2024 AFL Draft Predictions | TOP 30 - Post AFL Trade Period

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 102

  • @TrueFootyAFL
    @TrueFootyAFL  2 дні тому +2

    If you’re struggling, consider therapy with our paid partner. Click
    betterhelp.com/truefooty for a discount on your first month of therapy.
    If you have questions about the brand relating to how the therapists are
    credentialed, their privacy policy, or therapist compensation, here is an overview
    written by the UA-cam creators behind the channel Cinema Therapy that goes into
    these topics:
    www.reddit.com/r/cinema_therapy/comments/1dpriql/addressing_the_betterhelp_concerns_headon_deep/

  • @joelcampbell6639
    @joelcampbell6639 3 години тому +8

    This draft is very even and i don't see Richmond giving up all those picks for an injury prone fin o Sullivan, It is most likely that they will trade their later picks for future firsts

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 49 хвилин тому

      Plenty of players have been injury prone in their junior years, Joel Selwood is an example. Your not going to get high future first rounds picks for later picks unless teams want those later picks for academy and NGA's.

  • @kulaaofficial
    @kulaaofficial 5 годин тому +4

    That Richmond north pick swap actually makes so much sense for both teams. Norths rebuild would complete with the additions of Luke Trainor, Armstrong and another gun - they’d just need time then and Richmond would be setup with absolute elite talent over two drafts. Smart call

    • @MakeCakeNotWar
      @MakeCakeNotWar Годину тому

      As a tigers fan I would say yes, I'm not sure north says yes... but if North fans love it then yes

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      My pleasure guys. I think its a great fair trade for both teams. I think North would do this deal.

  • @willslamin4597
    @willslamin4597 2 години тому +7

    Richmond are not going to give up 6,10&11 for 2 and F1st. Absolutely ridiculous. The difference between 2&6 is minimal. Either 6&20 for 2 or not at all.

    • @TheBigM31
      @TheBigM31 Годину тому

      Yeah absolutely won't do that. maybe 6,11,18. I can see us doing 6 and 18 for 2 if we really want it but NMFC will take Tairu at 2 or 6.

    • @297fihsy
      @297fihsy Годину тому

      I’d love if we gave North 10,11 for 2. Spend 1,2,6 on elite mids and gets some talls with our later picks

  • @harrylederman1679
    @harrylederman1679 3 години тому +4

    Look at the Blue Abroad video from 1 day ago ''Carlron's Pick 3 master plan revealed'''...Dylan Alexander argued for FOS while Pommie argued passionately for Sid Draper.... The whole idea of going to number three in the draft was to give the midfield a point of difference...I.e. Pace/,Burst out of stoppage

    • @IloveDeKock
      @IloveDeKock 3 години тому +1

      Yeah ngl he’s got this very wrong with Carlton, if we draft jagga smith the clubs gone backwards

    • @quentondaniels8536
      @quentondaniels8536 3 години тому

      ⁠@@IloveDeKock- tenfold agree. It’s either Lalor, Draper or O’Sullivan as our pick 3.

    • @quentondaniels8536
      @quentondaniels8536 3 години тому

      @harrylederman1679 - talked with Pommy myself, his money is on Draper. Personally I’d love Lalor if he’s there at pick 3. But like Draper too.

    • @lex3191
      @lex3191 Годину тому

      Yeah really don’t understand why on earth Carlton would pick J. Smith. I also doubt Richmond would take both Lalor and FOS.

  • @tigrrrman
    @tigrrrman 5 годин тому +3

    Picks 6, 10 & 11 for pick 2, and a future 1st is way off the mark.
    There is little difference between pick 2 and pick 6 this year.
    Richmond's Pick 24, and a future 4th, for North's future 2nd, and future 3rd is more likely.
    It would give North the extra pick they crave, without having to part with pick 2.
    Richmond may only want to take 7 picks this year.

