The last statement sums it up perfectly for me: "You're gonna be exposed to a wide range of humanity, and it's very fulfilling". THANK YOU very much Dr. Goertz for what you do.
I appreciate your honest views! I love hearing about the little things you've experienced in your practice. I'm currently still in undergrad, but I hope whatever I'm learning is going to lead me in a fulfilling career in the future Looking forward to your next video!
Love your videos! Some topics I would also love to hear your opinion on: 1. Tips for aspiring students who want to become psychiatrists ( getting into medical school, residency, etc) 2. Working in private practice versus working at a hospital Thank you (from a recent BA in psychology graduate).
Hi Dr! Love the videos. I'm 25 years old and have never went to university - had planned to after high school but couldn't due to some circumstances. I've been doing a lot of research on career paths and feel like psychiatry could be good for me. As I'm sure you know, this will mean 10-12 years of school (assuming I get into med school without any problems). I'd be around 35-37 by the time I would start practising. Based on this, do you think it would still be worth it? Thank you.
Love your content, thanks so much Dr... Have you had any experience with Computational Psychiatry or just students coming from a computer/engineering background? I'm currently going back to school for a CS degree with a minor in Stats... but can't help being fascinated with Psychiatry... any reflections/recommendations are appreciated. All the best with the channel!
Thank you! Interesting. Some of my videos relate to quantum physics and the limits of logical thinking. I like, that the practice of psychiatry leaves a lot of room for creativity. I don’t recall students, who had a computer science background, however I did not know the background of most of them. Peter Goertz
Hello Doctor. I appreciate your work and that you share your valuable knowledge. From your experience is it a plus if someone that wants to be a Psychiatrist starts as Psychologist and Psychotherapist ? I am in Psychology and Psychotherapy and i started med school too. I did that in order to be in that area little bit erlier and have some experience already in mental health field job before i start my residensy as Psychiatrist. I like Psychiatry/ Neuropsychiatry/Neuropsychology a lot ! In Europe Neuropsychiatry not really exists as a fellowship after Psychiatry residensy .We mostly do that from the point of you view of Neuropsychology. That's why i try to do both.
Thank you! I find psychology/psychotherapy very important. A potential risk of studying psychology/psychotherapy and attending medical school at the same time is overextending yourself and not having enough time for recreation. Peter Goertz
Excelent video! I'm a Med Student in South America who wants to be a psychiatrist, can you make a video talking more about the quality of life being resident and being psychiatrist? Thank youuu
Hi Dr. I am 35 now..always wanted to become Psychiatrist but couldn't because of finances...now I will complete my MSc Psychology in 2023...is it still of some worth to start in 2024 and become a psychiatrist at the age of almost 47? I have two kids. Live in UK.
Thank you for bringing this up. A few years ago I worked with a medical student in her 60’s, very competent and on the ball. It may be wise to consider whichever path feels right to you in your bones. Peter Goertz
Hey I have a question, first thank you for your amazing videos !! I want to do the same exact thing become a psychiatrist but I really don’t know where to start . I go to a private college and I major in psychology with the minor of biology starting my sophomore year. I want to know if these are the right steps heading towards becoming a psychiatrist also when it comes to medical school do I have to go earn my master before entering to medical school? Or I should be fine . Thank you so much!
I really like psychiatry but i am afraid i will get crazy/depressed by dealing with so many depressed and anxious people. What are your thoughts about this?
Hi Mattia, Interesting question. This has not been an issue for me, however each person is different and will need to make this decision for themself. Peter Goertz
im unsure if i should major in Psychiatry or try to get an MS in Clinical Counseling/psychology .. Psychiatry requires more math and science and you actually go to med school? Did you have to deliver babies and stuff and cut open people/perform doctor related work and would you say it’s harder than the MS in Clinical Counseling degree? Then again maybe Psychiatry has more flexibility when it comes to career options than just your degree in clinical counseling only.
Hi I’m 16, I want to go into these routes, I’m not sure. Should I risk it and go med school to become a psychiatrist? What are the benefits? Or should I go to psychology school? Im worried and I don’t want to spend the rest of my life studying..
