JUST STOP! Why Dok Quit Supporting New Comics
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 жов 2022
- Thinking Critical contributor and X-Men historian Dok has been supporting new comics for over 35 years. That's all finished now. Dok explains why he quit supporting new comics recently. A lot of long-time Marvel and DC Comics fans are experiencing the same issues as Dok. Just stop supporting new comics from Marvel and DC Comics.
Recommended Video
Hardcore Readers Won’t Quit All Comics…Just New Comics
• Hardcore Readers Won’t...
🛒 SHOP THINKING CRITICAL - Official Merch!
www.redbubble.com/people/T-Cr...
DO NOT CLICK THIS! bit.ly/3E4PLkY
Thinking Critical Comic Book Podcast is live on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Podbean, Spotify, Amazon Music/Audible, TuneIn + Alexa, iHeartRadio, PlayerFM and Listen Notes.
Link: thinkingcriticalcomicbooks.podbean.com
Support Thinking Critical at Ko-fi. Monthly subscriptions receive bonus content and early access to some channel content.
Ko-fi.com/thinkingcritical
Thank you for supporting the channel!
Thinking Critical Discord: / discord
Twitch Channel
/ thinking_critical_yt
Contact Thinking Critical:
Twitter: / wes_from_tc
Email wesdigscomics@gmail.com
#marvel #dccomics #comicbooks - Розваги
What Dok is saying is how I feel. For me to buy, see, watch, play or read something from the "current year" has to make it worth. Genre entertainment has been so tainted and burnt bridges, I can't make the investment any more. Stuff like The Northman, Wolf Walkers, My Hero Academia, and other new things are getting my attention not the old bastardized IP.
My Hero literally said if you live in a vilage, the countryside, a small town that you are a unintelligent, bigoted, racist. My Hero is a garbage series, read One Piece/JJK/Kaiju/Chainsawman don’t waste your time on Reddit tier garbage.
@@TMac-os1hy my hero academ. is truly cringe. Just repackaged Naruto in Tokyo
I fully support Docs decision. I agree with almost 100% of everything he said.
Hes spot on.
Stop supporting people who openly say they hate you and are intentionally trying to ruin our beloved hobby and characters.
I’ve been talking shit to Dok because he always complains yet he will keep buying the books which to marvel shows you still support it and as long as you buy it that’s all they care about.
@@fishin4bass2002 That's the same issue I have with people who continue to watch Disney remakes. They complain but they still continue to watch more Disney remakes. They are just encouraging Disney to profit off your Nostalgia
@@fishin4bass2002 Speak with your wallet.
@@zemox2534 not to mention a lot of people are paying for subscriptions and don’t even know it.
I've said that in other comments as well. The old stuff is better than what they "produced" now. It's just pathetic. Marvel used to be so innovative and great💪. And DC created the greatest superhero of all times. Superman. Without him there might not be any superhero comics. They threw in the trash. That's not fair. But what is fair in the life? Justice is only available in the Justice League and happy endings only in the cinema.😒
Granted, this UA-cam show had huge part in me also pretty much quitting comics. Because I not only have nothing I want to read, but I also have a lot of creators i actively don’t want to give my money. 😬 It’s sad and I miss reading comics, but I use the time to dig up older stuff I had missed and read comics I always put on my „later“-reading-stack.
Switch to Epic Collections or omnibus. Read the good stuff from before
Or just start filling in gaps in back issues
I started going hard at collecting and wanted to buy everything new i could get my hands on and it quickly dwindled into less and less weekly pickups and i started going for comics i wasnt around for or hadnt heard of before and its so much more rewarding of an experience
@@jcaceres516 This is the the way
Dok quit because he is not a comic book fan, he is a middle aged fan with arrested development
Zeb Wells was good in X-Men with both New Mutants and Hellions.But Spiderman was the worst decision, he destroyed everything Spencer built, although I think it was more editorial and C.B.'s decision. But still the way he did it made me angry.
This is such an unfortunate problem that you'd think would be easy to avoid or prevent yet with every choice the industry keeps making the wrong decisions.
With those writers there is no future for new comics. I'm drop them some time ago, I was tired of feeling sad and mad about a situation that wasn't going to improve. Having 1% of good content that is connected to a pile of trash isn't worth of it.
Dok is right. Variant covers sales have decreased by well over half in the last six months or so.