    • @____Riley____
      @____Riley____ 2 години тому

      With the way this mock draft went for both clubs, I think they'd both be pretty happy with the trade. I can see North being more hesitant to do the trade due to them maybe wanting to hold onto their future 1st to allow for a big player trade next year.

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      Understand as a Richmond Supporter you want to keep all your picks. But think about this. You could potentially get another Dustin Martin and Trent Cotchin all over again. Plus have the first 2 picks next year too or at least 2 top 5 picks to add to that. All the top 5 picks this year are all gun midfielders and won't be available at pick 6.

  • @angusheasly2674
    @angusheasly2674 5 годин тому +2

    Carlton and Richmond both made deals with Brisbane in the trade period - It’s unfortunate but I think neither bid on Ashcroft

  • @domonicsheridan5347
    @domonicsheridan5347 3 години тому +1

    Hey mate great work it’s hard to see Richmond dropping out of the draft that early but could be worth it, the players u had them taking were on the money I like Carlton getting draper as every one calls him a pod to our midfield

  • @widesreentv
    @widesreentv 2 години тому +3

    At most i could see richmond giving up 10 and 18 for pick 2, which north wouldnt take
    The draft is too strong and deep to be giving up 3 picks especially if harry Armstrong is available at 6 like youve projected

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      Correct. North wont make a deal unless pick 6 is involved.

  • @seanchristie7150
    @seanchristie7150 38 хвилин тому

    Fantastic episode, loving the analysis and reasoning behind each selection. Keep up the awesome work 💙 💛 🦅 🏆

  • @spindoctor6385
    @spindoctor6385 31 хвилина тому

    I think the potential trade works a lot better for Richmond than the previous idea of getting 2 for 6&20.
    I noticed a lot of North fans didn't like the idea of giving up 2 at all so I doubt they would like this much better.
    I personally think it would suit both clubs, Richmond get value differed to next year and North get more picks in what is supposed to be a strong draft, with the thought that it should finish the initial rebuild stage and progress to more targeted trades and free agents in the next couple of years.

  • @ralphgomeze8873
    @ralphgomeze8873 8 годин тому +4

    With what’s available for West Coast , I would have them take Murphy Reid. Giving West Coast 3 Reid’s in their list 😂

    • @DoubleThinkFan
      @DoubleThinkFan 2 години тому

      🗣Reid handballs to reid, reid kicks to reid 🗣😂

  • @quentondaniels8536
    @quentondaniels8536 3 години тому +1

    As a Carlton supporter, can not see Jagga as our pick 3; it’ll be either Lalor, O’Sullivan or Draper.

  • @higgo267
    @higgo267 27 хвилин тому

    Lalor at 1 then best mid available at 6. Therefore the added extras of 10 & 11 we can go possible mid help, but more run and strength. I go Hotton(x-factor) replacement for Bolton, then Bo Allan pace for half back/wing or mid help.

  • @scottbennier1335
    @scottbennier1335 7 годин тому +4

    Port will not add yet another small forward , they took 2 in last year’s draft + Richards + Rioli + Byrne-Jones + McEntee . I would think Port would look at some class outside run as they have lost Karl Amon last year and will lose Travis Boak next year. Port have very little in the area of genuine wingmen.

    • @scottbennier1335
      @scottbennier1335 6 годин тому +1

      …… Also Port would be considering Benny Barrett a small forward who is in Port’s NGA later in the draft or rookie list and of course the imminent return of Sam Powell-Pepper (although he’s not small , he is a high pressure forward)

    • @jakeborlace1871
      @jakeborlace1871 56 хвилин тому +1

      Also everyone seems to forget about sam powell pepper coming back from ACL

  • @drgreenthumb1348
    @drgreenthumb1348 Годину тому

    Well done on the podcast yesterday

    • @drgreenthumb1348
      @drgreenthumb1348 Годину тому

      Tigers definitely won't make that trade, absolutely ludicrous as a Tigers supporter. Give up 3 top 11 picks for 1 pick in a so called best draft in 20 years.

