RWBY White Trailer: Original Vs Anime Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 чер 2022
- Would you want me to make more of these comparison videos until July 3rd, when I'll upload my first RWBY IQ On Crack Part 1? Let me know what you think about it!
- Комедії
While the anime version adds Weiss' family watching her fight, I love the OG one more because the dark background contrasting with the white actors really nails home the feeling of loneliness. Even at the beginning of the trailer, we see her in a stadium full of spectators and paparazzi but no one feels like they're really "there." Sure Weiss' family in the White trailer can still be watching her, but we as viewers can't see them. Weiss' mental space doesn't register them in the moment, so it really puts us in Weiss' shoes and it emphasizes how she's pitted against an opponent 10x her size and being all alone with no one to help her.
I won't even compare the choreography and musical timing because nothing can top Monty's cinematography. He's mastered those aspects all around and it would be unfair to compare it to a retelling on a completely different medium.
The loneliness & white-on-black contrast (even the “mirror”) was actually referenced in the final scene of ep3.
if combined with the quality of the anime then the tone of the og omg it ganna be godly
@@dolf_ if it was done by ufotable they maybe able to copy the camera and the choreography one to one.
then it definitely would have been godly.
i agree. i think adding the family into the picture is too much especially for a trailer. its context/exposition that is misplaced and is added too early. It follows the trope of many other animes/characters and takes away from Weiss by adding her family.
A lot of people are forgetting to mention how well the OG fight works with the music. It was like a fucking magical dance to watch, it adds a shitton to the experience.
The timing and impact of the fight was better in the og. People calling out bias seem to be forgetting there's more to an animated fight than how pretty the visuals look
The inclusion of Jacques,Whitley,winter and Kline was a nice touch to connect the trailer to the show (also Queendom Jacques has more bones in his face than willem dafoe 🤯)
and he still have the fking clip-on tie
Well this was the White episode was not season it was the bonus material but yes seeing her whole family was good in the Manga it showed a mad doctor controlling it like a machine a father was pist about the scar. The SiG manga series i believe or dc comics im a big fan so i could be mixed up here but your absolutely right also in the version it mad Dr was there only observer. If your a fan check out the manga's and Dc comics:) Crow shows Ruby what her moms weapon was cause everyone said she used a sword she used a scythe, It was just really well laid out.
@@ponytailmoth8548 that my man Jacque richest man on remnant still using a clip on
Not bad at all. The anime adds her family members watching her fight, it makes a good addition. Still, in terms of choreography, the OG Trailer still won 😌👌
Yeah, but the modern rwby choreography is not nearly ass good as this.
Disagree, the anime is better at least in this fight
Tell me you're biased without telling me you're biased.
@@KusogakiRenfir Basically quite some amount of the fans who says the same thing lol.
The fight animation from White trailer was made by Monty Oum. It's without contest that Monty's fights would be better. However, those were pretty much THE best parts of OG RWBY.
Something I didn't notice until I watched this video where the two fights are side by side, but in the original Weiss uses her glyphs to skate along the ground more than she does in the anime version. In the anime, she just straights up runs when moving across flat ground and only uses the glyphs for air platforms.
as usual biased and far-fetched
@@skitt2366 ??
@@skitt2366 tell me you can't explain without telling me you can't explain
It's almost like sliding on the ground is easier to animate than running lmao
@@plmokm33 first of all I don’t think it necessarily is. And second, if it really is easier then all the reason the anime should’ve done it. Better and less spending.
The anime version was pretty good except- the ice dust attack that stopped the Armor at 2:05
That felt like it started up too slow compared to how hard the og Trailer went.
Yeah, it looked like it could've easily moved out of the way before the ice reached it
There's many of these small slow awkward moments in-between the fights in ixe queendom, probably to save the budget for the more well animated shots
That's also the part I kinda feel slow in that part but whatever
I think it's for the dramatic effect, the pause makes it more impactful. But the next part where she jumps on the blade does feel a tad too slow.
@@billlee3851 more like the pause makes it look shittier
Man, i miss watching Monty Oum's animations. It's snappy, it's fluid and most of all, it gives a sense of its own floaty physics that they still, imo, struggle to emulate to this day. That said, I'm glad the anime is capturing a lot of that feel from the action scenes from the original and are giving more context to the shit they essentially added later on and pretended has always been part of the lore (they're not pretty good at having basic worldbuilding in the original first few volumes till they got an actual writer much later in the volumes).
