Of course, but I figured if I titled it “Magnetic Rose Analysis” or something less intriguing UA-cam’s ass algorithm’s wouldn’t have given the video much of a chance and at least amongst my friends I’m really the only one who knows about this film. Big goal was to get Magnetic Rose to as big of an audience as possible and if that meant pleasing UA-cam, 🤷♂️ And I haven’t seen Cannon Fodder but stylistically and aesthetically it looks good!
When you consider the weight and space limitations and restrictions aboard any spacecraft or station, wide open spaces and polished stone columns like you see in that opera hall are even more extravagant and affluent than they would be even in a crowded city. That vessel or station was clearly built and designed for _extreme_ luxury and opulence.
Interesting observation! I feel like Taylor would be able to afford a ship like that with how many racks he makes + a realistic holographic projection of Misato from Eva
You're welcome! This is my favorite anime short film so with this video, I aimed to pack in as much about this film as I could! Also, here is a link to an article I used for researching Satoshi Kon. Don't know if you've seen this already but I hope it helps! union.fsu.edu/movies/blog/SatoshiKon
Good analysis, definitely missed a few details you pointed out! especially with the ending, I had the impression that the ship wasn't destroyed but I wasn't too sure, now thematically it makes sense for it not to be.
According to a Japanese Wikipedia and scans of the manga I saw online - ony Magnetic Rose is based on a story from the manga. Other two are not in there
Recently watched it, and gosh was it amazing. Magnetic rose was wonderful, cannon fodder is subtle but effective, and i find that stink bomb was terrifying in its own peculiar way. Sad it’s so underrated, I’ll be sure to tell my friends. :)
This might be the fourth video I've seen in my feed with a title similar to "Magnetic Rose: A Forgotten Masterpiece(that you never heard of)". Its scriptwriter is Satoshi Kon. So yes, people know about it, it's just that it's a serious film without over the top action and superpowers. Similar to why Jin-Roh is not as popular as Gundam.
Just watched it. Honestly, it feels like a dime-a-dozen vague psychedelic trip. Heavy nonsensical storytelling (or rather, lack of), no context for their technology level (how did the guy who was just chiding his partner "What, you never seen a hologram before or something?" not realize the illusion of his family was a hologram?! That's some real wheelchair vegetable level incompetence). It never explains if they were supposed to actually be supernatural ghosts or if it was some form of mind digitization (certainly they'd be aware of such technology), or why that caused her to go insane, OR how her ship was able to generate magnetic fields stronger than anyone there can even comprehend, to the point where the magnetic field was literally ripping apart ships (which would take "literal star going super nova" levels of astronomical extremes). They never even hinted at nanotechnology, which is the only way she could have made the family-breakfast-table scene, which should have been an immediate giveaway for the dude who was subjected to it, yet he never gave any indications of comprehending what was happening. And if this lady was THAT rich, and had mysteriously disappeared in her spaceship-city-of-over-the-top-extravagance 60 years prior to "present day" for the salvage dudes, how had no one heard of her? Hell, if there were some guy back in the 1960s who left on his own personal man-made NYC-sized luxury cruise ship that makes the Titanic look like a tic-tac compared to Mt. Everest, you can best bet literally EVERYONE would have heard about him even in this day and age! There's no WAY they wouldn't know her story, the shape, appearance, and scale of her ship, the technology on board, and how to identify it if they came across it. And the ending... Talk about dissatisfying!
@@jumpreport That essay took me about 10 minutes or less to write. How long did this 20:47 long video take to record, edit, and upload? If you get to be passionate about anime, why can't I be passionate about calling out writing errors in anime, or be passionate about wanting better quality in modern anime compared to the best of the best classic 90s/2000s animes (like Trigun)? Credit where credit is due though, your videos are well made, and I have to give the studio that animated Magnetic Rose top marks for their exceptional animation work!
@@jumpreport not sure if a clickbait is the best tactic, that kind of stuff makes me want to come, leave a comment and never come back. That's rather short sighted strat but whatever
Just watched the film on Tubi and I want everyone to watch it Magnetic Rose was so amazing
Agreed. Hoping that this video will help get more people to watch it!
It’s not forgotten by any means, but it is definitely underrated.
Also you HAVE to see all the short films. My favorite is cannon fodder.
Of course, but I figured if I titled it “Magnetic Rose Analysis” or something less intriguing UA-cam’s ass algorithm’s wouldn’t have given the video much of a chance and at least amongst my friends I’m really the only one who knows about this film. Big goal was to get Magnetic Rose to as big of an audience as possible and if that meant pleasing UA-cam, 🤷♂️
And I haven’t seen Cannon Fodder but stylistically and aesthetically it looks good!
@@jumpreport absolutely. Gotta ride that algorithm.
not everyone will like "Stink Bomb", i think. but i don't care what others say, but i think it's good.
so weird maybe but this one reminded me a LOT of Event Horizon in the delusions and atmosphere in many scenes
Lol love that movie, thankfully this short was a little less crazy and gory but regardless both are great films
When you consider the weight and space limitations and restrictions aboard any spacecraft or station, wide open spaces and polished stone columns like you see in that opera hall are even more extravagant and affluent than they would be even in a crowded city. That vessel or station was clearly built and designed for _extreme_ luxury and opulence.
