WHAT IS HAPPENING?! The Apothecary Diaries Episode 19 REACTION!

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 86

  • @ShiniTrek
    @ShiniTrek 5 місяців тому +167

    Nobody is supposed to know JinShi is of noble birth. Only a certain few. Him walking out like that is like revealing it to the world

  • @sonlen796
    @sonlen796 5 місяців тому +167

    "I think Maomao knows Jinshi is not a eunuch now."
    Manga readers: *frog noises*

    • @detroyes2
      @detroyes2 5 місяців тому +22

      Light Novel readers: Bwaaaaaaahahahahaha!

    • @its_penny_
      @its_penny_ 5 місяців тому +2

      Literallyyyyy

  • @MinscS2
    @MinscS2 5 місяців тому +140

    Ahhh, the episode that solidified this as an S-tier show w/o a doubt AND made me fall out of my couch...

    • @prasnatou4469
      @prasnatou4469 5 місяців тому +2

      my dumbass read, "made me fall out of my cooch"...

  • @Sheppart92
    @Sheppart92 5 місяців тому +203

    "The light novel author, Natsu Hyuga, actually confirmed in an X (formerly Twitter) post made in January 2021 that the guard later received punishment from the military strategist, Lakan.
    During “The Ritual” chapter, Lakan was visibly upset that his daughter was hurt. The short post of author Natsu Hyuga, also nicknamed Boar-sensei, revealed that the guard was beaten and tormented by Lakan for a while after that incident. The guard eventually managed to get promoted 2 years later because he is a hard-working guard at heart.
    She also added in a reply that the guard was just faithful to his duty.
    The events of episode 19 follow the light novel’s Volume 2, Chapter 12. Aside from this X (formerly Twitter) post, there are no further mentions of the guard’s character in The Apothecary Diaries’ light novels and manga adaptations."

    • @ma.2089
      @ma.2089 5 місяців тому +13

      Surprised they even gave him a good ending

    • @isheplatinum1218
      @isheplatinum1218 5 місяців тому +11

      @@ma.2089 Wouldn't say it was a good ending, since he was beaten and tortured by Lakan, but a fair amount better than expected considering he had pissed off two of the most important people in the country so badly.

    • @JakeTran141
      @JakeTran141 5 місяців тому +3

      @@isheplatinum1218well, if the story was accurate to it’s base material which is old China, the guard would have been executed already. Luckily the punishments in this series are more lenient.

    • @AniMageNeBy
      @AniMageNeBy 5 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for the info, though you shouldn't spoil too much. I have high hopes for a second season of this anime, after all.

    • @Sheppart92
      @Sheppart92 5 місяців тому +2

      @@AniMageNeBy The Anime only adapted Light Novels Volume 1 and 2, and there are currently 15 released in Japan so there is a lot more source material available..
      And they already announced that they work on a second season.

  • @kanzenatsume
    @kanzenatsume 5 місяців тому +39

    it's 7am and Angelo wants to see the state of things under Jinshi's table 😂

  • @Ash_Wen-li
    @Ash_Wen-li 5 місяців тому +159

    "Jinshi is getting ready to surpass the Emperor's brother in rank"
    Jinshi is the Emperor's brother as far as everyone else is concerned. Regarding succession, since the Emperor doesn't have a male heir (officially), Jinshi would technically be next in line. And if his true identity was found out, he'd be the heir by default since he is the Emperor's son. So anyone with knowledge of either of those things might be inclined to take him out if they want the future Emperor to be the son of a Concubine. ESPECIALLY if they know the latter since the Emperor having another son wouldn't matter if that information became public.

    • @um536vids2
      @um536vids2 5 місяців тому +9

      I think that the main disagreement between Jinshi and the Emperor is that Jinshi wants to fully commit to the lie. He believes that he can’t realistically be legitimated as the heir, because it is difficult to explain why they lied for 18 years about him being the Emperor’s brother, and some factions within the empire will dismiss the new story and assume that they are lying now to screw over the eventual rightful successor.

    • @biazacha
      @biazacha 5 місяців тому +7

      @@um536vids2not to mention what that would mean for Ah-Duo if the switch her did becomes public info, we know the biggest threats for the Emperor are precisely backers from the Empress Dowager. Neither the Emperor or Jinshi want to paint a target on her back, not now that she finally was freed from her role as concubine.

