Sibal-Mehta Intense Argument; Stop! Please Don't Interfere

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 кві 2024
  • Sibal-Mehta Intense Argument; Stop! Please Don't Interfere #lawchakra #supremecourtofindia
    Follow us on Twitter:- / lawchakra
    Follow us on Whatsapp : whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaP5...
    Visit Our Website:- lawchakra.in/
    Patna High Court Karnataka High Court Live Stream.
    #Patnahighcourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Supremecourt
    Courtesy :- Supreme Court of India
    Books on Constitution:- amzn.to/3rqFpbh
    Tools Used for editing:- amzn.to/3EelR1r
    For business Enquiries:- enquire@lawchakra.in
    #SupremeCourt#Mussorrie #advocate #lawyer #legal #livehighcourt #indianlaw #law #live #court #argument #criminaljustice #guiltyminds #learnadvocacy #courtlive #justicelive #lawmotivation #beajudge #ias #judge #law #legal #patnahighcourt #justiceashutoshkumar #judiciary #motivation #learnlaw #IAS #supremecourtofindia #IPS #2022 #Patnahighcourtstream #orissahighcourt #SupremeCourt #Orissahighcourt#GujaratHighCourt
    #Law #Chakra#JusticeAshutoshkumar
    *This Video is strictly for Legal Awareness & Education Purpose only.📚
    🙏 Follow us on twitter, Instagram and facebook.
    @Lawchakra
    👉Twitter
    / lawchakra
    👉 Instagram.
    / lawchakras
    📑*Fair Use Policy -*
    Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 137

  • @VijayReddy-gb5li
    @VijayReddy-gb5li 11 днів тому +40

    When the Electoral Bonds are unconstitutional.Then why all this discussion..
    What about the EVMs there is polling going on in the country .
    EVM must be discussed with Top priority

    • @Govindarajan-rf5kk
      @Govindarajan-rf5kk 11 днів тому +2

      Justice Sanjiv Khanna reserve the judgement. When he is going to deliver is million dollar question. Also the nature of the kudgement.

  • @Qwerty52009
    @Qwerty52009 11 днів тому +41

    Learned Advocate Sibalji's argument deserves high appreciation 😅😅😅

    • @JthElement
      @JthElement 11 днів тому

      Which argument, @ what min/sec?

  • @user-kt4zt2zu6t
    @user-kt4zt2zu6t 11 днів тому +27

    Dear CJI no more discussion about EVM,EVM should be ban.

  • @radhakrishnadevaraju7327
    @radhakrishnadevaraju7327 11 днів тому +6

    " RIP ELECTION COMMISSION 🙏 ELECTION COMMISSIONER & CHIEF ELECTION COMMISSIONER " 😂🎉😢😮😅😊

  • @ushagopale322
    @ushagopale322 11 днів тому +4

    Why cji ji not help to remove Evm put vvpat .change the power of Ec by changing them . Please

  • @jessiemonny5092
    @jessiemonny5092 11 днів тому +6

    Excellent Sibalji..powerful words.

  • @aijaazkhan7355
    @aijaazkhan7355 11 днів тому +6

    Are chief justice Koi Faisla Lenge ki aisi Mor Banke andhe log ke jaisa Dekhte Rahenge

  • @mecrypto2500
    @mecrypto2500 11 днів тому +27

    Bhakto ko mirchi lag rahi hogi ...😂😂😂

  • @syleshbabu3253
    @syleshbabu3253 11 днів тому +3

    Sibal was advocating 'Zero Loss' in 2G Scam.

  • @assamantaamal
    @assamantaamal 11 днів тому +4

    Excellent argument by the learned lawyers. Hat's off to them.

  • @kaleemshaik4765
    @kaleemshaik4765 11 днів тому +10

    sibble sir blow my mind with his think and the way of trying to save democracy sc should think come closer to this issue

  • @krishnakalidas572
    @krishnakalidas572 11 днів тому +33

    I like his toughness. He is like a captain of a sinking ship.👍🏼🙏🏼

    • @idabaretto7862
      @idabaretto7862 11 днів тому +1

      Stand corrected ship's NEVER in capable captain.

    • @modguy9894
      @modguy9894 11 днів тому +1

      except that the ship has already sunk

    • @amalapop
      @amalapop 11 днів тому +1

      absolutely

    • @amalapop
      @amalapop 11 днів тому +1

      he is too good at what he is doing

  • @shashikantchandel7848
    @shashikantchandel7848 11 днів тому +11

    excellent argument by Adv kapil sibal , there he is with exact motive of all electoral bond theory...welldone sir hat's off....veteran mumbai

    • @nalinidevries754
      @nalinidevries754 11 днів тому +1

      Comedy 😂😂😂😂 bullshit

    • @maheshb3538
      @maheshb3538 11 днів тому

      Sau sunar ka ek luhad ka. No problem

  • @BujjiWir
    @BujjiWir 10 днів тому

    Truly speaking, none of them are having any work to do. Supreme court is becoming like a time pass club.