Store sales have plummeted. Sales at cons have tanked --- some people don't even make their table fees back. And guys doing eBay sales are tired of buying back their own books (for a fee), and are now quitting buying the variants from us.
I always had one question about variants that nobody ever wanted to address ..... If they are an expensive niche product within a very small industry, who you gonna find to buy them off you ???
the variant problem happened in the 90's as well not sure why they never learned from that time because variants lose their appeal and value and they over produced books which helped pushed marvel into bankruptcy.
I walked from comics back around 2013 or so. It got to the point where I wasn't having fun anymore, no matter what book I read. I like the idea of comics, but I don't like the execution of comics and in the modern woke era, I wouldn't be caught dead with any of it. I'll go back and read classic stuff, but anything modern, hard pass. I will never give them my money again and today, that goes for the MCU as well. I can't stand modern media anymore. I've got tons of comics and DVDs and other things that I can go and watch, why should I bother with the crap that's currently on the stands? The only way these people are going to learn is if they go bankrupt. Adios. I stopped caring a long time ago.
Not all modern media is bad. There are a few diamonds in the rough.
@@zemox2534 I agree, there is the rare gem but that's getting harder and harder to find these days. We used to buy 100+ DVD/Blu-rays every year. Now, if we get 20, that's phenomenal. We used to watch 12-15 TV shows a week. Now, we're down to 2-3. Used to buy a metric ton of comics back in the 80s. Today, I wouldn't touch any with a ten foot pole.
Alterna exists.
I don't know what a current woke era is but I'm still enjoying marvel, dc, and more
Literally u said exactly what I'm feeling.....I'm still a little on dceu and stuff....but mcu and comics ? Done with them
I’m with Dok except I bailed out earlier. I was getting all the X titles and when they ended them all to start the Jonathan Hickman reboot I thought, as a collector, that this was an opportune time to stop collecting. I was right about Hickman. He was not the messiah we were praying for.
Welcome to the club. We would all love to come back to reading and enjoying comics again but the big two are dead set on not letting that happen. They rather die.
This 1 is for Dok. I know personally how hard it is to walk away from something I never thought I would, but the comics industry made it clear they don't want me or my money anymore. In two months check how much money you saved not paying ppl to insult you. For me the number was crazy. Congrats and good luck Dok. Wes good vid
If cholesterol had a voice...
This is even shocking to me but my cholesterol is great. Decades of smoking, drinking, whoring around, and eating terribly, and I’m still doing great.
Thank You Dok!!!
My pull box has continued to diminish to only Batman and Daredvil.
- Captain America has no spine always questioning America.
- Spider-Man is a bipolar whiny bitch. Marry MJ or get rid of the character
- Superman is a ruined character that lacks any unique powers since we have dozens of Kryptonians flying around
- X-men like Dok said are a bunch of hippy drug pushers on an island.
- DC turns every character bi or gay for click bait ruining continuity.
Like Dok my disposable income will not fund these these terrible stories by horrible writers that ruin continuity, turn these overpriced books into rom coms, and try to manipulate me into buying events.
This is so true with everything you said it sad how our beloved Comics has become in the last few years😢
Dok's explanation as to why he doesn't find indies appealing is exactly where I stand.
Always worth repeating: Superheroes aren't characters, they are products. You can still find solid work in smaller publishers, out of the superhero genre. Brubaker's Criminal series continues to impress. People get killed, stay dead, and the death means something. What a concept!
This is me at this point now. I just can't handle the unabashed narcissistic and venomous intent of most current day "creators". The complete lack of accountability and just God tier arrogance while they shit on the thing I've loved for literally most of my life is too much. We used to talk on Pontificators about how to save the big 2, but now I can't even discuss it, it's so disheartening.
The last time I seriously read X-Men was when Grant Morrison wrote it. I would have continued reading past his story-block, but I became very annoyed when one month after Magneto had a magnificent death, he was brought back to life and the new writer threw out Morrison's work. I attempted to pick the book up a couple of times and then the last was the beginning of Hickman's run. I stopped for the same reason I have never been fully invested in X-Men. I just don't have the finances or willingness to purchase 20+ X-Men monthly related books, 20+ monthly Spider-Man related books and the same for Batman. 20 is an arbitrary number but I'm sure you will understand. I have never forgiven Marvel for destroying Peter Parker's marriage and (Norman Osborne) sent his newborn daughter to the slave trades of Europe while faking her death to the parents. Norman Osborne has to answer for that last sin. Am I the only one that remembers that travesty? I really want to roll back to the 1970's and early 1980's of storytelling in comics.
