@@toivotraks it is. your “economy” is mostly a donations from EU and most of your people are working in biggest EU countries not in Estonia, same with every Baltic country. you just a small dying village, nothing else
@@NikitaLemeshev-e8r Another troll from Russia who even can't write decent English. Head overloaded with total trash and idiotic notions. I am absolutely indifferent what you believe - it doesn't change the reality of things even a little bit. End of line for you. Bye!
@@NikitaLemeshev-e8r Your grandparents used to trash talk America. Now they are ashamed of their grandchildren trash talking small countries that are still doing better than Russia lol. Russia is honestly such a waste of space that does more harm than good to the world. Should just nuke itself already.
It's actually a thing in Russia. News use unusual words to describe stuff. For example we won't have news " 2 people died in gas explosion" but " clap happened in a house". And when our economy sinks its "negative grow". My government trying their hardest to avoid negative feedback
US, GDP: 17 Trillion. National Debt: 24 Trillion. Russia, GDP: 1,3 Trillion, National Debt: 150 billion (and even that obligatorily, as guarantees for participation in the international banking system. But the biggest sham, is the information in the West about Lithuania. The claim of 19k as personal annual income in Lithuania, is beyond comical. I 've visited the country more than 6 times since 2011, it is in complete and utter disarray, it is a disaster. I have a Lithuanian person right now and mentioned this to her: Her answer: "19 thousand dollars?"? "Yes". "19 Thousand dollars?","Yes". "Did they perhaps mean ONE THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED year?".
Yeah, but for example agriculture exports is all time high. Beating giants like US or France in grain market. "Thanks" to these sanctions, russians have to depend mainly on themselves.
They got sanctioned by the world's largest market and still managed to recover their economy within a few years, yet the actions they got sanctioned for still stand.
@Олег Широбоков Yeah but the communists are much worse than the Nazis. At least the Nazis were all sent to prison. Where are the communists now? Any communist in prison? The communists are still murdering, poisoning and terrorizing Eastern Europeans!
One interesting fact is also that Estonia's GDP per capita was actually higher than Finland's prior to WW2. It would be a prosperous country today comparable to Nordics if they weren't captured by soviets back then.
You could say the same with Romania, it was a functional democracy and had a modern capitalist economy. Bucharest was nicknamed Little Paris... Communism did a lot of damage in the world...
2:12 Man, Kazakhs were richer then Russians. Also happy for Baltic states, maybe one day all the post-Soviet countrys will become as great as they are. And I really want to visit Baltic states, especially Estonia 🇪🇪. With all love from Kazakhstan! 🇰🇿
@@toivotraks Привет, Эстония! Мы вам очень завидуем и надеемся, что однажды наши страны тоже будут для всех людей, а не для кучки лжецов и воров у власти. С наилучшими пожеланиями
The GDP of the Baltic States is so high because they receive constant subsidies from the EU and do not have the cost of the army and they have small countries ,but in fact they sold all their factories and the last railways for scrap and live only on subsidies.
these are simply the fastest dying countries in Europe and the world-together with Romania and Bulgaria-when 30 % of the population left, and the rest live on EU subsidies or die
Russia sacrificed 10 years of growth for Crimea lmao (edit, thanks for all the replies, this comment was partly a nutshell joke but thank to everyone who hasn't been toxic! I've learned many things)
You should keep in mind USD to RUB currency and that in those data GDP showed in USD. So if you have economic growth 10% for example, but USD to RUB come from 35\1 to 50\1 it will show you negative growth, which in reality doesn't make much sense
The have no choice. The western bloc has eaten their words of not letting the NATO expanding east. In short, if EU accepts Russia Russia would join immediately. R.I.P. Russian struggling against sanction.
@@jurgeeen And show these data in roubles - Russia stands in one place while all the rest take off like mad. Why please is rouble falling to 90 roubles -1 euro and more, if the economy is so strong? These tables have to use stable currencies.
Despite being called former Soviet republics, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were de jure aren’t part of the Soviet Union, but independent nations under occupation.
@@SilverPlaqueVII yeah, the baltics were under "Illegal occupation" having been neutral through ww2 until Germany invaded them, and soviets performed coups in the baltics
@@SilverPlaqueVII de jure we can state whatever we want but in reality.. Estonia joined into USSR with elections (yes possibly fraud) but still there werent any military conflict while joining nor mass protests - also it worth to notice that (!)many(!) hi-rank communist party members continued it's political career after Estonia gained independence (if it would be that much occupation previously they would end up in jail not in government in independent Estonia). Estonian president A.Rüütel, Estonian prime ministers S.Kallas, E.Savisaar and A.Ansip and many others were hi rank communists - You can check that fact even from their wikipedia pages - it is not conspiracy.
@@maitsepolitsei I wouldn't be surprised if estonians were too scared to rise up. I've read that nearly every single native ingrian was sent to concentration camps and dispersed across Russia, with hundreds of thousands of them being brutally murdered after attempting to gain independence/join Finland in around 1919/1920. that would still be fresh in the memory of estonians during ww2.
@@mz2535 yes thry do teach us where and what the baltic countries are! After Latvia, i put the rest after refrencing to the “ love and support all “ thing
Perkamoji galia Lietuvoje didesnė, didesnis 'juodųjų' pinigų kiekis. Didesni mokėjimai grynaisais, daugiau išmokama pinigų neoficialiai susitarus dėl darbo užmokesčio. Verslai linkę nepasikliauti valstybės mokesčių politika, didesnė dalis verslų išnaudoja teikiamas lengvatas, nors atitikimo kriterijus minimalus. tai dar vis postsovietinis mentalitetas.
@@anghelusz1 Your comment makes no sense. No one should spend hours to try to learn all the flags in the world for a 3-minute video clip whose main purpose is to entertain. Geopolitics? Please. The data in these types of video aren't even entirely accurate and verified. Just an extrapolation of data collected from unknown sources. As a UA-cam content creator, one should make his/her video more accessible to everyone so they can enjoy and understand said video. And then maybe they can learn the countries and their flags while watching it too. And that's the point of my original comment.
@@adrianciobanu5856 Sir, the euro is more valuable than dollar. So it makes total sense to the average moldovan making more dollars than euros, at least numerically speaking.
I'm wondering how much of the economic growth in Russia can be explained by the rise in commodity prices between 2009 and 2013. And the effect of the fluctuation of the oil price on their GDP. Would be useful to explain if the production capacity of Russia actually increased or if just the prices of their goods increased.
All three Baltic countries Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are absolutely unprofitable states subsidized by the European Union, with industry destroyed by the West after the collapse of the USSR , with a population that leaves there every year for other European countries, in fact, these are countries of limitrofa
@@макслюлюкин Could you provide sources for this? Not because I disagree, in fact I'm writing an essay right now arguing exactly this and extra sources would be helpful.
@@madehtml5me кхм пук русские люди в Крыму проголосовали за присоединение к России на референдуме, потому что они русские и им не нравилось давление на русскоговорящее население на Украине, но это неправильно, так не должно быть, Украинацеевропа!!! Очнись, чел, по европейским стандартам право на самоопределение граждан важнее территориальной целостности. Единственная причина, почему к Крыму отнеслись не так, как к Косову, это то, что люди там русские. Но Крым уже не вернётся к вам, он попал вам по недоразумению в 50-х, когда вы и страной-то не были)
Turkmenistan's GDP is quite wrong here. I assume that official currency rate is used here for calculating GDP in USD. But the problem is that the real rate (in black market) for local currency is 2.5-3 times worse compared to official ones. You just can't buy USD there using official rate.
The GDP is based on the wealth produced by a country, and what would be its value in dollars - it does not mean the income people in that country get, or what can they buy with that income. As Turkmenistan’s economy is strongly dependant on oil, gas and raw materials, the GDP fluctuates a lot, depending of the prices and demand of these materials.
Why on earth to link this militaristic Russian march with Baltic States Ukraine or Kazakhstan, Tajikistan etc so irrelevant and irritating for post Soviet non Russian States... unwise!
Подавать ВВП в номинале - давний способ манипуляции в расчёте на дурачков. В научном сообществе всегда используется ВВП в пересчёте на паритет покупательной способности (ППС), по которым ежегодно и ежеквартально публикуется много рейтингов от тех же МВФ, Всемирного банка, ОЭСР, ООН и пр., что является единственным научным методом сравнения уровня жизни и объёмов экономики по всем странам мира. В принципе, эти азы знает каждый студент первого курса экономического факультета. Но манипуляторы продолжают как ни в чем ни бывало))
@@Ls151000 есть две большие разницы. За 1000 долларов в месяц в большинстве стран мира ты вполне можешь прожить месяц, снимая жилье и питаясь нормальной едой. В США и небольшой дюжине других стран ты за эти же деньги сможешь месяц прожить разве что под мостом в картонной коробке. На трейлер и то не хватит (разве что внутри большой и шумной семьи из Гондураса). Именно поэтому, когда тебе дают сравнение ВВП в номинале - это в научном мире никто не воспринимает всерьез. Именно для этого все международные организации, сравнивая объемы национальных экономик и реальный уровень жизни (возможность приобрести определённый набор товаров и услуг внутри каждой экономики), всегда делают пересчёт ВВП на ППС, где учитывается и уровень внутренних цен на все, и уровень зарплат, и ставки тарифов, и что самое главное, заниженность или завышенность национальной валюты по отношению к доллару США. Большинство стран мира (даже Евросоюз) занижают курс своей национальной валюты к доллару различными, в том числе монетарными методами, так как это огромный залог их конкурентоспособности на международном рынке. И многое другое этот факт разным странам также даёт. Единственное, в номинале объёмы их экономик будут казаться в несколько раз меньше, чем это есть на самом деле. Это же касается и ВВП на душу населения. Именно для этого у экономистов есть международно признанный давно в науке и практике параметр - ВВП на душу населения в пересчёте на ППС. Учите матчасть!
After a decade of the most rightwing, freemarket economic policies (known as shock therapy), Russia in 2000 had a lower gdp than Russia in 1990 as apart of the USSR.
USSR GDP is a fake. USSR produced thousands of tanks every year and no one needed it, but it went to GDP. And they did it a few year after collapse of USSR.
@@mikaminskas Thats not how it works. GDP is calculated by adding consumer and gov spending, total investments, and net exports. If the gov bought a tank than the gdp increased. Thats how all country's gdp is calculated and for good reasons. The military usually takes up about 3% of gdp here in america does that make the US's gdp fake?
@@David-bh5le i don’t remember exact number, but Russia military budget in 93 was only 20% smaller than now(in dollars), but overal GDP was almost 4times smaller. Russian now has a military budget around 6% of GDP. So you can count. Also ussr were producing different outdated shit: outdated TVs, Radio, cars and etc. No one needed it anymore in ex-ussr countries because they got a normal electronic from western countries and these industries just died very fast.
@@mikaminskas yup, that is important, USSR economy wasn't even the market economy, so the GDP doesn't make a lot of sense if we wan't to count it the normal way in communist countries.
@@nur-alijanqojayev329 yeah i guess so, this is why i dislike Russia. but ppl and media are* kinda lovely* to follow, even planning live in Kazan and Moscow i remember when after the sanctions Kazak ppl started to buy cheap Russian products (cars for example) and then our Government decided to change the money policy and then Russian came to re-buy now our cheap goods then I felt like a backup country for Russia xD
uhh EU isn bad at all :D and 80% of the russians who live in Baltics agree, most russians know that they have better lives in EU than in Russia :D especially right now
В этом видео можно увидеть, как потенциальные экономики (Россия, Украина, Беларусь, Казахстан) проебали все из-за политики своих правительств и министерств экономики, при этом особенно интересно следить за Украиной и Беларусью, как упало все не важно кто у власти - диктатор или коррупционер. Любопытно так же заметить как "вонючие прибалты", которые, как бы, "пропили советское наследие", вырвались за 30 лет далеко вперед даже от той же России, у которой есть нефтегазовая труба.
