Gears 5 was financially and critically most successful gears... 😂 What do you mean gears has been dead? What's the criteria for that? Is it sales or your feelings? because sales determines success and failure...selling 5 million plus physical+digital while being gamepass day one is crazy... Even halo or any xbox exclusive couldn't do that... It was just slightly below God of war 2018 sales.. Even though overall gow 2018 sold more, gow 5 proved xbox games can sell while being in gamepass... Go back and watch the critics when space marine one launched 😂.. They had same video of space marine being next gears... 😅
@@THUGPUTIN Yeah I just scoured six or seven articles to make sure what you just said has any credence to it. It doesn’t. Sea of Thieves pulled better numbers overall than G5, and it didn’t sell those copies on top of gamepass, those “engagement numbers” are overall. It definitely was the best first party launch for Xbox of that generation, which isn’t saying much. it critically being the best received gears game is just untrue. 200 players on steam world wide. Plus it came out like five years ago, you can rarely find an MP lobby on steam or Xbox. Hence, it’s been dead for awhile now.
I’d say my biggest complaint is the melee system feeling really clunky at times especially when trying to block and the severe lack of armor options for customization.
@@BobSmith-vx3knI find it weird I really enjoyed Judgement. The sort of "COG grandeur" the colors of the game and make of the buildings presents, as well as the armor Kilo Squad wears lookin a tiny bit ceremonial (mainly Baird) but also practical, and the little challenges for the missions were welcome for me.
@@carny15 He says it’s an 8.5 DESPITE the lack of polish in certain areas. The animations locking you out of defending yourself mid attack/action is definitely a detriment, but it can be worked around, while the menus are clunky to work with. It’s still good despite these things, so it gets a higher score.
Gears of war was finished after 3 when cliffy B sold it to Microsoft. It's like an author selling their book for someone else to write. It's over. I loved gears. But it ended at 3.
If TC manages to fuck up E-Day, it’s over. They have a amazing game on hand but I doubt they can pull it off. I just want them to remaster 2/3 and go away.
As I am very, very Warhammer-pilled, its really fun, but vary much an 7/10. Which is not a bad thing, a 7/10 in a universe I love is fantastic. I will have lots of fun in it in the upcoming months, but I can easily see someone not being into it.
@@bfedezl2018 My friend 7 out of 10 is good. By definition that means it's better than most games on the market. You have to be exceptional to beat that number. And Space Marine 2 is good but it's not exceptional, It doesn't redefine any genres It doesn't change any formulas and it doesn't really alter anything. Is the perfectly serviceable and extremely standard game with no micro transactions. It is in my opinion the very definition of a 7/10.
Space Marine 1-2 are both amazing games, but will NEVER replace Gears of War due to gameplay differences and fan bases. Plus, let's not forget Gears of War: E-Day is on it's way, so we'll be getting the whole original team back again, plus the older weaponry and aesthetics we all fell in love with in the first place.
Gears started off good but it should have kept that hard core game play and violence just like SM2 and kept Dom alive the whole time. They really could have did so much with the horde, the swarm and the story, instead we ended up with Kait…
This space marine 2 is fun but it's still developed in SWARM ENGINE which was used for world War z... It's world War z in warhammer universe than gears of war in warhammer universe... The comparison doesn't make sense.. People should play word war z again and see how much this game takes from that... There's nothing gears about this...
We don’t have to play World War Z to see the inspirations; it’s pretty obvious, and not everyone likes zombie themed media in general, even if they like horde shooters.
On ps5 this game needs to tone down the graphics or resolution or something ,, as soon when you enter combat the framerate goes all over the place 😢,, other than that the game is epic
i feel like this game will shine a hell of a lot more in the next few years with higher end cards like the 50 series and above, at the moment i feel like the performance just simply isn't quite there
@@carny15 nah for those with bigger 4k screens its really is no good :-( turns into a blurry mess when you have to lower the res right down for it to be playable, i really dont wanna come across as snob though this 60 fps shit really has to stop.. in this day and age it really isnt acceptable considering how much we are paying for high end tech. and for the love of god when will fromsoft open up the fps lcap 60 fps is a joke
@@cheeemzy6651 Sorry bud, not everyone has the income to afford things that can run 4k as smooth as butter. Maybe you should try getting a cheaper monitor more in-line with the pixel count that it runs well on? While I agree optimization is number one priority with everything, it just *kinda* sounds like you’re complaining about being too rich.