Ice Queen added some tension, and did a good job making the scene part of the larger story. But the original was a more exciting fight. The fluidity of the action and the camera, the pacing... Monty Oum really had a grasp for making fights a joy to watch.
The original trailer and it's scenes were always part of the larger story. It was important in establishing who Weiss is and what she does.
Both of these are amazing in their own way FOR the purposes they were made.
The White trailer was just that--a trailer. It's purpose is to show what the show is capable offering in terms of visuals, choreography, timing, and animation. Monty did an amazing work with it, and the song in the background was also great. But when we first saw it, we had no idea what it even was about, but it was just a huge hint of what Weiss as a character is. All of the White Trailer was just a teaser and it's amazing.
IQ's bit served as an INTRODUCTION, not only to Weiss as a character, but to a vital part of the story. With the medium, of course we can't get the exact frame rate, the angles, and they had to adjust the timing of the choreography so it would flow according to the fps, but at least we get some artful keyframes that I should commend for its clarity! I often have a hard time watching action anime for that very problem, but IQ so far nails it. They added the Schnee family as art of that storytelling process, which is a great decision, in my opinion, as the intro already serves as a summary of, if not the entire story, at least the characters involved. Everything is clearer to us in just a few minutes, and we're not left wondering about what else the story has to offer. That being said, I'll forever miss the original soundtrack, but I can understand why they won't add that--copyright stuff included.
In my opinion, no one won because they're not supposed to compete with each other. They have different purposes. The original was to showcase Monty's animation, IQ focused on the storytelling aspect and seems to aim at fixing the amount of errors in the original's story, but also giving it its own path to forge. Comparing them would be as pointless as debating the better Joker among Heath Ledger and Joaquin Phoenix. So far, I'm impressed.
Very well articulated!
Totally agreed with this one
I would actually disagree. In terms of pure storytelling I don't think the anime version does much of that. It feels more like easter eggs or fan service to include her family since someone unfamiliar with the source material will still not get a lot of characterization from it aside from that Jacques not believing in her as much as Winter. We don't even know who Jacques or Winter is so there's not much we can analyze about her family situation from this.
What's great about the original trailer was the music got in her head and did some foreshadowing of her character arc. It also alluded to her singing career and popularity contrasted with her loneliness on her path as a warrior. There was a lot of symbolism (e.g. the mirror transitions and the shuttering of the lights in the performance hall as she dedicated herself fully to the strike) and it had a theme whereas the anime discarded the theme of loneliness and symbolism in order to be realistic.
@@joshuaf2072 Valid, valid. I kinda fail to see them as easter eggs tho because it's been so long since I dove into RWBY itself, it's as if I'm looking at the anime through fresh eyes instead of coming from the original. I'd really have to disagree with the fan service part. Before the fight, it was well-established what kind of family Weiss has: a mother with drinking problems, a devious younger brother, a judgemental and belittling father, and a sister that at least tries to train her to be better. Even from someone who has forgotten the original source material, I learned so much about the characters faster than I did when watching the original RWBY, having to wait like.. 3 volumes? Then honestly I stopped watching after that.
As for the themes of loneliness being discarded for the anime, I understand the anime would feel very impersonal to a lot of people because it doesn't emphasize what Weiss *feels* underneath the stress of her family's expectations. Maybe I forgot to put this is in my original comment, but the White trailer's purpose included that-emphasis on who she is as a character and what she's feeling. Side note, I've always believed her singing career was just an excuse to add the track reasonably into the episodes, but I never took her seriously as a singer because she doesn't sing for the rest of the series (or I stopped watching when she did again), so I'd understand why they would remove that trait from her.
In IQ tho, we already have an establishment of what her family is like before the reanimated White trailer portion, so the audience can have an idea of how lonely she is already, but we don't need to dwell on it. While the White trailer requires introspection from the audience to relate to the showcasing of Weiss's character-because it is a *trailer* which teases what the show can bring and introduces just a hint of the characters, in this case, Weiss's true feelings, the anime is more forward in it's storytelling and doesn't need to dwell on Weiss's situation. The anime focusing on moving forward, and same with Weiss. The fight focuses on what Weiss HAS TO DO even if it's against her family's expectations.
Tldr: White trailer focuses on Weiss's feelings while being pressured by her family; IQ focuses on Weiss's liberation, determination, and rebellion against those pressures. It's not about being lonely anymore, it's about doing what has to be done despite the pressures.