По ВВП на душу населения Литва обошла Португалию и Грецию (2020 г.) :Р Послушайте сегодня интервью нашего посла (Баярунас) на ЭМ. Он об этом сказал. Кроме того по средней, минимальной з/п и пенсиям Литва в последние 2 года ОБОШЛА Эстонию, которую догоняли;) А сегодня еще новость: в Литве изобретено ЛЕКАРСТВО от Ковид-19, первое в мире! Сейчас оно отправлено в Швейцарию на испытания. И на подходе второе лекарство. В Литве будут производиться и уже разработанные западные вакцины. А экспресс-тесты мы уже сами готовим и экспортируем. Вывод из видео Вы сделали правильный. Спасибо.
@@Den2067 О, пригожинский нарисовался! :D Отрабатываешь на дезе? Прежде чем туфту втюхивать, погугли: страны-доноры и страны-реципиенты в ЕС по годам. И посмотри % и суммы дотаций из бюджета ЕС, куда, кстати, ВСЕ страны ЕС перечисляют свои средства, в т.ч. и Литва. Литва там далеко не в лидерах. Огромная дотационная помощь идет, ты удивишься, Греции, Португалии, даже Испании, балканским странам и... Польше. Дотации ВСЕГДА идут на конкретные программы и цели, например, на культурные цели, восстановление древних памятников архитектуры, реновацию домов, дороги и пр. При этом 50% конкретной программы оплачивает страна-реципиент из СОБСТВЕННОГО БЮДЖЕТА! И осуществляется строгий контроль за использованием выделенных средств со стороны соответствующих финансовых органов ЕС. У нас не воруют и работают на совесть, поэтому и результаты такие. Я в предыдущем комментарии не упомянула, что Литва обошла по уровню з/п не только Эстонию, которую привела в пример, но и всегда обходила Польшу, и некоторые страны Центральной Европы, не говоря и о балканских странах, за исключением Словении. Про наличие промышленности и производств в Литве также советую погуглить. Удивишься. Но тебе это не надо. Вот когда вы в России догоните Литву хотя бы по уровню средней и минимальной з/п (1524 и 642 евро соответственно), которая у нас постоянно повышается... тогда можешь тут шипеть. В Вильнюсе средняя з/п на уровне 2000 евро + -. Часто ваши тролли про цены начинают верещать. Судя по вашим ценам, в Литве продукты не дороже, а местного производства (молочные и мясные, овощи) даже дешевле. А если сравнивать продукты в Литве и, например, во Франции, то у нас в разы дешевле. Но ты там вряд ли бывал ;) А мы ездим практически по всему миру БЕЗ ВИЗ, даже в США. А в ЕС не только свободно передвигаемся, но и можем там учиться, работать, покупать недвижимость, открывать бизнес, не меняя гражданства и не выпрашивая вид на жительство... Так что Sergej B. был прав, а тебе остается исходить желчью и бессильной злобой от зависти:)
@@Den2067 P.S. Только что зашла на наш новостной портал. И увидела новость как раз в тему: до конца этого года минимальная з/п в Литве будет повышена до 704 евро. Это еще одно преимущество членства в ЕС. Существует требование регулярно повышать уровень з/п до постепенного достижения среднего по ЕС. % повышения з/п задан для каждой страны отдельно в зависимости от отставания.
@@Sandra-Kristina вечно путаю Литву с Латвией и Эстонией. Как то ни в информационном пространстве, ни в магазине ничего о вас не напоминает. Кроме как ваши политики что то брякнут в адрес России очередной раз))
Потому что в совке все деньги уходили туда в Прибалтику. За счёт остальных их развивали. И Россию развивали за счёт остальных. Все стройли в России и Прибалтике.
@@altynadam4343 Not logical at all. After leaving USSR GDP of Baltic states should be decreased then but quite opposite happens. Actually same process is going on in Russia today - almost all regions in Russia get poorer, and Moscow get richer and richer. Baltic states give ~20-25% of their GDP to Russian military needs.
As a Latvian this makes me happy. Long life Baltic! 🇱🇻❤️🇪🇪🇱🇹 Now every russian that said Latvia is poor... Do you even know what it's like to have money? 😂
For such charts use PPP values, not nominal ones. Nominal values are inherently poor for such comparisons because they rely on currency exchange rates and ignore differences in purchasing power - a weakening of a given currency will be displayed as a contraction in nominal terms in $ although the actual economy has not contracted or even grown. Adjustment by PPP eliminates substantial distortions caused by exchange fluctuations. For instance, in 1997 the Russian economy reported very slight growth but the chart shows an epic collapse in dollar terms that did not take place.
Well, the purchasing power still depends on the exchange rate a lot. You can buy shit for national money but ultimately the good stuff is still imported. To get imports, usually you need foreign currency and stuff.
both should be used, PPP doesnt tell the whole story. just a simple expample: yes, you might buy potatoes cheaper but smartphones cost pretty much the same everywhere. going abroad the income in nominal matters much more than ppp. best is when both are high.
wrong. company's tend to ignore economic differences, and so things are priced the same. 1000 USD for a smartphone, and the equivilent of 1000 USD for russia.
@@ksudenisova2462 Я должен сделать ваш смех очень грустным, всего около 5-6% бюджета. И эти деньги не пойдут ни в карманы олигархов, ни в президентские золотые дворцы. Каждый евроцент идет на целевые проекты, по всей стране проводится большая работа. В результате страна с каждым годом становится лучше, современнее и организованнее. Тот, кто смеется после, смеется лучше.
Что показывали? Номинальный ВВП той же Литвы ниже, чем у Танзании и Узбекистана. А номинальный ВВП на душу насления - это просто ВВП поделенный на количество людей в стране. Если в стране депопуляция, то он будет расти даже при стагнации номинального ВВП.
@@benguru2697 ворьё обидели? Прибежали едросню защищать?)) Высокий ВВП показывает, что если не узурпировать власть и не воровать из бюджета строя себе, детям и любовницам дворцы можно достойно жить даже в маленькой стране не имеющей природные ресурсы. Ясно, что вам, единоросам и их обслуге это больно. В такой стране не построишь себе дворец будучи каким-нибудь генеральным прокурором или соседом по кабинету в питерской мэрии в «лихие 90-е». Насчёт депопуляции. Киселев вам не скажет, но в прошлом году население России сократилось более чем на 500 тыс человек, чего не было (в РСФСР) с 1945 года.
99 год - очухались от кризиса, реформы уже работают - понеслись в гору (потом ещё и нефть начала возвращаться к своим стандартным показателям) 2012-13 - и к рынку уже привыкли, нефть уже три года по 110, но всё равно в минуса пошли…
@@LESORUBBB да, хороший рост (конечно низкая база), но даже тогда бедную Португалию так и не догнали на душу, по сто метровой квартире не получили, жкх… ( (У меня есть, но я осознаю своё положение) А сейчас и не обещают даже.
But emigration from there is beating all world records for last decade. And vice versa: emigration from Russia virtually stops in first decade of 21st century and still didn't restarted. Can you explain these facts? They show the _real_ situation way better than "spherical horse" of charts and numbers.
Been watching a load of your videos, they're really entertaining. Do you think you could do a video showing nominal GDP from 1800-2020 showing the British Empire as one economic entity? Keep up the good videos!
1. It displays that it makes sense to play together with rest of Europe (see the baltic states) 2. As an Austrian/German I love Estonia. The drive for digitalization is what I miss so much here. I hope Estonia becomes the European Silicone Valley.
It can't because Estonia is too small and can't attract skilled people from eastern Europe. Czechia or Poland has a much better chance for that. Czechia profits from being a popular destination for skilled Russians, Belarusians and Ukrainians. It's beneficial to be able to attract skilled workforce from 200 million population. Not only that but also other developing countries like Brazil or India. You may be surprised but they are willing to immigrate to Czechia. Estonia will always suffer from simply being too small and on the edge of the EU.
@Ярослав Л No it's war plans of central powers in 1914. They are the real victors. Russia collapsed and independent states broke off. But you should blame communists and revolutionaries of 1917. Without them Russia would have won WW1 and remained intact. What happened cannot be undone.
It wouldn't say much. Exchanging or owning dollars was something that would put you in jail, so the government could set any exchange rate it wanted. They didn't trade with the West much anyway. Because the economy was so imbalanced, you couldn't always buy basic necessities like butter or meat even if your salary was relatively high. Things like cars or TVs or washing machines were insanely expensive, most people couldn't afford a car after 20 years of saving. Most urban households didn't have things like washing machines or hair dryers, microwaves were unheard of. Long story short, all of my grandparents insist(ed) life is much better now (Ukraine).
@@themeiafy Actually ita wasn't so but about cars yes. But anyway even the life in the Western Europe at the same time was quite similar. The things changed from 85-86... For example in Italy in 82 the car price starts from 5 millions lires when awerage salary was 300k-400k lires and there wasn't such a think like bank's credits like we all have today, so if you had savings to buy a car you buy it, if not you use a bicicle or take a bus to go to work. The problem with basic things in USSR starts with Gorby's Perestroyka..
@@sergeypopov801 What are you talking about? Life wasn't nearly the same in the West. At least people there could actually BUY a house, instead of being at the mercy of the government. They could go wherever they wanted. Rural residents didn't even have passports in USSR until mid 1970-ies! They'd be attested if they were caught outside of their place of residence. And it's not like they could do farming, either. All they could do was work at a collective farm for a salary which could only buy them bread. Yes, there was no deficit until 1980-ies, but you could only choose from 2-3 brands at best. And I'm talking most basic things like sausage or candy, not something crazy. And it's not like people could afford those outside of a capital, they were dirt poor. Even buying a clothes item was a big problem, except maybe for like 5-10 "good" (slightly better, in fact) years.
@@themeiafy dude lot if people frim Kolhoz hadn't passport cause they ligelly didn't need it. It wasn't necessary to have a passport if you lived in rural areas. There wasn't need to show ID (passport in russian cause in west theu called pasdport what we called traveling or external passport) when you buy a ticke in siviet times. Yes we don't had 300 tipes of shampoo or shoes like in the west but we had 5 tipes and you could buy them in every shop of the coutry. Yes in the west you could buy a house or a car immediately but only if you had a money, in ussr you get a house for free and also cars was given for free for some job achievemnts and yes, some people waits for yers for them but only a small part of people. I grew up during soviet times and i remember it well. Communism wasn't better or wors than capitalism. It was just different system with different problems. And yes we lived in exactly same way like western europeans. I've spent 15 year of my life living and workin in Italy, Germany and France and saw the family photos of lot of people, heard a lot of stories about how the life was in past. Just google the Beatles's photos before the became famouse, you can see that they lived like us. Ofcourse in capitalism you can get rich and live like a God, in communism you can't neither if you was a high rank party member, but common people, the workers, lived in ecatly same way cause as i said there wasn't a Mutual credit system in western Europe in those times so if someone saved enoght money it could buy a house or a car, if not he couldn't. We, soviets, often had to wait in queques for them but as i said your position in queque was depending of lot of factors like was you a good citizen that respect laws and works good, was you a smoker or drink, had you just a medium school grade or you had finished the university, what kind of studies you've choosen an etc.. All those factors influenced your position in quequesto get a house or a car. About the restant good i can garantee that we had everything. My grandparents were "poor" acvording to awerage soviet salary, they in two earns 150 rubles while my mother, a mining engeneer gainhad same salary alone. The life was really cheap a those times. With 150 ruble you could live for two month alone or gan mantain the family of two adult and 2 kids for a month. That's why a lot of families had only one income made generally by father and lived good.
