Mo was a great singer in his own right. He could do falsetto almost as good as Barry, but he just felt that Barry and Robin were better singers than him and he never pushed himself forward.
@@susieq9801 Yes it's not that hard to write lyrics, but getting the melody to fit the song was Maurice's mastery. The guy was a musical genius and a great loss to the world.
Robins voice is so stunningly exotic and hypnotic it can split your heart into and make you feel as though a raging waterfall of tears and emotions is cascading over it.
What I liked about Robin's voice he could change his voice to sound different. Different pitches I think he probably had,,3 or 4 different sounds. You have to keep playing their music to know what I'm taking about. Actually all 3 could change their sound. But I love when Robin's voice sounded fragile 😅
I didn't see anything in the comments and hope I'm not overstepping but the performance was the song "For Whom The Bell Tolls" at a benefit for Children In Need
Yeah, big surprise by Robin, huh? I loved them all!! I remember songs and moments by them, when I was breaking up with my first boyfriend. They hold places in time for me!!! AND may I say, I just love your passion for music!!!
For me , it the best song from Beegees, ok, not the best, cause all are great, but, it is for sure my all time favourite. And Robin? God! This is a damn interpretation , this is "his song" ! God bless you all and a happy new year straight from Portugal 🇵🇹🙏🌟🎇
This is my favorite live version of this song and it is one of their best - which is saying alot. I love the way they transition their shared leads in this song and Robin is particularly awesome! This entire album is fantastic and full of 10s.
What a great video, For Whom The Bell Tolls is from their 1993 Size Isn’t Everything álbum. It’s a beautiful haunting song with Robin’s unique ethereal voice and Barry soothing beautiful vocals. Thank you for your great reaction. Another fantastic Robin lead is HEART LIKE MINE, so filled with longing. ❤❤❤
The contrasting voices really make this song whether alternating or sung together. Barry's is sad and soft sound about a lost love. Robin's is a powerful cry of anguish for someone lost to him forever..."a hole in my soul". You should listen to "I started a joke" live in Melbourne 1989 if you haven't done so. Robin was called by many critics and peers the best blue eyed soul voice of his generation. His vibrato was in inimitable and effortless. Another great Robin lead when still in his teens is "Black Diamond".
Great review, Sir ... Thank you. Please check out their version of "Will you still love me Tomorrow" .... They recorded that as a Tribute to Carole King. She said it was the best ever version recorded of the song. Their vocals on it are just stunning. Possibly their very best. You'll love it. You'll be amazed, i promise you ...... ♥️
They sing with such a gentle purity. With all the horrible over singing today, to actually hear voices respecting the lyrics...total joy. There's 2 other excellent versions of this song. The official clip and also the version that sing outside in New York. Brilliant. Another beautiful later song of theirs is I Could Not Love You More. There's a lovely official video but an even better one where it's just the 3 of them. Never go wrong with the lads.😢
Barry and Robin usually were singing the same part and they say that Maurice was the expert harmonizer. Perfect voices, perfect boys. Love Love Love. RIP Robin & Maurice.
These songs really showcases Robin's beautiful voice. I Can't See Nobody. When He's Gone. Mr Natural. My World. Also Michael Jackson and Barry Gibb have a song together. All In Your Name.
Love this song. They said in an interview that it was written about their brother Andy Gibb and Victoria Principle and their relationship and break up.
Thanks for this reaction, I definitely agreed with your comments. This live performance of the song 'For Whom the Bell Tolls' was epic. Robin really owned it. I have seen the music videos and had an equal appreciation of Barry's soft soothing voice then the contrast with Robin's more emotional soulful voice. I couldn't say which appealed to me more. Here Robin's voice seemed super charged with emotions .. magnificent 👏 Another hidden gem...It Doesn't Matter Much To Me'. There is a back and forth between Barry and Robin's vocals in that song. ua-cam.com/video/x9DaUzv4yi8/v-deo.html
Not just phenomenal songwriting but they all wrote hits for many other artists, including Olivia Newton John, Barbara Streisand, Dolly Parton and Kenny Rogers, Diana Ross, Leo Sayer, Frankie Valli,Dionne Warwick,Yvonne Elliman,Destiny Child,I attended a Bee Gees concert in Las Vegas in 1997 called One Night Only, they were phenomenal live, in a interview Barry and Robin mentioned they always considered themselves first and foremost songwriters before being vocalists, but obviously they were amazing musicians and vocalists, great reaction thanks 🙏
Children In Need is held once a year in November and it's on TV for around 7 hours raising money and profiles for a lot of the smaller charities around the UK. Dame Shirley Bassey actually took part with a rapper for this charity event live from The Royal Albert Hall, possibly about ten or so years ago
Love love this song....but as much as I hate to think it, it sounds to me like the vocals were taken from the studio recording. I don't understand why because they've sounded great together live in other venues. To add to your point about Robin's voice, there's something I can't define about it. It punches straight through to my soul every time unlike any other vocalist I can think of.
