Why would women who aren't a genocide supporting politician who embraces US's biggest war criminals and wants the US military to be the "most lethal in the world" feel defeated?
No one cared about Kamala being a woman, we cared because she is an incompetent piece of shit who would have thrusted America deeper into a hole that just makes America look stupid. We won as Americans when we elected a good leader rather than her manipulative lying ass. Trump 2024
Beautiful list. I still get emotional when I rewatch Babs present Bigelow with the Oscar. But I’m surprised Anne V Coates didn’t make the list for her editing of Lawrence of Arabia-that’s some of the most iconic work in the history of film.
Astonishing to believe Rachel Morrison was the first woman to be nominated in the Best Cinematography category in 2018. 😱 Cinematography remains the only category never won by a woman.
Because she was a horrible candidate. Dems were arrogant, again, chasing that "A woman won!" instead of nominating the best person for the job. Bernie Sanders.
hard video for today (and I am not even American) I would add Hildur Guðnadóttir first woman (I think) who won Best Original Score since Dramatic Score and Original Musical or Comedy Score categories were combined and that was in 2020 so it took them a while Greta Grewing being the only woman nominated for best director in the 2010s (if I am not wrong) is mindblowing because how is it possible that out of 50 slots, 49 were taken by men? i guess women can do anything...except become the president of the US.
@girlboss3426 i am not 2010s are period from 2010 to 2019 (by that I mean the year of film release not award date). We are in the 2020s. Jane was nominated for 2021 (in 22) and Justine was nominated for 2023 in 2024.
Loved this video! Thanks a lot! I have two petitions: - Can you make some videos not predicting nominees or winners, but giving your own choice with your own criteria of who are the top 5 in each category and the best. Without all these Oscar politics and out-of-the-movie considerations? - Can you make some videos about acting, director and best movies for foreign language movies? There are so many movies made around the world that It would be amazing if you could talk more about them in the several categories and not only compress everything into the one single category of best foreign language movie. Thanks a lot!
Thanks for mentioning Ruth Prawer Jhabwala! I've read her book, Heat and Dust, and watched the film years later (also by Merchant-Ivory), loved them both.
Ironically, even as a huge movie buff, I can only name two film editors from the top of my head - both of them women - Thelma Schoonmaker and Sally Menke (not counting directors cutting their own films). Great vid!
Devastating time are you serious. Did you not see the election results, Kamala lost which means America is going to be better and stronger than ever. I thank god every day we didn’t elect that lying, manipulative, incompetent, piece of shit hack as our president.
Love for Verna Fields missed out from the list. I know you could only squeeze 10, but she was groundbreaking, not to mention her editing on the best film of all time - JAWS
Thank you for doing this today. We see you, and we appreciate you. I know Kathryn Bigelow gets the #1 spot before I even get there, but every second of this is a treat... but wait, where's Verna Fields for "Jaws"?!
Just a name dropping, but i met her last year and the person was very interesting and inspirational that i need to talk about her : EUZHAN PALCY has won an oscar for her all career in 2023, and if you're able to find it you should watch her 2 first movies " sugar cane alley " and " a dry white season " . As a french person really fund of cinema, i never heard of her before I met her despite her winning a f***g oscar ! That's how we used to care about women in the movies industry ( even in France ) , and that's what we need to change ASAP.
It fascinates me when a film get a best pic nomination, and the director does not get nominated. I remember Billy Crystal hosted the 1992 Oscars and during his intro, he did a medley of songs for the film nominees. Specifically, for "Prince of Tides," I remember, "Did this film direct itself?" That line lives in my head.
I want to include Rachel Portman, who won Best Original Score for a Musical or Comedy in 1997. It's a category that was later discontinued. Portman won for her lovely score for Emma, and she was the only woman in the category.
It would have been great to see Rachel Portman on the list, and although the video only mentions individual achievements, I think Marilyn Bergman and Lora Hirschberg deserve an honorable mention as the first women to win in the score and sound categories, respectively.
Great, great video Brian, as usual, I truly loved it. Speaking of Kathryn Bigelow, what do you think happened with her film Detroit ? There was a lot of Oscar buzz, and in the end I was really disappointed when the movie was snubbed at the Oscars. A video about that would be perfect. Thank you so much Brian.