I'm with you. The Baby May storyline still stings.
I started reading them in the 50's & EVERY kid read comics. There was something for everyone no matter what their interests. 🙂🎃
You guys do know there are comics outside of Marvel and DC right?
Love that laugh @ 24:03 😂😂😂 was perfect
"Heh-ha. Enjoy unemployment"😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Beautiful
I don't blame Dok for quitting new comic books. I have cut back to buying two or three books a week because there are so few good books to read. I have given up on all event books. I just stopped caring...
God, listening to Dok talk about Wildstorm’s glory days was depressing me. Those were damn good times. And he’s right, Wildstorm isn’t Wildstorm if you have Batman showing up. I thought for awhile that Valiant might give us an alternative. But, for people who enjoy the bits and pieces of how an interconnected universe works, good luck!
Most of the sales at my local comic shop are collectors that don’t read the comic. The roughly 10 titles I read a month are non-DC/Marvel. Sad…
I disagree wit Dok on Indies. I have read alot of indies and crowdfunding books. Saying that it is a streamlined, etc. books makes me think he hasn't read a lot of Indie's at all. There are some great comics out there
Saga came back, radiant black, deadly class ends on Wednesday and others that I haven’t gotten around to show me that indies are king. I read old marvel and dc but indies have been amazing
@@haltwhogoesthere47 Right? And that's just a handfull. I enjoyed KYRIE on indiegogo alot, GROKEN, BONDS, the Drive, Perfect 10 and Aaron Lopestri's Wraith of God is fantastic. There are really good quality comics out there. Even Image, Dark Horse, Awa Upshot, Ablaze are pumping out cool comics lately
@@darksydeiscomics1891 so how long do you think you can keep up reading indie comics.
@@chilesai1117What kind of question is that? I buy them as long as i want to
the Big 2 gave me a mix of a few things that I've never been able to find in any indies:
dozens or hundreds of unique superheroes (power sets run the gamut & have no single point of origin)
an interconnected line of books set in the same universe that interact periodically with one another
an ongoing narrative.
As much as I loved Invincible, it was a steamlined series with only the occasional spin-off mini. The Spawn titles are fine but they're just variants of the same character. I can get 1 or 2 of those items in indies, but I can't get them all. I can get any of those individually from any number of other forms of media.
Dock’s right ASM has been less than average at best which is a shame as I’ve been reading ASM for so long and I pick it up still out of like loyalty or routine I guess! Dok I’d recommend Mighty Morphin Power Rangers from Boom. Also Venom has been to ambitious imo, fantastic interview Wes 🤘
What gets me is how these super hero comics aren’t super hero comics and these writers have to change who these characters are fundamentally and change their respected histories. I don’t care if a comic like swamp thing isn’t a super hero comic because it’s supposed to be a horror comic not a super hero comic. Also these comics only take 5-10 mins to read despite costing more. Nothing really happens in these comics. What used to happen in one comic now takes 3-6 issues. They have to constantly mock not only the fans but also the genre and it’s history. What makes todays comics even worse is how they try to make you read all of these other comics just to keep up with one series. For example if you are just reading Spider-Man, X-men or venom your going to have to read 14 titles during the dark web event, 20 if you want to read everything including the ms marvel and the Mary Jane and Black Cat tie ins. Then there are going to be even more events where they expect you to read more tie in books and event issues. I don’t want to have to read all these titles I don’t care about.
I gave up Batman when Bob Kane stopped doing it!
It's crazy that *both* the X-Men and Spider-Man are terrible at the same time. I would be annoyed if I read Spider-Man (I won't cause OMD). Nobody likes or wants to watch a story where their favorite character is hated and cucked by the established love interrest, unless it's someone fetish or something.
I agree with the part where like, event after event, tie-in after tie-in, when do you get back to the main story of whatever book you are wanting read? Dark Web, and then soon summer of symbiotes. I'm definitely considering dropping venom.
Awesome work mate
thank you! i learned my prostrate gland was swollen from the ad in the middle of this video. heres to shrunken prostrates!!