As a psychiatrist you have knowledge of physical problems and their connections with mental problems, so, in that sense, you have a broader understanding. The path toward being a psychiatrist does involve a lot of studying. Peter Goertz
Hi, i dont mean to word vomit my entire situation here as i dont know if you will even see this, but I would love to have your input. Im sorry this is so long but I hope you will have the time to read and respond ( i absolutely get it if you dont!) I just turned 18 and i live in india. Here medical school is straight out of high school. Unfortunately, due to whatever circumstance, i didn't have biology as a subject in 11th and 12th grade, but i had physics, chemistry and mathematics. Which means i am not eligible to even give NEET, the medical entrance test in india as bio is a prereq. Now this is Unfortunate as i realized my interest in psychiatry pretty late. Im done with high school now and if I choose to go the medical route, I'd have to redo 12th and graduate again with bio as a subject and prepare for the incredibly difficult medical entrance test here in india. And im not a big fan of science, I feel like i would hate the journey of med school but I would love actually practicing as a psychiatrist. Also I am not interested in any other field of medicine, nothing else fascinates me.(apart from neuroscience, psychiatry, and maybe cognitive science which im aware is not a medical field) On the other hand, my career counsellor recommended that I prepare for the law entrance test and forget about medicine. I've been doing that for a couple months now and i enjoy the preparation much more than the science courses! Law school is also right after high school too by the way i forgot to mention. So I was thinking of studying law and psychology, as i can practice an area of law that im interested in and also practice therapy on the side. I like this idea and the culmination of both the fields. This is within my reach as well and i wouldn't have to retake any courses. Also i am not sure if i would enjoy psychiatry or psychology practice more? I know psychiatry is the scientific, biology aspect of it ( sorry for my poor framing of words) whereas psychology is the behavioural and talk therapy aspect. If I dont enjoy science, does it mean i would enjoy being a psychologist more? I guess I do want to be more involved with a client at a personal level, and psychology is better for that. But there is just something about psychiatry that makes it so appealing to me and I cannot stop thinking about it. It's broader in scope, you can prescribe medications, and also help with the more severe mental disorders which a psychologist cannot. I think I may have glamourized it too much in my head haha. I know 18 is not that late and it just means that I will become a doctor one year later than my peers, but I want to pick what is in my best interest and at this point, im very confused. Redoing a year sounds very very stressful to me, i know i will struggle with science, also i have no choice but to study in india, due to financial reasons, so these are my options. I would like to know what you think, and get your opinion. I can't expect you to fix my life for me haha but with all your experience in the field and extensive knowledge of both psychiatry and psychology, and given my particular situation, what do you think i should do?
Hi Namratha, It seems wise for you to get as much information as possible about the fields that you might be interested in, e.g. law, psychiatry, etc. After that it may be good to trust your feelings and do what feels right to you. Right after you wake up in the morning may be a good time to check what feels right to you. Peter Goertz
I am currently in school to be a psychiatrist. I am in my first year for my bachelor's. Do you have any advice for my academic journey? Also, In my life I have suffered from many mental ups and downs in my life but my goal is to help people who suffer from the same diagnoses I did .. Do you have any advice for me concerning that ? Thank you so much I love your videos they are a lot of help ! Much love be well ❤
Thank you Kesha! This video addresses one of your questions ua-cam.com/video/joiCPDk8I-Y/v-deo.html Regarding your academic journey, it may be wise to get as much information as necessary, and then do what feels right to you on a gut level. Peter Goertz
I am inclined to think that although it's true that a psychiatrist can do both medication management and therapy, the therapy is rarely reaching the standard that the psychologist works at.
The reason it is common nowadays to have a psychologist is simply because psychiatrists are not trained sufficiently or competent in any way beyond prescription of medication. Psychologists have 4 years undergraduate pure psychology (human behaviour, emotions, thinking and more) and at least 2 years masters degree in clinical psychology for diagnosing, assessing and at the same time integrate all psychological theories for the benefit of the patient. Psychiatrists have 6 years unrelated medicine with about 6 weeks basic psychiatry (not psychology) and during residency are majorly concerned with diagnosing and prescribing medication. As a patient I will avoid psychiatrists pretending to be therapists like the plague. They are NOT. They can if they are good help with meds but also frequently overprescribe.
