opinion diversity. We've got 5 judges who think similarly, that's all. If Dlow had replaced FootboxG for example, Alexinho would still be ~4th overall and we'd still call out the judges. But at the same time, these days with any artform, if you think like everyone else you're a sheep, and when you don't, you're a contrarian who goes "how can I be different today?" So either way you're screwed.
2nd elim placing as well, yeah. Kinda crazy. But Alexinho himself left a comment on the elim saying he's aware that it was a controversial decision. Alexinho just did his elim, it's not his fault but the judges really.
Anybody doing crazy beats could literally do the same imagine if this is what everyone do to pass elims.. settings the bar so low for passing elims is not good imo
In my own ranking I gave him the Napom treatment in terms of showing much. He already proved several times he is a world class beatboxer so he scored pretty high for me (3rd), because I think it was a unique approach, a very well structured piece, really pleasing to the ear and I also just felt really entertained by his elim. I do absolutely see your points tho I think I was just a lot more "forgiving" because of how much I liked it :D
One question to you, if bly crespley did this routine. Do you think you would give him the same scoring? Art is objective and of course, i give respect to those few individuals that thinks “baby shark” is a world class banger in the music industry.
@@Pinkguy6999 no I don't think I would have, because I haven't heard anything from him before and I would lean more into the points Dlow criticised. I still would have vibes hard to the grooves.
@@GonasJoldbut as you mentioned, it is a unique approach, well structured and please listening to the ears and thus a 3rd place placement, right? How does it related to the popularity of the artist🤔
Plus the argument “he alrdy proved himself in previous events” is completely absurd imo. So you are basically agreeing to biased judgement in the cost of the hard work of new comers. This mindset is unfair and discouraging to new generations of beatboxers and the creative industry in general.😢 The napom treatment mentioned in dlows gbb23 analysis, mentioned that napom proved himself in gbb23 that he is powerful and skillful enough that yr. Not previous events. Elsewise, it is no difference than “napom is in becoz he is a legend”.
People will never cease to amaze me when it comes to beatbox competitions, these are all judge's opinions, you can not agree with it, judging art in and of it self is stupid, so when it comes to judging, it's hard, especially because it's on such a high level, everyone so far, at least for me, could've made it, i want to hear your thoughts, be respectful please, peace ✌️
Sorry but sometimes it can objectively not as good as the others. No hate to the artist respectfully. Reckless placements can lead to discouragement to artists who have been preparing for long time, leading to their departure from the scene or future events.
Dude, pause and talk as much as you want. We are here for your commentary and fun energy!
Amen
Somewhat disagree but I understand
yeah
Indeed, and the people that are upset about it should just go watch other reaction channels, the analysis and explaining are what makes his videos perfect.
@@lorcan8484, well, if you don't want pausing then go watch the original video. As with all reactions, the point is also to support the original video. Watch D-low's reaction and then the original video or vice versa and you get both commentary and no pausing.
Alexinho : " B Ps "
Judges : 😱🤗😛😁
😜 🤙
Once again, you make the most sense with these explanations. Thank you.
Sorry but no one can ever persuade me that this ranks higher than stitch remix blackroll and Osis xD
Stitch and black roll yes, remix n osis no
@@tooic3y637 erm, i'd like to hear elaboration on how this is better than stitch's elim
for me it's very obvious why
Lol. Even in the official ranking stitch and blackroll didn't pass the top 8 battles.
D-low is definitely going to be very shocked by who made it in and who didn't. At this point I can see half of who he put in the top 8 not in the top 8 based on who I know the judges put through.
Glad to know that I wasn't the only one who thought that Alexinho's elim should've ranked lower.
I ranked him 9th, cuz the beats were patternly simple but hard to do, others i preferred more cuz they were complex and different pallete
he should not have been in the qualifiers but we all know why he made it in. favoritism continues with the judge panels.
I really liked alexinho show, but i didnt put him on my top 8. Pacmax was my 8th because he also bring a really good show but with more flavour
@Javier-bs9nr do you think the same thing goes for Julard?
Yeah, favoritism has always been a thing in beatbox sadly. It's understandable why it happens, as you would obviously want the most well known people there, but it makes it harder for newcomers too.
Thank you dlow for your analysis and bring justice to stitch and blackroll
I completely agree with your ranking. I love Alex and all, but I believe he was placed way too high. Second place overall was a bit surprising to me.