Sorry but there are 2 huge abscence Marina Cicogna and Julia Philips. Cicogna was the first woman who won an oscar as Best Foreign Film (only 3 or 4 women director won that) and Phillips who was the first Academy Award Nominee and Winner for The Sting, a couple of years later of Cicogna win. From both I choose Cicogna had better and most memorable films with better directors in her short but influensial career
Great video! How about another video about how no black directors have won best director? In nearly a century of the Academy Awards and ZERO wins plus no nominations until the 1990s? It was truly shameful! 😢
It makes me so happy to aee Sofia Coppola get her due. She was absolutely eviscerated for her performance in "The Godfather III", a film she was thrown into at the last minute and didn't even WANT to do. She was so very young, and people were so incredibly cruel. For as much as Hollywood is lauded/derided for being liberal, it's still very much a boy's club. These women have fought tooth and nail to get where they are.
Talking about woman"d achievement In this show Love Without End. Lin Dai was originally a country bumpkin who came to seeknher uncle The leading actor Kwan Dham found out her talent in Singapore and before long she became a famous singer. This song described the countryside where she came from. Reminiscent of the storyline in My Fair Lady which came out in 1963. This show as in 1961. ua-cam.com/video/aGRWgbSf4hk/v-deo.htmlsi=D60xhtQr7sVX1iFp
The victory for Thelma & Louise's screenplay bugs me a lot because that is NOT original at all. It is almost a copy-paste of Bless the Beasts and Children!
Nomaland is so dull. Im sorry. Chloe zhao went on to direct the terrible marvel film eternals. The first marvel movie to be certified rotten on rotten tomatoes
Eternals was artistically the best marvel movie made in the 2020s definitely underrated and I think retrospective criticism shows it is widely appreciated by most cinephiles
@@ChrisThomson-y7l Not necessarily. It challenges the formula. I don't think we should always make movies that follow a pattern. It tried something new. It was interesting. Formulaic is so mundane. It was beautiful.
@thereyofwater Ruth E Carter won in 2018 for Black Panther(not one of my favorites i hate superhero movies in general) becoming the first African American to win Best Costume Design(I don't even think there were men nominated that year in that category tho) Brian could have easily missed it but not all the academys fault 😉
@manligi9701 and men have been nominated in that category before. Not in the last decade I mean but men have been nominated and even won in the category before.
9:05 Am I the only brown guy that hears people refer to pale east Asians as "people of color" and goes 🤷🏽♂️ Feels like whitewashing the mere concept of people of color. Reminds me of when the press called Antonio Banderas a person of color 😂😂😂😂
I remember people complaining about the snub of Greta Gerwig in best director even though she did a pretty normal directing job on just a pretty decent movie. Plus all the men in the category just did much better on the films they had
At the 1965 Oscars there were two costume awards--for black and white films and for color films. There were 3 female and 2 male nominees in the b&w category. The winner was Dorothy Jenkins for The Night of the Iguana. In the color category there were 3 male and 2 female nominees. The winner was Cecil Beaton for My Fair Lady. So yes, women have won for costume design, but men have been nominated and have won as well.
That's not the point but I hope The Apprentice get at least a nomination for best makeup, it was almost uncanny how Sebastian Stan looked like Donald Trump, incredible
Sarah Polleys win for Adapted screenplay is such a terrible win. Its literally just feminism so over the top and ranting about how women are awesome and all men are pigs
@miguelsantos-cd9tu yep. The movie that said that all men are monsters and systemically would allow all other men to do such atrocities. Its baffling how much nuance is completely skipped in that film. But calling 12 year old boys as rapists was an extremely disgusting piece of screenwriting I had to sit through.
@SoulKnightKing Just because Trump won, does not mean it is stupid troll day. The film is based off a book based on a true situation. This actually happened (and is worse) and this is an imagining of what was discussed. The fact that you can’t relate because you lack empathy for women(possibly due to your own actions?) or survivors of abuse does not make this a bad movie.
