This budget is going to change things massively - Sky's Ed Conway analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 414

  • @At_the_races
    @At_the_races 26 днів тому +22

    Unemployment and inflation are going to soar.

  • @brad9205
    @brad9205 27 днів тому +42

    Everytime the government increase the financial burden on business the media say that companies will have to "absorb" some of it. Just how much do they think they can absorb? They don't absorb any of it. It all ends up in the price of the product, which is partly why everything is so expensive, and why so many find day-to-day living such a struggle. And yet they will still champion extra costs on the businesses supplying them with the things they need, thinking that the money is taken from shareholder funds. It most certainly is not.

    • @MrIDFWU
      @MrIDFWU 27 днів тому

      Every time? The burden has been on the people for how long now? Businesses need to pay up

    • @Fab666.
      @Fab666. 25 днів тому +1

      @@MrIDFWUbusinesses won’t pay a penny extra, it’ll trickle down to the consumer and employees in a flash.. because the businesses can make it happen

  • @NSW-ye3xw
    @NSW-ye3xw 27 днів тому +44

    Those hotel bills must be overdue.

    • @NorfLondon4Eva
      @NorfLondon4Eva 27 днів тому +8

      So is your dole money

    • @lynxo5695
      @lynxo5695 27 днів тому +3

      Migrants hotels cost 8million a day. Which is billions annually.

    • @anatolydyatlov5196
      @anatolydyatlov5196 26 днів тому +2

      ​@@lynxo5695 the Tories are to blame for immigrants in hotels, Labour are actually processing asylum claims meaning the hotels are emptying

    • @Chris-pq3wp
      @Chris-pq3wp 26 днів тому

      ​@@anatolydyatlov5196yeah giving them residency, which no one wants!

    • @TomNook.
      @TomNook. 26 днів тому +1

      3bn a year on housing boat arrivals. 3bn on Ukraine every year....until as long as it takes.

  • @dave0n2wheels69
    @dave0n2wheels69 27 днів тому +109

    The most important aspect of taxation is who is paying it, why is this never reported? This budget appears to place the burden more on those who can afford it.

    • @Mattarm2720
      @Mattarm2720 27 днів тому +31

      I agree, I watched the entire budget, I couldn't place fault with anything aside from maybe the thresholds for NI employer contributions. I thought it was a well explained well thought out budget, of course Tory client media will bank on the fact that the average person isn't going to watch the whole thing, much of sunaks response to the budget was actually debunked within the budget statement, and they totally forget that the obr is releasing their report tomorrow and covering all of sunaks nonsense. He also forgets that hunt tried to block the report altogether claiming political shenanigans, it was meant to be released directly after the budget, but it's been moved to tomorrow instead

    • @wildandbarefoot
      @wildandbarefoot 27 днів тому +11

      It may help if media presenters had to declare their personal tax interest before they pose as unbiased arbiters. Rigby looked like she'd been literally slapped.

    • @dave0n2wheels69
      @dave0n2wheels69 27 днів тому +11

      @@Mattarm2720 Let's hope the public will see through the misrepresentations in the press, and see this budget for what it was - a good first step towards recovery.

    • @adventtrooper
      @adventtrooper 27 днів тому +2

      @@Mattarm2720 Headlines are tonight in TV, and tomorrow morning in print. By 11am tomorrow, enough people will have 'seen' the budget to not bother looking again and the OBR report can be buried.

    • @dareilori6413
      @dareilori6413 27 днів тому +7

      The workers/consumers will be the ones paying it in my opinion. Companies may be forced to offer less pay rise and/or increase cost of products and services. If UK businesses have to find £20b in their cost of doing business, then they will have to review their margin requirements in line with ROCE.

  • @manojchowdhary4208
    @manojchowdhary4208 25 днів тому +4

    So to summarize- much higher taxes, higher government borrowing, somewhat higher investment but still lower growth? 😢😮

  • @NTL578
    @NTL578 27 днів тому +137

    Seems like most of the taxation was placed on multinationals companies and billionaires.

    • @jivebunny3765
      @jivebunny3765 27 днів тому +48

      Nonsense. It's all gone on small private business.

    • @danguee1
      @danguee1 27 днів тому +18

      I've worked my socks off for 40+ years of my working life. I've never employed anyone and I've never required capital. But I've lived frugally and saved/invested hard. Me and my small one-man limited company are going to be hammered. So much for being responsible and saving for my retirement.... [same with my health: I've eaten healthily and kept fit - but, I know my medical 'needs' as far as the NHS is concerned, are less than the obese drinkers/smokers ahead of me in the queue...].

