A list for future Smg4 theory Who is Meggy’s Parents? Tari’s mystery Origin? Karen’s secret Husband. Mr. Puzzle’s identity? Behind the door in the Smg4 castle?
Tari literally had a three season tv show called Meta Runner that explains her origins, and I’m pretty sure Meggy’s parents were mention in some of her earliest appearances.
Anyone worried about the fact that Mr. Puzzles not only knows that Mario’s _Mustache_ is the source of the series’ persistent funny… but can essentially just *_”create”_* his very own version of Mario, now?
This video started out trying to explain why Mario dies and can come back to life in a regular SMG4 episode, but slowly devolved into the caddicarus jesus games video without the context.
This ain't no SMG4 Crew, this is Meme Theory. Also I have no idea that Marvel actually used the SMG4 idea for the Anchor Beings and Avatars, I even saw Deadpool and Wolverine and saw the SMG4 Genesis Arc.
Here's what I think, since Mario is the "avatar" if the SMG4 universe, there are safeguards and limitations as to what can actually "kill" mario, sure, he can die to a bomb, but he'll be fine like 5 minutes later, but if an outside entity, such as Zero, attempts to kill Mario, those "avatar" safeguards can't kick in, since it's not a normal thing killing Mario, it's an unknown being, actively killing the host
This is actually Mr Puzzles pulling the strings again. His plan had started since SMG4 Meme Hunters, and the seeds were sown as far back as WOTFI 2023, where he made a patreon "Pay to Play" ARG. Note that ever since [It has got to be perfect], SMG4 suddenly turned into what I can call an Unholy fusion of a TikTok influencer, a Mr Beast Clone and a Jerk? Also, ever since Puzzlevision, SMG4 has suddenly had the cast "following Scripts"... Which was something he never did before. You know who does that? Mr Puzzles.
Theory: In Puzzlevision it is revealed that South Park exists in the Smg4 universe, and you know what other character is known for coming back from the dead? KENNY so that means that MARIO IS KENNY!
2:16 cool to know that the smg4 guys saw Deadpool and Wolverine, also I think it’s funny to imply that people at marvel watch smg4, and that it’s possible Kevin feige himself took ideas from them. Who knows, glitch could get hired to make a marvel animation in the future.
WAIT... if you look closely on 13:25 you can clearly see that he got launched straight into the castle... which means you can calculate with the distance falling per second multiplied by the angle of the bisector and find somebody who knows how to do math, and we can find out where the castle is! Get out your papers and pens because there's a new theory to solve...
I actually slowed down the video and the castle appears to be, by looking at the frames, somewhere in Austria or Bavaria. The problem is that the intense light at the end of the scene makes it hard to see which part or state of Austria SMG4 was falling to.
I would just like to mention, that out of all the BS that he threw at us the whole "Nintendo is a cult" part is the most believable. Although the Papa Johns part is just because of an old episode.
I’m beginning to wonder, is Mario secretly Wade Wilson aka Deadpool? Or maybe Logan aka Wolverine? Edit: Here’s the timestamp for Deadpool and Wolverine: 2:16 (spoiler warning)
@LilMan-w3gaSerial Designation N here!!! I’m now president of Nintendo Glitch give us our show back or else we’ll end the universe That’s from Uzi :) Bye SMG4
Video idea: SMG4 feels like he is missing something important deep inside him, like something that needs to be repaired with something or someone. He has to dig deep and go through his memory to try and what out what exactly he is needing to fix. After going through meaningful moments, like how the original castle was destroyed and WOTFI 2023, he realized he wants to repair his relationship with SMG3; as it was rather rocky. (You can build it from there and make it as silly as you want, but I think this could be cool tbh)
Definitely. I *refuse* to believe that the bare-bones story he sang in _Creative Control_ was his entire motivation for completely torturing and screwing over the entire SMG4 crew. People who engage in *that* level of absolute cruelty seem to have more than just a simple "I am friendless" story as their motive.
Yeah, I want to learn more about Mr Puzzles. That's one of two reasons why I'm glad that he's back. The other being him going down a little too easily in the Puzzlevision movie.
