Dr. Chandra visited our lab at the University of Toronto in around 1987. My supervisor was in awe of him. A little digging into his publications indicated that he was the senior author of most of his scientific publications. I became suspicious. My first thought was the he was building his career on the backs of unfortunate graduate students: no professor would have the time to conduct that body of research. If my passing encounter with Dr. Chandra could have aroused my suspicions, I find it rather difficult to believe his associates at Memorial were blithely unaware of his fraud over such an extended period.
In german we have a saying. Sau Häfeli, Sau deckeli. This means translated Pig Bowl, Pig Lid. This saying describes this “Professor” perfectly and his surroundings. He only could keep lying, because his surroundings we’re doing the same. So it did not make difference. He must have pissed off his colleagues in a different way for them to turn on him.
Well done Marilyn, very courageous in the face of such a character! The University was clearly in the wrong both on a professional level as well as a moral one in not calling this Faker to account. For them to attempt to minimise the offences then try to call out the Journal that published the rubbished research shows the height of their hypocrisy. Dreadful man, won't call him a Doctor.
Brent Mcfadden unfortunately, people who blow the whistle rarely, if ever get the protection they need. I do hope Marilyn is ok and has not suffered adversely for speaking the truth and acting ethically. 🌲🌝☘️
@MissGuided Me No, I'm referring to this ridiculous "Human Earthling", who, with absolutely no experience in laboratory research, glibly tried to claim that awful scientific crimes like Chandra's are common. Those of us who spend our lives in science would no more do this than we would eat babies.
Marilyn and the VP of Memorial present a stark contrast in both morality and courage. Shame on Memorial administration for their complicity and for compromising the integrity of all university research. Bravo, Marilyn.
Greedy, egotistical and self-serving. Marilyn Harvey should be commended and paid tribute to her defense of academic integrity. Glad to see an ethics award was named after her.
Loss of Income was the reason the President of the University didn’t do anything. The President wouldn’t have published the study, however, he didn’t see any reason to get rid of Dr Chandra.
Chandra had to have pocketed the money given to him to conduct the studies which were not done. Would the Canadian tax authorities be net rested in collecting taxes on the income?
Would it be fair to say whereas on the one hand the university can claim it was afraid it might be sued for calling out Dr. Chandra, on the other it basked in the limelight of Dr. Chandra’s “distinguished success” as a scientist, even though they knew he was fraudulent? Wouldn’t the university have benefited from his achievement? To quote Shelley: “what a tangled web we weave when we practice to deceive.”
The University Vice President... that's why I'll never get a high and mighty title in our world; I'm not a bulls*t artist. I wish someone would do a study as to how many students feel ripped off after attending any university.
I wish someone would do a study on how many of us who are adjunct faculty in these universities and are getting low pay and working very long hours in order to subsidize these egoists feel ripped off after teaching in these universities.
The fraudster wanted to be called as "father of nutritional immunology" A jury trial in July, 2015, concluded that the allegations of fraud against Chandra were truthful, he was ordered to pay $1.6 million to cover CBC's legal fees, and he was later that year stripped of his membership in the Order of Canada. As of 2019, four of Chandra's research publications have been retracted.
I have come across numerous Indian businessmen and "academics" and their mad obsession with money is almost scary! In pursuit of wealth status and riches, all is fair!
Indain, Pakistani, British, American, African, Australian, New Zealander, Canadian and whatever nationality greedy people are greedy. I have lived in the US for for 45 years, traveled overseas and have met so many greedy callous shysters I've lost count but then again I have met so many "salt of the earth" kind charitable folks as well. So what does that tell ya?
Clint Allen this isn’t a racial issue. The doctor’s probity is in question. An audit of his IRBs would most likely prove that most if not all of his purported research never was conducted. Fraud in medical research is common.
