The only objective, balanced, and well researched documentary on the Israel-Palestinian conflict and i am not surprised it was made in the 90s by PBS when I was not even born. to find a documentary like this in current year is almost impossible.
''"our airfields are being attacked!" "what the hell are you talking about?" "our airfields are being attacked!" "our airfields?" "the airfields in the sinai are being attacked" "all the sinai airfields?" "believe me, all the airfields are being attacked" *hangs up* *phone rings again* *picks up* ”our airfields are beings attacked!" So then i said to myself, well, something must be going on."''
*ring ring* The CIA: "The Russians have invaded Lithuania." Trump: "The Russians have invaded Lithuania?" The CIA: "Yes they've invaded Lithuania." ... ... Trump: "Maybe it was CHINA" *Trump hangs up phone*
I am not a Jew or a supporter but if the Arabs went to the UN meeting in 1947 and did not attack them it would not be a problem today.. they would be living together in peace..
I am an Arab and the Western world against us because I am Muslims, America, Britain, our religion, and ignited wars, we have the foundations in Palestine, our holy sites, the Mosque of Al-Qasi in Palestine, 1400 years old.
How do we know that you're telling the truth. You see when your religion lets you lie. Non-Muslims never know what games you're playing. Big problem my friend.سعود العتيبي
Oh poor HRH King Hussein constantly shafted and lied to, always arguably losing the most in the Six day war and October war. Real shame. May he rest in peace
Can you imagine being the general of an army that was exponentially superior in almost every regard and yet suffed a humiliating obliteration because ofa brilliantly executed stealth attack ?!? That has to be one of the most tragic emotions a person could ever face in their lifetime.
I'm not sure it was superior in every regard. Didn't American intelligence tell the Israelis that, even if the Egyptians attacked first, the Israelis would win in "a bit longer than 7 days"? I think the implication was that the Israelis had a superior fighting force that, regardless of the actual order of events, would come out on top.
The Israelis didn't receive any help from the US in 1967. The Americans told them, if you go it alone (which they did), "you're on your own." The US was selling Israel arms from a few years before, but active military support (i.e. financial support to purchase weapons) and intelligence-sharing didn't start until a few years later. I think everyone was a bit surprised at how Israel decided to just go ahead and do the thing itself, as the film shows.
@@t33nyplaysp0p If you check history records re aid given to both sides since Israel was granted their rightful land, it's just about the same. One group became self sufficient an created a meaningful, desirable democracy...the other spaffed their aid up the wall on weapons, tunnels, bombs and acts of terror
The problem with this documentary is not so much that the information is inaccurate as the gentleman below claims, but that it lacks context. The seeds for today's conflict in Israel and indeed the entire Middle East lie in the post-WW1 settlement. That's the starting point, not the end of WW2. For those interested, Google these three terms: 'McMahon Correspondence' 1915, 'Sykes-Picot Agreement' 1916 and 'Balfour Declaration' 1917.
I'm amazed at all of the various pressures King Hussein of Jordan faced in his life, and all of the different interests he had to juggle. It's obvious that at a lot of points he did things he didn't want to do, and that he thought were incredibly misguided or even foolish, because he had to -- mostly to maintain credibility with fellow Arab leaders and to satisfy the "Arab street."
@mikealvord55 well if you keep grabbing more land then you can extend your 'border buffers' I guess Poland was a 'border buffer' for Germany. See how asinine that sounds?
@mikealvordif if you want proper border buffers ask certain zones to be demilitarized and allow the UN to occupy them like they have before. That way if one side attacks through the dmz the other has ample time for a counter that would disable their opponent. It's that's simple, yet Israel consistently refuses to do that. Almost like they want more land lol
Read the Hadith re rocks and trees calling out to Mulsims, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him - not an atrocity? basis for peace? brotherly love?
The rivalry between Jacob and Esau will never end till the God of Jacob returns to make all things right. Esau's god, the false idol of Islam & his false prophet of hate will fall and must kneel and acknowledge the God of Israel as God.
I wonder if this documentary was aired on BBC (or perhaps an Arab language station that could've been pirated in England, sans voiceover) as I recognize a lot of clips from this used as samples by Manchester musician Bryn Jones alias Muslimgauze
1:51:03 this clip of Habash speaking is used at the end of Muslimgauze track "State of Palestine" (ua-cam.com/video/BIEMU7OJ7QQ/v-deo.html) WITHOUT the English voiceover, very interesting! I wonder where Mr. Jones could have sourced such a thing
Egypt and Jordan controlled Gaza and the West Bank for 20 yrs prior to 1967. Why didn't they grant Palestinians independence then? Meanwhile Israel is supposed to give land to a people who murdered their athletes, even handicapped hostages like Leon KLINGHOFFER.. a people who rejected the initial partition and tried everything to destroy Israel and pursue a vicious propaganda even though Jews technically never left Israel since the time of Jesus. Yes, the Romans exiled most Jews but there was always a presence there, even when the Crusaders arrived there.
