For real. Like I still thought about it a tiny bit but I was enjoying the scene too much to care. And then the horse fell out of the sky and so did everyone else and I was done for.
two things Rockstar messed up in this scene: 1. how they make Dutch such a smart guy throughout the game and doesn't see how it's not farfetched, what Arthur says. 2. When Arthur is ready to shoot, and doesn't do it when Micah shoots Susan... both are very strange, but Arthur not shooting is absolutely unreal, based on the whole game.
i dont agree with the first point as we seem Dutch is pretty much messed up in the head once he left John to die, but the second point is spot on, with how much Arthur hated Micah he would have 100% shot him when Micah shot Susan, hell he knows he was going to die from the TB so even if the other gang members shot him he still might as well have killed Micah
@@theaces3697 sure, but honestly, I thought after all they've been through, he'd side with Arthur.. he made enough good points to make him think about it.
well I don't really see that Rockstar tried to sell us Dutch as a "smart guy" quite on the contrary in fact. Since the first part of the game they show us that Dutch is just a con artist, an idiot, a snob which best asset is that he can read. The game is telling us every single mission that he's just an egomaniac with an intellectual complex. All his "plans" fail cause he's not capable of making any serious risk calculated planning. He just doesn't listen any of Hosea's quite smart advices because that would imply letting himself look as he's not in control and keep looking for the stupidest alternative that keeps the band together under his "leadership". Hell, there's even a camp event where Uncle tells him he's full of shit and we can see how Dutch panics and reacts violently cause he knows he's been spotted. All the Micah thing is just confirming what the game already has been telling us from the start; everyone in the camp hates Micah and avoids him like herpes, the only one in love with him is Dutch because Micah keeps kissing his ass all the game. Micah is the most intelligent one because he knows he doesn't have the charisma it takes to lead the gang to do stupid shit for him, but Dutch can. So by manipulating Dutch he indirectly manipulates the gang. In fact, to realize how much of an ignorant snob Dutch is we can go to all Angelo Bronte's interactions. Dutch is convinced he can outsmart him with fancy words and half assed rethoric, but Bronte tells his men that this man in front of him is not more than a hillbilly that smells like shit. Then Bronte proceeds to outsmart and manipulate Dutch into risking his men instead of his own. Bronte, a guy whose mother language is not even English. Then all the killing Bronte things happen and we can see Dutch is not a calm and collected guy, he is just an insecure, egoistic, pathetic old man obssesed with power and control that explodes when finds someone who can actually see through him.
Arthur holding his Desert Eagle in a 1:04 shot produces strong resemblance to Vladimir Lem from Max Payne 2, pointing his gun at Max in one of the graphic novel shots, dunno why, it's just the first thing that came to my mind
exactly, fitgirl cracks are not cracks exactly, they remove the steam DLLs from their games, and make the game run offline with some software they use (Idk about the name). And just use their own software to compress them insanely for us to run. So, none of the game files are missed.@@groyperfuhr4871
the insane compression is a bit annoying though. like for ex was installing fallout 4 the other day. sure, it had all DLC's but the install took like ~3 hours because the whole rip was compressed into ~30 something GB's. cyberpunk 2077 1.0 took a long ass time to install as well. but the consistency is excellent. been using fitgirl since back when far cry 5 came out. better than some other rippers where I've installed the game only to find out everything is in russian and I gotta memorize what the menu buttons say to actually get in game xD@@abhirupkundu2778
It's the one-two punch of seeing the fucking horse fall first then followed immediately after by everybody doing the goofy ass WAAAAAAAA scream as they plummet like a rock
I love how watching this I got so invested in the cutscene again and watched it playout even with the missing terrain that the end of the video caught me by surprise and I couldn't stop laughing lol.
imagine living in 1899, casually having a walk outside, taking in the nature around you, when an entire group of strangers together with their horses just casually fall from the sky like rain
It is here in the literal direct daylight that we're able to clearly see how incredibly reluctant Javier and Bill's faces and movements are to them pointing a gun at Arthur and John.