Dr. Chandra: ( Indignant ) "What? You, as my employer, have irrefutable evidence that I fraudulently wrote and published studies that were never actually done? Wait, are you blind or something? Can't you see I'm not white? That means my skin color, as you well know, comes with the mandatory label of "under-privileged". Which makes accountability and consequences, once again as you well know, for my own bad behavior an act of bias < = racism? ) on your part?" ( 11:58 ) Memorial University of Newfoundland: ( Stammering And Stuttering About ) "Ahhh no! No we're ah, we're not blind, and ah, we now see the error in our ways Dr. Chandra. We also, after 30 seconds of deep contemplation and soul searching, want to extend to you our deepest apologies and let you know that it won't happen again Sir. Dr. Chandra: Good, see that it doesn't.
I do not think that the University or the research-sponsors would initiate charges against him, for obvious reasons. I would rather that the investigating journalist would ask him questions like - "Dr. Chandra, can you sleep peacefully at night?" and "Do you believe in God and retribution?". I would have loved to see his reactions to those questions instead.
How about we quit experimenting with our babies food and work on what causes allergies. We have become a reactive following country, instead of a proactive leader, sad.
I’m by no means a scientist but why isn’t there a slew of lawsuits by a number of entities such as colleagues, students, industry officials, etc., There seams to be lots of individuals standing on the sidelines.
+ Dos Guers +The socialist, attempting to falsely discredit corporate interests, while ignoring weaponized RACE Does the fault lie with the "delicate world" of academia,? Especially the University who ignored their ultimate role, in providing higher education?. The search for the truth, that society can then rely on, to make the most informed decisions on many issues, not just medical. If the public looses faith in what is produced by Universities, be it important research, or educated [or is it uneducated] students and graduates. Your willingness to blame the defrauded victim, of this charlatan and corrupt public/academic officials. Do you hold the babies, the elderly, or any other, potential physical victims, of these crimes, blameworthy, as well. Nestle' is the unwitting player here, according to this report, along with every other corp. that commissioned studies from this criminal con man, not to mention the public who have suffered financially, and possibly had poor health outcomes as a result. Seeing how you are BLIND to matters of responsibility, and/or guilt, YOU WILL NEVER EVEN ADDRESS THE REVERSE RACISM RESPONSIBLE FOR MUCH OF THE PROBLEM. I would bet $1,000, that academics, failed in their obligations to both REVIEW his NON-results, BEFORE PUBLICATION, & in their obligation to maintain skepticism in continuing to test, replicate, and compare results in the future. You earn the, $$$, a cool thou.U$ if you can prove that his RACE, and the fears of those in responsible, official positions at having motivations being questioned, even falsely, as it seems in this case, on racial grounds. Clearly his peers did not review his evidence, methods, and research results, as they should, for decades. His race as indicated by his last name, & unquestioned reputation, lead his peers to not scrutinize his results, for fear of the stigmas likely to be attributed to them, falsely. The dear DOCTOR threatened his own University with {knowingly FALSE} allegations, of racism, to avoid punishment, allowing him to continue to commit these crude, & cynical thefts. The fact that this "craven RACE BAITER" to use his RACE as a weapon, to defraud the public and steal their tax money. Cowards like you never face facts. $1,000 US in your pay-pal, or Paytreon,# with a verified independent 3rd party monitor, and payer if you accept my challenge. Reply Here, or on my channel. Yours, and KOut!
Back when The NY Times printed news and not the opinions of the ‘journalists’ ‘reporting’ the ‘news.’ Today, the way this story would be reported would depend upon the wokeness of Dr. Chandra
Since the Indian government has clamped down on corruption, counterfeiting, and tax evasion. The Indian economy has come to a grinding slow down? Gee, I wonder why? 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
thy should be both equal guilty and should be both indicted and should be In jail and this profiteer which you call doctor he work for those companies only to enrich himself only period
University ethics out the window. Too cowardly to do the right thing. That should be enough to reduce its student attendance and government funding. Seems a lot of universities these days are on the wrong side of ethics.
I remember a recall on nestle Baby formula I guess this is why they couldn’t give that stuff away they tried coupons in the mail for free formula. I’m sure some used it. This doctor should have lost his license over this.
Sounds also like doctor Chandler and just sat there got a paycheck and kept getting one nobody was checking anything to see if he was working and doing a job this is also staff problem as well both sides are wrong if he asked me you got to have good qualifications on a job to do a job nobody stopped and looked unbelievable truly man how do you think we feel unsafe where do you get these clowns I am in a porcelain store of course
So sad that you complain about him when GREED is the real PROBLEM and us every where and i am not surprised that you allowed commentary on this topic...