Thank you for your comment. To my knowledge in current psychiatric training there is often less focus on psychotherapy than there used to be. Peter Goertz
To my knowledge current psychiatric training often focuses less on psychotherapy than it used to. However, a significant number of current psychiatrists are still well trained in psychotherapy and can help patients without medication.
@@goertzpsychiatry9340 Hello. You mentioned that a number of psychiatrists still are well-trained in psychotherapy. I'm interested if it's my choice to get a further qualification in psychotherapy (as a psychiatrist) or not?
You have the option as a psychiatrist to get further training in psychotherapy. When I was in residency, additional training in psychoanalysis was available. Peter Goertz
It’s a demonic practice. Psychiatrists are the biggest evil present today. Prescribing dangerous drugs like candy, causing serious harm through these drugs, and then blaming the patient. Rot in hell.
I am sorry if your experience was less than favorable after receiving treatment from a psychiatrist. Fortunately, you may have different experiences with different psychiatrists. I hope that you or those you know continue your journey to mental wellness.
The last statement sums it up perfectly for me: "You're gonna be exposed to a wide range of humanity, and it's very fulfilling". THANK YOU very much Dr. Goertz for what you do.
Thank you Esther!
Dr. Goertz...can you please post a video with your views on this so called anti-psiquiatry movement... The internet is getting floaded with these...
@@botabotilde Thank you Anibal for your suggestion.
I Thank You for your invaluable insight and clear explanations...
@@botabotilde Thank you Anibal!
Please, for the love of God, keep posting such great content. Love your work! Keep it up doc🙏🏻
Thank you!
I appreciate your honest views! I love hearing about the little things you've experienced in your practice. I'm currently still in undergrad, but I hope whatever I'm learning is going to lead me in a fulfilling career in the future Looking forward to your next video!
I appreciate your comment! Peter Goertz
Love your videos! Some topics I would also love to hear your opinion on:
1. Tips for aspiring students who want to become psychiatrists ( getting into medical school, residency, etc)
2. Working in private practice versus working at a hospital
Thank you (from a recent BA in psychology graduate).
Thank you Danial! Thank you for your suggestions. Peter Goertz
@@goertzpsychiatry9340 You're very welcome!
I want to know too!! I plan on going to college for this field of interest but am curious about specifics
I’m so inspired by you 🙏🏾
Thank you very much Dr. Onumba! Peter Goertz
I love these videos so much
Thank you Nicolette! Peter Goertz
Will be joining as a Psychiatry Resident in 2 weeks time . Thanks for the wonderful video .
Thank you and congratulations! Peter Goertz
I recently got accepted into psychiatry residency in New York. After watching this video, I became more and more excited for July 1st!
Hi Abdullah, Thank you and congratulations! Peter Goertz
Hi Dr! Love the videos. I'm 25 years old and have never went to university - had planned to after high school but couldn't due to some circumstances. I've been doing a lot of research on career paths and feel like psychiatry could be good for me. As I'm sure you know, this will mean 10-12 years of school (assuming I get into med school without any problems). I'd be around 35-37 by the time I would start practising. Based on this, do you think it would still be worth it? Thank you.
In my opinion around age 35 is a reasonable age to become a psychiatrist. Peter Goertz
Love your content, thanks so much Dr... Have you had any experience with Computational Psychiatry or just students coming from a computer/engineering background? I'm currently going back to school for a CS degree with a minor in Stats... but can't help being fascinated with Psychiatry... any reflections/recommendations are appreciated. All the best with the channel!
Thank you! Interesting. Some of my videos relate to quantum physics and the limits of logical thinking. I like, that the practice of psychiatry leaves a lot of room for creativity. I don’t recall students, who had a computer science background, however I did not know the background of most of them. Peter Goertz
im in the same boat
Hello Doctor. I appreciate your work and that you share your valuable knowledge. From your experience is it a plus if someone that wants to be a Psychiatrist starts as Psychologist and Psychotherapist ? I am in Psychology and Psychotherapy and i started med school too. I did that in order to be in that area little bit erlier and have some experience already in mental health field job before i start my residensy as Psychiatrist. I like Psychiatry/ Neuropsychiatry/Neuropsychology a lot ! In Europe Neuropsychiatry not really exists as a fellowship after Psychiatry residensy .We mostly do that from the point of you view of Neuropsychology. That's why i try to do both.
