News Track Debate: Is India Ready For One Nation, One Election? | Rahul Kanwal | India Today

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 145

  • @shekharkale2588
    @shekharkale2588 Місяць тому +28

    If election happens only 5 years, what will then Media show to public 😂😂

    • @wallysquash3361
      @wallysquash3361 Місяць тому +12

      Hindu-muslim, PM's foreign trips, does he eat mango or not

    • @tazneemlatiff5609
      @tazneemlatiff5609 Місяць тому +2

      ​@@wallysquash3361😂😂👌👌

    • @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov
      @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov Місяць тому

      If BJP wins as it looks like till 2047,only and only BHARAT's progress.... Progress and progress.

    • @tazneemlatiff5609
      @tazneemlatiff5609 Місяць тому

      @@raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov depends on your idea of progress

    • @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov
      @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov Місяць тому

      @@tazneemlatiff5609 Idea of progress? . Like all desh premis would like to see BHARAT top the world.

  • @inderpalsinghbanga2491
    @inderpalsinghbanga2491 Місяць тому +13

    EC failing to conduct elections in 4 states and dreaming about 28 states and 8 UT😂

  • @AkashYadao-r3j
    @AkashYadao-r3j Місяць тому +11

    Rahul is a bjp agent .... I have always seen him speaking like a bjp spokesperson

    • @hightech8276
      @hightech8276 Місяць тому

      Non biological modi 🔥

    • @RG-ww4yk
      @RG-ww4yk Місяць тому +1

      4 panelists against BJP, and yet we call him BJP agent. Good logic

    • @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov
      @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov Місяць тому

      @@RG-ww4yk May be people want to hear only one idea. That is not our idea of BHARAT.

  • @meijianngamkamei3324
    @meijianngamkamei3324 Місяць тому

    @Dr.Shama Mohd Thank you for bringing the name of my state manipur on the discussion before all the people who think that manipur problem is not India Problem.

  • @allanmenezes8503
    @allanmenezes8503 Місяць тому +5

    I find the anchor deliberately interrupting panelists who raise very strong arguments proving that one nation one poll is a flawed concept

    • @harshildhaduk3766
      @harshildhaduk3766 Місяць тому +2

      Go to Palestine 😂😂

    • @Krishna________
      @Krishna________ Місяць тому

      It’s evident you’re trapped in a web of confirmation bias, only seeing what suits your narrative.

  • @vanceworld4981
    @vanceworld4981 Місяць тому +8

    One nation one election will later turn to "One election One decades" Later "One man no election"😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @strongsimba
    @strongsimba Місяць тому +3

    The ECI which cannot even hold 7 phases of LOKSABHA election with peace is dreaming of reaching the stars 😂😂😂
    Even they cannot hold MAHARASHTRA, JAMMU and KASHMIR together.
    Lets be realistic. Im not congress supporter

  • @Hector0782
    @Hector0782 Місяць тому +8

    Anchor Rahul is blindly obsessed with BJP .

  • @dinesh6489
    @dinesh6489 Місяць тому +3

    Election can't be seen as saving money. 🤦😡🤮

    • @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov
      @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov Місяць тому

      @@dinesh6489 Elections should be held impartially as EC has been holding it for the last 3 terms. What's the harm if we as well save money? Many more poor will be taken out of poverty line, as NDA has very beautifully done it for the last 11 years.

  • @bhalchandraarabatti8334
    @bhalchandraarabatti8334 Місяць тому

    Rahul you closing remarks is top class👌

  • @-AkhilTej-
    @-AkhilTej- Місяць тому

    🎯💎🏆 Great insightful & fruitful video 🏆💎🎯
    लोकः समस्ताः सुखिनो भवन्तु
    ( May all beings lead prosperous life across Globe 🌍 )

  • @allanmenezes8503
    @allanmenezes8503 Місяць тому +2

    Manipur situation has a lot of relevance with the conduct of election A government which cannot ensure law and order in Manipur after such a long period, will it be able to conduct free and fair elections where people can come out and vote without fearing for their lives

  • @forefrontgoa
    @forefrontgoa Місяць тому +4

    One India one election propaganda is just to divert attention from Chinese invasion in Arunachal Pradesh. When it comes to 2/3rd majority requirement it will fail. Our population is huge and it requires large security all over the country. The voters will be confused as to whom to vote. EVMs are firstly defective and to acquire more it will is a huge expenditure

  • @narzary2
    @narzary2 Місяць тому +6

    Only parties with big money will benefit.

