Sometimes when you have someone as wise and knowledgeable as Rabbi Shapiro, you just have to step back and give them space to speak which is what has been done so beautifully here. Too many interviewers nowdays interrupt their guests which obstructs the flow of knowledge. Whenever I listen to Rabbi Shapiro, I always learn something new whether it be about Judaism, Israel or Zionism. I hope you bring him back in the future.
I'm an Israeli and I listen to it, all the same lies of any anti Israeli... Nothing new... Zionism is very very basic in Judaism and to claim otherwise is ridiculously absurd. The whole religion is base around the temple in Jerusalem (Zion is the other name for Jerusalem)
It is wonderful to hear this truly brilliant analyst! I actually asked you ,some time ago to have this great Human being on to clear the cobwebs out of the global north!!! Most sincerely Michael Foley 🤔
Excellent, Excellent discussion... very informative and insightful!!!! This video is a "Must Watch" for anyone struggling to decipher and understand the origins/definitions/delineations of Zionism, Judaism, and Semitism!!! Thank you very much!!!
Remarkable! More confused than before but grateful to experience the mess this mess stands on... People, if not done yet, subscribe, like and share... This channel is of value!
You're absolutely correct that this pact/law was front and center with the creation of the UN post-WW2, but IIRC, it's a reiteration of the agreements conceived by the League of Nations as a response to Germany's actions in WWI. This international agreement/law is why Germany's actions re: the Sudetenland were considered illegal at the time.
Thank you, Thomas Karat and Rabbi Shapiro. I have listened to this for 3 and half hours and taken notes. There are many things I have understood and read about. This is quite an eye-opener for consciousness and subconscious mind to stay open. As a reader of many books of various backgrounds, be it philosophy, history, religions & religious divisions, sciences, political science, economics, literature, music, and art. Governments and beauocracies. This will challenge me to be awake. With deep respect to both of you. 🙏❤️🌍🌏🌎🌿🕊🎵🎶🎵💫✨️💫
Thank you, that was enlightening. I had been pondering in the past months, what is it, to be a Jew? Considering what is coming out of Israel, and particularly the thing called 'secular Jew', I could not really wrap my brain around how to define. This deep dive clarified a lot!!
Thank you for this. Very interesting. I will admit, I will need to watch this again to absorb all of it. So complicated. I am saving it. Great content as always.
A very interesting conceptual analysis. I liked the joke about Netanyahu being the prime minister for random people, and as he is such a strange person, who never swears or has a hair out of place, speaks in dulcet tones and yet is presiding over the most distressing sadistic cruelty, it is interesting to learn something about his father too.
День тому+1
Go see his history with his father, not far from 20's Germany years...
What for me the biggest Question is ? Why Israel destroys so many Olive Trees some Olive trees were more than 2400 Years Only in 1948 Israel destroyed 900.000 Olive trees theyvplanted European pine trees but they burn every summer
Good evening, Kissinger stated that it will disappear before it reaches its 8th decade ( his words not mine) the question then is why bother analysing something that will soon disappear? You may say so that we may learn from history. Yeah, right.
I am from Rockland county New York. I am part Jewish, my father, but Iif I had met a man like him when I was young I may have been attracted to Judaism. I like everything about him. I love his accent.?❤
Zionists have already tried to built a first Jewish state in Crimea, modern Ukraine in 1930. As the result, the original Turkish Crimean population was forcibly banned to Central Asia by Stalin, in ONE DAY! Just imagine! Just to make place for jews who where installing over there. But later Soviet Union renounced to give Crimea to Jews, and gave a land in Siberia instead. That first Jewish Autonomous Republic of Birobidjan in the Russian Federation still exists to this day. Yiddish is the national language. Birobidjan is made 14 years before Israel. Right now there are TWO Jewish states : Birobidjan and Israel. So zionist propaganda about Israel being the only Jewish state is a complete lie!
Brilliant ! A fascinating - and frankly head-spinning - illumination. I didn't expect to be entertained as well - but the Rabbi is not just erudite - he has a wonderful sense of both humour, and of absurdity. And Zionism is absurd ; tragically so. Thank you both.
