FALKLANDS CONFLICT - Falkland islanders

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 гру 2009

КОМЕНТАРІ • 646

  • @phil-zz5hk
    @phil-zz5hk 4 роки тому +105

    STILL HAVE GHOSTS IN MY HEAD TODAY . WAR ISNT GREAT , BUT WE HAD TO DEFEND OUR SOVEREIGNTY . RIP THE BOYS FROM 1ST BATTALION WELSH GUARDS . CYMRU AM BYTH

    • @PhreddCrintt
      @PhreddCrintt 4 роки тому +6

      So with you Phil. I won't go into details.

    • @phil-zz5hk
      @phil-zz5hk 4 роки тому +2

      @@PhreddCrintt thank you mike

    • @66kbm
      @66kbm 4 роки тому +3

      Worked with 2 Coy 1 WG in West Belfast 86, great guys.

    • @Sk4M_.RangeroftheNorth
      @Sk4M_.RangeroftheNorth 3 роки тому +6

      Yeah my Dad says he remembers it like yesterday. He was on HMS Liverpool. Nothing but love and respect for all you did for us. Thank you so much.💯👊🏼💯💙

    • @phil-zz5hk
      @phil-zz5hk 3 роки тому +3

      @@Sk4M_.RangeroftheNorth the liverpool . she was built in my home town . birkenhead .

  • @iwfgb
    @iwfgb 2 роки тому +23

    "I'm not walking out... I'm not surrendering to the bloody Argies, certainly not!" LOVE IT!

  • @Anglo_Saxon1
    @Anglo_Saxon1 3 роки тому +5

    Sandy Woodward"if my job is to have to start blowing heads off,I'll do it in the most efficient way I can" . Straight to the point Sir.

  • @Teasehirt
    @Teasehirt 4 роки тому +10

    I was fifteen still at School, used to watch the News Reports whilst my parents slept, soooo PROUD of These GUYS.

  • @katotomasi6404
    @katotomasi6404 3 роки тому +10

    As ugandan,a ship named Uganda, participated in the British naval fleet.

  • @iceshakle
    @iceshakle 4 роки тому +12

    Nothing say's understatement like the British.

  • @RogueRM
    @RogueRM 12 років тому +39

    Never seen this before, and was amazed to see Cpl Bob and L/Cpl Rogue_RM at 26:12 to 26:23.
    I've been famous for 30 years and didn't know it!

    • @alphadeltabravo4373
      @alphadeltabravo4373 2 роки тому +2

      It must be amazing to come across some little known documentary on the war you fought in as a young kid, and then to be lucky enough to actually be shown in it... That's awesome. That's amazing. Thank you for your service. I'm not even English, but I will always have respect for those who have earned it. Thank you to you and your family for your service and sacrifices. Best wishes

    • @nigelpilgrim4232
      @nigelpilgrim4232 11 місяців тому

      A lot of this was on the British national news on TV at the time of the Falklands islands conflict

  • @joebenevides
    @joebenevides 13 років тому +26

    Thanks for uploading all these Falklands conflict videos! I was glued to the TV in America at the time, but had to leave on holiday to Hawaii in early June, so I missed the final battle scenes and liberation.
    I was lucky enough to visit the Falklands in January 2007. The woman who answered the phone when she was a little girl when UK forces called Fitzroy to ask if Argie troops were around, served us lunch in the Stanley cafe she now owns.

  • @Moredread25
    @Moredread25 2 роки тому +4

    Great collection of footage.

  • @cycleSCUBA
    @cycleSCUBA 3 роки тому +7

    God rest the souls of the 3 Falkland British Citizens who died in the conflict.

    • @grupoaereo9
      @grupoaereo9 3 роки тому +2

      were killed by british...

    • @loyalist5736
      @loyalist5736 2 роки тому +4

      @@grupoaereo9 We're killed by Argentina starting this war .

  • @juanmcamargo2007
    @juanmcamargo2007 2 роки тому +20

    As an Argentine citizen, i'm very sad about this conflict.
    That war never should have happened

    • @mikel7981
      @mikel7981 2 роки тому +10

      It was the stupidest war of the late 20th century and yet also the most righteous war carried out by a Western power at the same time. For Argentina, it was nothing but a propaganda stunt carried out by an unpopular government, for worthless Islands with no strategic or cultural interest, against a small peaceful population who were neither composed of their countrymen, nor did they want to be. Even some of the Argie soldiers interviewed, quickly gathered this fact. They realized they had becomes the aggressors and put their life on the line based on a lie to invade a place where they didn't even feel at home.
      It would have been easy for the British to simply write off these worthless little islands and it's people, but they didn't much to their credit. The only righteous use of military force is in defense of ones people and their homes or a friendly ally.