What is surprising to me is the clouds are actually rendered and not just a picture. Rendered clouds make sense for games where you fly around, but you basically would never see the difference if it were not for the glitch.
@@BrunoHartmann- "Oh Hell, Dutch those eddibles ain't shit" "Goddammit Arthur, have some god damn faith...Aaaaaah *starts falling through space and time*
I Disagree.. Downloading A Cracked Rdr2 Wouldn't Do This.. He's Obviously Using A Trainer to Send Them Up While He Was Starting The Cutscene. That's Why They Fall After It Ends..
Oh WOW!!!! That is very interesting thank you so much for letting me know!!!!!! I will be sure to UNSUBSCRIBE from Nestan and dislike ALL of his video now that I have heard this DEVASTATING information!!!@@xrickardoxgamer3282
Grimshaw was a wild card, and unpredictable is my thoughts. If he shot Arthur at that point, Dutch might have gotten emotional and realized Arthur was right. He had to wait for Dutch to make a call.
I actually cracked the game the first time I played it, and never had any issues. I took my sweet time and explored everything, EVERYTHING. Took me 2 months or so and I played for hours every single day. The best open world singleplayer game I have ever played in my life. So good in fact, that I bought it on steam afterwards because I felt bad for playing it for free. It was that good, and I never buy singleplayer games.
I did the same thing for Witcher 3. I had just got into being a PC gamer really, was a broke college kid mostly, pirated every game for the most part. Witcher 3 was so good I actually bought it. Then played it through the end again. Then when the first DLC came out, started over and played it again through the DLC. Then when the 2nd DLC came out, started over and did it again, through the end. Witcher 3 and Red Dead 2 are probably the only 2 games I feel sad when I beat them. When I comer to certain parts of the game, when you're totally into it, and its just a flood of immersion, like you're there, so into the game. No other games have done that to me.
@@bigmacdoubleyouv Aye, I've played Witcher 2 before, when I was trying out random games 3-4 years ago. One of the better singleplayer RPG games out there. I really enjoyed it.
good man. I never buy singleplayer games except for far cry (not anymore tho after how bad 6 was) and borderlands cause borderlands is only good with friends fighting for loot
did the same for RE:Village, I would give anything to experience that game again, i never had a PC growing up so this was the first time I got my mind blown by a game.
I've not played a resident evil game before, but a game or two you could try out to get some of the same vibe you got from RE:Village would be The Forest or Sons of the Forest. The story isn't nearly as fleshed out but it's damn scary and there's a lotta cool shit you can do/make in either game. Sons of the Forest is still in early access though so probably wanna start on the Forest. graphics are still good on the first game anyways, and the first game is scarier imo. @@sarcasmenul
Micah: "be quiet, you live in the clouds."
Arthur: "don't we all?"
This isnt arthur this is aiden
@@jason.vorheesaiden pierce 😂😂😂
@@npi57Arthur Pierce
AP:Haven't you heard? I'm the vigilante. I clean up mess like them, except Arthur, John, and Susan
oh yeah, i guess youre right...
AAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHGGG
It's a testament to the voice acting and character animation that I got so invested in the scene that I forgot they were in the sky for a bit there.
For real. Like I still thought about it a tiny bit but I was enjoying the scene too much to care. And then the horse fell out of the sky and so did everyone else and I was done for.
Honestly same… even felt invested in the cutscene even though I already played through the game
Me two actually 😂
@elliewilliams2362 yeah they fell out of the sky and everything! True talent right there folks ❤❤❤
@@Taima😂😂 the horse falling at first was like a wake up call
Props to the gang for literally floating in the air for the scene
LMAOOO
As micah said to arthur " You live in the clouds"
The afterlife
Alec Baldwins best scene
Flouting? They're all in heaven here, repeating all the story again
1:47 "Be quiet, you live in the clouds"
Quite literally 😂
Fr
This scene still hits soo hard even "in da clouds!" Gives me chills every time, it's so perfect nothing can ruin it!