Thank goodness, someone actually gets! A religion isn't a nationality or an ethnicity. Judaism is a religion just like Christianity and both sprang from, and are very different to, ancient Temple Judaism. PS If the Israelis are correct, then all those Catholics in Asia just became Italian!
This was a great attempt at trying to explain an inherently confused and confusing situation. That there is no explanation of terms or descriptions of participants makes it difficult to create laws or enforce rules and protocols. It is a hodge podge of unknowns. I would call this a piece of land where a cult took refuge. It appears they wanted a Zionist state and had intention of making it a Zionist-only state. They did not want to say it, but that sounds like the intent. If the military/militancy defines your values, those not in agreement will never have inclusion. A state with so many seclusions and so many exclusions will have a difficult time remaining a state. I have asked what is a Jew. I have never gotten an answer. If it is a Jewish state, should you not describe what is a Jew? How do you maintain a state where only certain people are allowed to enter based on bizarre and arbitrary reasons. The state is simply a military base. They made no plans for anything but the military. They do not know how to build a country. The religions within are not formally recognized as participants in the state making Zionism the only party, the only mission, the only religion, the only priority. I am a victim of the Zionist state. I have been for 50 years. I was involved in a miracle that lead me to be followed by the CIA. I was handed to a contractor who had ties to Zionists. I have been drowned, cut, tortured to bring out the Messiah. My teeth are pulled out. I am repeatedly drugged and sexually assaultedmy hair is almost gone. I have metal plates that keep me from walking away. My truck was filled with my things and driven off of a mountain. I have contacted my government hundreds of times. I have had no one speak to me. Someone tried to kill my babies when they were born. They got the meaning of the miracle all wrong.
Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched-refuse of your teeming shore, send these, the Homeless, temptrst-tost to me, Ilift my Lamp beside the Golden Door - The Statue of Liberty
Ok so UA-cam agrees that Northern Ireland is a result of a settler colonial situation within Ireland. Happened within different plantations within Ireland Would UA-cam agree with that? Because its history and facts. Laois Offaly plantation, Munster plantation, Ulster plantation and then Cromwellian plantation? Would UA-cam agree with that? Because it's history, which makes it not something you can agree or disagree with So to add to that, the Rabbi's point that Northern Ireland is an ethno state re its foundation is not really like what happened in Israel. Elements are the same. Can UA-cam agree with that
@14:40 "there is no Jewish nationality" wait what?? We call the other nationalities the "70 nations". Obviously a Jewish nationality is implied there, our nation. And the Land of Israel was settled in a way that did not involve the legal construct of "citizenship", which is not found in halacha to my knowledge. One was a descendant of Jacob or a convert, and a Jew -- or else one was living among the Jews. This is an obvious reading of the Tanach.
And Israel present Levites Ephraimites Ruvenites Danites Isacharites Samaritans Danites Jews Benyaminites Ghadites Mannasites Shimeonites With other words 1 finger can not say its equal to 2 hands Jews are only 1 tribe of Israel
@YakovShapiro - The Moschiach can declare the Palestinians or anybody else who asks, to be descendants of Jacob and his twelve sons and thereby as inheritors of the land.... Demographic problem solved. How about it Rabbi? ... I have the lost Ahron Habrit (here in America [and the Menorah]).
Thank you for spreading this critical message!
Rabbi Shapiro, keep up your great work!
Sometimes when you have someone as wise and knowledgeable as Rabbi Shapiro, you just have to step back and give them space to speak which is what has been done so beautifully here. Too many interviewers nowdays interrupt their guests which obstructs the flow of knowledge. Whenever I listen to Rabbi Shapiro, I always learn something new whether it be about Judaism, Israel or Zionism. I hope you bring him back in the future.
I'm an Israeli and I listen to it, all the same lies of any anti Israeli... Nothing new... Zionism is very very basic in Judaism and to claim otherwise is ridiculously absurd. The whole religion is base around the temple in Jerusalem (Zion is the other name for Jerusalem)
Look up the Haavara coin Nazis
Modern day Hebrew is completely fabricated.
I always love listening to this rabbi. His knowledge but also his voice is soothing and wonderful ❤
It is wonderful to hear this truly brilliant analyst!
I actually asked you ,some time ago to have this great Human being on to clear the cobwebs out of the global north!!!