Poor Doc 😔
it's good to heard his feelings on this whole thing. Thank you
Welcome to the club. I haven't bought a new comic in over a decade and never looked back. Put my $20-30/mo comic budget towards back issues. I've almost completed my Marvel Two-in-one run.
Marvel Two-in-one is a great comic. Are you also going to buy the two Marvel Feature issues that came just before Marvel Two-in-one?
Marvel Team-up was great too.
@@sonic31century1 I just have the Defenders issues of Marvel Feature. I would love the Thing/Hulk issue though. I'm a sucker for team up titles. Super-Villain Team-up is another good one, Namor and Dr. Doom.
same quick comics in over 10 years its going on 15 plus years now and never looked back its even worse now for art and writing and pushing politics into them. i did end up buying some of the 70's x-men books tho.
Poor, doc. I know how he feels, yet I still have a little bit of hope that things will get better in the future. Touch wood. Fingers crossed. Amen.
I'm sure things well get better not only is comics going through a phase but all of society is going through a phase right now it won't be like this forever. unfortunately for me personally even if things do get better i think I'm kinda done for good. I'm not even interested in back issues. this generation really did kinda ruin my love for comics. ill always enjoy these characters and ill still tune into a movie or tv show that looks good but i think I'm pretty much done with comic books themselves
I did the same with superheroe movies and shows, they are so generic , nihilistic and/or woke now. No other option is allowed. I used to watch and dedicate my free time to comics and superheroe content, but after rebirth I was so jaded about the whole thing that decided to let it die. decided to focus on better hobbies, health and my career and I think is the best decision. dont care anymore so the news dont affect me , I just watch SOME youtube channels from time to time because I liked the people making the content.
Dok Unfiltered. The Late Night version of 'The Dok is always right show'.
I'd recommend Dok get into Geiger, Radiant Black, and Samurai Doggy for indies.
I understand Dok. The only CB I keep up with now from the big two is Moon Knight. That’s the only decent comic from Marvel. Everything else I’ve found has been meh. And to be honest outside a few indie books I’ve just preferred manga a lot more. It’s very sad to see Marvel and DC go down how they did. And with this golden age of CB media slowly hitting its end the fallout is going to be larger. But I doubt these companies care. They don’t want folks like us. The actual fans who’ve stuck around for decades. And you know what? Cool. There are plenty of good alternatives out there.
I’m just gonna put my $ into car parts. I’ll go back to my car building hobby or buying tools.
Moon Knight,Daredevil and Amazing Spider-Man are my only interest in Marvel today.
@@ScienceJesus That's perfectly fair and reasonable. Definitely a better investment than modern CBs. :)
I haven't quit buying new comics, but I'm buying less new books than ever. At this point, I only pay for things that I know will be good. Way to much trash out now to spend money sampling things.
"we collapsed the tent so there would be room for everyone"
and they all froze in the snowstorm
After I read “One more day” I quit ASM the only way I would come back would be go back his own book ASM issue # 801 with Mary Jane as his wife.
Well Wes, you did manage to break Dok before you. Congrats (I guess)
I haven't given up entirely, I just stop and read the TPBs before stopping some stories, and combine this with back TPB when applicable
Could you recommend comic books similar to Clive Cussler or Tom Clancy?
Welcome to the club. Hey at least Doc gets to choose his exit some of us were forced out when all the local shops near us shut their doors due to lack of sales.
Zeb wells? The one that’s a writer for robot chicken? And super mansion?
Yup. I think he was great on hellions but the problem is that style isn’t going to work for Spider-Man. He doesn’t respect continuity or the characters enough to give him a legacy character. He’s a comedy writer who wants to mess things up.
where's his channel?
I can’t co-sign on this one. I agree with most of your videos. But that just felt like an unfocussed rant from Dok to me.
Zeb Wells and JRJR Spider-Man for me is exactly the sort of book I enjoyed in the 80s, 90s, 00s. It’s solid superhero stuff with no ideological crap fused to it. Most of the guys I know who have fallen away from most big two comics are loving it, with the exception of the tie-ons and the upcoming event, which is very frustrating.
This just feels like a personal taste thing as opposed to a commentary on modern comics. The entire rant on Batman just felt like one big long moan.
I’ve not read it as the XMen line is to unwieldy, very uneven, poorly structured and there’s a lot of terrible books attached to it, but Immortal XMen and what Gillen has been doing has been well received generally. I’ll check that out on Marvel Unlimited at some point.
