How politics destroyed ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan’s career and set back India’s space program

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 24 чер 2021
  • A shameful episode of petty politics destroyed the life and career of the brilliant ISRO scientist, Nambi Narayanan and set back India’s space program by nearly a decade. 25 years after he was set free, the Supreme Court finally named 18 police officers, all now retired, for their role in framing Nambi.
    #isrospycase #nambinarayanan #crimestories
    Join us on
    Discord: / discord
    Instagram: @gobisbo
    Facebook: Bisbo
    Twitter: @Bisboworld
    Sources
    Times of India
    Isro espionage case: FIR against 18 ex-cops; June 25, 2021
    Justice Jain submits report on police role in framing scientist in ISRO spy case; Dhananjay Mahapatra; April 5, 2021
    No rocket science, this: The framing of Nambi Narayanan may have involved three conspiracies in one; Arun Ram; September 14, 2018
    The Tribune
    1994 ISRO spy scandal: Justice DK Jain Committee submits report on allegations against Kerala police officers; April 3, 2021
    The Leaflet
    SC to hear next week Centre’s application to accept Justice DK Jain committee report on ISRO scientist espionage case; April 5, 2021
    India Today
    Kerala: Key questions about spy scandal remain unanswered a month after spy ring exposed; M G Radhakrishnan; November 30, 1999
    Indian intelligence agencies feud, work at cross-purposes bringing embarrassment; Shekhar Gupta; January 31, 1995
    Scroll.in
    ‘Give us any Muslim name’: How authorities tried to build a false spy case against Nambi Narayanan; Nambi Narayanan & Arun Ram; September 15, 2018.
    The Wire
    Here's the real story of Isro 'spy' case that rocked the nation in the 1990s; Manoj Joshi;
    September 16, 2018.
    Indian Express
    Fake ISRO spy case: The seven characters of the false espionage story; September 19, 2018.
    The Print
    The fake ‘spy thriller’ that cost Nambi Narayanan his career, life savings and self-esteem; Shekhar Gupta; September 14, 2018.
    ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan says Kalam wanted him to give up fight, but he refused; Rohini Swamy; September 16, 2018.
    Justice for ISRO’s Nambi Narayanan: How IB, CBI, courts tangled in spy case, ruined India's interest; Shekhar Gupta; Aug 13, 2020.
    BBC News
    Nambi Narayanan: The fake spy scandal that blew up a rocket scientist’s career; Soutik Biswas; January 27, 2020.
    Youth Ki Awaz
    S. Nambi Narayanan: A Patriot Turned Into A Traitor By A Broken System; Shubham Singla; April 10, 2021.
    The Week
    ISRO 'fake' espionage case: SC orders CBI probe into arrest of Nambi Narayanan; April 15, 2021.
    Hindustan Times
    The 1994 espionage case that led to Isro scientist Nambi Narayanan's arrest; Shivani Kumar; April 16, 2021.
    The Hindu
    Nambi Narayanan | The battles of a space dreamer; Tiki Rajwi; April 17, 2021.
    Taazakhabarnews.com
    How Nambi Narayanan was framed in a fake Spy Case?; Neeraj Mahajan

КОМЕНТАРІ • 2,4 тис.

  • @SaurabhPandey-zk9yl
    @SaurabhPandey-zk9yl 2 роки тому +2368

    Everyone wants to criticize police,media without criticizing themselves.
    If tomorrow a case of same nature comes out then we will be the first person to call the accused a traitor or spy.
    Media knows public's emotion very well and thats why they play with it very easily.
    If you disagree then just think about Riya Chakraborty case and how public and media unleashed hell on her.

    • @jayanthreddy1582
      @jayanthreddy1582 2 роки тому +218

      And the same media was sympathizing Mr. Nambi Narayanan when he was released after 14 years. The people who called him a traitor, later called him a patroit. Media's stupid race for TRP and publicity ruins every person who are in their radar.

    • @SaurabhPandey-zk9yl
      @SaurabhPandey-zk9yl 2 роки тому +11

      @@jayanthreddy1582 Exactly

    • @anuragdwivedi3748
      @anuragdwivedi3748 2 роки тому +131

      Are you drunk ? Riya chakorborty was involve

    • @jayanthreddy1582
      @jayanthreddy1582 2 роки тому +44

      @@anuragdwivedi3748 Do you have proof? This happened with Nambi sir 14 years back. People accused him baselessly.

    • @anuragdwivedi3748
      @anuragdwivedi3748 2 роки тому +89

      @@jayanthreddy1582 see her interview not everyone is innocent she said Sushant is afraid of height but in next video you will find Sushant is flying plane and she also said sushant comes in her dream 😂😡

  • @ipdharwad
    @ipdharwad 2 роки тому +3143

    Poor Nambi didn't accept job in NASA to serve his homeland and he got this for his patriotism. Shame.

    • @davidalexsebastiank6250
      @davidalexsebastiank6250 2 роки тому +209

      And many ISRO scientists were killed and UPA Government didn't care about it

    • @devjitmondal47
      @devjitmondal47 2 роки тому +28

      Thats why nationalism is cancer

    • @rajadhirajmaharaj
      @rajadhirajmaharaj 2 роки тому +48

      @@Pythonsr71 hahaha... none of the scientists in NASA are billionaires...
      a million dollar is 7 crore rupees, so, maybe yeah, he couldve been a millionaire or not, depends on what role they were giving him in NASA. remember, he was put in leadership position in ISRO, i doubt that NASA would have done the same, probably a less charismatic small role.
      so, he took the best offer at that time.
      it was not his patriotism or sacrifice, but a very much rational decision indeed.
      the accusations and tortures are basically what happens when a country is at war or warlike situation with another country. and ofcourse the uneducated inhumane nature of policemen in general. they are like the last benchers in school who, if get a chance to harass the topper, will do it very spontaneously.

    • @SS-tp9cj
      @SS-tp9cj 2 роки тому +3

      @Adrish Kar And that's the conclusion you found?? Lol.