Turns out cowpoke did in fact live in the clouds.
Heheheheh that was nice one
They were all in his house…
But you can’t fight gravity
@@PabloEdits20your right, they couldn’t and fell right to their deaths
Arthur: You ready john
AAAAAAAAQQQAAQQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
They could fight change, but they couldnt fight gravity
Underrated
Iconic
Some could say they couldn't fight change either, thats why they caught up in this fever dream😂
Fr 😂😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
2:31 that gunshot shocked Arthur's horse so much it fell from the heavens.
Someone shot the horse
Bro it falls so fast 💀
Lucifer lore:
Poor Beull.
God damn I didn't even notice. I'm crying at this video.
“You ready john?”
*switches off creative mode*
This is a much more dramatic background for this standoff.
The clouds and blue sky really highlight the tension between the characters.
2:36
Arthur: You ready John?
John: Yeah
Arthur: AHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA
Gravity got hem 😔
Me and the boys when we agreed to scream in bathroom
@@ConquestadorExplore why?
@@Louis13XIII yes
Honestly, this one got me hard.
Arthur casually pulls out a deagle
Lmaoo where’d he get that from
@@chrisv8341 god
@@imnotaracistokayaurthur was like:
Hello?God?
Yes my child?
Can I have a desert eagle?
It's 1899?
Please?
Ok just don't tell anybody
That shit had me crying 😂
@@chrisv8341Kristian3D
"you're in the clouds, cowpoke" quite literally
**“Be quiet cowpoke, you live in the clouds”
@@pringlepringle *"You're lying"*
Yes indeed lol and I’m your 999th like on this comment!! 😂😂🥳🥳🎉🎉😎😎💯💯🔥🔥
At least everyone suffered the same fate… except Miss Grimshaw, she escaped gravity.
two things Rockstar messed up in this scene:
1. how they make Dutch such a smart guy throughout the game and doesn't see how it's not farfetched, what Arthur says.
2. When Arthur is ready to shoot, and doesn't do it when Micah shoots Susan...
both are very strange, but Arthur not shooting is absolutely unreal, based on the whole game.
i dont agree with the first point as we seem Dutch is pretty much messed up in the head once he left John to die, but the second point is spot on, with how much Arthur hated Micah he would have 100% shot him when Micah shot Susan, hell he knows he was going to die from the TB so even if the other gang members shot him he still might as well have killed Micah
I love how your making a serious comment about details of a scene, but you commenting on a meme video
@@Gouda992 i know... i know... but it's not that far off about making conversation using the scene in the meme, tho...
@@theaces3697 sure, but honestly, I thought after all they've been through, he'd side with Arthur.. he made enough good points to make him think about it.
well I don't really see that Rockstar tried to sell us Dutch as a "smart guy" quite on the contrary in fact. Since the first part of the game they show us that Dutch is just a con artist, an idiot, a snob which best asset is that he can read. The game is telling us every single mission that he's just an egomaniac with an intellectual complex. All his "plans" fail cause he's not capable of making any serious risk calculated planning. He just doesn't listen any of Hosea's quite smart advices because that would imply letting himself look as he's not in control and keep looking for the stupidest alternative that keeps the band together under his "leadership". Hell, there's even a camp event where Uncle tells him he's full of shit and we can see how Dutch panics and reacts violently cause he knows he's been spotted. All the Micah thing is just confirming what the game already has been telling us from the start; everyone in the camp hates Micah and avoids him like herpes, the only one in love with him is Dutch because Micah keeps kissing his ass all the game. Micah is the most intelligent one because he knows he doesn't have the charisma it takes to lead the gang to do stupid shit for him, but Dutch can. So by manipulating Dutch he indirectly manipulates the gang. In fact, to realize how much of an ignorant snob Dutch is we can go to all Angelo Bronte's interactions. Dutch is convinced he can outsmart him with fancy words and half assed rethoric, but Bronte tells his men that this man in front of him is not more than a hillbilly that smells like shit. Then Bronte proceeds to outsmart and manipulate Dutch into risking his men instead of his own. Bronte, a guy whose mother language is not even English. Then all the killing Bronte things happen and we can see Dutch is not a calm and collected guy, he is just an insecure, egoistic, pathetic old man obssesed with power and control that explodes when finds someone who can actually see through him.