    • @juanmcamargo2007
      @juanmcamargo2007 2 роки тому +4

      @@mikel7981 In 1982 i was 4 years old, so i didn't know nothing about politics.
      After so many years and hearing the three sides of the conflict (Argentines, British and islanders), i'm convinced that the war was the worst idea.
      The Argentine government should have obeyed the UN Resolution at that moment.

    • @aammerahmed3866
      @aammerahmed3866 2 роки тому +1

      @@juanmcamargo2007 What if the Junta took on ISIS? Thank you and look forward to your reply. Aammer.

    • @Muck006
      @Muck006 2 роки тому +6

      @@juanmcamargo2007 There are only two sides ... because the islanders are BRITISH ... and it is sad that "you lot" havent yet "given up on those islands" (as Top Gear showed).
      Should I - as a german - ask for war against Poland, because they hold territories that were once ours?
      GET OVER IT ...

    • @nigelsheppard625
      @nigelsheppard625 Рік тому +2

      @@Muck006 Well said Sir

  • @jamesgordge
    @jamesgordge 10 років тому +76

    the islanders have the right to self determination and they chose to be British

    • @emmanuelzepernick7209
      @emmanuelzepernick7209 5 років тому +11

      Jmes Gordge: Those islands are British..Never been Argentinians. All they have is Vernet's story and if you read my comments I described already who was Luis Vernet.. He was hired by the British Consulate to administer the islands that's all. When Great Britain returned from the war they rescinded Vernet's contract and when he refused to leave the islands he was then kicked out. But Great Britain always have the legal right of possession of those islands.. Something Argentina don't .. So, do not pay any mind to what they say.. They are never going to be able to get those islands. Great Britain needs to establish it's sovereign to those islands once and for all with the UN ..

    • @marianlopez457
      @marianlopez457 3 роки тому +2

      The pirates havent got right self determination.MALVINAS ARGENTINAS 🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷

    • @tylerbrennon4023
      @tylerbrennon4023 3 роки тому +10

      @@marianlopez457 They've lived there for centuries. Nice try.

    • @votefrmtherooftops3123
      @votefrmtherooftops3123 3 роки тому +3

      Argentina got what it deserved. Made they should have been taking over completely but I applaud the outcome

    • @marcosalva5946
      @marcosalva5946 3 роки тому +3

      Usurpar no te da derecho de decidir sobre soberania mas si estas a 14 mil km y el territorio en cuestion no esta dentro de tu plataforma continental .

  • @locknathsingh8886
    @locknathsingh8886 4 роки тому +6

    Watching from Queens 👸 NY. This is a magnificent video. Love ❤️ it. Wish it had a Part 2. Thank you 🙏 for uploading. Appreciate it. I’ve subscribe.

  • @richlisola1
    @richlisola1 3 роки тому +22

    It’s a rare chance, the chance to declare your nationality. To choose your identity-Notwithstanding the peril the Falklanders found themselves in. The Argentine threat allotted them the chance to call out their nationality to the world. To fight for their freedom and raise the Union Jack 🇬🇧 as their flag.
    In that, the Falkland Islanders were blessed. 🇫🇰

  • @doorman437
    @doorman437 3 роки тому +9

    41 Argentinians disliked this video

    • @stanmarsh4468
      @stanmarsh4468 3 роки тому +3

      I'M ARGENTINIAN. And I liked It😊😍

  • @Zooumberg
    @Zooumberg 5 років тому +3

    Great video compilation Steve.

  • @jollywyrm5684
    @jollywyrm5684 3 роки тому +8

    very proud to all the servicemen who participated in the defence of the Falkland Islands and its people against the war mongering argies

    • @randykreager5800
      @randykreager5800 2 роки тому

      You mean the land you stole from latin America and Argentina in the first place. It was never yours for the taking.

    • @decimated550
      @decimated550 Рік тому

      @@randykreager5800 all land is for the taking, it's the history of mankind. the land you stand on sir was captured by your ancestors from another race , and they had captured that land from an older race or tribe. the british were right to take it, and indeed , the argentines were right to try and take it back.

    • @Valencetheshireman927
      @Valencetheshireman927 Рік тому

      @@randykreager5800The land never belonged to Argentina. It was British before Argentina even existed

    • @MillerVanDotTV
      @MillerVanDotTV 7 місяців тому

      @@decimated550perhaps the Indians will give brittania back to the Romans…

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому +3

    In Britain it was boiled potatoes with mashed peas. And a dried nose bugger on the pillow when we pulled back the covers. You English are a really class act.

    • @jimcrawford5039
      @jimcrawford5039 3 роки тому +4

      The word is British. England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

    • @AndrewStead-wv4po
      @AndrewStead-wv4po 8 місяців тому

      talking about 'class acts', that gravy and biscuits shite that you Americans eat, isn't really up to much!!..... 😂🤣

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    That one went over my head. Jimmy are you shadowing me like 007?