    • @unitedstatesofamerica4737
      @unitedstatesofamerica4737 2 роки тому +7

      @@rajadhirajmaharaj stupidity is everywhere

  • @nayanpatel1036
    @nayanpatel1036 Рік тому +234

    Thank you R Madhavan for making "Rocketry: The Nambi Effect" and bringing the story of such a great scientist to the world and teaching a huge lesson to the nation.

    • @aishr8125
      @aishr8125 11 місяців тому

      @@ananymouse3988He is clearly mentioning Madhavan from the film industry

    • @sivag2032
      @sivag2032 9 місяців тому

      ​@@ananymouse3988yes you have turned commenter turned Rocket scientist researcher

  • @omyandsea
    @omyandsea Рік тому +93

    Lesson learnt : Never believe if someone is guilty until proven ! And never accuse anyone

    • @hello-zn8fd
      @hello-zn8fd 2 місяці тому

      Kerala worst state. People are cruel, aggressive

  • @sunnysoni8221
    @sunnysoni8221 Рік тому +66

    No amount of money offered to Nambi in compensation can get the years of missed progress back.
    Filling cases against police officers after 26 years, who now must be at good ranks makes ZERO sense but still fine.
    May the truth prevail.

    • @mendachinnappanna3352
      @mendachinnappanna3352 Рік тому +3

      This money recovered from retired police officers and chief Minister of that time, the Court must give orders

  • @johanshibumathew6575
    @johanshibumathew6575 2 роки тому +548

    Just imagine what ISRO could have done if we had Nambi Narayan's knowledge with us for 27 years?

    • @aweirdoonyoutube299
      @aweirdoonyoutube299 2 роки тому +8

      Wonders

    • @justarandomguywithoutaname8719
      @justarandomguywithoutaname8719 2 роки тому +22

      U can say we could have had several rovers on mars, not just an orbiter

    • @sibymathews182
      @sibymathews182 2 роки тому +3

      What exactly? Send people to land on Uranus?

    • @prabhanjangokhale5587
      @prabhanjangokhale5587 2 роки тому +37

      @@sibymathews182 nope we would have brought back juzuz from Virgin marry...rice bag

    • @deepalakshmi5890
      @deepalakshmi5890 Рік тому +18

      Exactly so we know how anti Indian Congress and all parties supporting minorities people may not like it but Kerala government would never do this if it’s a Christian or Muslim scientist

  • @sachinjambhulkar6970
    @sachinjambhulkar6970 2 роки тому +778

    Once again politics has choosen its prey and demolished larger scientific interest of the country. It's disheartening and beyond imagination how Nambi's family have suffered all this time. A justice delayed, is equal to Justice Denied!!! All appreciation for Bisbo team for putting across through very clear animation and lucid script

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому +29

      Yes, really disheartening that this happened

    • @siddharthjmt8216
      @siddharthjmt8216 2 роки тому +14

      Actually their is a saying innocent until proven guilty, but here it seems to be guilty until proven innocent.😓😓😓

    • @eshwarashawn4493
      @eshwarashawn4493 2 роки тому +2

      China 👍. India hopeless

    • @joshuajohn74
      @joshuajohn74 2 роки тому +9

      @@eshwarashawn4493 🤣 justice gets delayed in India
      There isnt any justice in china

    • @vishu7478
      @vishu7478 2 роки тому +16

      he is a the great Princeton university student. Had he gone to america, now he would have earned crores & today would have become a famous scientist in the world. But He decided to serve the nation and we know what happened to him! heartbreaking this. Even today he is living here in India without joining international colleges for teaching with a great salary! that shows his patriotism

  • @notumang
    @notumang Рік тому +41

    Thank you for making a detailed video on this. 🙏🏻
    Recently I saw R Madhavn interview in which he talk about Nabmi sir. One sentence that shook me was, "Although justice is delivered, award and compensation was given but try and search for my name in google, top results include all false accusations against me, and people still believe them".
    Some important take from this case:-
    1. Politics have precedence over anything in this country.
    2. Lack of awareness leads to misinformation injected in the grapevine of our society.
    3. If a budding scientist took this as an example he will never imagine his career in #ISRO resulting in another channel for brain drain
    4. Rather than posthumously correcting our mistake, we should acknowledge our mistake and deliver the justice Nambi sir expects and deserves.
    A huge thank you for Bisbo 🙏🏻

  • @manusamy2763
    @manusamy2763 Рік тому +27

    The mental agony of his wife and daughter during those custody period couldn't be imagined.

  • @avijitgoswami3082
    @avijitgoswami3082 2 роки тому +279

    It takes 25 years to take action against police ????? That's the problem ... You can change a politician in 5 years but what about police ????

    • @rahulsisodia8743
      @rahulsisodia8743 2 роки тому +5

      Police follow the orders.

    • @avijitgoswami3082
      @avijitgoswami3082 2 роки тому +29

      @@rahulsisodia8743 not always .. they are more brutal then politician ... They alway have loopholes to save criminal ...
      But always have law to punish human ...
      Though many police are stuck in the system

    • @cbicommentbureauofinternet5290
      @cbicommentbureauofinternet5290 2 роки тому +17

      @@avijitgoswami3082 exactly
      If cops do crime
      Then noone dares to raise Q
      That's a problem

    • @avijitgoswami3082
      @avijitgoswami3082 2 роки тому +6

      @@cbicommentbureauofinternet5290 I already suffered
      ... A rapist fraud ngo doctor blackmailing me with false women case ...
      In Bengal rape victims are not getting punishment, then how women law become powerful against common men ...