  • @utpaldatta1967
    @utpaldatta1967 11 днів тому +4

    Solid points by Adv Kapil Sibal. Hope CJI gives a stern judgment

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому +5

    And to my bench i would have said ,let's proceed with pending cases as it should be in SC .

  • @manasshukla2037
    @manasshukla2037 11 днів тому +5

    Kudos to Kapil Sibal for such a forceful and fair argument! Proud of him.

  • @NaomiPinto-dp5fw
    @NaomiPinto-dp5fw 10 днів тому

    Sad day for Democracy in this

  • @gsnijjar7931
    @gsnijjar7931 10 днів тому

    Sibal is a HARDCORE CONGRESSMAN WHO ON THIS PRESENTATION
    WHAT HAS CONGRESS DONE ALL THESE YEARS

  • @TheSwaraj
    @TheSwaraj 11 днів тому +2

    Ticket for Sibbal has been booked.

  • @DhrishaPatil-mu1nu
    @DhrishaPatil-mu1nu 10 днів тому

    Electoral bonds, PM Cares Fund money should be seized by SC and used for upgrading Courts all over India.

  • @kumaryogi2005
    @kumaryogi2005 11 днів тому +5

    ​​मोदी जी सुरत शहर में सांसद को मनमाने ढंग से कैसे जीत का सर्टिफिकेट दे दी यानि डी एम चुनाव आयोग सब मिलकर अन्याय कर रहे हैं सुप्रीम कोर्ट में न्याय व्यवस्था पर ही लोकतंत्र बचे हुए हैं

  • @PhilipLama-nm2vl
    @PhilipLama-nm2vl 10 днів тому

    Mr. Sibal is right on the money...🙏 💕

  • @ajjushaikh6403
    @ajjushaikh6403 11 днів тому +1

    Cji sir pliz AP loktantr ko bachlijy

  • @deepakashwinshah8161
    @deepakashwinshah8161 10 днів тому

    Sibal spot on only this time because its major chunk beneficiary has gone to BJP but my genuine argument is which party started political funding by corporates as election funding and why???? for free and fair elections for all

  • @rajendrarana8182
    @rajendrarana8182 11 днів тому +6

    Mehta must work for the nation not for modi and shah
    Every one knows both the gujarati keaders are criminal.

  • @shamshadalamkhan9494
    @shamshadalamkhan9494 9 днів тому

    Nice discussion

  • @nasreensultana9374
    @nasreensultana9374 11 днів тому +1

    Eci functioning anti people,anti democratic openly violation of laws, as well as constitution its transperency?jai loktantra bharat zindabad,jai hind....

  • @MrPeriyachi
    @MrPeriyachi 11 днів тому

    Unfortunately the prioroities going to go the people who gave the money to the party. It is pity to see that a supreme court also started listening stories of these lawyers

  • @gopal2724
    @gopal2724 11 днів тому +3

    Kapil sibal ji is always great.
    Fortunately in the Hon, ble CJI The great D.Y. C. C. Sir. To save democracy.
    God be with people and supreme court.
    God save the country.
    Gopal

  • @VijayReddy-gb5li
    @VijayReddy-gb5li 11 днів тому

    The SC cherishes to discuss with Mehta but always frowns at SIBAL or anyone other than Mehta..They always intimidate others arguing against BJP.
    It's evident..why so..

  • @SATISHKUMAR-qz5xf
    @SATISHKUMAR-qz5xf 11 днів тому

    1.Politicians k Practice par pratiband hona chahiye,
    2.Saath hi Advocates ka fee fix hona chahiye- case ka time fix hona chahiye.
    3.Itni Chhutti kyun hona chahiye Judges ko? 6days working hona chahiye because yahan Festivals k liye bhi kafi sara awkash hota hai.
    4.Mukya Nyayadheesh ka chayan vidhivettaon k mat se chunao ke madhyam se minimum 3 years k liye hona chahiye.
    5.Supreme courts me hi sabse jyada-setting/getting chal raha hai jiska karan hai vartman Collegium System, it is self explained corrupt practice "tu meri khuja- mai teri khujaun".
    6.SC western culture ko promote kar rahe hain Article 377 example hai and English ko 75years bad bhi mandatory banaye rakhna eska udahran hai. Sabhi Indian Language ke jaankar SC me hone chahiye.
    7.UPSC/NDA k thrugh appointment hona chahiye lower court me uske baad Lower Courts ke sarvottam judges ko pronnat kar k High Courts saath hi High courts k sarvottam pradarshan walon ko SC me pronnat karna chahiye.