  • @poppaleggansquat3640
    @poppaleggansquat3640 2 роки тому +8

    The Junta thought Britain wouldn't fight for an island so far away. Don't they learn history? Great Britain- fighting and winning away from home for centuries, we've been playing away games for 800 years! Sad when a failing regime throws poorly trained (predominately) conscripts into a war as a distraction tactic for its citizens.

    • @javiermartinmehdi1914
      @javiermartinmehdi1914 Рік тому

      Tu lo haz dicho mi "querido" PIRATA lucha FUERA DE SU HOUSE osea LAS MALVINAS no son su HOUSE o como dice la justicia a confesion de partes reelevo de pruebas...

    • @MillerVanDotTV
      @MillerVanDotTV 7 місяців тому

      Britain gave up on pretty much all of their colonies. Falklands were different because BP thought there was oil WITHIN the islands EEZ.

    • @poppaleggansquat3640
      @poppaleggansquat3640 7 місяців тому +2

      @@MillerVanDotTV the oil was very recent so wasn't a factor at the time. The Falklands had been very important to Britain during WWII as shown by ships retiring from the River Plate battle docking there. Truth was Britain would have let it go but for the continual lobbying of its residents as the last referendum returned a vote of 99.8% wanting to stay under British control. As far as it being a colony - thats where the place has a population when you arrive to colonize but the Falklands were a British discovery so a bit different.

  • @randbarrett8706
    @randbarrett8706 4 місяці тому +1

    Those Harrier jets look like a lot of work to fly

  • @nahuel941
    @nahuel941 13 років тому +1

    @Eddieposted no matter who are also islands because deshabitadaslas still belonged to Spain
    you only saw estabn desahabiatadas but within the jurisdiction under the treaty Spanish

  • @Strompy82
    @Strompy82 14 років тому +1

    Nice upload. Thank you.

  • @chew76
    @chew76 3 роки тому +4

    57:35 is my dad looking a bit concerned

    • @JammyDodger45
      @JammyDodger45 2 роки тому

      I think he's holding in a big 💩

  • @andrescirulnick2307
    @andrescirulnick2307 4 роки тому +7

    Como me gustaría que este traducido. Es muy interesante el video.

    • @internetperiodista
      @internetperiodista Рік тому +1

      Learn to speak English. It’s a “must be” condition in the modern world whether profesional and tourism business matters

  • @MC14may
    @MC14may 4 роки тому +8

    Waterloo was won from the playing fields of Eaton.
    The Falklands was won from the hills of Brecon.

    • @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq
      @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq 2 роки тому

      But take a look at the Harriers taking off to chase the far faster Mirage fighter jets, epical as much as the Argentine pilots were brave.

  • @kevin48800
    @kevin48800 7 років тому +12

    they wasent celebrating when they knew the british was sending a task force, i loved the song dont cry for me argentina

    • @VictorLepanto
      @VictorLepanto 5 років тому +6

      @@mcriver856 Sure, fuck the king, whoever he is. You do know that QUEEN Elizabeth is the reigning monarch, right?

    • @ryangrant1449
      @ryangrant1449 3 роки тому

      Haha. The look on there faces when they realised there about to get asswhipped is priceless

  • @simonbird1973
    @simonbird1973 3 роки тому +6

    Free the Incas, Argentinians should return to motherland Germany!!

  • @kiwiadventures3773
    @kiwiadventures3773 2 роки тому +2

    Shame it didn’t mention the landing craft that was blown up by the SBS.

  • @Johnconno
    @Johnconno Рік тому +2

    'We just wanted to be left alone, we love our sheep.'

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Romney's fortune is modest by most standards. He's a successful businessman and outsourcing is a normal practice to maximize profits. Obama's job czar, Jeff Immelt CEO of GE outsourced GE jobs to Asia. GE is 2nd largest corp in US and paid zero income taxes in 2011. And when Obama wakes up in the morning the first person he sees turning over is Jeff, not Moochelle. Romney considers Russia enemy one of USA and has said so. Romney understands America's exceptionalism and has written about it

  • @paulspydar
    @paulspydar 13 років тому +1

    @OlenkaWagner Thanks for the correction , sorry for my mistake, its not often I make an error like that as i am very much into my history. Thanks again,

  • @Housey1985
    @Housey1985 2 роки тому +1

    1:32:22 what uniform and patches is that chap wearing? Almost looks USN to me…😮

    • @nigelpilgrim4232
      @nigelpilgrim4232 11 місяців тому

      There certainly no Americans in the combat role of the Falklands war !!!!

