I’ve been driving BMW and Audi all my life. I’ve always appreciated your reviews and I know you’re a fan of Porsche, but I had never driven one. Finally test drove a Macan GTS a few months ago and fell in love for all the reasons you mention in this video. I get it now. I have a loaded 2022 GTS arriving in a few months! Keep up the great work!
Re - maintenance. I have a 2015 Macan S bought new. I have just over 100,000 kms on it. Brakes are perfect. Feels like new. I have completed the scheduled maintenance for the brakes since new. Yes the full brake replacement (pads and rotors) will cost about $2000, but I still don't know when that will be needed. For comparison, I have had 10 new cars over many years prior to buying the Macan S, and have changed brakes pads and rotors twice by now. So you are essentially getting a better engineered product that lasts much longer, while paying more when you eventually need to replace and repair components on the car. Your choice. For me, I prefer driving a better product than paying less, but more frequent repairs and replacement.
Had 3 Macan Turbo’s over 40k Miles and absolutely loved them. Looks, dynamics, quality. Got distracted by AMG Merc and now in MY21 X3M40i which is a very impressive all rounder. Super smooth and punchy in-line 6, good handling, excellent cruiser but can be hustled in sports mode. Macan GTS is probably 9/10 versus X3 at 8/10 but here in the UK, in a normal (non-Covid market), BMW dealers have more inventory to move and once you’ve fallen foul of the Porsche options list, the X3M40i should end up as much cheaper, lease or purchase. If money is no object then the Macan GTS - no brainier. It feels special. If you’re budget constrained then X3M40i will not disappoint and you won’t feel short changed.
I drove a brand new x3 and felt like the steering was sloppy. Also the interior/dash felt like a car from 10 years ago. Definitely lacking for a brand new car.
just tried to get back into Macan GTS but "poverty" spec came in £15,000 over a new X3M40i fully loaded. With Porsche's much stronger residuals that closed the gap in PCP to +£10,000 deposit but gotta pay for my gas & electric too!
I'm 6 months into my ownership of a 2015 Macan Turbo and love this thing to pieces. People think the car is brand new its fast enough, handles amazing for what it is, and is the perfect small Suv size IMO. Don't think twice treat yourself to the Macan
Great review guys. I also tilted toward the Macan. Just the best all round package and unique, engaging driving experience. One quick mention for Zack.. stop interrupting Andrea 😆
I was waiting for my 2022 x3 M40i to arrive when you guys reviewed it month or so back. Finally got it in December and love every bit of it. Drive, tech and style - ( only complaint I ever had with bmw is seats are not the most comfortable). We lease our cars and have a 10 year relationship with our BMW dealership and we skipped the eye gouging prices at Porsche and Mercedes (one dealer offered me $900 a month with 5k down on a base GLC, I didn’t even answer and walked out and went right to my bmw guy)
If you don't mind, what was the sticker price of that GLC, and how much are you paying for the BMW lease? Just trying to get an idea of the lease deals available.
@@rajeshbhattacharjee2989 honestly I don’t remember exact amount. It was a basic build not a 43 or 63. Didn’t have heads up display that my M40i does or 3 year maintenance (btw Benz second service is $750) I wanna say it was late 40s to early 50s thousand. My M40i is around 80k with options I selected (custom ordered) I sold my leased 2018 3 series instead of returning the lease and got 7k for that which I just put towards the down payment. I also sold my 2018 leased Benz but kept that money. And I am around $690 a month for my M40i before I added tire insurance because the run flats can really hit you if you have more than 2. But again we lease about 5 BMWs from our guy and known them for 10+ years so I would take my deal with a grain of salt. I tested another bmw dealer with same built and I was quite far in price.
@@rajeshbhattacharjee2989 100% agree. Budget brand cars are straight up scamming people. I know someone who was looking into a Nissan Rouge (idk why) but she saw online price and at the dealership it was jacked up by 6 grand. I saw the breakdown and they added $1200 for tints the the dealership added and another $1500 for special coating on seat and exterior. No one can see the special coating and the guy couldn’t describe what it was, all he said was you can’t see it but it’s there. It’s a crazy market and 90% of the dealerships are scum bags.
Nice review. I got my first bmw as an X3 M40i back in 2020 and fell in love with the inline 6 and the power it can generate in Sports mode. As my love for beemer grew I now own an F90 aka 2022 M5 Comp. which took 8 months in the making and I couldn't be happier. I know performance wise Porsche edges out but bmw is big value for the bucks. Now thinking of trading in the M40i for a Macan S or GTS just for the experience
The problem with the base Macan is that by the time you add the options (that most people want) - you're knocking on the door of the Macan S's price. Later when you go to sell it, your nicely optioned base model will be having to compete on price with the stripped down "former dealership loaner car" base Macan's. Better to just get the S from the very beginning I think.
