Best Workstation GPUs 2018: Premiere, AutoCAD, VRay, Blender, & More
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 лис 2018
- The best GPUs for production tasks are up for analysis: We talk gaming vs. workstation cards (Quadro & WX vs. GTX/RTX), video editing, and more.
Ad: Buy Gigabyte's Z390 Master motherboard (geni.us/VGdZP on Newegg)
Article: www.gamersnexus.net/guides/33...
This GPU benchmark for workstation and gaming video cards pits Quadro vs. RTX / GTX, WX vs. RX, and draws conclusions as to the best solution for video editing, 3D modeling and rendering, AutoCAD, and beyond. We benchmark video cards in Adobe Premiere, Magix Vegas, AutoCAD, 3ds Max, Maya, Blender, Siemens NX, Redshift, Radeon Pro Render, V-Ray, Octane Render, Creo, SolidWorks, and Catia. This round-up is targeted for professional workstation PCs that need GPU acceleration solutions.
GPUs TESTED:
Titan Xp - (Amazon) geni.us/nqtv
RTX 2080 Ti - (Amazon) geni.us/FMUDZN
Quadro P6000 - (Amazon) geni.us/WrokY
GTX 1080 Ti - (Amazon) geni.us/6BsL7tG
Quadro P5000 - (Amazon) geni.us/z7tuV
Quadro P4000 - (Amazon) geni.us/73ExvCE
Quadro P2000 - (Amazon) geni.us/IxnF8jS
AMD RX Vega 64 - (Amazon) geni.us/JgdESt
AMD Radeon Pro WX 8200 - (Amazon) geni.us/rUolb
AMD Radeon RX 580 - (Amazon) geni.us/5gBBl
AMD Radeon Pro WX 7100 - (Amazon) geni.us/YxGj18
AMD Radeon Pro WX 5100 - (Amazon) geni.us/SM458
AMD Radeon Pro WX 4100 - (Amazon) geni.us/N0BzyAV
AMD Radeon Pro WX 3100 - (Amazon) geni.us/DRFuu
Grab GN merch on the store: store.gamersnexus.net/
Like our content? Please consider becoming our Patron to support us: / gamersnexus
Find Rob Williams here: / @techgage
** Please like, comment, and subscribe for more! **
Follow us in these locations for more gaming and hardware updates:
t: / gamersnexus
f: / gamersnexus
w: www.gamersnexus.net/
Testing, Editorial: Rob Williams
Video: Keegan Gallick
Production: Steve Burke
Links to Amazon and Newegg are typically monetized on our channel (affiliate links) and may return a commission of sales to us from the retailer. This is unrelated to the product manufacturer. Any advertisements or sponsorships are disclosed within the video ("this video is brought to you by") and above the fold in the description. We do not ever produce paid content or "sponsored content" (meaning that the content is our idea and is not funded externally aside from whatever ad placement is in the beginning) and we do not ever charge manufacturers for coverage. - Ігри
![Lp. Последняя Реальность #97 ЧЁРНАЯ МАТЕРИЯ [Анти Скинт] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/k4MjXCzKsYw/mqdefault.jpg)
Article with quick reference charts and links to products (additional links above): www.gamersnexus.net/guides/3399-best-workstation-gpus-2018-for-adobe-premiere-autocad-vray-and-more
Watch our Best CPUs of 2018 video before Black Friday: ua-cam.com/video/TCxjhEMGNZE/v-deo.html
Watch our Best Cases of 2018 video: ua-cam.com/video/U2RkwBXaYQA/v-deo.html
Find more of Rob here: ua-cam.com/channels/-Rm-fVvpu3-aSTwG96RmTQ.html
nice! Thanks, Rob for dropping by for a vid. B)
Did you had HBCC on the Vega and WX?
AutoCAD logo is out dated for the past few years
How come no Titan V?
The second graph is wrong. He's says the rx580 beats the wx7100 because it is above on the chart but the result for the wx7100 is actually higher XD
This content is very helpful, as gaming performance is easy to find, yet data for professionals and freelancers is scarce and often difficult to parse. I'd love to see more content targeted towards artists and workstation users to bolster the library of content on the channel.
Ditto.
hesrightyouknow.jpg
If you are looking for sources Puget Systems has a lot of testing on their site.
agree.
This metric set is extremely useful for even hobbyist;
more than often even when trying to ask pro-user of those application, the answers are always so vague they might as well not answer it.
