Why Didn't Spanish America Unite Like Brazil?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 чер 2024
- Thank you for watching! I hope you enjoyed the video!
🫂 Attributions
NASA Goddard Space Flight Center Image by Reto Stöckli (land surface, shallow water, clouds). Enhancements by Robert Simmon (ocean color, compositing, 3D globes, animation). Data and technical support: MODIS Land Group; MODIS Science Data Support Team; MODIS Atmosphere Group; MODIS Ocean Group Additional data: USGS EROS Data Center (topography); USGS Terrestrial Remote Sensing Flagstaff Field Center (Antarctica); Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (city lights).
🎵 Music
Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
creativecommons.org/licenses/b...
Covert Affair
Spy Glass
Hard Boiled
Dances And Dames
Bass Walker
Walking Along
Umbrella Pants
Exotic Battle
Enter The Maze
Constance
Digya
Showdown
Minima
Crossing the Chasm
Invariance
Outfoxing The Fox
Infados
Expeditionary
Disco Sting
Electro Cabello
Aurea Carmina
Ether Disco
Stringed Disco
Faster Does It
I Knew A Guy
Fast Talkin
Just As Soon
Sovereign
Investigations
Marty Gots a Plan
Accralate
Sneaky Adventure
Drums of the Deep
Pin pls and a will watch this ten times
Done😎
Ty
There goes to 5hours
I like this video top ten for this week
Thank you!
it's funny that in Brazilian Historigraphy, we make the oposite question: Why Didn't Brazil dismebered Like Spanish America?
alliance with Britain
@@elultramontano uhm no? its waaaaaay more complicated than that
@@elultramontano we already have answers being written for more than 150 years of historiography until today.
The british is one of the minor causes of the brazilian unity.
They sure helped in the independence processe by diplomatic and econonic means, but the political means of the unification during and after the independence war are autoctonous.
@@jeanitacarambi354bro, I think there are two main reasons for Brazil to be united after its indepedence: Pedro I, who fought against regional independences processes, and Duque de Caxias, who did the same
@@user-dk1fg5ct7s you're right. Seeing the question as a a matter of agency of individuals, Pedro I and Caxias are two heroes of the national integrity.
But there are others points of viewing. As exemple, economic and social ones (many historians sees the manutering of slavery as a cause of a "pact" of the elites for the conservation of the economical estrutures and avoid of slave revolts).
I was not expecting the bit of brazilian and portuguese history at the end! You clearly did your research
As a brazilian i can confirm that all of the brazilian parts were factual
@@emanuel585 é, eu reparei kkkk
Thanks! I spent a long time researching and writing the script
@@icebulb Amazing video! It would also be cool to have a video dedicated to the history of Dom Pedro II. He was a hyperpolyglot, educated in numerous subjects, was raised by José Bonifácio, patriach of Brazil, and Rafael, o Anjo Negro, an ex-slave. Under him, the royal family had no slaves as he despised it and banned slavery with his daugther he had plans to integrate the ex-slaves into Brazilian society, but the Republican coup exiled him to Portugal and forgot all plans about ex-slave integration.
I will add him to the list! Although I already have lots of ideas in the back-burner haha
I swear if the answer is “it’s basically napoleons fault” I’m gonna lose it
It's basically Napoleon's fault
Latinoamerican independence wars in a nutshell.
Haters gonna hate
If you paid attention to the video you will realize he's pretty much the most important figure in the 19th century. With the exception of the United States and Canada, the contemporary structure of all the countries in the American Continent is a direct result of his actions.
@@Krisliet bro I was clearly joking.
8:10 "Avoid 2029-2034" bro what are you planning
😂
@@Alberto2 My goals are beyond your understanding 👹
ww3
WW3 release date before gta6
wait, since covid started in 2019, does that mean we're getting a sequel outbreak in 2029? maybe a 10 year anniversary special?
As an Argentine and a lover of UA-cam informative vids, I must say this is the most accurate depiction of South American history, which is quite something, as this continent is usually forgotten in historical accounts, USA narrative tends to merge Mexico with all of South America, which isn't even in the same hemisphere!