@@sergeypopov801 What a lot of nonsense. I could stop reading at "didn't need a passport". It's not like they could get it if they needed it. And they didn't need it because they WEREN'T ALLOWED to do anything aside from working at a state farm. And yes you could get an apartment for free, but it would probably be either a room with 5 other families, or you'd have to wait for it for 25 years and live with your parents and kids in a two-room apartment. Nice, isn't it? You'd have to be REALLY nice to certain people if you wanted something better. Please stop BS-ing me, I'd rather read Pravda newspaper if I wanted some Soviet propaganda. I know how things were in real life, not in newspapers
This is totally excellent. Could you please move the flags to the RIGHT of the the bars and the NAME of the countries to the LEFT so that we can SEE name of the country not trying to guess what the flag represents = most of the names are hidden on the left in this graph which is very annoying!!
lay down claims on transnistria, and suddenly there is no conflict anymore in moldava, then join romania, and be part of EU. we have nice money for developing regions. you gonna get high speed rail and infrastructure, and some subventions for agriculture etc. thats much better then claims on the shithole on the other side of the river
@@beorlingo I think, from a believer living in a poor country myself, it's more about finding some comfort, some guiding force in your existing living conditions. It's not about asking god/gods/entity for actual monetary richness, but for finding spiritual richness and guidance while you try to escape poverty.
@@danielgeller7629 So what you are saying is that all countries with high populations should be poor and non-productive and small countries should be rich and well functioning?
@@leonidasg2257 you just said some bullshit. What is the "big daddy governance type"? And Estonia is the first in the list, because its population is stupidly 2 times lower than the for example Lithuanian. Estonia doesnt even produce anything
@@danielgeller7629 By big daddy government I ment that Estonia was the first country to move away from a big central government model and liberalize its economy. Most post soviet countries are today still run by the governmnt and a few oligarchs, are full of corruption and struggle to make any progress. Also population has NOTHING to do with it. If you dont understand what gdp PER CAPITA is, there is no point talking to you.
The upper part of the list is the same - just Lithuania has surpassed Estonia due to lower prices there and Russia has a bigger number for real living standards - still fourth, over 10000 dollars behind Estonia. There are more components in that kind of comparison - Lithuania has much higher taxes than Estonia, so after taxes Estonia has still the highest salaries and buying power.
Well, once I bought perfect cheese in Tallinn for just 1€ for a 150g pack. It brought me gack to childhood. The same cheese, but without smell and taste, can be purchased in Moscow for at least 2€. So tell me how Russia can have 28.000 by purchasing power? Moreover, 11.000$ is an average number, you know Russia has huge gap between the richest and poorest ones. Estonian 22.000$ per capita, opposite, literally mean 22.000$ per almost everyone who's involved in labour market. It's sad to admit, but Russia has failed with its corruption and weird ambitions outside the country. People's wealth is not a priority for our ruler.
You’re such uneducated and narrow minded person that there no sense to explain how many people those countries lost due to immigration and luck of well paying jobs. How many factories and other industrial objects (like nuclear power stations) were closed by force of UN. Those countries now called Прибалтийские Вымираты! And that’s why they SO SUCCESSFUL that they are begging for financial help from UN, military help from US, and contribution money from Russia. Oh! Yeah! Jump from nothing to top!!!! They used to be called FACE of USSR, now they’re called the BUTT of Europe!
@@ninaakari5181 Oh yeah! Be afraid! By the way, could you remind us, what only country in the world used nuclear bombs against civilians, killing at least 200k right away?!
@@haeveen8255 Not gonna lie, I think they would be better without EU... they are between the most libertarian countries in the world, despite having low resources.
@@jonnymario771 Hello from Estonia! My country's north-eastern part is mostly Russian-speaking and without European open market economic stimulus within EU and military presence by NATO this region could well be like Crimea or Eastern Ukraine.
@@toivotraks I see, the stimilus was from their economy. But you guys, for example, didnt even need public education for developing. Compare to my country, Brazil, with lots of public/universal shenannigans and we are a piece of crap, even with a huge country and lots of resources. Free market economies are way beyond rigged countries like mine. What I meant about the EU is that you guys are like the top tier of Europe, IMO.
@@mishacol Imagine assuming that I am American or that I like America lmfao. "u dont like my ex-commie cleptocratic shitfest, you must love usa" ::))))))
"How come Baltics can live without Russia?" - Very simply, they are dying out and sitting on the neck of the EU. Let them continue this way at the expense of the EU :)
@@tnickknight Well, it depends entirely on what you want to measure. If we talk about growth, I think productivity is far a more direct indicator than consumption. (In an extreme case: You can consume a lot, but if you are not producing, you even expose yourself to the same problems of poorly planned socialism.)
Kazakhstan 1991: 20 times smaller than Russia, 3 times smaller than Ukraine Kazakhstan 2019: 9 times smaller than Russia, 1.17 times larger than Ukraine. Behold the power of Kazakhs! our secret is superior potassium of course
This is the key question! Just three Baltic nations took right decisions after collapse of the USSR. Look at CIS countries, look at Russia with its enormous potential and resources!
Yes, and that was the only right decision they made. Baltic countries, except for Estonia, are stagnating and dying out. I'm glad the European passport provided me with the opportunity to move to a developed European country from there.
@@nimkati5627 Lithuania is on par with Estonia, Latvia not far behind. And you got your European passport to move in Europe - unlike Russians - thanks to Baltic countries being in EU and Schengen. And after that right decision we are moving in the right direction - unlike the rest of CIS.
@@nimkati5627 I'm an average pensioner in Estonia, supplementing my income a bit by working a little. I'm living, not surviving! To say otherwise seems quite offensive to me. I can easily cope with my living expenses, I can have a full cultural life, I can travel abroad before and after covid, I can use all electronic things provided by my country, I'm socially insured. Best greetings from Estonia and good luck for living in a developed country!
Also, keep in mind not just the sheer GDP per capita but also the sources of this income. Selling natural raw resources vs. industrial products and services is not the same thing.
@@bigjim1041 in the USSR nobody believed it as well. But it happened. It will happen in the US as well. And it looks like we don't have to wait too long
@@adinik3960 Many Russians use just GDP (PPP) to underline and boast their greatness - totally ignoring per capita that reduces that greatness catastrophically.
@@toivotraks What has Russia to do with it? It doesn't matter to me, the important thing is that PPP GDP is the main indicator of the economy. And Russia is considered a wealthy country, is in the top 50 countries in terms of GDP in terms of PPP per capita from more than 200 countries of the world and is also included in the number of developed countries according to the HDI index.
@@MalleusImperiorum Don't know what Clinton has to do with this, but if you take a look to the Index of Economic Freedon by the Heritage Foundation, Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia are mostly free states. All the rest have lower scores, they're more restricted. That implies things such as weaker property rights, less monetary, financial, trade, investment and business freedom, and/or higher tax burden. Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, and Central Asia ex-Soviet nations are classified from "moderately free" to "mostly unfree". Many of these countries have liberalized their economies more in the latest years, though.
@@SnipermanElite In the 90's most of these countries were under direct control from Washington D.C., the US (being the world champion of liberal freedoms and democracy) had an opportunity to make these countries as free as they get. There were lots of talks about authoritarianism of socialism and freedoms of capitalism - now that they were free to choose their leaders and free to become billionaires. So, what happened? Why are they so dirt poor and obviously worse off than before the 90's? Where did all the Western promises go? No way the US advisors lied to them just to plunder their countries, to sell off for nothing and bankrupt thousands of Soviet enterprises! It couldn't be!.. Hmm, maybe if they try the same thing they will finally live like Scandinavians instead?..
@@SnipermanElite Just so you know, the Heritage Foundation is an American conservative rightist organisation sponsored by oil oligarchs. They would easily rank Hitler's Germany the most "economically free", as long as it's allied with the US, of course..
@@СэрВортон So i guess that's poverty is better then stop undermine western countries.... Yep russian logic. Astonia is amazing and a model to all the developed and developing countries.
It was inevitable, your production methods and the things you are producing are out of date, and suddenly the real value of said machinery and product are staring you in the face. The other problem was the immense arms production was all but useless, nobody wants it nor can they afford it. The T-55 was the most produced tank in the world, but it has no real market value.
@@toivotraks when market destroys your economy and sends 50 million into unemployment with everything being sold for pennies, as these countries enter into recession for the first time after 70 years and life expectancy drops by almost a decade but it's still gomunizms fault... So fucking delusional
@@nationalist1389 It's called an economic recession. Economic recessions could occur when a country artificially increases its economic value through overestimulating the economy. It could happen in the context of use of loans from banks without any government intervention like happened in 2.008, or in that case, with an economic system that is overestreched by producing many products considered obsolete, out of demand. You can correct me if I'm wrong. Sorry for my English, it's not my first language.
@@nationalist1389 as the other guy already mentioned, its the switch from communism to capitalism that caused a big recession, probably since when they opened their markets, they just couldnt compete with foreign products. Regardless, i dont need to tell you that communism doesnt work. Look at cuba, look at china, even China is partially privatising their industry (going more capitalist) because they know communism is the inferior economic system. It's sad, but true. And no political propaganda should keep you from checking facts.
Agree. It's the same story with average salary. On paper situation is good, but if you count how many people actually receive it and mention things like taxes, prices etc, then it's a completely different statistics.
PPP will make minor adjustments. Due to lower prices, Lithuania has replaced Estonia as first while Russia is still fourth - although a little nearer to "fabulous three".
All of these countries are shells of what they could have been had the soviets not existed, if the Whites won in the Russian civil war than all of these would be much, much richer.
@@evzenvarga9707 Which ones are white? This movement retained its integrity only because of a common enemy, and inside it there were many conflicting trends, some of them hated each other.
Yet the free market seems to have failed literally every other post-Soviet state outside the Baltics. Its a shame too since almost 80% of Soviet citizens voted to keep the union together in a referendum but it was dissolved anyways because of capitalists
@@darklibertario5001 Lol. In 90's Russia had absolute zero interference of goverment in economy. We all saw how it ended so no it's not abou a state control, it's about what the west did. Estonia had the most advanced elctronic industry in USSR so after collapse of it, Estonian industry was integrated in NATO's production chains while in other ex republics with free market and zero goverment controll entire industry was sold for ridiculouse prices to the mafia members that then did'n upgrade it or make it works but just cut it in pieces and sold for original or right prices. That's how the Oligachs has apperaed and that's why almost all ex soviet repubblics had economic falls in 90's and some of the have it even today. For example Russia is still rebuilding it industry while Ukraine is still cutting and selling.
@@maxon5153 In the end- you lost lots of dead weight (regions who elect pro-Russian parties), and that pushed Ukraine to finally 'mobilise' and start to actually build the state: rebuild army, expand the use of Ukrainian language, return Ukrainian church, etc. Hopefully soon you will get invitation to NATO and then EU- that would allow fast growth over the next decades, to become a power state, and be at/near the top in these charts.
What stuns me how the West did virtually nothing during or after the Russo-Georgian War in 2008. Some folks don't even seem to remember it ever happened. They got scolded and their economy was allowed to roar on, the US let them participate in RIMPAC military exercises in 2012, and of course they got to host the Sochi Olympics. It was only when Ukraine had a piece get lopped off that the western countries started to actually care and hold them accountable.
All those GDP are bullshit. Lets say in Ukraine you can make Haircut for 2 euros . In Latvija you have to pay 7 euros. Same haircut , difference more than 3 times. What you have to consider is how much person earns and how much the person has left after necessary spending.
@@toivotraks This is what I want to say. A person living in, let's say, Estonia, and earning 1300 euros, can have the same living standard as a person earning 500 euro in Ukraine.
@@janjarik How i know? I and we have lots of Ukrainian work buddys in here who travel half Europa to live and work in Estonia. Why they come here? for 7 Eur haircut? idi..t
Once Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia join the EU their economies will be growing like the Baltic states as well. Unless that selfish Mr Putin tries to stop them.