I would say space marine 2 is not gonna replace gears. Both are good franchises for gears judgement is the one of the main problems besides the horrible launch of 5. So for e day all they need is a good launch
I don't mean to shit on your premise because clearly you're coming at this from the POV of a gears fan. But the idea that anything Warhammer "will not replace gears" is just hysterical to a WH fan. Every single aspect of gears visual style, and lore to some extent owes itself entirely to WH. That said the gameplay while sharing some surface similarity is different so I've no disagreement there.
What’s to replace? Gears has been dead for a hot minute
Gears 5 was financially and critically most successful gears... 😂 What do you mean gears has been dead? What's the criteria for that? Is it sales or your feelings? because sales determines success and failure...selling 5 million plus physical+digital while being gamepass day one is crazy... Even halo or any xbox exclusive couldn't do that...
It was just slightly below God of war 2018 sales.. Even though overall gow 2018 sold more, gow 5 proved xbox games can sell while being in gamepass...
Go back and watch the critics when space marine one launched 😂.. They had same video of space marine being next gears... 😅
@@THUGPUTIN Yeah I just scoured six or seven articles to make sure what you just said has any credence to it. It doesn’t. Sea of Thieves pulled better numbers overall than G5, and it didn’t sell those copies on top of gamepass, those “engagement numbers” are overall. It definitely was the best first party launch for Xbox of that generation, which isn’t saying much. it critically being the best received gears game is just untrue. 200 players on steam world wide.
Plus it came out like five years ago, you can rarely find an MP lobby on steam or Xbox. Hence, it’s been dead for awhile now.
@@Moss_and_Such bro didn't have to cook him like that🗿
I’d say my biggest complaint is the melee system feeling really clunky at times especially when trying to block and the severe lack of armor options for customization.
Don died with the franchise
Dom***
I couldn’t agree more. I remember saving up in high school to buy judgement and it was a steaming pile of dogshit. Gears 3 was peak
@@BobSmith-vx3knA reminder, the next Gears of War is gonna be E-Day, so Dom will be back.
@@BobSmith-vx3knI find it weird I really enjoyed Judgement.
The sort of "COG grandeur" the colors of the game and make of the buildings presents, as well as the armor Kilo Squad wears lookin a tiny bit ceremonial (mainly Baird) but also practical, and the little challenges for the missions were welcome for me.
After doms death, that was pretty much it really.
SM2 just needs some more polish and fine tuning. Menus are clunky. Still an 8.5/10 for me. The future looks good for 40K.
8.5 is bad? 😂
My God, you kids are spoiled
@@carny15 He says it’s an 8.5 DESPITE the lack of polish in certain areas. The animations locking you out of defending yourself mid attack/action is definitely a detriment, but it can be worked around, while the menus are clunky to work with. It’s still good despite these things, so it gets a higher score.
Gears of war was finished after 3 when cliffy B sold it to Microsoft. It's like an author selling their book for someone else to write. It's over. I loved gears. But it ended at 3.
If TC manages to fuck up E-Day, it’s over. They have a amazing game on hand but I doubt they can pull it off. I just want them to remaster 2/3 and go away.
It's a worthy successor. Nothing has really filled that void that Gears left
As I am very, very Warhammer-pilled, its really fun, but vary much an 7/10. Which is not a bad thing, a 7/10 in a universe I love is fantastic.
I will have lots of fun in it in the upcoming months, but I can easily see someone not being into it.
7/10? Lol no one agree with that shitty take. Both reviews and players value it much better. Sounds like a you problem
@@bfedezl2018 My friend 7 out of 10 is good.
By definition that means it's better than most games on the market. You have to be exceptional to beat that number.
And Space Marine 2 is good but it's not exceptional, It doesn't redefine any genres It doesn't change any formulas and it doesn't really alter anything. Is the perfectly serviceable and extremely standard game with no micro transactions. It is in my opinion the very definition of a 7/10.
It’s a solid 8.5/10 by my metric, there’s very few games that reach a 9 to me but this one comes close
@@TheLordofMetroids a game doesnt have to shake the world to be a 8-9/10, it just needs to be really good, which space marine 2 is
With a few updates this game is a 9.5 for me. The lack of PVP maps is an issue, other than that its more SM1 in next gen glory
I do hope the new Gears Of War can turn things back.. with Gears Eday.