If he only did the right thing AND the right way He probably did the same thing to get through medical school or for all I know he's not even a legitimate medical doctor
This teaches us Ladies that “Breast Milk” is best. Let us breast feed our children this is the very reason ALMIGHTY GOD gave us free food for our children - breast milk. These type of people will do anything for money thus harming your newborn child.
You keep him in the university and you asking the why they published. The journalist is right they were depending on you why they have to read between the lines.
Dr. Chandra visited our lab at the University of Toronto in around 1987. My supervisor was in awe of him. A little digging into his publications indicated that he was the senior author of most of his scientific publications. I became suspicious. My first thought was the he was building his career on the backs of unfortunate graduate students: no professor would have the time to conduct that body of research. If my passing encounter with Dr. Chandra could have aroused my suspicions, I find it rather difficult to believe his associates at Memorial were blithely unaware of his fraud over such an extended period.
In german we have a saying. Sau Häfeli, Sau deckeli. This means translated Pig Bowl, Pig Lid. This saying describes this “Professor” perfectly and his surroundings. He only could keep lying, because his surroundings we’re doing the same. So it did not make
difference. He must have pissed off his colleagues in a different way for them to turn on him.
Well done Marilyn, very courageous in the face of such a character! The University was clearly in the wrong both on a professional level as well as a moral one in not calling this Faker to account. For them to attempt to minimise the offences then try to call out the Journal that published the rubbished research shows the height of their hypocrisy. Dreadful man, won't call him a Doctor.
Brent Mcfadden unfortunately, people who blow the whistle rarely, if ever get the protection they need. I do hope Marilyn is ok and has not suffered adversely for speaking the truth and acting ethically.
🌲🌝☘️
And once again the nurse is the only one with a moral code
#canadianhero #canadianheros
i would like to meet the nurse and give her a big hug and tell her thank you for standing up for us and our children ......god bless her!1!
what's even more horrendous is that this type of fraud is not uncommon....
--Says the guy who's never been in a research lab in his life.
@MissGuided Me No, I'm referring to this ridiculous "Human Earthling", who, with absolutely no experience in laboratory research, glibly tried to claim that awful scientific crimes like Chandra's are common. Those of us who spend our lives in science would no more do this than we would eat babies.
Shame on the university! They turned a blind eye so they’d still keep getting public funding 😳🤔🤨🙄
Marilyn and the VP of Memorial present a stark contrast in both morality and courage. Shame on Memorial administration for their complicity and for compromising the integrity of all university research. Bravo, Marilyn.
Greedy, egotistical and self-serving.
Marilyn Harvey should be commended and paid tribute to her defense of academic integrity. Glad to see an ethics award was named after her.
Shame on the university. Send that man on an ethics 101 course. Are other researchers at that university credible?
🌲🌝☘️
YOU'RE A GOOD PERSON MARILYN! PLEASE DO NOT DOUBT YOURSELF!! GOD BLESS!
🙏🌈🦄🕊
Marilyn is a hero, Chandra and the University president are not worthy to wash her socks
SJ Bobkins: I love that. She’s a precious soul. May God grant her peace and happiness.
Loss of Income was the reason the President of the University didn’t do anything. The President wouldn’t have published the study, however, he didn’t see any reason to get rid of Dr Chandra.
Wow, the university vice president's excuse regarding Dr. Chandra's firing/lawsuit, is so disingenuous. He doesn't have a leg to stand on.
He is smiling as if he has done something wonderful.
Fabricating research for a produce for infants/babies to ingest.
WOW!
A blind frame work!! Unbelievable this guy got away with such devious behaviour!
Absolutely shocked!
And look at that smile unreal....
My baby drank this milk, I had to take him to the Janeway every so many weeks for blood tests and examination. We should have been told .
Noreen O'Neill poor kid. Did that for nothing. I wouldn't want to do that, can't imagine baby going thru that
Noreen O'Neill my daughter as well. It was recommended to me because I was having trouble breastfeeding.
