Can you use Solid Rocket Boosters to Land on Duna?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 346

  • @ReidCaptain
    @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +372

    I really want to strand someone on Laythe. After that, I'll start a rescue mini series.

    • @LordSeal7
      @LordSeal7 3 роки тому +4

      U are blessed by the seals, go google seals banana pose

    • @rowbot5555
      @rowbot5555 3 роки тому +2

      How about a liquid fuel only to laythe mission?
      Or if that doesn't work, then a monopropellant to laythe mission (much harder)

    • @adsjik3033
      @adsjik3033 3 роки тому

      puff engine to laythe :trol:

    • @charliewells9595
      @charliewells9595 3 роки тому

      That sounds fun

    • @saturnv1970
      @saturnv1970 3 роки тому +3

      SAVE THE PEOPLE ON DUNA!!!

  • @elmarjuz
    @elmarjuz 3 роки тому +13

    I've been following/playing/watching this game since alpha, so just under 10 years.
    This must be the weirdest physics-based approach to controlling solid fuel I've ever seen.
    Mad props, dood.

  • @labo3900
    @labo3900 3 роки тому +110

    About the altimeter you can push on the wave button so it tells you ground level and not sea level

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +37

      Handy!

    • @sergegordeev9426
      @sergegordeev9426 3 роки тому +9

      @@ReidCaptain It looks like blue waves when it displays altitude above sea level and like green mountains when it displays altitude above terrain.

  • @O5MO
    @O5MO 3 роки тому +167

    12:17 "I don't have a ton of fuel"
    Your rocket literrally have tons of fuel

  • @oliwierkwiatkowski8817
    @oliwierkwiatkowski8817 3 роки тому +515

    Well that’s a solid video idea!

    • @jereheiskanen1364
      @jereheiskanen1364 3 роки тому +7

      @Lochlan Batty i agree

    • @GriziDaWiz
      @GriziDaWiz 3 роки тому +4

      Let’s use solid rocket boosters to fly you into the sun. Where you belong for making such a pun.

    • @oliwierkwiatkowski8817
      @oliwierkwiatkowski8817 3 роки тому +16

      @@GriziDaWiz I'd say that would be pretty lit.
      like fusion lit
      lol

    • @marshaenderheart
      @marshaenderheart 3 роки тому +7

      Take my thumbs up and get out

    • @GriziDaWiz
      @GriziDaWiz 3 роки тому +6

      @@oliwierkwiatkowski8817 someone needs to stop this man.

  • @Hlebuw3k
    @Hlebuw3k 3 роки тому +93

    There are pistons and hinges with the "Breaking Ground" DLC. They actually work like mechanical parts, and can be chained like you tried with fins

    • @kristinabegail
      @kristinabegail Рік тому +1

      I think he ether doesn’t have it or it was before they were a thing

  • @thetacticalmedik7100
    @thetacticalmedik7100 3 роки тому +219

    Make a rocket that on last stage splits into 3 different rockets and save people on duna

  • @delfininsjezus
    @delfininsjezus 3 роки тому +38

    Tip: Go to general settings, enable advanced tweakables. Now you can enable autostrut on any part. Autostruts are invisible struts that make your craft more rigid

  • @mohammedmunir6419
    @mohammedmunir6419 3 роки тому +283

    Or you know, you could have just detached the solid rocket engines when you were at the right speed, and wouldnt need a heavy system to block the thrust

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +194

      Well yeah, or I could have prefilled the tanks to have the right amount of fuel, but that's less fun

    • @mohammedmunir6419
      @mohammedmunir6419 3 роки тому +69

      @@ReidCaptain true, i see your point, sometimes engineering the weirdest inventions is the best part of KSP

    • @alexwang982
      @alexwang982 3 роки тому +17

      @@ReidCaptain Or just use robotics??