@@julianmoe928 Fax, bro. Those might be the main two reasons as to why I enjoy him being back. If you want to apply a third, I just find him to actually be pretty fun as a hammy villain kind of character
*REQUEST:* Tari and Boopkins Teach Meggy to Like Anime! *PLOT:* This is Similar to Mario's Goes On A Diet and Mario's tunnel of Doom, But NOW It's Meggy's Turn to Learn a thing or too. Learn to used to Anime!
You know, as much as SMG4 has grown and divided itself from its original shitpost lore. I think it’s kind of niche yet touching to have official lore be implemented from videos that are now 8-12 years old. It’s like you are watching the past present and possible future of what was a simple game that then sprouted into the biggest reveal you have seen. New opportunities come and go. I love it
Fun fact: His oldest video is “The Cake Is a Lie!” From 13 years ago, as his longest livestream was 99 hours but is now private. it was part of the “It’s Gotta Be Perfect” arc.
I thought he was going to talk about the theory that everything takes place in a recording in a game called GMOD, where he has multiple characters, maps and camera placement, And on top of that, it's easier to create special effects like explosions.... Hahahahah... What I was thinking about this theory... thinking?
"An abyss filled with hundreds of Mario corpses" Mario: the Music Box Arc has this exact thing after fighting Len, so yes, there is an abyss with hundreds of thousands of Mario corpses
Awesome work, SMG4! I've been a huge fan from the very beginning, and I can't wait to see more videos from this amazing series!! But always remember, you take a small rest if needed. We are always here
My theory (for the SMG4 explanation) is that there are 2 types of deaths: Normal death and permadeath. Normal deaths are common, where most die and, probably due to guardian powers, get revived after a random amount of time, with their afterlives being holding areas. Permadeaths are what victims can't return from, however it's only possible under certain conditions, those conditions(after 2018) being: Be a side character/villain, get killed by another character in a moment of the storyline that falls under one of certain types of tone and mood (serious). The avatar of each universe isn't supposed to be permakillable, but Niles and the god box found a way to bypass that.
Film theory:never does a theory on smg4
Smg4: Fine I'll do it myself
Lol
@@MichaelBoyd-uc2kn *The SMG4 Theorists have left the chat*
@@Green_KirbyI was about to say something similar lol
Am not gonna lie they might have a stroke doing smg4 lore….😂
A list for future Smg4 theory
Who is Meggy’s Parents?
Tari’s mystery Origin?
Karen’s secret Husband.
Mr. Puzzle’s identity?
Behind the door in the Smg4 castle?
Tari literally had a three season tv show called Meta Runner that explains her origins, and I’m pretty sure Meggy’s parents were mention in some of her earliest appearances.
@@skykrasher4475 I know but that’s Meta Runner Tari, Not Smg4 Tari. Also we don’t see Meggy’s Parents often.
Mr. Monitor Father
Is There SMG5?
Is Box Dude still Alive?
What happened To SLG4?
Good topics.
I mean MP is well MP
….love to find out if he’s actually Ness though
This captures how crazy sounding MatPat was a few years ago when his theories weren’t 70% FNAF
“a few years” Mans literally retired 💀
@@WhatABinglylittlescronklylil- yeah, but that’s recent.
A few years back, like the early to mid 2010’s is what I was talking about
Mario❤️❤️❤️
He even referenced the whole “Mario is evil” thing from like years ago.
???@@WhatABinglylittlescronklylil-
2:34 snowtrapped scene… he remembers it… GUYS WE MIGHT BE GETTING REMASTERED SNOWTRA- *dies*
JUST MAKE THEM KISS ALREADY jk jk unless...?
@@Fix-It_Felix256 😏
I think so.
Anyone worried about the fact that Mr. Puzzles not only knows that Mario’s _Mustache_ is the source of the series’ persistent funny… but can essentially just *_”create”_* his very own version of Mario, now?
NOPE YOUR NOT THE ONLY ONE
Mario will be milked just like Ryan’s world
Skibidi toilet>>Hazbin Hotel, Helluva Boss, TADC, Murder Drones, BFDI, FPE, Meta Runner...
@Bkevinmss No
@@𱁬as if😂
This video started out trying to explain why Mario dies and can come back to life in a regular SMG4 episode, but slowly devolved into the caddicarus jesus games video without the context.
7:48 Hearing Luke ramble on about Nintendo and Jesus being linked has gotta be one of the funniest things to come out of the show.