Most sincerely Michael Foley 🤔
It is great to see Rabbi Shapiro back with Thomas.
Excellent, Excellent discussion... very informative and insightful!!!! This video is a "Must Watch" for anyone struggling to decipher and understand the origins/definitions/delineations of Zionism, Judaism, and Semitism!!! Thank you very much!!!
Remarkable! More confused than before but grateful to experience the mess this mess stands on...
People, if not done yet, subscribe, like and share... This channel is of value!
The international law against taking land by force was enacted post wwii.
You're absolutely correct that this pact/law was front and center with the creation of the UN post-WW2, but IIRC, it's a reiteration of the agreements conceived by the League of Nations as a response to Germany's actions in WWI.
This international agreement/law is why Germany's actions re: the Sudetenland were considered illegal at the time.
Thank you, Thomas Karat and Rabbi Shapiro. I have listened to this for 3 and half hours and taken notes.
There are many things I have understood and read about.
This is quite an eye-opener for consciousness and subconscious mind to stay open.
As a reader of many books of various backgrounds, be it philosophy, history, religions & religious divisions, sciences, political science, economics, literature, music, and art.
Governments and beauocracies. This will challenge me to be awake.
With deep respect to both of you.
🙏❤️🌍🌏🌎🌿🕊🎵🎶🎵💫✨️💫
Thank you, that was enlightening. I had been pondering in the past months, what is it, to be a Jew? Considering what is coming out of Israel, and particularly the thing called 'secular Jew', I could not really wrap my brain around how to define. This deep dive clarified a lot!!
Great, thanks for this
Very interesting talk, thank you gentlemen.
Thank you for this. Very interesting. I will admit, I will need to watch this again to absorb all of it. So complicated. I am saving it. Great content as always.
❤️Rabbi Shapiro
44:15 The Jews were given their own state (oblast) in Soviet Russia in 1934, called the Jewish Autonomous Region, which still exists.
Palestinians can go to live there
Magadan
A very interesting conceptual analysis. I liked the joke about Netanyahu being the prime minister for random people, and as he is such a strange person, who never swears or has a hair out of place, speaks in dulcet tones and yet is presiding over the most distressing sadistic cruelty, it is interesting to learn something about his father too.
Go see his history with his father, not far from 20's Germany years...
"As long as God is my friend I don't care about people." ❤❤❤❤ everyone should think like this.
What for me the biggest Question is ?
Why Israel destroys so many Olive Trees some Olive trees were more than 2400 Years
Only in 1948 Israel destroyed 900.000 Olive trees theyvplanted European pine trees but they burn every summer
@@ZenatiOmar and destroyed the environment...:(
Thanks Rabbi. Very interesting to this non-Jewish American.
Thank you Mr Karat❤
Good evening, Kissinger stated that it will disappear before it reaches its 8th decade ( his words not mine) the question then is why bother analysing something that will soon disappear? You may say so that we may learn from history. Yeah, right.
I am from Rockland county New York. I am part Jewish, my father, but Iif I had met a man like him when I was young I may have been attracted to Judaism. I like everything about him. I love his accent.?❤
You could've spelled 'Shapiro' correctly🥶 Small matter compared to the IDF crimes, of course
Thank you 🙏
Thank you. Good message. I crave more Scripture as a support for the points made.
Zionists have already tried to built a first Jewish state in Crimea, modern Ukraine in 1930. As the result, the original Turkish Crimean population was forcibly banned to Central Asia by Stalin, in ONE DAY! Just imagine! Just to make place for jews who where installing over there. But later Soviet Union renounced to give Crimea to Jews, and gave a land in Siberia instead. That first Jewish Autonomous Republic of Birobidjan in the Russian Federation still exists to this day. Yiddish is the national language. Birobidjan is made 14 years before Israel. Right now there are TWO Jewish states : Birobidjan and Israel. So zionist propaganda about Israel being the only Jewish state is a complete lie!
Brilliant ! A fascinating - and frankly head-spinning - illumination. I didn't expect to be entertained as well - but the Rabbi is not just erudite - he has a wonderful sense of both humour, and of absurdity. And Zionism is absurd ; tragically so. Thank you both.