    • @nathanmitchell295
      @nathanmitchell295 27 днів тому +18

      lol what? Labour are the party for multinationals. They much prefer everyone working for big corporations instead of starting their own business or finding their own path.

    • @RB-n6c
      @RB-n6c 27 днів тому +4

      If it has, wave goodbye to multinationals companies and billionaires, and say hello to higher prices and mass unemployment.

    • @dunnomate3587
      @dunnomate3587 27 днів тому

      @@jivebunny3765not true, small businesses are actually better off with this budget, they don’t have to pay ANY NI for their staff

  • @joeblogs5163
    @joeblogs5163 27 днів тому +74

    I bet they could raise £B's on taxing all the gifts/bribes MP's get 😂😂😂😂😂

    • @4adiarmuid
      @4adiarmuid 27 днів тому

      just claw back tory corruption and it would raise billions

    • @MrSatnavatron
      @MrSatnavatron 27 днів тому +1

      it just about covers the 37 billion spent on track & trace

  • @Centaur987
    @Centaur987 27 днів тому +75

    Need to take into account the black hole in the budget at the end. Comparing the March OBR figures is disingenious as they said their figures would have been materially different if given the full information

    • @KS-kn9tn
      @KS-kn9tn 27 днів тому

      The “black hole” is what they want to pay themselves they are self serving, arrogant thieves

    • @danmks2
      @danmks2 27 днів тому +10

      Absolutely. Not clear at all that this has been accounted for. Ergo, the comparison is unlikely to be valid

    • @dareilori6413
      @dareilori6413 27 днів тому +1

      So, what are those lines hidden from OBR? Compensation? We look forward to seeing what OBR did not know in March that now known?

    • @joskowal3711
      @joskowal3711 27 днів тому +6

      I agree this was really irresponsible analysis... I'm all for giving the government a hard time but outright misrepresenting data to put them in a bad light is wrong.

    • @Charlieb6308
      @Charlieb6308 27 днів тому

      Lies beget lies

  • @equinox95
    @equinox95 27 днів тому +53

    The UK is a sinking ship.

    • @justsain3236
      @justsain3236 27 днів тому

      They don't want to compete with American companies like Intel, Twitter, Apple, Boeing and as a result the country becomes poorer.

    • @suntzu94
      @suntzu94 27 днів тому +2

      But the brits told me “Brittania rules the waves” 😂😂😂

    • @dancoy09
      @dancoy09 27 днів тому +6

      ​@@suntzu94 How's the weather in Moscow?

    • @CardinalNous
      @CardinalNous 27 днів тому +9

      @@dancoy09 Economically better than the UK

    • @AGTC009
      @AGTC009 24 дні тому +1

      It already has ! It's a submarine.

  • @moonstomper68
    @moonstomper68 27 днів тому +8

    Tax and spend, we all knew it, a leopard never changes its spots

  • @rayfearne1379
    @rayfearne1379 27 днів тому +8

    We all know, this is not a budget for Growth! It's a disaster for the UK! Labour, need to go!

    • @H5ddt
      @H5ddt 26 днів тому

      We gave the conservatives a 14 year chance let’s relax and watch

  • @HarleyMolesworth
    @HarleyMolesworth 27 днів тому +28

    Tax and borrowing to increase enormously to the highest ever level in order 'to drive growth' - and the growth forecast is actually downgraded significantly as a result. Genius. Great job. Not

  • @G3Z44
    @G3Z44 27 днів тому +15

    So good of them to place an extra big burden on many businesses that are still recovering from covid, rising interest on Covid loans, 2 times increases in wage costs in the last two years and now further wage costs and ni costs to employers. Where has any incentive gone to take a risk and start your own business or even try to maintain one. Might as well just work for the government which it seems we are effectively going to be doing from now on in. Hardly going for growth in my opinion. This and the previous governments incompetence and level of waste is a disgrace.

    • @jaybee4288
      @jaybee4288 27 днів тому +3

      People shouldn’t be starting businesses though that’s part of the point. Like it or not we are a nation of workers. It’s wrong that people in the right place, time or with the privilege to have start up funds can earn so much more than the rest of us and not contribute more.

    • @G3Z44
      @G3Z44 27 днів тому +3

      @ so if people weren’t starting or operating businesses who employs everyone?

  • @Centaur987
    @Centaur987 27 днів тому +104

    Good budget. Actual spending on the economy and developing the country.