In the end... *They couldn't fight gravity*
"You live in the clouds" tho, this is just perfect
They could fight it. Just not forever.
Man I fucking died when they all started falling together💀💀
Hahahahaha
"And in the end..... I did"
2:36 caught me so fucking off guard with how everyone was falling and screaming, not just Arthur
Psychologist: "Arthur Pearce isn't real, he can't hurt you"
Arthur Pearce:
The collab goes hard
WOW, that’s a good one 😂
But he can only use 10% of his power with no electronics in this era
Lmfao exactly
Trust me, I have a cracked copy of RDR2 this don't happen
The scene was legitimately so good I got suckered in again, forgot they were floating and laughed my ass off when it went to gameplay
Arthur holding his Desert Eagle in a 1:04 shot produces strong resemblance to Vladimir Lem from Max Payne 2, pointing his gun at Max in one of the graphic novel shots, dunno why, it's just the first thing that came to my mind
Love how Arthur was not the only one who suffered a death.
Arthur just casually having a Deagle in 1899...
I thought I was the only one who noticed
@@ARMmemes I noticed too
Isn't that the joke?
@@matthewlo55 no lmao
its an m1899
"AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA" - Arthur Morgan, 1899
(Arthur deposits $10,000)
Dutch: WE NEEEEED MORE MONEY
1:48 Micha's least self aware line in the Cracked version of Rdr2
This is modded... not cracked
I'd say with this context he's quite literally right.
@@AlexandruCarjan no shit but that's the entire bit of the video
Fr
This entire video is before and after newton invented gravity
Cunk should check this out...
The entire video is more like "why you should only use fitgirl cracks when pirating games"
ily fitgirl
exactly, fitgirl cracks are not cracks exactly, they remove the steam DLLs from their games, and make the game run offline with some software they use (Idk about the name). And just use their own software to compress them insanely for us to run. So, none of the game files are missed.@@groyperfuhr4871
the insane compression is a bit annoying though. like for ex was installing fallout 4 the other day. sure, it had all DLC's but the install took like ~3 hours because the whole rip was compressed into ~30 something GB's. cyberpunk 2077 1.0 took a long ass time to install as well. but the consistency is excellent. been using fitgirl since back when far cry 5 came out. better than some other rippers where I've installed the game only to find out everything is in russian and I gotta memorize what the menu buttons say to actually get in game xD@@abhirupkundu2778
2:38 Will live on as one of the most comedic, satisfying endings to a UA-cam Video. Ever.
What a Masterpiece from absolutely nothing.
It's the one-two punch of seeing the fucking horse fall first then followed immediately after by everybody doing the goofy ass WAAAAAAAA scream as they plummet like a rock
2:37 ross: THIS IS AGENT ROSS WITH THE MINECRAFT ADMINS
“You ready John?”
The Deagle really looks good with Arthur's Aiden Pearce looking drip
Desert Eagle…
@@EUROCORP2027Deagle.. D-eagle..
@@EUROCORP2027potato tomato
@EUROCORP2027 there's a thing called slang yknow. Not illegal to have a shortcut
@@EUROCORP2027Esert Deagle
I like how there's a voice line for each character screaming whenever they fall, another detail to the list.
there isn't, characters other than arthur and john use a generic set
I love how watching this I got so invested in the cutscene again and watched it playout even with the missing terrain that the end of the video caught me by surprise and I couldn't stop laughing lol.
Shows true to RDR2's masterfullness XD
The sky is falling the sky is falling.
imagine living in 1899, casually having a walk outside, taking in the nature around you, when an entire group of strangers together with their horses just casually fall from the sky like rain
*”you ready John?”*
*STARTS FALLING TO THEIR DOOM*
😂
*Epic action scene starts*
Gravity: “Ight I’m back what I miss?”
