Viltrox vs Sony: Which Is The Best 20mm Lens?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 12 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 79

  • @RandumbTech
    @RandumbTech 7 місяців тому +2

    You are going to LOVE the Zf! I've been adapting all of my e-mount lenses and they work great. As for this Viltrox 20, it's tough to find fault in a $145 lens. However, the footage with the Sony 20 looks quite a bit better and is probably worth the trade-off in size and weight.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      Just watched your video, and seeing you excited about the ZF is getting me excited... However, I think I may rent it first, but I love the idea of adapting e-mount lenses, too, so thanks for that!
      Yes, Sonys 20 is worth every cent, but both are easy recommendations!

  • @PhotoGearFun
    @PhotoGearFun 7 місяців тому +4

    I got the Viltrox a little while back and I have to say I'm very happy. I use it almost exclusively for video. I wanted the Sony 20mm but couldn't justify the $900 price tag. This Viltrox does a great job especially for the price. Thanks for the video hope all is well with you.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      I completely agree with you on all that... And honestly, we are all pretty lucky to have all the affordable lens options that we have. I'm thinking back even just a few years ago, it would be absurd to imagine something of this quality, in a compact ultra wide lens as the viltrox 20 with auto focus for that price... So it does seem like an easy choice especially compared to the $900 of the G lens!
      Appreciate that...and hope you're well, too!!

    • @censorthis152
      @censorthis152 2 місяці тому

      You settled for a far less sharp , inferior lens. You're going to regret it eventually. That 200 dollars could have gone towards the better lens.

  • @tonypmedia
    @tonypmedia 6 місяців тому +2

    Hella review man!!!! I'm about to scoop this now and get it here tomorrow from amazon.... on the next video, "Yo what's up peoples this is Brian and today I'm going to use my ZV-E1 and discus how I got my grass the way it is. Bad ass right?... stay tuned(intro)... discussion"!!!! As a lawn care worker myself, tht yard i could not get my eyes off man great freakin job.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      Ha ha... Good eye! I wish I could say that my secret to a well-manicured lawn was hard work, sweat, and toil, but it's really... just turf! When we decided to put it on our lawn, Los Angeles was in an extreme drought, so we thought it might be the right thing to do... But since then, there's been news of it not being particularly safe (carcinogens or something) and it's been raining like crazy here for the last two years. Regardless, it's super easy to maintain!
      And really happy you're picking this lens up, it's hard to pass up for the price! You'll have to come back and let me know how you like it... And thanks for stopping by and commenting at all! Appreciate you!!

    • @tonypmedia
      @tonypmedia 6 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano I sure will man, hit me up with a sub! I'll for sure be posting about this lens after my next shoot in a couple weeks. The video part is my going thing

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      @@tonypmedia done! Looking forward to it...

  • @soholingo
    @soholingo 7 місяців тому +2

    I was waiting for this one, excellent review as always. Funny you mention the ZF.... :)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому +1

      You helped push me to finish this review! And... You thinking of looking at the ZF too!?

    • @soholingo
      @soholingo 7 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano Yah it reminds me of my k1000 from middle school days. If it had the internals of the z8, I would absolutely change systems for it...
      (8k60p video in a hip body???? sign me up!)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому +1

      @@soholingo ha ha, yeah I get that. That Nikon ZFii is going to be it, then!!

  • @francoismarc3
    @francoismarc3 7 місяців тому +1

    "I have a fast moving son." Hahaha loved that. And woah, I forgot how much the active stabilization crops in... I once owned the 20mm from Sony, but sold it because I got tired of vlogging with a big full frame camera. I didnt take many photos with it, so had to sell it, but watching this video makes me miss it. Its an INCREDIBLY good lens. However, saving money is paramount, so that Viltrox is looking especially good. The vlogging with the Viltrox looks great too! I dont think anyone is going to notice a drop off in quality or anything with this lens. This comparison is NIIIIIICE! But now I want the A7c2 and the Sony 20mm again hahaha

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      I completely get all that...if we are not going to use our phones or pocket cams to vlog, then the camera has to be as small as possible, so the A7Cii (or zve1) and the viltrox 20 is pretty dang small and the quality is always going to be better than our tiny sensored step children!

    • @soholingo
      @soholingo 7 місяців тому

      The 20G is a lens that you do not sell. You will always be able to make that lens work for you even if you need to go to apsc mode. :)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      I completely agree!!