"The British washed their hands of it." Hysterical. Considering the Brits promised a free Palestine while announcing the Balfour Declaration at the same time.
Palestinian Arabs is the right term, if not simply Arabs, almost all of them descendants of the Conquests of Islam that invaded and occupied East Roman and Persian territory.
What the IDF is engaged in is exactly what Nazi troops were doing in the early days of the notorious Warsaw Ghetto, when Jews from captured Poland were herded into a walled-off part of the city and left to starve in its confines. If the captive Jews in that ghetto in the early days of its existence had chosen to mass in protest at their wall, they would have been mowed down in the same way that the IDF is slaughtering Palestinian protesters. Instead they tried to survive as best as they could by paying to have food smuggled in to them. Only later, as their captivity dragged on and as the Nazi mass extermination campaign began, did some organize a heroic campaign of armed resistance against their captors.
Egypt made some suprising strikes on Israel,as they outnumber Jewishmilitary by about 10-1,However,Israel always prevails,according to God's Promise.early in the 40's[before my time]the Egyptians reported[en masse]about seeing thousands of soldiers on Jewish side.This was a supernatural act.Missionaries and schoolchildren have re[ported similiar visions of armies "in white"No army has ever worn white uniforms.Consider the 4 jet strike on Saddams reactor.Similiar experiences by Filipino terrorists in their jungle /hostages.There's SO many.google and read about many more.This isnt sensationalisms,but facts.Genesis 12:3 holds true forever@@omalone1169
Arabs have still not accepted the existence of Israel on 26.000 km2, even if themselves have occupied some 10 million km2 outside the Arab peninsula that covers 3 million km2.
Arafat accepted Israeli during Oslo Accords. Israel never complied with their end of the bargain. And who cares how big or small it is? It was stolen. Why should Palestinians pay for the Holocaust? That’s the question we should all be asking.
back in the day Yasser Arafat looked a hell of a lot like Ringo Starr come to think of it I've never seen them together I wonder why that is and could Arafat keep the beat or could Ringo field strip an ak-47 man I gotta lay off the plant vapors starting to get squirrely
the Palestinians recurrently attacking Israel would be like if the Confederate Army lost the war, and then kept on attacking the Union Army for the next 100 years, and many Union soldiers were off-the-boat Europeans who basically weren't even American, they were technically foreign fighters fighting for the Union cause.
@Danielesalsa543 you're correct, because the confederacy was never supplied with massive amount of arms from the UK, the leading super power at the time.
The problem is that everyone that is religious believes that god is with them. What will hold you all together when you realize there is no such thing as god?
Roosje Keizer Typical western christian behavior.calling Allah as"moon god"?dumb ass do you even know basic of islam so stfu.stupid people of trinity.you all cant even prove trinity. 1+1+1=1 like wtf.bible is a corrupt book
Why not explain the San Remo Resolution which gave the Jews their Jewish state along with all the Arabs their own countries in the middle east? Unless you understand this important piece of international law then you make assumptions and mistakes in thinking the Arabs have a right to any Israeli land.
I realize there are strong feelings but the two state solution was for the Arabs to move to Jordan. That was the original deal that was not honoured. The Arabs that remained were to fully integrate into Israeli society. Seems simple enough.
News flash.....Israel became a nation under international law in 1948. It used to be a nation prior then Rome spread the Jews to the wind after the revolt around 70 AD. There has never been a country called Palestine. The Roman Emperor Hadrian changed the name of the region from "Judea" to "Syria Palestinia" in the 2nd century to insult the Jews. Israel is a Jewish state among 50 plus Muslim states. What is your problem? You hate freedom and the rights of a country to defend and develop itself? Israel existed before Rome and Greek empires. They were a country, had a monarchy and made their own money. Archaeology has long proved this as fact. I guess you just hate Jews and facts.
The land belongs to the Jews just as the land belongs to Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and others. If Israel cannot exist neither can these others because the same international law implemented the right to exist for all of these countries.
