GTX1080Ti Showdown - MSI Gaming X vs Gigabyte Aorus Xtreme Edition
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 вер 2024
- MSI Gaming X GTX1080ti vs Gigabyte Aorus Xtreme GTX 1080Ti, lets go!
Big thanks to www.playtech.co.nz for making this video possible!
Thank you guys for supporting me, I love how supportive my fans are!
Hit me up on Twitter for updates: / techshowdownyt
Help me offset my lower ad revenue by donating: / techshowdown
Music provided by: / lakeyinspired
*Note: These benchmarks were done on my x99 Personal Rig but with a 6800K at stock settings rather than my 6900K at 4.2ghz which is why the numbers here are different from the last 1080Ti Showdown, these were both also done before I did the Creators update.
Full System Specs can be found here: bit.ly/2buaaaj
just a heads up on the ghost recons wildlands, one of the settings ( i cant remember which) are the reason for the poor fps, i think it was said that the top setting on one of the options made every fps no matter the card/bad, so to lower it one setting, just for future so you can hit the 150's on the 1080 res setting.
Hey man fellow kiwi here nice to see someone from NZ put together a fairly popular tech channel also able to put together some quality comparison videos. Keep up the good work.
Cheers mate!
This is a great comparison video. Well done!
Cheers!
Please don't say that there should be a lot of HEADROOM for overclocking due to a 20deg temperature difference. Lots of cards have minimal overclocking left. You MAY see boosts, but temperature is NOT a good indicator of what to expect.
Great comparison test. I have watched a couple of comparison reviews for these cards but I saved yours for last as I love your channel. Great video that was well edited.
I just got the MSI 1080ti Gaming X, I was barely able to installed in my case, I'm glad I got that one since its a little shorter than the other, just the right size.
I am in the process of getting one now - the thing that makes me lean towards the Gigabyte card is the 4 year warranty - had a with heat in the top of the line card - living in Queensland so that is my concern
yes but what about the Asus OC rog 1080ti vs The Aurous Extreme 1080ti.
Great video bro..
I will do another showdown with the Asus in the future just got to get through a few things first
Aorus beats the ROG OC mate, the 2 best 1080Ti's are the ZOTAC AMP EXTREME and the Aorus.. The strix maybe 1-2 fps lower in certain games
those two are the worst choices of all 1080 ti lol
for vertical mount gpu, i prefer aorus design.
The difference in frame rate and performance seems to be barely 1% to the Gigabyte. And when it comes to noise the Gigabyte has a weird whistling sound along with the fan sound (thank you for recording it rather than just explaining). Plus the Gigabyte is 60 euro more expensive (in The Netherlands). Thus MSI wins for my next PC next month :D
when you test fan speed you should do fan rpm instead of fan percentage. Different cards will have different fan rpm to percentage ratio.
Just a thought.
Yeah it is a difficult thing but I do it by percentage to let people know how much extra fan speed they could use if they needed it.
Really don't know how you could have a hard time deciding between the two. The Auros pitched a shutout in the benches, looks better, is slightly quieter and cheaper to buy. The MSI has too much red on it, is plastic, doesn't have as many features or as good software and is much more expensive. Easy choice for me.
Stev A the MSI has a better airflow and is quieter! And in my country les expensive, and the red looks dope
Is there a difference when both of them are Overclocked to the max speed? Because I wanna buy the MSI 1 but I am not sure...
Aorus was only better by 1-2 fps. temps would be the deciding factor if prices were very similar.
Bought a regular Aorus. OCd it out of the box to over 2000mhz. Don't wanna pay an extra 100(in Canada) for an OC I may or may not be able to do myself. :P
I say may or may not cus'.. you know, I'm kinda playing the lottery again if I buy the regular edition. x_x
Nice video, just what I was looking for - comparison between these two cards. I will pick the MSI Gaming X. Subscribing to your channel also.
Great video once again
Looking forward to the rx580 vs 1060 showdown
Yeah should be fun!