Mr. Wick: "..YeaAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHH!!!"
MAY I STAND UNSHAKEN-
Arthur thinks he's aiden pearce 😂💀
Finally, someone notices it.
Had to scroll way too far
Was abt to say lol
🍐
😂😂
I laughed way too hard at watching the entire gang screaming while they fall from the sky
🤣🤣😂😂🤣🤣😂😂
I never thought they had voicelines for the gang members falling, since this never happens.
It is here in the literal direct daylight that we're able to clearly see how incredibly reluctant Javier and Bill's faces and movements are to them pointing a gun at Arthur and John.
Cutscene so intense I forgot that they were in the sky lol.
This puts “you live in the clouds black lung” to a whole nother damn level
They're all in heaven
Why micah in heaven?
@@Lerd1 he's gonna fly straight to hell after this
@@r3dst0rm308 exactly
I laughed harder than I should’ve when they all started falling and screaming
pinketons: "PUT YOUR GUNS DOWN"
horse: *falls to their inevitable death*
Turned into a bloody battle royale real quick
Arthur in Aiden Pierce's outfit actually makes him look badass
In all honesty, I could see Arthur soloing with a Desert Eagle…
Neutral ending: Arthur and John died, but so did the ones who betrayed them + the whole pinkerton agency
The synchronised screaming was absolutely hilarious xD
Dutch: "You can't fight gravity, John."
Van Der Linde Gang: "Sure, bitch".
this felt like as if they did it again but in heaven
And god said hell no
“You live in the clouds”
*everyone literally on the clouds*
😂😂😂😂
Micah :"you live in the clouds"
Arthur: So you are trespassing in my property?
And this how the gang fell apart... Like Literally.
You got scammed bro, my cracked version is working fine.
2:38 the clouds and falling camera is so realistic
Looks so much better than GTA V... can't wait what GTA VI will look like.
@@SuperGeronimo999Have seen leaks it seems they added volumetric clouds and fogs
What is surprising to me is the clouds are actually rendered and not just a picture. Rendered clouds make sense for games where you fly around, but you basically would never see the difference if it were not for the glitch.
Arthur looks so threatening with a desert eagle.
2:38
The moment when the brownies hit you and then the whole gang simultaneously
"Those edibles ain't shit..."
The gang whole 2 secs later:
@@BrunoHartmann- "Oh Hell, Dutch those eddibles ain't shit"
"Goddammit Arthur, have some god damn faith...Aaaaaah *starts falling through space and time*
The acting is still so good i kinda forgot they were floating in the sky til the end.
1:04 Clouds or not, that Desert Eagle looks mighty fine!
I guess Aiden took it to heart when he was called a 'middle aged cowboy in a trenchcoat' 😂
2:32 I fell to my knees when the horse fell😂
1:50
Micah: be quiet cowpoke you live in the clouds ☁️
Also all of them live in the clouds!
I legit was expecting dutch to start going "congratulations"
Yo this story telling is top notch. I completely forgot they were in the clouds until that horse fell at the end of the scene lmao. Scared tf outta me
Arthur looks like aiden from watch dogs tf
Nestan never disappoints us with his content.
I Disagree.. Downloading A Cracked Rdr2 Wouldn't Do This.. He's Obviously Using A Trainer to Send Them Up While He Was Starting The Cutscene. That's Why They Fall After It Ends..
Oh WOW!!!! That is very interesting thank you so much for letting me know!!!!!! I will be sure to UNSUBSCRIBE from Nestan and dislike ALL of his video now that I have heard this DEVASTATING information!!!@@xrickardoxgamer3282
Okay but arthur's outfit along with the desert eagle goes hard af
2:31 the horse dodging the bullets got me
"Snap back to reality, ope, there goes gravity"
You ready John? (fall guys theme plays)
Arthur dressed up like Aiden Pearce 💀
Yes, javier had pointed gun towards arthur and john.When pinkerton says " put your guns down" then just pause it.
so what
@@noinoino5396 so what?