Lumping Ben Percy and Keiron Gillen in with Vita Alya and Danny Lore doesn’t seem fair at all. Percy has done a great job on Ghost Rider and his books over at AWA are solid. Gillen has had a pretty good career, probably not a writer I’d single out when there is dozens of crappy writers out there more deserving of criticism.
I haven't bought a new comic in years now. I started falling off after new 52 showed that it wasn't a actual reboot.
And I'm glad I never picked it back up.
Having dropped x-men post hox,pox did they actually verify the triangle with scott,jean, and logan ?
I loved original WildCATs, this current run by Rosenberg…I’m hoping it picks up cuz so far…
i just flew through a Thor Epic Collection from the early 80's, there has not been an ongoing run in my comic-buying life that I would have kept on with like this stuff. It's rich in lore, it's not in such a damn hurry to shock me, or to get internet buzz, it's fucking great.
I guess I am quiet quitting new big two stuff. Just looked at last LCS run and it was mostly reprint books from the big two and a few indies.
You hit on the head, there were so many bad eras and the good eras lasted for the briefest of time. Now I am just collecting random issues from the past but nothing from the last 8 years. I am not even seeing the movies.
The last 3 issues of Xforce have been good, and I'm looking forward to the next.
I quit buying weekly new comics from Marvel, DC and the independents quite awhile back. The JLA/Avengers drawn by George Perez had happened (a dream crushed byJim Shooter and Dick Giordano in 1983) and Jeff Smith's Bone ended four months later. For the next several years I found myself buying approximately ten comics a week, reading them once, then giving them the bag-n-board treatment... never to be touched again. I kept looking, but, the thrill was gone. Nothing new could compare to those two events from 2004. Fables and Walking Dead came closest.
I had a financial hardship in 2015 and regretfully sold my entire collection (except any comics worked on by Perez or John Byrne and the Bone hardcovers). When I got back on my feet, I decided to focus on collecting backs issues of Marvel, DC, Archie, Harvey and Gold Key starting with 1969 (the year I was born) and ending in 1989. Along the way I started adding smaller publishers like Pacific, Eclipse, Dark Horse and Comico. I only had spinner rack comics growing up, so, characters like Cerebus, Jon Sable, Grimjack, Ms. Tree, Flaming Carrot and American Flagg are all "new" to me. It's been a slow process, but, it sure has been FUN!
I still read random new comics from pirate sites and keep up with news on the the 'net hoping that something... ANYTHING... new will reignite that spark. If it never happens, I am perfectly happy knowing that I have LOTS of stuff still to explore from two decades worth of comic book publishing!
I've probably purchased less that 100-200 new books since Marvel's Original Sin event. I was becoming wary of the editorial and creative practices at that time, and unfortunately, they got worse.
I'd been actively accruing a collection of comic books since the late 80's. I just had to walk away.
Welcome to the club, Doc!
I quit supporting new comics years ago. All the woke trash isn't worth the trash paper its printed on.
Bingo. you'd have to pay me big bux to read that crap.
Pretty much have given up with new comics, the whole Peter in Tasm thing is ridiculous since The Avengers, F4 (Richards) X-Men have done worse. The storytelling is soulless, characters constantly being regressed or changed for adding politics and most of the writers not knowing nor acknowledges the established history or backstories about the characters. Also biggest bs is mutants can return yet Gwen can only stay for a sec.
You did it !! you said you would get him to quit. !!! Sometimes getting what you want feels…. 😢. a little empty!
Also gave up a long time ago. Christ the shit's so badly written nowadays i couldn't justify the bandwidth pirating it. I use channels like this and others to check if it's still shit or of it's getting better.
I agree. Stop feeding the ESG. These companies are doomed.
My steak and potatoes always depended on a good GL title from DC, and other 2nd and 3rd string books. At one point in time I was collecting around 17 monthly titles from DC. I like characters like Hawkman, Captain Atom, the JSA, the Ray, the Freedom Fighters, characters and teams like the Question, Aquaman, Young Justice, Impulse, LoSH, and I've always been a stan for Grifter. There's just not enough out there anymore to really get me excited for the broader DCU. I've never been a big Batman fan, I've read a few decent runs though. I'm occasionally a fan of Superman.