  • @splashdamage1459
    @splashdamage1459 5 років тому +2

    Great to see that Para carrying a Charlie G on board the Canberra

  • @sulasmith3352
    @sulasmith3352 2 роки тому

    55:46 / that tattoo looks better than the daggy one I got about 15 years ago?!? 😮

  • @VictorLepanto
    @VictorLepanto 5 років тому +7

    I don't even remember about an Argentine sub being sunk. It is strange how your mind edits memories.

    • @MillerVanDotTV
      @MillerVanDotTV 7 місяців тому

      It was “sunk” at the dock of the barbaric whaling station at south Georgia

  • @sulasmith3352
    @sulasmith3352 2 роки тому +2

    1:22:26 what’s she doing, trying to find a vein?

  • @DramaticPrairieDog
    @DramaticPrairieDog 11 років тому +6

    "I counted them all out, and I counted them ALL back"

    • @lukebell2683
      @lukebell2683 3 роки тому

      DramaticPrairieDog us British has a way about us back then

  • @fazorator
    @fazorator 12 років тому +41

    I love how the argies are super butt hurt.

  • @mgytitanic1912
    @mgytitanic1912 8 років тому +3

    What I'd really like to know is how a video on the 1982 Falklands Conflict suddenly morphed, in the comments section, to a debate on who won the Second World War. The two are not really linked except that the Graf Spee was sunk by British Cruisers off Montevideo, which isn't a great distance from those islands, in 1939.

    • @edisloud
      @edisloud 8 років тому +1

      +Justin Lee a great distance? it's over a thousand miles lol

    • @mgytitanic1912
      @mgytitanic1912 8 років тому +2

      ed loud Its 1100 miles and the closest the second world war came to those islands.

    • @edisloud
      @edisloud 8 років тому +1

      +Justin Lee yep that's about right. no idea how people ended up talking about ww2 tbh, can't be bothered going through all the trolling to find out right :)

    • @mgytitanic1912
      @mgytitanic1912 8 років тому +1

      I browsed through, something to do with some Americans claiming they won it for us (Falklands) or something

    • @mgytitanic1912
      @mgytitanic1912 7 років тому +2

      MrLaizard And how do you work that out?

  • @guillermofernandodelgado604
    @guillermofernandodelgado604 4 роки тому +3

    I didn't know that the "Atlantic Conveyor" had a sister or similar ship called the "Atlantic Causeway". This documentary has images that I had not seen in other documentaries or news

    • @66kbm
      @66kbm 4 роки тому +1

      Ditto, much footage onboard RN ships i had never seen before. Probably was not worth broadcasting at the time but was held in the archive for the future, we, in the future, are now enjoying, getting invlovled in, being sad with those images.

    • @phil-zz5hk
      @phil-zz5hk 3 роки тому +1

      Name Built In service Tonnage Owner Notes
      Atlantic Saga 1967 1967-1987 12,231 GRT SAL Broken up 1987
      Atlantic Song 1967 1967-1987 11,771 GRT OW Broken up 1987
      Atlantic Span
      Atlantic Service 1967 1967-1984
      1984-1987 11,995 GRT Transatlantic Broken up 1987
      Atlantic Star 1967 1967-1987 15,055 GRT HAL Broken up 1987
      Atlantic Causeway 1969 1969-1986 14,946 GRT Cunard Broken up 1987
      Atlantic Champagne 1969 1969-1985 15,351 GRT CGT Broken up 1985
      Atlantic Crown 1969 1969-1985 15,489 GRT HAL Broken up 1985
      Atlantic Cinderella 1970 1970-1985 15,437 GRT OW Broken up 1985
      Atlantic Cognac 1970 1970-1985 15,351 GRT CGT Broken up 1985
      Atlantic Conveyor 1970 1970-1982 14,946 GRT Cunard Sunk during Falklands War
      Atlantic Premier 1972 1978-1982 10,998 GRT SAL Ex Mont Royal. Broken up 2004
      Atlantic Prelude 1972 1978-1983 11,148 GRT OW Ex Montmorency. Broken up 2005
      Atlantic Project 1978 1978-1981 5,466 GRT Stena Chartered from Stena Line
      Atlantic Prosper 1978 1978-1981 5,466 GRT Stena Chartered from Stena Line, Sunk 2006
      Atlantic Companion 1984 1984-2015 57,225 GRT Transatlantic Sold for scrap to Alang, India Sep 2015
      Atlantic Concert 1984 1984- 2016 57,225 GRT Transocean Lengthened in Japan 1987. Scrapped in 2016
      Atlantic Compass 1984 1984- 2016 57,225 GRT OW Lengthened in Japan 1987. Scrapped in 2016
      Atlantic Cartier 1985 1985- 2017 57,225 GRT OW Lengthened in Japan 1987. Sold for scrap 2017 to Alang, India
      Atlantic Conveyor 1985 1985- 2017 57,225 GRT Cunard Lengthened at Scott Lithgow's Clyde shipyard, Glasgow Scotland 1987. Sold for scap 2017 to Alang, India

    • @phil-zz5hk
      @phil-zz5hk 3 роки тому +1

      the conveyer was rebuilt in the north east of the uk

  • @stevemcelmury4618
    @stevemcelmury4618 2 роки тому +1

    When the Belgrano was torpedoed, her two destroyer escorts FLED back to port, while h?