  • @OliverWiehe
    @OliverWiehe 7 місяців тому +1

    Great shot of the steam coming off the fence! Traveling with one lens and cell phone is a GREAT way to keep the bag light! It sounds like other lens manufacturers are making lenses similar to the quality of Sony for a lower price, you just have to know where to look - Viltrox is now on my radar! While watching I kept thinking this could be a podcast topic _ if you could only take one camera body - one lens and cell phone - what do you take? Thx for another solid episode that keeps me thinking !!!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      I love that idea, for a podcast topic and really a life challenge...to try and decide how minimal and compact you could go with a travel combo: one phone, one camera, and one lens. I think, I probably could easily come up with 2 out of 3 of those... But the viltrox 20 would be in the running!

  • @stkuj
    @stkuj 7 місяців тому +1

    TBH, I can't really tell the difference! Awesome travel set up! Out of the Chinese companies today, Viltrox is coming up with some real value-based lenses. I typically don't buy any lenses but Sony & Sigma, but I did buy the Viltrox 20. Heck it's so cheap! The Pixel works great as your B-cam for travel. Does the Pixel has stabilization?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      That tends to be my preference too (Sony or Sigma), but I'm also a sucker for cheap lenses especially if it's a unique focal range, and was surprised by how the Viltrox performed!
      I'm also been really pleased with the Pixel so far and it has really good stabilization. It has three modes, all way better than any phone I've used in the past.

  • @TomScryleus
    @TomScryleus 7 місяців тому +1

    Excellent video. I think the viltrox looked better in a lot of shots.
    I have been considering the tamron 20mm f2.8 in the past. good price, and compact.
    BUT... as I now have the king of lenses for minimalist vloggers (Tamron 20-40). I think I'm good...
    can you make a video about the viltrox 16mm? (or have you already made a video about it?)
    ps. also, those camera skins look amazing.

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому +1

      Thank you, and I completely get that, if I had the Tamron 20-40 (which I might get and sell off some others), I too wouldn't want for a 20 f2.8 by itself.
      I have been considering the Viltrox 16, but I currently don't own it. I really want it, but again I'm frustrated by its build. I wish they made it lighter and more streamlined. That being said, I may end up with it ...and of course, I'll make a video with it!
      Also, thanks...I really love putting skins on my camera. They are pretty divisive though for some reason. Some people loathe them. I just like to add a little personality to the cams because I find Sony's compact camera to be a bit plain.

  • @ArminHirmer
    @ArminHirmer 29 днів тому

    I have the Tampon 28-200 on my A7Cr and for wide angle so far the Sony 24/2.8, which is a bit to close to 28. So I ordered the Viltrox 20 when I am out and need a wider angle. All fits nicely in a small bag

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  29 днів тому

      That sounds like a perfect addition to your lens-lineup! It's crazy how compact the 20 is and how well it performs!! Hope you enjoy it as much as I have...

  • @chosenideahandle
    @chosenideahandle 7 місяців тому

    Finally with a comment here lol. Great video, as usual! It’s a tough one. I love fast primes, but it’s always a pill when it comes to shelling out the bucks for the nicer Sony glass. You know I like the Rokinon for affordability, and it’s so light! If I went back to full frame I’d probably buy the Rokinon again for travel (that would be the third time lol).

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      Ha ha... I get all that! Do you ever miss full frame!?

  • @alvarez7441
    @alvarez7441 9 днів тому

    I'm kinda low budget and I think Viltrox is perfect for who don't have what Sony is asking for

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  9 днів тому

      I completely agree... It's crazy the price difference and it still performs almost as well as Sony's!

  • @LivingInLAwithANJ
    @LivingInLAwithANJ 2 місяці тому +1

    Hey, I heard that about your wife not asking you why you got this lens!!😂😂

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  2 місяці тому

      @@LivingInLAwithANJ ha ha... Oops!!