    • @Dan-ze4qz
      @Dan-ze4qz 27 днів тому +38

      Paying for hotels that's all we're doing

    • @TheSkaffen
      @TheSkaffen 27 днів тому +1

      @@Dan-ze4qz Don't forget the attack submarines.

    • @john-9074
      @john-9074 27 днів тому +30

      Great budget? - The forecast is now projecting lower growth as a consequence of the increased taxes.

    • @NickGodwin
      @NickGodwin 27 днів тому +5

      Yep. Although joining Single Market would benefit everyone.

    • @paulbird3235
      @paulbird3235 27 днів тому

      This is exactly what the Tory's failed to do. They were to busy looking after their friends, and robbing the poor.

  • @ri-lh3zi
    @ri-lh3zi 27 днів тому +35

    We all knew after furlough our taxes in the future would increase. It's just happened a lot sooner than most were ready for.

    • @NTL578
      @NTL578 27 днів тому +2

      Hopefully they do go after people who fiddled it, like she said.

    • @alansouthall8221
      @alansouthall8221 27 днів тому +1

      should slash spending

    • @PJH13
      @PJH13 27 днів тому +1

      If it were to pay for furlough you'd see taxes increase and borrowing come down; borrowing is actually increasing a lot too though.

    • @damianbutterworth2434
      @damianbutterworth2434 27 днів тому

      @@PJH13 yep. Never balanced the books in 20 years. The government keep making a crisis to borrow more.

  • @NipunSawhney93
    @NipunSawhney93 26 днів тому +7

    This is clearly the worst budget in a century.

    • @jake751
      @jake751 25 днів тому

      Don't talk stupid

  • @richardjoangreen6918
    @richardjoangreen6918 27 днів тому +30

    Where is all the money coming from if the country owes so much already

    • @TimoDyer
      @TimoDyer 27 днів тому

      Boris Johnson and Liz Truss added 1 trillion to the debt. Hunt left a 22bn black hole. What a car wreck to work with.

    • @HS-sr9ww
      @HS-sr9ww 27 днів тому +5

      Fed mate. keep printing the money= Inflation

    • @dareilori6413
      @dareilori6413 27 днів тому +2

      More debt

    • @jivebunny3765
      @jivebunny3765 27 днів тому +3

      100% transfer of money from private business to the state.

    • @PJH13
      @PJH13 27 днів тому +8

      @@HS-sr9ww Unsuprisingly Mr Bot, the UK does not have a 'Fed' - we are not a federation.

  • @vanessarealrose5919
    @vanessarealrose5919 26 днів тому +2

    All I see is us working class suffering even more, money taken from our hard work to be used for their gain and not ours.

  • @ABanRocks
    @ABanRocks 27 днів тому +19

    Big taxes and big borrowing. Labour will destroy the economy as always. 😮

    • @ArcadeStunfisk
      @ArcadeStunfisk 27 днів тому +2

      Can’t be any worse than the Tories have destroyed it over the past 14 years

    • @robertreynolds580
      @robertreynolds580 26 днів тому +1

      @@ArcadeStunfisk It is...we can't afford this borrowing. Put into perspective...we are now paying MORE in interest...EVERY YEAR...on the borrowing than we do for our schools.

    • @dovetonsturdee7033
      @dovetonsturdee7033 26 днів тому

      @@ArcadeStunfisk But I understand from the manifesto that Labour had a plan?

    • @robertreynolds580
      @robertreynolds580 26 днів тому

      @@dovetonsturdee7033 Yes...but it wasn't a cunning one!!!

  • @johnwoods7650
    @johnwoods7650 27 днів тому +32

    I don't like Sky, but they have some mathematically literate people who are great with graphs.

  • @Afterthoughtbtw
    @Afterthoughtbtw 27 днів тому +2

    But remember that 1993 was a crisis budget? So is this.
    The Tories have been frittering away money to multinationals and desperately hoping they would get voted out so they could try to put the blame on Labour.
    The Tories plans are pointless to compare to - no-one seriously believes that had they got in, they would have actually done that. They knew they were losing, so they could promise what they wanted. Had they given a serious (and honest) manifesto economically, it would have looked dramatically different.

  • @michaelmoran2022
    @michaelmoran2022 27 днів тому +17

    IncreasingNI contributions for Business, will come back to bite employees,in the form of Less increasing wages going forward,bad move👎👎

    • @DarkCreed
      @DarkCreed 27 днів тому +2

      Or less employees who are expected to do all the job roles.