Episode 13 is also very frightening starring Patricia Neil. A woman finds herself in a hotel room without her husband. What subsequently happened would terrify. This episode is the one I remembered clearly The theme is very original. The woman found out she was dead and about to meet her maker but her husband was still alive in the earth plane. It is said that married woman gets even more success than singles if they marry well and have longevity in their marriage ua-cam.com/video/NQX-WczviZg/v-deo.htmlsi=pPZmEw0UtMLBJLP7
Of the 33 episodes of ghost Story in 1072, the one I saw as a child was Episode Mo. 11. It was about The Haunted House that goes tick tock tick I'm the middle of the night when the Grandfather Block goes chiming It is done very subtly done throughout the session and more frightening than The Smeyybille Horror The title of this episode is Touch Ofadnedd. In Jong Kong Shaw Brothers there was a show whose the tun along similar lined when a group of youngsters in hrtited s house with strange happenings. I incorrectly temnetrf this episode ad a setting in the 19th century The woman came back to her roots after gaining much fame and success ua-cam.com/video/T6crD5jyVDQ/v-deo.htmlsi=HSbIokYeAgE8vNtO
Honorable Mention: Hildur Guðnadóttir who won for Best Original Score from Joker!
🎉 yes
Came here to say this!
On this day where many women feel defeated, I think you for this video
Why would women feel defeated … xx-xy….
@@davidkaplan5507harris
Why would women who aren't a genocide supporting politician who embraces US's biggest war criminals and wants the US military to be the "most lethal in the world" feel defeated?
*leftist women. FTFY
Surprising you say that when the dems don’t even know what a woman is!
Hildur Guðnadóttir for Joker is a really notable win, too. One of only 3 solo female winners in that category.
I was very surprised that win didn’t get mentioned at all
Thank you for this especially today. I needed to relive these moments and hear someone who is appreciates the wins of talented women.
No one cared about Kamala being a woman, we cared because she is an incompetent piece of shit who would have thrusted America deeper into a hole that just makes America look stupid. We won as Americans when we elected a good leader rather than her manipulative lying ass. Trump 2024
I would have included Verna Fields winning Best Editing in 1976 for Jaws - that for me was an awesome win.
Where is Emma Thompson in adapted screen play ?
Yeah 🤔
How you gonna include Sarah Polley and not even MENTION Emma Thompson winning all the way back in 1996?!?
Bigelow should of been nominated for Director for Zero Dark Thirty. Inasnity
Schoonmaker is far and away one of the best editors of all time. So many masterpieces edited by her
Ironically (inadvertently) timed video?
I disagree. Videos like this is WHY the timing feels bad; make no mistake, this fuels people the wrong way
well no.. because it was obviously intended to be a topical celebration of trump losing.. oops how did that work out?
🎉
@@yeahiagree1070 A lot of optimistic people underestimated the gullibility and hatred of the American people; I wasn't one of them.
@@PicklesRTasty huh?
Beautiful list. I still get emotional when I rewatch Babs present Bigelow with the Oscar. But I’m surprised Anne V Coates didn’t make the list for her editing of Lawrence of Arabia-that’s some of the most iconic work in the history of film.
We see what you did here and we appreciate you for it, Brian
Astonishing to believe Rachel Morrison was the first woman to be nominated in the Best Cinematography category in 2018. 😱 Cinematography remains the only category never won by a woman.
I would’ve listed Hildur Guodnadottir when she won original score for Joker. Technically she is the only woman to win for “Original” score.
She didn't win today 😢
@@Ninaofthe90sThe not zee god? No, thanx, spanx. 🤮
At least sharice davids won her seat
Because she was a horrible candidate. Dems were arrogant, again, chasing that "A woman won!" instead of nominating the best person for the job. Bernie Sanders.
Maybe in 2028, who knows? :)
GOOD!!!
I love your videos. Warmth radiates.
Thank you for the shout for The Remains of the Day! One of my all-time favourite films, a great adaptation of a great novel.
Needed this today. 💔 Thank you.🗽
What about Verna Fields for her win for editing Jaws
0:42 It's ironic that Rick Baker holds record for most wins in make up, he won 7 times.
Julia Phillips- first woman Producer- but she shared with a man, I get that- but it was a huge moment- maybe do a video on that.
hard video for today (and I am not even American)
I would add Hildur Guðnadóttir first woman (I think) who won Best Original Score since Dramatic Score and Original Musical or Comedy Score categories were combined and that was in 2020 so it took them a while
Greta Grewing being the only woman nominated for best director in the 2010s (if I am not wrong) is mindblowing because how is it possible that out of 50 slots, 49 were taken by men?
i guess women can do anything...except become the president of the US.