Luke Canniff I totally agree with you. I would really like to see these type of benchmarks expanded to include 3D modeling apps such as Rhino3d. There is a benchmark plugin (holomark) available for the v5 version.
2:14 Autodesk 3ds Max
2:57 Autodesk Maya
3:46 Dassault Systemes CATIA
4:34 Dassault Systemes SolidWorks
5:10 Siemens NX
6:09 PTC Creo
6:57 Autodesk AutoCAD 2016 3840x2160 Cadalyst
8:00 Blender 2.79b Cycles Render Time
8:47 AMD Radeon ProRender 2.3.379
9:46 Redshift 2.6.22
10:35 Chaos Group V-Ray 4.02.05
11:27 OctaneBench 3.08
12:15 Adobe Premiere Pro CC 2019 AVC H.264
12:50 MAGIX Vegas Pro 16
YOU are the MVP. Thanks.
That was one hell of a round of chart simulator
+
I didn't think I was going to enjoy this (only because I don't do any kind of workstation tasks) but this was so interesting.
Yeah, I've never seen such an unpredictable batch of results.
Oh wow a different host this time. Nice to see GN experimenting with other hosts than Steve or Buildzoid
Yeah buildzoid has a very grating voice and needs a script
i would like to see some information about these benchmarks next time, i have no idea what are the most used for
@@ADR69 i'm pretty sure this dude is reading from a script too.
BZ does a great job imo
This video is like oasis for content creators amongst gaming benchmarks and rewievs. Thank you guys =)!
Damn this man knows his Render engines. Would be cool to see UE4 and Unity benchmarks. I might make a test map to compare my 1080ti with the 2080ti when I get it.
Pretty sure GTX/RTX would run circles around Quadros there.
Thank you Rob, very cool!
This video is perfect. I actually need a 4k$ workstation for 3D rendering but I don't know what to look for. Thanks!
Now you do! We have a lot of 3D rendering applications in this one.
I built a $3500 3D workstation :p took me a long time to save up, can't wait for NVidia official RTX SDK.
This doesn’t affect me but what are the benchmarks for 2 RTX 580s? There’s plenty of people out there that would love budget access to faster workstation related tasks. Considering how cheap these cards can be had on the secondary market. I think including some dual “mid range” card setups would be very meaningful to a lot of people. Anyone that is watching this video is look to spend there money wisely. Anyone who isn’t is just going to buy the most expensive card anyways.
@@TH3M3RC Do you mean rx 580 or am I missing something fron Nvidia? (obvs I'm jk)
luca_palo I type RTX so much it auto corrected 😂
YES! Thanks so much for this. Absolutely amazing level of quality here - I frickin love GN! You've helped tremendously in my efforts to build the ultimate WS in 2018! I'll head over to Patreon soon!
Thank you for this, there is a shocking lack of proper benchmarks using CAD programs.
Hundreds of UA-camrs benchmarking the same few games gets old.
After wading through all the gaming benchmarks, I finally get to some content that matters. Thank you.
Please keep up the great workstation content. This is one of the most informative videos I've found on gpu's for cad and rendering.
Well presented analyses. Rob's narrative has great flow. Even though I will never require a render workstation, I thoroughly enjoyed this content. Great change up.
My company has just bought new AutoCAD workstations with 1080tis, glad to see the choice to switch from Quadro seems to be justified here. Don't see many benchmarks for professionals, thank you GN and Rob for the vid!
great comparisons and very useful! thank you so much for taking the time. That was lots of work you put in!
I really enjoyed watching this despite not currently being in need of a heavy duty workstation GPU it's nice to finally see a tech channel covering this side of things in detail, As recommendations for improvements, 1 - Add more Cards (Especially AMD branded cards) to your benchmarking list, 2 - It would be nice to see things like average temps during these benchmarks and power draw too, 3 - It would be awesome to see reviews for each individual workstation GPU much like gaming GPUs but with a heavy focus on productivity applications and 1 or 2 gaming benchmarks on games which are known to hammer down graphics cards in order to provide a more varied view of what performance a content creator can achieve when wanting to play the occasional game on the weekend
Finally something for us professionals!!!! I like this we need more of these =)
As a freelance 3d artist, I thank you for this comparison.. would be cool to see more stuff like this in the future.
@Flávio Vink will do :) thanks!
Salut, tot pe 3ds max lucri? Ce zici de noul update de la Blender? Uite-te te rog la el si dai o sansa. Mie mi-a intrat la suflet.