  • @johnybukh6267
    @johnybukh6267 Місяць тому +2

    One nation one election?? which state will godi media cover😅😅😅

  • @Shubham-zn1ww
    @Shubham-zn1ww Місяць тому +3

    Rahul Kanwal is such a bhakt. He isn't letting the opposition speak.

    • @bobkr156
      @bobkr156 Місяць тому

      Yes you are right he is such a Bhakt....that he personally visited the Congress HQ--- in his own personal capacity .....met and bow down to various top official of the Congress party, ( Party President, General Secretary, Chairman) to clear his position as liberal neutral friendly journalists who never meant to offend the Congress party or its God..... and successfully got his Character Certificate issued by the party.
      Man.... being a Bhakt Rahul is suppose to do that to BJP/NDA but alas he has doing that to Congress Party only...
      Kanwal's bestfriend Rajdeep Sardesai had been doing successfully as RaGa also publicly stated. Now a days he is getting same from TMC

  • @pinkykonsam4169
    @pinkykonsam4169 Місяць тому +2

    21 thousand cannot take decision. Funny decision....why probe up Rajive Gandhi

  • @rajeshkumarvanka6974
    @rajeshkumarvanka6974 Місяць тому

    One nation one election is a good decision...

  • @pinkykonsam4169
    @pinkykonsam4169 Місяць тому +7

    Indian national media is very funny 😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @rudrooprionandi1921
    @rudrooprionandi1921 Місяць тому

    The state issues can not be addressed properly if there is one nation one election.

  • @radhachura11
    @radhachura11 Місяць тому +4

    Vjp agenda... One nation one party gundaraj
    UCC... Masterstroke to indian culture😊

  • @hemantapegu1053
    @hemantapegu1053 Місяць тому

    AAP member absolutely said it well.

  • @raajajagan
    @raajajagan Місяць тому +1

    Why not do every 20 years will save lot money !

  • @EnricNyk
    @EnricNyk Місяць тому

    If the ECI cannot conduct a single phase Election in a State how can they conduct One Nation One Election?

  • @user-fj3ic5kt3fakv
    @user-fj3ic5kt3fakv Місяць тому

    ఇదేమి క్రొత్త ఆలోచన కాదు కాని, అప్పుడు కూడ one time ఎలక్షన్స్ నిర్వహించినట్లు దాఖ లాలు ఉన్నవి. మరి ఆ పద్ధతి కొన సాగక పోవుట కు కారణం ఏమిటి?

  • @acpatel9491
    @acpatel9491 Місяць тому

    Yes, that is the only way to move forward. We can't spent most of our time playing politics.

  • @renganathkrishnan1196
    @renganathkrishnan1196 Місяць тому

    Rahul kanwal's loyalty and obsession to the BJP is unbelievable

  • @vsv7470
    @vsv7470 Місяць тому

    Some media people can be happy for this because of it benifits

  • @Whisperer-ve9wv
    @Whisperer-ve9wv Місяць тому

    Who will listen to these panelists???

  • @BharathBhushanLohray
    @BharathBhushanLohray Місяць тому

    Make 2/3 majority necessary to remove govt & simple majority to form government. If govt falls mid way, let Presidents rule prevail for the remaining term.

  • @Shubham-zn1ww
    @Shubham-zn1ww Місяць тому

    The question is, Vishwaguru-Attentionjeevi claims we are the 5th largest economy, we are becoming 5 trillion dollar economy, we are the MOTHER OF DEMOCRACY but we are INCAPABLE of holding elections. I mean, what a mockery. Never, during Congress' time did we see our government so helpless.

  • @maheeway1287
    @maheeway1287 Місяць тому

    The main objective is one nation one election one party

  • @allanmenezes8503
    @allanmenezes8503 Місяць тому

    In my opinion instead of one nation one poll , elected representatives who defect should be disqualified and not allowed to stand for elections for at least one term

  • @horatiusdsilva9473
    @horatiusdsilva9473 Місяць тому +1

    One Nation One Election , opposition should not except . This will be dangerous because Mr.Narendra Modi can do any foolish things by bringing Dictatorship.

  • @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov
    @raghuvirjambaulikar-sn2ov Місяць тому

    Rahulji, sorry, under the Global boss and Vishwa Guru BHARAT is always ready for everything.

  • @hightech8276
    @hightech8276 Місяць тому

    If a coalition govt formed in state ,then the ruling govt lost its majority before 5 years then what again election in all over india??