    • @cbicommentbureauofinternet5290
      @cbicommentbureauofinternet5290 2 роки тому +3

      @@avijitgoswami3082 that's the problem.when people make false allegations. Then real innocent people who were actually ,Dharshan by DharshanKari ,don't get justice.
      The criminals should get punished.
      If he is a Real DharshanKari or a false accusation blackmailer

  • @spoidy_
    @spoidy_ 2 роки тому +1116

    Shame on politics and police who destroyed the career of great scientist...
    This incident pushed back indian rocket science 14 years..
    Many successful missions like chandrayan were supposed to launch 14 years ago, If nambi narayanan's cryogenic technology was done successfully without any political interruptions ........
    ______________________❤️___________
    Edit :- Thank you all for 1k+ likes
    And 49+ replies ❤️❤️❤️
    ______________________❤️___________

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому +73

      Couldn't agree more!

    • @siddharthjmt8216
      @siddharthjmt8216 2 роки тому +37

      I think it's also shame on public because godi media was telecasting this man as a traitor for TRP, and without cross checking the facts nor even understanding the problem involved they blindly concluded nambi as a traitor. If their was public pressure at the start their are high chances the case would've shifted to cbi long back before it actually happened.
      Edit: most of u who read this comment highly misunderstood this the word godi means a media that propagates fake news/hate speech to create herd mentality that's the only thing I meant, I was just against yellow journalism and herd mentality but most of u concluded I meant so called bjp supported media and I was pro congress and pro upa 😂😂😂😂. Well just to clarify I think both these central level parties are shit and pure non sense one for corruption and other for capitalism anyways this is just my opinion on these political parties which is completely unrelated to my original comment. In the end I'm just saying pls don't conclude anything blindly of what u understand of certain words atleast try to understand the message in the sentence. Godi media can be arnab from republic or Rajdeep from India today both of them are same nonsense to me.

    • @vanshshetty3066
      @vanshshetty3066 2 роки тому +98

      @@siddharthjmt8216 what non sense are you talking dude , AK Anthony had plotted this he was quite close to Sonia Gandhi , so it’s obvious your Dalal media had spread the fake information to defame the scientist , and to take India back by several years in scientific technology development.

    • @vanshshetty3066
      @vanshshetty3066 2 роки тому +98

      @@siddharthjmt8216 it was the Modi government which gave him Padma Bhushan , your favourite upa government just kept on dragging his case in the Supreme Court , even after knowing that he was innocent .

    • @todkolas7582
      @todkolas7582 2 роки тому +5

      If you start the shame, there are countless number of things in India to be shameful of. Just be proud bro. 😉

  • @bhavanikumar7150
    @bhavanikumar7150 Рік тому +5

    Great video explaining the case to the layman. Congratulations. As a citizen I apologise to Mr Nambi for all torture and evil he had to undergo.

  • @souravkumar3452
    @souravkumar3452 2 роки тому +22

    I am science student but I never hear about him. He decided to serve his motherland and tourtured for 25 years. What kind of problems he and his family had face on those periods
    Hope this never happen again

  • @UpasanaBobby
    @UpasanaBobby 2 роки тому +479

    It was not Nambi Narayanan' s career, but India's Cryogenic rocket technology development was spoiled by whoever behind the whole this so called espionage drama.

    • @praks07
      @praks07 2 роки тому +28

      It was both.

    • @arockiyarajwilliams9861
      @arockiyarajwilliams9861 Рік тому +2

      Podaa.... Listen he was too patriotic. K he worked on behalf of India only. Yet, might our own Indian or other countries tech guys might done this.but nam & his whole family in his own state why to be punished for that?

    • @algung2522
      @algung2522 Рік тому

      ...must be America? ...or colonial master British?

    • @krishnahazarikarao7812
      @krishnahazarikarao7812 Рік тому +5

      Yes..collateral damages were many. India lost its scientific research capacity by 20 years or more, since Nambi a great scientist was incapacitated In future Indian scientists will fear to tread similar path of scientific research & initiatives..US showed how it can easily take advantage of our rotten political system. Very sad & scary.

    • @tpt9028
      @tpt9028 Рік тому +2

      I doubt all these claims. If not arrested, could Nambi make a rocket engine to challenge NASA?!!! There is only a Nambi Narayanan in the entire ISRO capable of developing a rocket engine?!! These are just tall claims! He was just part of a team of engineers and used to claim the credit for himself for the achievements of his team! Also he became famous only after this case (if he was such a genius we should have known him long before)!

  • @Maryam_195
    @Maryam_195 2 роки тому +1045

    Being a pakistani nd a physics enthusiast , my heart is deep in sorrow. When will india nd pakistan start to honor nd respect their scientists nd educationalists instead of illitrate politicians ?

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому +108

      Well said Marium

    • @theinstayatri9463
      @theinstayatri9463 2 роки тому +104

      Please don't include Pakistani scientists with Indian scientists. Indian scientists never sold nuclear technology to Iran, North Korea, and Libya. 😏
      And @Bisbo can you be a bit less secular and tell the truth instead!

    • @victorray9369
      @victorray9369 2 роки тому +107

      @@theinstayatri9463 u r another lol.

    • @warpdrive9229
      @warpdrive9229 2 роки тому +39

      Similar thing happened to Abdus Salam in Pakistan. Very sad thing :(

    • @RitamSanyal
      @RitamSanyal 2 роки тому +51

      @@theinstayatri9463 awwww, can't bear the truth 😁 well I liked this fear of truth in you that you are telling a person to be less secular so he can spread propaganda like you 😏

  • @rochitshukla6093
    @rochitshukla6093 2 роки тому +4

    Fantastically explained, without any exaggeration. 🔥🔥 The hardwork will surely payoff 🔥🔥

  • @deyvanaiarumugam6083
    @deyvanaiarumugam6083 2 роки тому +1

    Thank you for making this video. The greatest and living legend Sir Nambi Narayanan.

  • @TheRehankhan143
    @TheRehankhan143 2 роки тому +348

    There must be justice for nambi. Our scientists don't deserve this. It should be an example for other not to mess with our tech guys. The police guys who framed nambi must be dragged to court and charged

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому +16

      Hopefully justice will prevail soon

    • @jigneshmore2756
      @jigneshmore2756 2 роки тому +6

      Unfortunately we are not able to provide security to our scientists

    • @earthplanet2239
      @earthplanet2239 2 роки тому +4

      I'm sacred now because I have interest in defence and space technology. What to do.