Absolutely LOVE the workstation for design/engineering content. 20+ years in the engineering filed and these types of reviews are very rare and difficult to find. Well done to Rob Williams and all who worked on this one. Well done to GN for branching out into the industrial space. Five stars, full marks, etc. etc.
Exactly what I needed. Thank you guys! Great work!
I have quite a few friends who are in production / content creation and they ask me for hardware recommendations all the time. I never had easily data to easily parse through and make solid recommendations since being a software engineer, I personally have no experience with workstation parts. Content like this is going to help those people directly AND people like me who non-technical friends and family often turn to for recommendations. Really enjoyed this content piece GN!
This is one of the most useful videos that nobody is doing out there. Top notch job from GN.
Amazing job really with your testing!
As a 3D artist myself, i always wondered why people buy quadros.
Because large professional scenes take a lot more than 11GB of VRAM.
DawoopFilms that is why we have out of core support (dabs)
simply driver optimization as you see in few tests the geforce cards are so far away that it could only be explained due to lack of driver optimization
you can hate Nvidia for giving the driver optimization just for quadros but truth to be told it costs them money to develop those drivers and the premium price you
pay for quadros finance the driver development.
@Rafael Mesa for maya if you use the legacy viewport with a gtx,you are screwed.The 2.0 works.I used a k4200,1080ti and have a p6000 now(ebay offer for 1900€).And if you have a heavy scene or animation that doesnt work well on 2.0, than you shoud return to legacy viewport where the quadro has the same fps performance as 2.0.Hope you find the info interesting.
@@123OGNIAN Ditto. My w9100 actually performs worse than a 1070 or a Titan XM in VP 2.0 until I start adding heavier and heavier things to the scene until it is hitching and pausing so badly on the Geforce cards that it is utterly unusable, despite the high FPS. On my w9100 it is buttery smooth despite the lower FPS. In legacy, which I still have to use for certain things, it is literally up to 10 times faster.
Really, really hoping that this video will be updated soon. There's still not enough reliable workstation content so I'd love to see GN get back into this space
God bless you for videos like this ! There's always a shortage of videos on professional video cards
This was a much needed investigation. Thank you!
To the new host that I have never heard before from gamersnexus congratulations you did a great job look forward to seeing some more content from you in the future. 👍
Finally, a new content related to production.
Thanks for putting this content together even though the audience for it is quite small. It'll be a great reference for my next system.
This is by far one of the best benchmark video out here. Like Subs. Comments and Shared
Badly needed this video! Thank you so much!
Finally! waiting for a long time for you to cover something very important like this on your channel it's very rare to find you should do more videos like this "Gaming GPUs & Workstaions GPUs", Thanks you! #GamerNexus
Absolutely the best Video Card round up ever well done!!!!!
This is an excellent video 👍 very useful information
Re AutoCAD - you took a benchmark from AutoCAD 2016! That's a near 4 year old piece of software... it's falling off the supported roadmap in March next year. We've have 2017, 2018 and 2019 since then.
But having said that, this is the best content piece I've ever seen from a non-CAD channel covering workstation use, seriously well done. The advice regarding knowing your workload is critical, and LTT should really stop with their attempts to influence our market. It's important to point out to potential buyers that CAD is extremely deep, there are countless workflows internally and sometimes it isn't as cut and dry as one spec is best for the entire application... it depends on what modules you use to an extent. But well done guys I can tell how much work went into that.
@@Neil3D a likely reason for covering Autocad 2016 is since then they have stopped using lifetime licences and moved to a running subscription model
@@bengrogan9710 You can still get a 30 day trial of AutoCAD 2019 the same way you could with 2016. The ending of perpetual licensing didn't change trial offerings.
@@Neil3D Not my reasoning. Without a lifetime licence you cannot properly maintain a stable version as you are required to patch immediately.
For a reviewer this endsyour ability to reliably repeat benchmarks at later dates for cross comparisons with newly released hardware.
pls provide lifetime licenses to gn
What missing from this are AMD Pro WX 9100 (16GB) and Vega Frontier (16GB) cards which would near or at the top of the charts.
God bless this video. I'm not a content creator myself but have long wondered what that market looks like, how the cards relate in different workloads and such.
great content ! keep these professional work coming !
Love the glimpse into the workstation market. This is fun stuff!
Next up: compiling and memory performance benchmarks in Linux on HEDT setups? :)
thanks for benchmarking workstation applikations, hard to find stuff like this
Wow sudden new voice. Steve keeping us on our toes with surprises.
Thank you for this video. I found the different content very interesting to learn about.
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS, very appreciated.