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому +4

    Good morning 🙏 🌄 🎉🎉 Wah , SC became an institute of Macro Economy , lecturer by Kapil Sibal to Judges .
    Wah ji Wah ...

    • @saheb2900
      @saheb2900 11 днів тому

      Wah ji wah janina,

  • @user-ez4vy2io7z
    @user-ez4vy2io7z 11 днів тому +4

    Well said advocate

  • @aksingh7524
    @aksingh7524 10 днів тому

    Donations so received and per candidate allowed to spend in ele tion shall be much more.

  • @gsnijjar7931
    @gsnijjar7931 11 днів тому

    Kind attn CJI DYC
    Sibal is talking about LEVEL PLAYING FIELD
    Has he forgotten the DAYS OF THE PAPER BALLOT
    ROUGES WOULD JUST ENTER THE POLLING STATION
    - TAKE THE BALLOT PAPPERS
    - STAMP THEM
    - STUFF THEM INTO THE BOX
    DYC - I ASK YOU
    HAVE YOU FORGOTTEN

  • @sadanandanvayalveetil7132
    @sadanandanvayalveetil7132 11 днів тому

    If this law was not passed by Modi Govt. there would not hv been financing financing of political parties.

  • @epenethmuthu
    @epenethmuthu 11 днів тому

    भविष्य में कानून अस्तित्व में रहेगा या प्रतिबंधित होगा, यह हमारे भारतीय संविधान पर आधारित है।

  • @sadanandanvayalveetil7132
    @sadanandanvayalveetil7132 11 днів тому

    From the style of arguments I feel the layer is the judge and judge is a layer.
    Is it the way the SC is working. A Lawyer is making every body's mouth shut including that of CJI.

    • @tanmaykashyap9995
      @tanmaykashyap9995 10 днів тому

      If you are talking the truth you can shut mouth of anybody you want

    • @tanmaykashyap9995
      @tanmaykashyap9995 10 днів тому

      No one can stop you when you are talking truth

  • @sanatmandal7903
    @sanatmandal7903 11 днів тому

    If the election bond is giving under the control of election funding headed by the committee, CJI, AG, ECI . Then there was no controversy over the funding during election.

  • @humblebutterflys7809
    @humblebutterflys7809 10 днів тому

    हमेशा से भारत की विडंबना

  • @user-we8mg1lg9m
    @user-we8mg1lg9m 10 днів тому

    ♥️ N A T O ♥️

  • @user-vu1bx1yj1k
    @user-vu1bx1yj1k 10 днів тому

    Why polling through EVM?

  • @vinodkulkarni3443
    @vinodkulkarni3443 11 днів тому +6

    hon court should enquiry all previous election expenses .

    • @dilippandit6966
      @dilippandit6966 11 днів тому

      Right from 1951 first election in the country take into consideration how much donations contributed by industrialists in the country prior to electoral bonds . Congress was ruling party and sibbal was a member of party. Give account for the same.

  • @shamshadalamkhan9494
    @shamshadalamkhan9494 9 днів тому

    Nice

  • @mkyacoob6783
    @mkyacoob6783 11 днів тому

    👍👏👏👏👌

  • @epenethmuthu
    @epenethmuthu 11 днів тому

    IN FUTURE WHETHER LAW WILL EXIST OR BE BANNED as LAW IS BASED ON OUR INDIAN CONSTITUTION.

  • @quran2981
    @quran2981 11 днів тому +2

    we are highly appreciate to sibal sir, we all sallute for showing the clear picture of electoral bond......thankyou sir

  • @rcthakur7688
    @rcthakur7688 11 днів тому

    Why the SC should be allowing these obstructive advocates to waste their time and lecturing on the subjects of which they have no expertise. Can they give an account of the total amount which the political parties collected as election fund from 1952 to 2019 when the electoral bond scheme was introduced?

  • @mukeshbajaj7273
    @mukeshbajaj7273 11 днів тому

    Wasting SC time.

  • @godfreyclements6578
    @godfreyclements6578 10 днів тому

    Please Ban EVM and save our precious democracy and people of this country from these wolves.

  • @neeluswar
    @neeluswar 10 днів тому

    Sibbal Saheb is a legend contrary to the SG.

  • @poonamverma9981
    @poonamverma9981 8 днів тому

    Some companies r in loses n giving donations.....a common man can see ... through those channels from where they bought shares in tha company.....