@@engendroman thank you! It took a lot of time to research and to come up with a script so I'm glad its accurate haha
All Spanish America shares the same past
It doesn't matter about the hemisphere. Mexico and South America is part of Latinamerica
@@bilykralik885But has different culture and history
Or even on the same continent re: Mexico.
this dude is the oversimplified of countryballs
Exactly
And better
And far better
bro this actually good
With a decent sense of humor (compared to Oversimplified's newer videos)
BRAZIL MENTIONED
Não de una forma muito boa
@@tiosubaruomg achei que ele valorizou bem o Brasil, quase uma ode
@@tiosubaruomg Obvio que o assunto foi focado na américa espanhola, mas ele conseguiu explicar os motivos pelos os fatos explicados durante a história então o video em si foi ótimo.
Eu tenho um nojo dessa carência brasileira. Parecem aquelas crianças que nunca tiveram amigos, e só de ser citados não saem do pé.
@@micahbelliii3180 isso é consequência da baixa escolaridade e destruição do patriotismo depois de tantas coisas ruins que aconteceram nesse país. Devido a esses fatores, grande parte dos brasileiros valorizam mais os gringos do que ao seu próprio povo, e por isso ficam tão felizes quando são mencionados de forma positiva por eles.
An interesting thing that can be noticed is that whenever someone from another country mentions Brazil and talks about it, there are always Brazilians to come and watch and been a subscriber
📍 xique-xique Bahia
Claro po
Become*
Hue
@@nikolasmaduro157kkkkkkkkkkkkkk
Someone: mentions brazil in title
Brazilians: WHO SUMMONED ME?
@@ateteu_ legit 😂😂😂
Boa tarde meu nobre!
22:45 there is a very interesting historical fact here involving Brazil. During july and december 1822, Brazil occupied Upper Peru at the request of its governors, who feared an invasion by Bolívar's forces. Later, in 1825, the Empire of Brazil would occupy part of Bolivia, with the aim of dissuading Simón Bolívar from helping the United Provinces of the Río de la Plata during the Cisplatine War.
Brazil was the Portuguese royal family, Dom João VI moved the seat of the Portuguese government from Lisbon to Rio de Janeiro in 1808
Basically they had a strong man creating cohesion while Spain did not.
As it history @@treehugger3615
@@treehugger3615 it wasn't really about creating cohesion but more like all the viceroyalties had decent Governors for most of it's history, can't really compare the two
A channel with 4.5 subs producing this quality content is amazing to say the least. I am glad youtube algorithm showed me this.
Good work!
Glad you enjoyed it! Hopefully our community gets bigger in the near future☺️
@@icebulb bro can you do this type of videos for islamic world during 18th century or India from death of aurangzeb to independence
@@Cursedpeopleakajuice I've added to the list another suggestion about why didnt the arab states unify!
I ABSOLUTELY LOVED THIS VIDEO!!! It’s great to see latam history covered in detail and humor, greetings from Puerto Rico!
Love to see Puerto Ricans here! 😎
"Latam" 💀
@@TeSu-fs7mp it's an actual word
@@TeSu-fs7mp😂 Because i put money their a 2nd to 3rd generation immigrants 😂
What's Latam ?
as a brazilian, I really liked this video. Definitely underrated.
Thank you! 🇧🇷
I feel like a hipster who just stumbled across the next big history youtuber.
@@tysonplett3328 nominated for compliment of the year 🏆
Do you? This seems like a pretty established style of presentation
Best summary on the process of Latin American independence that I've seen on the English side of UA-cam.
@@zddxddyddw I've got cheat codes cause I'm Spanish myself
It’s not Latin America. Know the history!!!! South America/ Spanish America is the correct term . Want us to call United States and Canada GERMANIC America ??
@@lizsalazar7931cry more it's LATIN AMERICA ;)
@@efml1815 everyone is allowed to dream
@@efml1815no, it's Spanish or Ibero America
This channel is underrated
Amazing video! I'd love to see more content about Latin America. If I may suggest some topics, I think it would be really fun to see the War of the Triple Alliance, the War of the Pacific, the reign of Dom Pedro II and the Second French Intervention in Mexico. Keep up the great work regardless!
@@sibberianno6333 some of those are already on the list! 😏 The thing is that these videos take a long time to make. Wish I could crank them out faster
I absolutely love how accurately you pronounce the names in the video. Like, most of the time I'm watching these kind of videos, people tend to pronounce the names of locations and historical figures in a funny way, and I don't blame them as it's hard to pronounce a word from another language, but you are able to pronounce EVERY single foregin word PERFECTLY. Congrats!!! Really good and informative video as well!
