This was a gem of a discussion by two brilliant scholars. What a shame it does not have more views - ironically, the lack of views is what they touch on at the end.
As a classical homeschooling mom this is exactly what is needed. We are bring back the quadtrivium. It is the arts of humanities with the arts of the sciences into a liberal arts education. Thank you for this conversation
Absolute gold. Thank you, Stephen and Iain, for this exhilarating conversation. Iain’s comments in the last ten minutes or so on the demise of universities, church and the media are spots on.
Iain's insight and Stephan's questions and responses are simply beautiful. I cannot get enough of these kinds of conversations. i would love to be apart of the learning these two have to offer.
Please activate Closed Captions for your future videos. Being able to read what is said makes listening to conversations much more pleasant and the content more digestible.
Brilliant, thank you. For anyone unfamiliar with Dr McGilchrist's work, I highly recommend his book The Master and His Emissary, which for me has been life-changing. It discusses how the lateralisation of the brain affects the way we view the world, the way we relate to one another, our attitude to the arts and culture, and some of the philosophical questions touched on here.
At 53:30 it's sounds like the sound of positive self awareness. Haven't heard this tone from mcgilchrist before. What a skillful interview with a powerful intellect/empath.
I really like how Ian doesn’t pontificate about how to “fix” educational problems or etc. saying that people are smart enough if alerted to new ways of viewing to solve the problems. They are deep issues. This is why it took me another 40 years after coming up with this fundamental problem in educational systems and I also use the same examples in the same way sometimes it’s uncanny. Anyway, the problems are much deeper and historical. And they are related to the rise and fall of civilizations, and the mortality of humans themselves. I cannot say enough about the courage and wisdom of Ian McGilchrist since he actually went through the system. He became a doctor. That training is the opposite of what keeps the right brain fully capable and functional. I left graduate school after 4.5 years of PHD work and a master’s project because I thought they were wrong. By “they” I mean everyone on Earth. 😂🤷♀️ Seriously that’s why I left-to write my own book about why. I told people that I left because there is no such thing as “spots in the brain” for any function because every spot is defined by every other spot. That was back in 1995 when I left. I couldn’t face a post-doc and trying for grants for something that was wrong 😑. This is where the educational system fails-it is a grid or “sifter” of cognitive wholeness at every level. There is no time to think or integrate what you know. It forces people to not think. Thinking interferes with good grades. SERIOUSLY. The reason people are skeptical of that assertion is because no one actually knows how to think. I do not think in words except when preparing for communication. Anyway… I would love to do an interview about this stuff for Ralston College too. I can tell you what the “logos” is and why this is related to all the major religions and myths. Thanks for this awesome interview. ❤️🔥🙏🏻 I almost forgot, lol… starstruck a bit… I worked out the details of how and why this works in the brain beyond lateralization and how it relates to everything else including what civilization is doing. Which we don’t see normally-like in the split brain studies Ian Talks about or the right hemisphere stroke examples. Thanks again. I really need help with getting my ideas out too. Ian and I would be extremely synergistic 🎼 I have been using the example of symphonies for a long time. Heroes are better together 🥰🙏🏻🙌 Only with me, I never let up on my work despite being reduced to living in my car the last 2 years because “no place was made for me in the world” as I always say. Yet here I am. Anyone who can help me I will be extremely grateful. I have had faith and strength throughout, but this is my mission god gave me on this Earth and I will never turn from that task. Thank you again. I have renewed hope that we can save the world before it destroys itself if I can get the word out soon. Ian’s ideas are opening the door. ❤️🔥♾
Thank you for that; both of you! Yes the people are so capable of hearing these deep and intriguing conversations, in fact a great hunger exists for them. I'm gratified that there is in the Deep South a college of this caliber, which I hope will prosper! Thanks again.
Applications for Ralston College's MA in the Humanities for 2023 are now open: www.ralston.ac/humanities-ma
This was a gem of a discussion by two brilliant scholars. What a shame it does not have more views - ironically, the lack of views is what they touch on at the end.
As a classical homeschooling mom this is exactly what is needed. We are bring back the quadtrivium. It is the arts of humanities with the arts of the sciences into a liberal arts education. Thank you for this conversation
Absolute gold. Thank you, Stephen and Iain, for this exhilarating conversation. Iain’s comments in the last ten minutes or so on the demise of universities, church and the media are spots on.