    • @isheplatinum1218
      @isheplatinum1218 5 місяців тому +3

      @@biazacha I think the biggest threats you are referring to are backed by the previous Empress Dowager (current emperors grandmother), not the current.

    • @stefotomov
      @stefotomov 5 місяців тому +2

      I actually think that Jinshi is Emperor and Ah-Duos son. The "emperor's brother" was actually the child that died, but Jinshi and that baby were swapped after their birth, although I am not sure if Ah-Duo and/or the Emperor know of that fact.

    • @Ash_Wen-li
      @Ash_Wen-li 5 місяців тому +1

      @@stefotomov That's the idea the show seems to be promoting. Ah-Duo knows for sure imo. I'm unsure if the Emperor knows but I think he does.

  • @XC11301991
    @XC11301991 5 місяців тому +82

    Lakan def cares for his daughter and he antagonizes Jinshi because he's the dad that's assessing his daughter's boyfriend. Obviously they aren't together yet, but Lakan def knows Jinshi is royalty and Jinshi has interest in Lakan's daughter.
    Lakan def is intelligent but as you've seen, he's pretty laid back and rather lets other people do the work. He has a general idea of what is going on but doesn't prone further unless it directly intrigues him or is his responsibility. He knew something was up with sabotaging the royal proceedings and was there waiting for his daughter to solve it most likely. Lakan himself seemed shocked more on his daughter being hurt is my bet.

  • @TheQuetzalcoatl
    @TheQuetzalcoatl 5 місяців тому +109

    she fell on his lap but she was concussed, she has no idea XD

  • @janewow77
    @janewow77 5 місяців тому +58

    Previous cases in previous episodes: The warehouse case (explosion, theft), excessive salt case (former warehouse manager - Master Kounen), rare food/seaweed/food poisoning case (current warehouse manager), metalworker case - it seems like random cases but those are connected in this episode. If case like Master Kounen happened like a year ago, this is like a long-term plan to kill someone...shows how important that someone is.

  • @hhound4283
    @hhound4283 5 місяців тому +52

    9:30 Seeing Lakan's face we now know where Maomao gets that face that scared Jinshi. 12:00 Everyone has their face lowered so as to not look directly at Jinshi, since it would be disrespectful to look directly at royalty and Jinshi's robes show hin as a high ranking royal figure. Maomao likely has a concussion, going into shock and passing out so probably didn't register the state of Jinshi as a eunuch (or not).

  • @szaxa272
    @szaxa272 5 місяців тому +82

    So about Jinshi not hurrying while carrying an injured Maomao, its considered rude for those of the upperclass to be in a hurry and to run. Its a public perception thing. Maomao was even scolded for being in a hurry earlier on in the series and is why everyone stares at her in scenes when she is running.

    • @Mitsu2040
      @Mitsu2040 5 місяців тому +1

      I didn't know that 😮

    • @-Bill.
      @-Bill. 5 місяців тому +14

      Plus, he obviously has military training (we've seen him sword fight and he talked about the camps) so he's probably got some experience with wounds. The head wound was the most dangerous (she really shouldn't have been moved - we know now) but I'm sure be can tell that the leg wound isn't serious enough to be fatal (in fact her dress will probably stop the bleeding in a few minutes as the blood clots) It will need to be cleaned and stitched for healing but she's not likely to die.

  • @viviennewood4836
    @viviennewood4836 5 місяців тому +30

    you have to understand that the scene on the stairs has a certain weight for the role that Jinshi has in the Court. an identity that he hides. Maomao during the time spent close to Jinshi has understood that he is not a simple eunuch, but every time she discovers new information about him, she prefers to ignore it because she thinks that knowing the truth could create problems for her. but you might already guess who Jinshi really is.

  • @aaronmgriffin
    @aaronmgriffin 6 місяців тому +20

    12:25 I think the symbolism is him leaving a trail of blood in his wake

  • @reeeyou
    @reeeyou 5 місяців тому +10

    11:26 No... 😂 Becoming an eunuch is a hush hush, behind-the-scenes thing. Except for their promotions, though there's still no big ceremonies like this for an eunuch.
    They will also obviously not have any ranking guards guarding an eunuch's ceremony (if any at all). Eunuchs are considered "Yin" in energies, much like women are considered the same, so they do not perform most ceremonies or rituals (there are some which are performed by high ranking consorts or the empress though).
    Here we see Jinshi wearing a robe with dragon imagery, which is often used for high ranking officials (which does not include eunuchs no matter their position in the court). Depending on the dynasty, it can also be exclusive only to those in the Royal Family.
    A very interesting detail if you look at the design of the dragon, it has 5 claws which we consider a "true dragon". Officials are not allowed to wear that particular design, they are only allowed to wear imagery of dragons with 4 claws.
    So for those people who understands the significance of these, it pretty much cements that he has never been an eunuch and he is actually widely recognized part of the royal family, otherwise he wouldn't be wearing those robes and be the head of the ceremony. And this is done without saying anything at all, pretty masterful story telling.