    • @lucaciesco9180
      @lucaciesco9180 27 днів тому +5

      Mate they haven't increased out wages for time unless forced anyway. Employees very rare increase wages without force

    • @aktolman
      @aktolman 27 днів тому +1

      Yes - how on earth do they expect that to play out; how is that going to encourage growth, there might be a short term gain, but then all the affects will be negative. They don't know what they are doing.

    • @trepidstation
      @trepidstation 27 днів тому +1

      They don't raise wages anyway!!

    • @stephenjon3502
      @stephenjon3502 27 днів тому

      Maybe some people shouldn’t be in business to begin with if they can’t pay their employees a decent wage….

  • @SuperJammygit
    @SuperJammygit 27 днів тому +35

    Didn’t effect the migrants in any way what so ever

    • @blazzz13
      @blazzz13 27 днів тому

      DEFORM types obsessed with migrants- what the feck does this have to do with that?

    • @DarkCreed
      @DarkCreed 27 днів тому

      Free workforce 🎉

    • @seanclarke8015
      @seanclarke8015 27 днів тому +11

      How do the cavemen always shoehorn migration into every topic. If only they applied that determination into improving communities. 😂

    • @DA-cf3js
      @DA-cf3js 27 днів тому +1

      Staying in free accommodation is a job now 😂

    • @Dongfloppy
      @Dongfloppy 27 днів тому

      Probably the most knobby comment thus far

  • @robw2486
    @robw2486 27 днів тому +11

    Taxing the super-rich will also mean they will just up sticks and leave the country. Why not stop illegal immigration, and all the spend that goes with it? Seriously.

    • @NSW-ye3xw
      @NSW-ye3xw 27 днів тому +7

      Sounds too much like common sense to me.

    • @Leprechaunmonkey101
      @Leprechaunmonkey101 26 днів тому

      Their assets won’t leave they’re not magicians

  • @stephen6262
    @stephen6262 27 днів тому +4

    Let the banks build cheap houses And rent them out to everyone

    • @fishing-gardening-travelling
      @fishing-gardening-travelling 26 днів тому

      Banks are only in it for the money. If it wasn't for the law, the banks would charge 75% interest on late and missed payments. Loan sharks 🦈

  • @Angel-xq9yz
    @Angel-xq9yz 27 днів тому +26

    i breath out CO2 ,
    the next green tax

  • @user-ps3qk3xl2d
    @user-ps3qk3xl2d 27 днів тому +14

    The road to serfdom.

  • @elrevesyelderecho
    @elrevesyelderecho 27 днів тому +18

    4:08 In short, say hello to the Four Horses of the Apocalypse: fiscal deficit, money printing, devaluation and inflation.

    • @MrSatnavatron
      @MrSatnavatron 27 днів тому +1

      not really any other option after 14 years of sell offs

  • @sextonblake4258
    @sextonblake4258 27 днів тому

    Besides promising NOT to raise taxes, the increase for the NHS was conditional on reform.
    This has been dropped and the media has simply not noticed.

  • @dancoy09
    @dancoy09 27 днів тому +24

    Tax them rich! Love it and look at the Russian bots here trying to downplay everything

    • @leonmorris7862
      @leonmorris7862 27 днів тому +2

      Yeah instead they're just taxing small businesses

    • @dancoy09
      @dancoy09 27 днів тому +7

      @@leonmorris7862 make sure to really look at the budget. Research pls!

  • @stephanosuk78
    @stephanosuk78 27 днів тому +31

    Growth in 2026 was Never going to be 2.2% a 10 year old could see that.

    • @spacetime3
      @spacetime3 27 днів тому

      Indeed fiddled number orginally by the tories ofc

    • @stephanosuk78
      @stephanosuk78 27 днів тому

      @spacetime3 So.

  • @pd1648
    @pd1648 27 днів тому +2

    WEF - tax and control the people - Starmer loves WEF over The Commons - wake up - we are the people this affects

  • @MusiCoolPiyush
    @MusiCoolPiyush 27 днів тому +5

    It's funny how no one ever mentions Brexit anymore.. Look at how bad the UK economy was in the 70s before UK joined EU.. and now we are back to the same economy levels of 70s.. every other country moves forward in time.. we somehow went back 🤔🤔

  • @Philip5478
    @Philip5478 27 днів тому +16

    "Just look at how much higher that line is and that may not look like an enormous difference between those two lines, but believe me it is". Proceeds to look at line and its 1% More at most. Sick of main stream media, nothing but click bait and propaganda peddling.