    • @zderpydiamond4800
      @zderpydiamond4800 2 роки тому +8

      @@alexwang982 I don't think he had breaking ground installed.
      Just look at the tabs in the V.A.B.
      Shhhhhhhh...
      No I'm not a whole year late...

    • @AlexeiLjanej
      @AlexeiLjanej 2 роки тому +3

      @@zderpydiamond4800 im a year and 4 months late

  • @Lucius-Caecilius
    @Lucius-Caecilius 3 роки тому +22

    Build a bus rocket, it has several seperate capsules, and you can orbit a planet, drop a few capsules off, then move onto another planet, also loving this series :)

    • @minamagdy4126
      @minamagdy4126 3 роки тому +2

      And have the capsules autonomously return, for the rescue mission? Or should he strand more kerbals?

  • @shromp_
    @shromp_ 3 роки тому +219

    How about this: Going somewhere with only the most powerful liquid fuel engine in the game (I think it's the Mammoth? Whichever has the four small thruster nozzles on it.)
    Or: Going somewhere with only the weakest liquid fuel engine in the game (I believe that's the Ant engine but could be wrong)

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +67

      Oooo

    • @mohammedmunir6419
      @mohammedmunir6419 3 роки тому +13

      @@ReidCaptain I recommend using the spider engine instead for the first few stages, as it has better efficiency lower into the atmosphere, and has control gimbling, at the cost of being more heavy, but also the exact same thrust. The ant and spider engines are practically siblings, so might be helpful to consider both

    • @ziggythomas1123
      @ziggythomas1123 3 роки тому +4

      The weakest engine is the mini Puff engine, I forgot it's name. It's the smaller Monoprop engine.

    • @blakebevan1941
      @blakebevan1941 3 роки тому +2

      @@ziggythomas1123 that one is amazing for its size

    • @shromp_
      @shromp_ 3 роки тому +4

      @@ziggythomas1123 Maybe that is the weakest engine in the game, but I’m only counting liquid fuel engines, not monopropellant ones.

  • @YMandarin
    @YMandarin 3 роки тому +13

    kinda amzing how accurate you got your duna encounters with these crude ways

  • @fernandochueca4213
    @fernandochueca4213 2 роки тому +1

    I am amazed at how he gets to duna without a single manouver node and uses such a complex system instead of firing the rockets away. Also not using heat shield for rentery is amazing. Nicrly done!!!

  • @owlboy1827
    @owlboy1827 3 роки тому +5

    “On a lonely planet, slowly spinning its way to damnation, amid the incompetence and unpreparedness of lesser space programs, one team stands resilient against the herds. Putting their lives on the line to aid those who were previously unaware of the quicksave option. Yes, it's the incredible adventures of Jebediah and his crack team of Kerbalnauts. They are, The Blunderbirds! Saving the Kerbin race one stranded explorer at a time.“

    • @sneed2600
      @sneed2600 3 роки тому +1

      Matt and Reid need to collaborate video

    • @owlboy1827
      @owlboy1827 3 роки тому +1

      @@sneed2600 I concur

  • @zderpydiamond4800
    @zderpydiamond4800 2 роки тому +1

    14:45
    That landing was friggin awesome!!
    Aslo can we talk about how at 16:04 Bill fricking annihilated the solar panel and the headbutted the entire vessel like 5 feet into the air!!

  • @Shadowhurtz
    @Shadowhurtz 3 роки тому +6

    Notes for future videos:
    Pretty sure you can modify the deploy speed and altitude in the context menu for the parachutes.
    Congrats on doing a successful lithobraking though.

  • @1mariomaniac
    @1mariomaniac Рік тому +2

    15:24 unintentional lithobreaking maneuver 😆

  • @pokakoka69
    @pokakoka69 3 роки тому +2

    This rocket is the definition of adding more boosters and that's pretty nice

  • @EmbeddedWithin
    @EmbeddedWithin 3 роки тому +2

    Reminds me of the space shuttle’s system to lower the thrust for the soIid rocket boosters. At max Q they block some part of the solid rocket fuel that’s entering the solid rocket motor engine. Pretty neat. Blocking the fuel to lower throttle for a srm.