Thank you! I find psychology/psychotherapy very important. A potential risk of studying psychology/psychotherapy and attending medical school at the same time is overextending yourself and not having enough time for recreation. Peter Goertz
@@goertzpsychiatry9340 Yes i agree with you Doctor. Thanks a lot for the reply.
Excelent video! I'm a Med Student in South America who wants to be a psychiatrist, can you make a video talking more about the quality of life being resident and being psychiatrist? Thank youuu
Thank you! And thank you for the suggestions. Peter Goertz
Hi Dr. I am 35 now..always wanted to become Psychiatrist but couldn't because of finances...now I will complete my MSc Psychology in 2023...is it still of some worth to start in 2024 and become a psychiatrist at the age of almost 47? I have two kids. Live in UK.
Thank you for bringing this up. A few years ago I worked with a medical student in her 60’s, very competent and on the ball. It may be wise to consider whichever path feels right to you in your bones. Peter Goertz
Hey I have a question, first thank you for your amazing videos !! I want to do the same exact thing become a psychiatrist but I really don’t know where to start . I go to a private college and I major in psychology with the minor of biology starting my sophomore year. I want to know if these are the right steps heading towards becoming a psychiatrist also when it comes to medical school do I have to go earn my master before entering to medical school? Or I should be fine . Thank you so much!
Hi Donesha, Thank you! Your current path sounds reasonable to me. You do not need a master’s degree before medical school. Peter Goertz
I really like psychiatry but i am afraid i will get crazy/depressed by dealing with so many depressed and anxious people. What are your thoughts about this?
Hi Mattia, Interesting question. This has not been an issue for me, however each person is different and will need to make this decision for themself. Peter Goertz
im unsure if i should major in
Psychiatry
or try to get an MS in Clinical Counseling/psychology ..
Psychiatry requires more math and science and you actually go to med school? Did you have to deliver babies and stuff and cut open people/perform doctor related work and would you say it’s harder than the MS in Clinical Counseling degree?
Then again maybe Psychiatry has more flexibility when it comes to career options than just your degree in clinical counseling only.
Yes, you would have to complete medical school in order to go into psychiatry.
Hi I’m 16, I want to go into these routes, I’m not sure. Should I risk it and go med school to become a psychiatrist? What are the benefits? Or should I go to psychology school? Im worried and I don’t want to spend the rest of my life studying..
As a psychiatrist you have knowledge of physical problems and their connections with mental problems, so, in that sense, you have a broader understanding. The path toward being a psychiatrist does involve a lot of studying. Peter Goertz
Hi, i dont mean to word vomit my entire situation here as i dont know if you will even see this, but I would love to have your input. Im sorry this is so long but I hope you will have the time to read and respond ( i absolutely get it if you dont!)
I just turned 18 and i live in india. Here medical school is straight out of high school. Unfortunately, due to whatever circumstance, i didn't have biology as a subject in 11th and 12th grade, but i had physics, chemistry and mathematics. Which means i am not eligible to even give NEET, the medical entrance test in india as bio is a prereq. Now this is Unfortunate as i realized my interest in psychiatry pretty late. Im done with high school now and if I choose to go the medical route, I'd have to redo 12th and graduate again with bio as a subject and prepare for the incredibly difficult medical entrance test here in india. And im not a big fan of science, I feel like i would hate the journey of med school but I would love actually practicing as a psychiatrist. Also I am not interested in any other field of medicine, nothing else fascinates me.(apart from neuroscience, psychiatry, and maybe cognitive science which im aware is not a medical field)
On the other hand, my career counsellor recommended that I prepare for the law entrance test and forget about medicine. I've been doing that for a couple months now and i enjoy the preparation much more than the science courses! Law school is also right after high school too by the way i forgot to mention. So I was thinking of studying law and psychology, as i can practice an area of law that im interested in and also practice therapy on the side. I like this idea and the culmination of both the fields. This is within my reach as well and i wouldn't have to retake any courses. Also i am not sure if i would enjoy psychiatry or psychology practice more? I know psychiatry is the scientific, biology aspect of it ( sorry for my poor framing of words) whereas psychology is the behavioural and talk therapy aspect. If I dont enjoy science, does it mean i would enjoy being a psychologist more? I guess I do want to be more involved with a client at a personal level, and psychology is better for that. But there is just something about psychiatry that makes it so appealing to me and I cannot stop thinking about it. It's broader in scope, you can prescribe medications, and also help with the more severe mental disorders which a psychologist cannot.