@@harakitty2058 of course. The Greek and Spanish economies and living standards are far stronger today than they were when the joined the EEC in the 1980s. Before the pandemic the Greek economy had a growth rate of 1.9%. That's better than UK economic growth of 1.4%.
@@harakitty2058 Greece had corrupted governments and Spain it still is a good place to live in. Otherwise, westerners would buy properties in Sochi instead of Southern Spain.
Georgian economy is doing great considering Russian economical war and 4 real wars in last 30 years + Georgians have 300 000 Refugees in country, 8% of population .
@@spectre2889 no, PPP - purshasing power parity, this is parity in prices. Every economical statistics without PPP are wrong, because for example prices in Ukraine 4 times lower than in Russia in US $. Factually, Ukrainian GDP PPP per cappita is same as Russian, but in this statistics Ukrainian 4 times lower.
@@toivotraks Yes,they are,a lot of russians buy stuff from Ukraine and sell them in Russia getting 4 times more money So yeah,if you want to go to Eastern Europe I recommend Ukraine:the prices are 4 times lower
When you go up one place because your economy is not disintegrating as fast as the other countries' 😎
because your population disintegrates faster than your economy😎
In Estonia neither population nor economy is disintegrating - quite the opposite, thank you.
@@toivotraks it is. your “economy” is mostly a donations from EU and most of your people are working in biggest EU countries not in Estonia, same with every Baltic country. you just a small dying village, nothing else
@@NikitaLemeshev-e8r Another troll from Russia who even can't write decent English. Head overloaded with total trash and idiotic notions. I am absolutely indifferent what you believe - it doesn't change the reality of things even a little bit. End of line for you. Bye!
@@NikitaLemeshev-e8r Your grandparents used to trash talk America. Now they are ashamed of their grandchildren trash talking small countries that are still doing better than Russia lol. Russia is honestly such a waste of space that does more harm than good to the world. Should just nuke itself already.
Russia’s GDP doesn’t shrink, it just increases backwords
Very well said
I was the 200th person who liked your comment
It's actually a thing in Russia. News use unusual words to describe stuff. For example we won't have news " 2 people died in gas explosion" but " clap happened in a house". And when our economy sinks its "negative grow". My government trying their hardest to avoid negative feedback
US, GDP: 17 Trillion. National Debt: 24 Trillion. Russia, GDP: 1,3 Trillion, National Debt: 150 billion (and even that obligatorily, as guarantees for participation in the international banking system. But the biggest sham, is the information in the West about Lithuania. The claim of 19k as personal annual income in Lithuania, is beyond comical. I 've visited the country more than 6 times since 2011, it is in complete and utter disarray, it is a disaster. I have a Lithuanian person right now and mentioned this to her: Her answer: "19 thousand dollars?"? "Yes". "19 Thousand dollars?","Yes". "Did they perhaps mean ONE THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED year?".
@@nomayor1 that's 900EUR net monthly. A high schooler can get this much in Vilnius, tf you're talking about
The last 3 couldn't even make it to the point of having their names printed.
what country’s where they?
@@Ryan_7389 Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgystan (if you consider per capita)
@@kbboy101 thanks
Lol, i could only tell wich one is Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Georgia by the flags
Eghem, Poland? XD
When can be my full name displayed?
- When you're at the top of the list, now shut up ...stan!
When you binge bald and bankrupt and this video gets recommended
You reading my algorithm my dude
Same here!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Any video with the word “Soviet”
True story
Russia: "we dont care about your sanctions!"
*loses half gdp*
Russia: "We don't depend on exporting oil"
Oil prices drop.
Loses half GDP with the further help from sanctions.
Yeah, but for example agriculture exports is all time high. Beating giants like US or France in grain market. "Thanks" to these sanctions, russians have to depend mainly on themselves.
@Олег Широбоков птн пнх
They got sanctioned by the world's largest market and still managed to recover their economy within a few years, yet the actions they got sanctioned for still stand.
@Олег Широбоков Yeah but the communists are much worse than the Nazis. At least the Nazis were all sent to prison. Where are the communists now? Any communist in prison? The communists are still murdering, poisoning and terrorizing Eastern Europeans!
As Lithuanian watching this - every second my smile becomes bigger and bigger :D
Почему это?
Love wishes from Sweden to the baltic states, we hope for flourishing economy for you guys
Yes, as your country loses ~30% of population since "independence"
@@namesurname-1488 mad cus bad
Looked like the economy was flourishing up to 2003 but then it stagnated until like 2015
One interesting fact is also that Estonia's GDP per capita was actually higher than Finland's prior to WW2. It would be a prosperous country today comparable to Nordics if they weren't captured by soviets back then.
Same with Latvia and Lithuania.
pretty much the same situation is the rest of Baltics. Actually they aren't any "baltics" they are new prosperous North
You realise that the Nordics were poor before they discovered oil?
You could say the same with Romania, it was a functional democracy and had a modern capitalist economy. Bucharest was nicknamed Little Paris...
Communism did a lot of damage in the world...
@@psychout3481 What oil in Finland and Sweden - LOL.
2:12 Man, Kazakhs were richer then Russians.
Also happy for Baltic states, maybe one day all the post-Soviet countrys will become as great as they are. And I really want to visit Baltic states, especially Estonia 🇪🇪. With all love from Kazakhstan! 🇰🇿
Thank you for your kind words! Best greetings from Estonia!
Interestingly in the last few years, Ukraine grew but Kazakhstan stagnated.
@@toivotraks Привет, Эстония! Мы вам очень завидуем и надеемся, что однажды наши страны тоже будут для всех людей, а не для кучки лжецов и воров у власти. С наилучшими пожеланиями
@@rudythoraxx Хорошие видео на русском про Эстонию. С наилучшими пожеланиями из Эстонии!
The GDP of the Baltic States is so high because they receive constant subsidies from the EU and do not have the cost of the army and they have small countries ,but in fact they sold all their factories and the last railways for scrap and live only on subsidies.
I'm amazed with Estonia Latvia and Lithuania. May be these countries is the world fastest countries turning from low income to high income countries.
Yeh and high rice of all prices , you can buy less with your salary compare to 2010
Cuz these countries are so small
There are no people in these countries everyone left for Western Europe that’s the reason.
these are simply the fastest dying countries in Europe and the world-together with Romania and Bulgaria-when 30 % of the population left, and the rest live on EU subsidies or die
OR maybe the world fastest countries loosing their population... it's statistics, dude
Nominal and Per Capita together, this is an excellent idea. Would love to see for all other countries
Russia sacrificed 10 years of growth for Crimea lmao (edit, thanks for all the replies, this comment was partly a nutshell joke but thank to everyone who hasn't been toxic! I've learned many things)
You should keep in mind USD to RUB currency and that in those data GDP showed in USD. So if you have economic growth 10% for example, but USD to RUB come from 35\1 to 50\1 it will show you negative growth, which in reality doesn't make much sense
@@jurgeeen bla bla bla enjoy 80 rub for a dollar and drink vodka
The have no choice. The western bloc has eaten their words of not letting the NATO expanding east. In short, if EU accepts Russia Russia would join immediately. R.I.P. Russian struggling against sanction.
@@jurgeeen And show these data in roubles - Russia stands in one place while all the rest take off like mad. Why please is rouble falling to 90 roubles -1 euro and more, if the economy is so strong? These tables have to use stable currencies.
@@dukenukem8381 aw yes, economics are hard so I'll just call you an alchohlic
Alternate title:
Estonia trying to join the nordic countries be like:
Edit: lol its just a meme why did the comment section become a warzone
We are just good in faking statistics :)))
Despite being called former Soviet republics, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania were de jure aren’t part of the Soviet Union, but independent nations under occupation.
@@SilverPlaqueVII yeah, the baltics were under "Illegal occupation" having been neutral through ww2 until Germany invaded them, and soviets performed coups in the baltics
@@SilverPlaqueVII de jure we can state whatever we want but in reality.. Estonia joined into USSR with elections (yes possibly fraud) but still there werent any military conflict while joining nor mass protests - also it worth to notice that (!)many(!) hi-rank communist party members continued it's political career after Estonia gained independence (if it would be that much occupation previously they would end up in jail not in government in independent Estonia). Estonian president A.Rüütel, Estonian prime ministers S.Kallas, E.Savisaar and A.Ansip and many others were hi rank communists - You can check that fact even from their wikipedia pages - it is not conspiracy.
@@maitsepolitsei I wouldn't be surprised if estonians were too scared to rise up. I've read that nearly every single native ingrian was sent to concentration camps and dispersed across Russia, with hundreds of thousands of them being brutally murdered after attempting to gain independence/join Finland in around 1919/1920. that would still be fresh in the memory of estonians during ww2.
Yay Baltic ❤️ Love And Support All From U.S.A 🇪🇪🇱🇹🇱🇻🇰🇿🇷🇺🇹🇲🇧🇾🇦🇿🇬🇪🇦🇲🇲🇩🇺🇿🇰🇬🇹🇯🇺🇦
@man with square mustache I feel like it was congratulating the Baltic's, and then showing love for all countries that used to be apart of the USSR
@@mz2535 yes thry do teach us where and what the baltic countries are! After Latvia, i put the rest after refrencing to the “ love and support all “ thing
Support 😏😅
Perkamoji galia Lietuvoje didesnė, didesnis 'juodųjų' pinigų kiekis. Didesni mokėjimai grynaisais, daugiau išmokama pinigų neoficialiai susitarus dėl darbo užmokesčio. Verslai linkę nepasikliauti valstybės mokesčių politika, didesnė dalis verslų išnaudoja teikiamas lengvatas, nors atitikimo kriterijus minimalus. tai dar vis postsovietinis mentalitetas.
The country names should be placed right behind the numbers so they can always be visible to the viewers.
You can watch the flags
@@anghelusz1 Not alot of people can recognize the flags of 206 countries on Earth. Name is still the best way.
@@namviet7998 then they should, specially if they are trying to understand something about geopolitical history
@@anghelusz1 Your comment makes no sense. No one should spend hours to try to learn all the flags in the world for a 3-minute video clip whose main purpose is to entertain. Geopolitics? Please. The data in these types of video aren't even entirely accurate and verified. Just an extrapolation of data collected from unknown sources. As a UA-cam content creator, one should make his/her video more accessible to everyone so they can enjoy and understand said video. And then maybe they can learn the countries and their flags while watching it too. And that's the point of my original comment.
@@namviet7998 then you could watch another video or search and read the original documents.
Yet another load of information I needed
Really nice on the information
I’m glad you enjoyed!
This is shit info Moldova gdp pro capite in 2005 was 700 euro not 1175 dolari .
@@adrianciobanu5856 Sir, the euro is more valuable than dollar. So it makes total sense to the average moldovan making more dollars than euros, at least numerically speaking.
the first transition really doesn't show how vastly gdp per capita dropped from 1990-1991 in every country
It was probably fake numbers. Most Soviet citizens were paid fynny salaries and most of their assets were handouts such as state apartments.
@@kritasto2813 Oh it was fucking real; you ask the citizens, look up life expectancy.
I'm wondering how much of the economic growth in Russia can be explained by the rise in commodity prices between 2009 and 2013. And the effect of the fluctuation of the oil price on their GDP. Would be useful to explain if the production capacity of Russia actually increased or if just the prices of their goods increased.
Russia: You can't defeat me
Estonia: I know, but he can
*2014 Russian financial crisis*
@@madehtml5me It was oil prices tanking for the most part.
All three Baltic countries Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania are absolutely unprofitable states subsidized by the European Union, with industry destroyed by the West after the collapse of the USSR , with a population that leaves there every year for other European countries, in fact, these are countries of limitrofa
@@макслюлюкин Could you provide sources for this? Not because I disagree, in fact I'm writing an essay right now arguing exactly this and extra sources would be helpful.