:) That would be like apples and peers as comparison cos the AMD hasn't PhysX and Nvidia 3D.
this comparison is awesome
I don't get it the Aorus States it's 11.54" and the MSI lists at 11.42" yet in your video the Aourus look MUCH longer!
i got the none extreme for $999 and it's boosting in access of 2ghz with minimal voltage increase, although power is set to 150%. I also oc'ed the memory significantly to +220. Ive been playing Wolfenstein II: The New Colossus at 4k with ultra settings (several of the advanced settings only go to high regardless) and it rarely goes under 60fps. In other words the non-extreme can do exactly what the extreme can. I cant afford a ti so im satisfied with std Aorus 1080.
That is a very nice looking computer case, which one is that?
Corsair 760T, check my channels 'About' page for all my PC specs
:) You didn't mentioned another crucial fact about those cards, meaning that the MSI version it's noticeably shorter than the Aorus one allowing a better airflow especially on the smaller PC cases, cos it's not hoe it's working "now", but also for "how long" they will be enduring running at high temperatures., especially that the graphic cards are the most temperature sensitive and most of the times are failing without warning or when it's starting just like the cancer in humans it's too late already.
Hi
Thanks for the video, btw I have MSI GTX1080Ti gaming x, seems you are more supporting to Gigabit rather than MSI
I felt bad as I have MSI and no much difference in price between both Cards
All good Man thx
And the MSI Gaming X Plus?
Why Wildlands got such low FPS (under 60) at only 1080p . that game must be very badly optimized or what . Its not even that impressive looking to be honest.
hard choice
WHAT SYSTEM WAS USED ?
It's silly to compare manufacturers in fps when the main criteria in this are the temperature, noise and build quality (the presence of the coil whine).
This is only a comparison of frequencies, where, obviously, will be stronger than Aorus due to the increased base frequency.
aren't the pascal cards voltage limited. so a crazy oc shouldn't be possible, around 2050 give and take. only positive effect should be not encountering a thermal throttling?
Hmm nice numbers, i suspect that's the upper limit on Pascal cards. Never saw beyond 2100 oc on any channel (ln2 besides ofc). Nice channel btw,
Extreme 4k Gaming again impressive numbers. my first thought was, that the limiters would be lifted for a pascal refresh. it seem these are for rma concerns.. well according to a nv spokeperson. whatever the reason, hope your card won't die on you in the near future. cheers
Hey I need some help. Been saving up for a new cpu. Which cpu should I get? I7 6700k, 7700k, or 8700k?
8700K 🤗
I think its just luck of the silicone lotery sins my msi 1080ti gaming x runs at a hyer speed wen I enabel oc mode
hey great channal i just want to ask you are you in new zealand because im moving to auckland in few days i just want to know is there a place i can buy all the newly release gaming produts and all new tech stuff in auckland
Yeah buy from www.playtech.co.nz I was buying from them long before they sponsored me because the service is so good.
For games it's probably best sticking to Steam, if not, JB Hi-Fi is probably the next best thing.
Tech Showdown thanks mate excited to come to new zeland amazing country im bringing my pc with me will it be a problem in the air port is it ok to bring the pc
help guys! i have a 6800k clocked at 4.4 and the aorus card but cant overclock anywhwere near this and dont get the same resoults on 1440p, highest i can clock my core is 1750mh stable =0
I want to add something to your conclusion on which one to buy, if anyone likes the more colour neutral Aorus than they can buy this one or if anyone wants a red theme, they can buy the Gaming X card. Just my opinion! :D
I have the MSI one. Almost regretting now not getting the Gigabyte and should have to match the motherboard but I have zero issues with the MSI one. Big deal I lose 2fps on average. But seriously why buy one for 1080? It's complete overkill and you can save a few bucks going lower.
240hz
My strix bricked on me. And now I’m heartbroken.
in my country Aorus extreme more expensive than MSI gaming X, so MSI for the win
Please Help me
Processor : Intel Core i7-7700
Motherboard : Asus Strix H270F
PSU : Corsair PSU RMi 650W
I confused for Graphic card beetwen Asus GeForce GTX 1080 8GB DDR5X Strix A And MSI GeForce GTX 1080 8GB DDR5X
which one is suitable Graphic card for my PC Please???
Do some 4k SLI as long as you got them both!