Interesting observation! I feel like Taylor would be able to afford a ship like that with how many racks he makes + a realistic holographic projection of Misato from Eva
Man, every 50, 60, so forth, animes are forgotten.
They were indeed pretty well animated, i love that old type animation
@@getehrwolf6111 me too.
Great review. Ironically watched the short film during the Corona season 😄. A masterpiece. And I'm not even a hardcore anime fan.
Thank you! And yeah, great film that’s deserving of its praise
I am writing an analysis of this film right now, and I needed this inside! Thank you!
You're welcome! This is my favorite anime short film so with this video, I aimed to pack in as much about this film as I could! Also, here is a link to an article I used for researching Satoshi Kon. Don't know if you've seen this already but I hope it helps!
union.fsu.edu/movies/blog/SatoshiKon
@@jumpreport thank you very much!
You’re welcome! Is the film analysis for a class or just a personal one?
I’ve seen the clips of the one guy trying to save his daughter from the roof but I never knew the name of it so thanks for helping me find it
Good analysis, definitely missed a few details you pointed out! especially with the ending, I had the impression that the ship wasn't destroyed but I wasn't too sure, now thematically it makes sense for it not to be.
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed the film!
According to a Japanese Wikipedia and scans of the manga I saw online - ony Magnetic Rose is based on a story from the manga. Other two are not in there
Thanks for the info! I’ll try and match your freak better next time 😈
Recently watched it, and gosh was it amazing. Magnetic rose was wonderful, cannon fodder is subtle but effective, and i find that stink bomb was terrifying in its own peculiar way. Sad it’s so underrated, I’ll be sure to tell my friends. :)
This might be the fourth video I've seen in my feed with a title similar to "Magnetic Rose: A Forgotten Masterpiece(that you never heard of)". Its scriptwriter is Satoshi Kon. So yes, people know about it, it's just that it's a serious film without over the top action and superpowers. Similar to why Jin-Roh is not as popular as Gundam.
Or why everyone has heard of Frosted Flakes but not necessarily Count Chockula
Great analysis. Y’all just got a new subscriber 😎🤙🏽
Thank you man! Glad to see people are still coming to this vid and enjoying it
Dang, this one is darn good.
Thank you!
Made an article about this film this year!
Share it if you have a link to it!
I just watched it, its amazing
Let ‘em know!
Why always clickbait?
Ik shits getting out of hand
First
Just watched it.
Honestly, it feels like a dime-a-dozen vague psychedelic trip.
Heavy nonsensical storytelling (or rather, lack of), no context for their technology level (how did the guy who was just chiding his partner "What, you never seen a hologram before or something?" not realize the illusion of his family was a hologram?! That's some real wheelchair vegetable level incompetence).
It never explains if they were supposed to actually be supernatural ghosts or if it was some form of mind digitization (certainly they'd be aware of such technology), or why that caused her to go insane, OR how her ship was able to generate magnetic fields stronger than anyone there can even comprehend, to the point where the magnetic field was literally ripping apart ships (which would take "literal star going super nova" levels of astronomical extremes).
They never even hinted at nanotechnology, which is the only way she could have made the family-breakfast-table scene, which should have been an immediate giveaway for the dude who was subjected to it, yet he never gave any indications of comprehending what was happening.
And if this lady was THAT rich, and had mysteriously disappeared in her spaceship-city-of-over-the-top-extravagance 60 years prior to "present day" for the salvage dudes, how had no one heard of her?
Hell, if there were some guy back in the 1960s who left on his own personal man-made NYC-sized luxury cruise ship that makes the Titanic look like a tic-tac compared to Mt. Everest, you can best bet literally EVERYONE would have heard about him even in this day and age!
There's no WAY they wouldn't know her story, the shape, appearance, and scale of her ship, the technology on board, and how to identify it if they came across it.
And the ending...
Talk about dissatisfying!
Dawg left 3 essays on 3 different vids 💀
@@jumpreport
That essay took me about 10 minutes or less to write.
How long did this 20:47 long video take to record, edit, and upload?
If you get to be passionate about anime, why can't I be passionate about calling out writing errors in anime, or be passionate about wanting better quality in modern anime compared to the best of the best classic 90s/2000s animes (like Trigun)?
Credit where credit is due though, your videos are well made, and I have to give the studio that animated Magnetic Rose top marks for their exceptional animation work!
Son I hope ur gettin paid for writing these essays 😂
@@jumpreport
How much are you earning per month making these videos? 😂
Not much, get back to writing those essays to keep our engagement up 💀
How is Magnetic Rose "forgotten"? wtf? :D
Idk but the title made you click the video, watch and even comment on it 😬
@@jumpreport not sure if a clickbait is the best tactic, that kind of stuff makes me want to come, leave a comment and never come back. That's rather short sighted strat but whatever
cope