  • @IndependentViewOnly
    @IndependentViewOnly Місяць тому

    The only thing to be thought about it how many EVMS you will need then vs existing

  • @sreenathbv5586
    @sreenathbv5586 Місяць тому +1

    Kanwal couldn't able to conduct debate correct manner and he exposed many times

  • @manashbhattacharjee8572
    @manashbhattacharjee8572 Місяць тому

    Govt don't conduct examination neither elections, there are institutions for that.

  • @jonahsuchiang8940
    @jonahsuchiang8940 Місяць тому

    One nation one election big loss will be of the press and media industry.

  • @hemantapegu1053
    @hemantapegu1053 Місяць тому

    BJP's member is a fool to answer the issue and cost effectiveness

  • @bhalchandraarabatti8334
    @bhalchandraarabatti8334 Місяць тому

    Hey Rahul, how is onop against federal structure

  • @manashbhattacharjee8572
    @manashbhattacharjee8572 Місяць тому

    Media would loose lot of 'masala' of breaking news. But definately nation would gain by ONOE, the nation wouldn't be eternally in election mode.

  • @dinesh6489
    @dinesh6489 Місяць тому +1

    Tomorrow modi will save eat once we can save lots of the money.

  • @user-xl7zh7tf6i
    @user-xl7zh7tf6i Місяць тому

    Rahul, please dont call such AH (All Hoarse), politicians with vestted interests/ very poor conceptual understanding speakers as panel. Call domain experts, people who collected data for the ONOE committee or just call experts from economics, marketing, security. As its as mix of all these, not just politics.

  • @Piathungkikon
    @Piathungkikon Місяць тому

    Always against congress

  • @mathewvarghese6045
    @mathewvarghese6045 Місяць тому

    What happens if in a state no party or coalition in majority or incase contitutional break down or a state govt failed to maintain the law and order and requires to be disaolved.

  • @change962
    @change962 Місяць тому

    INC spokesperson is not up to it

  • @hingnamguang5635
    @hingnamguang5635 Місяць тому

    One nation one election and one bank

  • @user-xl7zh7tf6i
    @user-xl7zh7tf6i Місяць тому

    S Y Qureshi is a senior civil service person, I'm appaled with his language & knowledge levels. Cuvil servents are supposed to find solutions to problem. He is finding non-existent problems to a solution. Without even realising that the Govt is still building a concensus and is willing to tweak it. In such a case calling ONOE "ridiculous" by Qureshi is ridiculous.

  • @imranansari7283
    @imranansari7283 Місяць тому

    I fully suppored one nation one election.

  • @AmitKumarAlphaX
    @AmitKumarAlphaX Місяць тому

    NETA TO AISE HI 5-5 SAAL DIKHAI NAHI DETE THE, KAM SE KAM CHUNAV KE WAQT TO LOGON KO MIL JATE THE! AB SARA CHUNAV EK SATH HUA TO YE BEECH BEECH KI MUH DIKHAI BHI NAHI MILEGI!!😂😂😂😂

  • @HelloHi-ve2rk
    @HelloHi-ve2rk Місяць тому

    No not possible,naidu will pull out😂😂😂U turn govt😂😂😂😂straight to jpc then dustbin😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @manashbhattacharjee8572
    @manashbhattacharjee8572 Місяць тому

    Very poor debate, Priyanka gone into political mud singling, and then Manipur issue. Can't you get proper debaters

  • @hg6qc
    @hg6qc Місяць тому

    In indi alliance, there is one thing common i.e their shrewd smile. Whenever they are exposed, they start to give gandi smile like Sanjay Jha priyanka .. is this jhukki jhopadi fight 😅. Why do they use big big words like democracy khatre mein hai ,constitution khatm ho raha hai they don't say how ? Modiji got 240 seats to janta itni bebkuf nahin hai ki har koi inki badi badi words usage k trap mein aayegi

  • @pinkykonsam4169
    @pinkykonsam4169 Місяць тому

    If you keep boiling One state Manipur withe population of 30,00000 people For 1 and half year then u thing for 1 nation one election. And this funny anchor says u are comparing with orange and apple same on you Rahul......