  • @nardesh127
    @nardesh127 11 днів тому +1

    It’s laughable argument, donation is paid willingly, after receiver wish how he may use it.

    • @alokdhar4280
      @alokdhar4280 11 днів тому

      There's nothing in question as donation..it's Electoral Bonds..Means..Corporate Houses are buying E.BDs for clinching untoward benefits from Govt..So,such moneys are meant for Electoral Spends..and not for buying Jewellery sets...point 2.in question..Corporate Houses under listing with market orientation with the Stake/Bonds Holders of the Co.should have responsibility to get accountable permissions from them.....This is not any Godidaar of Wholesale Market who are openhanded to donate any to anyone without any questions...So K.SHIBALJI has pointed out these things properly and logically....Now,Bonds Beneficiaries should be bound to utilize such bribes for Elections purposes though it has been made clear by the SC as unlawful..SC could've directed otherwise if the funds Clinched were in statically deposited in the Banks...

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому

    😮

  • @manoharshetty8288
    @manoharshetty8288 11 днів тому

    There are various instances where the coprorate spend without any permission from Shareholders. The bOard is theauthorized to deal with such matters

  • @sampatsasane94
    @sampatsasane94 11 днів тому

    It doesn't seem elections are fair free . Bonds are unconditional. It doesn't require any further explanation. Voters should have benefit of the doubt. They should be given choice to caste their vote either in EVM or Ballet paper. Constitution has given right to caste their vote as well as well as right to choose EVM or BPB.

  • @tngenmarwein4747
    @tngenmarwein4747 11 днів тому

    Evm hatou desh bachou.... 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @sudarshansaini4480
    @sudarshansaini4480 11 днів тому +5

    I like kapil sibal arguments

  • @jophyjose7863
    @jophyjose7863 11 днів тому

    Voter right to know if his/her vote is properly cast and verified is denied... Plz take up the matter.. Then elected members representing an ideology changes party ideology once elected for money... In such cases, bielection should be done to protect the trust and sincerity of the voters

  • @leelasankar830
    @leelasankar830 11 днів тому

    Better tohavenonpoliticalruleinwholecountry😊bettertohavenoParlientlministers😊😊

  • @sweswarupini9732
    @sweswarupini9732 11 днів тому

    If u want instances then show all electoral bonds donated to the parties with time and date to people of India...leaders of country and electoral bond scheme bringer trying their privacy of secrecy in what worth?

  • @VishalTayade-nr8yp
    @VishalTayade-nr8yp 11 днів тому

    Banned EVM 🚫

  • @manishangral4325
    @manishangral4325 11 днів тому +3

    he is absolutely right

  • @sudarshansaini4480
    @sudarshansaini4480 11 днів тому

    Kapil sibal is right they spent donated money as feel as they like

  • @gopal2724
    @gopal2724 11 днів тому

    Apart from donations the hidden thing is irrespective of party affiliations of contributors of share money, money is taken not only without consent of share holders
    But also this share holders
    Money could be reaching
    Opposite party of share contributors money with out consent of contributor
    Will and taken for granted.
    Shall be viewed in detail the finally.
    Gopal

  • @user-ol7pj8kj4b
    @user-ol7pj8kj4b 10 днів тому

    BJP, itself made the law for electoral bond scheme to get commission from cooperate companies

  • @Ashok-jw8dg
    @Ashok-jw8dg 11 днів тому

    A company has a turnover of 5 crores. How can a 500 crore bond be given to a party? So what is the source of that 500 crore? Where did that 500 crore come from? Even if the company suffered a loss, how did they give the bond? So it means that the owner of that company has cheated to the IT department. The owner of that company can now be sent to jail.. Why haven't the IT department officials filed a case against this company owner? IT department officials also made mistakes. IT department officials should also go to jail..

    • @kaydee3407
      @kaydee3407 11 днів тому

      Which conpany is that

  • @dwarka15
    @dwarka15 11 днів тому

    He's full of nonsense, investors will trust the owners and put the money.

  • @hayavadanarao5613
    @hayavadanarao5613 11 днів тому

    Falthu arguments. People buy the shares for their profits. Share holders are least bothered to whom the Companies are donating so long they get dividends.

  • @Thegs77
    @Thegs77 11 днів тому +1

    You are Legend Hon Adv. Kapilji, history will remember you for your fight for truth and democracy.
    ❤Thanks
    🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому

    Who is threatening Democracy in Bharat ? Has Bharat been conquered by China or Pakistan ??? 😆 🤣 😂 😹 😆 🤣

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому

    😅chor machai shor.