Love your analysis. I feel the same, their songs are rides. You are never sure where they are going. The lyrics are always meaningful, too. The fact that they write the songs, produce the songs and sing the songs is more than I can comprehend. ( because there are so many over 4 decades )
President Pat, your reaction was spot on! The look on your face when Robin came in with the chorus said it all. What you said about the emotion Robin evokes when he sings is well known among the masses. He sounds like he is crying with heartbreak when he sings. He has always said that he sings from the heart. And he does a great job doing so with his incredible vibrato. I have yet to hear anyone, past and present, that has a vibrato like Robin's. So glad that it is now your favorite Bee Gees song, as it is mine, too, along with Massachusetts. Listen to Massachusetts, if you haven't already. You can really hear his vibrato on that song, too.
This song was also done with a New York City production with a backdrop of the Twin Towers and it particularly hits the hearts. Aside I love to hear the songs that feature each of them. Have you done Mo's Man in the Middle yet?
This was an awesome song.. however another beautiful song sung by Barry (take the lead)in this album was 'Paying The Price Of Love ' was also fabulous 🎉❤..
As you are probably aware, the Bee Gees started their singing and song writing career in 1958 when they were young children. Their father had a band and was a drummer. Their mother was a dance hall singer. The boys ended up supporting their family with their music. I'm posting a link here for a performance they did in 1960 (the video title says it's from 1963, but I really think it's from 1960). I think this video gives good insight into how natural their talent was and how far they grew over the years. Hope you enjoy the video,. Bee Gees - Brian Henderson's "Bandstand" Australia 1963 -- ua-cam.com/video/EbsUj3oK1wU/v-deo.html
Next........my most favorite song, "TEARS" From the album ONE. This album was the first after Andy passed away and was dedicated to him. Then listen to BODYGUARD, lead on it by ROBIN.
Great reaction. Thanks. There are so many Bee Gees Treasures that Radio ignored bacause of the Disco stigma. You get a chance, check out some 90's tracks like, Secret Love, Happy Ever After, You Win Again etc.. They are more pop sounds, but great harmonies, arrangements, lyrics and that bold flavor of all the brothers great voices!
Hello,I'm so glad to have found your channel,I'm a great fan of the BeeGees esp.Robin..You' the right,there maybe a great number of good singers but it takes only a few to be great songwriter at the same time great singer and producer too...to add it up,they're brothers and dominated the charts for many decades...thank you again for loving the BeeGees.
I love them too I know what you are saying. I sure do miss them. Barry sings country music and i seen a video where he sang at the Grand Ole Opry. I thought you might like to know. But I miss all of them terribly. Thank goodness we can watch their videos.
![BEE GEES - For Whom The Bell Tolls / Live Royal Variety 1993 [REACTION!!!]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IenEtwHmIIo/mqdefault.jpg)
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Barry starts the song and then Robin jumps in like 'hold my beer, i got this'
🙄
100%
Robin had a unique ability to grab the listener by the guts and not let go. His chills per note ratio was unmatched.
Robins beautiful Vibrato voice will never be matched
I always say that Barry bakes the cake and then Robin comes in and puts the icing on the cake
Exactly. Nicely put. I agree 😊
Well said!!!
Robin's voice is hauntingly beautiful ❤️🎙👏👏👏
Mo is harmonizing with Robin in most of the song. He doesn’t get enough credit for how much he impacts the songs.
Mo was a great singer in his own right. He could do falsetto almost as good as Barry, but he just felt that Barry and Robin were better singers than him and he never pushed himself forward.
@@grahamleadbeatter5981 - Mo was a great singer too and by far THE musician and arranger of their songs.
@@susieq9801 Yes it's not that hard to write lyrics, but getting the melody to fit the song was Maurice's mastery. The guy was a musical genius and a great loss to the world.