    • @peterwhitaker4038
      @peterwhitaker4038 2 роки тому +1

      i felt sorry for all the sailors that died on the Belgrano..but hey, World war two battle cruiser Versus Nuclear Submarine? only one outcome i'm afraid but at least it saved a lot of Argentinian and British lives because of that one action. the Argentine Navy never came out again.

  • @Suojeluninja
    @Suojeluninja 12 років тому +1

    Stuff like Mig-21:s. T-55:s, BMP-1:s, SA-2:s, SVD:s ect used to be relatively advanced during the Vietnam war.

  • @OlenkaWagner
    @OlenkaWagner 13 років тому

    @paulspydar - No problem. You are right that the "photo-session" left the UK no other option. Argentinians say that the whole thing lasted only a few seconds and was not agreed with the supreme commander, but one of the photographers managed to take photos, which were published and we all know the rest...

  • @lextalionis5539
    @lextalionis5539 4 роки тому +5

    🇬🇧🇨🇱

  • @bobdinwiddy
    @bobdinwiddy 9 років тому +4

    29:00 min :: puts a lump in your throat - not a military tattoo - but Rod's classic "I am sailing..." with families left on the quay singing "to be near you, to be free..." counting them all out and counting them all back... poor sods that pay the price for those who play high poker in order to keep the same poor sods quiet... and when the surrender came, the only wish from the vanquished was: if they could take their regimental flags back home... "honour" you see... forgive me for not understanding - I am but a poor sod...

    • @henryvagincourt
      @henryvagincourt 8 років тому +1

      +Bob Dinwiddy All goes with being part of the military my friend.

  • @R33s
    @R33s 11 років тому

    still brings smile to my face
    not he lives that was lost just what force british ppl / folk are STILL

  • @joshua6244
    @joshua6244 Рік тому +2

    They don't like it up 'em.

  • @gavingray5275
    @gavingray5275 5 років тому +4

    How many other countries could send bombers 8,000 miles to bomb a target??

  • @fivestarmichael
    @fivestarmichael 2 роки тому

    The British should have sent some warships to protect their fleet. 😄

  • @henryvagincourt
    @henryvagincourt 6 років тому +1

    Ex HMS Plymouth, great footage, some I haven't seen before.

  • @kosacoluis3737
    @kosacoluis3737 12 років тому

    That is Battle for Falklands, but is not all documentary? where is the other part?

  • @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq
    @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq 2 роки тому +2

    Argentina also improvised, as the invasion had been planned for at least one year later. But the people of Argentina rebelled on March, 1982, and then the military government decided to invade these islands as a diversion.

    • @matyk9dogtrainer
      @matyk9dogtrainer 2 роки тому

      De donde sos?

    • @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq
      @RicardoMartinez-oh9sq 2 роки тому

      @@matyk9dogtrainer Un marxista de los Setenta que tuvo que huir de Argentina para salvarse de los "fachos".

  • @electricink3908
    @electricink3908 2 роки тому +1

    Only one Argentine was killed that day not several. Corvette captain Pedro Giachino

    • @nunyabizniss7643
      @nunyabizniss7643 2 роки тому

      Officially, at least. It has been asserted by a huge number of eyewitness accounts that Argentine casualties were significantly higher than what is stated today

    • @electricink3908
      @electricink3908 2 роки тому +1

      One can safely say those claims are totally bogus. If it was true it could not stay hidden in Argentina , not like soldiers don't have any friends, family etc

    • @JammyDodger45
      @JammyDodger45 2 роки тому

      The photos of dead Argentinians lined up on the airport road disagrees with you.

  • @YARROWS9
    @YARROWS9 4 роки тому +2

    If we had our two big carriers HMS Eagle and HMS Ark Royal plus Bulwark, Hermes and Invinsible the Argies wouldn't have invaded the islands.

    • @davidbrown9093
      @davidbrown9093 3 роки тому +2

      Show weakness and have politicians run your armed forces and this is what happens, keep politicians out of military matters.

  • @transonicbuoy
    @transonicbuoy 11 років тому

    I am British and you are right.