So true … no hate for Alex ..2nd place above Osis Kaji wing was so overrated.
Alexinho is just enjoying the performance, so fun and so natural!
The French are fixing the gbb harder than jake paul fixes fights.
LMFAO
😂😂
I belive osis when he said " fuck the french on the stage , all this fucker has is bass"
what happened to wing
alex and julard shouldn't even get in they never deserves , feel bad for others like stitch and blackroll who didn't pass the eliminations cuz of these 2 french
Totally agree with your ranking
03:24 Please tell this to the future GBB judging panel because i agree with this statement. Although, i wouldn't have placed Alexinho top 8 we still need constructive conversation about what power means in a competition.
he said that but he still loooooves too much when napom clips the speakers with his liproll's in a competition💀💀💀i don't get it
@@tintobruh._He said that power isn't necessary, not that he doesn't enjoy it all
Lets go dlow
Dlow always explains very clearly and I’m totally agree with your thoughts and rankings! Such a reliable guy!
2nd is outrageous in a new era of beatbox no way stitch is worse than Alex
And by 8 places😢
I love Alexinho but this definitely gave a vibe of overconfidence. His cleanliness and inner metronome is undeniable but it’s just not enough. Can’t underestimate the new guys.
I don’t think he did enough to pass, I have no idea how he placed 2nd and someone like Blackroll or MaxO didn’t even pass
It's obvious, we have legend beatboxers but bad judges at this years, there was a huge mistakes in judging, stitch not in top 8, osis doesn't win GBB, undeserved win for Julard etc..
@@turkix57 My comment is not meant to say whether you're right or wrong. I just want to clarify that it's not the same to judge live on stage as it is through a video where the sound has been edited and adjusted. In fact, when Dlow was a judge during previous GBBs, viewers didn't always agree with his judgment, particularly during the Alem vs Elisii match, just to give you an example. I think it would be better to stop blaming the judges for their decisions. I believe they understand beatboxing far better than we do; let's not forget that almost all of them have been GBB champions, and as a result, they are legitimate to judge.
@@turkix57yall are jus following yall feelings ,if stitch made it in top 8 it would make sense but even if he didn’t it would also make sense stitch style is just not it especially if your the first one to do an elim,osis didn’t deserve to win the final jualrd was clear loud and efficient yall can’t accept that but i wonder if they wasn’t french what would be the next excuse 🤔
I really appreciate the polyrhythms and how he tights up the whole piece at the end, however I feel there were better structured eliminations than this one. Good to know I'm not completely deaf
THIS IS WHAT I WAS FREAKING WAITINNNNN’ ty dan
I felt like that elimination was biased to french, Julard and Alexinho performance couldn't be compared to stitches and they passed and stitches didn't pass 😅
good point. I also felt like this is not the strongest performance from him
Some of the people on your list ranked quite a bit higher and made it in, simply because of how much power they have and how loud they were in the venue
Definitely do the overall list after, Ill be there for the must watch content
this gives the same energy as PACMax's elim, and honestly PACMax did more. Idk how he ended up so high in the actual placements.
I wrote this before seeing Dlow's ranking and its exactly where I would have put it wow. Sign me up as a GBB judge lol
Genuinely one of the worst elims in GBB history... insane.
I think the only reason Stitch is hated and Alex got in is because Alex is good at battling, and stitch is kinda only know for elims...
The decision should not be made on external biases like, "oh, well this guy can battle and we don't think this one can." It should be purely based on the Elimination.
100%
Agreed 💯
one of the dumbest comments I've ever had to read. What are you even saying
@@felixschneider1398 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@felixschneider1398 I think he means Alex got in because of what the judges think he can do, not based on what he did in the moment. That's unfair to people like Stitch who may not have the best battle track record but had an amazing performance in the moment.
felt like i got hurt inside when i heard his real ranking
anyways completely agree with what you said
Nothing but facts were spoken in this video
1:00 I think it's for the big stage screen, so it looked like he was watching himself walking on the stage.
genius ngl
he really took stitch deserved second place
He is so creative ❤
I personally think the judges at gbb this year had quite a bit of personal bias
I cant wait for Alexinho vs Julard
That was my favorite battle
Yeah, the two french guy who for some strange reason, magically made it through, with more deserving wildcards.