@@madehtml5me кхм пук русские люди в Крыму проголосовали за присоединение к России на референдуме, потому что они русские и им не нравилось давление на русскоговорящее население на Украине, но это неправильно, так не должно быть, Украинацеевропа!!!
Очнись, чел, по европейским стандартам право на самоопределение граждан важнее территориальной целостности. Единственная причина, почему к Крыму отнеслись не так, как к Косову, это то, что люди там русские. Но Крым уже не вернётся к вам, он попал вам по недоразумению в 50-х, когда вы и страной-то не были)
@@макслюлюкин And Russia is 100% unprofitable fascist dictatorship sponsored by oil revenue🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣enjoy ur victory drunk vatnik🙃
I love the Baltics. Hi from Kazakhstan!
Hi from Estonia!
hi, and thanks from latvia
Hi, and a thanks for Lithuania! And that makes a nice chain going down just like in real life.
Respect and love from turkey to our relatives
Hello from Latvia, Thanks for your opinion. Alga Kazakhstan!
I like how Moldova just goes up and down like a friking rubber ball
It's like a tiny Argentina but in Western Europe lol.
@@SnipermanElite rather mexico or colombia.
@@SnipermanElite It's not in Western Europe though.
@@SnipermanElite Eastern*
Turkmenistan's GDP is quite wrong here. I assume that official currency rate is used here for calculating GDP in USD. But the problem is that the real rate (in black market) for local currency is 2.5-3 times worse compared to official ones. You just can't buy USD there using official rate.
Näme ýazanyñyza düşünmedim yöne siziñ Türkmendiğinizi bilýärin ! 🇹🇲🇹🇲🇹🇲
The GDP is based on the wealth produced by a country, and what would be its value in dollars - it does not mean the income people in that country get, or what can they buy with that income. As Turkmenistan’s economy is strongly dependant on oil, gas and raw materials, the GDP fluctuates a lot, depending of the prices and demand of these materials.
@@Eddieteddy965 GDP is always calculated in local currency. And then it is converted to USD based on official exchange rates.
Putin: haha crimea is russia
Economy: it was good life, proschajte, patsany!
rofl
@@zlaya_ytochka goodbye economy haha xD
@@sergeygorlovmsk похуй
@@Mememememes why?
@@sergeygorlovmsk because it's all in dollars, while in Russia a bill payment (water, electricity, etc.) is about $40 per month.
Hmm.. interesting topic mate, nice work👍
Thanks! 🙏
This is awesome, and so is the music! 😃👋
I'm glad you enjoy both!
Марш "Прощание славянки"...
hello
@Aaron Tirmanator *piece
Why on earth to link this militaristic Russian march with Baltic States Ukraine or Kazakhstan, Tajikistan etc so irrelevant and irritating for post Soviet non Russian States... unwise!
Proud to be Estonian
💩
👍😉 Greetings to that great country ❤🇪🇪🎉
Подавать ВВП в номинале - давний способ манипуляции в расчёте на дурачков. В научном сообществе всегда используется ВВП в пересчёте на паритет покупательной способности (ППС), по которым ежегодно и ежеквартально публикуется много рейтингов от тех же МВФ, Всемирного банка, ОЭСР, ООН и пр., что является единственным научным методом сравнения уровня жизни и объёмов экономики по всем странам мира. В принципе, эти азы знает каждый студент первого курса экономического факультета. Но манипуляторы продолжают как ни в чем ни бывало))
Пипл хавает. Всё нормально...
Чел, нет единственного и неповторимого метода в статистике))
@@Ls151000 есть две большие разницы. За 1000 долларов в месяц в большинстве стран мира ты вполне можешь прожить месяц, снимая жилье и питаясь нормальной едой. В США и небольшой дюжине других стран ты за эти же деньги сможешь месяц прожить разве что под мостом в картонной коробке. На трейлер и то не хватит (разве что внутри большой и шумной семьи из Гондураса). Именно поэтому, когда тебе дают сравнение ВВП в номинале - это в научном мире никто не воспринимает всерьез. Именно для этого все международные организации, сравнивая объемы национальных экономик и реальный уровень жизни (возможность приобрести определённый набор товаров и услуг внутри каждой экономики), всегда делают пересчёт ВВП на ППС, где учитывается и уровень внутренних цен на все, и уровень зарплат, и ставки тарифов, и что самое главное, заниженность или завышенность национальной валюты по отношению к доллару США. Большинство стран мира (даже Евросоюз) занижают курс своей национальной валюты к доллару различными, в том числе монетарными методами, так как это огромный залог их конкурентоспособности на международном рынке. И многое другое этот факт разным странам также даёт. Единственное, в номинале объёмы их экономик будут казаться в несколько раз меньше, чем это есть на самом деле. Это же касается и ВВП на душу населения. Именно для этого у экономистов есть международно признанный давно в науке и практике параметр - ВВП на душу населения в пересчёте на ППС. Учите матчасть!
After a decade of the most rightwing, freemarket economic policies (known as shock therapy), Russia in 2000 had a lower gdp than Russia in 1990 as apart of the USSR.
USSR GDP is a fake. USSR produced thousands of tanks every year and no one needed it, but it went to GDP. And they did it a few year after collapse of USSR.
@@mikaminskas Thats not how it works. GDP is calculated by adding consumer and gov spending, total investments, and net exports. If the gov bought a tank than the gdp increased. Thats how all country's gdp is calculated and for good reasons.
The military usually takes up about 3% of gdp here in america does that make the US's gdp fake?
@@David-bh5le i don’t remember exact number, but Russia military budget in 93 was only 20% smaller than now(in dollars), but overal GDP was almost 4times smaller. Russian now has a military budget around 6% of GDP. So you can count.
Also ussr were producing different outdated shit: outdated TVs, Radio, cars and etc. No one needed it anymore in ex-ussr countries because they got a normal electronic from western countries and these industries just died very fast.
@@mikaminskas yup, that is important, USSR economy wasn't even the market economy, so the GDP doesn't make a lot of sense if we wan't to count it the normal way in communist countries.
@@captainsponge7825 USSR was a mixed economy, Capital, credit, banks, capital circulation, and wage labor still existed along with central planning.
2015 Per Capita
Russia: 2:14 Hey man, what are you doing?
Kazakhstan: 2:16 Oops, sorry, sir.
Russia be like : if you will have bigger gdp than me I'll make creamea scenery
@@nur-alijanqojayev329 yeah i guess so, this is why i dislike Russia. but ppl and media are* kinda lovely* to follow, even planning live in Kazan and Moscow
i remember when after the sanctions Kazak ppl started to buy cheap Russian products (cars for example) and then our Government decided to change the money policy and then Russian came to re-buy now our cheap goods
then I felt like a backup country for Russia xD
@@galymzhankyrykbaev2976 Russia is bad! Rule, the kazakh, over steppes!
Estonia , latvia and Lithuania are euro countries 👌🏻 EU not so bad after all huh?
Im from latvia
EU isn't good for everyone, though I do support it
uhh EU isn bad at all :D and 80% of the russians who live in Baltics agree, most russians know that they have better lives in EU than in Russia :D especially right now
Hope to cleaning from dirty katsaps all our territory soon, and join to EU. Ukraine.
В этом видео можно увидеть, как потенциальные экономики (Россия, Украина, Беларусь, Казахстан) проебали все из-за политики своих правительств и министерств экономики, при этом особенно интересно следить за Украиной и Беларусью, как упало все не важно кто у власти - диктатор или коррупционер.
Любопытно так же заметить как "вонючие прибалты", которые, как бы, "пропили советское наследие", вырвались за 30 лет далеко вперед даже от той же России, у которой есть нефтегазовая труба.
По ВВП на душу населения Литва обошла Португалию и Грецию (2020 г.) :Р Послушайте сегодня интервью нашего посла (Баярунас) на ЭМ. Он об этом сказал. Кроме того по средней, минимальной з/п и пенсиям Литва в последние 2 года ОБОШЛА Эстонию, которую догоняли;)
А сегодня еще новость: в Литве изобретено ЛЕКАРСТВО от Ковид-19, первое в мире! Сейчас оно отправлено в Швейцарию на испытания. И на подходе второе лекарство. В Литве будут производиться и уже разработанные западные вакцины. А экспресс-тесты мы уже сами готовим и экспортируем. Вывод из видео Вы сделали правильный. Спасибо.
@@Den2067 О, пригожинский нарисовался! :D Отрабатываешь на дезе? Прежде чем туфту втюхивать, погугли: страны-доноры и страны-реципиенты в ЕС по годам. И посмотри % и суммы дотаций из бюджета ЕС, куда, кстати, ВСЕ страны ЕС перечисляют свои средства, в т.ч. и Литва. Литва там далеко не в лидерах. Огромная дотационная помощь идет, ты удивишься, Греции, Португалии, даже Испании, балканским странам и... Польше. Дотации ВСЕГДА идут на конкретные программы и цели, например, на культурные цели, восстановление древних памятников архитектуры, реновацию домов, дороги и пр. При этом 50% конкретной программы оплачивает страна-реципиент из СОБСТВЕННОГО БЮДЖЕТА! И осуществляется строгий контроль за использованием выделенных средств со стороны соответствующих финансовых органов ЕС. У нас не воруют и работают на совесть, поэтому и результаты такие. Я в предыдущем комментарии не упомянула, что Литва обошла по уровню з/п не только Эстонию, которую привела в пример, но и всегда обходила Польшу, и некоторые страны Центральной Европы, не говоря и о балканских странах, за исключением Словении.
Про наличие промышленности и производств в Литве также советую погуглить. Удивишься. Но тебе это не надо.
Вот когда вы в России догоните Литву хотя бы по уровню средней и минимальной з/п (1524 и 642 евро соответственно), которая у нас постоянно повышается... тогда можешь тут шипеть. В Вильнюсе средняя з/п на уровне 2000 евро + -. Часто ваши тролли про цены начинают верещать. Судя по вашим ценам, в Литве продукты не дороже, а местного производства (молочные и мясные, овощи) даже дешевле. А если сравнивать продукты в Литве и, например, во Франции, то у нас в разы дешевле. Но ты там вряд ли бывал ;) А мы ездим практически по всему миру БЕЗ ВИЗ, даже в США. А в ЕС не только свободно передвигаемся, но и можем там учиться, работать, покупать недвижимость, открывать бизнес, не меняя гражданства и не выпрашивая вид на жительство...
Так что
Sergej B. был прав, а тебе остается исходить желчью и бессильной злобой от зависти:)
@@Den2067 P.S. Только что зашла на наш новостной портал. И увидела новость как раз в тему: до конца этого года минимальная з/п в Литве будет повышена до 704 евро. Это еще одно преимущество членства в ЕС. Существует требование регулярно повышать уровень з/п до постепенного достижения среднего по ЕС. % повышения з/п задан для каждой страны отдельно в зависимости от отставания.
@@Sandra-Kristina вечно путаю Литву с Латвией и Эстонией. Как то ни в информационном пространстве, ни в магазине ничего о вас не напоминает. Кроме как ваши политики что то брякнут в адрес России очередной раз))
@@Den2067 Koroche, muchajeshsia ty v Latvii, no na istoricheskuju rodinu tebia i sviazanym ne zatashchish :D.
Growth of Baltic countries is unmatchable 🇪🇪🇱🇻🇱🇹
Потому что в совке все деньги уходили туда в Прибалтику. За счёт остальных их развивали. И Россию развивали за счёт остальных. Все стройли в России и Прибалтике.
@@altynadam4343 Thanks for giving insight, Never knew that.
@@altynadam4343 Not logical at all. After leaving USSR GDP of Baltic states should be decreased then but quite opposite happens.
Actually same process is going on in Russia today - almost all regions in Russia get poorer, and Moscow get richer and richer.