Iain's insight and Stephan's questions and responses are simply beautiful. I cannot get enough of these kinds of conversations. i would love to be apart of the learning these two have to offer.
Please activate Closed Captions for your future videos. Being able to read what is said makes listening to conversations much more pleasant and the content more digestible.
Brilliant, thank you. For anyone unfamiliar with Dr McGilchrist's work, I highly recommend his book The Master and His Emissary, which for me has been life-changing. It discusses how the lateralisation of the brain affects the way we view the world, the way we relate to one another, our attitude to the arts and culture, and some of the philosophical questions touched on here.
At 53:30 it's sounds like the sound of positive self awareness. Haven't heard this tone from mcgilchrist before. What a skillful interview with a powerful intellect/empath.
I really like how Ian doesn’t pontificate about how to “fix” educational problems or etc. saying that people are smart enough if alerted to new ways of viewing to solve the problems. They are deep issues. This is why it took me another 40 years after coming up with this fundamental problem in educational systems and I also use the same examples in the same way sometimes it’s uncanny.
Anyway, the problems are much deeper and historical. And they are related to the rise and fall of civilizations, and the mortality of humans themselves.
I cannot say enough about the courage and wisdom of Ian McGilchrist since he actually went through the system. He became a doctor. That training is the opposite of what keeps the right brain fully capable and functional. I left graduate school after 4.5 years of PHD work and a master’s project because I thought they were wrong. By “they” I mean everyone on Earth. 😂🤷♀️ Seriously that’s why I left-to write my own book about why. I told people that I left because there is no such thing as “spots in the brain” for any function because every spot is defined by every other spot. That was back in 1995 when I left. I couldn’t face a post-doc and trying for grants for something that was wrong 😑. This is where the educational system fails-it is a grid or “sifter” of cognitive wholeness at every level. There is no time to think or integrate what you know. It forces people to not think. Thinking interferes with good grades. SERIOUSLY. The reason people are skeptical of that assertion is because no one actually knows how to think. I do not think in words except when preparing for communication. Anyway…
I would love to do an interview about this stuff for Ralston College too. I can tell you what the “logos” is and why this is related to all the major religions and myths. Thanks for this awesome interview. ❤️🔥🙏🏻
I almost forgot, lol… starstruck a bit… I worked out the details of how and why this works in the brain beyond lateralization and how it relates to everything else including what civilization is doing. Which we don’t see normally-like in the split brain studies Ian Talks about or the right hemisphere stroke examples. Thanks again. I really need help with getting my ideas out too. Ian and I would be extremely synergistic 🎼 I have been using the example of symphonies for a long time. Heroes are better together 🥰🙏🏻🙌
Only with me, I never let up on my work despite being reduced to living in my car the last 2 years because “no place was made for me in the world” as I always say. Yet here I am. Anyone who can help me I will be extremely grateful. I have had faith and strength throughout, but this is my mission god gave me on this Earth and I will never turn from that task. Thank you again. I have renewed hope that we can save the world before it destroys itself if I can get the word out soon.
Ian’s ideas are opening the door. ❤️🔥♾
WTF....you must live.
I go hungry , often.
These are WONDERFUL! THANK YOU. ❤
The last 10 minutes are important. Well, the whole thing is important, but its conclusion is clear.
I wish this was 3 hours long.
Beau C. Diamond Music ..... and then a panel discussion and then a Q&A.... and then a weekend workshop up on the Isle of Sky!!
@@kbeetles nice dream lol
Brilliant discussion.
Possibly life-changing
Iain is on the Ball. Awesome. Brings it all together for me.
At 32:06, that concept is well-known in buddhism teaching: 境由心生 (Situation is arisen/reflection of consciousness).
Thank you for this knowledge
Wonderful and steady philosophy of consciousness / meaning. Keep up the good work.
Thank you for that; both of you! Yes the people are so capable of hearing these deep and intriguing conversations, in fact a great hunger exists for them.
I'm gratified that there is in the Deep South a college of this caliber, which I hope will prosper! Thanks again.
Loved "We need to up the game".
I will try to find a poem I wrote many years ago on what I consider is the"truth"..
What is the name of the philosopher he is talking about in 11:55 ?
Heraclitus
Yes. He is my favorite ancient philosopher too.
I would like to reference the quote from freeman Dyson. Would you mind sharing where this was published?
12:00 Coming together of opposites, the string of a bow.
Brilliant diagnosis beginning around 1:08:00 of what's gone wrong with the humanities in higher education.
❤
Y