@@indraneelphukan5906 huh
julard literally destroyed alexinho hahahah
@@jimyb89blancorodriguez13 Alexinho memed his way into second place and got destroyed by actual competition
Yeah, d low can say what i felt about this, i don’t have the words for it but d low said what’s in my heart
yeah....agreed, from the video, idk live, but for what I listened to from the video it wasn't enough for top 8, to me (I preferred others, that's all)
live also not enough
its called reaction for a reason. so pause when you want
He made lots of errors, lots, and he didn't do any difficult techniques. I feel like this elimination is something that try to be more than what it is
I don’t think he should’ve made it but what mistakes did he make?
@@Neon1880 sounds werent consistent, the clickroll volume was inconsistent also and overall in the end the drops were easy and, at the same time, not as powerful or consistent as Heliums or Julards
@ I’d agree with this statement
@@felipeneto659he was quite a standout though compared to everyone’s eliminations
@@roboket3524 true, but Stitch and DEN really stood out and went very off meta, but got scored down for it instead of scoring up... Stitch and Wing sounded VERY unique, even more unique than Alexinho (for example, Alexinho did sucker punch and clickroll drops just like almost everyone else)
12:13 D-Max
3:47 d-low always pausing on napom’s face 😂
Grand stage presence/legacy battle 2024 like imagine if any other competitor did the same thing
I honestly feel like alex is in purely because of how entertaining his battles are and how long he has been in the game. Also I think he brought a fresh take later in the event which typically does very well vs someone like stitch doing something VERY different but before anyone else has performed. The psychology of humans and their bias is a metric that has both necessary and reductive qualities but thats life hey!
YES! i wrote almost the same! alex was 12th for me
kind of surprised I haven't seen the comment yet- to me this seems to be a one huge reference to Fuga from Rofu (even the thumbnail has similar vibes) rather than a full-on competitive elimination.
also would make great sense, as the GBB takes place in Japan where people could recognize the similar style.
Nah he just borrowed glasses from fuga, thats just it
i dont think he deserved 2nd
I completely agree with dlow and his placement for Alexinho, he didn't deserve 2nd place
i think it would be cool to see a polished list for these elims, just because you havent heard them before and you seem to have some thoughts on changes to the list already (regarding pacmax)
1:51 Bean Bags
The real rank for alexinho 👍🙏
no offense but in what world is this better than blackroll's...
Now im really interested in where colaps placed him, csuse i thought i just don't understand his complaxity since i ranked him 13th
Based ranking
Alexinhoooo 🔥
I think Alex profited from being a huge contrast to others (just like abo ice was). especially because everyone doing powerful beats after Julard just didnt compare so there was heavy bias (understandibly after this kid made the whole stage shake like a level 13 earthquake)
But Stitch was a huge contrast too
@@Jan-fe9vr Exactly. If Stitch didn't pass why did Alex? Alexinho wrote a comment on the original upload and said that he knew it was a controversial decision placing him 2nd in elims but he just wanted to do his own style which i respect. I really don't think Alexinho wanted to pass that much and it probably surprised him.
@@emilflarsen2 I don't understand how that explains anything at all. I also have no idea why he passed and Stitch didn't.
@@Jan-fe9vr I don't have an explanation either. :/
@@emilflarsen2Stitches Did his own style also... Unfortunately we will never be able to see stitches in gbb again.
So sweet ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
1:03 - Alex's weird intro turns Dan into a chicken
there is no way this is better than Ice
0:10 HALLELUJAH =D
He wants beanbags
Alexinho ❌ Alalanyo 😂😂😂
wooop
If it was a less famous bestboxer they wouldn't have got in.
lol he still has crazy good quality drum kit so that really makes a difference
@Eli-mh7nh Thats what we know from his history. But I feel like the judges have to go off of just this performance to make it fair!
Place it last 😂
have you ever officially judged an online competition with recorded elims? Where you can actually pause and catch everything like you do in these videos but with a real ranking
Yes he has, he even participated in such competition so he knows what he is talking about and you dont
U doin this for the battles, for loopstation and duos as well?
I was expecting the drops to hit harder...bit of an anti climax
first time this early
The fact that this got put through is disgusting
Find better judges
I think footboxg was actually great though
I don't know how Alexinho managed to move over Stitch or Blackroll honestly😂
Even alex would have said he trolled the elim 😂
I think it's a justified spot for alex elim.