Baltic states give ~20-25% of their GDP to Russian military needs.
Прибалтика живет на игле европейспих выделений средств и кредитов
@@chac66 Москва является регионом-донором, это так, к слову
As a Latvian this makes me happy. Long life Baltic! 🇱🇻❤️🇪🇪🇱🇹 Now every russian that said Latvia is poor... Do you even know what it's like to have money? 😂
when your gdp is in the trillions like russia then you can brag
@@bjorn1583 if you're GDP per capita will be higher than average African, krm... Russia, then you can answer my comment.
@@reinis7899 my countries gdp per C is higher than yours so keep playing with yourself
@@bjorn1583 wtf how. Russians literally think that in soviet union life was better when in Modern Russia
@@jeremijasskrabas5955 What did you smoke before writing that?
Когда прибалтов останется 3 человека, их вообще невозможно будет догнать.
Можно догнать Прибалтику, если в России останется 100 человек.
Mечта идиотов. Сколъко времеми это повторяете, сами успешно тонув в деръме?
@@algimantasbrikas5198 тонем и тонем, уже через пару лет снова по прогнозу МВФ до двух триллионов дотянем, все никак не утонем
Только вот население Эстонии растет, а России падает
если бы прибалты конролировали территорию рашки , у них бы был ввп в 3-4 раза выше чем у режима хуйла. они на 6 лямов людей имеют 10% экономики рашки
For such charts use PPP values, not nominal ones. Nominal values are inherently poor for such comparisons because they rely on currency exchange rates and ignore differences in purchasing power - a weakening of a given currency will be displayed as a contraction in nominal terms in $ although the actual economy has not contracted or even grown. Adjustment by PPP eliminates substantial distortions caused by exchange fluctuations. For instance, in 1997 the Russian economy reported very slight growth but the chart shows an epic collapse in dollar terms that did not take place.
Well, the purchasing power still depends on the exchange rate a lot. You can buy shit for national money but ultimately the good stuff is still imported. To get imports, usually you need foreign currency and stuff.
both should be used, PPP doesnt tell the whole story. just a simple expample: yes, you might buy potatoes cheaper but smartphones cost pretty much the same everywhere. going abroad the income in nominal matters much more than ppp. best is when both are high.
The rank would be almost same. Except, Kazakhstan have higher per capita ppp than Russia
wrong. company's tend to ignore economic differences, and so things are priced the same. 1000 USD for a smartphone, and the equivilent of 1000 USD for russia.
Страны Балтии показали как бывает, когда живешь по европейским законам без тотальной коррупции и узурпации власти.
Абсолютно верно! И без газа и нефти, только с небольшой помощью Европейского Союза для инфраструктурных проектов. Горячий привет из Эстонии!
С небольшой помощью? Пхахахах
Половина всего бюджета - бабло из Евросоюза, не смешите , пожалуйста
@@ksudenisova2462 Я должен сделать ваш смех очень грустным, всего около 5-6% бюджета. И эти деньги не пойдут ни в карманы олигархов, ни в президентские золотые дворцы. Каждый евроцент идет на целевые проекты, по всей стране проводится большая работа. В результате страна с каждым годом становится лучше, современнее и организованнее. Тот, кто смеется после, смеется лучше.
Что показывали? Номинальный ВВП той же Литвы ниже, чем у Танзании и Узбекистана. А номинальный ВВП на душу насления - это просто ВВП поделенный на количество людей в стране. Если в стране депопуляция, то он будет расти даже при стагнации номинального ВВП.
@@benguru2697 ворьё обидели? Прибежали едросню защищать?))
Высокий ВВП показывает, что если не узурпировать власть и не воровать из бюджета строя себе, детям и любовницам дворцы можно достойно жить даже в маленькой стране не имеющей природные ресурсы. Ясно, что вам, единоросам и их обслуге это больно. В такой стране не построишь себе дворец будучи каким-нибудь генеральным прокурором или соседом по кабинету в питерской мэрии в «лихие 90-е».
Насчёт депопуляции. Киселев вам не скажет, но в прошлом году население России сократилось более чем на 500 тыс человек, чего не было (в РСФСР) с 1945 года.
99 год - очухались от кризиса, реформы уже работают - понеслись в гору (потом ещё и нефть начала возвращаться к своим стандартным показателям)
2012-13 - и к рынку уже привыкли, нефть уже три года по 110, но всё равно в минуса пошли…
Догадатесь почему ) в 2012 стал действовать путинский агрессивный авторитаризм.
Теперь до очередного кризиса тянем, и в пропасть.
Но ВВП был уже в 2 раза больше 1999
@@LESORUBBB да, хороший рост (конечно низкая база), но даже тогда бедную Португалию так и не догнали на душу, по сто метровой квартире не получили, жкх… (
(У меня есть, но я осознаю своё положение)
А сейчас и не обещают даже.
@@SergePriem поэтому ждём вас в качестве наблюдателя 19 сентября! Я в члены комиссии попал. Буду трепать!)
@@Sergeich84 я был много раз. Но сейчас сентябрьский отпуск выпадает. Жаль конечно, надо бы понаблюдать за этим цирком.
Baltic states promoted to another league and they are doing better than some southern European countries.
The best proof of "doing better" is the extreme deoopulation of baltic states:)))
But they have almost no economy and Europe’s biggest depopulation
@@dieterweise4793 it's called brain drain. The flight of the educated.
But emigration from there is beating all world records for last decade. And vice versa: emigration from Russia virtually stops in first decade of 21st century and still didn't restarted.
Can you explain these facts? They show the _real_ situation way better than "spherical horse" of charts and numbers.
@@theMerzavets these facts are easy to explains! Western propaganda
Been watching a load of your videos, they're really entertaining. Do you think you could do a video showing nominal GDP from 1800-2020 showing the British Empire as one economic entity? Keep up the good videos!
I’m glad you enjoyed! I’ll definitely try to recreate what you are talking about, but it might take some time.
@@RankingCharts No worries! I appreciate that you'll even consider taking the time to do that. Thanks!
Estonks
Uzbekistan: Going up and going down
Such a sad thing to see so many Russian internet trolls in the comments
Go back to your cave and be happy
1. It displays that it makes sense to play together with rest of Europe (see the baltic states)
2. As an Austrian/German I love Estonia. The drive for digitalization is what I miss so much here. I hope Estonia becomes the European Silicone Valley.
Best greetings from Estonia!
It can't because Estonia is too small and can't attract skilled people from eastern Europe. Czechia or Poland has a much better chance for that. Czechia profits from being a popular destination for skilled Russians, Belarusians and Ukrainians. It's beneficial to be able to attract skilled workforce from 200 million population. Not only that but also other developing countries like Brazil or India. You may be surprised but they are willing to immigrate to Czechia. Estonia will always suffer from simply being too small and on the edge of the EU.
@Ярослав Л No it's war plans of central powers in 1914. They are the real victors. Russia collapsed and independent states broke off. But you should blame communists and revolutionaries of 1917. Without them Russia would have won WW1 and remained intact. What happened cannot be undone.
Me, an Estonian:
"This truly does bring a smile to my face."
Fellow Lithuanian waiting to pass the Estonian GDP per capita rate.
Как там у вас?
Russia is like Brazil, in a roller-coaster.
Poor Russia, didn’t knew the sanctions hit them so hard in 2013
@@oaka5639 Not just sanctions, oil prices fell dramatically.
Not anymore, Brazil now is more like Russia in the 90s
@@oaka5639 lol, we don't care about sanctions anyway
azerbaijan
Conclusion: the less ppl - the better economy.
not rly
@@surcal7389 feel my sarcasm
No. Kazackstan has less then 10 millions, so what
@@Lindrid32 Kazakhstan has almost 20 millions
So - Vatican wins :)
It would be interesting to know how high the GDP of the several SSRs was before 1991
It wouldn't say much. Exchanging or owning dollars was something that would put you in jail, so the government could set any exchange rate it wanted. They didn't trade with the West much anyway. Because the economy was so imbalanced, you couldn't always buy basic necessities like butter or meat even if your salary was relatively high. Things like cars or TVs or washing machines were insanely expensive, most people couldn't afford a car after 20 years of saving. Most urban households didn't have things like washing machines or hair dryers, microwaves were unheard of. Long story short, all of my grandparents insist(ed) life is much better now (Ukraine).
@@themeiafy Actually ita wasn't so but about cars yes. But anyway even the life in the Western Europe at the same time was quite similar. The things changed from 85-86... For example in Italy in 82 the car price starts from 5 millions lires when awerage salary was 300k-400k lires and there wasn't such a think like bank's credits like we all have today, so if you had savings to buy a car you buy it, if not you use a bicicle or take a bus to go to work. The problem with basic things in USSR starts with Gorby's Perestroyka..
@@sergeypopov801 What are you talking about? Life wasn't nearly the same in the West. At least people there could actually BUY a house, instead of being at the mercy of the government. They could go wherever they wanted. Rural residents didn't even have passports in USSR until mid 1970-ies! They'd be attested if they were caught outside of their place of residence. And it's not like they could do farming, either. All they could do was work at a collective farm for a salary which could only buy them bread. Yes, there was no deficit until 1980-ies, but you could only choose from 2-3 brands at best. And I'm talking most basic things like sausage or candy, not something crazy. And it's not like people could afford those outside of a capital, they were dirt poor. Even buying a clothes item was a big problem, except maybe for like 5-10 "good" (slightly better, in fact) years.
@@themeiafy dude lot if people frim Kolhoz hadn't passport cause they ligelly didn't need it. It wasn't necessary to have a passport if you lived in rural areas. There wasn't need to show ID (passport in russian cause in west theu called pasdport what we called traveling or external passport) when you buy a ticke in siviet times. Yes we don't had 300 tipes of shampoo or shoes like in the west but we had 5 tipes and you could buy them in every shop of the coutry. Yes in the west you could buy a house or a car immediately but only if you had a money, in ussr you get a house for free and also cars was given for free for some job achievemnts and yes, some people waits for yers for them but only a small part of people. I grew up during soviet times and i remember it well. Communism wasn't better or wors than capitalism. It was just different system with different problems. And yes we lived in exactly same way like western europeans. I've spent 15 year of my life living and workin in Italy, Germany and France and saw the family photos of lot of people, heard a lot of stories about how the life was in past. Just google the Beatles's photos before the became famouse, you can see that they lived like us. Ofcourse in capitalism you can get rich and live like a God, in communism you can't neither if you was a high rank party member, but common people, the workers, lived in ecatly same way cause as i said there wasn't a Mutual credit system in western Europe in those times so if someone saved enoght money it could buy a house or a car, if not he couldn't. We, soviets, often had to wait in queques for them but as i said your position in queque was depending of lot of factors like was you a good citizen that respect laws and works good, was you a smoker or drink, had you just a medium school grade or you had finished the university, what kind of studies you've choosen an etc.. All those factors influenced your position in quequesto get a house or a car. About the restant good i can garantee that we had everything. My grandparents were "poor" acvording to awerage soviet salary, they in two earns 150 rubles while my mother, a mining engeneer gainhad same salary alone. The life was really cheap a those times. With 150 ruble you could live for two month alone or gan mantain the family of two adult and 2 kids for a month. That's why a lot of families had only one income made generally by father and lived good.
@@sergeypopov801 What a lot of nonsense. I could stop reading at "didn't need a passport". It's not like they could get it if they needed it. And they didn't need it because they WEREN'T ALLOWED to do anything aside from working at a state farm. And yes you could get an apartment for free, but it would probably be either a room with 5 other families, or you'd have to wait for it for 25 years and live with your parents and kids in a two-room apartment. Nice, isn't it? You'd have to be REALLY nice to certain people if you wanted something better. Please stop BS-ing me, I'd rather read Pravda newspaper if I wanted some Soviet propaganda. I know how things were in real life, not in newspapers
Seriously? Прощание славянки!