    • @gazpachopolice7211
      @gazpachopolice7211 2 роки тому +11

      Frankly Nambiar had it better because he was educated. There are thousands who rot in jail waiting for trial for petty crimes they may not have committed.

    • @siddharthjmt8216
      @siddharthjmt8216 2 роки тому +10

      Actually I think a scientist should not be arrested by normal police man in the first place atleast in civil and security matters because it's almost impossible for a normal cop to understand these scientific terms and technology and to conduct an investigation next to impossible.

  • @prakashm.s8134
    @prakashm.s8134 2 роки тому +1388

    By the way, the guy who made up this story to topple the Kerala government become the 23rd Defence Minister of India. (A. K. Antony)

    • @jdsurgeon4820
      @jdsurgeon4820 2 роки тому +88

      Dat hit me hard bro

    • @giornogiovanna4117
      @giornogiovanna4117 2 роки тому +305

      After all this si the most literate state we are talking about
      Literacy does not equal to education

    • @Dk01359Travel
      @Dk01359Travel 2 роки тому +282

      Congress is that termite which ate the nation from inside

    • @Vamshk
      @Vamshk 2 роки тому +130

      Congress made the most out of the pseudo socialist reforms.. by enjoying the benefits directly in the name of government working for one family

    • @vinaykumar-mk1lg
      @vinaykumar-mk1lg 2 роки тому +114

      Sonia Gandhi should be sent to life imprisonment

  • @bindureddy2415
    @bindureddy2415 Рік тому +9

    Justice must prevail to Nambi sir!
    Those who are the reason for destroying his career should be sentenced, in order to prevent any similar intentional acts in future.

  • @balamadras
    @balamadras 9 місяців тому +6

    It is unbelievable how kerala police easily got out of this issue without even a scratch. The judicial system is very lame.

  • @vikrantsood2053
    @vikrantsood2053 2 роки тому +414

    The Kerala police should be made accountable..and those responsible should be arrested..

    • @vikrantsood2053
      @vikrantsood2053 2 роки тому +2

      @Ashwini M P
      AWESOME news... 🙏🙏

    • @jey2275
      @jey2275 2 роки тому +7

      They are all arrested

    • @pradeepkumar-hp6wn
      @pradeepkumar-hp6wn Рік тому +18

      One police man - who visited the mali ladies hotel room to check her visa documents. As usual he wanted sexual favors - he didn’t get it.
      His vengeance to twist things up went out of control. Media getting a bond style story - Leading to dirty politics taking advantage.
      These Mali ladies came to india for their personal reasons. That police mans greet had lead to all these. Shame on him. Those ladies were jailed for years and exploited for years just to keep the story running. Disgraceful.

    • @victimoffame2389
      @victimoffame2389 Рік тому

      Not just arrest, should be executed.

    • @ameenaaneesh6862
      @ameenaaneesh6862 Рік тому +7

      @@pradeepkumar-hp6wn well said. Nobody mentions how traumatised and devastated their lives became. Mariam was asked for sex which she refused. Fouzia was threatened using her daughter. They were both physically assaulted brutally. The worst part, nambi sir never met these women or vice versa.

  • @vitsboy46
    @vitsboy46 2 роки тому +184

    His story needs to be exposed so sad to see this😭😭

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому +15

      Certainly

    • @akashjay703
      @akashjay703 2 роки тому +4

      A movie is coming rocketry

    • @akashjay703
      @akashjay703 2 роки тому +5

      @Ashwini M P yes starring Madhavan, teaser is already released you can check in youtube "Rocketry" along with Sharukh Khan in North & Suriya in South India

    • @shaktitraders9337
      @shaktitraders9337 2 роки тому +2

      Told not exposed

    • @vitsboy46
      @vitsboy46 2 роки тому +1

      @@akashjay703 yes but till date the whole story is not clear

  • @p.v.chandrasekharan5666
    @p.v.chandrasekharan5666 Рік тому +8

    Heart breaking episode and shame on India’s investigating agencies!

  • @raghuiyer9656
    @raghuiyer9656 2 роки тому +25

    Because of corrupted politicians, good souls like him loses their lives. Apart from personal loss for those innocent people, it is a great loss for our country also.

  • @anujpatil572
    @anujpatil572 2 роки тому +327

    That's why indian great scientists prefers NASA as NASA keep them as a child

    • @amanhasnoname1052
      @amanhasnoname1052 2 роки тому +56

      They pay them well! ✅
      They give credit even to everyone!! ✅
      They don't have corrupt govt!! ✅

    • @mysticdragonex815
      @mysticdragonex815 2 роки тому +41

      @@amanhasnoname1052 Lol, so you think US Government is not corrupt?

    • @theinstayatri9463
      @theinstayatri9463 2 роки тому +29

      @@amanhasnoname1052 The murderers of Kashoggi in the Consulate took special training in US and had approval of US government. Go brainwash a Mexican or a Puerto Rican or a Guatemalan. 😂🤣🤣

    • @ytshorts9146
      @ytshorts9146 2 роки тому +38

      @@mysticdragonex815 better then Indian politics..

    • @trolldrums4u
      @trolldrums4u 2 роки тому +4

      Nasa is Fake Ex moon Mission ,

  • @symkvs
    @symkvs 2 роки тому +437

    It was to US and not Pakistan. These politicians who are still in Kerala brought India 20 years back in the cryogenic race. US took or played a plot. 10:05 projects the police officers . Good job bisbo

    • @dkhandelwal9766
      @dkhandelwal9766 2 роки тому +10

      Not only US but China also !

    • @masochistboy653
      @masochistboy653 2 роки тому +9

      If One scientists research is only required and rest are useless the india is doomed in space race. Even a space company like spacex is sending people to space. ISRO is being useless now. It should have been privatized long back.