Would love to see a 2019 version of this video, with the RTX Titan, Radeon VII and 5700 XT added
Thank you for including Octane.
Finally a pro focused gpu comparison!!! It's great! I would only suggest to include Rhinoceros 3D CAD software next time especially in the viewport comparison. Thanks anyway
Very very informative and well presented. thanks!
Great video!
Very good pacing and to the point(for most videos I use 1.25 speed, but not here).
Subbed to Robs channel, but if you decide to make more collaborations like this, I'm all for it! :)
Finally a work-oriented video! I wish you could make a separate channel to proper cover this kind of content, periodically.
Not a topic I have much interest in, but I watch it all anyway. Quite enjoyable content.
you guys never disappoint. I wish you had a review on best professional streaming setups, comparing items like the black magic studio 4k cam, and the accessories black magic sells.
I've watched this over a dozen times and this is by far the best comparison for professional reference I've seen. I've bought a Titan xp for myself and convinced my boss to buy 3 and a friend to buy one based primarily on this video. And they are as impressive as I expected.
Very thanks for clearly comparison.
Wow, really nice piece of work! And on a gaming hardware channel too. More of this!
I'd also like to add something of note, especially for Catia: Frame rate only matters for comfort in navigating assemblies. What matters is the amount of ram so you can actually open massive assemblies.
I believe he reference that, but the reverse is also true - comfortable working is fast working, assuming your buffer is big enough for your use
This was really fascinating. I'd like to see more (although that looked like a LOT of work) like with mid ranged gamer GPUs
Thanks for this! As an engineering student who games this is really useful and interesting information.
FINALLY! Thank you!
Awesome video! ♥
Hey it's that TechGage guy, I subbed to him after you recommend his channel a few months ago.
An interesting channel that I've sub too a long time ago. Especially when he does the workstation CPU's like TR and i9
Great content; thank you.
much better video than linus tech tips video about the same topic
Finally! I was waiting for something like this for years. I am really glad the new rtx gf cards are performing so well in the autodesk viewports. No need to buy the expensive quadros in those scenarios then, yay
Great info. It's a pity that the software producers don't publish their own benchmarks. I would've liked to have seen one of the 4096core Fiji GPUs included eg my R9 Nanos. Also - I run PowerDirector and would've liked to have seen that used in benchmarking as well as other low end/UA-cam type editors.
great video, ppl !
normally one only sees a few synthetic benchmarks for video and rendering....
Viewport performance analysis was MUCH appreciated. That and AutoCAD.
As a suggestion, for the next similar video...try to use other software as well... . like Rhino, Revitt, Inventor.. and ArchiCAD.
As an architect, i’m glad i watched this ..as i concluded that a gaming NVIDIA card might suffice..even for 3D rendering.
thanks very much, for this ;)
I would love to see an analysis like this specifically covering machine learning. I've been having to learn it for work and I'd love to know what to look for beyond just tensor cores and vram
Great! Thanks a bunch. I have been looking for just such a review. I hope a follow up with all the RTX cards is coming. Especially the new RTX P4000. Very curious how 3 or 4 of these single slots would perform...and if the vram is cumulative as all the other RTX.
Dude. Your script was savage. I love it.
Looking at the charts if you were just starting out, a second hand (or black Friday) vega64 looks like a pretty good choice. 1080ti also looks good.
I wonder how well a frontier edition would go in these benchmarks.
Impressive and useful video:)
Thanks for the reviews. It is still useful in 2021 and one of the best comparisons of there. Any plans for an updated similar comparison?
I don't have a need for a work station as I mostly game and only casually work a project. But thank you for the video. I found it very interesting in learning about this use case.
With premiere and after effects' piss poor code, it doesn't matter how fast your system is... the performance will always be piss poor especially Cc 2019
More of theses videos please, I’m always looking for performance reviews on the new quadro cards but there’s nothing out there.
I can't imagine how much work was put into this video. not to mention you have almost all the cards.
Thank You! Really helped me out! ^_^
Need one more video like this with the new gpus
Now we're talking! Really glad that fellow 3D artist taking over this segment.
Would love to see some results for texture painting software, like Substance Painter and Mari. Not only viewport performance, but also baking speed. It's kinda fall off this chart since this kind of workload requires realtime interaction thus simple amount of memory is crucial for ability to finish a work at all. Marmoset Toolbag and Blender's Eevee also could serve as a good metrics in here.