  • @marda7043
    @marda7043 8 днів тому

    Congress is now taking advantage of the social media world. When congress had so much money to contest elections 50, 60 years ago and won because of money. For vote banks congress party gave statehood to many small states in India without boundaries and these states have boundary issue with the each other especially with Assam. Thank you

  • @nardesh127
    @nardesh127 11 днів тому

    Donation given to temple does it not mean that you are trying please God ? Its a way of life

  • @aniltiwary9343
    @aniltiwary9343 11 днів тому

    Pleaae put the Date, Time of argument and Matter being discussed in thw video, to make it more meaningful and useful.
    Otherwise it is just time pass videos

  • @kishorzala9638
    @kishorzala9638 11 днів тому +2

    Sold supreme court

  • @varma287
    @varma287 11 днів тому

    This guy is CHUCK McGill

  • @basavarajusc9507
    @basavarajusc9507 6 днів тому

    He thinks he is the only intelligent guy in the legal faternity and others are dumb. When he talks of electrol bonds he has for gotten to calculate the %age what BJP recd and what opposition Parties recd collectively! Even SC is blind to this point.BJP RECD 44% and OPPOSITION PARTIES RECD 56% age then what is this big halla!!! Shor , sharaba!!! SHAME!! THE CASE RESTS!!😅😅

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому

    😅day chuhe khakar Congress Haj ko chali through sibbal.

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому

    Is none of ur bizz what political parties do with their donations , i rest my case !!!

  • @dineshdeshpande2092
    @dineshdeshpande2092 11 днів тому +2

    Kapil S..is not at all studious and appropriate in his arguments..his arguments smell of arrogance politically motivated and short on facts..CJI s interventions sound so intelligent pointed and clear..

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому +1

    Another one Mr Bushan , hey bhagwaan this elderly lawyers should be admitted in a home for pensions , where they can spend time to play games 🎮

  • @jayalaxmi248
    @jayalaxmi248 11 днів тому

    Lekka illade donation hafta tagondu. B nunga bahudu

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому

    Ek baath Aur Kahena Hai Muje : I'm a huge supporter of Modi Sarkaar with my knowledge , full support!
    Greetings from The Netherlands 🇳🇱 have a nice day !!

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому +1

    Ur SC IS THE GUIDE OF UR CONSTITUTION !!! PERIOD !!! U got it !!!

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому +1

    U can have national herald and its offices all over India.

  • @kumaryogi2005
    @kumaryogi2005 11 днів тому

    IN SURAT BJP CANDIDATE CAN NOT WIN FREE WITHOUT DEFEAT NOTA .

  • @meenakshisingh5309
    @meenakshisingh5309 11 днів тому

    Sc plz see wht bjp doing in surat this is democracy 😠

    • @tusharsamanta7997
      @tusharsamanta7997 11 днів тому

      Who stopped you to fill the nomination??? Don't do propaganda...

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому +1

    If it was my court, i would have said to him , out of my Court , go and join a COLLEGE OF ECONOMICS
    Namaskaar Kapil Sibal

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому +1

    This pure waste of time.donation to parties is not a issue of national importance to give urgent hearing

  • @dnyaneshwarrindhe3974
    @dnyaneshwarrindhe3974 11 днів тому +1

    This guy was law minister for years. Lost maximum cases he fought.

  • @mohedabbas2286
    @mohedabbas2286 11 днів тому

    BJP NDA all over, 👹👹👹👹👹👹

  • @Shayer-Tjandra
    @Shayer-Tjandra 11 днів тому

    Yes I'm Bhakth of a Progressive Bharat, and a devil 😈 too anti nationalist !
    Bharat Mata ki Jai !!
    VANDEMATARAM ❤❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

  • @nardesh127
    @nardesh127 11 днів тому

    What is the definition of donation, it’s willingly paid

  • @anantmahajan7224
    @anantmahajan7224 11 днів тому

    See how arrogant Mr Sibbal is.where from he derives this audacity? Soris is at work.

  • @nardesh127
    @nardesh127 11 днів тому

    Does it not apply to Mr Sibal and Singhvi, more money more power, more authority

  • @gkshorts2765
    @gkshorts2765 11 днів тому

    No visual no interest

  • @gajananpatole1465
    @gajananpatole1465 9 днів тому

    My donations bonds will go to Modi sarkar for development, not for congi pariwar ..its my choice ,and my rights.

  • @gajananpatole1465
    @gajananpatole1465 9 днів тому

    Inko electrol bond bjp se kam mile isliye yeh saara drama hai..Congress direct cash funding chahate hai ,ek rupee me only 15 paise kharch karke 85 paise khud ke pariwar ko baato..Ab Modiji inko mouka nahi degi..