Thanks for the great review / comparison of these cars. I've owned four Porsches over the years and currently still have a Cayenne S and Cayman S. I am replacing the Cayenne S and initially just assumed I would get a Macan S, as I don't need as large a car with the lesser gas mileage at this time. A friend had me look at the BMW X3 M40i and I was impressed by the lesser price, better gas mileage, more standard safety features, B58 engine and more cargo capacity. Obviously BMW options are also better priced. But the real deal breaker is that I'm an Android / PC person and can't understand why all the newer Porsche vehicles, except for the Macan and Cayman are sans Android Auto - quite annoying. So I am planning on getter the M40i. I'll still have the Cayman S though.
This video was so great. Confirmed everything I was hoping. Waiting on my delivery of my GTS - supposed to be here in 4 weeks! I’ve seen you guys are long time Porsche owners - any advice on prepaid Porsche maintenance?
Love the review but i love my 2021 x3 m40i! Looks, interior and the cracks and pops is so much enjoying! The drive is superb! Base vs base, i would say porsche but when you have the m40i, it will be so much better than the macan. Plus you get more car! With that being said tho, maybe my next car will be a macan!
Dear both, I really appreciate specifics you cover and compare in all your reviews. Very informative and helps alot. I drive a new M40i which is loads on fun. But Macan in the list for next time around. Thanks again, keep up the great work 👍 One question from my end and when I was configuring my M40i, I noticed that the Canadian config let's me pick laser led headlights where as the US side doesn't. There were similar other stuff like seat color choices. For example, I can choose any color and add rear seat heating as well as ventilated front seats in CA build where as it forces Me to go for Black vernasca in the US. Any idea why so and would it be hassle to buy one from Canada and import to US in the future if it comes to it? Have you had any customers take such approach and has there been hassles that you know off outside of the import tax aspect ( like maintance support possibility in the US if made in canada etc)? Thanks again.. regards, Arun
I just crossed shop the M40i to the macan s. Similar optioned is a $20k difference. For slightly improved driving dynamics, I wasn’t buying a macan for the purpose of driving a more prestigious brand. These small compact SUV vehicles don’t have a presence to them where the value of the brand amplifies the ownership experience. That’s just my opinion.
I'm driving my first Porsche, previously I've had BMW and Mercedes. 2 things: Customer service and reliability. Mercedes treated me like I was a nuisance when I asked for simple things like a test drive. BMW will break down on you so much that the $20k difference will be eaten in repairs. We haven't even talked about depreciation either...
Porsche Macan and Cayenne is a different level then BMW, Mercedes, Audi etc you have to drive to believe… I personally drive a Porsche Cayenne (to please the wife ^^)
I have the x3m c and its 30k more than these cars and is amazing to say the least.its a beast,never drove a macan but did drive a 911 turbo s up to 310kmh and honestly honestly driving my x3m i dont miss the 911 at all, it is that good.
Value for money it has to be the M40i. The Macan has a too fussy centre console and as with other Porsche models, in order to spec your Porsche to a reasonable standard everything is at extra cost!
Enjoyed this video a lot - but the price comparison of similarly equipped cars was way way off. A Macan S configured similar to a X3 40i carries a price delta of $14K USD. I don't doubt the Macan is a better vehicle, but factor in that and the crazy maintenance costs for years 2 and 3 on the Macan and you have probably a $18K price delta. Ouch.
@@andreaspencer9813 I owned a 1987 944... It was white with the red interior. It was one of the assets I sold to start my business when I moved to Florida. I have no regrets about that decision but I still have curiosity about ownership of a Porsche Macan.
I’m late to video but I’m deciding between these two and my deal breaker with the Porsche is that I’ve been in a bmw with run flats for 10 years and I’m spoiled. The thought of being stranded with a flat tire is bummer . 😢
I hear you! I just swapped to non-runflats on my BMW M340i XDrive and it’s the first car I’ve had without runflats since 2007. The fix-a-flat kits like ResQ are getting so good I thought I’d give it a try. I really wanted to try Michelin Pilot Sport AS4’s and they don’t come as runflats yet.
Having driven both, I think I boils down to what's most important to you...the Porsche for performance, but I found the BMW much more comfortable and had a smother ride...I'll be keeping my X3 Xdrive30e for a bit longer....and will probably get an X5 45e next 😊...
Lmaoo Acura?? ☠️☠️☠️ Cut it out. Anyone with Porsche or bmw money isn't picking an Acura over either of these 2 cars, unless they're trying to save money but not because Acura is the better car.
Acura and Lexus are just rebadged economy cars. Premium cars maybe but definitely not stand alone luxury. Please dont bring the Germans down to mainstream level.
@@TheLaw_11 Does Audi share the same engiene? No. Does VW have Quatro? No. Do A6 and up share anything with VW? No. Does Q8 share the same platform with Lamborghini and Bentley? Yes. Do Lexus and Acura use the exact same engine, chasis, transmistion and AWD with cheap Toyotas and Hondas? Yes Why did you even compare AUDI to getto luxuries ?!