My gtx msi 1080 ti gaming x has been making a sound while playing with high fps. Is this normal?
probably coil whine
Or unlucky silicon lottery
it has a lower fan speed, "in what is regarded as the max fan speed, wich is different in both cards" ;)
hi i really need your help look i want to buy new computer and my parts is: gtx 1060 xtream gaming 8gb ram intel core i5 7600k now my qustion is 600w its ok for the computer or i need more ?
if your rig doesn't have any huge amount of lighting from the ram fans or even strips it's enough. but I advice u to get a 750w for future proofing
i have the crossair 230t he had led in front, and if i want in the future to upgrad the pc i upgrade also the 600w
so 600w its enough for my pc or its not good enough
strictly speaking it's enough to last u. but having a little more juice is always a good option. but YES 600w is enough
thank U SO MACH I Appreciate it
U HELP ME THANX
!GREAT JOB U ARE DOING SUBSCRIBE
Kev. Drop"N", them dope beats...
but aorus cool down their mosfets and memory modules, so msi out of comparison with temperature of those out of 90C
This is true
3:26 Is it me, or is that rear case fan spinning way off balance. And no I'm not looking at the offset sticker, the fanhub itself is wobbling lol
it's the sticker being off center, probably not the fan.
pick the Aorus only for the look
😂❤❤😂
LOVE YOUR REVIEW RIGHT ON THE MONEY !!!
GIGABYTES BEING REALLY HIGH END ARE WAY UNDER RATED...
Right now on Newegg USA the difference with shipping is only $5 (The Aorus is the higher priced one at $750). BUT what the review didn't mention is that the Aorus offers a 4 year warranty vs 3 years for the MSI. So with slightly higher fps and a longer warranty, the Aorus was the more sensible choice for an extra $5. Mine arrives on Friday. Can't wait!!
Do you think someone buying a top of the line graphics cards is going to have it for more than 3 year? I bet 99% of people would not :)
Holly shiat joe !! how ritch are you holding 2 x TI cards mann !!
UA-cam money and Ad revenue is all it takes
why not Extreme vs Lighning Z ?
because Lighning Z much more expensive then Auros ( like 150 / 200 euro ) Msi cant win with that cost against auros
well here in PH they are the same in price
aorus exstreme edition has best out of the box clock speed not even Asus strix has better out of the box clock speed
i hope i wont crack the motherboard with all that weight !
the seahawk x 1080ti will be nice.
Has msi coil whine?
Anıl Akalın some has some has noy
but i had one and I RMA'd it and now getting Aorus but any card can have it
Silicon lottery my dudes
“Gods”
must be nice
Ha! I did a video with both these same cards! In my battle the msi came out on top after overclocking :)
Upgrade Addiction buddy you make proud of my msi gtx 1080ti gaming x. Cheers
I got better speeds out of Gigabyte and better FPS on heaven
not by much but still 5-6 FPS
even after OC
@Sofiane1993 He meant he oc'd both and MSi won
Gigabyte aorus extreme edition 1080ti monster
Aorus Xtreme should be pitched against MSI Gaming "Z" for a fair comparison between two top cards from both venders. Gaming "X" simply isn't the top card from MSI. It's the Gaming "Z" instead.
there is a gaming x plus which have higher clock and bigger cooler
There is also a Lightning Z, way faster than all has clock speeds higher than gaming x and z but also most expensive and limited edition
MSI is cheaper go with that
aorus c est sur !
This is a trash review if you didn’t take the change to manually overclock the core and memory, advance the voltage and crank up that fan curve. I don’t care what these cards autoboost to. You done messed it up.
Shit have the msi 😰
msi Mode OC Base : 1 569 MHz
Boost : 1 683 MHz
Gigabyte Mode OC
Base : 1 632 MHz
Boost : 1 746 MHz
~50€
more expensive for ~1fps Identical card wholesale
Aorus high perf and long time with it's perfect for gamer want perfs + time and good warrantly Aorus 4 years ;)
aourus for 2 fps more? lol
@@clark98881 i got an aorus for 375 euro. solid. there was no msi available so i went for the aorus. but if the msi is available, they usually ask the same price. might aswell go for the aorus at that point.