  • @SonesBen
    @SonesBen 5 місяців тому +18

    Gaoshun, who has to babysit all these weirdos, is the one you really feel sorry for.

  • @detroyes2
    @detroyes2 5 місяців тому +17

    If Maomao is Lakan's daughter... that means she is potentially noble herself. All that would be needed would be for Lakan to publically acknowledge Maomao as his daughter, and she would immediately be elevated in rank to the same social class that the main consorts are. And judging from what is said about Lakan's family being among the most powerful in the kingdom, that also means Maomao would be catapulted into the ranks from which high-ranking noble families choose their marriage partners. Like say, the Emperor's family.
    HOWEVER... I suspect the reason Lakan hasn't done that is because he doesn't want her to become just another pawn for his family to cement alliances with. I also suspect Maomao understands this and wants to avoid that fate as much as possible, which helps explain some of her reluctance towards her father. But its something to watch out for as the story continues. Maomao and Jinshi appear to be on a long term path towards one another, and sooner or later, Maomao won't be able to avoid some rather substantial promotions in rank.

    • @GreySeashell-j3m
      @GreySeashell-j3m 5 місяців тому

      She would be considered a bastard tho. The parents are not married. SO it's not as easy to "elevate rank"

    • @detroyes2
      @detroyes2 5 місяців тому +1

      @@GreySeashell-j3m Ummmmm.... the last episode of this season has some implications on your point. Legitimacy can be bestowed retroactively, and in any case, there is plenty of precedent in Chinese history for bastards becoming legitimate simply by being acknowledged by the father.
      The LNs make it clear that this is an option for Lakan in regards to his daughter, tho - at least up to the point I've read - he has not yet said anything about why he hasn't done so. It'll probably be a plot point somewhere down the line.

  • @skan8
    @skan8 5 місяців тому +19

    I just want to say that out of all couples' reaction channels I've seen, you seem to be the most healthy combination, also you guys seem pretty smart, which is a lot nowadays. I would like to have family friends like you guys :)

    • @martinloss4171
      @martinloss4171 5 місяців тому +1

      Yes, but her remark in 11:22 regarding "Jinshi becoming an eunch" was also 1 in a 1000

  • @stillmaomao
    @stillmaomao 6 місяців тому +27

    Agreeee, the music is incredibly well directed in this series. (and Jinshi DOES look great 😌)
    like you discussed, Lakan there was prolly shocked for multiple reasons (could be any, could be all):
    - that Maomao ended up in that severe of a state (maybe he sussed out something bad was gonna happen just not exactly what)
    - that Jinshi came out with Maomao (maybe he figured Jinshi was high up in the rank but not the position exactly)
    - lastly, that someone as high up as Jinshi willingly carried her out himself in front of all those people considering his status
    P.S. love how they hinted Jinshi participating in a ceremony in earlier episodes (i.e. him going vegetarian for a while)

    • @XC11301991
      @XC11301991 5 місяців тому

      I think it's def the first 1. as I believe Lakan knows Jinshi is royalty as he made a statement that only one would be able to oppose Jinshi, that one person being above Jinshi would be the empereror. 3. is a possibility but I really think it's just Lakan carrying for his daughter and def got angry she was hit, but was prob shocked at the state she ended up being.

    • @stillmaomao
      @stillmaomao 5 місяців тому

      ​@@XC11301991 true true

    • @ma.2089
      @ma.2089 5 місяців тому +1

      Lankan had implied earlier that he knew Jinshi’s position. I guess since it was vague, maybe he actually had the wrong idea and Jinshi just assumed he knew?

  • @ngasalaja2839
    @ngasalaja2839 5 місяців тому +29

    For me this is peak maomao moment

  • @nowhere3246
    @nowhere3246 5 місяців тому +3

    Don't know how I chanced upon your channel recently but I gotta say you 2 are currently my fav anime reactors. Been binge watching your previous anime reactions. When I'm done I will move on to your non-anime reactions.

