Cart With Legs (feat. I Like To Make Stuff) - Objectivity 169
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 вер 2024
- We team up with Bob from the UA-cam channel I Like To Make Stuff to look at a design for a cart with legs instead of wheels... More links below ↓↓↓
Featuring Bob Clagett from I Like To Make Stuff speaking with Brady.
Check out Bob's channel: / iliketomakestuffcom
Objectivity on Patreon: / objectivity
Subscribe to Objectivity: bit.ly/Objectiv...
Films by James Hennessy and Brady Haran
Royal Society website: bit.ly/Royal_So...
The Royal Society's own UA-cam channel: / royalsociety
Facebook: / objectivityvideos
Twitter: / objectivity_vid
Patron thank you page: www.bradyharanb...
Objectivity T-Shirts: teespring.com/...
"Let H denote a horse." is my new catchphrase.
Bob and Brady! Two of my favorites in the same video. That said if you want legs on a cart Izzy Swan is probably the guy to talk to
Arent you that guy who copies preexisting woodworking inventions?
Theo Jansen's ideas on bulldogs and dinosaur's are fine for me.
Am I seriously the only one here so far who immediately had to think of Sapient Pearwood, Rincewind and Luggage? 😳
Tim Berghoff Hence the toes.
glad somebody else thought the same haha
I love it! “He’s UNINVENTED the wheel”! EXACTLY!!! If it ain’t broke - don’t fix it!!!!!
Best part: Let (h) denote horse!
Boston Dynamics is building these now. They are frighteningly efficient, as they hop and jump and run over rough terrain with ease. The Cart with Legs is here, now, and not silly at all.
But notably, Boston Dynamics has not included a horse as part of the cart with legs. Perhaps the presence of the horse was holding Potter's design back? /h
I think one of their monsters is in fact a Mule...
True, but look at how many years they have been working on it, not to mention the serious amount of tech onvolved.
Kudos to Mr Potter, only took them 400 years to achieve the dream
yes but we had to wait for a lot of technological advances. that is a common occurrence. There is no need to shout about it, no one is calling robots silly. 350 years ago it was a different story.
I Like to Make Stuff is a fantastic channel and very sub-worthy. I love all of Brady's channel's and very much appreciate this crossover.
boston dynamics, get on this!
on the other hand we know how to build the strombeasts which have dozens of legs and walk along pretty clip and stable. its a surprisingly elegant and simple design that gets pretty complex
put wheels on the horse (h)
MichaelKingsfordGray
Well I can tell you the problem right now!
NEVER PUSH MONGO
(Not even if you're a horse)
I thought it would be legs like a Strandbeest (look it up, it's cool) has. that's what people build nowadays when they use legs instead of wheels when there is no active control of the legs
Strandbeests are awesome!
I agree on the awesomeness of Theo Janssen's works. Chebychev's plantigrade machine is similarly wonderful.
Yes, I immediately thought of those as well! The Strandbeast is(sort of)self propelled by wind vanes and walks under its own power. It seems the cart was meant to passively walk while being pulled. Hypothetically, it's advantageous to have multiple feet as opposed to two thin wagon wheels. The load would be distributed more evenly over a larger surface area. Increasing flotation over soft surface(to prevent miring)and potentially smoothing the ride (multiple points on the ground vs two points for wheels). Obviously it was technically feasible at the time.
it just wasn't invented yet. as this videos shows that they didn't use the better legs
Basically inventing a robot, with a horse as a power supply.
I would've liked to hear what the proposed improvement the cart with legs gives over a wheeled cart. Surely it's mentioned somewhere in the archive, or at least you can all conjecture. I'd guess Potter was thinking along the lines of related modern attempts, which is that they handle rugged and unpredictable terrain much better
I know you avoid it sometimes, but I loved when the microphone picked up the sound of crinkling paper when Rupert turned the pages.
Bob and Brady? This must be a dream!
That looks like something Simone Giertz might rig up.
When I saw Bob in the thumbnail I couldn't believe it, what a good collab!
"That's the question you're here to answer, not the question you're here to ask" Lol
The Flintstones combined the legs and the wheels, but Theo Jansen's Strandbeest seems to be able to move quite well with just multiple legs and wind power.
is he actually gonna attempt to replicate it? I'd be happy to see that, even if it ends up not working :p
I'd love to see Brady help Bob build this contraption!
Early robotics! (Or the original designs for the first proto-mech, for all of the Battletech players!)
Two of my favourites in the same video!? Is this the UA-cam version of the Avengers?
Major crossover, for sure!
[post redacted for spoilers]
omg mention of john Aubrey, I have research to do on the Aubreys. Need to visit myself.
Hey James, Brady, and Keith. Since its around the anniversary, would you be interested in doing a video on Arthur Dodson and his work prediciting tides for the d day invasion?
When I heard cart with legs, my mind went the boring route. I pictured a tea cart with wheels on one end and table legs on the other.
This makes one appreciate legs that work. Human, animal, insect, etc..
Glad to see youre still making these videos! Love it
the ultimate crossover episode
Are those 2 hoops actually springs so the cogs with the chains around can oscillate back and forth?
I hope he builds it with the toes because they were adorable :) and we'll need a (h) horse too
Where's Keith?
Rupert is discount Keith.
BOB!
These videos always help make my day :).
Cheers!
Most unexpected youTube crossover, ever! :)
Will we have more Bobjectivity in the future? I need more!
Wasn't Robert Hook the guy Issac Newton hated?
You know you can walk with wheels to but the results do not look like legs or wheels when you design a working model in a simple enough form to compete with wheels by themselves.
I whent with a flywheel like wheel design. Couldn't find a good enough use for it outside of just sand terrain and soft snow. Shame really it looked like a centipede and had some good qualities but just to many break points. Same as the cart design.
I imagined legs spread like a cricket, not human shaped.
"A cart with legs instead of wheels"
"Metal Gear!? It can't be!"
Well where is it!
Behind you!
He really should try to build this just to see if it would work.
HI WELCOME TO CHILIS
That was an interesting choice lol, but it seemed to work.
Hi, I'm Bob, and I like to... er, Look at old stuff?
A bit like a shoe-horn, the kind with teeth
nice haircut
Metal Gear?
where is kieth????
You don't have to zoom into peoples faces. It's just awkward. It's hard to predict the conversation, camera guy. So I just feel like a confused participant of the conversation. Otherwise the camerawork is great.
Hi I'm Bob and/at I like to make stuff
TheKlabim me too, I also recently made a 'walking' robot, similar to the jansen mechanism, or klann linkage
First comment Brady rocks
First!