    • @infinityxtanishq8712
      @infinityxtanishq8712 2 роки тому +31

      @@masochistboy653 Einstein , Gandhi and abdul Kalam were also just one men

    • @abhirajarora7631
      @abhirajarora7631 2 роки тому +27

      @@masochistboy653 SpaceX and ISRO both have different missions. Stop LARPing.

    • @petrichor259
      @petrichor259 2 роки тому +28

      @@masochistboy653 Name a major superpower without govt controlled space research organisation. You cant. These organisations are there to develop foundation for technological advancements upon which private players can improve their tech. It is always the public money that goes it to basic tech research as it is expensive , private players wont put much money into it. Once the tech becomes mainstream and affordable, private players also hop into space race.

  • @RK-in3iu
    @RK-in3iu 2 роки тому +11

    You know the state of your country when Veerappan's wife became a successful politician.

  • @seanras4046
    @seanras4046 Рік тому +12

    The persons who laid the false allegation should be identified and given capital punishment. India is being ruined for political ambition.

  • @pavan9965
    @pavan9965 2 роки тому +94

    Media and false allegations are responsible for destruction of his career

  • @jayanthreddy1582
    @jayanthreddy1582 2 роки тому +478

    Waiting for Madhavan sir's "Rocketry" which focuses on his life. Hope it releases soon.

    • @shekhar1438
      @shekhar1438 2 роки тому +2

      Do you know when is it going to be released on OTT platforms?

    • @sanurawat1651
      @sanurawat1651 2 роки тому +2

      Kab hori hai release?

    • @dhruv6183
      @dhruv6183 2 роки тому +5

      It got delayed due to 2nd wave.Jo official announcement yet !

    • @shubhanshusingh335
      @shubhanshusingh335 2 роки тому +7

      Why people are calling everyone sir these days. While the world is ditching this sir culture, we indians r embracing it more

    • @sunilbarik6726
      @sunilbarik6726 2 роки тому +2

      Read the book by Nambi narayanan about isro spy case u will get toq know more.This movie is also inspired from that book

  • @nithinchinni
    @nithinchinni Рік тому +6

    Imagining the life of Nambi Narayanan going through such a pain and all his life dreams shattered. Just think how many motivated people in India lost interest in achieving something.

  • @dgillies5420
    @dgillies5420 Рік тому +10

    Let this video be a lesson for India.
    As my closest born-and-raised-in-India EE-engineer friend (whose father owned a factory in India) says,
    "India is full of corruption, especially police corruption!"
    With a small bribe these police were able to destroy India's leading rocket program and leading scientist!
    Nambi was on the verge of earning BILLIONs of dollars in the satellite-launch business - for India!
    So this is why tech workers are always leaving India! If India can't protect its best and brightest people, why stay there?
    Why not go someplace where your work is respected and you can work in peace? Someplace else!
    This injustice will continue until India reforms its police & judicial systems!
    Just delayed 25 years is justice denied!
    I say this in the hopes that constructive criticism will help India!

  • @sooryadazp4214
    @sooryadazp4214 2 роки тому +42

    Dirty politics in Kerala 🔥 india lost more than 20 years ...

  • @omkarporedi61
    @omkarporedi61 2 роки тому +87

    Seeing this condition of such a great scientist who will willingly take any job for ISRO?
    Currently same is happening with doctors due to which many are leaving and setting abroad.
    This is a shameful event.

    • @deepapatel5059
      @deepapatel5059 2 роки тому +8

      Concur that..a lot of my doc colleagues are unwilling to let their kids practice in india..they say it's a hell!

    • @nikolovdimitry5996
      @nikolovdimitry5996 2 роки тому +6

      I'm too leaving after I graduate. I started preparing for usmle already.

  • @paduvathil
    @paduvathil 2 роки тому +1

    This is one of my favourite channels!! lots of informative videos !! Thanks for sharing such videos !!
    Best wishes to you and your family !!
    Keep uploading !! Stay safe !!
    Thank you so much
    Lots of Love ❤❤❤❤❤❤

  • @MrHappyyyyyy
    @MrHappyyyyyy Рік тому +6

    Saw his biopic Rocketry The Nambi effect.
    Great man 👏👏👏

  • @skywalk3rcodm917
    @skywalk3rcodm917 2 роки тому +52

    Congress party always did this kind of things .

  • @leanderbarreto6523
    @leanderbarreto6523 2 роки тому +81

    18 policemen are finally in the dock for this fake case

  • @shoryaakriti5990
    @shoryaakriti5990 2 роки тому +10

    It had been better for him to take job opportunity at nasa ....See that's why most of the youth of India doesn't like to serve in our country because of the dirty politics and corrupt media.

    • @aweirdoonyoutube299
      @aweirdoonyoutube299 2 роки тому +1

      Yeah even my son has great knowledge in space
      But he wants to go to NASA

  • @zil1832
    @zil1832 2 роки тому +47

    Lesson: *Sensationalist Medias can destroy lives!*

  • @FireFox-di5cz
    @FireFox-di5cz Рік тому

    Thanks for the video bro, much required 🙏

  • @balasubramaniansethuraman8686

    Well done sir. The culprits behind this case should be dealt with.

  • @white_shadow05
    @white_shadow05 2 роки тому +85

    Nambi who refused a fat paying job at USA to work for his motherland was completely destroyed for no fault of his own. If I was him, I'll leave India with all my family to some other country never to return back. His knowledge in space is immense and he can help advance any country instead of sitting idle at a desk job. Being India he'll never get justice from the judiciary. It's better to seek asylum outside India and work his mind instead of letting his knowledge rot at the desk office. Sue the newspaper too please.

    • @tamilpatriot7815
      @tamilpatriot7815 2 роки тому +3

      Well said.

    • @miekkb
      @miekkb 2 роки тому +4

      thats why u're not him...as a muslim I admire his loyalty and patriotism

    • @white_shadow05
      @white_shadow05 2 роки тому +7

      @@miekkb Loyalty! My foot. What sense does it make... tearing one heart and holding in one's own hand? Being patriotic and laying waste one's talent doesn't help anyone. And I don't want to be him, no not in a thousand year.