  • @YMandarin
    @YMandarin 3 роки тому +15

    You should start to use autostruts.
    Also, there are robotic parts like pistons, hinges etc. They are part of the breaking ground dlc though.

    • @josephraffurty9293
      @josephraffurty9293 2 роки тому +2

      Agreed. Regular struts or auto struts would help keel those side boosters flopping around and help stabilize the flight profile cause your thrust isn’t vectoring as they flop around.

  • @Secreto31126
    @Secreto31126 3 роки тому

    Loved the editing during the landing, the music reminded me the End Times song of Outer Wilds!

  • @slickhobgoblin9179
    @slickhobgoblin9179 3 роки тому

    Sometimes I have no idea what anything means during these videos but they are still so fun to watch haha.

  • @sp_1798
    @sp_1798 3 роки тому +2

    All these powerful rockets to deliver a like 3 ton payload. Keep it up!

  • @delta8816
    @delta8816 3 роки тому +3

    Tip: you can use mirror mode by pressing R. You won't have to fiddle around with making rails extend both ways and thus save on part count.

  • @redscopio3027
    @redscopio3027 11 місяців тому +1

    Structural fuselage has left the chat

  • @nathandavenport1996
    @nathandavenport1996 2 роки тому +1

    Thing is, if you switch the altitude mode from sea level to ground level, it will deploy parachutes 5000 meters *above* the ground- not sea

  • @LordSeal7
    @LordSeal7 3 роки тому +4

    Seals respect this

  • @GriziDaWiz
    @GriziDaWiz 3 роки тому +3

    So many kerbals were killed and harmed in the making of this...
    *good*

  • @Totally_Bonkers
    @Totally_Bonkers 2 роки тому

    this reminds me of how my first mun landing went. Wasn't professional at all, was going fast, lost like half of my thrusters in the crash, but jeb survived.

  • @samthecat8553
    @samthecat8553 3 роки тому +1

    I never thought I'd say this, but this is too Kerbal Space Program for Kerbal Space Program.

  • @billydunn582
    @billydunn582 3 роки тому +1

    that was both incredibly stupid (in the best KSP way) and absolutely ingenious, well done

  • @regularrock8637
    @regularrock8637 2 роки тому

    The reason your parachutes didn't deploy earlier isn't just because of your speed or altitude, but also because in addition to adjusting the deployment altitude, you also needed to adjust the deployment minimum pressure, that little thing that's set to 0.04 by default. That should be 0.01 on a Duna landing. That number sets the minimum atmospheric pressure the parachutes need to feel before they semi-deploy into their drogue mode. The altitude setting (which is set to 1000m by default and which you maxed out to 5000m) controls when the parachute goes from semi-deployed to fully-deployed.

  • @sfsclips6226
    @sfsclips6226 3 роки тому

    “I have to at least pretend to be efficient...”
    *DE-ORBIT FROM THE APOGEE*

  • @5APPH_13
    @5APPH_13 3 роки тому +4

    Hey, there's a DLC that gives you TONS of Robotic parts, it's perfect for this idea!

  • @EllyCatfox
    @EllyCatfox 3 роки тому

    That was one hell of a lithobrake.

  • @OutbackCatgirl
    @OutbackCatgirl 3 роки тому +1

    Don't forget you can set thrust limiters and a fuel limit on srb's. it makes a world of difference.

  • @Totally_Bonkers
    @Totally_Bonkers 2 роки тому

    this is the goofiest rocket i've ever seen. i love it.