  • @harrylederman1679
    @harrylederman1679 3 години тому +1

    Carlton will not take Jagger Smith because he is just more of the same that we already have. [Cripps,Walsh,Cerra & Hewitt who are also 30 positions + accumulators... We need POD = price of difference] pace /explosion out of the middle coming out of the front of stoppages and that one will most likely be Sid Draper... Yes we would like FOS ideally for the similar attributes but he's a better Mark and kick as well as a goalkeeper

  • @coolbananas127
    @coolbananas127 2 години тому +1

    If this draft genuinely has as much depth as were being told I can’t see the need for Richmond to give up all those picks for pick 2, unless they really rate FOS as being that much better than every other midfielder they could pick up in the top 15. They’d probably be better to try and trade later picks to get into next year’s draft.

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      North are not interested in later picks for their future 1st. Their future 1st is looking to be a top 5 pick. Who would trade later picks for a top 5 pick lol.

  • @deanbeissel2807
    @deanbeissel2807 7 годин тому +2

    A couple of those picks are pretty rogue, especially Melbourne.
    I am hoping eagles take either Allan or travaglia, so I hope you are wrong haha
    Lindsay would be handy too

  • @samantha-jane4424
    @samantha-jane4424 День тому +1

    My hope is that we dangle the future first round (maybe the future second too) and try to get a higher pick (4-9) to try and get another decent pick in this years draft.

    • @TrueFootyAFL
      @TrueFootyAFL  День тому

      I would be happy with that in theory! I wonder if our F1 would tempt a team out of their own top ten pick though. It’s a tough one. I wonder if we are more likely to trade into the 20-40 range if we rate it as even

  • @kingshezz6931
    @kingshezz6931 7 годин тому +4

    Carlton are not taking jagga, he’s too similar to what we already have we have in the midfield. They’ll go for an explosive mid like Draper or FOS.

    • @harrylederman1679
      @harrylederman1679 3 години тому

      I just went on about the same thing before I saw your comment so I don't think these people know that we need explosion and pace to balance out our midfield requirements

  • @bobrob7641
    @bobrob7641 6 годин тому +1

    Hey mate. The combine was last week not sure if you’re aware just based on your last couple videos

  • @ShadowLight-kn7rl
    @ShadowLight-kn7rl 5 годин тому

    Armstrong, Smillie and Trainor w/Stevens as F/S.
    Boy that's a draft haul for North and I'd love that to happen fir my Roo's. Fills every need and from what I'm hearing the concussion speculation around Trainor has turned out to be just that. A wild case of Chinese whispers that's unfortunately put a cloud on his rankings.
    Loving your work mate! Keep up the good stuff!

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      As a North supporter I would love to see those 3 guys drafted. Fills the need for everything we need.

  • @eaglefruit
    @eaglefruit Годину тому

    I reckon Richmond goes into the draft with their full hand and just takes live offers throughout the draft. Last year we saw a lot of live trades in which clubs slid back for future picks. With such an even draft, clubs would have a very different ranking, and not until draft night could they know if certain players are still going to be there, so Tigers could just field competing offers all night.
    I reckon they'd do 10+11 for 2, but not 6. North should be desperate to get more than one decent pick in a plump draft so would do a lesser deal than the one you proposed.

  • @ShadowLight-kn7rl
    @ShadowLight-kn7rl 5 годин тому +1

    North trading picks 2 and F1st for Richmond's picks 6, 10 and 11 is a SPICY MEATA BALL!!! Despite my displeasure at North trading F1st it's worth the risk and probably the right time to take said risk is getting this draft perfect. Both clubs get a massive premium for BOTH their respective rebuilds and where they are at and that's a really good deal

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      Agreed!!!! Works for both teams.