    • @aman7697
      @aman7697 2 роки тому +3

      @@white_shadow05 you don't understand love . Love does not work on deals . You are too immature saying this . Well i think you are the type of person who will betray his motherland for money because you are frustated with someone else's false accusations.

    • @white_shadow05
      @white_shadow05 2 роки тому +2

      @@aman7697 It's not about money... It's about justice I am talking of. If it's money, he is already well compensated for the ordeal he had to faced. You think he will get justice, I pity those Indian believing in the judiciary system of India. And you are saying this so easy, preaching all about love... because you are sitting comfort in your zone and typing me reply. Would you say and stay the same if you had gone through the same, I highly doubt.

  • @naveents1732
    @naveents1732 2 роки тому +21

    Shame on those people. This is how real talent is destroyed in India

  • @kirandangi1729
    @kirandangi1729 Рік тому +7

    He should have accepted the US Offer and stayed there . His lifestyle and life would be better.
    Furthermore, For a respectable person disrespect is worse than death.

    • @kshitijkumar5629
      @kshitijkumar5629 Рік тому +2

      Exactly, blinded by patriotism could have killed even the Einstein in Germany by Hitler

  • @evm6177
    @evm6177 2 роки тому +6

    Even in Kerala, Nambi case is such a confusing conspiracy.. 🙏Thanks to this channel we finally got the full unfiltered picture literally. America does not let anyone grow.. their dirty politics with help of local goons proven again. The Smart West made profit we again suffer losses.

  • @petrichor259
    @petrichor259 2 роки тому +26

    If Nambi decided to stay at NASA ,he could have had an awesome professional life but he didnt and came back to India to serve the nation and look how he was treated.😢

  • @SILOPshuvambanerjee
    @SILOPshuvambanerjee 2 роки тому +18

    Whenever I see this my head bows in shame. God bless him.

  • @roshansherigar2000
    @roshansherigar2000 2 роки тому

    Thank you for bringing out this story!

  • @PARTHPATEL-vk4cs
    @PARTHPATEL-vk4cs 2 роки тому +16

    This happens in the state of 100% educated people. He refuses nasa offer how he can chit India
    Not only nabi sir so many isro scientists killed during Congress government

    • @diya1113
      @diya1113 2 роки тому +1

      in past kerala wasnt that well off u kno

    • @asmitasinha6547
      @asmitasinha6547 2 роки тому +3

      @@diya1113 Kerela is anti India or more I say Anti Hindu. They are worst than Taliban and Jihadis. They must leave India

    • @godsdaughter22222
      @godsdaughter22222 2 роки тому

      S

    • @godisincontrol6753
      @godisincontrol6753 2 роки тому

      @@asmitasinha6547 ....who are you to say that! You are a immigrant from afganistan. U are the one must leave here

    • @asmitasinha6547
      @asmitasinha6547 2 роки тому +2

      @@godisincontrol6753 I am an full fledged Indian by birth. And I have heard and read countless times about how Arrogant Kerelites literally reject anything our govt does. And how Horribly they treat North Indians and Hindus. My father got a posting in Kerela , but he returned only after 3 months. Almost every single time he described how Horribly North Indians are treated there😠😠.
      He said he didn't felt like he was in India at all.
      INSTEAD OF SHOUTING AT ME YOU SHOULD DO SOME RESEARCH ABOUT HOW MUCH KERELITES HATE WE NORTH INDIANS, INDIAN GOVT , HINDUS😠😠😠😠

  • @kuriankuri
    @kuriankuri 2 роки тому +122

    Kerala's main media groups played a greater role in the downfall of former CM K.Karunakaran,,

    • @BUSSIDGamingKerala
      @BUSSIDGamingKerala 2 роки тому +18

      Yes. It is a clear example of Newspaper's/Media's power in falling of Government.

    • @arunpaul2587
      @arunpaul2587 Рік тому +3

      Please name and shame Kerala's main media groups.

    • @RajeshChandran81
      @RajeshChandran81 Рік тому +4

      @@arunpaul2587 Malayala Manorama...

    • @sreekanths18
      @sreekanths18 Рік тому +2

      Manorama worked for Chandy

  • @n.s.shankar
    @n.s.shankar 2 роки тому +77

    Now iam thinking that are there any more people like this who have suffered and how many more such scientists and wizards were destroyed this way.

  • @sameersharma3600
    @sameersharma3600 2 роки тому +1

    *You Just Nailed it,Keep it Up Politics Should be kept out from Atleast Sectors like Defence, Space research etc* 😍😀

  • @pakaboss007
    @pakaboss007 Рік тому +5

    Watched Rocketry yesterday. Feeling ashamed as Indian. I also declining career opportunities in US just to serve my country and pay all the hefty Tax but looks like it will just fill the pockets of our bloody Politicians. 😞

  • @abhirajarora7631
    @abhirajarora7631 2 роки тому +49

    I love how the State Of Kerala dropped charges against the police officers who falsely implicated Mr. Narayan. That mleccha, Sybi Matthews went on to become Chief Information Commissioner of Kerala. Truly God's own country. What a wonderful police system of the superior Mallus. If it hadn't been for the Supreme Court of India, these sh*ts would have walked free.

    • @vishnuvm5133
      @vishnuvm5133 2 роки тому +11

      True... Political dramas in kerala makes many lives suffer on that time.

    • @diya1113
      @diya1113 2 роки тому +1

      back in the days kerala politics was more of this drama.. even now its not so better

    • @gavaskarreddy6911
      @gavaskarreddy6911 Рік тому +5

      Actually Nambi was a victim of Hinduphobia. Believe it or not.

    • @foxnevertelllies77
      @foxnevertelllies77 Рік тому +3

      @@gavaskarreddy6911
      ISRO Espionage Case was a political drama, masterminded by rivals of K.Karunakaran,from his own Congress Party.
      Mainly 2 persons were severely affected by this Espionage case-
      K. Karunakaran & NambiNarayanan.