I mean, they're not exactly foreign words for me hahaha so you could say I'm cheating a little bit
@@icebulb Wait I didn't know you were spanish too lol
This dude deserved More View
Great Video, +1 sub from Brazil
Thanks!
Vitor gasta o dinheiro e compra HOI4. Confia em mim. Você vai gostar
Honestly I didn't want this video to end
@@juliangheiler7646 There will be more to come, worry not!
crazy high quality video i was shocked to see only 2.5k subs
Thank you!
this is so underrated. 10/10
@@segundacontado_pixel thanks!
Fun fact, according to some records Dom Pedro l was having a terrible case of diarrhea on the sept 7th 1822, instead of the river like it's portraid, he was suffering in a bush close to that river, when he said that famous phrase.
@@petergohan I've read so many different accounts of that day that I dont even know whats real anymore haha
@@icebulb It is real, but he said that along the river, and then rushed to the bushes.
Highest quality video I’ve seen in a while. Basically perfect. Saludos de Chile
@@Agustin_R thank you!
Happy to see another upload from icebulb 💪
More to come! I'm glad you enjoyed it
pretty high quality vid mate love it
Glad you enjoyed it!
W video man, thanks for actually explaining history properly
You're welcome ;)
YOOO HE'S BACKKKK
I never left😎
This is one of the most cohesive videos I’ve seen on this subject in English and I love the way this was created!
@@chiefpanda7040 thank you!
Amazing work. sat through the entire 31 minutes extremely invested.
Thank you!
This is one of the best history channels I've ever seen
Best compliment I've ever received
Fk Spain and their claims that's why 😂
This was very funny, especially all the gags you threw in
Haha thanks, I try to make it entertaining as well as informative!
Fascinating video, man!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Damn, your videos are amazing! Oversimplified but in country balls.
That's right!
Country balls...
@@D9fjg did I say it wrong or smt?
DANG this was a really good video. Very interesting! Instant subscribe, cant wait for the future santa anna video!!!!!!!
@@GreenieGuest glad you enjoyed it! I can't wait to make it!
Excellent stuff, I gotta see more of your work!
@@chemiczny_bogdan3467 hopefully I can increase my posting frequency!
Loved this underrated video!!
@@duducereser3945 thank you!
EXCELLENT video!
I was able to learn some trivia cliffnotes here and there and if I need to learn learn I can just rewatch it again!! :D
@@n1hondude thank you! Glad my video was useful!
I LOVE your presentation, you sprinkled the style of Oversimplified, added countryballs and have your own unique and funny flavours too! I can see this channel getting millions of subs in the next year or so!
@@aayushagarwal2420 let's hope so! I'm glad you enjoyed it!
wow this was a great video!
Thank you so much!
Love this video!
Glad you enjoyed it!
i loved this so much! thank you for your time and how you do these funny and educational videos! Didn't get bored:)
That's awesome! Thank you so much!
I gotta say, this seems pretty high quality, keep it up
@@carljo002 will do!
This is a really good video!
Thank you!
this is amazing! brains4breakfast would be proud!
Thank you!
Loved that your channel showed up on my recomended! Subscribed!
Welcome aboard!
El mejor video acerca de este tema que he visto, buen resumen, buen humor. Saludos desde Ecuador.
¡Gracias! 🇪🇨
Didn’t realize you had 5K subs until the end of the video, excellent stuff!
@@R4de thank you!
Good vid!!!
@@tijn0236 thank you! ☺️
Amazing video! Perfectly explained
@@lucasargerich8736 thank you!
Great video
Thank you!
underrated, i subbed
@@reaprwap thank you!
Great video ❤
Glad you liked it!!
Amazing work! I watched it completely and it taught me many things I didnt know.
@@fernandomunozleon I'm glad you liked it!
Impressively quick, understandable and entertaining.
I'm glad you like it!
Nice job making this it's very good!
@@Writer-Two Thank you so much!
@@icebulb No problem
Good stuff, brother, well done! Subbed.
Much appreciated!
You must be one of those UA-camrs doing challenges where they start new channels to see whether or not they can be successful, great stuff, man!
@@UmUs This is my first channel hahaha. Glad you enjoyed the video!