A true Torah Jew
Thank goodness, someone actually gets! A religion isn't a nationality or an ethnicity. Judaism is a religion just like Christianity and both sprang from, and are very different to, ancient Temple Judaism.
PS If the Israelis are correct, then all those Catholics in Asia just became Italian!
2068.
To homogenize Jews of differing cultural backgrounds, in other words?
This was a great attempt at trying to explain an inherently confused and confusing situation. That there is no explanation of terms or descriptions of participants makes it difficult to create laws or enforce rules and protocols. It is a hodge podge of unknowns. I would call this a piece of land where a cult took refuge. It appears they wanted a Zionist state and had intention of making it a Zionist-only state. They did not want to say it, but that sounds like the intent. If the military/militancy defines your values, those not in agreement will never have inclusion. A state with so many seclusions and so many exclusions will have a difficult time remaining a state. I have asked what is a Jew. I have never gotten an answer. If it is a Jewish state, should you not describe what is a Jew? How do you maintain a state where only certain people are allowed to enter based on bizarre and arbitrary reasons. The state is simply a military base. They made no plans for anything but the military. They do not know how to build a country. The religions within are not formally recognized as participants in the state making Zionism the only party, the only mission, the only religion, the only priority. I am a victim of the Zionist state. I have been for 50 years. I was involved in a miracle that lead me to be followed by the CIA. I was handed to a contractor who had ties to Zionists. I have been drowned, cut, tortured to bring out the Messiah. My teeth are pulled out. I am repeatedly drugged and sexually assaultedmy hair is almost gone. I have metal plates that keep me from walking away. My truck was filled with my things and driven off of a mountain. I have contacted my government hundreds of times. I have had no one speak to me. Someone tried to kill my babies when they were born. They got the meaning of the miracle all wrong.
Evangelicals are changing their minds all the time
Thank you Rabbi Shappiro Hashem Bless you and count more days to your life in good health and Happyness 120 years for you❤😂
Actually it's not a spiritual connection, it's very physical connection to the land and archeological digging confirmed it.
It's similar to what Japan did in the 1920s or Germany in the 1930s
Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched-refuse of your teeming shore, send these, the Homeless, temptrst-tost to me, Ilift my Lamp beside the Golden Door - The Statue of Liberty
Ok so UA-cam agrees that Northern Ireland is a result of a settler colonial situation within Ireland. Happened within different plantations within Ireland
Would UA-cam agree with that?
Because its history and facts.
Laois Offaly plantation, Munster plantation, Ulster plantation and then Cromwellian plantation?
Would UA-cam agree with that? Because it's history, which makes it not something you can agree or disagree with
So to add to that, the Rabbi's point that Northern Ireland is an ethno state re its foundation is not really like what happened in Israel.
Elements are the same.
Can UA-cam agree with that
Mawladat is also in Arabic born place
@14:40 "there is no Jewish nationality" wait what?? We call the other nationalities the "70 nations". Obviously a Jewish nationality is implied there, our nation. And the Land of Israel was settled in a way that did not involve the legal construct of "citizenship", which is not found in halacha to my knowledge. One was a descendant of Jacob or a convert, and a Jew -- or else one was living among the Jews. This is an obvious reading of the Tanach.
By the way another Jewish state exists in Russia. It was given to the soviet jews by Stalin in the 1930's.
What would happen if a water laden comet were redirected to impact, how would that extreme terraforming effect the inhospitible planet
*its soldiers.
As if Arabs don’t use religious faith in their terrorist actions ! All ha Ackba
And Israel present Levites Ephraimites Ruvenites Danites Isacharites Samaritans Danites Jews Benyaminites Ghadites Mannasites Shimeonites
With other words 1 finger can not say its equal to 2 hands
Jews are only 1 tribe of Israel
Judah..
The line of David to the Lord.
But Bible doesn't say seeds! But seed.
The spiritual body is Israel, not by blood association.
@YakovShapiro - The Moschiach can declare the Palestinians or anybody else who asks, to be descendants of Jacob and his twelve sons and thereby as inheritors of the land.... Demographic problem solved. How about it Rabbi? ... I have the lost Ahron Habrit (here in America [and the Menorah]).
just scream Alla who Acbar!!!!😛