I adore listening to these isolated tracks. I get so many surprises and insights, especially listening to Ringo's drums and Paul's bass alone. Thank you for publishing these.
@@Humblemumble7 “you’ve” NOT “you’re”. And, a “cursory” understanding of what the Beatles did to create this is like a cursory understanding of quantum mechanics
@mattmichael6792 Incorrect! Haha - '4 track analog YOU'RE* qualified to declare.... Also, your analogy doesn't hold up. You posed that you'd only be qualified to "declare" something impossible by attempting it. I don't have to know anything about quantum physics to have a cursory understanding enough to declare it difficult. Never mind the glaringly obvious FACT that what you're stating as "impossible" clearly isn't.
I wish George (or John, I can’t tell who’s playing the guitar since the guitar parts are so damned sparse) would have had a more prominent presence on the track as far as the guitar parts go. Not that I want it to be a hard rock song or anything like that, I just kind of wish the guitar parts were more “meaty” and just given more to do. But I’m a guitarist, so naturally that’s where my brain gravitates whenever I listen to rock (both more recent and older bands alike). Either way, this song is still damn near perfect anyway (it’s my favorite Beatles song).
@marlonennes1206 18:28 You can hear a chord being stabbed in a staccato sort of way. I'm not sure who's playing it, though. Between 18:21 - 18:28 I can hear it the clearest.
It's impressive that you were able to single-track the vocals. Hearing it that way, I can make out that only John is on the harmony. I have long suspected that as I can't hear George in the mix at all. They should have given him a harmony part.
@@ilovemusic7748 no way. You can hear John's signature rasp on the first "blue suburban skies". Now I don't really hear anyone else on harmony, but it's possible George jumped in on the last two choruses.
Why can I sing BftBo Mr. Kite perfectly over the drum track? It wasnt my intention. I was just listening to the vid in the background and naturally started singing Mr. Kite and it fit spot on
Is there a folder in which I can download these? It's getting annoying putting them in audacity and splitting and lining up all the tracks perfectly lol
Yeah I have quite of few of them. I sourced the Love album, Abbey Road, All Things Must Pass, Let It Be, and the White Album by buying the disks and that was really expensive. I also found a good source online for some Yellow Submarine and Anthology 5.1 mixes.
Sure, although I don't think it'll be any better than the other videos since I'll most likely source most of the isolated tracks from the rock band stems. But if I can make better stems I'll publish a video
I love how imperfect and human music was in the past. And even with imperfections they were perfect.
Imperfection is more interesting than perfection in music.
Oh really?
If there are or were any of your so-called "imperfections"....
You wouldn't have noticed.
I adore listening to these isolated tracks. I get so many surprises and insights, especially listening to Ringo's drums and Paul's bass alone. Thank you for publishing these.
Love these isolated tracks
3:41 that trembling sound of the bass is beautiful
Greatest A and B side ever recorded
Paperback Writer and Rain... yes totally
It was a double A side single
If you’ve ever tried to build an arrangement on 4 track analog you’re qualified to declare this impossible.
*you're
what?
*you're
Also, you needn't have done a thing to have a cursory understanding of the difficulty of a thing.
@@Humblemumble7 “you’ve” NOT “you’re”.
And, a “cursory” understanding of what the Beatles did to create this is like a cursory understanding of quantum mechanics
@mattmichael6792 Incorrect! Haha
- '4 track analog YOU'RE* qualified to declare....
Also, your analogy doesn't hold up. You posed that you'd only be qualified to "declare" something impossible by attempting it. I don't have to know anything about quantum physics to have a cursory understanding enough to declare it difficult.
Never mind the glaringly obvious FACT that what you're stating as "impossible" clearly isn't.
I’m in a little band, and i like the seperate tracks overdubbing part the best!
This is awesome! I’ve never heard the harmonium so clearly before.
At 18:31 there is a clear mistake by a brass instrument. A little flat.
I wish George (or John, I can’t tell who’s playing the guitar since the guitar parts are so damned sparse) would have had a more prominent presence on the track as far as the guitar parts go. Not that I want it to be a hard rock song or anything like that, I just kind of wish the guitar parts were more “meaty” and just given more to do. But I’m a guitarist, so naturally that’s where my brain gravitates whenever I listen to rock (both more recent and older bands alike). Either way, this song is still damn near perfect anyway (it’s my favorite Beatles song).
i can't even hear guitars on it
@marlonennes1206 18:28 You can hear a chord being stabbed in a staccato sort of way. I'm not sure who's playing it, though. Between 18:21 - 18:28 I can hear it the clearest.
@@overjoyous thnx, i will try to listen
It's impressive that you were able to single-track the vocals. Hearing it that way, I can make out that only John is on the harmony. I have long suspected that as I can't hear George in the mix at all. They should have given him a harmony part.
My theory is its Paul and George singing the harmonies and John goes in and says “skies i sit and”
@@ilovemusic7748 no way. You can hear John's signature rasp on the first "blue suburban skies". Now I don't really hear anyone else on harmony, but it's possible George jumped in on the last two choruses.
Amazing its all done on only 4 tracks.
It's a great job
A snare. That's it. Who does that?... it's all it needed
Why can I sing BftBo Mr. Kite perfectly over the drum track?
It wasnt my intention. I was just listening to the vid in the background and naturally started singing Mr. Kite and it fit spot on
Is there a folder in which I can download these? It's getting annoying putting them in audacity and splitting and lining up all the tracks perfectly lol
I do have them available to my Patreons as the Beatle stems require more work than other stems I create.
@@isolatedstems I am a starving child and I am about to starve to death. Gootbye
@@ambientmoderI'll toss yah a bone here's the files to Penny Lane : drive.google.com/drive/folders/1HVEzYFkJhoTtW0KhKVezraee90hef0As?usp=sharing
Paul flubs it @3:33.
do you have the songs in 5.1 mix?
Yeah I have quite of few of them. I sourced the Love album, Abbey Road, All Things Must Pass, Let It Be, and the White Album by buying the disks and that was really expensive. I also found a good source online for some Yellow Submarine and Anthology 5.1 mixes.
@@isolatedstems :)
may you please share the mixes with us? 😅
could you try and do carry that weight at some point?
Sure, although I don't think it'll be any better than the other videos since I'll most likely source most of the isolated tracks from the rock band stems. But if I can make better stems I'll publish a video