  • @glickle
    @glickle 11 років тому +11

    I'm neither British nor Argentine but after reading the history I have to say that Britain's claims are more compelling than Argentina's. This constant claim that Britain stole the islands from Argentina makes no sense. Britain has had a presence on the islands over a hundred years before Argentina even existed as a country. And Argentina's entire claim is based on their "inheritance" from Spain when it was Spain who just took the islands from England by force. (And then returned them again.)

    • @emmanuelzepernick7209
      @emmanuelzepernick7209 5 років тому +2

      glickle: Great Britain claimed those island long before Spain.(1765 I think) They left but by the time the Argentinian were living there they were doing it with Great Britain's consent..Luis Vernet was named Administrator of the islands by the British council.. Luis Vernet was an Argentinian that wrote a letter to the British asking permission to live in the islands. ( his letter to the British council are published you can find them if you study that part of the history) Great Britain gave him the permit and permission to bring people to live in the islands.. Later on Great Britain gave him licenses for hunting and fishing and agreed that they should developed and cultivate the islands. At that time Great Britain was fighting the USA colonies. Afterwards they returned and rescinded Vernet's contract or permission. He refused to leave the islands claiming he brought people and development.. Great Britain them kicked him out. Since then they been arguing possession but they never had possession ( they do not even have a single document that could validate their claim) of those islands and they should never have. That is why I do not understand why the decolonization committee wants both country to negotiate..There is nothing to negotiate those islands are British for over 400 years and there is enough proof of it..

    • @roberteugene7295
      @roberteugene7295 5 років тому

      @@emmanuelzepernick7209
      In addition, one claim by Argentina is that they "inherited" the Spanish claim. That has no basis in any principle of international law. While Spain could have bequeathed land to Argentina during the process that made Argentina a country, Spain couldn't gift Argentina a land claim that was in dispute. That's the way an international court would see it.

    • @anibalcesarnishizk2205
      @anibalcesarnishizk2205 Рік тому

      @@roberteugene7295
      The aborigins could claim with the same logic that the whole land called Argentina belonged to them.

  • @jamjam472
    @jamjam472 4 роки тому +2

    14:24 That must be Flight Lieutenant Mortimer (801 NAS) preparing fellow pilots (including 'Sharkey' Ward, front center/left in audience, at 14:10) on board HMS Invincible

  • @MrJonezy541
    @MrJonezy541 11 років тому +3

    i lose faith in humanity when i read some of these comments...

  • @OlenkaWagner
    @OlenkaWagner 14 років тому +2

    @wingnut208 - I have noticed pabloandrescom's comments are quite similar. I think he uses an automatic translator - this construction "English of ****" is copied from an Spanish grammar construction "..... de m*****" ;) He also never goes into any serious discussions :(

  • @TrentVenture
    @TrentVenture 12 років тому

    That's ridiculous! ... being polite would be pointless.
    You can't talk to 40,412,376 peices well done rump steak

  • @D800Lover
    @D800Lover 3 роки тому +1

    Only God can end war. So if there is no God.... what then?

    • @randbarrett8706
      @randbarrett8706 3 роки тому

      Perhaps we annihilate ourselves, perhaps we unify and lose a need for practicing warfare.
      I’ve read that a reason that Europeans became particularly skilled in the profession of arms before the people of other continents was that European nation states were almost continuously fighting limited wars against each other. Supposedly, other continents were more or less unified along geographic boundaries and the people there just spent less time fighting each other than the Europeans.

    • @D800Lover
      @D800Lover 2 роки тому

      @@randbarrett8706 - Annalisation is hardly a desired solution to end war. Is God not ending it more desirable? Except we are not 'allowed' to think that, because God has been canceled - yep, cancel culture is not new.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому +1

    Jimmy, did you know I lived and grew up in Oakland? Where have you been? Under a rock? It's fun imagining you crawling out from a rock, blinking your beady eyes, and hissing at the world with drool out the corners of your mouth. Hi again Jimmy! I really, really miss you and your Vietnamese chitchat. Bet you have carbuncles like Marx? He kept complaining how he was going to get back at the world for having his carbuncles. Something must trouble you. Yes, I think carbuncles.

  • @1111hola
    @1111hola 11 років тому

    my god! how can you say this being an englishman!

  • @SeptentrionalFiniste
    @SeptentrionalFiniste 12 років тому

    how could you be sure?

  • @OlenkaWagner
    @OlenkaWagner 13 років тому

    @olistaeuble - If I were a spy I wouldn't write my comments on YT. And I would be more interested in current events than in past events ;) BTW. Your profile says "Switzerland". Spies from different sides liked coming to Switzerland...

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Obummer is just like Chamberlain. And you know how that adventure turned out. Some people just never learn.