  • @mrgedavies
    @mrgedavies 7 годин тому +2

    Love your work and appreciate your research but Wayno's in his own world. There's little difference between 2 and 6 this year so the Tiges would be potentially trading 10 and 11 for a 16 after F/S, NGAs in 2025.

    • @omertahir7436
      @omertahir7436 4 години тому

      Massive difference in talent between 2 and 6 after top 5 they drop off

    • @mrgedavies
      @mrgedavies 3 години тому

      @@omertahir7436 Jagga, Langford, Ashcroft, Smillie, Draper, Lalor, FOS. Which 2 of these 7 are you saying are not top-shelf?

  • @wayno845
    @wayno845 2 хвилини тому

    I totally understand some Richmond supporters not liking this deal. With that many picks the Tiges can really bolster their future with this draft. Just remember North's future 1st will likely be a top 5 pick next year in another strong draft. If Richmond do this deal you can potentially get Dusty and Cotchin all over again, taking Lalor, FOS or Jagga. These guns won't be available at pick 7 (Pick 6). Then you get another gun next year on top of your own selection. Pick 2 and 1-5 next year for pick 6, 10 and 11. Maybe 18 gets involved with a swap of future 2nd or 3rd rounders. I don't see Richmond or North doing a deal with anyone else.

  • @extreamaussieguy2968
    @extreamaussieguy2968 6 годин тому +1

    Could actually see Port trading down, say 13 & 36 for 18 & 20 from Richmond.

  • @higgo267
    @higgo267 7 годин тому +11

    No way Richmond would even consider. Maybe 6 & 20. Tigers view 10,11 as cream selections. Tell them their Dreaming.

    • @brettcoles5262
      @brettcoles5262 5 годин тому +1

      Well said Mr list manager bahahahahahaha

    • @odjiragaming5778
      @odjiragaming5778 5 годин тому +2

      Pick 2 and next years pick which is likely pick 5 at the latest, for 6, 10, and 11? Good thing you're not a list manager.

    • @omertahir7436
      @omertahir7436 4 години тому

      On ya bike son 6 and 20 tigers can keep it, we hold pick 2 you want it pay up or keep your picks and we take FOS

    • @higgo267
      @higgo267 2 години тому +1

      @@omertahir7436 you want more than us. No Tauru for you. We'll keep and still get a great mid at 6 ( Langford/Smillie). Then we just pull in the cream with 10 &11. More the merrier for us.

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому

      @@higgo267 At the end of the day the deal has got to be right for both teams. This is fair and reasonable. Pick 6 and 20 for pick 2 is not fair for North and you know it. That deal will never be done.

  • @Jacpark
    @Jacpark 20 секунд тому

    Norths pick 2 and future 1st for 6, 10 & 11 is ballsy to say the least, as a North supporter I would love that, Still think Pick 2 for 10 & 11 will happen, Richmond get 3 of the first 6 picks, North get access to the Key position players we need,

  • @odjiragaming5778
    @odjiragaming5778 5 годин тому

    North trading pick 2 and next years pick which is most likely pick 2 or 3 for 6, 10, and 11 is insane. The only way North wins out in that trade is if they rocket up the ladder next year, which isn't happening, no matter how much I want it to.

  • @MakeCakeNotWar
    @MakeCakeNotWar Годину тому

    Lalor has never had a fully footy preseason cause he always has cricket commitments. He said so in an interview... sooo yeah he is a potentially a top pick without fully focusing on footy... so yes untapped potential.

  • @fergulator7297
    @fergulator7297 5 годин тому

    Hinkley loves his small forwards so Berry is a big chance at port if he's still available

  • @RICHMOND2025
    @RICHMOND2025 7 годин тому +5

    Richmond lose that trade. Maybe if it was 6, 11 and 20 for 2 and F1.

    • @GhostOfRT300
      @GhostOfRT300 7 годин тому +4

      Hartley would never do such a ridiculous trade. This is what separates professional recruiters like Hartley and keyboard draft warriors like this guy.