  • @Lucius-Caecilius
    @Lucius-Caecilius 3 роки тому +4

    Build a rocket powered entirely by the smallest rockets you used in the final stage, the ones which didn't show thrust

  • @Andromeda69420
    @Andromeda69420 3 роки тому

    “So I’d be able to stop the solid fuel boosters”
    I caught that RC, lol

    • @minamagdy4126
      @minamagdy4126 3 роки тому

      I mean, they do boost the solid fuel

  • @TheColourOfFear
    @TheColourOfFear 3 роки тому

    About not being able to see the DV of the sepratrons, if you have advanced tweakables on, you can right click them and press something like "count in delta V"

  • @anonymous-rb2sr
    @anonymous-rb2sr 3 роки тому +2

    Dude, there is a robotics parts DLC that everyone uses, you should get that
    It was given for free to anyone who had bought KSP alreayd like all the other DLCs so most people have it it's not an issue

  • @rupert_1491
    @rupert_1491 2 роки тому

    Reid captain: plays game
    Nasa: write that down write that down

  • @helloeverything496
    @helloeverything496 3 роки тому +2

    Stratzenblitz75 went to the moon with only SRBs but he didnt block the thrust he just figured out the exact amount of propellant to put in each one.

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому

      That sounds kinda painful to tune, but I'm sure it was very satisfying once it worked out!

  • @OlaftheGreat
    @OlaftheGreat 2 роки тому

    "In the next episode, we'll be flying into the sun using only ion engines"

  • @razdahooman
    @razdahooman 3 роки тому

    Liquid Fuel engines: Look at what they need just to mimic a fraction of our power!

  • @mrpepsiman3477
    @mrpepsiman3477 2 роки тому

    you are currently my favorite ksp youtuber

  • @djelibaebi
    @djelibaebi 3 роки тому

    i dont understand anything about engineering and even less about anything that goes on in these videos

  • @enderger5308
    @enderger5308 3 роки тому

    Save every Kerbal you stranded in a single launch.

  • @DrewTeter
    @DrewTeter 3 роки тому +1

    I'm 3 minutes in and yelling at my screen "A hinge! Use a hinge!"

    • @HeizouHaver
      @HeizouHaver 3 роки тому

      He doesn't have breaking ground

  • @Monkeman1210
    @Monkeman1210 6 місяців тому

    Amazing channel, I know it's an old video, but you deserve to know from everyone you can. 😁

  • @piglinman6760
    @piglinman6760 3 роки тому +4

    cool rocket i just now subed :) :)

  • @platypus6523
    @platypus6523 3 роки тому +2

    Tip: you can use WASD to rotate your parts before placing them.

  • @normalbird8040
    @normalbird8040 3 роки тому +2

    you can press g for deploying everyone of the landing gears

  • @strajox
    @strajox 3 роки тому +4

    Waiting for only jet engines to duna :)

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +1

      Maybe one day, that seems v hard

    • @TheOneGaming0
      @TheOneGaming0 3 роки тому +1

      @@ReidCaptain just use the space air

    • @magica3526
      @magica3526 3 роки тому +1

      @@ReidCaptain it's not just hard, it's impossible

    • @dolphinman042
      @dolphinman042 3 роки тому +1

      @@magica3526 jets have been used to get to orbit, so Duna is maybe slightly possible to achieve

    • @sadoldman1234
      @sadoldman1234 3 роки тому

      @@magica3526 theoretically it's possible

  • @neolexiousneolexian6079
    @neolexiousneolexian6079 3 роки тому

    Hold down shift when using the translate gizmo, or at least use structural fuselages and cubic struts instead of empty fuel tanks.
    Good idea with the blocking. I tried to use staging, with separatrons that cancel out and push away lit SRBs, I think, which doesn't give anywhere near the same potential finesse.
    AIRBRAKES can be grabbed by the Klaw. You can use them as servos.

  • @cesare8270
    @cesare8270 2 роки тому

    Get to space using only the sepratrons, the little solid fuel rocket used to push things away when you decouple

  • @FlyingBaco
    @FlyingBaco 3 місяці тому

    I just watched a video about hexagons being the bestagons and at the start I noticed the wall of fuel tanks was a hexagon

  • @JeromeBakerSmoke
    @JeromeBakerSmoke 2 роки тому

    itd be cool if you could also make orbital launchers in the game or mass drivers and colonize planets and such

  • @De1taF1yer72
    @De1taF1yer72 3 роки тому

    Parachutes use altitude compared to the ground not sea level. You can also click the water icon next to your altitude to see altitude compared to ground.