    • @oipoip3
      @oipoip3 27 днів тому +6

      1% of a nations GDP is a lot of money 😂

    • @ENRICHEDK
      @ENRICHEDK 27 днів тому +1

      @@oipoip3exactly, some ppl really need to study a financial course 🤣

    • @glassshatters4337
      @glassshatters4337 27 днів тому

      bro doesnt know what GDP is

  • @MakeWhatYouCan
    @MakeWhatYouCan 27 днів тому +6

    Sure this will be unpopular, but it has to be done.

  • @matthewmarsh9760
    @matthewmarsh9760 27 днів тому +3

    Eliminate ILLEGAl entry to this country might save a couple of quid

  • @r1pperuk
    @r1pperuk 27 днів тому +1

    Ultimately Ai and US corporates are going to decimate UK economy over the next 10 years. So not sure any of this will help.

  • @Supergeologist
    @Supergeologist 27 днів тому +1

    Same old Labour, eventually they will run out of other peoples money!

  • @davebellamy4867
    @davebellamy4867 26 днів тому +1

    2:25 The words public sector and investment don't really compute!😂😅

  • @heatherlinnette189
    @heatherlinnette189 27 днів тому +1

    With regard to secondary Class 1, Class 1A or Class 1B National Insurance contributions, the amounts paid are part of the employment-remuneration costs for the employer that are deductible as an expense in computing the taxable profits or losses of the employer's trade, profession or vocation. So in other words, the national insurance contributions that an employer pays its tax deductible,as it is classed as a business expense! so when a business works out the profit for a tax bill, they look at business expenditures, which can be deducted from the tax bill. Guess what national insurance contributions falls into this category for a business.

  • @RenoReborn
    @RenoReborn 26 днів тому

    London's about to get a whole lot richer and the rest of us are about to get a whole lot poorer, gunna be some fun times ahead.

  • @danguee1
    @danguee1 27 днів тому +5

    Unintended consequences: more borrowing for DEI social programmes = lower future growth (including lower efficiencies) --> lower future tax receipts --> more borrowing. Rinse. Repeat....

  • @randomcomputer7248
    @randomcomputer7248 27 днів тому +6

    OH look, when Thatcher was in power the burden was at record lows

    • @blazzz13
      @blazzz13 27 днів тому +9

      Maybe it was all the money from flogging our public services and council homes?

    • @Coolagreen16
      @Coolagreen16 27 днів тому

      And opportunities for young people leaving school was non existent. Typical Tory comment.

    • @nurby1824
      @nurby1824 26 днів тому +1

      It would be she sold everything off and tried to implement the poll tax after screwing eveybody over and we all know how that ended for her.

    • @randomcomputer7248
      @randomcomputer7248 26 днів тому

      @@nurby1824 Everyone I know who bought a council house are very pleased and it changed their lives.
      Fair comment to say that they should have built more to replace.
      No leader is perfect its mostly far from it, Pole was unfair and her greatest screw up.
      How ever, we could do with her now rather than the elite spineless cretins both sides of the spectrum now have.

  • @Ruhiit
    @Ruhiit 26 днів тому

    Good. The big companies need to pay up more 🎉

  • @RonaldShea5680
    @RonaldShea5680 27 днів тому +16

    Problem, a dangerously indebted country, the Labour party's answer, more grossly irresponsible borrowing. The future is bleak indeed.

  • @leonardireland7362
    @leonardireland7362 26 днів тому

    They said it's a budget not to spook the markets, so why has the Euro gone down

  • @lacdirk
    @lacdirk 27 днів тому

    A more material criticism of the tax burden is that from the 40s to the late 70s, marginal tax rates were 90% or near that. It made no sense for investors to take money out of their companies, they just reinvested profits into them so the businesses would expand. Achieving the same tax burden while the top 1% pays relatively nothing is obscene.

    • @SillySatire
      @SillySatire 27 днів тому

      I think not. The top 1% pays 30% of all income tax.

    • @lacdirk
      @lacdirk 27 днів тому

      @@SillySatire Right, and now ask yourself what percentage of the income they get.
      The reason they pay more than they used to in recent times is that their share of income has increased disproportionately.
      Even getting them to pay the same average rate as the people working for them will require far more drastic measures, to include the other sources of income they have (i.e. other than working).

  • @adriancurtin6012
    @adriancurtin6012 27 днів тому +1

    A lot of extra the taxation is for long term public capital projects.

  • @sonyse2t5
    @sonyse2t5 27 днів тому +1

    UK is toast😂

  • @tlaw192
    @tlaw192 24 дні тому

    All this government does is increase tax tax and tax, regulate regulate and regulate. So un-innovative!!