You are very wrong cause justine triet was nominated this year,we also had jane campion and chloe zhao(and both won)
@girlboss3426 i am not 2010s are period from 2010 to 2019 (by that I mean the year of film release not award date). We are in the 2020s. Jane was nominated for 2021 (in 22) and Justine was nominated for 2023 in 2024.
Loved this video! Thanks a lot!
I have two petitions:
- Can you make some videos not predicting nominees or winners, but giving your own choice with your own criteria of who are the top 5 in each category and the best. Without all these Oscar politics and out-of-the-movie considerations?
- Can you make some videos about acting, director and best movies for foreign language movies? There are so many movies made around the world that It would be amazing if you could talk more about them in the several categories and not only compress everything into the one single category of best foreign language movie.
Thanks a lot!
Thanks for mentioning Ruth Prawer Jhabwala! I've read her book, Heat and Dust, and watched the film years later (also by Merchant-Ivory), loved them both.
The timing of this video. I see you, Brian 💙
Great list. Thank you❤
Ironically, even as a huge movie buff, I can only name two film editors from the top of my head - both of them women - Thelma Schoonmaker and Sally Menke (not counting directors cutting their own films). Great vid!
i can't imagine how does it feel. love from brazil yall.
Very educational video in a devastating time. Thank you, Brian 😭
Devastating time are you serious. Did you not see the election results, Kamala lost which means America is going to be better and stronger than ever. I thank god every day we didn’t elect that lying, manipulative, incompetent, piece of shit hack as our president.
Brian that title gave me kick. Wish it was her today instead too
Thank you, Brian, for a very educational video.
Love for Verna Fields missed out from the list. I know you could only squeeze 10, but she was groundbreaking, not to mention her editing on the best film of all time - JAWS
Too soon
Thank you for doing this today. We see you, and we appreciate you.
I know Kathryn Bigelow gets the #1 spot before I even get there, but every second of this is a treat... but wait, where's Verna Fields for "Jaws"?!
Thelma Schoonmaker is the best living editor (it helps that I love Martin Scorsese)
Where is hildur guadinottir, sian heder, jenifer lame, emerald finnel.
Just a name dropping, but i met her last year and the person was very interesting and inspirational that i need to talk about her :
EUZHAN PALCY has won an oscar for her all career in 2023, and if you're able to find it you should watch her 2 first movies " sugar cane alley " and " a dry white season " .
As a french person really fund of cinema, i never heard of her before I met her despite her winning a f***g oscar !
That's how we used to care about women in the movies industry ( even in France ) , and that's what we need to change ASAP.
...Maybe Ill watch this one tomorrow...
Most editors in early Hollywood were women. Once Hollywood and Wall Street got in bed with each other, the women were replaced.
It fascinates me when a film get a best pic nomination, and the director does not get nominated. I remember Billy Crystal hosted the 1992 Oscars and during his intro, he did a medley of songs for the film nominees. Specifically, for "Prince of Tides," I remember, "Did this film direct itself?" That line lives in my head.
I want to include Rachel Portman, who won Best Original Score for a Musical or Comedy in 1997. It's a category that was later discontinued. Portman won for her lovely score for Emma, and she was the only woman in the category.
It would have been great to see Rachel Portman on the list, and although the video only mentions individual achievements, I think Marilyn Bergman and Lora Hirschberg deserve an honorable mention as the first women to win in the score and sound categories, respectively.
Great, great video Brian, as usual, I truly loved it. Speaking of Kathryn Bigelow, what do you think happened with her film Detroit ? There was a lot of Oscar buzz, and in the end I was really disappointed when the movie was snubbed at the Oscars. A video about that would be perfect. Thank you so much Brian.
Apt. It'll happen, but not today.
I don't understand the hype around lost in translation.
That’s okay you dont have to
Sorry but there are 2 huge abscence Marina Cicogna and Julia Philips. Cicogna was the first woman who won an oscar as Best Foreign Film (only 3 or 4 women director won that) and Phillips who was the first Academy Award Nominee and Winner for The Sting, a couple of years later of Cicogna win.