  • @Papershields001
    @Papershields001 2 роки тому

    All solid, all day, everyday.

  • @seapeame3595
    @seapeame3595 3 роки тому

    You've created a piston engine in almost every other game... I think it's KSP's turn!

  • @JelliousSea_YT
    @JelliousSea_YT Рік тому +1

    Ok so, I loved it, every part of it, but I was cringing a bit, instead of deploying landing legs manually press the middle button on the right side of the distance gauge, and if you want to see how far you are from the ground, press the blue button directly to the left from the counter, your welcome.

  • @veritateseducational217
    @veritateseducational217 3 роки тому

    This is a great video! What’s with this low view count?

  • @zephranarx2172
    @zephranarx2172 3 роки тому +4

    Is it possible to use monopropellant to get anywhere?
    If so, land on a random planet using only monopropellant

  • @eagleboi3593
    @eagleboi3593 3 роки тому

    With the Breaking Ground DLC you can make servos which can put the heat shield in the way of the SRB.

  • @jacobkrout1627
    @jacobkrout1627 3 роки тому

    Well now you have to stage a rescue mission

  • @the_realmaquis5224
    @the_realmaquis5224 3 роки тому +1

    Me watching him build something in ksp using physics : laughs in kraken

  • @Klick404
    @Klick404 3 роки тому +1

    Idea: Only use the electric thruster. I’d be surprised if you could even get to Orbit

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +3

      As long as they can lift their own weight with enough of them it should be possible

    • @Klick404
      @Klick404 3 роки тому +1

      @@ReidCaptain possibly, good luck if you try though!

    • @YMandarin
      @YMandarin 3 роки тому

      @@ReidCaptain they can‘t lift their own weight on sea level. Some people did it though.

    • @geryz7549
      @geryz7549 3 роки тому +1

      @@ReidCaptain It is definitely possible, Bradley whistance has done it before

  • @natemyers1791
    @natemyers1791 3 роки тому

    If you enable advanced tweakables, you can see the delta v provided by sepratrons

  • @madsen1940
    @madsen1940 3 роки тому +1

    You should play Main Assembly

  • @ADonutMan
    @ADonutMan 3 роки тому

    I like how eberybody tries to challenge themselves with playing the game with only solid fuel boosters, while me when I first got the game didn't knew how to change thrust and just played onliy with solid fuel boostres XD
    P.s. I don't want to make myself look cool, this is really challenging great vid!

  • @baseddino
    @baseddino 3 роки тому

    using the solar panel to get out lol genius

  • @MarcWeavers
    @MarcWeavers 3 роки тому

    sepratrons have an option to make them show delta V, might need advanced tweakables enabled in game options

  • @ricktheostrich712
    @ricktheostrich712 3 роки тому +1

    I dont know enough about KSP to know if this is even feasible, but would it be possible to make a ship that can navigate underwater, like just building a submarine and not a spacecraft

    • @scavorthespacecowboy2096
      @scavorthespacecowboy2096 3 роки тому

      Submarines are possible to make with a DLC, I forgot which but it adds propellers

  • @aidan9411
    @aidan9411 3 роки тому

    If you don't know, the Breaking Ground DLC adds robotic parts which could have REALLY helped you out this mission.

  • @BlackholeYT11
    @BlackholeYT11 3 роки тому

    I'm watching this like, "does he even have the Breaking Ground robot parts?" lol. You could literally have just used a robotic hinge from the start

  • @dathomirpizzagirl9686
    @dathomirpizzagirl9686 3 роки тому

    Bro that end was so fucking stressful

  • @demapples144
    @demapples144 3 роки тому +1

    Make a rocket using only the tiny boosters

  • @TheOneGaming0
    @TheOneGaming0 3 роки тому +4

    Could you have used engines facing up to counter the bottom ones

    • @nikkiofthevalley
      @nikkiofthevalley 2 роки тому +1

      It would double the weight and add dead fuel. Not a good idea.