I’d go Macan S… but that black plastic below the front lights looks like blank button spaces inside cars when options aren’t ordered. (Do fog lights go there?)
Macan by a landslide. Only Porsche is able to develop a 15-year-old Q5 platform into a performance SUV, which remains class leading today. BMW might win when it comes to lease rates and monthly payment though.
The Macan is much more expensive than the X3 and a softer ride is really welcome in the rest of the real world where the roads are really rough. Yesterday here in the West Island of Montreal on the Sources overpass heading north from highway 20 several people blew their tires while some ruined their suspension, wheels and tires all because of some very bad pot holes. And Montreal isn't the exception...You can drive almost anywhere in the east from Canada to the US and these are the road conditions. If you want better handling then get a car...this business of trying to make SUVs feel like cars is not practical. I drove an 330i as a courtesy car for a day while my bimmer was in for regularly scheduled (free) maintenance and that car has sharp steering and a tighter suspension however in the cold when the suspension feels stiffer you feel every bump in the road. For a 4 cylinder Turbo that car is very peppy. I know a lot of people like the 340i for that great engine but honestly with al the traffic and the current price of a liter of gas, I prefer a smooth drive over a "spirited" one. If you need that extra excitement then wait until the end of winter and get yourself a proper summer sports car. And you don't have to break the bank to get one either. There are a lot of both new and used choices out there. Another interesting point too; my dealership is in Laval, QC one of Canada's largest BMW dealership and I had to show a vaccine passport to be allowed in because the passport now works by square footage. The dealership has almost NO inventory and doesn't expect any until April! In the used car department in the showroom they were showcasing used BMW M's, mostly "competition" and now these 2 year old low mileage high performance vehicles sell for more than when they were new! Yup it's gotten that bad! Once again you guys, your review was excellent and the production quality top notch. BTW - Some BMW models get 4 years free maintenance.
Good viewing for a Canucks hockey game intermission. Looks like you were puttering around UBC. I'd like to see these rigs driven hard. Then you really find the strengths and shortcomings of each vehicle. At least test the real world 0-100km/h and 1/4 mile times. Macan looks best, aside from the black wheels.
@@andreaspencer9813 Hey Andrea & Zack. Yes PLEASE do that GV70 comparison. That 3.5L TT engine along with that GORGEOUS interior, heat/cooled & massaging seats. I think its a winner vs the Macan. Thx for all of your content. You 2 vibe really well together. Behind every successful man stands a successful woman. Zach is lucky to have you in his corner. I should know as I'm EXTREMELY fortunate that my lovely wife hasn't sent me packing these past 27 yrs:-)
The Macan has better driving dynamics but the B58 & S58 engines available in the X3 are much better than the comparable Macan engines. Also, the interior of the BMW is better than that of the Macan, Imo. The price of the Porsché isn’t worth the premium price over the BMW.
For me it’s a deal breaker when expensive car like Porsche sacrifices safety for sake of reduction production costs by replacing all buttons with touch screens. You pay too much to sacrifice safety while getting distracted by the touch screen. Interesting that in almost every video you say you don’t like black shiny plastic, but in more expensive Porsche it seems to be OK) is it another black shiny plastic✨?)
BMW's don't age well. When they change their design every 4 years, present (and previous) models look instantly out of date when the new model arrives. The Macan has a more classic look that hasn't changed in 10 years. That's not to everybody's liking but it helps it age more gracefully and hold its value
The Macan is the clear winner as it provides excellent handling and steering feedback all while still having a comfortable ride. the BMW has no steering feel and has a very stiff ride and is just very boring to drive in general.
Macan.. all day, every day!!! Andrea knows!!!! Zack, You HAVE to get her, one.. Please!!!! lol Andrea, You obviously know they're "calipers" not "Calibers." Unless it was a play on words..
Yes unfortunately but after sitting in the passenger seat for a while it is still comfortable enough with the basic power adjustments. Chip shortages caused certain deletes.
My 2019 X3 m40i suspension was too stiff for daily driving. It would bounce if the concrete was the slightest bit uneven. Bumps delivered a harsh bang to the driver. I test drive a 2023 X3 M40i with the adjustable suspension. Stiff and stiffer is the best description. The dealer then told me to not even try the X3 M.
The BMW’s blocky back end looks frumpy to me so, all other things being equal, I’d buy the Porsche on looks alone. However, I don’t like the “slick and more modern” buttonless interior on the Porsche. I want lots of buttons to busy it up like a jet fighter.
Perhaps an unpopular opinion but I think the Macan facelift is a huge step backwards. It's disappointing to see Porche dive headfirst into the hideous trend of excessive black plastic trim everywhere. Can't wait for OEMs to move on to another design cue.