    • @CarlieAndAnge
      @CarlieAndAnge  5 місяців тому

      Thanks so much! Great to have you here.

  • @japkorox91
    @japkorox91 5 місяців тому +6

    That was not a ceremony for eunuch.
    Only a royalty performs ceremonies, like praying to the gods etc.
    All the small accidents seem to have been made to look like accidents with the intention to harm the royalty that will be performing the ceremony.

  • @sammed473
    @sammed473 5 місяців тому +4

    APOTHECARY DIARIES IS PEAK STORYTELLING

  • @jasonwinterboer5232
    @jasonwinterboer5232 5 місяців тому +3

    The Emperor's sick brother... isn't that Jinshi? That's the position he got swapped into (and the actual brother died under Ah-Duo's care), and that's why he's never present at court affairs, because it's Jinshi off doing whatever Jinshi does.
    So it can't be the Emperor's brother trying to assassinate Jinshi, because they're the same person... right?

  • @Runo1923
    @Runo1923 5 місяців тому +7

    6:00 I'M DED

  • @BlackDerek
    @BlackDerek 5 місяців тому +2

    15:00 I feel like they are missing some key information about the Emperor's brother. 😂

  • @kingkord1227
    @kingkord1227 5 місяців тому +4

    Yall, Kaiju n0 8 is practically made for you

  • @MyaMore-cb7zb
    @MyaMore-cb7zb 5 місяців тому +4

    God Ange got me there ahah, i'm still laughing ! D:

  • @dorkshoujo
    @dorkshoujo 5 місяців тому +7

    Laughing over Angelo's remarks about Jinshi's manhood and Carlie simping over his hair😂😂
    Hahahaha FYI the ceremonial rite is something that's only done by some1 of upper rank/noble etc. So in that moment when he was carrying Maomao, every1 was bowing to him and they were also shocked of him carrying Maomao😅 that's all I can spoil for now but it's quite obvious at this pt who Jinshi is haha😅

  • @Fatima-gn1nv
    @Fatima-gn1nv 5 місяців тому +3

    Solo i membri della famiglia reale possono officiare le cerimonie quindi jinshi fa parte della famiglia reale. Maomao non ascolta ciò che non le interessa per evitare di essere coinvolta ma è incuriosita da chi sia in realtà jinshi. Lakan è scioccato e arrabbiato perché Maomao è ferita. L' ultima scena jinshi porta in braccio Maomao in segno di rispetto, un membro della famiglia reale salvato da una serva. E' un gesto simbolico che fa uscire allo scoperto jinshi ( non è il suo vero nome)

  • @AniMageNeBy
    @AniMageNeBy 5 місяців тому

    Aha! THE episode to watch for! Very curious to your reaction, now!

  • @luferink5218
    @luferink5218 5 місяців тому +1

    I loved this episode 🥲

  • @Yishy22
    @Yishy22 5 місяців тому

    Great cover!

  • @biskuitmelempem9805
    @biskuitmelempem9805 5 місяців тому +1

    Beginning of the episode😂😊😂
    Ending of the episode 😲🤬😱😰😭

  • @craigroberts5688
    @craigroberts5688 5 місяців тому +1

    Hi great reaction as always. Was just wondering if you had castlevania a Netflix series on your radar to react to ? Fantastic series think you would both love it.

  • @smugsneasel
    @smugsneasel 5 місяців тому +3

    Man season 2 is such a banger. Granted it couldn't have become so without all that setup from season 1. I love this show. But certainly not as much as Jinshi loves MaoMao. That boy loves her so freaking much.

  • @eshw23
    @eshw23 5 місяців тому

    Pleaase react to Castlevania and Lord of the rings.

  • @mrthedave1745
    @mrthedave1745 5 місяців тому

    🐸🐸😂😂

  • @letstalkmangaandanime1396
    @letstalkmangaandanime1396 5 місяців тому

    please react to Classroom Of The Elite

  • @AniMageNeBy
    @AniMageNeBy 5 місяців тому +14

    Hmm... A bit disappointing. You both weren't cooking.... at all. I'm not understanding how you missed all the clues that were strewn around when Maomao was researching the issue with the ceremonials. Maybe I was expecting too much, but... At some episodes, you guys are really quick-witted and grasp things like it's nothing, but now you were both... very slow on the uptake.

    • @ScoffeeBean
      @ScoffeeBean 5 місяців тому +6

      Breath of fresh air honestly. Doesn't mean they're slow, it's just a good anime with a lot of subtle clues not everyone will catch until it's revealed.