The loneliness & mirror-transition were actually referenced in the final scene of ep3, so… kinda?
The anime version is good... But no where near being able to give me goosebumps when listening to the haunting music and perfectly choreographed balance of action and concert transitions.
Yeah, the original is more fluid as well. Leaving nothing to change in the spirit of the battle and the haunting epic of a song entangled in it.
The OG choreography is much better in all of the clips I've seen, but the music is the bigger problem for me.
The RWBY ost is actually really good and the music is always fitting. In these clips all I hear in the anime is generic battle music
I totally agree about the music, but I'm actually shocked at how good the anime choreography is. It's very close, sometimes even better
@@hundvd_7 its ok to lie
@@cubepvc and its okay to let go of nostalgia man
@@hydratedobama8450 The fight choreo for IQ still objectively feels inferior to the original, but it's still noticeable better than a lot of fight scenes out there. No talk no jutsu, no prolonged pauses where the character renders themselves vulnerable to the enemy while planning a strategy in their mind. Just wordless and never-stopping fight choreography where the characters think on the fly
This fight literally feels WRONG without Weiss' melancholic singing in the background it has a way different feel and also anime Weiss' moves are 95% less elegant
I like the inclusion of Jacques, Whitley (especially him we love extra Whitley content), Winter etc but it makes the fight a bit less personal to her in my opinion
Was about to say just this!!!! Her ballet/ice skating flow isnt there instead feels more like….a spear wielding goddess i know of
@@chibamoon6410 Of course not. Anime is rather the type of animation that's conservative in frame rate. We really wouldn't be able to achieve the same smooth 3D animation with just keyframes and a lack of many in-betweens. That's why they had to rely on their keyframes, but the interpolation gets wonky, resulting in the lack of elegance.
Limits…are all the same…
@@mariacillan9668 i don't think it's the fact it's an anime, since later volumes of 3d RWBY also fail to capture this feeling. it's probably the fact that Monty Oum (the animator) was a dancer and a fencer, so he knew all of the little details to add in order to make Weiss feel more elegant
@@luxenn awww honestly you're right. It's one of the reasons why I stopped watching the original one. Altho in terms of choreography, I prefer this anime over the latest volumes of RWBY. The studio seems very experienced in drawing action with a lot of clarity. Same studio as the ones behind Black Rock Shooter, yes? I could dig it.
Anime is good, but the original is just a lot more dynamic. The 3D truly makes it work better and faster
well ofc it was motion captured so itll look more dynamic thats why rwby characters move in a way that feels a real person is moving if that makes sense
Are sure about that 3d motion are slower than 2d version, I can tell that because I am animator myself
@@passionweasel3181 don’t know if it’s different for modern rwby but in the volume 1-3 days crwby has actually said that they only motion capture regular talking scenes, and that it’s more easier to just start from scratch for fights
オリジナルとアニメどっちも見たけど、戦闘シーンはオリジナルの方が最高に面白い😁
オリジナルの疾走感は曲も相まって見ていて興奮するし、主要キャラだけでなく敵キャラの動きもカカシみたいになってないのが良い。
日常パートはアニメの方が背景もちゃんと描かれているのがグッド😄
We really have to give Monty Oum credit for his insane coreography, it was such a shame he gone so young.
Monty’s animation for Weiss is my favorite
As for the anime version it’s good
2:07 it doesnt feel like she stabbed the rapier to the ground, more like gently poked it. I think they added to much frames there and her posture isnt low enough, you can literally see her muster her strength to thrust that sword but her body doesnt even recoil from the impact unlike the original where she is literally on her knees since the rapier was stabbed through the ground. The ice is a bit too slow, the reason it was fast in the original is because she wants to keep distance from the golem while still catching it off guard. In the anime, the golem just lost a couple of braincells(or intelligence) from a few seconds ago where it could somewhat react and follow the movements of Weiss but now it couldnt even see the slowly crawling ice on the floor. The removal of the green power(forgot what it was) at 2:15 is just weird, the power literally blows the hand of the golem from below to disarm it while in the anime it just shows Weiss overpowering the golem when SHE LITERALLY COULDNT EARLIER to disarm him. The removal of the song from the Original and the scenes of Weiss in the stage just removes the vibe and the character it is trying to portray. The loneliness you can feel from the trailer is gone from this one and it saddens me a bit. The fight was like the symbolism of her fighting against her loneliness in that scene. Though I didnt watch past season 3, I really liked the show and its kinda sad for this trailer to not give us insight on the character of Weiss but more on her family situation.