2:25 😡
Just like MatPat!
Mario💗💗💗💗
Really
@@SMMG4 Yep, very funny to see. It is being linked to God and Nintendo
MatPat & other game theories would be proud of this video 😂
I think so too🥲
This ain't no SMG4 Crew, this is Meme Theory. Also I have no idea that Marvel actually used the SMG4 idea for the Anchor Beings and Avatars, I even saw Deadpool and Wolverine and saw the SMG4 Genesis Arc.
It didn't have the Smg4 Crew logo on it
They ripped off SMG4!
@@jameslawrenson1208no they didn’t matpat join UA-cam before smg4 smg4 make one theory and matpat make millions how is that rip off
Government when you got the payment free movies and that are back in online girls is funny this month now stupid phone
Mario💖💖💖
Here's what I think, since Mario is the "avatar" if the SMG4 universe, there are safeguards and limitations as to what can actually "kill" mario, sure, he can die to a bomb, but he'll be fine like 5 minutes later, but if an outside entity, such as Zero, attempts to kill Mario, those "avatar" safeguards can't kick in, since it's not a normal thing killing Mario, it's an unknown being, actively killing the host
Ooooooohhhhhhhhhh
Smart
That’s exactly what I always thought. It makes sense that a universe’s avatar isn’t just some random guy that could die at any moment.
Very wise thinking. Makes sense.
This is actually good
2:34 NOT THE SNOWTRAPPED REFERENCE
No digas eso
06:01😂😂😂 Penguinz0 Is Jesus😮
@@lizliz5919 JAJAJAAJJAJA
Tru
he will never escape snowtrapped...
1:04 "he always comes back" SPRINGTRAP!
NOT SNOWTRAPPED😭😭😭😭 2:34
Lol
WHY DUD THEY LENTION IT
0:40 smg4 game Theory intro
thanks for letting me know
Same intro but music cuts, and low quality edit
Bro you do copyright you gonna get cancelled if you do that ok
No shit
MatPat should be a character on SMG4 just to slap him for doing a Game Theory episode since that was his thing and he ain't no successor.
“Thats Just A Theory. AN SMG4 THEORY”
Ive Seen the Same RageBaiter Many Times.
Skibidi toilet >> Hazbin Hotel, Helluva Boss, TADC, Murder Drones, BFDI, FPE, Meta Runner...
Mario💖💖💖
@Bkevinmssno cringy boi
A GLITCH THEORY
8:34 bro became smgpat
SMG4: STOP COPYING US, MARVEL!
Also SMG4: *Copies MatPat in this episode.*
hello you from brandon yates.
+the Chanel the smg4 theorist
Perfect example of SMG4 being a hypocrite
Bro What??
Yeah
Smg4: “We’re out of idea what should we do” guy: “ theorize your own show where you made the lore”
Are you hearing yourself
I think it's a parody or tribute
They're clearly not playing it straight, dude. Why would he speculate so outlandishly otherwise?
Mario🧡🧡🧡
@@psychie8625 Yeah, he would not imply Mario's Jesus if he was playing it straight.
This is actually Mr Puzzles pulling the strings again.
His plan had started since SMG4 Meme Hunters, and the seeds were sown as far back as WOTFI 2023, where he made a patreon "Pay to Play" ARG.
Note that ever since [It has got to be perfect], SMG4 suddenly turned into what I can call an Unholy fusion of a TikTok influencer, a Mr Beast Clone and a Jerk?
Also, ever since Puzzlevision, SMG4 has suddenly had the cast "following Scripts"... Which was something he never did before.
You know who does that?
Mr Puzzles.
Theory: In Puzzlevision it is revealed that South Park exists in the Smg4 universe, and you know what other character is known for coming back from the dead? KENNY so that means that MARIO IS KENNY!
Mario🫶💖
NANNNNNIIIII!!!??
AND KENNY IS NESS
AND NESS IS SANS
AND SANS IS A ROBOT
Omg they killed mario
2:05 The lore excluding post-Puzzlevision
@Bkevinmssthe most chill bot
Do i have a feeling that Mr Puzzle Might Gonna be returned again for revenge
Nah there was way more lore before
@@ethantasti2521hi
@@WizardLizard-8for real
Mario is William Afton
He always comes back
THE SPAGHETTI OF 1987
🤣 lol I love it
Brings back the days of Matpat
@Bkevinmssdorkly sonic “ why you say that like it’s a completely normal sentence? “
@Bkevinmssuh what?