  • @chandrashekarhb9349
    @chandrashekarhb9349 2 роки тому +89

    This is the respect scientists gets in this Country.

    • @shockwavevideos5689
      @shockwavevideos5689 Рік тому +1

      Well the centeral agency proved him innocent. The state investigation agency was corrupted. This is not 100% what the whole country represent. Just that corruption in those days was way too high and Kerala has a history of doing such bad things. Stop blaming the country and start blaming the actual culprits

    • @minhazgoldar6889
      @minhazgoldar6889 Рік тому

      @@shockwavevideos5689 kerala is a lot better now,atleast better than the northern states of India.

    • @ayushimishra8273
      @ayushimishra8273 10 місяців тому

      ​@@minhazgoldar6889Are you joking ?? Kerala still has lots of scams !!

  • @perfectuniverse4048
    @perfectuniverse4048 Рік тому +2

    Make rocketry movie a success.... That is the real respect we show to Mr Nambi Narayanan sir. Such brilliant scientist how badly he was treated.... Please guys this movies success is Nambi sirs success

  • @livenletlive826
    @livenletlive826 Рік тому

    Excellent video! Nice way of explainning through graphics! Keep it up! Greetings from PANAMA!

  • @sreeram4964
    @sreeram4964 2 роки тому +44

    Those politicians behind this is still enjoying positions and respect.

  • @Kanonymous-gj9pr
    @Kanonymous-gj9pr 2 роки тому +50

    This is why talented and smart Indians go to foreign countries to work. 😔

    • @ramyamohan1918
      @ramyamohan1918 Рік тому +3

      After watching the movie my son saying mom never love your country and work for your country. The If this is the case of indian scientists Who will work for india.

    • @chandrashekarbasuviaha6539
      @chandrashekarbasuviaha6539 Рік тому +1

      and they don't even like to come back and settle down there.

    • @Cookwithruchi7887
      @Cookwithruchi7887 Рік тому

      Curruption and bad politics destroy my country

  • @RK-in3iu
    @RK-in3iu 2 роки тому +8

    Indians love having masala in their life rather than watching something that actually helps them. That's the reason Nambi and several others were unsung.

  • @MrSandeepmukherjee
    @MrSandeepmukherjee 2 роки тому

    Awesome presentation....you deserve all praise

  • @navrangarajan8642
    @navrangarajan8642 2 роки тому +67

    Eagerly waiting for Madhavan's movie Rocketry to show his story!!!

  • @sanvithmurari2252
    @sanvithmurari2252 2 роки тому +18

    Interesting and informative. Never heard about This. Thank you a lot bisbo.

  • @doctorsdiary8741
    @doctorsdiary8741 9 місяців тому

    Thank you so much, for explaining these topics

  • @satyambalhotra1076
    @satyambalhotra1076 2 роки тому

    this channel provide us a knowledgeable news in clear-cut way only in short duration without any mixture and boringness.

  • @jjjj123kkkk
    @jjjj123kkkk 2 роки тому +33

    I was a kid back then, very faintly i remember him being taken to court. Thanks for putting up the details as i was not so keen on watching the movie. Why are some people of our country always sold out to money and sex. At least Nambi sir survived, thinking of Sushanth Singh still brings sadness on my face.

  • @jey2275
    @jey2275 2 роки тому +27

    Kerela's inhuman treatment of suspects are well known .

    • @sujitmemane
      @sujitmemane 2 роки тому

      like?

    • @jey2275
      @jey2275 2 роки тому +1

      @@sujitmemane that of Amir UL Islam .

    • @jey2275
      @jey2275 2 роки тому +3

      @v p not that better UP is horrific

    • @ChoCoMoCo69
      @ChoCoMoCo69 2 роки тому +2

      @@jey2275 I don't think so it is a Hindi speaking state that's why it's always on news.

    • @Nirmalkvarghese
      @Nirmalkvarghese 2 роки тому +1

      North Indian sangi

  • @h.6725
    @h.6725 Рік тому +2

    👏👏 quality investigation 👏👏
    (Sarcastic).

  • @giornogiovanna4117
    @giornogiovanna4117 2 роки тому +8

    This is india’s most literate state 😂

    • @giornogiovanna4117
      @giornogiovanna4117 2 роки тому

      @NinjA 4otnite! weebo? Tf is that??

    • @ke4827
      @ke4827 2 роки тому +3

      They are so literate that they can't stand other religions and want to convert everyone to Islam or Christianity. So much for being " liberal" and " educated".

    • @asmitasinha6547
      @asmitasinha6547 2 роки тому +1

      @@ke4827 KERELITES WERE FIRST BRITISH AND NOT ISLAMIST AND CHRISTIAN SLAVES. THEY WERE THE ONES WHO WERE DEMANDING FOR A SEPARATE SOUTH😠😠😠😠

    • @godisincontrol6753
      @godisincontrol6753 2 роки тому

      @@asmitasinha6547 ....if u are unhappy make a seperate north India

    • @asmitasinha6547
      @asmitasinha6547 2 роки тому

      @@godisincontrol6753 WHY SHOULD WE?? WE FOUGHT SO HARD FOR MANY CENTURIES TO LIBERATE AND UNIFY OUR COUNTRY. WE NORTH INDIANS LOVE OUR INDIA. U SOUTH INDIANS LOVE UR COLONIAL MASTERS. U GUYS LEAVE.

  • @ShivamGupta_15
    @ShivamGupta_15 2 роки тому +17

    फौज :- हमें कांग्रेस ने रोका
    वैज्ञानिक :- हमें कांग्रेस ने रोका
    आतंकी :- बिल्कुल झूठ ! हमें तो कांग्रेस ने कभी नहीं रोका |

  • @UMESHPILANIA
    @UMESHPILANIA 2 роки тому +43

    You are doing an amazing job!
    One thing I can tell you, we still have not learned from this, People don't care about national interests when it comes to political benefits even now, Sometimes I feel sad about it, Even now if you raise your voice, You'll be associated with some or the other political party without understanding the importance of the issue!