Edit: Another thing I would like to add, at 1:27 you could see her become sad since she couldn't beat the golem with her own skill and effort. She has to resort on the dusts which she got with her father's wealth which she absolutely hates. In 2:23 even she is sad, she sees how easy it is to defeat the golem using dusts. In the original it is portrayed as a sad thing through the music and her expressions but in the anime it is portrayed as triumph which is NOT her character. She hates relying on her father's wealth and pursues independence from the name of Schnee which defined her whole life.
tl:dr original is more on Weiss while the anime is more on Weiss Schnee
@@dividedtime8529 lemme fix it for you tldr: wiess in the og is more for insight for the story
And the anime is more for fighting bc f i g h t i n g and anime.
i mean technically speaking you dont need force to make magic happen it just does magic doesnt have logic but i get ur point it just doesnt look good side by side with OG it rlly just looked like she was using her full force and strenght and trying her best but it looked weak at the end lol
When watching the animes fight, I knew it was very close to the trailer, but im very impressed with how close it was to the original. For the most part, weiss used the same or similar moves as the trailer with similar timings in the fight. All of the hits felt like they had impact, which is something I can't says for the nevermore fight in particular (specifically yang punching the grim in the mouth). So far I think that they are most comfortable animating weiss, which is good, because the name of the anime makes me think she'll be the main focus (that and the lack of the dock fight)
All in all, great video!
Honestly both are good for what they are and I most likely would enjoy both equally when watching separately.
Personally I dislike Weiss face in the anime. It's missing it's sharpness which suited her character a bit better. I know she is a softy in the inside as well, but originally her personality was the princess with the sharp tongue and it just seems off to see this round face in the anime version.
I mich prefer Weiss disarming the thing with a wind? Blade rather then a fire blade.
Why in the world did they change the perspective in the anime edition?
The shot at 0:23 looks so much more dramatic in the 3D version, simply due to the perspective. I think it could have added a lot more atmosphere had they made the shots more cinematic.
I'm kind of sad that Weiss' ballet like sword form is effectively gone
i like the visuals (not necessarily animation) better on the anime because it feels like it's easier on the eyes, but the action itself and choreography i still prefer the original
The music makes the original the best of the two for me.
Anyone else want to see a side by side of the dock fight?
Just a paused screen until Roman starts running away
If the creator of RWBY still alive, he would be proud that his masterpiece becomes Japanese anime.
The difference mainly seems to be that the original focussed on the swifter combat with that wonderful choreography by monty oum while the 2d anime takes that and adds on it with more dramatic flare, such as more establishing shots longer breaks to give you more time to breathe and view the scene closer and adding the family dynamic thats such a big part of weiss's character arc right off the bat, with her starting off in the show being that snobby daughter of a rich person but over time she loosens up more, dealing with her abusive family dynamic and growing into her own person with their own interests other than being the best to set a good image for herself and the company
The OGs flow was incomparable.. still can't believe it was done by just one man. You should check out dead fantasy on how he creates flow and absurd amounts of continuity in his animations.
Left lookin like a blender animation with all the effects off
to me this really showcases how much caseys singing adds to each scene.
I'm very impressed by the timing and shots that line up so well. Even if delayed, the amount of frames that are paying homage to the og trailer is very beautiful and respectful. Adding and expanding in a new way. The original RWBY will always be close to our hearts, it's the series we've come to love (or hate). I think a good portion of Ice Queendom shows a level of love, attention to detail, and respect for the original material.
It's a different universe, a new take. It's not a replacement. Holding it to the expectation of it doing so will both disappoint you, and take away what makes Ice Queendom good. They come from the same idea, but they don't have to be the same.
If this version followed the og to a T, then we'd be bored. New scenes, revisions, additions- all make this a unique retelling of RWBY. Not to say I love the new anime or that I don't have some issues with it. But I do have an open mind. This video shows a lot of care to the details shown in the original trailer. Some shots are almost identical! That's beautiful and I really appreciate how they decided to keep it in their re-imagining.
I'm here for the visuals, amazing stuff
The original trailer had a fuck ton more style. But the anime establishes some of the character traits of the Schnee family that makes sense with the rest of the series, both original and anime
It was nice to listen to that song again. It has been too long since I've heard that song.