@@grahamleadbeatter5981 - Amen! Never properly acknowledged and fans knew it.
This song is so awesomely beautiful. It make me cry when I heard Robins voice. This stole my heart ❤️
For Whom The Bell Tolls - one of my favourite Bee Gees songs.
Robin’s voice is unique! ❤
Oh my! I so respect your opinion. They are well beyond BEATLES ETC, Thank You for honoring them!!!
All three of these men have beautiful voices. RIP Mairice and Robin.
Robins voice is so stunningly exotic and hypnotic it can split your heart into and make you feel as though a raging waterfall of tears and emotions is cascading over it.
Gorgeous Robin!!❤
bee gees blue island live mtv
Just love love love Robins voice ❤
Robins voice is haunting but beautiful. ❤❤
That exactly what I said - hauntingly beautiful! ♥️
Yes Barry is beter
Robin’s voice grabs at your ❤❤ heart and soul…wonderful!!
Alone😊
Yes! Such a good song.
What I liked about Robin's voice he could change his voice to sound different. Different pitches I think he probably had,,3 or 4 different sounds. You have to keep playing their music to know what I'm taking about. Actually all 3 could change their sound. But I love when Robin's voice sounded fragile 😅
Robins voice is so under rated. Hes amazing. They all are .❤❤❤
They are absolutely the greatest group of all time !
Damn straight they are.
I totally agree with you about Robin's voice.
Robin's voice wasn't always featured but when it was, it was incredible
I LOVE the Bee Gees! And I love your reactions to them. I'm a new fan of your platform! But I gotta say, Robin is my favorite!
Individually they were brilliant, together they were perfection ❤❤❤
I didn't see anything in the comments and hope I'm not overstepping but the performance was the song "For Whom The Bell Tolls" at a benefit for Children In Need
*Robin sharing the lead turned a song into a masterpiece with his Vibrato*
Barry was on first lead, so he was sharing the lead with Robin.
Agree 100%. This song, along with Massachusetts, are my favorites. Both are masterpieces. Robin's vibrato is the best, hands down!
Yeah, big surprise by Robin, huh? I loved them all!! I remember songs and moments by them, when I was breaking up with my first boyfriend. They hold places in time for me!!! AND may I say, I just love your passion for music!!!
Thank you for reviewing this song. I agree- Robin's voice so beautiful! Yes this is art!❤❤❤
Great analysis. You would love Robins lead in Don't Fall in love with me
Robin Gibb arrasó con su maravillosa voz fronteras en las décadas de los 80, y 90,
Please react to 'Wedding Day'.... my favorite by the BeeGees.... Thanks for your reaction!
Iamarobinfan
President Pat, you ought to listen to Robin Gibb taking lead in their hit Bodyguard, fabulous sensual R&B tune..❤
VERY GOOD!! REACT MADDLEY BEE GEES LIVE MELBORE 1989...
For me , it the best song from Beegees, ok, not the best, cause all are great, but, it is for sure my all time favourite.
And Robin?
God!
This is a damn interpretation , this is "his song" !
God bless you all and a happy new year straight from Portugal 🇵🇹🙏🌟🎇
This is my favorite live version of this song and it is one of their best - which is saying alot. I love the way they transition their shared leads in this song and Robin is particularly awesome! This entire album is fantastic and full of 10s.
It's not actually live. The live version they did is great as well though.
What a great video, For Whom The Bell Tolls is from their 1993 Size Isn’t Everything álbum. It’s a beautiful haunting song with Robin’s unique ethereal voice and Barry soothing beautiful vocals. Thank you for your great reaction. Another fantastic Robin lead is HEART LIKE MINE, so filled with longing. ❤❤❤
The contrasting voices really make this song whether alternating or sung together. Barry's is sad and soft sound about a lost love. Robin's is a powerful cry of anguish for someone lost to him forever..."a hole in my soul". You should listen to "I started a joke" live in Melbourne 1989 if you haven't done so. Robin was called by many critics and peers the best blue eyed soul voice of his generation. His vibrato was in inimitable and effortless. Another great Robin lead when still in his teens is "Black Diamond".
I totally agree with you. Robin's voice is so soulful!