From both I choose Cicogna had better and most memorable films with better directors in her short but influensial career
The Big House was a great movie with a great story. I’m so happy Marion won for that.
Maria Cocigna and Julia Phillips Sorry but these 2 women were more influential and epic than most of your list
Maybe for round 2
Great video! How about another video about how no black directors have won best director? In nearly a century of the Academy Awards and ZERO wins plus no nominations until the 1990s? It was truly shameful! 😢
It makes me so happy to aee Sofia Coppola get her due. She was absolutely eviscerated for her performance in "The Godfather III", a film she was thrown into at the last minute and didn't even WANT to do. She was so very young, and people were so incredibly cruel.
For as much as Hollywood is lauded/derided for being liberal, it's still very much a boy's club. These women have fought tooth and nail to get where they are.
It definitely sucked for her but it was her father that got most of the ribbing because he casted his own daughter in such a large role.
where's Original Score...Hildur won the Oscars Best Score for Joker at the Oscars 2020..
What about Carly Simon and Melissa Etheridge in Best Original Song?!
Next time, baby...
Quite topical for today
Jane Campion winning best director for a terrible terrible Power of the Dog before PTA is a crime against humanity
I am sending huge support for american women today (from Poland)
I would mention Jennifer Lame for Oppenheimer’s editing!
How about the first woman to win Original Score, Rachel Portman in 1997? Hildur Godnadotir the second solo woman to win Score 13 years later.
Talking about woman"d achievement
In this show Love Without End. Lin Dai was originally a country bumpkin who came to seeknher uncle
The leading actor Kwan Dham found out her talent in Singapore and before long she became a famous singer.
This song described the countryside where she came from.
Reminiscent of the storyline in My Fair Lady which came out in 1963. This show as in 1961.
ua-cam.com/video/aGRWgbSf4hk/v-deo.htmlsi=D60xhtQr7sVX1iFp
The glazing in this video is crazy
The victory for Thelma & Louise's screenplay bugs me a lot because that is NOT original at all. It is almost a copy-paste of Bless the Beasts and Children!
hope more women win Oscars
Shame y’all missed your chance at history on the 5th 😒
I tried to watch Nomadland, but I could finish it. I don’t get why it got so many awards…
It’s Oscar bait 100 percent. Chloe Zhao’s career has also since completely derailed with Eternals so it was a complete fluke
Because it’s total awards bait and the narrative of a woman of color directing it helped it
Because that year was absolutely terrible. The competition today is almost nonexistent
what about queers won an Oscars...
Kamala didn't come out on top
Not looking good for Sebastian Stan now.
Isn't it ironic that the nation who fought against Hitler just elected his reincarnation for president again!
@@genericyoutubecommentchann7418yeah he has to hide for 4 years behind the other side of the wall
🎉
Nomaland is so dull. Im sorry.
Chloe zhao went on to direct the terrible marvel film eternals. The first marvel movie to be certified rotten on rotten tomatoes
her films are getting exponentially worse (and were never all that to begin with.) eternals literally one of the worst i've ever watched.
Eternals was artistically the best marvel movie made in the 2020s
definitely underrated and I think retrospective criticism shows it is widely appreciated by most cinephiles
@@ThisApp it’s terrible
@@ThisAppeven in the most basic structure of filmmaking it completely fails.
@@ChrisThomson-y7l Not necessarily. It challenges the formula. I don't think we should always make movies that follow a pattern. It tried something new. It was interesting. Formulaic is so mundane. It was beautiful.
There are zero black women on ur list, why?
That's the Academy's fault, not his.
@thereyofwater Ruth E Carter won in 2018 for Black Panther(not one of my favorites i hate superhero movies in general) becoming the first African American to win Best Costume Design(I don't even think there were men nominated that year in that category tho)
Brian could have easily missed it but not all the academys fault 😉
@@stevenstevenson5303
He said costume design mainly has women as is and he wanted the categories where there's mainly men
@manligi9701 i guess people need that today
@manligi9701 and men have been nominated in that category before. Not in the last decade I mean but men have been nominated and even won in the category before.