I think too many people are comparing these two pm based off nostalgia
I would liked them to add the mirror theme, even if it was instrumental :( the theme gave the necessary impact on the scene.
The original music was so amazing. This song for the White Trailer has me in tears within seconds, the emotions behind the scene hit hard.
I think what really separates them is the op was also character building and helping us get a feel for a character we knew nothing about but in in Ice Queendom it's more to help the plot of her past
Love the Og always will especially with the soundtrack
IDK if this is just my dumbass Opinion, but generic anime fight music does not feel correct for some of these iconic fight scenes.
The distracting lack of Mirror Mirror, From Shadows or Red like Roses during these iconic fights kinda took me out of the experience imo. Im not asking for straight up ports of the og music you can remix it or just add key litmotiffs. It just doesn't fucking feel right to my lizard brain without it. Still most of everything is way better and the character writing is competent this time.
They even manged to make the fights look really good, nothing in comparison to OG Monty but still well adaptated nonetheless.
The OG trailers were meant to potray a character by the fight coreography and looks alone , not the writing immo , also really hard to have all those well choreographed fights Monthy did , in 2D since that's not a company like A-1 pictures or Ufotable , Shaft has been revamping their animation quality but it still very recent , like , it even lead Magia Record to have some production problems , also it would take way much time to produce . About the songs well copyright right?They wouldn't buy Mirror Mirror rights for a fight that don't last more than three fricking minutes or less , since they're rushing the scenes already established by the OG to jump into the new plot but i do agree that some fights scenes or script decisions are questionable , but not bad
In the first half, the original's, camera movements and choreography appealed more to me, while the second half, the anime seemed to have more angled and is more eye catching.
Wish they showed Weiss dance around the armor like she did in the trailer instead of running.
To even be worthy to compare to Monty's animation is quite the accomplishment. But obviously, nothing will ever beat Monty's work. The pacing, the groundedness, the details. Nothing beats it. The RWBY trailers are the pinnacle of fighting animation, and will be for decades to come.
After all these years...
I like the new version, but I've still got that nostalgic fondness for the original. There's something about it ...
Was expecting more choppy animation but this is great
I like how they even did the pose in 2:32 I Love The show so much!
My eyes were mostly on the original, I only watched the anime when paused. While the original was a trailer, the anime (I haven't watched yet so this is more of an assumption here) is more a back story segment.
After a long time, I understood why Weiss has a scar on her eye. She is Kratos' daughter 😱
This sounds like the start to a crossover fanfic.
I know RWBY and God of War have a few but none where this idea is used. Sounds interesting honestly
@@gbaboy7775 Maybe I'll make a fanfic 🤭🤭
The anime version is eye candy. Although the original hits it home with the music somewhat explaining not to judge a book by its cover.
I like the movement of the armour better in the original
i like the og more because its at a faster pace. in the anime things seem to be kinda slow
I wanna say I like the OG a bit better because it showed the grace and style of that of a ballerina/iceskater..the anime just shows her regular fighting...but like the only thing that would make me made about anime Weiss is if she loses her fighting prowess like she did in the 3d -__-
anime was... well, anime. good and all, additional touches like direct and not vague connection to the series itself, etc.
but original was art. that's just different level. not like action itself in anime lacks something but it's... good and decent anime. but not really something bigger
Imagine saying cgi is art
@@LupinaCatto imagine saying art have to use specific technique to be art
I hope Kenjiro Tsuda will voice Qrow cuz the drunk vibe very fits with that voice XD
Holly shit winter has the bakery
I feel like I am listening to the empire's music from Star Wars for the animated trailer.
i think the og will always have an upperhand in soundtrack and fight choreo but the anime vers is still sick
Damn I miss Monty’s animations :(
Мне нравятся оба
В оригинале за счет 3D анимации получилось более плавное и мягкое движение, что смотрелось выигрышно и динамично. Плюсом к этому была постановка боя, которая дополняла плюсы 3D анимации. Также круто смотрелись цветовые решения. Чувствовалось одиночество
И я не могу сказать, что аниме как-то сильно проиграло на фоне. Да, это не уровень КРД, но бли выглядят достойно. Анимация на уровне. Были моменты, когда я даже удивлялась, потому что выглядело правда круто; круче, чем я могла подумать. Аниматоры и художники выложились, и это радует
Я стала рассматривать аниме не как адаптацию или ремейк, а как отдельное произведение по мотивам, наверное, поэтому и не расстраиваюсь, когда что-то анимируют не так, как в оригинале или как мне бы хотелось
2 dimension will always aesthetic
Original is details on character more & the anime focus on whole scenes occurred on that period. For me, I still like the original one. I able to focus on character more since I like that way.