@Bkevinmss wait a minute is this a bot account or smth
FUN FACT: REPORT BOTS DONT REPLY THEM
@@EliVance2025 i already did
9:42 missed opportunity to play no party from marios madness (and a hallyboo reference)
Love the way the whole Game Theory style in SMG4 Theory lol! Good idea and qoute on qoute it’s definitely good.
Close enough, Welcome back MatPat.
5:40
"SO if Luigi is a DEMON.... then Mario has to be.......JESUS."
this had me laughing so hard xD
Same 😂
Same
Me too 🤣
2:16 cool to know that the smg4 guys saw Deadpool and Wolverine, also I think it’s funny to imply that people at marvel watch smg4, and that it’s possible Kevin feige himself took ideas from them. Who knows, glitch could get hired to make a marvel animation in the future.
Me need more of these smg4 theory episodes, cuz this was hilarious
2:34 SNOW TRAPPED MENTIONED???
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Ok
I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE WHO SAW THAT
OMG LOLLL
Oh no😂😂😂
About the last episode, it was interesting to see that Mario's mustache is the source of his "funny". He isn't the avatar for nothing!
13:40 Outro finishes for him!
Lol
internet anarchist kind of gave smg4 a boost good job smg4 on all your videos I laugh every time
Bro Mario literally has plot armor that’s why he “Always come back”
Mario: I ALWAYS COME BACK
Mario is Springtrap (William Afton) Confirmed.
Mario is springtrap 2.0
Mario trap bu bu. Dbudududududududududududududa
@@joshblackwell8632 but hey, that's just a theory
Smg4 theory: SMG3 is ballin?!?!
Yes he's ballin :D
The're is a video about !
@@Ludi312 Oh yeah. That was a good episode
Smg4 theory: Are Smg3 and Smg4 Ship is being Now canon?
@@adamcurazi2122 we need this theory
Mario has been the Awesome character in the SMG4 Series!
Agree!
that what mario wants you to thinl :D
Debatable
Love how this episode is a brilliant merge of Matpat's old and new game theories with a little bit more of his "crazy conspiracy" side showing. XD
WAIT... if you look closely on 13:25 you can clearly see that he got launched straight into the castle... which means you can calculate with the distance falling per second multiplied by the angle of the bisector and find somebody who knows how to do math, and we can find out where the castle is! Get out your papers and pens because there's a new theory to solve...
Smg4 please pin this
I actually slowed down the video and the castle appears to be, by looking at the frames, somewhere in Austria or Bavaria. The problem is that the intense light at the end of the scene makes it hard to see which part or state of Austria SMG4 was falling to.
@@odinpeanut with enough people searching, all we need is a country area to look for, we got this guys
What do Mr Puzzles, William Afton from FNAF and Chucky have in common?
*THEY ALWAYS COME BACK!*
You forgot mario I’m at 2:35
You forgot the Terminator
remenber: one of them is killable, but smg4 doesn't.
You forgot Niles,SMG0, Eldritch axol during the cosmology lore
@@Dacal-eexcept they never made a third return
4:23 Hey, Did Mario made a deal with the Devil in "What if Mario was in Cuphead"?
I know the game that was in!
@@michelboucher3971 It's not it's an SMG4 episode
@@CartoonEj203 Yeah I know but the devil mario part, the game ui thought a game i had
2:17 Is it true? 🤔🤨
Yes! Yes it is.
I would just like to mention, that out of all the BS that he threw at us the whole "Nintendo is a cult" part is the most believable. Although the Papa Johns part is just because of an old episode.
Wrong title: "THEORY is mario dead"
Right title: The mario iceberg
I’m beginning to wonder, is Mario secretly Wade Wilson aka Deadpool? Or maybe Logan aka Wolverine?
Edit: Here’s the timestamp for Deadpool and Wolverine: 2:16 (spoiler warning)
This genuinely needs to be an smg4 series
3:26 Sweden mentioned???!!!! 👀🇸🇪🇸🇪
sweden???
Yooo! My Home Country!