I think about change my Asus Strix 1080 OC for the MSI 1080ti Gaming X . Do you think its a nice upgrade ?!
yes
Thats retarded. Unless you're gonna buy used one and its really cheap, best would be from a trusted source like a close friend or something, buying new one is just stupid when there is new series already on the market.
If you're aiming for such price range then why not buy a 2080 Super instead? New one will probably cost as much as new 1080 Ti, but the 2080s will be slightly better in the FPS alone and much better in handling the Ray Tracing in games and thats for the same price - A Win-Win choice.
Generally GTX 10xx series are handling the Ray Tracing very badly, even tho they might not be so much weaker than the RTX's but yeah handling Ray Tracing on 1080 works worse than on 2060 (kinda understandable considering Ray Tracing is a RTX feature) and thats just a 2060. And if you're really going to spend so much money on a card then i see no reason to buy it if you're not gonna use such features like the Ray Tracing. It generally makes no sense to buy 80's series if you're not planning on playing 1440 or 4k with full ultra settings in new games i think we can all agree on that, right?
These cards are 100% the same just with different stock-clock, lol
And what did you expect lol? They are just cooling brands, buying MSI or Aorus GPU is paying extra for the look, slightly better base clocks and supposedly superior cooling, it was always like that. I just dont see the reason to make such a stupid comment. It kind of looks like you thought buying the Aorus or the MSI's Lightning series is like buying a better card. Well technically it is better, cause better cooling lets you clock it more, but apart from that and looks, there's no difference and why would there be ffs?
@@patrykkumek5619 Calm your tits, you don't know anything. Custom PCB's and power delivery and water cooling capabilities.
I will not read or reply any more.
Front panel HDMI on the Gigabyte one is quite attractive to me, since VR is the reason I'm thinking of upgrading.
What about gaming Z, the gaming x is not the top of msi cards
I want to upgrade from my R9 295X2 to a 1080 Ti Seahawk X.
Problem is... I have a 1440p 144 Hz freesync monitor...
AMDdizzle The great Vega SHOULD be next month. I know it sucks waiting. I'm in the same boat though.
I would wait for vega but if you really can't wait you can use an nvidia gpu with a freesync monitor, you just won't be able to use freesync it will just act as a normal monitor (and you'll be disappointed when vega comes out lol)
I would wait for vega but if you really can't wait you can use an nvidia gpu with a freesync monitor, you just won't be able to use freesync it will just act as a normal monitor (and you'll be disappointed when vega comes out lol)
The irony that NVidia could support freesync... but then, it would not be NVidia.
Yeah then nobody would buy the more expensive gsync monitors lol they have to lock away something to keep people around just like consoles and their exclusives
Can you do a video where you SHOW MSI ,Aorus VS ZOTAC I would love to see that. and as always have a nice day🤗
Nice review, i have decided to buy a 1080ti :D.....(FTW3-SLI)
Aorus made a bit more noise imo from what I could tell from your video. Just a bit though.
Your temp thing is incorrect. 50 percent fan speed doesn't have the same RPM then the AORUS on 50 percent
😂😂😂❤❤😂😂
THE TWO LOVES OF MY LIFE...
MSI GTX1080 TI 11G
❤❤ DRAGON ❤❤
I LOVE I MEAN LOVE THIS CARD SO MUCH
BEST PURCHASE I EVER MADE...
heya I've found some big disparities between ghost recon wild lands in the benchmark and in actual game play could you please test this
Ill see if I have time but I do know it is consistent between runs so as a benchmark it is still solid for comparing GPU's.
thanks would appreciate it :)
you ever go back to this video and be like sick as ****, what great gpu's.
but what about the evga ftw 3, is the msi still a 1-2 fps close or not?
gret
очень хороший обзор . Спасибе большое 10/10!!!!!
А чё он не показал тесты в играх,,,, нихера не понятно....🤪
Miss you big man R.I.P
what happen to him ?
@HB C omg sorry to hear that, when that is happening, rip, now he's in better place. judge by the comment rip 2 months ago, is it coronavirus ?