Yay RWBY and Jojo's my two favorites 😊
THAT ENDING BROKE ME AHAHAHA
I know Weiss is characterised differently between OG and anime, but the moment Weiss gets injured in the OG, she starts relying on dust. This undermines her will to be independent and free, as reduces her capabilities to her ties with the Schnee company. Absolutely heartbreaking and amazimg characterisatiom, which I wish they had included the anime.
Original RWBY is not only good for its one but was an amazing piece of what felt like “high effort homemade” I would call it. However as much as the anime beats it’s in every way imo. Sure the music is not the Williams family however I believe the set up and writing of the anime beats in what the music carried in the OG. But that’s just me
I haven’t watched the anime, but from this fight, you could tell minty had a strong eye for design and animation. Most everything is white for weiss, but there are hints of color for a reason. Same with the other trailers.
Weiss doesn’t feel like weiss here when fighting in the anime. Her ice skating gymnastics just isnt there. Ive not seen the others but im hoping the fighting style for them hasn’t changed
im happy for rwby fans, their show has got a bigger budget now
Something about the anime one just isnt quite it for me. Its like you cant tell individual hits or where exactly shes moving, its a lot more dificult to read. Where its ends up in this point where its so dificult to decifer certain motions that it almost feels like theres nothing truly happening, just a bunch of blurs on the screen. With Ruby it works really well because her power literally allows her to become a loose blob so that thing can flail around like crazy until theres a hit, where you can see the full body again. And like wtf they should have done what anime does best and go ward as fuck with the posing, but shes just kind of hunched over standing there kind of like shes not really into it. Where the hell is the warped perspective ballerina pose shot,.
if the anime had the original music it would have been a lot better
Nothing beats the original Remember Monty in a room w/ some friends before Rooster teeth got big i love the new anime but they messed up they ruby exploding sneeze so epic An did a great job an Kadakowa has more spending bigger budget but dc even did well with the comics.
One point anime missed is how Weiss started targeting Arma Gigas' joints a few seconds into the fight after it became clear the armor is a bit too tough for her normal strikes.
As a new watcher, Anime's a lot better. Tho the original 3D animation looks pretty good considering how long ago it was made
Bruh this may be my personal "hot take" but the new one seems low key choppy. the original had no dull moments but the new one feels like even her taking her stance is drawn out. Its not too bad though, but placed side by side this stands out
the limitations of 3D in the pass
The og animation is easier to follow w my eye, and the remake has a lot of staccato movement that makes it hard to focus on
Anime art style is lit! But the music in fight scenes a bit lacking. Miss OG rwby 😭
From a movie stand point, the original camera shooting is more a Hong Kong kunfu movie style. It is much better than the traditional Hollywood style 2d version.
LOL my eyes keep looking about the right side while my brain keep telling me go left too. you got to compare between the too. don't just look to the right
I liked the black and white of the original but the family being there is interesting
Animation: Anime Win
Cinematography: Original Win
even for me who first watched this, Original has good cinematography
Just weiss doing queen things ♡
I’m all for a soft reboot of RWBY. Remake everything up til now in traditional anime style.
Honestly, the novelty of the 3D indie animation has worn off. Now that RWBY is bigger, it’s deserving of this quality. Look how gorgeous it is. And how it improved upon the original. Even adding her family spectating.
I still prefer the original one it showcases better uses of her glyphs, the choreography is superior and the dark background contrasts with with weiss better and gives you more of a feeling of loneliness which is a constant theme of her character. And the original has the original song that goes with it which just has more impact then what's in the anime one.
The anime trailer isn't bad or anything I think it's pretty decent actually and it sticks pretty close to the original but the original I still think is superior in everyway except visually.
The anime is good, but I really like the black and white theme in the og
... this seems to be the theme. the art is better the story sincs up more but the OG was more direct, it flows better and works with the music so much more .