I take the car that is more spacious, has android auto and doesnt have that silly clock in the middle. I also prefer car to look like angry beaver rather than furious duck 😉
What's up with the BMW suspension? They use front struts on the X340i while Mercedes uses multilink on the GLC 43 Coupe and Porsche uses double wishbone; even the SQ5 has multlink all around. I like the BMW engine and transmission more, the B58 is definitively best in class. I also like the that it looks like an SUV and not a coupe SUV and doesn't compromise as much on interior spacing. But the Porsche feels so much more solid in handling and interior quality. Really disappointed on how much cheaper it is than an X5 because it addresses my complaints but I don't want something that huge. If I wanted something that huge I wouldn't even consider the X5 over something far more practical like a MDX Type S
I’ve been driving BMW and Audi all my life. I’ve always appreciated your reviews and I know you’re a fan of Porsche, but I had never driven one. Finally test drove a Macan GTS a few months ago and fell in love for all the reasons you mention in this video. I get it now. I have a loaded 2022 GTS arriving in a few months! Keep up the great work!
Wow, congratulations!
Wow, that is amazing, congratulations. You are going to have so much fun, the GTS is incredible. Now that you bought a Porsche, you'll never go back.
The B58 is a jewel and easy to tune, Porsche you pay the brand mainly
Was there a dealer markup for booking?
@@JohnSmith-me2wg No.
Re - maintenance. I have a 2015 Macan S bought new. I have just over 100,000 kms on it. Brakes are perfect. Feels like new. I have completed the scheduled maintenance for the brakes since new. Yes the full brake replacement (pads and rotors) will cost about $2000, but I still don't know when that will be needed. For comparison, I have had 10 new cars over many years prior to buying the Macan S, and have changed brakes pads and rotors twice by now. So you are essentially getting a better engineered product that lasts much longer, while paying more when you eventually need to replace and repair components on the car. Your choice. For me, I prefer driving a better product than paying less, but more frequent repairs and replacement.
Had 3 Macan Turbo’s over 40k Miles and absolutely loved them. Looks, dynamics, quality. Got distracted by AMG Merc and now in MY21 X3M40i which is a very impressive all rounder. Super smooth and punchy in-line 6, good handling, excellent cruiser but can be hustled in sports mode. Macan GTS is probably 9/10 versus X3 at 8/10 but here in the UK, in a normal (non-Covid market), BMW dealers have more inventory to move and once you’ve fallen foul of the Porsche options list, the X3M40i should end up as much cheaper, lease or purchase.
If money is no object then the Macan GTS - no brainier. It feels special. If you’re budget constrained then X3M40i will not disappoint and you won’t feel short changed.
good for you i hope one Day i can have porche macan
I drove a brand new x3 and felt like the steering was sloppy. Also the interior/dash felt like a car from 10 years ago. Definitely lacking for a brand new car.
just tried to get back into Macan GTS but "poverty" spec came in £15,000 over a new X3M40i fully loaded. With Porsche's much stronger residuals that closed the gap in PCP to +£10,000 deposit but gotta pay for my gas & electric too!
Are you chur you have 3 macan then give me 1 free
I'm 6 months into my ownership of a 2015 Macan Turbo and love this thing to pieces. People think the car is brand new its fast enough, handles amazing for what it is, and is the perfect small Suv size IMO. Don't think twice treat yourself to the Macan
Nice video. I just received my 2022 Macan GTS on Monday and I am having a blast with it!
Great review guys. I also tilted toward the Macan. Just the best all round package and unique, engaging driving experience. One quick mention for Zack.. stop interrupting Andrea 😆
I was waiting for my 2022 x3 M40i to arrive when you guys reviewed it month or so back. Finally got it in December and love every bit of it. Drive, tech and style - ( only complaint I ever had with bmw is seats are not the most comfortable). We lease our cars and have a 10 year relationship with our BMW dealership and we skipped the eye gouging prices at Porsche and Mercedes (one dealer offered me $900 a month with 5k down on a base GLC, I didn’t even answer and walked out and went right to my bmw guy)
If you don't mind, what was the sticker price of that GLC, and how much are you paying for the BMW lease? Just trying to get an idea of the lease deals available.
@@rajeshbhattacharjee2989 honestly I don’t remember exact amount. It was a basic build not a 43 or 63. Didn’t have heads up display that my M40i does or 3 year maintenance (btw Benz second service is $750) I wanna say it was late 40s to early 50s thousand. My M40i is around 80k with options I selected (custom ordered) I sold my leased 2018 3 series instead of returning the lease and got 7k for that which I just put towards the down payment. I also sold my 2018 leased Benz but kept that money. And I am around $690 a month for my M40i before I added tire insurance because the run flats can really hit you if you have more than 2. But again we lease about 5 BMWs from our guy and known them for 10+ years so I would take my deal with a grain of salt. I tested another bmw dealer with same built and I was quite far in price.