@HB C thank you very much for the info.
Gigabyte has a bit of bad rep in recent years, yet price-to-features they are unbeatable right now. The Gaming/Windforce can go as low as Pait in price and still have full 3 years warranty. Aorus are ALYWAS cheaper then Gaming X or Strix, and still have the same if not better performance.
MSI is impressive in reviews, but if one factors in the price - they are overpriced, at least in Europe. And I mean noticeably - you can buy higher model of another brand instead for the same price (1060 3gb vs 6gb, 1080 vs 1080 Ti, RX 580 4gb vs 8gb, 570 vs 580, etc, etc)
I've just had to return my Aurus...it's too bloody big for my case! It's 12 inches long man!.
By the looks of it the MSI is shorter, possibly about 11 inches maybe?
If you still have them could you measure it please?
MSI Gaming X is never cheaper then a Gigabyte. They have ARMOR for that, but then the Gigabyte is better.
Honestly, all these cards boost different. Even within the same branding so milage will vary. I have the Gaming X Ti and I've already seen it hit 2100 mhz on it's own without Afterburner. But others have stated their cards only hit 2025 mhz. So it's all a lottery, you'll get whatever you get.
I will say a buddy of mine bought the EVGA Black Edition ti. That card runs HOT... 85 degrees with a maximum 1850 Boost. I say "Buyer Beware", that's awful.
I admit it's not the best, but he does have two in 140mm passing to two out 140mm. My Gaming X sits at 62c under full load benchmarks. I rarely see it out of the 50's under Wildlands.
what about the temperature on msi?
I've got a gygabyte one
Well sadly all the 1080ti comparisons are null and void basically because it silicon lottery with Pascal. You can a founders that will overclock better than a $770 Evga FTW3. In aftermarket it about noise and temps and they are all within a couple of % on both. So It basically buy what looks nice to you and hope Silicon gods bestow upon your chip.
I have seen people on overclock.net pushing 2100 rock solid on MSI and not getting 1925 barely stable on the Aorus and vise versa.
My Aorus hit's 2025 without me touching it so i'm sure i could get 2100.(Not 100% sure but more than likely)
Please I need Help, GTX 1060 Gaming X for $304 vs GTX 1060 Aorus 2.0 for $329 vs GTX 1060 Aorus Xtreme 2.0 for $329?
I can't wrong with the decision, because I'm from Venezuela and I'm going to import it from Amazon, Thanks in advance...
just buy cheaper one trust me all of them are same but if u dont mind cost and u have a chase with window then mybe looking can make differance then my opinion is auros xtrame looking better
Hi, I bought the Aorus Xtreme 2.0 this morning for $319...
thats best choise i think gl hf ! :)
Only issue with the MSI Gtx 1080ti is that it is bulky and will most likely sag. Still that doesn't throw me off from purchasing one
RetireVFX 10:48 auros is bulkier.
I have the MSI Gaming X 1080ti and it does not sag at all. It actually has a lot more screws that retains the backplate to the heatsink to avoid sag. the STRIX has a lot of sag and I would imagine the AORUS Xtreme would have more sag due to it being heavier but I can tell you that the MSI does not have any noticeable sag.
Big issue with it is that ugly red junk all over the card. A founders even looks better than that ugly pos.
ElteeMullet thats true. Unless you have a red build, gaming x will NOT look good. Thats one of the reasons I like the Msi Seahawk X 1080ti.
Char Aznable seahawk x is normal 2 slot spacing
A 3770k i7 takes a gtx 1080 ti?
If you ask if they work well together, yes. same build I have.
im using 1080ti FE with my 2500k 4.2 gigahertz automatic overclocked speed
you should rename the channel to teddy tech
First :D
None could get a constant 60 fps or more on all tests. I guess we have a long way to go before we can game at 100 plus fps in all 4k games. Not so powerful in my opinion.
Its always been the zotac amp extreme cards are the best
I using i7 4770. Can i use this cpu with this card for perfomance from card?
Your 4770 is perfectly fine for a turd 1080ti
yes,i have the 4770k and aorus,it will run at 4.5ghz but i put it back to stock and it's fine.