Both you ladies get an attorney adn sue the univesity, it's president, Vp, and "Dr. Chandra" maybe he is no doactor at all...just saying.
Bonnie Holman: I second that. Do it.
Hope they are protecting the Lady! Tis the tip of the iceberg! Be lots of this going on!
He didn't live in Australia in 1979 did he? My brother died at the hands of a Dr Chandra's negligence.
I wonder where Memorial is placed now on the Universities ratings guide. Doesn't bode well for scholarship and the custom of attracting new students.
One lie after another. No one you can trust. No damned body.
Chandra had to have pocketed the money given to him to conduct the studies which were not done. Would the Canadian tax authorities be net rested in collecting taxes on the income?
You'd think they'd jump on a thing like this but 🤷🏽♀️
That University should have its charter pulled.
Memorial University of Newfoundland should lose its accreditation for ITS OWN ethical violations.
Would it be fair to say whereas on the one hand the university can claim it was afraid it might be sued for calling out Dr. Chandra, on the other it basked in the limelight of Dr. Chandra’s “distinguished success” as a scientist, even though they knew he was fraudulent? Wouldn’t the university have benefited from his achievement? To quote Shelley: “what a tangled web we weave when we practice to deceive.”
Needs to have his license revoked, so unethical! He is deplorable!
The devil is a liar, that's the devil's bab.
The University Vice President... that's why I'll never get a high and mighty title in our world; I'm not a bulls*t artist. I wish someone would do a study as to how many students feel ripped off after attending any university.
I wish someone would do a study on how many of us who are adjunct faculty in these universities and are getting low pay and working very long hours in order to subsidize these egoists feel ripped off after teaching in these universities.
This is 2008 documentary. Google the guy - progress has thankfully been made.
The fraudster wanted to be called as "father of nutritional immunology"
A jury trial in July, 2015, concluded that the allegations of fraud against Chandra were truthful, he was ordered to pay $1.6 million to cover CBC's legal fees, and he was later that year stripped of his membership in the Order of Canada. As of 2019, four of Chandra's research publications have been retracted.
He'd be a perfect fit for the IPCC. He and phony "Nobel winner" Dr. Michael Mann would be a match made in heaven!
Why did university management also not get fired for coverup and complicity in a crime? After all they were not in the dark about what was going on.
Oh, yeah!...
Shame, Shame, Shame both Chandra & the University !!!!!
I have come across numerous Indian businessmen and "academics" and their mad obsession with money is almost scary! In pursuit of wealth status and riches, all is fair!
Indain, Pakistani, British, American, African, Australian, New Zealander, Canadian and whatever nationality greedy people are greedy. I have lived in the US for for 45 years, traveled overseas and have met so many greedy callous shysters I've lost count but then again I have met so many "salt of the earth" kind charitable folks as well. So what does that tell ya?
Would never become a national documentary in the States.
Hey, if you can’t write yourself a recommendation letter, who can you write one for?
As an indian I am ashamed of his act... Ban him completely
4:05 that moustache has a life by itself
BARRIOACTIVE
It's bigger than the dude's face
Just doesn't look right on his bone structure
I bet he would look 20 years younger without it
He was well shielded by "political correctness."
Kross N Kuss fraud is common place in medical research. Many entities were complicit in Chandra’s fraud.
Would you have said that if he was Caucasian?
Clint Allen this isn’t a racial issue. The doctor’s probity is in question. An audit of his IRBs would most likely prove that most if not all of his purported research never was conducted. Fraud in medical research is common.
@@clintallen4049 no he wouldn't have.
The man with the full mustache has the silkiest voice I’ve every heard
They'll never find Amrit L. Jain. I believe that Amrit is a Indian name, and Jain is probably from Jainism.
+Basil Williams I'm sure he never existed!
lol. it's not from Jainism as such. it's a surname in india. a very common one.
If he existed there would at the very least be University evidence...a degree?
@@bikinggal1 Even if it was bought
This guy is something else...
It is happening today as well. Companies buying reaschers and promote the product
How many Dr Chandra will be out there?