Yo, sup Crazytrain2015
du gamla du fria du fjäll höga nord du tysta du glädjerika sköna
HOME OF AVICII AND ZARA LARSSON LADS AND GALS
13:20
Jesus was like "yeah we don't want him.."
Yeah, because SMG4 used his Father's name in vain
Here's a Theory for all of you: Mr Puzzles has been controlling SMG4 ever since PuzzleVision, and forcing everyone to "Follow Scripts" through SMG4.
Ok, so while I’m not a fan of newer smg4 really, this vid ABSOLUTELY nails older game theory videos, right down to the jokes and goofy theories.
As someone who saw The Last Supper, I can confirm they took out the mario part.
0:01 But that’s just a theory, a Meme Theory!
I checked The Translation Of Ouija and it Said Weegee😮😮😮, Luigi has a Weegee cult
Oh boy! I wonder if this is the start of the smg4 theory series?
MatPat in the corner staring:
7:49 and *the big N* 💀💀
@LilMan-w3gaSerial Designation N here!!!
I’m now president of Nintendo
Glitch give us our show back or else we’ll end the universe
That’s from Uzi :)
Bye SMG4
@LilMan-w3gasure daddy 😘
@@DinoRickyMr N....nice to see you in the flesh...or the metal ...
@@DinoRickybtw n while ur at it can u tell hakita that ull end the world if he doesn’t hurry up on Act 3 and P-3
NI-
*my lawyer advised me to not finish the joke*
I saw the thumbnail,i thought it was an actual theory by matpat and game theory,(i was like "wait,is this a game theory video or an smg4 video?")
Are we gonna ignore the fact SMG4 watched Deadpool and Wolverine?
Yep
It’s not really that surprising, it’s popular and has jokes similar to SMG4
Step Aside new Game Theory host, SMG4 got us some new theories, he needs to run Game Theory now.
1:00 “He always comes back.” Now where have I heard that before….
Fnaf or Child’s play
FNAF
@@allanaisawesome1465 Thanks, but it was a rhetorical question. Glad to see you spotted the reference though
Fnaf
Video idea: SMG4 feels like he is missing something important deep inside him, like something that needs to be repaired with something or someone. He has to dig deep and go through his memory to try and what out what exactly he is needing to fix. After going through meaningful moments, like how the original castle was destroyed and WOTFI 2023, he realized he wants to repair his relationship with SMG3; as it was rather rocky. (You can build it from there and make it as silly as you want, but I think this could be cool tbh)
HELL YEAH SMG34
Skibidi toilet >> Hazbin Hotel, Helluva Boss, TADC, Murder Drones, BFDI, FPE, Meta Runner...
Wow mate
@@LanceStrollTheGOAT Not true at all lmaoo
The ability to speak doesn’t make you intelligent
12:33 OMG america has already fallen!
Smg4:flash bangs us with him smashing caveman Mario
Also smg4:not this not this cut cut cut
Is smg4 Dead??? 13:01
That’s just a theory, a SMG4 THEARY!
Or is it
1:05 He ALWAYS comes back
An SMG4 Game Theory Video Is Something I Never Expected😮
I can't believe how on point this Game Theory imitation is 😭 (I love it so much)
SMG4 Theory Idea:Mr Puzzles has an extended backstory he didn't wanna tell.
Family
Definitely. I *refuse* to believe that the bare-bones story he sang in _Creative Control_ was his entire motivation for completely torturing and screwing over the entire SMG4 crew. People who engage in *that* level of absolute cruelty seem to have more than just a simple "I am friendless" story as their motive.
@@PatrickLimmer it could've been something more fun take for example Bill Cipher who's a great villain in comparison to Puzzles.
Yeah, I want to learn more about Mr Puzzles. That's one of two reasons why I'm glad that he's back. The other being him going down a little too easily in the Puzzlevision movie.
@@julianmoe928 Fax, bro. Those might be the main two reasons as to why I enjoy him being back. If you want to apply a third, I just find him to actually be pretty fun as a hammy villain kind of character
7:16 PARIS OLYMPIC 2024 FLASHBACK
I know... We shocked you... Sorry that my country when nuts on that.
huge W for doing a reference of mat pat game theory:D
*REQUEST:* Tari and Boopkins Teach Meggy to Like Anime!