    • @akhileshkhadseofficial
      @akhileshkhadseofficial 2 роки тому

      And It's been on rise since the Right wing part got reinstated....

    • @cyclix5314
      @cyclix5314 2 роки тому +4

      @@akhileshkhadseofficial It's been existing since way before buddy

    • @UMESHPILANIA
      @UMESHPILANIA 2 роки тому +7

      @@akhileshkhadseofficial I didn’t know that there was a right-wing government in Kerala when this incident happened!

    • @ramanujsingh1663
      @ramanujsingh1663 2 роки тому

      @@UMESHPILANIA There was a Communist Government in Kerala during Nambi case

  • @ramyavenkatesh4452
    @ramyavenkatesh4452 Рік тому +1

    That is WHY we settle in different country. INDIANS WILL NEVER THINK FREELY, AND WILL JUMP INTO CONCLUSIONS IN A HEART BEAT. Media will shatter India.

  • @sumanagarwal1450
    @sumanagarwal1450 Рік тому

    Very well researched real story. Kudos!

  • @shaikshafi1284
    @shaikshafi1284 2 роки тому +5

    These type of things just make question government police and now we can't even understand what is happening in CBI we need unbiased news ❤️❤️ thanks bisbo

  • @spoidy_
    @spoidy_ 2 роки тому +167

    Those who are waiting for rocketry movie 👇👇 ❤️❤️

    • @harshitbaboo7221
      @harshitbaboo7221 2 роки тому +1

      Is it based on this??

    • @ManiKandan-dv8uo
      @ManiKandan-dv8uo 2 роки тому +2

      @@harshitbaboo7221 yes directed and acted by actor R.Madhavan

    • @vinayakk2745
      @vinayakk2745 2 роки тому +4

      @@harshitbaboo7221 yes! That movie's trailer brought light over this, very few people knew about it earlier.

    • @Critique007
      @Critique007 2 роки тому

      That movie will be a trash..judging from the trailer quality.

  • @HarishKumar-ye1jd
    @HarishKumar-ye1jd Рік тому +2

    ISRO should have indipendent enquiry body like armed force. To avoid political influence against arresting Scientist Nambinarayan.

  • @Just_forfun9140
    @Just_forfun9140 Рік тому +5

    Justice system need reforms:
    1. Detainees should treated as innocent until proven guilty by courts.
    2. Police should be prohibited from beating or mistreating detainees guilty or not.
    3. In this video, the police officer who made moves on the detained woman for her favors, what happened to him?

  • @arjungowda2146
    @arjungowda2146 2 роки тому +8

    I'll never jump to conclusions without having much data especially on social media

  • @ravikrishna9490
    @ravikrishna9490 2 роки тому +12

    Got to know the case in simple manner, thanks for the video.

  • @abhishekmishra5936
    @abhishekmishra5936 2 роки тому

    Thank you bro for this real life story.

  • @kshitijasingh1065
    @kshitijasingh1065 Рік тому

    Wow amazing man. So sorry on behalf of our countrymen/govt.

  • @siddharthkishan9989
    @siddharthkishan9989 2 роки тому +3

    Was waiting for this story... great work Bisbo like always 👍

  • @DEEPANJANBISWAS
    @DEEPANJANBISWAS 2 роки тому +52

    The case could not have taken its blown out proportions without media trials. Same happened in SSR case any many more. There should be a law to prevent media from giving verdict themselves for an undertrial case

  • @janakigopalan1992
    @janakigopalan1992 Рік тому +1

    My heart aches that a sincere, patriotic, intelligent , spiritual Nambi Sir had to go through this. May Goddess Bhagavathy punish the criminals.

  • @avinashpoojary2970
    @avinashpoojary2970 2 роки тому

    Justice must be given to Mr.Nambi, after such cruel plots.

  • @harishkotian9694
    @harishkotian9694 2 роки тому +4

    Brilliant as always, Always a clear cut winner between all articles.😘🙏

  • @TheThinkPlace
    @TheThinkPlace 2 роки тому +17

    Hardest of punishment should be given to those Police Officers they have committed crime against every Indians.....They are the traitors and Nambi Narayanan is a true patriot

  • @aashvisworld3192
    @aashvisworld3192 2 роки тому

    Very detailed and interesting comic videos ! 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

  • @varunthedoc
    @varunthedoc Рік тому +4

    Moral of the story … accept jobs in USA without thinking twice

  • @asanjeev003
    @asanjeev003 2 роки тому +6

    Really appreciate the detiled research on the stories!

  • @atharvchavan544
    @atharvchavan544 2 роки тому +4

    Thnks bisbo for such videos. Newspapers were too vague something on this. Was too lazy to google

  • @kuppusamyrajaram5551
    @kuppusamyrajaram5551 Рік тому

    🙏 Excellent synopsis of the case. Intelligent people shall not be innocent!!??

  • @syedsahir1136
    @syedsahir1136 Рік тому +1

    This is how India's Development is Setback by Decades compared to other nations, who knows how many such corrupt activities people have done for their own profit and power and were not disclosed in public. My heartfelt respect for Nambi.

  • @VATSSAMEER
    @VATSSAMEER 2 роки тому +5

    You have such an amazing storytelling skills.. the video catalogue that you have already is so interesting !! Hats off team _/\_

  • @amulchowdary755
    @amulchowdary755 2 роки тому +6

    every time you blow our mind with your content and creativity, Love your video bisbo keep it up and keep bringing new content to us. lot of love from your fan. :)

    • @BisboWorld
      @BisboWorld  2 роки тому

      We're glad to hear it Amul!

  • @ayushiparsheera
    @ayushiparsheera 2 роки тому

    Great channel. Thankyou .. So viewer friendly ..news coveragr

  • @ramanagoud7860
    @ramanagoud7860 Рік тому +1

    Great gift for his patriotism to the country!!

  • @thecodinghotel1791
    @thecodinghotel1791 2 роки тому +3

    never heard about this, thank you for this video