Even tho the anime gives more clearer detail many fans prefer the original, except for me
I find it saddening that wiess doesn't dance while fighting in IQ
Fans Demanding Japan to create RWYB Anime. Anime: have Better Visual and much organized
Meanwhile comment section: Nahh I still prefer original
If you prefer the original and you don't like the Anime version . You shouldn't make a Demand for Anime in the first place that you think will ruin it
While the animation for the anime is very nice, I think the original stands out much more mainly with how great the use of angles and the music was. The camera angles and animation were well done for it's time and some parts of the anime are kinda lacking in it, at least to me it doesn't give the same feeling. Still do like how they remade the first fight with Ruby.
One thing the anime wont accomplish is the colors. The one thing I liked about rwby was that a lot of the background was black so it made the fight even more highlighted. The knight somehow looked even taller and scarier because of how it ominously popped up outta no where. It was almost as if it appeared from the darkness like its magic. The anime made it appear like it was robbitic and easy to destroy.
They did a good job recreating the fight, but I can’t help but feel that something is amiss with her family being there and not showing the true loneliness of her character like White Trailer does.
Still prefer 2D, its hardest to me (i mean for making the battlescene)
Love 3D more for its smoothness but well youre not weebs if liked 3D one for sure
@@randomdreamer1619 Original fight scene is better the only bad is the cgi design is not that good also the background is lacking of details as for anime the animation actually good but sometimes kinda hard to follow the fight scene .
@@randomdreamer1619 i'm not live to be same as like your expectation ma dude, i also know 3D is good, original still good, but i still want to have different taste, not like staying on my safe zone thats why right now i prefer 2D
From the story pov anime is better because etablishes weiss relationship with her family.
I also liked anime's background is not just black and white. Monty still has superior choreography and background singing is better in the original
Hm, it's more faithful than I actually remembered. Interesting.
RWBY was a big part of my childhood and of course, as an anime fan, I couldn't help but be excited that it was getting an anime adaptation.
So I clicked in, hoping to see a fresh take on Weiss, something that sets it apart from the literal flood of new anime this year AND the original.
But after seeing how badly it fares compared to the classic elegance and beauty of the original...
I guess some things are meant to stay in my memories.
P.S. I don't mean to say that it's trashy or not worth watching at all (the animation isn't bad at all overall), but maybe I had too high expectations of it and I was terribly disappointed as a result. For those who do enjoy it, ganbatte! I wish it all the best.
THISSSS!!! Exactly the way I feel, the anime just didn't live up to the brilliant humor, pacing, and choreography that RWBY originally had. Disappointed, but still happy I got more Pyrrha content :)
The fights aren't bad but they just lack the impact that rwby classic had everything just kinda hits here and there and you don't feel the power behind every attack also minus points for no Jeff Williams
animation is good, its not so bad , she looks dashing af
まぁ、モンティが最強ということで、、
Yeah, the original wins on all fronts for me.
The anime looks good, but nothing beats the OG
最後の音楽がyesって、わかってるじゃん！
Again, I find myself liking the new Anime version more. It feels more inclusive of being part of an actual story or world rather than the original that feels ironically more like a fan adaptation of a character's story. The fighting itself feels more grounded with the large knight having mass to match its physical form but not being comically slow or in the OG almost immersion breaking quick. Weiss's movements also match what one would expect a versatile technique with agile capability but fragile enough that she's not a frontline slug fighter such as Yang, Nora, Jaune or even Pyrrha going for wide motions rather than random moves that has the aura (pun intended) of artistic flourish to sell a trailer or idea for a series on the creator's part rather than the practicality of a girl that's trying to prove herself. Ultimately, the OG version suffers from Monty's arcade animation style, which is good in its own way but the anime one looks like an actual fight between a giant knight and a normal size teenage girl.
I also can't help but wonder if people would like the anime version more if it came out first in regards to the blatant, yet in good faith, nostalgia and admiration that people had for Monty.
I haven't watched both of the versions, yet I find myself liking the CGI more than the anime. Sure, the anime has top notch qualities and does a good justice to fighting scenes, however, it lacked some important parts where some characters do their own unique flashy moves in the original one and some scenes were quite slower, I felt that it was unnecessarily needed to do to make the fight longer and more "impact"
The original might not have good special fx but the choreography of the fight is so brilliant it's put of this world, no one can even do that kind of possibility of executing it perfectly. I find myself learning this Monty literally knows what he's doing, normally I would mock 3d animes because not only do they have budgets, they won't know what to do to animate properly. To me, Monty is such a brilliantly genius animator despite the budget. He knew so much what to do