  • @kesavansrikumar6514
    @kesavansrikumar6514 Місяць тому

    The opposition especially AAP representative says government will fall in 6 Mo. Cost comparison is for normal situation.. always if you have by-election you will have additional cost .. AAP and opposition looking for gov falling in 6 months.. this shows their mentality of unstable country… these people (opposition) is always negative and against Nation progress

    • @Divyansh-hm3io
      @Divyansh-hm3io Місяць тому

      Bro it's democracy cost save karni hai to 10 saal me election karao 😂😂

  • @chopisecharles5507
    @chopisecharles5507 Місяць тому

    Rahul is channel is totally wrong 😂😂😂

  • @lohithmjajee
    @lohithmjajee Місяць тому

    Mr SY Quereshi need to understand , a Bill is followed by changes in policies to enable it. Once this bill is passed then EC will have to ensure / plan to execute it in that fashion.
    Current EC functions based on how the current rules are framed. So using that as example not to improve system shows pure lack of progress / anti development mindset.
    If Mr Querishi was an authority in finance then No GST, No Digital India, No UPI, etc. he is sounding like PC Chidambaram

  • @GpsgGPSGrewal
    @GpsgGPSGrewal Місяць тому

    Miniscule viewership of india today (godi media ) .I stopped watching this compromised channel also due to compromised anchors Dardesai & Rahul Kanwa😢

  • @robinsonrebello4789
    @robinsonrebello4789 Місяць тому

    ZEROOOOOOO nation and election Scrap

  • @PhilipKamei-bd2vm
    @PhilipKamei-bd2vm Місяць тому

    This is just diverting tactic, not worth debating

  • @YAo-qm1fe
    @YAo-qm1fe Місяць тому

    One nation one election is only Damasha as the BJP trying to escape their Corruptions and not doing anything A Joker Modi

  • @lp1034
    @lp1034 Місяць тому

    Single-phase Loksabha election with adhaar linked voter ID and biometrics to cast the vote should be the priority.
    Rajyasbha members should win at least one Lok sabha election either before or after becoming a Rajya Sabha member and served one term.
    This might be passed in the cabinet and probably the parliament but will the public accept it?
    What is the EC going to do for the next 5 years go on a paid vacation?
    What if a government falls in any state or at the union have President's and governor's rule who will be a puppet of the ruling party at the union?
    The whole move is distraction of the public from key and pressing 8ssues wh8ch the government has failed to address in the last decade and till date.

  • @AbhishekKumar-nt1qh
    @AbhishekKumar-nt1qh Місяць тому

    Why India today always do that.

  • @tseringpaljore4996
    @tseringpaljore4996 Місяць тому

    No

  • @cool-aquarian
    @cool-aquarian Місяць тому

    BJP’s end goal: One Nation One Corruption. 😊

    • @MELOTION-24
      @MELOTION-24 Місяць тому +1

      this not your 400 par assembly 🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • @user-rz9yh8dw4s
    @user-rz9yh8dw4s Місяць тому +1

    Jasmine Shah...the biggest jhulmal in this country is the honesty of AAP JOKERS AND KHUJLIWAL

  • @TechRagaFusion
    @TechRagaFusion Місяць тому +1

    I am deeply concerned about the quality of representation in your ongoing debate on the critical issue of "One Nation, One Poll." Specifically, the lady representing Shiv Sena is an utter disappointment. Her complete lack of understanding of the subject and inability to contribute to a constructive discussion is alarming.
    Is she present merely for superficial appeal, with no intellectual capability to engage in such a vital national debate? Her background of switching ideologies from Congress to Shiv Sena speaks volumes about her political convictions, or rather the lack of them. Are such opportunistic individuals being allowed to appear on your debates just for a paycheck?
    Is it responsible for a national TV channel to host discussions on crucial issues with such unqualified, clueless participants? Are you seriously expecting the public to trust these panels? This isn't just undermining the debate but also insulting the intelligence of the viewers.
    I urge you to reconsider the quality of your panels and uphold the standards of credible, meaningful discourse.

    • @binukurian6339
      @binukurian6339 Місяць тому

      You are also a disappointment. Do you have answer for their questions which BJP spokesperson fails to answer 😂

  • @AbhishekKumar-nt1qh
    @AbhishekKumar-nt1qh Місяць тому

    Highly unprofessional and partisian on India today and Rahul Kanwal. 4 vs 1 debate . Still not giving time and chance to Guru Paswan

    • @binukurian6339
      @binukurian6339 Місяць тому

      There is no point in giving more time. His points were absurd 😂😂

  • @sreelathanair1080
    @sreelathanair1080 Місяць тому

    Who is the zombie shama…

  • @sreelathanair1080
    @sreelathanair1080 Місяць тому +1

    More to come..one country one law,HINDU nation…..❤❤❤jai sri Ram

  • @sandipmishra1651
    @sandipmishra1651 Місяць тому

    Naam mein Guru, baat mein Chela!!! Bakwaas karta hsi

  • @RaulKumarOfficial
    @RaulKumarOfficial Місяць тому +2

    I support 1 Nation 1 Election. Congress does not want India as a developed country.