The worthy successor Gears of War deserves
Gears of War 1-3 > Space Marine 2
Space Marine 2 > Gears of War 4-5
if gears wasnt dead and burning in a pit for years i would say maybe. but there is just nothing to replace anymore lmao
Space Marine 1-2 are both amazing games, but will NEVER replace Gears of War due to gameplay differences and fan bases. Plus, let's not forget Gears of War: E-Day is on it's way, so we'll be getting the whole original team back again, plus the older weaponry and aesthetics we all fell in love with in the first place.
not confirmed gameplay though.. how will it differentiate itself against the newer gears or will it build ontop of them?
gears of war e-day will have to pull some crazy shit out of their ass considering their last entries just didn't hit right
Gears started off good but it should have kept that hard core game play and violence just like SM2 and kept Dom alive the whole time. They really could have did so much with the horde, the swarm and the story, instead we ended up with Kait…
That font for "The Final Verdict" makes it look like "The Anal Verdict".
11:28 a World Eater 🔥🩸
This space marine 2 is fun but it's still developed in SWARM ENGINE which was used for world War z... It's world War z in warhammer universe than gears of war in warhammer universe...
The comparison doesn't make sense.. People should play word war z again and see how much this game takes from that... There's nothing gears about this...
Yes, thank you for describing the video
We don’t have to play World War Z to see the inspirations; it’s pretty obvious, and not everyone likes zombie themed media in general, even if they like horde shooters.
@@provaricus627 it’s not inspiration it’s literally the same Dev team that made WWZ.
On ps5 this game needs to tone down the graphics or resolution or something ,, as soon when you enter combat the framerate goes all over the place 😢,, other than that the game is epic
I’ve had no issue on Ps5 but I’ve been using performance mode over the graphics mode, id try that
God Emperor be praised!
I know nothing about the lore of Warhammer, but when I get my PS5 Pro I’m gonna play the shit out of this game.
It’s a fantastic game
Never. I like both franchises, but gears is its own thing.
i feel like this game will shine a hell of a lot more in the next few years with higher end cards like the 50 series and above, at the moment i feel like the performance just simply isn't quite there
60+ fps ilon High is not good enough?
@@carny15 nah for those with bigger 4k screens its really is no good :-( turns into a blurry mess when you have to lower the res right down for it to be playable, i really dont wanna come across as snob though this 60 fps shit really has to stop.. in this day and age it really isnt acceptable considering how much we are paying for high end tech. and for the love of god when will fromsoft open up the fps lcap 60 fps is a joke
@@cheeemzy6651 Sorry bud, not everyone has the income to afford things that can run 4k as smooth as butter. Maybe you should try getting a cheaper monitor more in-line with the pixel count that it runs well on? While I agree optimization is number one priority with everything, it just *kinda* sounds like you’re complaining about being too rich.
@@provaricus627 huh? I'm just saying it would shine a lot better in the future when it could be ran comfortably at native resolutions
If you think about it, gears of war is about space marines since the story takes place on the planet Sera which isnt earth.
But they don’t come from Earth, so they are not Space Marines because they’ve never gone to space
@@Buster-McTunder fair enough.
I would say space marine 2 is not gonna replace gears. Both are good franchises for gears judgement is the one of the main problems besides the horrible launch of 5. So for e day all they need is a good launch
Not the same movement. What are we talking about here?
The inspirations for the violence is clearly there. There’s more aspects to a game that can be translated.
Everyone under a rock fr
Love it, love it, love it.
what does it have to do with it?gears of war
It's very geary
I mean if the year was 2012 and people still gave a shit about gears of war maybe but I think it’s 2024.
Please explain very enemies verity in warhammer 40k please 🙏 please explain okre tyrants other enemies of space marine please I beg of you please 🙏
Of course it will replace the current gow games. Why do you think gow is bring back dom and pheonix as the main protagonists in the next game?
Clicked this vid just to leave a comment but it seems most people beat me to it already
Its pronounced May-lay, not Me-lay
I don't mean to shit on your premise because clearly you're coming at this from the POV of a gears fan. But the idea that anything Warhammer "will not replace gears" is just hysterical to a WH fan. Every single aspect of gears visual style, and lore to some extent owes itself entirely to WH. That said the gameplay while sharing some surface similarity is different so I've no disagreement there.
Gears of war is still my favorite game. The multiplayer is awesome but the story sucks now
But there is micro transactions
Where. The little cosmetic bundles and the season pass? Those are one-time purchases.
Replace? Gears was pretty much dead after Gears 2..
Lol what
How can you make such an awful video quality in 2024 ?
It feels more like God of war wearing gears skin
I’ve never heard something as blatantly wrong as this take.
@@Moss_and_Such ummm ok??? You guna argue with an opinion? U must be bored.
@@dondon8792 Everyone who’s commenting on UA-cam videos is bored bruh
@Moss_and_Such lolol touche. So really talking grown up to grown up. What would you say the game is like?
Pretty much, if you treat it as a regular shooter you're gonna have a bad time.