Great review, Sir ... Thank you. Please check out their version of "Will you still love me Tomorrow" .... They recorded that as a Tribute to Carole King. She said it was the best ever version recorded of the song. Their vocals on it are just stunning. Possibly their very best. You'll love it. You'll be amazed, i promise you ...... ♥️
They sing with such a gentle purity. With all the horrible over singing today, to actually hear voices respecting the lyrics...total joy. There's 2 other excellent versions of this song. The official clip and also the version that sing outside in New York. Brilliant. Another beautiful later song of theirs is I Could Not Love You More. There's a lovely official video but an even better one where it's just the 3 of them. Never go wrong with the lads.😢
Love the video you're referring to of I Could Not Love You More!🎶
Barry and Robin usually were singing the same part and they say that Maurice was the expert harmonizer. Perfect voices, perfect boys. Love Love Love. RIP Robin & Maurice.
Another tear jerker song with Robin in the lead is " I Will "
Barry & Robin share leads on I Will.🎼
Listen to Saved By The Bell - Robin Gibb solo hit from 1967. His voice is unbelievably beautiful
These songs really showcases Robin's beautiful voice.
I Can't See Nobody.
When He's Gone.
Mr Natural.
My World.
Also Michael Jackson and Barry Gibb have a song together. All In Your Name.
And of course I started a joke!
@@inekebaalman3320 - Especially in the 1989 Melbourne concert.
Michael and Barry have what??????
@@susieq9801yes. I've watched it many times.
@@awordfrompresidentpat1985Michael Jackson and Barry Gibb recorded a song together. They were great friends. It's called
All In Your Name.
Love this song. They said in an interview that it was written about their brother Andy Gibb and Victoria Principle and their relationship and break up.
Love this song. Number 1 material. Under appreciated.
Thanks for this reaction, I definitely agreed with your comments. This live performance of the song 'For Whom the Bell Tolls' was epic. Robin really owned it. I have seen the music videos and had an equal appreciation of Barry's soft soothing voice then the contrast with Robin's more emotional soulful voice. I couldn't say which appealed to me more. Here Robin's voice seemed super charged with emotions .. magnificent 👏
Another hidden gem...It Doesn't Matter Much To Me'. There is a back and forth between Barry and Robin's vocals in that song.
ua-cam.com/video/x9DaUzv4yi8/v-deo.html
This was not live but epic anyway😊
This is my go to reaction when I want to see and hear my Robin. Your reaction is also my favorite to this beautiful song.❤❤❤
I grandioso Robin !!! tiene una voz única !!!
This is one of their amazing songs that hit you, and you just throw your hands up and say, Thank you, Jesus!!!
Not just phenomenal songwriting but they all wrote hits for many other artists, including Olivia Newton John, Barbara Streisand, Dolly Parton and Kenny Rogers, Diana Ross, Leo Sayer, Frankie Valli,Dionne Warwick,Yvonne Elliman,Destiny Child,I attended a Bee Gees concert in Las Vegas in 1997 called One Night Only, they were phenomenal live, in a interview Barry and Robin mentioned they always considered themselves first and foremost songwriters before being vocalists, but obviously they were amazing musicians and vocalists, great reaction thanks 🙏
Children In Need is held once a year in November and it's on TV for around 7 hours raising money and profiles for a lot of the smaller charities around the UK. Dame Shirley Bassey actually took part with a rapper for this charity event live from The Royal Albert Hall, possibly about ten or so years ago
thank you for the explanation.
Our love is one of the best song they perform for Andy they start but Andy finished. It brings me to tears.
Love love this song....but as much as I hate to think it, it sounds to me like the vocals were taken from the studio recording. I don't understand why because they've sounded great together live in other venues. To add to your point about Robin's voice, there's something I can't define about it. It punches straight through to my soul every time unlike any other vocalist I can think of.
Love For whom the bell tolls. They all sound great. You might enjoy their Medley 1989 and 1974 both in Melbourne. ❤❤
BeeGees are freaking legends, nuff said
And they sounded as great if it was live or a studio recording.
Patrick you would love bodyguard. Robin sings lead and it is amazing.