What a creep
Dr. Chandra: ( Indignant ) "What? You, as my employer, have irrefutable evidence that I fraudulently wrote and published studies that were never actually done? Wait, are you blind or something? Can't you see I'm not white? That means my skin color, as you well know, comes with the mandatory label of "under-privileged". Which makes accountability and consequences, once again as you well know, for my own bad behavior an act of bias < = racism? ) on your part?" ( 11:58 )
Memorial University of Newfoundland: ( Stammering And Stuttering About ) "Ahhh no! No we're ah, we're not blind, and ah, we now see the error in our ways Dr. Chandra. We also, after 30 seconds of deep contemplation and soul searching, want to extend to you our deepest apologies and let you know that it won't happen again Sir.
Dr. Chandra: Good, see that it doesn't.
so i am curious about Nestlè
This shows why you can trust Scientific work . Eventually anyway
In Hindu mythology, *Amrit* is God's nectar. Literally, *Amrit* translates into *immortal* or *without death*.
+Gibran Khan HAHAHAHA That explains why they think they are smarter than anybody else. And they are so unethical illogical turds.
"...The Jain religion teaches salvation by perfection through successive lives, and noninjury to living creatures, and is noted for its ascetics."
@@lesleyboulant4053 And...???
I do not think that the University or the research-sponsors would initiate charges against him, for obvious reasons. I would rather that the investigating journalist would ask him questions like - "Dr. Chandra, can you sleep peacefully at night?" and "Do you believe in God and retribution?". I would have loved to see his reactions to those questions instead.
The Memorial University of Newfoundland should be closed down, as it has lost its credibility.
Con man big time pure greed
Shame on you Mr Indian professor, Shame!!!
what has this to do with indian? there are such people in all places
@@me-uo2wp #FarmingtonUniversity
@@me-uo2wp True that
How about we quit experimenting with our babies food and work on what causes allergies. We have become a reactive following country, instead of a proactive leader, sad.
“She did what she could do””. Poor gal to have been involved so unknowingly. All that money gone!
This is back when CBC hadn't sold out. If you can't beat em, join em. Think "Safe and Effective"
I’m by no means a scientist but why isn’t there a slew of lawsuits by a number of entities such as colleagues, students, industry officials, etc.,
There seams to be lots of individuals standing on the sidelines.
You mean the President of the University did not want to lose his salary, so that’s why he did not fire Dr. Chandra.
So does Nestle feel any fallout for this fraud?
+ Dos Guers +The socialist, attempting to falsely discredit corporate interests, while ignoring weaponized RACE
Does the fault lie with the "delicate world" of academia,? Especially the University who ignored their ultimate role, in providing higher education?. The search for the truth, that society can then rely on, to make the most informed decisions on many issues, not just medical. If the public looses faith in what is produced by Universities, be it important research, or educated [or is it uneducated] students and graduates.
Your willingness to blame the defrauded victim, of this charlatan and corrupt public/academic officials. Do you hold the babies, the elderly, or any other, potential physical victims, of these crimes, blameworthy, as well. Nestle' is the unwitting player here, according to this report, along with every other corp. that commissioned studies from this criminal con man, not to mention the public who have suffered financially, and possibly had
poor health outcomes as a result.
Seeing how you are BLIND to matters of responsibility, and/or guilt, YOU WILL NEVER EVEN ADDRESS THE
REVERSE RACISM RESPONSIBLE FOR MUCH OF THE PROBLEM. I would bet $1,000, that academics, failed in
their obligations to both REVIEW his NON-results, BEFORE PUBLICATION, & in their obligation to maintain skepticism in continuing to test, replicate, and compare results in the future. You earn the, $$$, a cool thou.U$
if you can prove that his RACE, and the fears of those in responsible, official positions at having motivations being questioned, even falsely, as it seems in this case, on racial grounds. Clearly his peers did not review his evidence, methods, and research results, as they should, for decades. His race as indicated by his last name, &
unquestioned reputation, lead his peers to not scrutinize his results, for fear of the stigmas likely to be attributed to them, falsely. The dear DOCTOR threatened his own University with {knowingly FALSE} allegations, of racism, to avoid punishment, allowing him to continue to commit these crude, & cynical thefts. The fact that this "craven RACE BAITER" to use his RACE as a weapon, to defraud the public and steal their tax money. Cowards like you never face facts.