  • @worldoliwier2242
    @worldoliwier2242 3 роки тому

    Thats a Solid feat

  • @oLxcid
    @oLxcid 3 роки тому +1

    I woud recommend buying ksp complete edition it adds robotic parts such as hinges pistons motors and propellers

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому

      Ye just picked it up, didn't realize what I was missing out on

  • @GoofballPaul
    @GoofballPaul 3 роки тому

    Perhaps just using separator rockets pointed at the booster to blow it up to kill its thrust would be more effective than your heatshield gizmo?

  • @XAORESS
    @XAORESS 2 роки тому

    Ah yes. The good old times before robotics dlc

  • @slashshake2371
    @slashshake2371 2 роки тому

    you could just add hinges that will move in and out, so you could throttle it from 0-100

  • @xapplezapple3453
    @xapplezapple3453 3 роки тому +2

    Plz do more of KSP

  • @xiphos5740
    @xiphos5740 3 роки тому

    Love the series!

  • @GamingClubGermany
    @GamingClubGermany 2 роки тому

    You could also just use parachutes on the undersite to slow enough to slow you down but that would be cheating
    Awesome videos! keep it up!

  • @maximilianmorse9697
    @maximilianmorse9697 3 роки тому +3

    Do you not have the Breaking Ground DLC that adds pistons and hinges?

  • @jkirby47
    @jkirby47 Рік тому

    I got so confused when you where building until saw you take off

  • @Royalgreen_
    @Royalgreen_ 3 роки тому

    Maybe rescue all kerbals at once
    that would be fun (:

  • @wuzz111
    @wuzz111 3 роки тому

    This would be so easy with the robotic parts DLC. Then all you would need is a piston or servo

  • @metalandsteel
    @metalandsteel 3 роки тому

    You know what else you should do? Build a base on Duna and have ships airdrop supplies

  • @RedLuigiE
    @RedLuigiE 3 роки тому +1

    Ik you and RCE do collabs for Poly Bridge 2, can you do it for KSP? ALso, how do you know this much about this game?

    • @ReidCaptain
      @ReidCaptain  3 роки тому +4

      Very little, I played a few years back and am just having a good time with it

    • @RedLuigiE
      @RedLuigiE 3 роки тому +1

      @@ReidCaptain Fair but I'm still considering you a pro a KSP. (Do you do UA-cam for a living? If so, on a technicallity, then you are a pro)

    • @Fisheiyy
      @Fisheiyy 3 роки тому

      There is not multiplayer by default for KSP but you can use the mod Luna Multiplayer and setup a small server to mess around on

  • @bob38028
    @bob38028 3 роки тому

    Looks like somebody never took their solids modeling course
    Jokes aside this is an excellent step in furthering the engineering prowess of Kerbal kind. 10/10

  • @cakeman4356
    @cakeman4356 3 роки тому +4

    Fly to the mun and back with only solid fiel and no decouplers allowed

  • @GK34779
    @GK34779 Рік тому

    you could also go somewhere only using RCS if you want...

  • @GK34779
    @GK34779 Рік тому

    you could use only the 'poodle' liquid fuel engine to get to Moho if you want...

  • @sadanchouhan7014
    @sadanchouhan7014 3 роки тому

    Make a exoskeleton sir
    It's a different idea thats wayyyyyy took much fun

  • @woohoo1092
    @woohoo1092 3 роки тому

    Getting to Kerban's moon using only RCS thrusters lol

  • @ramchandrabelsere6820
    @ramchandrabelsere6820 2 роки тому

    You dont need to stop srb you just need to adjust thrust and fuel