    • @kalfunai
      @kalfunai 3 роки тому

      JUST LIKE YOU AND YOUR FAKE ORANGE MORON

  • @TheStephenMac
    @TheStephenMac 12 років тому

    Just out of interest where are you from

  • @hobied62
    @hobied62 5 років тому

    This is why all warships now have falankes defence systems. American or Russian ships would not have done any better. Sadly as a Brit the Argitinians did well with good equipment, means the British did better no 3 world nation win here.

    • @hobied62
      @hobied62 5 років тому

      @A True maybe I didt phrase it right I ment individual ships, you certainly could have over whelmed them.

    • @Zooumberg
      @Zooumberg 5 років тому

      @A Sorry mate, but US forces are not perfect. That's not to degrade both past and present US forces. They did Europe a magnificent service during world war 2. However, during the invasion of Grenada, it was a classic example of how not to conduct an invasion. The intelligence was so bad that the lads on the ground had to use tourist maps and even had to raid Esso petrol (that's gas stations for our American cousins), with military coordinates handwritten on them. It still didn't prevent US forces attacking and killing their own men with airstrikes. America given the same equipment and resources couldn't have done any better during the Falklands.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому +1

    Hey Ed the talking horse: Your buddy Castro is now just a vegetable. Please accept my big whoppie, dearie.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Correction: It was a naval war fought at times on land as a diversion. The object was freedom of the seas to conduct our world commerce without interference. We got that PLUS the Brits out of the Great Lakes region which they were supposed to have vacated in 1783 but didn't. With New Orleans we controlled the Mississippi which is exactly like controlling the English Channel to UK. Big defeat for the British because it meant the USA established hegemony of North America & Western Hemisphere.

    • @originalkk882
      @originalkk882 4 роки тому

      So America's first act was to try to invade Canada, which failed. They had initial success at sea against smaller British frigates, but by the end of the war the RN had imposed a blockade which led the New England traders to push the US gevernment for a peace treaty as they were facing bankruptcy. Plus the Battle of New Orleans took place after the peace treaty had been signed, so had no actual effect on the outcome of the war.

  • @normagonzalez2251
    @normagonzalez2251 8 років тому +1

    1:28:25 Misiles Argentinos nuestros se dirigen sobre el enemigo ???

    • @normagonzalez2251
      @normagonzalez2251 8 років тому +3

      Viva Argentina¡¡¡¡

    • @emmanuelzepernick7209
      @emmanuelzepernick7209 5 років тому +2

      Norma Gonzalez: Se dirigian porque el primer dia que los Ingleses les volaron 8 en un solo dia se escondieron en Argentina y no volvieron a salir. Se quedaron totalmente sin ayuda aerea..La invasion les costo mucho y si planean otra ya les estan esperando para partirles las nalgas como lo hicieron en el 1982...A ver como te cayo esa?

    • @raquelalvarez356
      @raquelalvarez356 3 роки тому

      @@emmanuelzepernick7209 FEEEEEEELICITACIONES

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Your grandfather's brother was 17 years old? Gotcha..

  • @jreg2007
    @jreg2007 Рік тому +2

    the falkland Islands have been British since before Argentina was even a recognised country

  • @dehdeh55
    @dehdeh55 11 років тому

    That seems reasonable.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    I doubt the Wainwright story because MacArthur was kind to him after the war and made sure he was on the USS Missouri for surrender. Wainwright thought he might be court martialed because he did disobey orders not to surrender and he worried about that while imprisoned. But Mac was generous. Why would Wainwright be entitled to a CMOH? Where was bravery above and beyond the cause of duty? It demeans the meaning of the medal because what he did was what officers do when defeated.

  • @wildandbarefoot
    @wildandbarefoot 5 років тому +1

    We need more aircraft carriers. We wouldn't have lost all those ships with a bit of top cover. Tory Cuts. I'd rather have carriers than nukes.

    • @jackmerriman4445
      @jackmerriman4445 4 роки тому

      We have just commissioned 2. And we let the yanks deal with power projection anyway. Trident is a huge bargaining chip in the world game

    • @muttley8818
      @muttley8818 3 роки тому

      We now have 2. HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince Of Wales.

  • @me-cq7wv
    @me-cq7wv 6 років тому +7

    🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿👍

  • @ar2014
    @ar2014 12 років тому

    But who's talking about the a4's and the dauntless? i don't want a war or nothing like that

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    contd) Control of the Mississippi and elimination of British remnants around the Great Lake regions was absolutely vital to subsequent American Western expansion out of the confines of the original 13 colonies and trans-Alleghany region. We know as "Manifest Destiny" and resulted in the shape and size of US as you see today and not the confined area of the revolution. New Orleans controls the Mississippi's mouth and that's why we had to beat the British soldiers who beat Napoleon in that battle.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Yes, general,, the sun has finally set on the empire, 'ol boy. Take your gin and tonic and watch the sunset just fade away. As the eagle soars over Big Ben and drops a plop on Westminister.as a token of our esteem for ya all.