I think I may have glamourized it too much in my head haha. I know 18 is not that late and it just means that I will become a doctor one year later than my peers, but I want to pick what is in my best interest and at this point, im very confused. Redoing a year sounds very very stressful to me, i know i will struggle with science, also i have no choice but to study in india, due to financial reasons, so these are my options.
I would like to know what you think, and get your opinion. I can't expect you to fix my life for me haha but with all your experience in the field and extensive knowledge of both psychiatry and psychology, and given my particular situation, what do you think i should do?
Hi Namratha, It seems wise for you to get as much information as possible about the fields that you might be interested in, e.g. law, psychiatry, etc. After that it may be good to trust your feelings and do what feels right to you. Right after you wake up in the morning may be a good time to check what feels right to you. Peter Goertz
I am currently in school to be a psychiatrist. I am in my first year for my bachelor's. Do you have any advice for my academic journey? Also, In my life I have suffered from many mental ups and downs in my life but my goal is to help people who suffer from the same diagnoses I did .. Do you have any advice for me concerning that ? Thank you so much I love your videos they are a lot of help ! Much love be well ❤
Thank you Kesha! This video addresses one of your questions ua-cam.com/video/joiCPDk8I-Y/v-deo.html
Regarding your academic journey, it may be wise to get as much information as necessary, and then do what feels right to you on a gut level. Peter Goertz
Im 32, and considering this career, I haven't started college yet . Do you think it's too late ?
When I was a resident, another resident in my class was around age 40.
I have adhd , find it impossible to concentrate in class, what do you suggest, Dr, Thank you.
@@Letstalk-zx7jxIt may be helpful to get evaluated by a psychiatrist.
I am inclined to think that although it's true that a psychiatrist can do both medication management and therapy, the therapy is rarely reaching the standard that the psychologist works at.
Thank you for your input. Peter Goertz
Psychiatric hospitals are very nice but also like visiting a different planet
The reason it is common nowadays to have a psychologist is simply because psychiatrists are not trained sufficiently or competent in any way beyond prescription of medication. Psychologists have 4 years undergraduate pure psychology (human behaviour, emotions, thinking and more) and at least 2 years masters degree in clinical psychology for diagnosing, assessing and at the same time integrate all psychological theories for the benefit of the patient. Psychiatrists have 6 years unrelated medicine with about 6 weeks basic psychiatry (not psychology) and during residency are majorly concerned with diagnosing and prescribing medication. As a patient I will avoid psychiatrists pretending to be therapists like the plague. They are NOT. They can if they are good help with meds but also frequently overprescribe.
Thank you for your comment. To my knowledge in current psychiatric training there is often less focus on psychotherapy than there used to be. Peter Goertz
To my knowledge current psychiatric training often focuses less on psychotherapy than it used to. However, a significant number of current psychiatrists are still well trained in psychotherapy and can help patients without medication.
@@goertzpsychiatry9340 Hello. You mentioned that a number of psychiatrists still are well-trained in psychotherapy. I'm interested if it's my choice to get a further qualification in psychotherapy (as a psychiatrist) or not?
You have the option as a psychiatrist to get further training in psychotherapy. When I was in residency, additional training in psychoanalysis was available. Peter Goertz
@@goertzpsychiatry9340 Understood. Thank you.
A desirable career for a sociopath
It’s a demonic practice. Psychiatrists are the biggest evil present today. Prescribing dangerous drugs like candy, causing serious harm through these drugs, and then blaming the patient. Rot in hell.
Cringe
I wish the doctors can truly rot in hell. Absolutely disgusting.
I am sorry if your experience was less than favorable after receiving treatment from a psychiatrist. Fortunately, you may have different experiences with different psychiatrists. I hope that you or those you know continue your journey to mental wellness.
@@ImaniJones-m2k Seeing a shrink is the opposite of mental wellness.
@@ImaniJones-m2k “Less than desirable”. Seeing a shrink is the worst decision you could make for your “mental wellness”.