Lasha tumbay :D.
Fun fact, the countries which became richer are member states of Europe.
Could you also do a version with both nominal and proportional GDP that accounts for how expensive it is to live in the respective country?
If only the Baltics weren't occupied, they would be so much higher
Same level as scandinavia , baltics were richer than finland before ww2
@@anno6964 Somewhere around 80k+ per capita easily, since Scandinavian nations have bigger population.
They had same potential as Danmark.
@@anno6964 I think It was richer than Norway as well.
This is totally excellent. Could you please move the flags to the RIGHT of the the bars and the NAME of the countries to the LEFT so that we can SEE name of the country not trying to guess what the flag represents = most of the names are hidden on the left in this graph which is very annoying!!
Bro, just learn flags, its not hard
If he did that than the flags wont show
Just shows power of nordics/baltics
Good Estonia 🇪🇪
Big thank you and greetings from Estonia!
It shows the power of *free market* against corporativism and bureaucracy
Estonia is not nordic
@@nationalistefrancais1473 Yes, but it is Baltic and European democratic free market too.
Russia watching Estonia in 1993: 👁👄👁
Watching Moldova at the bottom of the list: haha, I live there
Привіт з України, бро)
lay down claims on transnistria, and suddenly there is no conflict anymore in moldava, then join romania, and be part of EU. we have nice money for developing regions. you gonna get high speed rail and infrastructure, and some subventions for agriculture etc.
thats much better then claims on the shithole on the other side of the river
@@certaindeath7776 you would do that shit to Bukovina, would you? oh, hell no!
@@certaindeath7776 They don't really care about us - Michael Jackson.
@@filonsky best option Bukovina back to Moldova, and Transnistria to Ukraine
Good luck to my brothers in estonia and lithuania (i have routes from there)
hi from Lithuania
Hi from Estonia!
Dėkui, seniuk, sėkmės ir tau :)
I live in Kazakhstan and I always hear from the news "It's crisis now"... In 2005 1USD = 130KZT, now it's 440
@Mikah yes, but we live better than any country except russia in list of post soviet countries
@Mikah we cloud live much more better if our goverment didnt stole money, we have so many resourses and oil
bcoz of potassium
@@Grzegorz_Brzeczyszczykiewitcz absolutely right! :)
@@Myrtanias Great success! I like.
*sad tajik noises* btw im from tajikistan
Tajikistan being the most religious. And Estonia the most atheist.
sorry about your country's mess :c
@@beorlingo My Estonia is most atheist, but still with very strong Lutheran work ethics. We believe in science and technology and clean environment.
I'm just thinking about how little god seems to care about those who speak of him/it the most.
@@beorlingo I think, from a believer living in a poor country myself, it's more about finding some comfort, some guiding force in your existing living conditions. It's not about asking god/gods/entity for actual monetary richness, but for finding spiritual richness and guidance while you try to escape poverty.
Estonia is first because it was the only country trying to move away from a big daddy government type.
Эстония слишком микроскопична и геоэкономически удачлива чтобы быть трендом.
Estonia is the first, because Estonia has a low population lol
@@danielgeller7629 So what you are saying is that all countries with high populations should be poor and non-productive and small countries should be rich and well functioning?
@@leonidasg2257 you just said some bullshit. What is the "big daddy governance type"? And Estonia is the first in the list, because its population is stupidly 2 times lower than the for example Lithuanian. Estonia doesnt even produce anything
@@danielgeller7629 By big daddy government I ment that Estonia was the first country to move away from a big central government model and liberalize its economy. Most post soviet countries are today still run by the governmnt and a few oligarchs, are full of corruption and struggle to make any progress. Also population has NOTHING to do with it. If you dont understand what gdp PER CAPITA is, there is no point talking to you.
You should take the information of the Real GDP (PPP) instead of the nominal one because the ppa tells you the true economy of a country
Both nominal and PPP are true, they just show different aspects of the same economy
The upper part of the list is the same - just Lithuania has surpassed Estonia due to lower prices there and Russia has a bigger number for real living standards - still fourth, over 10000 dollars behind Estonia. There are more components in that kind of comparison - Lithuania has much higher taxes than Estonia, so after taxes Estonia has still the highest salaries and buying power.
@@toivotraks 11 to 25 and 29 to 39 are different numbers, though standings wouldn't change much, here you're right
@@toivotraks Lithuania has the highest expenditure rate in Eastern Europe (and not only) , I mean people spending money for their needs.
Well, once I bought perfect cheese in Tallinn for just 1€ for a 150g pack. It brought me gack to childhood. The same cheese, but without smell and taste, can be purchased in Moscow for at least 2€. So tell me how Russia can have 28.000 by purchasing power? Moreover, 11.000$ is an average number, you know Russia has huge gap between the richest and poorest ones. Estonian 22.000$ per capita, opposite, literally mean 22.000$ per almost everyone who's involved in labour market. It's sad to admit, but Russia has failed with its corruption and weird ambitions outside the country. People's wealth is not a priority for our ruler.
Amazing video thanks!
Thanks!
Estonia! 👌
Azerbaijan in late 90s: Where is this fucking oil?
Azerbaijan in 2006: My time has come
The three states that had become part of EU and NATO, jumped from nothing to the top. This graph says it all.
@Kazumaf no. ))
It's price of independence
You’re such uneducated and narrow minded person that there no sense to explain how many people those countries lost due to immigration and luck of well paying jobs. How many factories and other industrial objects (like nuclear power stations) were closed by force of UN. Those countries now called Прибалтийские Вымираты! And that’s why they SO SUCCESSFUL that they are begging for financial help from UN, military help from US, and contribution money from Russia. Oh! Yeah! Jump from nothing to top!!!! They used to be called FACE of USSR, now they’re called the BUTT of Europe!
@@alexbond969 they used to be about to get exterminated by ussr and were saved by EU. God save the holy Europe against satanic Russia
@@ninaakari5181 Oh yeah! Be afraid! By the way, could you remind us, what only country in the world used nuclear bombs against civilians, killing at least 200k right away?!
We did it because we are number one exporter of Potassium 🇰🇿😍⛏️,👷♂️
The other countries are run by little girls
@@lalkadapper4251 Kazakhstan is run by a piece of furniture
@@Neversa алға, Назарбаев!
@@RedRose_228 это как быть адекватным? Че теперь вообще нельзя шутить? Тогда зачем вообще улыбаться, зачем нам тогда плакать, давайте будем серьезными
@@RedRose_228 понял
Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia are true examples for mankind, holy shit.
The help of EU, yes they are the richest among The Post Soviets.
@@haeveen8255 Not gonna lie, I think they would be better without EU... they are between the most libertarian countries in the world, despite having low resources.
@@jonnymario771 Hello from Estonia! My country's north-eastern part is mostly Russian-speaking and without European open market economic stimulus within EU and military presence by NATO this region could well be like Crimea or Eastern Ukraine.
@@toivotraks I see, the stimilus was from their economy. But you guys, for example, didnt even need public education for developing.
Compare to my country, Brazil, with lots of public/universal shenannigans and we are a piece of crap, even with a huge country and lots of resources. Free market economies are way beyond rigged countries like mine.
What I meant about the EU is that you guys are like the top tier of Europe, IMO.
@@jonnymario771 no way... Literally every project here in latvia is either fully or partially paid by eu
It was 13 years, 2004 until the best Estonia get the level of the 1991 the year of collapse. And what is happened in China during that period of time?
When Russia has such a big nominal GDP, other countries' names are not shown...
I love how Belarus and Kazakhstan, two Russian puppet states, are following it's trend xD
Says american puppet.
@@mishacol Imagine assuming that I am American or that I like America lmfao. "u dont like my ex-commie cleptocratic shitfest, you must love usa" ::))))))
Russians envy to the Baltics a lot as this is seen in thew comments below. How come Baltics can live without Russia:D
"How come Baltics can live without Russia?" - Very simply, they are dying out and sitting on the neck of the EU. Let them continue this way at the expense of the EU :)
@@vasily9269 this just proves his point
@@vasily9269 Russia is dying faster than Baltic countries
@@imin2905
Only in your wet dreams.) Over 30 years Latvia has lost half of its population, but what a big GDP, what a big!)
@@kaspalto8503 how is it?
Капитализм победил. Опять. Вот что санкции животворящие делают!
а если в попугаях посчитать?
Эти санкции повлияли первый год, а потом цифры всё равно начали расти. Не так быстро, как до этого, но растут.
@@nullussum2535 ну да, а если цены повысить ещё раза в три, вообще заживём, глядя на цифры
@@plasticweld я не говорила, что это хорошо. Я лишь поделилась своими наблюдениями.
@@nullussum2535 извиняюсь, ляпнул не разобравшись.
And that's why is good to know the per capita.
Oligarchs in 99
@@cowhatcat8158 And how's that relates?
Better to know the GDP PPP which is a far better gauge.
@@tnickknight Well, it depends entirely on what you want to measure.
If we talk about growth, I think productivity is far a more direct indicator than consumption. (In an extreme case: You can consume a lot, but if you are not producing, you even expose yourself to the same problems of poorly planned socialism.)
@@LuisRomeroLopez the biggest part of every post industrial economy is services sector. What do you think would be the right gauger here?
Kazakhstan 1991: 20 times smaller than Russia, 3 times smaller than Ukraine
Kazakhstan 2019: 9 times smaller than Russia, 1.17 times larger than Ukraine.
Behold the power of Kazakhs!
our secret is superior potassium of course
It s probably the methane in the rocks actually.
I heard that Kazakhstan was the salty country, is that right?
The three richest countries are the three who integrate EU ! 🇪🇺
This is the key question! Just three Baltic nations took right decisions after collapse of the USSR. Look at CIS countries, look at Russia with its enormous potential and resources!
Yes, and that was the only right decision they made. Baltic countries, except for Estonia, are stagnating and dying out. I'm glad the European passport provided me with the opportunity to move to a developed European country from there.
@@nimkati5627 Lithuania is on par with Estonia, Latvia not far behind. And you got your European passport to move in Europe - unlike Russians - thanks to Baltic countries being in EU and Schengen. And after that right decision we are moving in the right direction - unlike the rest of CIS.
@@toivotraks In Russia it's even worse, but that's not the point. An average person can't live in the Baltics. Only survive.
@@nimkati5627 I'm an average pensioner in Estonia, supplementing my income a bit by working a little. I'm living, not surviving! To say otherwise seems quite offensive to me. I can easily cope with my living expenses, I can have a full cultural life, I can travel abroad before and after covid, I can use all electronic things provided by my country, I'm socially insured. Best greetings from Estonia and good luck for living in a developed country!
In 1999 The Baltic’s Are Arranged Perfectly.
I love how much the Baltic sisters have benefitted from being in the EU. Such a contrast to the other countries that aren't in.
🇪🇺 🗽
Yes - that fact just jumps into the eye!
So much loans and grants, yeah.
@@DreamWalkerVl so much hungry in the URSS.
@@antba4039 After 1933? Not really.
Estonia: I have to prove that I'm Nordic!
Props only for the name
@man with square mustache how's argentina bro?
Estonia: I have to prove that I'm like to ask money from Germany ,like litle girl for breakfast in school
Also, keep in mind not just the sheer GDP per capita but also the sources of this income. Selling natural raw resources vs. industrial products and services is not the same thing.
I believe, the day will come, when we will watch the video about: Post-US States GDP Comparison - After US disband to the small undepended states.
Yea no that's not going to happen.
Happy dreaming!
@@toivotraks A time will show, who from us is dreaming. Will see...
@@bigjim1041 in the USSR nobody believed it as well. But it happened. It will happen in the US as well. And it looks like we don't have to wait too long
@@Fricid Got a source for your theory?
Good stats. Congratulations Estonia that has been increase the economic development(not just the economic growth).