    • @AenimaEater
      @AenimaEater 5 місяців тому +2

      Agreed, they were off their game this time

    • @ealexgu
      @ealexgu 5 місяців тому +2

      especially Carli. I don't get how she still thought the emperor's brother as a separate character when the anime spent 1 cour revealing that the baby died.

    • @choikangkai7611
      @choikangkai7611 5 місяців тому +3

      They're reacting not taking a test. They've always been saying that theorizing aint their strong point, and that surprisingly they are doing fine in this show but obviously not all the time. The shock might have contributed too lol

    • @AniMageNeBy
      @AniMageNeBy 5 місяців тому +1

      @@choikangkai7611 Well, if they were taking a test, they would have flunked. Now, I'm just saying it was kinda disappointing they were so slow on the uptake, while in other episodes they seemed to have a firm grasp on things and were pretty astute in their reaction.
      To each his own, but I prefer the latter instead of the former.
      But, ah well, no drama. Everyone can have an off-day. I blame it on the dumbing down by them watching OP lately. ;-)

  • @ostap_frost7898
    @ostap_frost7898 5 місяців тому +8

    Maomao is hurt really bad, trying to save you. What Jinshi will do, run for his life to find the doctor and treat her as fast as possible? Of cousre not. He will walk down the stairs slowly with cool face while Maomao is unconscious and bleeding and everyone around is watching. Typical anime moment

    • @giulsi
      @giulsi 5 місяців тому +5

      I heard he ran in the manga

    • @ma.2089
      @ma.2089 5 місяців тому +2

      Yeah, they decided for drama over actual realism there. Apparently the manga and assuredly LN had him run

    • @szaxa272
      @szaxa272 5 місяців тому +6

      There actually is a meaning to it. Its actually frowned upon for nobles to run, its considered disgraceful and a peasant thing. Thats why Maomao was scolded for it earlier on in the series.

    • @janewow77
      @janewow77 5 місяців тому +6

      Suddenly being pushed like that to the wall, even though he wasn't injured, that may impact him somehow maybe. Also yeah, ceremonial clothes may be heavy & carrying Mao Mao, maybe just to make sure he won't fall and make things worse. He did not know how bad her injury that time (but seeing her face and foot that time, it looked really bad indeed), it's like carrying her carefully not to injure her more maybe. Also, he could still be in shock like what just happened, why Mao Mao was there, etc

    • @-Bill.
      @-Bill. 5 місяців тому +8

      Jinshi has some military training as he could sword fight, and talked about the camps, so he likely has some experience with wounds. That leg wound was not bleeding enough to be immediately fatal and would likely stop once the dress became saturated and started to adhere to the skin and clotting began.
      Jostling someone with a severe head wound by running with them could actually kill them. Today, EMT's wouldn't move her at all until they stabilized her spine regardless of that leg. They would apply pressure but Jinshi is alone with everyone being too scared to do anything given what nearly happened to a royal. He's also got to maintain his dignity, it can be life and death in Imperial China.
      He's honoring her by carrying her, but being frantic and yelling about her might actually get her killed as people could use her to get to him. It's not out of the question for him to walk slowly regardless of the manga panels. I think the anime just really wanted to hammer home how subservient EVERYONE was to him.

  • @Crobemeister
    @Crobemeister 5 місяців тому +2

    Jinshi is the emperors brother. Only reason I'm "spoiling' this is because I'm pretty sure ,as the audience, you're supposed to get that by this point in the story. Maomao is still in denial about it and hasn't put it together yet. It's a little confusing because Maomao is normally so observant and gets things fast, but she has a blind spot for Jinshi. Jinshi is the child of Ah-Duo and the previous emperor, but was passed off as the Empress dowagers baby in the swap. So in reality Jinshi is a half-brother to the current emperor, but is essentially a full brother because of the baby swap.

    • @a2daj
      @a2daj 5 місяців тому

      You’re “spoiling” things but with some misinformation. They laid out the correct information in the show. Ah-Duo and the previous emperor never had a kid together.

    • @unknowndude494
      @unknowndude494 5 місяців тому

      Jinshi is the son of Ah-Duo and the current emperor

  • @nole5549
    @nole5549 5 місяців тому

    What is this lol

  • @92Juto
    @92Juto 5 місяців тому +1

    Dumbest reactors i've ever seen. At least they're sometimes funny i guess