I actually really liked this video, I'm subscribing ( also, the end cutscene was ominous )
Thanks for the sub! Haha yeah I went for an Avengers-esque end-scene
Amazing video, I'll sub
Thanks for the sub!
Great work!
Thanks!
25:08 The references, lol!
Great video, loved all the detail and gags on it, absolutely worth the wait.
@@cleitopson Thank you!!
I find it kind of ceazy that Rio was once an european capital
Yeah I got bamboozled too whilst doing the research
Fantanstic video 👍
Thank you!
Instant sub 🙌🏿 very well put together and informative, looking forward to everything to come
@@ebukaokoli7739 welcome aboard and thank you!
Good video man, keep it up
Thanks, will do!
I LOVE IT! This is like oversimplified. BUT ITS DIFFRENT! AND AWESOME! +1 SUB FROM POLAND!
Thanks for the sub! 🇵🇱
11:22 His name was Juan Bautista Cabral
very entertaining video, well done! u did a good job with the oversimplified style
@@exodoalcunhaabridordemares thanks!
Awesome video 👍
@@williampuckette5425 thanks!!
HES BACK
That's right😎
20:03 this was actually sad 😔
Absolutely love this content, very entertaining and well researched
@@fiornato6393 thank you so much!
Nice video!
@@benj.kerman609 thank you! I'm glad you liked it!
It’s really sad that those pairs of guys paradied in Paraguay without even the chance to roll a pair of die to gamble their way out.
He has returned
Stronger than ever
love how you blend in comedy like oversimplified I think you do it even better that Bruh when the portuguese king told his son to come back with him caught me off guard lol
@@tasow8915 I'm glad you enjoyed the video!
Super fun and educational video. I enjoyed every minute. Love from Brazil.
@@diegocamilo1122 I'm glad you enjoyed it!
A united spanish americas would've been a REALLY long chile: changed my mind
I'm on your side 😎
@@icebulb 🤝
Bro, im new around here, pretty cool channel
Welcome!
@@icebulb bro, thx for the great vid and the entertaining and informative content
Nice video, dude! Cheers from Chile.
Hey, thanks!
Very useful video
23:45 LOL!!!!!! Hi from Brazil 🇧🇷🇧🇷
There's a lot of Brazilians in the comments hahaha it seems like the algorithm is showing my video there, I love it 🇧🇷
This video was fire!
@@KingofDrama1 Thanks!!
This is the first video I saw from you and I love it.
@@barigamb thank you!
If Brazil is united and colossus, thank Napoleon Bonaparte. Portugal's royals ran away from the French Empire for refusing to trade with the UK, and transfered its capital from Lisbon to Rio de Janeiro in 1808, and in that same year Brazil became The Kingdom of Brazil, Portugal and Algarves.
King João, The Sixth returns to Portugal in 1821, and his son Pedro refuses to return and stays, getting Brazilian elite political support to become emperor, in exchange he proclaimed the independence of Brazil in 1822 through José Bonifácio, the one who wrote the letter of independence.
Great video! Never learned anything about the history of south america in school, nice to watch a well done video about it now
Glad you enjoyed it!
I gotta say this was excellently done. Even your pronunciations of Spanish names and places was spot on. Well done amigo!
Thank you very much!
Great video ♥️
Thank you!!
Epic
peak pronounciations on your part, 1 sub from brazil buddy
Thank you!
This was great, deserves more views
@@grantmarsh327 thank you!
This video reinvigorated my love for countryball documentaries. The highest calibre of such videos, from the humor to the transitions to the script, love every part of it. I was literally finding free time in my day just so I could keep watching your video.
First time watching your vids but got hooked so fast.
@@HamajiGotTalent this has to be one of the most flattering comments, thank you so much for your support!
Imma be honest: too lazy to watch it right. But one of the main and most important reasons, is that Brazil only really stopped being Portugal's "object" when it became a kingdom and an exile for the portuguese royal family. There were pretty much no universities here before that period, so the elites just sent their youth to Europe, and most of the ones that came back simply didn't have ideas of regional economical development. It took much long for Brazil to develop proper separate elites, which would compete enough to create political during the oligarchy era.
Yeah I mention that first half in the video!
I saw Brazil e vim mais rápido que pude.
Awesome video man! Keep it up :D
@@raffaelloalmache5774 thanks!!
BRO, IT IS SO GOOD, IT IS PERFECT
Took a long time to make 😅