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    America's War of 1812 was fought over the principle of "freedom of the seas." The land battles were secondary. American naval battles were raged in British home waters and against British coastal cities. This was done in conjunction with Napoleon's war on land and sea. America won its war aims, namely no more impressments of American seamen and no further interference with our freedom of the seas to conduct commerce with continental Europe.Also, America got control of the Mississippi River

    • @originalkk882
      @originalkk882 4 роки тому +4

      You really love to twist a few events in history to become "facts". How many naval battles were in British home waters? Precisely one US raid.
      What happened to the USN in the end? It was bottled up by a British blockade, and the rich American merchants who wanted the war in the first place lobbied the US government to seek a peace treaty, as trade and customs revenue fell precipitously.

    • @Valencetheshireman927
      @Valencetheshireman927 10 місяців тому

      “America won its war aims”
      Because Britain had stopped press ganging sailers before the war had even started

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    Winston was ignored in pre-1939 peacetime and you got War. Now, you say it was wise to ignore him post-1945 peacetime. And did Attlee, the socialist, provide Nirvana? Must be "no" because the Brits brought Churchill back in 1952. Winston wasn't responsible for the misery of WW2. He alone warned against Hitler and if listened to maybe WW2 could have been prevented. But my point is he was loyal to Britain, but the British showed extreme disloyality to him. Stunning character trait of British.

  • @italodardogomez866
    @italodardogomez866 3 роки тому +3

    Honor y gloria al soldado argentino!!!!

  • @nuevachicago
    @nuevachicago 12 років тому +3

    Colonialism still exists!! What is next slavery?

  • @doublehappiness9889
    @doublehappiness9889 2 роки тому +2

    24:48 - oops! :D

  • @ralfrath699
    @ralfrath699 11 років тому

    I have always accepted that the falkland brits belong to britain and after a referendum that most falkland peoples wants to belong to britian - this a a fair democratic vote of the poeple and must accepted by all sides. But what I never had understood that the brits never accepted that german people after world war 1 - also voted democratic - belong to germany - also austrians wants to go germany - Why did the brits dont accept this? Consequence of this was also WW2

  • @Thebonesoftrees
    @Thebonesoftrees 12 років тому

    how cute is the reporter at100:00

  • @milrevko
    @milrevko 12 років тому +2

    What about Vietnam?

  • @TheStephenMac
    @TheStephenMac 12 років тому

    Not united as such but think the majority of the world has realised that war is not the best way

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    An exception doesn't negate the rule. Of course there are fuckup officers. I encountered them, too. Was the other US officer present during the "offense"? What kind of witness was he if he wasn't there? You assume your side of the story and I want proof of the offense. Hell, if conduct was illegal, then why would the US not want to punish offender? But there is such a thing as due process. And this must be followed. It's also one thing to know and another to be able to prove. You God?

  • @OlenkaWagner
    @OlenkaWagner 13 років тому +1

    @paulspydar - Royal Marines, not Paras. I agree with the rest.

  • @Myles0Harcourt
    @Myles0Harcourt 12 років тому

    Who looks more deranged?
    01:22:15 or 01:22:36

  • @milrevko
    @milrevko 12 років тому +2

    WTF?

  • @05Rudey
    @05Rudey 11 років тому +1

    Well spotted sir lol

  • @klatu1956
    @klatu1956 11 років тому

    why dosent brazil claim asention island too!

  • @ar2014
    @ar2014 12 років тому +1

    that's why conscription was abolished. and argentina won every war, except the one with the brits in 1982, of course. don't listen to eddieExile

  • @1935rmb
    @1935rmb 11 років тому

    We found out the bugger was actually our free breakfast and we were expected to add our spit to reconstitute it. They actually sent up a knife and fork.with bugger instructions We were told it should turn bright green when ready for consumption. In American hotel rooms we place a chocolate on the pillow. Big cultural difference. You can be sure we ate at Burger King during our stay thereafter. I could tell you lots of horror tales we encountered. But I don't want to sicken you.

  • @nahuel941
    @nahuel941 13 років тому +1

    @Eddieposted En
    1765, una expedición inglesa llegó a las islas y las denominó Falkland Islands. En 1770, las fuerzas de ocupación inglesas fueron
    desalojadas por España, que reclamó a soberanía de las islas por vía diplomática. Cuando se creó el Virreinato del Río de La
    Plata, las Malvinas pasaron a depender de la gobernación de Buenos Aires. Desde 1774 hasta 1810, España nombró sucesivos
    gobernadores para el archipiélago.

  • @DarkprinX2500
    @DarkprinX2500 12 років тому

    how can someone calling for complete genocide reach top comment.. this astonishes mel... i was told the age of colonialism is gone.. but i can see now that it is quite alive ..