*PLOT:* This is Similar to Mario's Goes On A Diet and Mario's tunnel of Doom, But NOW It's Meggy's Turn to Learn a thing or too. Learn to used to Anime!
This is funny but we all know he can never die unless he is erased from existence itself.
You know, as much as SMG4 has grown and divided itself from its original shitpost lore. I think it’s kind of niche yet touching to have official lore be implemented from videos that are now 8-12 years old. It’s like you are watching the past present and possible future of what was a simple game that then sprouted into the biggest reveal you have seen. New opportunities come and go. I love it
That’s just a theory, a M A R I O theory
Mario💖💖
Víctim number one, eyeballs were unable to be found
@@a_rytofc ?
Fun fact:
His oldest video is “The Cake Is a Lie!” From 13 years ago, as his longest livestream was 99 hours but is now private. it was part of the “It’s Gotta Be Perfect” arc.
11:39 uh why on my birthday wtf...
This is why I only eat Hungry Howie’s.
13:20 Smg4 : Oh My God, It's Jesus!
JC: I Heard you took my father's name in vain
.
9:42 lemme just leave this here
Mario: *MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA*
Request: SMG4 Theory: is SMG3 is a FNaF!?
10:39 THE PHOENIX WRIGHT LAW AND ORDER MUSIC IS HITTING SO HARD RN
SMG4 x Game Theories Crossover!
I thought he was going to talk about the theory that everything takes place in a recording in a game called GMOD, where he has multiple characters, maps and camera placement, And on top of that, it's easier to create special effects like explosions.... Hahahahah... What I was thinking about this theory... thinking?
"An abyss filled with hundreds of Mario corpses"
Mario: the Music Box Arc has this exact thing after fighting Len, so yes, there is an abyss with hundreds of thousands of Mario corpses
Finally someone spoken thank you
Awesome work, SMG4! I've been a huge fan from the very beginning, and I can't wait to see more videos from this amazing series!!
But always remember, you take a small rest if needed. We are always here
Welcome to [SMG4 THEORY]!
(11:09) EXUSE ME?
My theory (for the SMG4 explanation) is that there are 2 types of deaths: Normal death and permadeath. Normal deaths are common, where most die and, probably due to guardian powers, get revived after a random amount of time, with their afterlives being holding areas. Permadeaths are what victims can't return from, however it's only possible under certain conditions, those conditions(after 2018) being: Be a side character/villain, get killed by another character in a moment of the storyline that falls under one of certain types of tone and mood (serious). The avatar of each universe isn't supposed to be permakillable, but Niles and the god box found a way to bypass that.
Nah...smg4 made a theory about his own show
He should know the answer by now
3:29 BRO JUST FOUND MY IP ADRESS FR 💀
mario just goes out to his local koopa shell farm and farms 1Ups until he is bored!
Damn I thought when I first saw the thumbnail a week ago, I thought this was the smg4 theorists channel
4:39
SUPER MARIO brain cancer
64
...
64
Am I the only one bothered about the fact that for some reasons his pupils cast a shadow? Lmao
So that's why Mario treats Luigi like he HATES him! But that's LUDICROUS! 5:04
I enjoy this. More SMG4 theory!
2:10 Deadpool and Wolverine
2:16 it was
But remember, it’s just a theory…
A SMG4 THEORY!!!
Because he is the icon of Mario Bros game
The first game that smg4 started his content
Right?
SMG4, When are you going to show us MORE SMG4 CREW episodes? Like Mario Reacts To Nintendo Memes 17 Ft. Saiko Chan?
12:05 actually that’s mama Luigi to you Mario
Do you support lgbtq
@@36spygames42I am trans so I do, do you have a problem?
@@Mr.Puzzles-wo8rpSame
SUPER MARIO WORLD CARTOON REFERENCE??????
Bruh what is society doing to this world 💀
I love how Mario is associated with Jesus even though he earns some place in hell for his war crimes.
Y'know I always thought Mario never actually dies in any way, as he always finds a way to resurrect himself.
Matpat would be proud
*”First…” This word is no longer available due to a copyright claim by Stingy.*
*Sorry about that.*
*:\*
HUH
Bot?
BOT
Hello, fellow peasants. These bots are also, mine.
*No mining in the halls…*