Estonia is dominating all things considered
They aren’t. Look at the first graph as well also if you visit any of the Baltic countries you won’t feel an economic difference.
Peanut sized small country. Russia 🇷🇺 can swallow it in minutes. Lol
@@inyourface9697 yeah NATO could definitely destroy russia quickly haha.
@@inyourface9697 "Haha my country good cuz my country big haha"
@@inyourface9697 When will Russia swallow Iceland, Luxembourg, Monaco, Liechtenstein etc?
A more objective indicator of GDP in terms of PPP, although there will be a similar situation, only Lithuania will already be in 1st place.
GDP by PPP for 2019
Russia - $ 4.390 trillion
Lithuania - $ 107 billion
@@НиколайУльянкин-г6т per capita
@@adinik3960 Many Russians use just GDP (PPP) to underline and boast their greatness - totally ignoring per capita that reduces that greatness catastrophically.
@@toivotraks What has Russia to do with it? It doesn't matter to me, the important thing is that PPP GDP is the main indicator of the economy. And Russia is considered a wealthy country, is in the top 50 countries in terms of GDP in terms of PPP per capita from more than 200 countries of the world and is also included in the number of developed countries according to the HDI index.
@@adinik3960 for a country that boasts that is #1 it must be difficult to almost get into first 25%
Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia vs all the rest is like economic freedom vs. no economic freedom.
"The rest" were built under direct instructions from Bill Clinton's office. Are you telling us now that he was lying about economic freedoms?
@@MalleusImperiorum Don't know what Clinton has to do with this, but if you take a look to the Index of Economic Freedon by the Heritage Foundation, Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia are mostly free states. All the rest have lower scores, they're more restricted. That implies things such as weaker property rights, less monetary, financial, trade, investment and business freedom, and/or higher tax burden. Russia, Ukraine, Belarus, and Central Asia ex-Soviet nations are classified from "moderately free" to "mostly unfree". Many of these countries have liberalized their economies more in the latest years, though.
@@SnipermanElite In the 90's most of these countries were under direct control from Washington D.C., the US (being the world champion of liberal freedoms and democracy) had an opportunity to make these countries as free as they get. There were lots of talks about authoritarianism of socialism and freedoms of capitalism - now that they were free to choose their leaders and free to become billionaires. So, what happened? Why are they so dirt poor and obviously worse off than before the 90's? Where did all the Western promises go?
No way the US advisors lied to them just to plunder their countries, to sell off for nothing and bankrupt thousands of Soviet enterprises! It couldn't be!.. Hmm, maybe if they try the same thing they will finally live like Scandinavians instead?..
@@SnipermanElite Just so you know, the Heritage Foundation is an American conservative rightist organisation sponsored by oil oligarchs. They would easily rank Hitler's Germany the most "economically free", as long as it's allied with the US, of course..
Moldavia is actually number 1 in freedoms
2:14 the moment we were all waiting for.
???
@@realtissaye Kazakhstan overtook Russia in per capita GDP.
@@komradekevinthekommuneistd7362 Fan fact, Moscow's GDP exceeds Kazakhstan's GDP by 10 times
@@RainlineX Moscow is not Russia))
Proud to be an Estonian!
Behave, puppet of Europe.
@@СэрВортон I'm a puppet to no-one; that's a good try, though. 🙂
@@СэрВортон
So i guess that's poverty is better then stop undermine western countries.... Yep russian logic.
Astonia is amazing and a model to all the developed and developing countries.
@@barneada Tiny puppet state is not an example to anyone. Estonia is a joke.
@@СэрВортон better to be puppet to Europe than Slave for Russia
kind of sad to watch almost every one of them decline at first
Decline everywhere was the inescapable result of the collapse of "Soviet heaven". What really matters is what happened after that.
It was inevitable, your production methods and the things you are producing are out of date, and suddenly the real value of said machinery and product are staring you in the face. The other problem was the immense arms production was all but useless, nobody wants it nor can they afford it. The T-55 was the most produced tank in the world, but it has no real market value.
@@toivotraks when market destroys your economy and sends 50 million into unemployment with everything being sold for pennies, as these countries enter into recession for the first time after 70 years and life expectancy drops by almost a decade but it's still gomunizms fault... So fucking delusional
@@nationalist1389 It's called an economic recession. Economic recessions could occur when a country artificially increases its economic value through overestimulating the economy. It could happen in the context of use of loans from banks without any government intervention like happened in 2.008, or in that case, with an economic system that is overestreched by producing many products considered obsolete, out of demand. You can correct me if I'm wrong.
Sorry for my English, it's not my first language.
@@nationalist1389 as the other guy already mentioned, its the switch from communism to capitalism that caused a big recession, probably since when they opened their markets, they just couldnt compete with foreign products. Regardless, i dont need to tell you that communism doesnt work. Look at cuba, look at china, even China is partially privatising their industry (going more capitalist) because they know communism is the inferior economic system. It's sad, but true. And no political propaganda should keep you from checking facts.
Baltic states! Always the best
Что твоя страна может сделать?
Всегда лучше... Половина людей здесь не знает где эти страны на карте находятся) Вам лет сто от силы.
@@МишаМедведь-р6о Mish da nenada tak negativna , vsjo norm ;)
@@vikentijslauruts2153, какой негатив? Я за объективность.
Привет из Ташкента!
@@МишаМедведь-р6о vsego harosego tebe i vam , udachi
@@МишаМедведь-р6о privet iz Liepaja
They put "per Capita" instead of PURCHASING POWER PARITY. 😆
It's NOT how much you make it's how much you can AFFORD with what you Make.
Agree. It's the same story with average salary. On paper situation is good, but if you count how many people actually receive it and mention things like taxes, prices etc, then it's a completely different statistics.
That's correct. However, the numbers are definitely worrying for a country with resources and population such as Russia.
Per capita is not the opposite of PPP
PPP will make minor adjustments. Due to lower prices, Lithuania has replaced Estonia as first while Russia is still fourth - although a little nearer to "fabulous three".
@@rid1bee PPP is the more accurate measure of a countries economic efficiency and health.
Can you make such a video on EU countries?
ua-cam.com/video/pAgpyVFTtUg/v-deo.html
Christ I feel sorry for Belarus, so much potential just put to waste
All of these countries are shells of what they could have been had the soviets not existed, if the Whites won in the Russian civil war than all of these would be much, much richer.
@@evzenvarga9707 all of these won't even exist. Cause Kolchak or Kornilov would never allow to make "national republics" from Russian territories
@@evzenvarga9707 Which ones are white? This movement retained its integrity only because of a common enemy, and inside it there were many conflicting trends, some of them hated each other.
@@Fricid Russia would've become a constitutional monarchy
Very good, I am happy to see this chart
I'm glad you enjoyed!
Estonia 👍👏 Kazakhstan has oil, gas, grain, metals and GDP per capita just only $8000 🙈
Because big corporations , and we don't live near Europe , ee live near China and Russia , please tell me how to live?
Kazakhstan has 10 000$ . And we are about 20 mln while Estonia is 1mln.
estonia is in the eu, plus, $8000 dollars are worth much more in kz than in estonia
Estonia has like 1 million people and is part of the EU. I would be more surprised If your gdp per capita isn't high
The success of the free market in Estonia is really impressive.
Yet the free market seems to have failed literally every other post-Soviet state outside the Baltics. Its a shame too since almost 80% of Soviet citizens voted to keep the union together in a referendum but it was dissolved anyways because of capitalists
@@croatia0728 Yet no other country used the same free market policies Estonia did, that's why they failed.
@@darklibertario5001 you mean receiving EU grants?
@@croatia0728 I mean less government interference in the economy.
@@darklibertario5001 Lol. In 90's Russia had absolute zero interference of goverment in economy. We all saw how it ended so no it's not abou a state control, it's about what the west did. Estonia had the most advanced elctronic industry in USSR so after collapse of it, Estonian industry was integrated in NATO's production chains while in other ex republics with free market and zero goverment controll entire industry was sold for ridiculouse prices to the mafia members that then did'n upgrade it or make it works but just cut it in pieces and sold for original or right prices. That's how the Oligachs has apperaed and that's why almost all ex soviet repubblics had economic falls in 90's and some of the have it even today. For example Russia is still rebuilding it industry while Ukraine is still cutting and selling.
I'm suprised by the fact that Russia is sooo weak.
Poor man in a bear's costume
Weak economically but not militarily. Its still a regional power
Empire of evil is suck with all of it resources,lol
I love how russia lost half of gdp after starting war with Ukraine
Btw thanks everyone who supports Ukraine in this war
@@maxon5153 In the end- you lost lots of dead weight (regions who elect pro-Russian parties), and that pushed Ukraine to finally 'mobilise' and start to actually build the state: rebuild army, expand the use of Ukrainian language, return Ukrainian church, etc. Hopefully soon you will get invitation to NATO and then EU- that would allow fast growth over the next decades, to become a power state, and be at/near the top in these charts.
Just imagine how long the poorest country in Europe can resist the second of the most powerfull militaries on this planet:))))
What stuns me how the West did virtually nothing during or after the Russo-Georgian War in 2008. Some folks don't even seem to remember it ever happened. They got scolded and their economy was allowed to roar on, the US let them participate in RIMPAC military exercises in 2012, and of course they got to host the Sochi Olympics. It was only when Ukraine had a piece get lopped off that the western countries started to actually care and hold them accountable.
So basically after the collapse, everyone became poor as fuck
All industries were privatized or destroyed, shock therapy.
😅
In Estonia now bananas are for any day, not just for Christmas.
All those GDP are bullshit. Lets say in Ukraine you can make Haircut for 2 euros . In Latvija you have to pay 7 euros. Same haircut , difference more than 3 times. What you have to consider is how much person earns and how much the person has left after necessary spending.
One small example - in Estonia MINIMAL wage for teachers is 1375 euros. How about Ukraine?
@@toivotraks This is what I want to say. A person living in, let's say, Estonia, and earning 1300 euros, can have the same living standard as a person earning 500 euro in Ukraine.
People like it because it better suits their agenda.
@@janjarik I know very well how much Ukrainians get average. Not 500 but 300 EUR. Yeah Ukrainia is lot cheaper but only 2 times, not 4.
@@janjarik How i know? I and we have lots of Ukrainian work buddys in here who travel half Europa to live and work in Estonia. Why they come here? for 7 Eur haircut? idi..t
Once Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia join the EU their economies will be growing like the Baltic states as well. Unless that selfish Mr Putin tries to stop them.
Ahahahahhahahahahha!!!!!!!!!!
Just like Greece huh
Or Spain
@@harakitty2058 of course. The Greek and Spanish economies and living standards are far stronger today than they were when the joined the EEC in the 1980s. Before the pandemic the Greek economy had a growth rate of 1.9%. That's better than UK economic growth of 1.4%.
@@harakitty2058 Greece had corrupted governments and Spain it still is a good place to live in. Otherwise, westerners would buy properties in Sochi instead of Southern Spain.
Georgian economy is doing great considering Russian economical war and 4 real wars in last 30 years + Georgians have 300 000 Refugees in country, 8% of population .
Why not GDP PPP?
There are both
@@spectre2889 no, PPP - purshasing power parity, this is parity in prices. Every economical statistics without PPP are wrong, because for example prices in Ukraine 4 times lower than in Russia in US $. Factually, Ukrainian GDP PPP per cappita is same as Russian, but in this statistics Ukrainian 4 times lower.
@@arty5876 Ahh ok ,thanks for explaining
I'm from Ukraine btw
@@spectre2889 So - are the Ukrainian prices four times lower than in Russia?
@@toivotraks Yes,they are,a lot of russians buy stuff from Ukraine and sell them in Russia getting 4 times more money
So yeah,if you want to go to Eastern Europe I recommend Ukraine:the prices are 4 times lower