9:05 Am I the only brown guy that hears people refer to pale east Asians as "people of color" and goes 🤷🏽♂️
Feels like whitewashing the mere concept of people of color. Reminds me of when the press called Antonio Banderas a person of color 😂😂😂😂
Who actually cares about the gender of a director, editor, or screenwriter? If they make a great movie then they will be recognized
I remember people complaining about the snub of Greta Gerwig in best director even though she did a pretty normal directing job on just a pretty decent movie. Plus all the men in the category just did much better on the films they had
This 👏
❤
Nomadland is the textbook definition of Oscar winning movie that is absolute bore
Are we ever going to stop seeing gender when it comes to awarding merit and artistry?
Never at this point
They first have to define what gender means. All these crazy progressives!
No, because the left extremists won't ever let it go. It's clearly narcissistic tendencies.
This is unjust that men didn't win costume design
At the 1965 Oscars there were two costume awards--for black and white films and for color films. There were 3 female and 2 male nominees in the b&w category. The winner was Dorothy Jenkins for The Night of the Iguana. In the color category there were 3 male and 2 female nominees. The winner was Cecil Beaton for My Fair Lady. So yes, women have won for costume design, but men have been nominated and have won as well.
Donald Trump won Y'all
What are the Oscar and Box Office chances of 'The Apprentice' now?
None
The ending of that movie makes sense now
That's not the point but I hope The Apprentice get at least a nomination for best makeup, it was almost uncanny how Sebastian Stan looked like Donald Trump, incredible
🎉
@LuisDDT2 Stan could land the 4/5th place behind the frontrunners, Strong for supporting much more difficult
Sarah Polleys win for Adapted screenplay is such a terrible win. Its literally just feminism so over the top and ranting about how women are awesome and all men are pigs
Is this movie that viewed 12-year-old boys as potential rapists?
@miguelsantos-cd9tu yep. The movie that said that all men are monsters and systemically would allow all other men to do such atrocities. Its baffling how much nuance is completely skipped in that film. But calling 12 year old boys as rapists was an extremely disgusting piece of screenwriting I had to sit through.
@SoulKnightKing Just because Trump won, does not mean it is stupid troll day. The film is based off a book based on a true situation. This actually happened (and is worse) and this is an imagining of what was discussed. The fact that you can’t relate because you lack empathy for women(possibly due to your own actions?) or survivors of abuse does not make this a bad movie.
So you didn't see the movie huh?
Most of this wins were undeserved of their Oscar. Not because they are women, of course, but their work was no the best in most cases
Kind of an ill timed video lol. We all know why you posted this, don't cry...
Why are you so bothered?
Zero self awareness here.
Why??? I mean, why??? This is such an absurd topic to make a video upon…
A hope a SHE gets the best Actress oscar and not a He (Carlos Gascón)
Oh man. It's 2024. Show some respect!
@victorlages5347 men are men in 2024 or 1892
@@victorlages5347This chick is on every video commenting the same thing. Her transphobia is exhausting.
@@gabbyb7347 stupids are stupids, but much more in 2024
Let her go nuts. These are the kinds of trolls that may end up helping Karla Sofia Gascón’s narrative in the long run!
Episode 13 is also very frightening starring Patricia Neil.
A woman finds herself in a hotel room without her husband.
What subsequently happened would terrify.
This episode is the one I remembered clearly
The theme is very original.
The woman found out she was dead and about to meet her maker but her husband was still alive in the earth plane.
It is said that married woman gets even more success than singles if they marry well and have longevity in their marriage
ua-cam.com/video/NQX-WczviZg/v-deo.htmlsi=pPZmEw0UtMLBJLP7
Of the 33 episodes of ghost Story in 1072, the one I saw as a child was Episode Mo. 11.
It was about The Haunted House that goes tick tock tick I'm the middle of the night when the Grandfather Block goes chiming
It is done very subtly done throughout the session and more frightening than The Smeyybille Horror
The title of this episode is Touch Ofadnedd.
In Jong Kong Shaw Brothers there was a show whose the tun along similar lined when a group of youngsters in hrtited s house with strange happenings.
I incorrectly temnetrf this episode ad a setting in the 19th century
The woman came back to her roots after gaining much fame and success
ua-cam.com/video/T6crD5jyVDQ/v-deo.htmlsi=HSbIokYeAgE8vNtO