If I learn something after purchasing a few Spiderman comics after from childhood to collegehood, is that the comics are too diluted and bait and trick. I believe i try to retry marvel comic spiderman during the avenging spiderman comic line (few months before the superior spiderman began) and I was like….. what the fuu*$?!? After few issue, I gave up after if was too much for me.
I understand the situation with spiderman comic now (marvel just killed the golden goose before dc could kill there golden goose or bat goose) and wonder if this fall of marvel heroes means that that marvel is accelerating faster to pass dc into their comic getting bankrupt first.
This is why I haven’t been in touch with marvel or dc because of so many shenanigans bull$&#% that they been pushing so hard that its like a horrifying mess that the entire place fill with turd and black fungus and molds with a pinch of some random worst virus that’s hard to tell where its coming from.
Now I am curious the comic sales of this year now if marvel and dc claimed their sale are doing well. I going for 90% liar liar liar pants on fire.
Oh dok….. I recommend One Punch Man manga to help ease the pain.
Im starting to feel the same way as Dok too, I mean especially the fact that modern writers and artist at DC is making most of their female characters looks less sexy looking by covering up almost everything including WONDER WOMAN (my main favorite female superhero, with her original blue star Spangled short trunks which is literally part of her leotard armor being covered up by a skirt making her look like Xena a bit) now theyve gone a bit too far covering up Powergirl, Harley Quinn, and probably Zatanna and Starfire too including I mean FEMALE HEROES CAN LOOK SEXY IF THEY WANT and not as being seen as a war crime I mean MARVEL eased up on that a bit on some of their Female characters having their old outfits back She-Hulk got her old leotard back is being is one of them examples but left Captain Marvel fully clothed, but still some comics nowadays due to these bad writers
Yes, I quit ASM after the Judgement Day tie in. Not even touching Dark Web. I have dumped all Spider-Man books except Carnage at this point. I still find Ram V's take on that story very interesting.
New subscriber here. Love your coverage/content so far. Totally agree. I just want to comment on something I haven't heard anyone talk about yet. It's funny that alot of the titles that are still beloved to many, and were made into movies (not necessarily high quality), were alot of times involved with or directly authored by a very very woke individual. Alan Moore. Has anyone else noticed this? I mean, just recently, he wanted all of his "proceeds" to go to a group that is almost inarguably funneling (stealing) donations to fuel a very very select few (BLM). Has anyone ever covered this?
Though I agree with a lot Dok said, it can take while before you find something new you can totally loose yourself in. I mean it took me a few years, but I ended up at Coffin Comics (Lady Death, Hellwitch etc), which was a far cry from what I used to read; but its written & drawn by proven industry vets. Who know how to tell stories about good vs evil and all the struggles, challenges & character development that comes with it. Of course the frequency in which these comics are released is slower, which perhaps is the main reason why so many cant adept. Crowedfunding to my opinion isnt a long term sustainable solution (especially not for international comic readers), and many of them still hold on to bad habbits from the past (specially when it comes to variants, cross overs, starting point for new comers), so we only can hope the indie scene (which holds a lot of experienced people) develops itself "quickly" to become the new norm (and hopefully also have learned from the past).
He was a fan of X-Men and Spider-Man, not comic books. That's fair enough, but we need to be honest here and admit that this kind of fan being the focus of the industry for so long is a big part of why comics are in the shape they're in.
I know people like to think that the comic companies are trying to drive the old fans away, but if they're trying to do that why are they sticking with the direct market? Why are they constantly handicapping digital? Why are they still releasing floppies? They're not trying to drive them away. DC and Marvel are taking the old fans for granted. They think, because this is what they've seen over and over again, that these old fans will buy anything as long as it has their favorite character in it. We're at the breaking point of this philosophy, but it worked for a couple of decades.
I don't care about Marvel and DC, but this is the best era for indie comics that I've ever seen. If the indie publishers could find some way to market their products to places outside of the direct market they would leave the "big 2" in the dust. Probably won't happen, though.
Dok, Look at Hunter Ninja Bear by Chuck Dixon. Or, Wes, tell him about it.
I think uncanny X-Men was written by Scott lobdell in the 90's.
Agree with all Doc has said. I stopped collecting comic books in 2015. I had by that point found everything boring. I was spending way to much money on books I wasn't reading, just buying to keep the runs going. And from what I see today, I made the right decision.