7k for 2018 was the difference after paying for the remaining equity on the car.
@@No_cap_yo thank you. $900/month lease is crazy for a 50k car
@@rajeshbhattacharjee2989 100% agree. Budget brand cars are straight up scamming people. I know someone who was looking into a Nissan Rouge (idk why) but she saw online price and at the dealership it was jacked up by 6 grand. I saw the breakdown and they added $1200 for tints the the dealership added and another $1500 for special coating on seat and exterior. No one can see the special coating and the guy couldn’t describe what it was, all he said was you can’t see it but it’s there. It’s a crazy market and 90% of the dealerships are scum bags.
Awesome video! Thanks guys for being so thorough. It was really useful. Love to have the base Macan as my next purchase.
Thank you so much, glad you enjoyed it!
It’s like you can read my mind! I was just comparing these two. Love you guys and your terrific reviews! The absolute best! 🙌
Awesome! Thank you!
Awe thank you so much!!
Nice review. I got my first bmw as an X3 M40i back in 2020 and fell in love with the inline 6 and the power it can generate in Sports mode. As my love for beemer grew I now own an F90 aka 2022 M5 Comp. which took 8 months in the making and I couldn't be happier. I know performance wise Porsche edges out but bmw is big value for the bucks. Now thinking of trading in the M40i for a Macan S or GTS just for the experience
Considering a new vehicle; these reviews are insightful. Thanks!
Great videos, you 2 (together) have really upped the content and entertainment value-Congratulations
Thank you so much, we appreciate the kind words and support.
Excellent reviews and comparisons. I'm looking at the Macan or BMX X5 and also the X3. I'm using your review of both cars. Great upload.
That Python green GTS Macan!
Drool!!
Gorgeous!
The Mamba Green is much better. Unfortunately, Porsche has discontinued it.
Great video Andrea! As I said before, this Porsche looks nice and interior is mix modern and futuristic design. Cheers! 👍🏻👍🏻
Thanks for watching, glad you enjoyed it, we appreciate the support.
@@andreaspencer9813 You are an very welcome Andrea! 👍🏻👍🏻
The problem with the base Macan is that by the time you add the options (that most people want) - you're knocking on the door of the Macan S's price. Later when you go to sell it, your nicely optioned base model will be having to compete on price with the stripped down "former dealership loaner car" base Macan's. Better to just get the S from the very beginning I think.
Well done! thanks you two make a great review team.....
M40i owner and very happy with the vehicle! Gotta love that B58 engine.
The inline 6 is pretty special! Enjoy!
Are you leasing it?
@@janoycresnova9156 No, I bought mine.
I prefer bmw for the price. I am not a fan of the center console of the macan, it’s overwhelming and not practical. Great comparison
Thanks for the great review / comparison of these cars. I've owned four Porsches over the years and currently still have a Cayenne S and Cayman S. I am replacing the Cayenne S and initially just assumed I would get a Macan S, as I don't need as large a car with the lesser gas mileage at this time. A friend had me look at the BMW X3 M40i and I was impressed by the lesser price, better gas mileage, more standard safety features, B58 engine and more cargo capacity. Obviously BMW options are also better priced. But the real deal breaker is that I'm an Android / PC person and can't understand why all the newer Porsche vehicles, except for the Macan and Cayman are sans Android Auto - quite annoying. So I am planning on getter the M40i. I'll still have the Cayman S though.
This video was so great. Confirmed everything I was hoping. Waiting on my delivery of my GTS - supposed to be here in 4 weeks! I’ve seen you guys are long time Porsche owners - any advice on prepaid Porsche maintenance?
We just pay as we go but it might be a deal, ask the service department what the typical service costs are?
Love the review but i love my 2021 x3 m40i! Looks, interior and the cracks and pops is so much enjoying! The drive is superb! Base vs base, i would say porsche but when you have the m40i, it will be so much better than the macan. Plus you get more car! With that being said tho, maybe my next car will be a macan!
Keep the M40i, the B58 engine goes over 100,000 miles w/out a glitch.
Thank you very much. Love both cars. One of them is going to be a retirement gift to myself!
Very interesting video !!! Also interesting to know about US vs CAN prices !!
Glad you liked it!
Thanks for watching, happy you enjoyed it!
Dear both, I really appreciate specifics you cover and compare in all your reviews. Very informative and helps alot. I drive a new M40i which is loads on fun. But Macan in the list for next time around. Thanks again, keep up the great work 👍 One question from my end and when I was configuring my M40i, I noticed that the Canadian config let's me pick laser led headlights where as the US side doesn't. There were similar other stuff like seat color choices. For example, I can choose any color and add rear seat heating as well as ventilated front seats in CA build where as it forces Me to go for Black vernasca in the US. Any idea why so and would it be hassle to buy one from Canada and import to US in the future if it comes to it? Have you had any customers take such approach and has there been hassles that you know off outside of the import tax aspect ( like maintance support possibility in the US if made in canada etc)? Thanks again..
regards, Arun
How about the Macan Sport compared to the X3 M50 2025?