  • @SolnceNavsegda
    @SolnceNavsegda 3 дні тому +1

    Please tell me what music is playing in the background?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  3 дні тому +1

      Hello! I'm not sure which track you're referring to but I'm guessing you mean the main title card song? Either way, all the songs used in the video were from the website Envato Elements, they sell stock videos, music, and assets... But because I don't have my editing timeline, I'm not sure which songs they are. Sorry!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  3 дні тому +1

      You can check it out here: elements.envato.com/?referral_code=15ff0513-dacd-4cee-9c04-2169f211f706&coupon_code=raf_mar23

    • @SolnceNavsegda
      @SolnceNavsegda 3 дні тому

      @@BrianCatalano 4:40 sec and 5:40 sec

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  2 дні тому +1

      @@SolnceNavsegda I will see if I can figure it out, but stock music is hard to search for... But I'll see

    • @SolnceNavsegda
      @SolnceNavsegda 2 дні тому

      @@BrianCatalano thx

  • @noisackda2564
    @noisackda2564 7 місяців тому

    Wow! This punches pretty high considering the price. I too wish the 16mm was smaller. Why did they make it the biggest and heaviest lens of all time?!?!?!?!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      That is a really bizarre construction choice... I'd still pay $500 for the lens if they didn't add all those bells and whistles. If they just made it smaller and lighter, the 16mm would have been a preorder for me. Maybe they make a 14mm f1.8, all plastic, or 17mm f2.... Here's hoping!

    • @censorthis152
      @censorthis152 2 місяці тому

      Actually , any trained eye can tell you the 20mm is on par with cell phone quality. The 16mm is heavy because to get 1.8 in 16mm focal range the physical optics requires that much heavy glass. (I'm an engineer who makes the software that designs lenses )

  • @deadman8816
    @deadman8816 7 місяців тому

    is your a7cii still has a AF issue? or did you find a way to fix it?
    im still waiting for sony or tamron's new update or announcement but no one's talking about this issue somehow..

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      That's a great question that I don't have a definitive answer for but after I updated the firmware to the camera and all my third party lenses, it's been pretty much as good as I could hope. However, as you saw in the beginning, the Viltrox missed a few times at the beginning but never again. I couldn't replicate the error, so I would say it's mostly a non-issue but not flawless!

  • @francoismarc3
    @francoismarc3 7 місяців тому

    Finding happiness in a bunch of metal hahaha. And wait, you are getting a Nikon?!?!?!?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому +1

      Ha ha... I had to add that because I feel ridiculous getting any more cameras. However, I'm going to rent it first, so it may be just temporary!

  • @1810fm
    @1810fm 6 місяців тому

    Hi there, can I have the link to your A7cIi camera wrap please. Is it from Alphagvrd? Which design is it, so beautiful. TIA 😊

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      Thank you!! Yes, it's from Alphagvrd, it's called nocturnal waves. Not sure if this link will direct you in the right spot but not too hard to find: alphagvrd.com/products/sony-a7c2-a7cr-camera-skin?variant=43948410437770

    • @1810fm
      @1810fm 6 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano truly appreciate it. ❤️

  • @antoniushansng6660
    @antoniushansng6660 2 місяці тому

    But is it good of photography? I planning to buy viltrox for hiking

    • @censorthis152
      @censorthis152 2 місяці тому

      Not really. The pictures are cell phone quality

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  2 місяці тому

      It really depends on what you are looking to shoot and what your expectations are, but you usually get what you pay for with sharpness or distortion. That being said, if you are on a budget, or want something really compact, the Viltrox is worth considering... But the Sony 20 is phenomenal across the board!

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  2 місяці тому

      @@censorthis152 Ha ha... that's fair. I think you do tend to get what you pay for with lenses especially with photo quality, but in a pinch, could work...

  • @noisackda2564
    @noisackda2564 6 місяців тому

    Yo Brian, have you seen the Laowa 10mm f2.8?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      I really wish you didn't ask... Of course I saw it and of course I'm salivating for it! You getting it!?

    • @noisackda2564
      @noisackda2564 6 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano The thing with me is if I want it, I'll get it. It's just a matter of time :P

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому

      @@noisackda2564 I'm usually that way, but often then a new thing comes out and I forgot the old thing that I thought I needed as a requirement in my life...and then an even newer thing emerges as a must-buy and so on--ad infinitum!

    • @noisackda2564
      @noisackda2564 6 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano :( But this lens tho! M'right? It's something different. Like who else would make something like this? Maybe TT artisans or Viltrox? It is a bit expensive for a niche lens though. Alright you've talked me off this ledge? Did you talk me off this ledge? I don't even know anymore. Are we living in a simulation? What is real?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      Ha ha! Just saw this... The simulation didn't want me to see it!

  • @sixx_xlr
    @sixx_xlr 6 місяців тому

    if they made their 16mm 1.8 like this it would be perfection :(

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому

      I couldn't agree more!! I don't quite get why they didn't...