Good for Doc I’m very much one foot out the door and saying good bye to new comics again myself
I’ve been putting my money into Manga and back issues only new thing I’m staying for is Artist Elite really want to see what Chad Hardin does and it’s been really solid book
3 creators & 3 character stories for one price
I really do think if Marvel and DC drive us away there will be no pushback on what they’re putting out currently they don’t take the criticism constructively they just say we’re hating just to hate and double down
Even if I end my relationship with new books I will always support my LCS because they’re truly the ones being hurt by the poor quality books that are un sellable either because poor writing or art or just high prices
Are you SURE you won't be considering going Pure Indie Books and Rippaverse instead for your Money?
So does that mean no more Dok on the channel?
The way the comic industry is run has long since been outdated in terms of the mindset of its staff.
Ask yourself this right this second comic fan who is reading this.
'New Person A has been chosen to write Comic Title B in the 4th Quarter of this year.'
When that scenario comes up does it make you want to go out and read the book? Likely it doesn't and the reason is simple. You will not trust 'Person A' to not ruin something you care about.
The Comics industry has treated itself as being the same as the TV and Film industry and it just doesn't work, you cannot trust that 10 years after you start it that some edgelord or political agitator is going to be there and make it about their personal stupid thing. If this were 20 years ago I'd suggest you all have an absolute solid roadmap out that is not to be shirked at all with solid guides for all stories in any particular series and nothing is meant to change it.
These days it's far too late. Solo indie comics is the only way forwards for you now.
I quit buying American comics in April (except for the Spawn Universe stuff, I’m still an unapologetic Mcfarlane fan boy). I will attest that I am much happier now that I’m not supporting bad comics. I hope the big two get there act together. I’m happy with my Manga and Mcfarlane comics. I get excited about what I’m reading now, which is how it should be.
I stopped buying new DC/Marvel in the early 2000s mostly for economic and logistical reasons; I was broke and comic book stores weren't anywhere near me anyways. Once the money situation cleared up around 7 years ago, I ducked back into DC/Marvel/Image and was horrified at how bad the product was compared to what I remembered just 15 years prior.
I'm buying more comics now than ever, but I'm buying Manga, Bande Desinees, BOOM!, Dynamite, 80s back issues from DC/Marvel and crowdfunded stuff. I feel bad for people who still feel compelled to buy DC/Marvel new.
I always believed when I ran the shop for NEC, if you are open and willing there is always something to find to read. There are enough genres of material to cover nearly anyones interests. But once you reach Dok"s level of fuck it really doesn't matter. You can't sell anything to more to them, and because they are so vested in super heroes they won't even listen to give something different a chance. And usually once they are gone they are gone for good. The ones that come back, or come back cause there is some sequel to something from 30 years ago they loved, are very few and very far between. This is something the industry never really understands. It's very hard to create a new fan....maybe 1 in 10 people will really become one. But loosing them is twice as easy. WTF20.
How does Chuck Austen compare to current writers? I haven't read X-Men in 20 years or so
Chuck Austen would be an improvement on every writer in that office. And that's a very sad commentary.
@@ScienceJesus it does seem like it. My condolences to you, Dok. Witnessing the death of your hobby
Hush isn’t very good and the animated adaptation is somehow even worse. Even Jim Lee’s art couldn’t save that thing. I only really know Snyder for his Batman run and I did like a lot of it, there’s a lot of great Batman moments and character moments imo and Black Mirror is one of my favorite Batman stories of all time, easily Snyder’s best work on Batman. End rant.
Hush was great other than the changing of the ending because everyone predicted it to be Jason coming back. So they chose to change it & give us a swerve to make Hush’s identity some dude nobody ever heard of before.
@@ScienceJesus - that and the story was just Batman fighting his entire rogues gallery. The art was fantastic but how on Earth does Poison Ivy take control of Superman? Does she know he’s Clark Kent? Did she just sneak up on Superman while he’s doing Superman things? How does Hush so easily manage to manipulate life long master criminals? It just felt sloppy and way too convoluted for no reason towards the end and felt way too similar to Long Halloween without the emotional impact or tightly woven plot.
Zeb wells Amazing Spider-Man run after the first story arc the series is lost in crossover hell so you get small incomplete stories if you don't care about the events the are involved in.....the stories I find interesting is the throw back series...