Because the Macan is a Porsche unlike the BMW you don’t have to buy the M sport model/ trim and badge to say it’s sporty and fast!
Great detailed analysis, Thanks. YES Macan!
Glad you liked it!
what a nice review very detailed you earned a sub
Thanks for the sub, we really appreciate it! - Andrea
Love these X3 tail lights and the overall exterior and interior redesign. The Macan is certainly nice too but prefer an inline 6 vs V6.
Great comparison… looking frwd for x3 n Gv70
Thank you so much, glad you enjoyed it!
great comparison!
Thank you, so glad to hear you enjoyed it.
Adaptive cruise control is not even available on the base X3, you need to go with the 40i, for the money it should be included.
Ferrari, Lamborghini , Porshe are the the super car Dream brands . Benz , BMW , Lexus just every day upper Middle class cars .
I just crossed shop the M40i to the macan s. Similar optioned is a $20k difference. For slightly improved driving dynamics, I wasn’t buying a macan for the purpose of driving a more prestigious brand. These small compact SUV vehicles don’t have a presence to them where the value of the brand amplifies the ownership experience. That’s just my opinion.
I'm driving my first Porsche, previously I've had BMW and Mercedes. 2 things: Customer service and reliability. Mercedes treated me like I was a nuisance when I asked for simple things like a test drive. BMW will break down on you so much that the $20k difference will be eaten in repairs. We haven't even talked about depreciation either...
@@AhmedAli-the1st for the newer Bimmers you are unlikely to need any repairs until it hits 80,000KM/50,000miles.
Good comparison and good choice
Thank you so much! - Andrea
Porsche Macan is the natural evolution of the Volkswagon Golf R and Audi SQ5
BMW X3 M40i feels like designed to only fight Mercs
I just used 18 Macan gts to replace 18 golf r. X3 is good, but its stiff and needs air suspension as an option.
THANKS FOR THIS. I just ordered an X3 m40i here in mexico city. But i was thinking if i should´ve got the macan. Maybe should have done that.
Porsche Macan and Cayenne is a different level then BMW, Mercedes, Audi etc you have to drive to believe… I personally drive a Porsche Cayenne (to please the wife ^^)
When will the Macan S be available? No dealership has them
They have them now, spotted one at the Vancouver dealer.
Macan is the better car. X3 (own) is a SUV offering better value and space. You can’t lose with either, but having a family X3 is an easier choice.
Hi to you both,
Great review!
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@Motormouth... I did,
Keep up the greatness.
I have the x3m c and its 30k more than these cars and is amazing to say the least.its a beast,never drove a macan but did drive a 911 turbo s up to 310kmh and honestly honestly driving my x3m i dont miss the 911 at all, it is that good.
Value for money it has to be the M40i. The Macan has a too fussy centre console and as with other Porsche models, in order to spec your Porsche to a reasonable standard everything is at extra cost!
Enjoyed this video a lot - but the price comparison of similarly equipped cars was way way off. A Macan S configured similar to a X3 40i carries a price delta of $14K USD. I don't doubt the Macan is a better vehicle, but factor in that and the crazy maintenance costs for years 2 and 3 on the Macan and you have probably a $18K price delta. Ouch.
Not to mention it’s considerably less practical in cargo space and rear seat space and doesn’t get anywhere near the gas mileage of the X3.
Doesnt porshe consistently rank higher in reliability over bmw?
My wife and I are in the market for a luxury suv but we were planning on leasing. Curious to know what your thoughts are on lease vs buy?
I like leasing, we both say it's a great 3 or 4 year test drive.
what in the world is that spare tire in the Macan?
Macan ..even base model is an amazing car/suv/bragging chip.
I have owned 3 BMW's and love the brand, but would switch this time around.
We have owned many BMW's too but once we bought a Porsche it was hard to go back.
@@andreaspencer9813 I owned a 1987 944... It was white with the red interior. It was one of the assets I sold to start my business when I moved to Florida. I have no regrets about that decision but I still have curiosity about ownership of a Porsche Macan.
Hey can you do comparison between all base models of GLC Macan and Q5. I am planning to buy a car but confused. Thanks
i know i can never afford any of them but i love watching especially the Porsche stunning suv
Yes, definitely fun to watch!
So well done guys
I’m late to video but I’m deciding between these two and my deal breaker with the Porsche is that I’ve been in a bmw with run flats for 10 years and I’m spoiled. The thought of being stranded with a flat tire is bummer . 😢
I hear you! I just swapped to non-runflats on my BMW M340i XDrive and it’s the first car I’ve had without runflats since 2007. The fix-a-flat kits like ResQ are getting so good I thought I’d give it a try. I really wanted to try Michelin Pilot Sport AS4’s and they don’t come as runflats yet.