    • @mrgedavies
      @mrgedavies 7 годин тому +3

      This is better than "Wayno's" suggestion. We need to be wary that North's F1 could blow out to 15 or 16 with F/S, NGAs etc.

  • @David-ib4kr
    @David-ib4kr 4 години тому

    GWS had the back to back and you skipped out on their second pick but overall I like the selection of Tom Gross for them

  • @Womas161
    @Womas161 5 годин тому +2

    I get we probably arnt going to take 8 but why is everyone so keen on us giving up all or half of our top 10 picks and not the later ones in the round we don't need nths pick 2. I get they want more in this draft, but we don't have to over pay for a very even draft at the top especially when we likely get 1 of the elite guys regardless . It's a fun excersie but richmond already knocked back 2 for 6 and 14 so I just can't see us entertaining anything with pick 6 involved. it changes the entire landscape of the mock draft.
    Regardless love your work keep it up legend 👌

    • @Womas161
      @Womas161 5 годин тому

      Also yuck on the Whitlock twins there my least favourote players in the top 40 if we followed this play book we have well and truly given up.

    • @john-iy9hy
      @john-iy9hy 5 годин тому

      because the draft is not that good .... tigers list is a mess they need 1st and 2nd pick

    • @Womas161
      @Womas161 4 години тому

      @john-iy9hy true our list isnt great but lets not pretend nths list isnt mess also you won 1 more game than us we could barley field a team at one point.
      🤣🤣 also thats just your opinion my opinion and everybody else thinks it bats very deep and is the best draft in 15 years. these are the people that are paid to actually know these things you know recruiters.

    • @john-iy9hy
      @john-iy9hy 4 години тому

      @@Womas161 i watched many games and not impressed jagga ball magnet and draper fast with his hands in close are the only good players

    • @Womas161
      @Womas161 4 години тому

      @john-iy9hy that's your opinion. I watched every one of the championship games and tried to watch as many of the coates leage games that where available and I completely disagree. I even went to the vfl games that the kids played in so that sucks if you couldn't see the potential that everyone else sees.

  • @mwm71638
    @mwm71638 13 хвилин тому

    Nightmare scenario for the eagles and horrendous mismanagement of a rebuild if all they come out of the draft with is Lindsay.

  • @JakeBeattie-h3s
    @JakeBeattie-h3s 5 годин тому

    i think port will trade 13 if they cant get tauru idk if its the best option getting Berry port are needing key backman talent considering delisting cluery and having aliir turn 31, tho i woudnt be suprised with berry but might not be best option with 36 and 50 being next picks

  • @billbaggins1688
    @billbaggins1688 3 години тому

    Tauru at 6? North would be pissed. Trainor has some concussion issues unfortunately and may slide. North ideally trade up and hope for Armstrong and Tauru. That would be a great result.

  • @himalayanhealthhut6656
    @himalayanhealthhut6656 Годину тому

    Dees are taking best available midfielder at 5, not Tauru. If Tauru is still available at 9, sure. But we need an elite mid after departure of Brayshaw and Tracc/Clarry now in their late 20’s. I like Langford at 5.

    • @eaglefruit
      @eaglefruit 31 хвилина тому

      I think Tauru is a smart option for them there, because he won't get past the next few picks, they may rate others higher but to get them and Tauru they need to pick him first.

  • @metallewd3472
    @metallewd3472 5 годин тому

    If I were Richmond I'd give away half our picks. Why does this not surprise me.

  • @hehehheheheheehehehehehe6476
    @hehehheheheheehehehehehe6476 Годину тому

    Would definitely take Joe berry over smillie but other than that love it

  • @Mbert7246
    @Mbert7246 6 годин тому +1

    This might break my heart if Tauru goes one pick before north 😢

    • @wayno845
      @wayno845 Годину тому +1

      Trainor is better than Tauru imo. I'd be happy with Tauru though. Imagine having 2 key position defenders like Trainor and Comben that can play either ends of the ground at any time. That gives the team great flexibility when leading a game or chasing the game. Clarkson the Puppet Master!!!!!!!