Dok has my sympathies. Some of these comics have been so unreadable that I can't even sit through reviews of them! Anyways, I haven't read regularly-scheduled new comics back in 2004-ish when my tent-pole (CrossGen) crashed down. Since then, its just been sporadic purchases of whatever tpb of gn looks interesting at the time...
X-men Red is not that bad... Or am I biased?
companies dont see the money they dont get
Dayum Dok,tell us how you really feel 0_o? Lol.
But I feel his pain and I can relate. I go to comic book stores to pick up dollar bin books, manga, back issues, and action figures.
My new comic buying habit has been very modest for many years. Basically, I just nibble around the edges with fun stuff like DC facsimile editions, Looney Tunes, DC Horror: Sgt Rock, etc. That's fine, because I usually read a couple back issues in bed every night.
I have too. I quit getting new comics well over a year ago and I don't regret it. Now I only buy collectable comics, silver and bronze age.
lol Chuck Austin X-men 🤮. I dropped Marauders vol 2 after issue 3, I have 4 and 5 But blah it’s just bad. The X-men was awesome though this month! Except for Havok, pumped on the cliffhanger though! I wish more Xbooks would end with cliffhangers like that. Immoral and Red are still the best of X.
I'm with Dok, Damian Wayne is one of main reasons of why I cannot stand modern Batman books.Everything that I read with Matt Rosemberg I found boring and weak stuff.I have no faith with the Wildcats in the main DC universe.These characters don't belong there.Amazing Spider-man,Daredevil and Moon Knight are the only comics that I follow today.
The characters don't even act like themselves anymore in the stories. Why waste my time?
I feel basically the same as Dok nowadays. It's ridiculous.
I drove well out of my way to check out a new comic book store a couple of weekends ago. Went to a town I hadn't been to in a couple of years, specifically to check out _a comic book store_
Guess what I didn't buy.
_A fucking comic book_
Bought Magic cards instead. Old stuff at that, because the new stuff is as bad off as comics are.
For those in the area - Buddy's Comics in LaGrange, GA is pretty cool, albeit _tiny_
Preach Dok.
UA-cam seems to be deleting comments, not sure what the key words are, so posting again.
I dropped all DC/Marvel during June/July because I got to the point where I couldn't financially support either company anymore.
It'll send a much stronger message to the publishers if fans support good indie comics and drive those up in sales than dropping out completely.
There are some great indie books out there once you shut off Marvel/DC and accept they're dead.
Gunslinger, King Spawn, Death Dealer, Nottingham, A Town Called Terror and maybe Vanish(first issue was fantastic).
i quit comics over 15 years ago. it has only gotten worse.
@Wes, I agree with you most of the time, I love your videos. But you should be careful who you give a platform to on your channel and not to get sucked into the doom and gloom.
Some guy in his 40s announcing he’s quitting comics, just comes across as a child having a tantrum, then he’ll probably be back reading again in 6 months time or whatever when something big catches his eye (I see it all the time).
Your channel is great because you have a balance between genuinely merited criticism and then some positivity and recommendations (many of which I’ve taken on board and checked out).
While agree that the industry is an absolute mess, particularly the big two, there’s always gems out there if you look hard enough (as you know).
Part of the problem is that there’s too many books being published across the board and too many wannabe writers who don’t have the talent to write a decent comic book. So the signal to noise ratio isn’t great. But that’s where we rely on guys like you to help us find the highlights.
Welcome to the party Dok. Took u a while. There's always manga and indie tho and of course the classics.
Welcome to the walk away.
Only DC I read is things I bought years ago and haven't touched or back issues on DCUI. Same for Marvel but I only sub to MU when it's free or dirt cheap
This is how I feel. Only I didn’t bail on comics. I bailed on Disney animation.
Sadly Marvel doesn't care anymore because they get their money making from their movies and TV shows nowadays. This is why I think they allow all these terrible writers more and more work because it just doesn't matter to them because their primary source of income is no longer the actual source material itself. It's a crying shame. As an X-Men fan I truly am depressed at the state of the books and for anyone who enjoys this Krakoa era...you clearly haven't read or respected anything that came before.
I feel like most people I see saying they’re quitting new comics are people that will only buy big 2 comics. I still buy them, but I buy like 3 or 4 books a month from Marvel. Indie books are a definite majority that I buy.