My favourite Bee Gee song Robins voice❤️❤️
Love your analysis. I feel the same, their songs are rides. You are never sure where they are going. The lyrics are always meaningful, too. The fact that they write the songs, produce the songs and sing the songs is more than I can comprehend. ( because there are so many over 4 decades )
President Pat, your reaction was spot on! The look on your face when Robin came in with the chorus said it all. What you said about the emotion Robin evokes when he sings is well known among the masses. He sounds like he is crying with heartbreak when he sings. He has always said that he sings from the heart. And he does a great job doing so with his incredible vibrato. I have yet to hear anyone, past and present, that has a vibrato like Robin's. So glad that it is now your favorite Bee Gees song, as it is mine, too, along with Massachusetts. Listen to Massachusetts, if you haven't already. You can really hear his vibrato on that song, too.
Each brother are great singers. I love them all. Together they are truly amazing!! The best group ever!! Wonderful experience
Barry can hold that last note for about 15 secs.
This song was for Andy they were missing him so much. That's what I heard about the song .
How are you not above 100k subscribers. One of the thoughtful reactors in the game.
This song was also done with a New York City production with a backdrop of the Twin Towers and it particularly hits the hearts. Aside I love to hear the songs that feature each of them. Have you done Mo's Man in the Middle yet?
This was an awesome song.. however another beautiful song sung by Barry (take the lead)in this album was 'Paying The Price Of Love ' was also fabulous 🎉❤..
For Whom the Bell Tolls ❤❤❤
SHEER HEAVEN
Oh, my, my, my, Boys, always superb!
This song is so beautiful, yet so emotional 🥲. Brings me teary eyes every single time.
Love how you love their music
You should hear Andy gibb
This song 'To Whom The Bell Tolls ' in this new album 'Children In Need ' was awesome ❤🎉
The correct album of this song should be 'Size' in the year 1993 instead of 'Children in Need ' ....sorry 😅
Very powerful song.
absolutely love this so so much - it is a ripper of a song
As you are probably aware, the Bee Gees started their singing and song writing career in 1958 when they were young children. Their father had a band and was a drummer. Their mother was a dance hall singer. The boys ended up supporting their family with their music. I'm posting a link here for a performance they did in 1960 (the video title says it's from 1963, but I really think it's from 1960). I think this video gives good insight into how natural their talent was and how far they grew over the years. Hope you enjoy the video,.
Bee Gees - Brian Henderson's "Bandstand" Australia 1963 -- ua-cam.com/video/EbsUj3oK1wU/v-deo.html
1955 !
@@JamesBrown-pf8tf - 1955? The twins would have been 5 and Barry 8. Not doing much of note in 1955.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Amazing 🕺🥰👍
Thank you! Cheers!
I love this beautiful song.
I miss the Bee Gees.
Next........my most favorite song, "TEARS" From the album ONE. This album was the first after Andy passed away and was dedicated to him. Then listen to BODYGUARD, lead on it by ROBIN.
Check out Cryin Every Day and Don't Fall In Love
Thank you sir very much! Maybe you want do Alone. It’s a music video which was made by Barry after Robin passed away. 😢
Great reaction. Thanks. There are so many Bee Gees Treasures that Radio ignored bacause of the Disco stigma. You get a chance, check out some 90's tracks like, Secret Love, Happy Ever After, You Win Again etc.. They are more pop sounds, but great harmonies, arrangements, lyrics and that bold flavor of all the brothers great voices!
They always surprise the audience
Thank you for your reaction, The Bee Fees are the Best.
Yes they are!
Everything they did was fantastic... the three of them, together. They are so very much more than disco.
Might like checking out Daryl Hall (Live from Daryl's House) Really awesome
Have you done "One", this one soars too. A beautiful one.
Robin had a solo song named'Juliet'...🎉❤
Barry that voice gives me shivers i love it x♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
IT TOLLS FOR THEE
Thank you Patrick, this is my favorite too. Like you say it changes from day to day but for the day that's it.
Absolutely!😊
Suggestion----Fanny be tender with my love by Bee Gees
You need to watch the one when they are outside in New York overlooking the twin towers 😢👍🏻😁🏴
Hello,I'm so glad to have found your channel,I'm a great fan of the BeeGees esp.Robin..You' the right,there maybe a great number of good singers but it takes only a few to be great songwriter at the same time great singer and producer too...to add it up,they're brothers and dominated the charts for many decades...thank you again for loving the BeeGees.
That song is called For whom the bells toll.
I love them too I know what you are saying. I sure do miss them.
Barry sings country music and i seen a video where he sang at the Grand Ole Opry. I thought you might like to know. But I miss all of them terribly. Thank goodness we can watch their videos.