Just realised the Matthew Rowell thumnbail error - that is hilarious - apologies folks this has now been fixed. This is what happens when you film & edit 2018 and 2019 back to back.
As a Carlton fan there is no chance we don’t take anyone other than sam Walsh, he’s finished top three in the Brownlow, is tenth in the last three years in total Brownlow votes, despite having a few injuries, butters is great don’t get me wrong but Walsh has more tickets in the bank in the terms of the previous years performances, and based on finals the man is a different animal in the spot light, he’s honestly my tip for the Brownlow is he’s injury free and has a full preseason for the first time since 2021
You accidentally put Matt Rowell in the thumbnail for this video. You had him drafted by Freo in the 2019 redraft video and you edited him with the Freo jersey but you accidentally put him on the thumbnail for the wrong video
Bailey Smith has performed in a finals series. He’s had a poor season but he’s shown what he can be and if he returns to that form he’s better than all bar 2 in this draft.
Loving the content. This one seems to have sparked the comments. I don't like to criticise the decisions made in this series. It is all very subjective and take a lot of effort. You could put that top 7-8 in 100 different combinations and you could make an argument for it to be that way. Easy enough to flip a coin with Walsh and Butters.
Perhaps recency bias but Idun has to be there after his finals series. He was epic in the prelim and although his stats aren't big, he's one of the best 1v1 defenders in the comp. Good video nonetheless.
Again, your order is close to mine. A clear top 12, then a fairly even following 12. Even purely on all round talent I would have Thomas at 12 rather than 10, and would have Sparrow higher, just after Briggs or maybe Scott.
Haha. As far as suspicious comments go, Blakey is a "treasure to watch" has just moved into second place behind Bruce's description of Cyril Rioli as "delicious"
Dude seriously, I got to your selection at pick one and then turned the video off, Walsh is so far the best pick in that year that it's not funny. The fact you picked Butters make's me question why I subscribed to your channel 😂
Using your 20 players, 1-Zak Butters 2-Sam Walsh 3-Connor Rozee 4-Max King 5-Ben King 6-Izak Rankine 7-Nic Blakey 8-Lachie Shultz 9-Isaac Quaynor 10-Jack Lukosius 11-Bobby Hill 12-Bailey Smith 13-Tom Atkinson 14-Jye Caldwell 15-Tom Sparrow 16-Kieran Briggs 17-Tarry Thomas 18-James Rowbottom 19-Bailey Scott 20-Jordan Clark
Just realised the Matthew Rowell thumnbail error - that is hilarious - apologies folks this has now been fixed. This is what happens when you film & edit 2018 and 2019 back to back.
Haha I didn't watch it because I thought I already had! Glad I came back!
I can see all the Saint's supporters yelling out Callum Wilkie's name at the screen.
technically he was rookie draft
Quaynor could be abit higher since making the 44 man all Australian this year
Zac Butters Connor Rozee and JHF are going to cause problems for alot of teams in the next 6-8 years,3 high quality players
Chayce Jones?! Bare minimum should be 15-20 range
Also if mature age players are included then Callum Wilkie!?
Rowbottom has come top 3 in the swans B+F 2 years running including a GF year.
Bailey Scott was a father son selection at North
Rozee is the only dual All Australian from the draft so far
Pretty great draft pool for 2018
Love that opu gave curtis taylor a shout, he was a huge slider on the night
As a Carlton fan there is no chance we don’t take anyone other than sam Walsh, he’s finished top three in the Brownlow, is tenth in the last three years in total Brownlow votes, despite having a few injuries, butters is great don’t get me wrong but Walsh has more tickets in the bank in the terms of the previous years performances, and based on finals the man is a different animal in the spot light, he’s honestly my tip for the Brownlow is he’s injury free and has a full preseason for the first time since 2021
Rowell on the thumbnail lol
Callum Wilkie should be here
You accidentally put Matt Rowell in the thumbnail for this video. You had him drafted by Freo in the 2019 redraft video and you edited him with the Freo jersey but you accidentally put him on the thumbnail for the wrong video
I commented that
didnt ask@@VCS7083
No cal Wilkie? Bit harsh he’s a jet pick 3 in the rookie draft
Would probably put him in the first draft he was eligible for with these revived draft hypotheticals.
Idun established himself as one of the best defenders in the league this year, surely he makes the cut
Bailey Smith has performed in a finals series. He’s had a poor season but he’s shown what he can be and if he returns to that form he’s better than all bar 2 in this draft.
Bailey Scott was a father son selection
Loving the content. This one seems to have sparked the comments. I don't like to criticise the decisions made in this series. It is all very subjective and take a lot of effort. You could put that top 7-8 in 100 different combinations and you could make an argument for it to be that way. Easy enough to flip a coin with Walsh and Butters.
you gotta find a new catch phrase; 'eye test' was a little over used mate. but solid draft
Wilkie doesn't make the list?
Chase Jones is better then Scott,sparrow and Clark and I'd rather him over lukocios
Connor Idun top 10
Perhaps recency bias but Idun has to be there after his finals series. He was epic in the prelim and although his stats aren't big, he's one of the best 1v1 defenders in the comp. Good video nonetheless.
Tarryn thomas was rated the 6th best player in the comp since he came back
Why is Rowell in the Thumbnail?
quaynor that low, thats wild personally. is it too biased to put him above lukosious
currently they are pretty close but I reckon lukosious has a lot of potential
Again, your order is close to mine. A clear top 12, then a fairly even following 12. Even purely on all round talent I would have Thomas at 12 rather than 10, and would have Sparrow higher, just after Briggs or maybe Scott.
What an insane draft
Haha. As far as suspicious comments go, Blakey is a "treasure to watch" has just moved into second place behind Bruce's description of Cyril Rioli as "delicious"
Hahaha after I said it I was like 'why did I say that...Ive never said that before"
Walsh in 2021 is better than any other player from this draft and it isn’t even close
Fax, wait your pfp is Walsh. That’s a bit biased
@@VCS7083 a bit biased bc I love him but you did say ‘fax’ sooooo…..
Rozee and butters are soooooo clear of Walsh
butters won the coaches mvp this seaosn, a better season than walsh 2021 by far
@@lukereschke8273 they had better years this year obviously. Walsh missed two months of footy. But over their careers, Walsh is clear
Surely do a 2001 redraft
Isaac Quaynor was an NGA before they changed the rules so Collingwood’s got him anyway
Next video idea best player from each Number picked in the draft. Do a top 20, then do some honourable mentions as I know earlier it was a bit silly!
You picked Bobby Hill at 11, Isaac Quaynor at 12 and Lachie Schultz at 13. All now Pies players. 👍👍
Butters is the closest thing to Gary Ablett Jnr I've seen
The King birthday joke got me 😆
lol why is Rowell in the thumbnail
Putting butters ahead of Walsh is a travisty
Ben king is better then Max King
Dude seriously, I got to your selection at pick one and then turned the video off, Walsh is so far the best pick in that year that it's not funny. The fact you picked Butters make's me question why I subscribed to your channel 😂
Using your 20 players,
1-Zak Butters
2-Sam Walsh
3-Connor Rozee
4-Max King
5-Ben King
6-Izak Rankine
7-Nic Blakey
8-Lachie Shultz
9-Isaac Quaynor
10-Jack Lukosius
11-Bobby Hill
12-Bailey Smith
13-Tom Atkinson
14-Jye Caldwell
15-Tom Sparrow
16-Kieran Briggs
17-Tarry Thomas
18-James Rowbottom
19-Bailey Scott
20-Jordan Clark