Dont know only got one flat in past 20 years that left me to call a tow truck. Took 15 min, and this is over 9000 ft in the mountains
Having driven both, I think I boils down to what's most important to you...the Porsche for performance, but I found the BMW much more comfortable and had a smother ride...I'll be keeping my X3 Xdrive30e for a bit longer....and will probably get an X5 45e next 😊...
Thank you for the details analysis. I propose a voting button..would be interesting to see which car/model gets the most no. of likes.
Love the both SUVs but macan is my choice how good is the macan offroad
In this segment my top pick would be the RDX. I can't wait until Acura brings the RDX Type S.
Lmaoo Acura?? ☠️☠️☠️ Cut it out. Anyone with Porsche or bmw money isn't picking an Acura over either of these 2 cars, unless they're trying to save money but not because Acura is the better car.
@@TheLaw_11 that's their problem. I don't care about the badge. I want the better car.
Acura and Lexus are just rebadged economy cars. Premium cars maybe but definitely not stand alone luxury. Please dont bring the Germans down to mainstream level.
@@kizo172 with that silly logic Audi is a rebadged economy car ( Volkswagen).
@@TheLaw_11 Does Audi share the same engiene? No. Does VW have Quatro? No. Do A6 and up share anything with VW? No. Does Q8 share the same platform with Lamborghini and Bentley? Yes. Do Lexus and Acura use the exact same engine, chasis, transmistion and AWD with cheap Toyotas and Hondas? Yes
Why did you even compare AUDI to getto luxuries ?!
Time stamps please
I’d go Macan S… but that black plastic below the front lights looks like blank button spaces inside cars when options aren’t ordered. (Do fog lights go there?)
That spot is open on S and GTS for more air flow.
Enjoy your content! What is your opinion about the Macan 14 way vs. 18-way seats?
14 way is good enough in my opinion.
Macan by a landslide. Only Porsche is able to develop a 15-year-old Q5 platform into a performance SUV, which remains class leading today. BMW might win when it comes to lease rates and monthly payment though.
They do have great lease rates which is why many keep going back for another BMW, lots of return customers.
Depends on your wallet 😀
Having driven both cars many times, I'd prefer Macan over X3 Ace comparison
Thank you so much, glad you enjoyed it!
I love my 2020 x3 but I did consider the mecan but bmw had better storage and head room.
The Macan is much more expensive than the X3 and a softer ride is really welcome in the rest of the real world where the roads are really rough. Yesterday here in the West Island of Montreal on the Sources overpass heading north from highway 20 several people blew their tires while some ruined their suspension, wheels and tires all because of some very bad pot holes. And Montreal isn't the exception...You can drive almost anywhere in the east from Canada to the US and these are the road conditions. If you want better handling then get a car...this business of trying to make SUVs feel like cars is not practical. I drove an 330i as a courtesy car for a day while my bimmer was in for regularly scheduled (free) maintenance and that car has sharp steering and a tighter suspension however in the cold when the suspension feels stiffer you feel every bump in the road. For a 4 cylinder Turbo that car is very peppy. I know a lot of people like the 340i for that great engine but honestly with al the traffic and the current price of a liter of gas, I prefer a smooth drive over a "spirited" one. If you need that extra excitement then wait until the end of winter and get yourself a proper summer sports car. And you don't have to break the bank to get one either. There are a lot of both new and used choices out there. Another interesting point too; my dealership is in Laval, QC one of Canada's largest BMW dealership and I had to show a vaccine passport to be allowed in because the passport now works by square footage. The dealership has almost NO inventory and doesn't expect any until April! In the used car department in the showroom they were showcasing used BMW M's, mostly "competition" and now these 2 year old low mileage high performance vehicles sell for more than when they were new! Yup it's gotten that bad! Once again you guys, your review was excellent and the production quality top notch. BTW - Some BMW models get 4 years free maintenance.
Vaccine passport? Hahaha
Excellent review!
Thank you very much!
Good viewing for a Canucks hockey game intermission. Looks like you were puttering around UBC. I'd like to see these rigs driven hard. Then you really find the strengths and shortcomings of each vehicle. At least test the real world 0-100km/h and 1/4 mile times. Macan looks best, aside from the black wheels.
By the way you know what's coming next... GV70 vs Macan!! Um, You guys didn't do that yet did you?
No, we haven't done that one yet, do you think we should?
@@andreaspencer9813 Hey Andrea & Zack. Yes PLEASE do that GV70 comparison. That 3.5L TT engine along with that GORGEOUS interior, heat/cooled & massaging seats. I think its a winner vs the Macan.