  • @TheIrishny
    @TheIrishny 27 днів тому +6

    We need to keep learning the same thing over and over.
    Increases taxes and increasing spending leads to disaster...always.

  • @phildobson8705
    @phildobson8705 26 днів тому

    Next: taxes inevitably put up inflation. Interest rates up, people losing homes. More NHS £managers doesn't make me happy.

  • @Supposedlyimrightwingnow
    @Supposedlyimrightwingnow 26 днів тому

    That government borrowing chart is scary... Reform will have a right mess to clear up come 2029.

  • @williamgoss4691
    @williamgoss4691 25 днів тому

    Great charts, thks.

  • @trashman1358
    @trashman1358 25 днів тому

    Out of the frying pan, straight into the fire.

  • @BigBazz-Clips
    @BigBazz-Clips 27 днів тому +5

    increase taxes on working people to put more economic migrants up in social housing

  • @detroitmachine1731
    @detroitmachine1731 27 днів тому +10

    How about they stop funding the war in Ukraine and give to people in need in the UK that are starving

  • @jamescooper8856
    @jamescooper8856 27 днів тому +3

    We are going to be poor under Labour than under the previous government. I’m a Labour voter I can’t believe I said that.

  • @wow-um3xf
    @wow-um3xf 27 днів тому +1

    I think the main question is how does this affect the price of Freddos 😂 thats a real deal breaker

  • @palermothegoalgod-wd2wp
    @palermothegoalgod-wd2wp 26 днів тому

    15 billion a year in foreign aid, charity begins at home.....

  • @ridleyclayburn4599
    @ridleyclayburn4599 27 днів тому +24

    We've got £3 trillion debt and they want to borrow more?

    • @Peter-xx6tz
      @Peter-xx6tz 27 днів тому +14

      @@ANH-1977or we could temporarily reduce the absurd expenses that weve been engaging in like giving billions in foreign aid or tens of billions in carbon capture and green energy plans

    • @ridleyclayburn4599
      @ridleyclayburn4599 27 днів тому +1

      @ANH-1977 who are they? Can someone define?

    • @Peter-xx6tz
      @Peter-xx6tz 27 днів тому +4

      @@ANH-1977 then we enforce border control to stop illegal immigration and increase the requirements for for legal immigration to slow that aswell. There was a time when we were only taking in 40 thousand people a year, we can go back to that if we wanted to

    • @XLBlades
      @XLBlades 27 днів тому

      @@Peter-xx6tz Who's going to tell him that brexit happened!

    • @Kalendrian
      @Kalendrian 27 днів тому

      3 trillion debt caused by corrupt tory mismanagement

  • @FormulaOneFix
    @FormulaOneFix 27 днів тому

    UK ready to bring back the Window Tax 🤦‍♂️

  • @eileenhackett1760
    @eileenhackett1760 27 днів тому +1

    I'm sure that i will survive the tax exemptions on private schools and private jets

  • @panmichael5271
    @panmichael5271 27 днів тому

    This is an EU style budget and sets the UK firmly back in the EU mould.

  • @phildobson8705
    @phildobson8705 26 днів тому

    Is this budget some kind of revenge attack against people who have physical components to their job?

  • @roberthunt8113
    @roberthunt8113 27 днів тому +3

    the 3bn given to the ukraine could be used to pay the heating for the pensioners wot a crap budget

  • @darren2564
    @darren2564 27 днів тому +3

    This is just a recirculation of our money budget. She is spending more of our money by taxing us more rather than a budget to create and grow money.

    • @samreid2041
      @samreid2041 25 днів тому

      This budget is intending to bring in money, but in the long term. By investing in public services (via increased taxation) it creates jobs and encourages investment from both in and out of the UK, helping the economy. There is no budget which could have simply grown money and solved the issues we are experiencing in the UK without any suffering, there is no easy fix!

  • @danielkisero2104
    @danielkisero2104 27 днів тому +7

    More debt longer inflation

  • @Mike_5
    @Mike_5 26 днів тому

    Are we any nearer to a proper definition of a Working Person from Labour after this?

  • @wagie95
    @wagie95 27 днів тому

    Raising taxes for those who CAN easily pay higher taxes.

  • @Laura-s3x6k
    @Laura-s3x6k 27 днів тому +8

    Should rename the Labour Party the Pinnochio Party.