One main thing about viewport performance is the API each application is running on. Autodesk products like 3ds max and Autocad are using direct3d, so it's no surprise that consumer cards have similar or better performance compared to Pro cards like Quadro. On the other hand, most CAD apps, like Catia, SNX etc, run on OpenGL and professional gpus usually have an advantage in this field (they have better optimized drivers, specs like cores etc aren't a paramount factor).
wonderfull content bro, thank a lot.
Nice video, good information. Although, the results are understandably subjective depending on what a persons needs or budget is. This information is definitely informative to those needs. That is why this is such a well done comparison. This is some really good content from GN that steps outside of the "Gamer" realm. It really is in-line with the tone of the channel overall. It isn't really just about "gamers" and their wants/desires. Hasn't been for a long time. GN comes across to me as more of a tech information and review channel than a "gamer" channel.
It would have been nice to see thr WX9100 and it's 16GB memory
Vega FE as well would look pretty smushed into the charts.
Also no mention of HBCC.
I was about to say.. where's the Pro WX 9100..?
Workstation Nexus?
Still interesting though.
Good job. I just wish you added simulation tests such as Fire/Smoke/Particles in Houdini.
Nice video, but I feel like more cards would have been even better. Maybe a revisit of how the rts cards preform when navi drops or so?
AMEN man no one else is doing this content
can't you make a budget video like this ? that would be very helpful for students, 1060,1050ti,rx460,rx560,rx480,rx580 with budget workstations gpus
Are you really serious?
Yes and the 1660ti
Yes, we need an entry into this industry and we don't have so much cash to spend, 1660ti or dual 1050ti or other budget gpus.
Depending on your workload, you could consider just using whatever you can get for hardware, and something like AWS EC2 (Amazon Web Services Elastic Cloud Compute) to do the actual final rendering. They offer instances with GPUs included, which means you can use a high end GPU and only pay by the hour (instead of the whole thing up front). The other major services offer this as well (Azure, Google Cloud, etc.), and support Windows-based instances. Without specific numbers in front of me, I'd still say it's likely you could get through college working this way, spending less money than buying the GPU (to include electrically powering the GPU out-of-pocket), and waiting less time for the final rendering.
Good video. Thanks.
Love the video, disappointed not to see VEGA FE though
Great content! I'm glad to see that my 1080Ti works well for 3ds Max, my everyday work software (much much cheaper than the P6000). Interesting it doesn't perform well at all with CAD (Solidworks, Catia) applications.
Well, I won't be so sure about all CAD softwares. because if you search in the open-source world there are a dozen of other CAD, more humble and less featured but might be enough for a non-pro usage.
@@PainterVierax tinkercad immediatly comes to mind.
Same, I couldn't find any info like this when I was shopping and I didn't have a Quaddro (or Titan, for that matter) budget, so I just kinda had to hope the 1080ti would handle my needs, which it easily has so far. Glad I'm not a mech. engineer.
Javier, I was more thinking outside Autodesk, Siemens, Dassault, etc. more BSD/GPL licensed softs like FreeCAD, BRL-CAD, ngspice, kicad. But I'm not a Maker, i only do handcrafting without CNC nor 3Dprinting and just make my plan in 2D with Inkscape.
I like that others at gamers nexus can host videos now 🙂 maybe the audience can support a larger company even though it's more scientific than pop-technology channels with only surface level explanations of concepts
That is our hope! That the audience will support our growth in new sectors. We believe in letting individual editorial staff do what they're good at. No need for me (Steve) to pretend I know every single thing.
@@GamersNexus great saying !!!
thay's my idea of a Journalist, a very good Journalist.
(not a newsSeller)
@@GamersNexus but youre the tech jesus !
I had been using an HP all in one with an i7 7700 and an R9 370 to draw and render some designs in CATIA V6, and it worked fine for the stuff we did (never more than about 20 parts in a single assembly at 1080p).
Really nice video. I'm looking to build a mostly for 1080p gaming PC but with the ability to indulge in workstation tasks from time to time on a budget. I was surprised just how well the RX 580 placed through out the tests it could given its price point. I would have liked to have seen the GTX 1060 6GB results listed though. Right now I have a budget of around $900 for the full build and this and the previous CPU video have been great for narrowing down the CPU and GPU. Right now its a draw between Ryzen 2600 and 1700x as they're right now at about the same price point and same base clock speed. One's more recent but the other has a higher core and thread count. May just flip a coin.
GN doing God's work like always.
The best reviews!
TY for this video
Great comparisons... Would be awsome if you could add Davinci Resolve to the list of software's tested the next time around.
Nice video!
Are you planning on doing an updated video like this one?