@@pratiksathe14 so what if he pointed his gun
@@noinoino5396 my comment will eat your brain forever
"You ready John?"
John: "Aim for the bushes?!"
THERE GOES MY HERO.....
Best movie scene ever
@@leonardopaschiero8457 FACT!!!
There wasn’t even a shrub.
Good reference
The other guys, right?
This is what i pictured went down after john died in RDR 1 In gunslinger heaven.
1:48 yes they do live in the clouds
Arthur : If I fall, I'm taking everyone down with me.
Turned Arthur Morgan into Aiden Pearce for real!
They just up in heaven recreating their last encounter during their free time is all
Arthur drawing out a piece jumpscared me
May I stand unshaken Amid, amidst a crashing clound
Aurthur as Aiden is truly something else
Somehow Arthur pulling out a desert eagle threw me off more than them being high up in the sky. 😂😂😂
same bruh 💀
They all in heaven but their lust for revenge cast them back down to earth 😂😂😂
God is like "hell naw, you ain't bringing this beef to my house"
im surprised a voice like that was recorded for the game
Micah: casually shoots grimshaw,
Dutch: WHO IS B E T R A Y I N G ME?
One thing I've never quite understood is why Micah shot Ms Grimshaw instead of shooting Arthur right away
Grimshaw was a wild card, and unpredictable is my thoughts. If he shot Arthur at that point, Dutch might have gotten emotional and realized Arthur was right. He had to wait for Dutch to make a call.
I know this should be something funny because they are in heaven, the scene is still too good and one of the best
Dutch Gang finally reunites in the Afterlife somehow.
Arthur: "You're ready John?
*intessive falling*
Arthur with a Desert Eagle is awesome
its funny how Micah pulls out 2 revolvers while Arthur has a D50 Hand cannon
Rdr2, but everyone is in purgatory
that Pinkerton must have some massive lungs to shout that far up
Arthur ballin as Aiden Pearce lmao
Oh man, that ending was beautiful.
I love how he flips the board for cover and fails 😂😂😂😂
He used a really tall ladder.
I actually cracked the game the first time I played it, and never had any issues. I took my sweet time and explored everything, EVERYTHING. Took me 2 months or so and I played for hours every single day. The best open world singleplayer game I have ever played in my life. So good in fact, that I bought it on steam afterwards because I felt bad for playing it for free. It was that good, and I never buy singleplayer games.
I did the same thing for Witcher 3. I had just got into being a PC gamer really, was a broke college kid mostly, pirated every game for the most part. Witcher 3 was so good I actually bought it. Then played it through the end again. Then when the first DLC came out, started over and played it again through the DLC. Then when the 2nd DLC came out, started over and did it again, through the end. Witcher 3 and Red Dead 2 are probably the only 2 games I feel sad when I beat them. When I comer to certain parts of the game, when you're totally into it, and its just a flood of immersion, like you're there, so into the game. No other games have done that to me.
@@bigmacdoubleyouv Aye, I've played Witcher 2 before, when I was trying out random games 3-4 years ago. One of the better singleplayer RPG games out there. I really enjoyed it.
good man. I never buy singleplayer games except for far cry (not anymore tho after how bad 6 was) and borderlands cause borderlands is only good with friends fighting for loot
did the same for RE:Village, I would give anything to experience that game again, i never had a PC growing up so this was the first time I got my mind blown by a game.
I've not played a resident evil game before, but a game or two you could try out to get some of the same vibe you got from RE:Village would be The Forest or Sons of the Forest. The story isn't nearly as fleshed out but it's damn scary and there's a lotta cool shit you can do/make in either game. Sons of the Forest is still in early access though so probably wanna start on the Forest. graphics are still good on the first game anyways, and the first game is scarier imo. @@sarcasmenul
I completely forgot about the broken cutscene until they all started collectively falling
In choosing sides, they all had to take a big leap of faith
Arthur looks like Aiden Pearce lmao