    • @chandrareddy4392
      @chandrareddy4392 Місяць тому +4

      could you please tell me one logical reason for your support? could you also please let me know the what happends if any government gets collepsed before the turm gets ended?

    • @raajajagan
      @raajajagan Місяць тому

      Desh drohi

    • @binukurian6339
      @binukurian6339 Місяць тому

      So, there were no developments in 10 years since 2014 because of staggered elections? New capsule for Modi's incompetency? 😂

    • @indianpoliticalvideo7430
      @indianpoliticalvideo7430 Місяць тому

      ​​@@chandrareddy4392 Other than the massive cost which will be reduced, for me and many other who is working in different state can now just come once in 5 years and vote which might increase voter turnout and participation in elections.... And also there are lot of discussions which is extremely necessary but not benifitial for common public... And non of the party take those decisions just bcz of elections...
      And about the collapse... The party comes to power through coalition should continue for all the years ... This will give a full stop for horse trading of MLA's and other things..

  • @NareshKumar-hb2eh
    @NareshKumar-hb2eh Місяць тому

    Bakwas by Qureshi.

  • @jeojoseph8652
    @jeojoseph8652 Місяць тому

    BJP is incompetent

  • @shalloojohn3370
    @shalloojohn3370 Місяць тому

    Because of this biased anchor I stopped watching India today which I considered a decent channel.

  • @Piathungkikon
    @Piathungkikon Місяць тому

    Gay host

  • @venkataramanamurthyjagarla1558
    @venkataramanamurthyjagarla1558 Місяць тому

    Why don't youbstop the nonsense by Priyanka and silly shama. They don't have any valid point to the good idea of of onop. AAP just forget them.

  • @vishnureddy4457
    @vishnureddy4457 Місяць тому +1

    Country can save thousands of crores that money can be used on development defence infra. Congress will never support any decision which benefits india.

    • @chandrareddy4392
      @chandrareddy4392 Місяць тому

      could you please find the expenditure for the elections held in india? it is hardly 20,000 crores.

    • @chandrareddy4392
      @chandrareddy4392 Місяць тому +1

      it is 4,000 crores per annam. 48 lack crores of indian national budget, the government can afford to spent this tiny bit of amount for the sake of democracy.

    • @allanmenezes8503
      @allanmenezes8503 Місяць тому +1

      The Manipur situation has connection with elections If you cannot ensure law and order even after such a long period, how is it possible to have free and fair elections Many voters may not come out to vote in fear of losing their lives

    • @raajajagan
      @raajajagan Місяць тому

      Jumla ,modi yogi shah speeches meetings in states cost more than elections

  • @janardhanreddy9547
    @janardhanreddy9547 Місяць тому

    Priyanka don't have mind

  • @janardhanreddy9547
    @janardhanreddy9547 Місяць тому

    Congress people don't have mind

  • @sharmababu2444
    @sharmababu2444 Місяць тому +1

    Making fools to people promoting sangh's agenda.

    • @indianpoliticalvideo7430
      @indianpoliticalvideo7430 Місяць тому

      Yah from 1950 to 1970 there was one nation happening in entire country... Yeah that was sangh's ag_enda nehru followed 🤣🤦

    • @sharmababu2444
      @sharmababu2444 Місяць тому

      @@indianpoliticalvideo7430 Now in four states ECI failed to conduct election in four states in Maharashtra,Haryana,Jharkhand and Jammukashmir not in single phase. Then why you support
      1 nation - 1election.

    • @indianpoliticalvideo7430
      @indianpoliticalvideo7430 Місяць тому

      @@sharmababu2444 thats not how ONOE election is conducted 🤦 how lok sabha elections are carried out the exact same way ONOE, the only difference is the number of Evms in one polling booth.

  • @janardhanreddy9547
    @janardhanreddy9547 Місяць тому

    Mh BJP win more than 150 seats

  • @forefrontgoa
    @forefrontgoa Місяць тому

    One India one election propaganda is just to divert attention from Chinese invasion in Arunachal Pradesh. When it comes to 2/3rd majority requirement it will fail. Our population is huge and it requires large security all over the country. The voters will be confused as to whom to vote. EVMs are firstly defective and to acquire more it will is a huge expenditure