$1,000 US in your pay-pal, or Paytreon,# with a verified independent 3rd party monitor, and payer if you accept my challenge.
Reply Here, or on my channel. Yours, and KOut!
Kelly Owens what are you on about ? U nut
Kelly Owens Couldn't agree with you more and thank you for for explaining it in a way that I couldn't you nailed it perfectly.
Kelly Owens well said.
I don't buy any NESTLE products, that corporation has been known for fraudulent bad products even in Third world countries for over 60-70 years
Give he a break. He is still paying off his student loans
But if the studies were actually done, would the results be any different? Has that been confirmed?
If the University has done nothing wrong why fear a law suit. A bunch of culprits are being protected.
The Vitamin business is huge. Pay somebody enough money they'll fing the results.
Word on the strasse is that he writes studies for Dr. Oz
Back when The NY Times printed news and not the opinions of the ‘journalists’
‘reporting’ the ‘news.’
Today, the way this story would be reported would depend upon the wokeness of Dr. Chandra
Shouldn't he get arrested for fraud? This is serious fraud
"THERE IS NOTHING AGAINST Dr.CHANDRA..ITS JUST A HOAK AGAINST Dr.CHANRA..AFTER SO MANY YEARS NOBODY FINDS SO SOLID TO ACCUSE Dr.CHANDRA"
Well what happen Jail?
😱Dr Chandra I’m so ashamed of ur fraud on kids product pls don’t come to India shame on u
Since the Indian government has clamped down on corruption, counterfeiting, and tax evasion. The Indian economy has come to a grinding slow down? Gee, I wonder why? 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Nestle, right.
#FarmingtonUniversity
thy should be both equal guilty and should be both indicted and should be In jail and this profiteer which you call doctor he work for those companies only to enrich himself only period
University ethics out the window. Too cowardly to do the right thing. That should be enough to reduce its student attendance and government funding. Seems a lot of universities these days are on the wrong side of ethics.
OHHHHHH YEAH AND THEIR NOT EVER GOING TO SEE A PENNY OF THAT MONEY BECAUSE HE ALREADY SAID THAT THEY DIDNT PAY HIM ENOUGH MONEY FROM THE GATE.
Not shocked at all 🙄🙄
2:53 ... "averse", not "adverse"
Can someone just sum it up?
He made up the data and lied.
I think university authority did wrong too they saved dr Chandra
I remember a recall on nestle Baby formula I guess this is why they couldn’t give that stuff away they tried coupons in the mail for free formula. I’m sure some used it. This doctor should have lost his license over this.
learned of this in school...so very sad...edit: deleted
Sounds also like doctor Chandler and just sat there got a paycheck and kept getting one nobody was checking anything to see if he was working and doing a job this is also staff problem as well both sides are wrong if he asked me you got to have good qualifications on a job to do a job nobody stopped and looked unbelievable truly man how do you think we feel unsafe where do you get these clowns I am in a porcelain store of course
So sad that you complain about him when GREED is the real PROBLEM and us every where and i am not surprised that you allowed commentary on this topic...
WOW
Why the mindless bell behind the dialogue?
If he only did the right thing AND the right way
He probably did the same thing to get through medical school or for all I know he's not even a legitimate medical doctor
Good artists copy, great artists steal.
google "Chandra telescope"
Doctor Chandra or TheFraud Chandra?
Of course that punk is a fraud, he's a fokken gypsy!
Bogus expert from India?....of course lol
Nestle - hmmm. They have plenty of their own controversies.
This teaches us Ladies that “Breast Milk” is best. Let us breast feed our children this is the very reason ALMIGHTY GOD gave us free food for our children - breast milk.
These type of people will do anything for money thus harming your newborn child.
Seems like an odd place for major scientific research to occur.
BTW Chandra committed medical fraud in Canada lol
Zooescape I’m confused about ur comment. How’s it funny?
You keep him in the university and you asking the why they published. The journalist is right they were depending on you why they have to read between the lines.
Greedy over took him
Another Bikram Choudhury.
the cartel in the us congress you no the damded druge dealeres the demcrates the thive of american hospitales