    • @sixx_xlr
      @sixx_xlr 6 місяців тому

      whoever does is going to make a lot of money @@BrianCatalano

  • @stefansundstrom6755
    @stefansundstrom6755 5 місяців тому

    🙏 Did you compare it to the 18mm Samyang?

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  5 місяців тому

      I did not compare it directly with Samyang's 18, but I will say the 18 works flawlessly on the zve1. I highlighted it here: ua-cam.com/video/F6GUKIc50uk/v-deo.html
      And prior to a firmware update, it really struggled on the a7c2, shown here: ua-cam.com/video/c6gtXU_A7zM/v-deo.html
      Yet, now I think the viltrox being a newer lens does work maybe slightly better but again I do often prefer the 18mm on the zve1 and the 20mm on the a7c2... And am generally impressed by how good the viltrox is, especially for the price. Hope that helps!

    • @stefansundstrom6755
      @stefansundstrom6755 5 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano Yes, I’ve seen that 👍🏻 Great video. I was just curious why you prefer the 20mm 2.8 as travel lens to the 18 😀

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  5 місяців тому

      @@stefansundstrom6755 oh, okay... I got it! Well, I think it depends on the camera I'm traveling with but the viltrox is slightly smaller, feels better built (slightly), performs fractionally better... And superficially, looks better on the camera (which I know that's stupid, but...)

    • @stefansundstrom6755
      @stefansundstrom6755 5 місяців тому

      @@BrianCatalano Feels like I've been searching for the perfect vlog lens for 5 years now, starting to think what I really need are longer arms 😂 The Sony 24mm 1.4 is too heavy and 24mm is a bit too tight, 11mm 1.8 in crop mode on the ZVE1 looks fun but isn't flattering, I don't get its vlog hype 😂 The Sony 20mm 1.8 is too heavy. Only the Samyang 18mm and Viltrox 20mm 1.8 remain 🤔 I'm just doing Instagram for now and wide-angle lenses are even less flattering vertically. I'm not even trying to look good, decently proportional is good enough😂 thanks for great content as always! 🙌

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  5 місяців тому

      @@stefansundstrom6755 I really get the struggle... As soon as I think I found the perfect lens for a specific need, my needs change and my hunt continues! I do think though the viltrox might scratch that itch for you!

  • @Mraz75
    @Mraz75 6 місяців тому

    Man the price, i’m sold to Viltrox

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  6 місяців тому +1

      I know!! It's hard to pass up when it's so cheap, compact, wide... AND with good autofocus! Good time to get into cameras with all these third party budget lenses!!

  • @chrisnlm
    @chrisnlm 5 місяців тому

    cant go wrong with the viltrox. Im walking to bestbuy right

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  5 місяців тому

      I think that's a great decision! Hard to beat the price... Enjoy it!!

  • @strippedlist
    @strippedlist 5 місяців тому

    THE WIND TEST IS CHILDISH, BECAUSE THE WILTROX WAS ALWAYS ON THE SIDE WHILE THE SONY IN CENTER

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  5 місяців тому +1

      Ha ha... That's a fair point! I did test them separately and found similar results, and I was using touch to tracking--which shouldn't weigh differently in the center of frame. It's also no surprise that the Sony 20 is a superior lens; it's honestly one of the best I've used of theirs. However, I recommend the Viltrox because it's fantastic by comparison... and for the price! So you are right as I'm sure my tests were far from scientific and likely as inaccurate as using "CHILDISH" in the above sentiment because results may vary for you!
      Thanks for the feedback as I'll keep that in mind for my future videos!

  • @keifer39
    @keifer39 9 днів тому

    Is anyone vlogging with giant cameras anymore? Quite frankly, if you're not a professional making money from your kit you'd be insane not to consider the viltrox (or you have money to burn)

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  9 днів тому

      I fully agree, that's why I love the size of Viltrox's 20! Also, you're right... Everyone seems to now be vlogging on their pocket 3 over a giant camera and lens set up nowadays too!

  • @plutonium5156
    @plutonium5156 7 місяців тому

    Faster, better bokeh (cause faster), weather sealed, buttons and switches.... no brainer. Sony hands down

    • @BrianCatalano
      @BrianCatalano  7 місяців тому

      I completely agree with you, that's why it's one of my all-time favorite lenses... But if you're on a budget, the Viltrox is a crazy good value!!

    • @m4rcin847
      @m4rcin847 Місяць тому

      PRICE - hands up and status there. 900$ for 1.8 niche prime is ridiculous.