    • @Mbert7246
      @Mbert7246 44 хвилини тому

      @@wayno845 that’s fair! I think Trainor is slightly better now. I really like Tauru’s long term potential, but there is risk

  • @joshuafrerk1363
    @joshuafrerk1363 4 години тому

    Personally I hope the saints pick smillie. He’s faster and stronger and hits the score board more. We definitely lack a good midfielder that can score.

  • @SpookyMooky
    @SpookyMooky 6 годин тому

    Love it for us norf fans

  • @zacrasheed4522
    @zacrasheed4522 5 годин тому

    In your draft, as a port adelaide fan i take best available and go murphy reid

  • @chrisreed6476
    @chrisreed6476 10 хвилин тому

    Ain’t no way Richmond give up 6 10 and 11 if it happens it will be 6 and 18 and if Richmond really really want to get up to 2 they would do 6 and 11 but I doubt that very much

  • @scottmeyers4856
    @scottmeyers4856 6 годин тому

    Great draft and could reasonably play out this way. What an unmitigated disaster for the eagles if this happens, proves they had no clue about this draft and couldn't possibly stand by their comments that they expect the kid they want to still be there. In saying that I'm a fan of Lindsay and would have to be the best if not 1 of the beat kicks in this draft. Be hard to pass on M.Reid if available tho

  • @andrewadam4869
    @andrewadam4869 Годину тому

    I stopped the video as soon as you suggested that Richmond Trade.

  • @PabloDiscordYT
    @PabloDiscordYT 3 години тому

    Saints won't let simile slip down to pick 13 LOL

  • @jasonbeck3814
    @jasonbeck3814 6 годин тому

    I don't go for tigers or roos .are you saying if Eagles had pick 2 and future pick 3 you would trade them for 6 10 and 11 remembering you previously traded pick 1 for 8 and 12.this deal is borderline laughable.better deal is either 6 and 11 or 10 11 and 20 but roos don't wont to go lower than 6 th

  • @jasonbeck3814
    @jasonbeck3814 6 годин тому

    Saknts sipporter would like langford and shanahan

  • @jasonbeck3814
    @jasonbeck3814 6 годин тому

    Like swans trade

  • @jasonbeck3814
    @jasonbeck3814 6 годин тому

    Armstrong perfect for roos

  • @djdeutsch8703
    @djdeutsch8703 Годину тому

    Murphy Reid will go much higher. Probably to the saints.

  • @mattcook9108
    @mattcook9108 7 годин тому +2

    That is an absolute garbage trade for Richmond. 6 & 20 perhaps but no way Richmond will give up 3 picks in a draft this deep. Terrible.

  • @john-iy9hy
    @john-iy9hy 5 годин тому

    Not lalor his stats are not that good in 3 games in the national championship he only had 10 disposals 5 marks and 2goals.... Richmond need Jagga the guy is a ball magnet and a clearance beast ....dont be surprised if Richmond go for Kako to replace Bolton.....

  • @AustinBrough-r6z
    @AustinBrough-r6z 2 години тому

    Murphy Reid!!!!!

  • @joshuafrerk1363
    @joshuafrerk1363 4 години тому

    I hope saints go for norths pick 2.
    Saints give pick 7,32 or future first for norths pick 2

  • @higgo267
    @higgo267 7 годин тому +6

    After watching you this combination is way off your previous predictions here and on other channels. This looks the worst and far reaching.

    • @jezzakleinert1711
      @jezzakleinert1711 5 годин тому +1

      don’t get upset over a youtube video buddy it’s a bit of fun prediction how can you label it worst and far reaching lmao

  • @jasonbeck3814
    @jasonbeck3814 6 годин тому

    First i like