    • @4adiarmuid
      @4adiarmuid 27 днів тому

      pinnochio is hunts avatar

    • @ZPheenix
      @ZPheenix 27 днів тому

      They didn't lie about anything though

  • @anonymoushuman8962
    @anonymoushuman8962 27 днів тому +5

    And what do we get for this?
    MORE UNION POWER. MORE STATE CONTROL. LESS WEALTH IN OUR POCKETS. LESS INDIVIDUAL FREEDOMS. LESS INVESTMENT. LESS ENTREPRENEURS INVESTING. LESS FOREIGN INVESTMENT.
    This woman is terrible for the uk. Time to protect our wealth.

    • @TimoDyer
      @TimoDyer 27 днів тому

      Boris Johnson and Liz Truss added 1 trillion to the debt. Hunt left a 22bn black hole. What a car wreck to work with.

  • @damianbutterworth2434
    @damianbutterworth2434 27 днів тому

    We never had a 3 trillion debt back in 1993. Things are not going to get better under Labour or Tories.

  • @wkwnsnwk
    @wkwnsnwk 27 днів тому +6

    Who is paying this tax burden is most important. Great budget.

    • @k0bb
      @k0bb 27 днів тому +1

      but this will lower wages and negatively impact the employment rate - both terrible for growth which is ultimately our best way out this hole

  • @olekfornal4036
    @olekfornal4036 26 днів тому

    And this is only the first budget

  • @At_the_races
    @At_the_races 26 днів тому

    For “public investment” read giving the public sector, IE the unions that fund labour, more money for doing even less.

  • @lestrem11
    @lestrem11 27 днів тому

    How does raising taxes encourage growth?

  • @davespeedy5365
    @davespeedy5365 27 днів тому

    Supporting the young and poor, and taxing the rich is really bad, say the rich

  • @petertaylor1447
    @petertaylor1447 27 днів тому

    I get the impression that the Government plans to borrow more - so higher interest repayments, tax businesses more - so they have lower profits for investment in new plant, kit, equipment, systems and spend more on day to day operating costs.
    No wonder the OBR says this budget will boost short term rather than long term growth.
    The presenter needed a chart of international growth comparisons. We are amongst lowest growing economies post Covid. Brexit effect?

  • @kaseycornflakes1234
    @kaseycornflakes1234 26 днів тому

    Starmer has `hit the ground stumbling`

  • @scottguitars1961
    @scottguitars1961 27 днів тому

    We have low productivity, skills shortages, low unemployment, £3tn national debt.
    Tax has to be raised. Where it comes from (and where it’s spent) is the issue.
    Just saying that tax overall will increase, with no nuance or context, is just propaganda.The question is, will it hit the most or least able to carry the burden.

    • @mariyaatanasova1556
      @mariyaatanasova1556 26 днів тому

      It will. No small business will absorb the tax bill. The prices for consumers customers will go up.

  • @thomashobbs1498
    @thomashobbs1498 27 днів тому

    But the taxes are raised only for businesses and very wealthy selling assets

  • @Side_Eye_Shibe
    @Side_Eye_Shibe 27 днів тому

    So... 3bn a year for Ukraine but 1.5bn for NHS beds, hubs and scanners... 🤔

  • @craphead9842
    @craphead9842 27 днів тому +1

    Fish and chips was less than 2 bob in 1940s compare that to today of a tenner.... Tony cuenca

  • @johncordey2769
    @johncordey2769 25 днів тому

    They need to take on more tax because we are expecting 315,000 migrants to arrive every year for the next five years.. that’s a lot of hotels .. but remember none of them will be paying taxes.. just us mugs.

  • @dorintudose8682
    @dorintudose8682 27 днів тому

    Putting a negative spell of course, the things will look terrible
    But actually, I think that a budget for the future and will help a lot in long-term

  • @NickGodwin
    @NickGodwin 27 днів тому +19

    Simplest way to boost Growth= get into Single Market

    • @r1pperuk
      @r1pperuk 27 днів тому +2

      DOH 😂

    • @Swan67-zw9jo
      @Swan67-zw9jo 27 днів тому +3

      Yep the world's largest trading unit which is just 20 miles from our shores

    • @outcastp23
      @outcastp23 27 днів тому +1

      Imagine giving up freely trading with the biggest market in the world (over 500 million) that's on our doorstep so that we could get a trade deal with a country on the other side of the world, market size 1/20 of the EU and who push lower standard of agricultural products into our supermarkets.

    • @stephenholmes1036
      @stephenholmes1036 27 днів тому

      ​then eat British and we barely use supermarkets

  • @snufkinmatt162
    @snufkinmatt162 27 днів тому

    They are comparing the growth forecast for the Tories which the OBR has now said was wrong due to being mislead. That's a bit dishonest.