2nd is crazy 😭
Lol😂
All respect to him but this elim nah bro 16th place for sure 👍
Very much enjoyed listening to a lot of this but there just wasn't a lot of meat on the bone
Yo!
The problem IMO isn't with the judges. It's the lack of opinion diversity. We've got 5 judges who think similarly, that's all. If Dlow had replaced FootboxG for example, Alexinho would still be ~4th overall and we'd still call out the judges.
But at the same time, these days with any artform, if you think like everyone else you're a sheep, and when you don't, you're a contrarian who goes "how can I be different today?" So either way you're screwed.
1:36 cause you're the best beatboxwer of all time
i must be first now dan
WORST ONE EVER
Beats are simple and easy, people like us who jst listen beatbox can do his beats😂 how come he qualified?
It was very underwhelming to me
yo
This passed and Stitch didn't pass, Den didn't pass
To me that's crazy
What a shame Stitch came prepared but they managed to make a troll elim pass and not him
2nd elim placing as well, yeah. Kinda crazy. But Alexinho himself left a comment on the elim saying he's aware that it was a controversial decision. Alexinho just did his elim, it's not his fault but the judges really.
put him under bly crepsley
Lmao😂 bly crepsley is now a meme
I cant see the video
Too much of a disconnect
Could've been better. But still, good one
Cronyism thts the word for alexhino
No idea how this got 2nd. Love the guy but it was among my least favourites
Palexindrhome
At last
wiw
비잘알
Alexinho is so old he could be my father and im 23
imo he gets in through composition alone, those polys were crazy and the whole elim was fresh and chill and easy to listen to
Anybody doing crazy beats could literally do the same imagine if this is what everyone do to pass elims.. settings the bar so low for passing elims is not good imo
@@AyukaAmameth no the quality is there, listen to beatbox for over 15 years and your ears and perspective will change
Probably not 2nd though. He's around 6th-10th.
@@markjestermatote7774 defo would rate the elim towards the bottom of the passes but still a pass, not top 6 tho
probably the worst elim, by the end i was bored.
Yo d low react with Derrick Part 2, Who's with me?
|
|
V
This was the most boring Elim for me thus far, I am still dumbfounded as to how he got 2nd..
the trasnsitions are WOW
We got Shostakovich beat from Alexinho before GTA 6
I don't think Dlow would appreciate such a beatbox very much.
You missed wings elim btw
First😂
In my own ranking I gave him the Napom treatment in terms of showing much. He already proved several times he is a world class beatboxer so he scored pretty high for me (3rd), because I think it was a unique approach, a very well structured piece, really pleasing to the ear and I also just felt really entertained by his elim.
I do absolutely see your points tho I think I was just a lot more "forgiving" because of how much I liked it :D
Oh and btw I was so hyped for your reactions / opinions and I love that you are so quick with the uploads 🙏
One question to you, if bly crespley did this routine. Do you think you would give him the same scoring?
Art is objective and of course, i give respect to those few individuals that thinks “baby shark” is a world class banger in the music industry.
@@Pinkguy6999 no I don't think I would have, because I haven't heard anything from him before and I would lean more into the points Dlow criticised. I still would have vibes hard to the grooves.
@@GonasJoldbut as you mentioned, it is a unique approach, well structured and please listening to the ears and thus a 3rd place placement, right? How does it related to the popularity of the artist🤔
Plus the argument “he alrdy proved himself in previous events” is completely absurd imo. So you are basically agreeing to biased judgement in the cost of the hard work of new comers. This mindset is unfair and discouraging to new generations of beatboxers and the creative industry in general.😢
The napom treatment mentioned in dlows gbb23 analysis, mentioned that napom proved himself in gbb23 that he is powerful and skillful enough that yr. Not previous events. Elsewise, it is no difference than “napom is in becoz he is a legend”.
People will never cease to amaze me when it comes to beatbox competitions, these are all judge's opinions, you can not agree with it, judging art in and of it self is stupid, so when it comes to judging, it's hard, especially because it's on such a high level, everyone so far, at least for me, could've made it, i want to hear your thoughts, be respectful please, peace ✌️
Sorry but sometimes it can objectively not as good as the others. No hate to the artist respectfully. Reckless placements can lead to discouragement to artists who have been preparing for long time, leading to their departure from the scene or future events.
Of course, some minority may also think baby shark is a world class masterpiece and i respect those few individuals