Thx for all of your content. You 2 vibe really well together. Behind every successful man stands a successful woman. Zach is lucky to have you in his corner. I should know as I'm EXTREMELY fortunate that my lovely wife hasn't sent me packing these past 27 yrs:-)
@@randahlbeach Thank you so much for the kind words, much appreciated.
Macan too beautiful 😍
Macan sure looks better
thanks for this, will get the M40 for 2 yr lease then will get the Macan S afterwards... will buy whatever I pick after driving both for 2 yrs each
The Macan has better driving dynamics but the B58 & S58 engines available in the X3 are much better than the comparable Macan engines. Also, the interior of the BMW is better than that of the Macan, Imo. The price of the Porsché isn’t worth the premium price over the BMW.
Porsche is a tier above BMW. No if, ands or buts about it. 💯 Fact
@@TheLaw_11 I didn’t ask
Porsche still doesn’t have a digital gauges cluster?
For me it’s a deal breaker when expensive car like Porsche sacrifices safety for sake of reduction production costs by replacing all buttons with touch screens. You pay too much to sacrifice safety while getting distracted by the touch screen. Interesting that in almost every video you say you don’t like black shiny plastic, but in more expensive Porsche it seems to be OK) is it another black shiny plastic✨?)
BMW's don't age well. When they change their design every 4 years, present (and previous) models look instantly out of date when the new model arrives. The Macan has a more classic look that hasn't changed in 10 years. That's not to everybody's liking but it helps it age more gracefully and hold its value
I have both
Why don't they just through the comfort seats in all bmw models?!
Great idea! 👌
M40i wins in my book .
Oh no, the rear of the X3 looks like a Subaru compromise hahaha
The Macan is the clear winner as it provides excellent handling and steering feedback all while still having a comfortable ride. the BMW has no steering feel and has a very stiff ride and is just very boring to drive in general.
Macan.. all day, every day!!! Andrea knows!!!! Zack, You HAVE to get her, one.. Please!!!! lol
Andrea, You obviously know they're "calipers" not "Calibers." Unless it was a play on words..
We already have two Porsches.
@@Motormouth... But not a Macan. I know you have the 911, and the Cayenne(to fit the boys).
No passenger lumbar support in x3. That’s a big issue
No passenger lumbar? Are you for real?
Yes unfortunately but after sitting in the passenger seat for a while it is still comfortable enough with the basic power adjustments. Chip shortages caused certain deletes.
My 2019 X3 m40i suspension was too stiff for daily driving. It would bounce if the concrete was the slightest bit uneven. Bumps delivered a harsh bang to the driver. I test drive a 2023 X3 M40i with the adjustable suspension. Stiff and stiffer is the best description. The dealer then told me to not even try the X3 M.
The key is to go with the smaller wheels. Then they ride quite well.
It's disappointing that Porsche isn't available with Android Auto.
dont like the new exterior for Macan although runs like a beast and resell well.
Only only guy in the world who doesn't like the rear lights.
The BMW’s blocky back end looks frumpy to me so, all other things being equal, I’d buy the Porsche on looks alone. However, I don’t like the “slick and more modern” buttonless interior on the Porsche. I want lots of buttons to busy it up like a jet fighter.
X3 👍
Perhaps an unpopular opinion but I think the Macan facelift is a huge step backwards. It's disappointing to see Porche dive headfirst into the hideous trend of excessive black plastic trim everywhere. Can't wait for OEMs to move on to another design cue.
As of now, the base Macan is 70,935 in CAN. Ridiculous from Porsche. But the base X3 is 56,700.
I take the car that is more spacious, has android auto and doesnt have that silly clock in the middle. I also prefer car to look like angry beaver rather than furious duck 😉
I didn’t know Madonna was reviewing cars.😅
Thanks guys I will take the X3
Thanks for watching!
It’s a close call between Macan S and X3 M40i. Value goes to BMW, resale goes to Macan. Both are great entertaining drives.
X3 is anyday better than macan, be it space and price wise!
Let’s see, $120 for X3 oil change at the dealership, and $400 for the macan. I’ll keep my X3 M40i, besides it eats Macans for lunch. ANYDAY.
Android auto terms and conditions don’t allow porche to use it.
What's up with the BMW suspension? They use front struts on the X340i while Mercedes uses multilink on the GLC 43 Coupe and Porsche uses double wishbone; even the SQ5 has multlink all around. I like the BMW engine and transmission more, the B58 is definitively best in class. I also like the that it looks like an SUV and not a coupe SUV and doesn't compromise as much on interior spacing. But the Porsche feels so much more solid in handling and interior quality. Really disappointed on how much cheaper it is than an X5 because it addresses my complaints but I don't want something that huge. If I wanted something that huge I wouldn't even consider the X5 over something far more practical like a MDX Type S
The x3 made in USA. It’s not Germany car.
Macan is small 😐
BMW backend ruins it
The front end of the X3 is ugly. The Macan is much better looking.