  • @RonaldShea5680
    @RonaldShea5680 27 днів тому +6

    Sterling crisis on the immediate horizon.

    • @adiintel1
      @adiintel1 27 днів тому

      They can always debase the currency 🙃

    • @Claire-dg3gh
      @Claire-dg3gh 27 днів тому

      Great news for our EU membership application.

  • @chesney2008
    @chesney2008 26 днів тому

    REFORM UK WILL SORT THIS MESS OUT WHEN THEY GET IN 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧

    • @1-0-v6d
      @1-0-v6d 26 днів тому

      the uk will be too broken to fix by then, wake up the uk is finished.

  • @J_Bone1888
    @J_Bone1888 27 днів тому +21

    As much as I despise Starmer, this is actually a great budget.

    • @dareilori6413
      @dareilori6413 27 днів тому +12

      More taxes and debt a good budget? For every taxes collected, that is money taken away from consumers. The inflation is also forecast to be higher, which means mortgage rates would be higher for longer.

    • @andrewwaller5913
      @andrewwaller5913 27 днів тому +5

      Deluded nonsense

    • @J_Bone1888
      @J_Bone1888 27 днів тому +5

      @@andrewwaller5913 let's just allow public services to crumble then. A police force, NHS and care system not fit for purpose. Or tax companies more (still less than any other G7 country) and put the money in the right places as we have had 14 years of the complete opposite which has put us in this mess

    • @drewpainter1384
      @drewpainter1384 27 днів тому

      ​@@dareilori6413 I'm no labour fan but they won't want to borrow large amounts of money if inflation is up. This will mean having to pay back more due to higher interest rates.This looks to me like they are thinking interest rates are going to be coming down in the future hence the borrowing

    • @AM2K2
      @AM2K2 27 днів тому +1

      Higher taxes, higher debt, higher inflation AND stagnant growth (as per the OBR)?!

  • @adamfull3181
    @adamfull3181 27 днів тому +15

    Get labour out ffs

    • @britcan4067
      @britcan4067 27 днів тому +2

      1000000%

    • @TurtlesandStuff.
      @TurtlesandStuff. 27 днів тому +5

      Why? It's a great budget and is going to actually move the country forwards after 14 years of Tory stagnation. Just look at the markets reaction to the budget.

    • @britcan4067
      @britcan4067 27 днів тому +1

      @@TurtlesandStuff. ask the small businesses owners!

    • @NickGodwin
      @NickGodwin 27 днів тому

      ​@@britcan4067 I heard a spokesperson for small business on channel 4 give it a positive view. 14 years of Tory corruption (VIP lanes, lying to the Queen, lying to the country). I guess some people might be bitter at having missed out on the free money.

    • @Whizzy-jx3qe
      @Whizzy-jx3qe 27 днів тому +1

      @@britcan4067Brexit.

  • @flippineck2825
    @flippineck2825 27 днів тому

    The rich people are all freaking out! GOOD! Signs that it was a great budget.

  • @thebamfordman
    @thebamfordman 27 днів тому

    This is all Sunak's fault for making himself unelectable with his mad grinning and even madder policies.

  • @angrypidgeon1714
    @angrypidgeon1714 27 днів тому

    a bit harsh these taxes m'lord

  • @heatherlinnette189
    @heatherlinnette189 27 днів тому

    look at what the Conservative party have done to the NHS ! How they’ve been trying to dismantle it and underfund it, so it’s not fit for purpose. I personally would rather pay higher taxes and have an NHS that works. What did the Conservative party do? They would use the national insurance what is the national insurance for? It’s for the NHS. Most people would agree that they would prefer to pay slightly more national insurance and have a fully working NHS then losing it. Austerity has been proven to be a false economy. It literally had a mistake on a spreadsheet that said it would work when, in fact, when the figures were done correctly said it was detrimental to an economy ! which has been proven.

  • @KevinTalbotTV
    @KevinTalbotTV 27 днів тому

    glad i left uk, tax is out of control

  • @stephenball-qo7ug
    @stephenball-qo7ug 27 днів тому +5

    A weaker economy is called a recession.

    • @jjefferyworboys8138
      @jjefferyworboys8138 27 днів тому +11

      It's not. A recession is 2 consecutive quarters of negative growth. Positive growth however small is still growth.

  • @benjifox6354
    @benjifox6354 27 днів тому +3

    So everyone who said tax the rich, well who’s the rich that even living in the uk, since the election an estimated 15,000 millionaires have already gone but I guarantee the rest will go now

  • @paulrichardson8914
    @paulrichardson8914 27 днів тому

    A great budget for us working people.