Science Magazine "Modern Jews may traditionally trace their ancestry to the Holy Land, but a new genetic study finds otherwise. A detailed look at thousands of genomes finds that Ashkenazim-who make up roughly 80% of the world’s Jews, including 90% of those in America and half of those in Israel-ultimately came not from the Middle East, but from Western Europe, perhaps Italy."
your point? Are the Italians of today genetically related to the ancient Romans and Etruscans? Are the current day Japanese people genetically related to the original Jomon people who lived in the archipelago before? Are any of the Bantu people in central and sub-saharan Africa related to the non-bantu inhabitants they displaced?
@@hafsaisam141 Oh, I agree. The Palestinians are basically Arabs. Arabs and Jews are Semitic peoples from the middle east. So, quite frankly all sides have some claim there but so far, Israel is the only one who can actually back it up with not just genetics but economic and military force. This whole war is just nothing but a long-standing blood/tribal feud between various native tribes😒😒Nothing new for the Middle East.
This is factually incorrect. 60% of Jews worldwide are of Middle Eastern origin. The Jews who lived in Europe all came from expulsions from the Roman Empire and spread all over Europe.
If both side haven't done such dirty things and kept small but true efforts to make peace would have led to peace ..may be not in a day but in few years ..
Although clearly pro-israel, still very accurate. One only has to look at history to see that Israel has the right to the land. From a Biblical perspective there is no doubt.
Truly, these showed who's the devil and instigators . The bad and the good.. Sadly, it's the people who suffered the most . Worst of all , there won't be peace because of hate and pride of these leaders and the negative propaganda .
Basa could have agreed to recognise Israel and when Israel left the Sinai he could have said "You know when I said I agree to recognise Israel well I actually LAID."
Video is ludicrously biased. 1) The video announces its bias right off the bat by referring to the region as "Palestine". There is no such thing as "Palestine". The term was invented by the Romans and used by the British Crusaders to remove the Jewish connection with the region and delegitimize Judaism and the Jewish state. 2) The Arabs do not and have never seen Palestine as "a home". They see it as land that was ruled by Muslims at some point and must remain so. When the State of Israel was formed, the Arabs already living there were offered to stay on under Jewish majority rule. Those who accepted are now the happiest and wealthiest Arabs in the entire Middle East because they live as citizens in a Western democracy. The issue at stake was not their "home" but Arab rule over it. 3) *It's a complete and total LIE to say that the Arabs "wanted nothing to do with the Jews".* The reality is that the Quran says that Jews and other "unbelievers" must live under Islamic rule with no rights and pay a special Jizya tax, just for being of a different religion (Surah 9:29). This was the relationship a million Jews living in Arab lands had to endure and that the Arabs sought to keep. This is why the Arabs found the prospect of a free Israel - and also a free Kurdistan, Lebanon, Armenia, etc - so offensive...they wanted Kurds, Druze, Christians, Jews, and everyone else who wasn't Arab Muslim to have no rights and accept total domination by Sunni Islam. 4) "The innocent" by and large did not "suffer with the guilty". The British were attacked because they had no business being in the region in the first place. The Arabs were attacked because they attacked Jewish children and anyone else they thought couldn't fight back, and that is why Jewish schoolbuses of the time had to have wire mesh windows, and why Arab villages ultimately had to be removed - they wouldn't stop attacking Jewish settlements. The goal here is to bring Jewish activities into the region down to the level of Hamas and the PLO that deliberately killed as many innocent people as possible and for the purpose of causing as much terror and mayhem as possible, in an effort to turn a bad cause into a good one. 5) The "illegal immigrants" were travelling to a region that their ancestors were from, for the reason they were being mass-murdered in Europe because...wait for it...they were perceived as "Orientals"! You're really going to have to explain to me how a colonial power with no legitimate claim on the region and a bunch of Arabs who migrated there after the Mohammedean conquests in the 10th century get to decide who is "legal" and who is not. The conflict is not about land or peace or what have you. The conflict is mostly about Arab Muslim bigotry and their insistence on blaming Israel for everything from poverty to the weather to shark attacks off the coast of Egypt. Israel as a country the size of New Hampshire existing in a region several times the size of the continental US is only controversial because of the Jews living on it and no other reason. This video is Stockholm Syndrome garbage of presuming the Arab claims are something other than lies and bigotry because there's 500 million of them, they have oil, and they're willing to use terrorism against civilians to achieve their goals.
Aeschlimann1 Might doesn't make right. Neither do raw numbers. In spite of the fact those Muslims do nothing but make babies then try to pass this off as a basis to make demands.
Ethan Farber Actually majority rules, that's what democracy is. Maybe if Jews hadn't been inbred for 7 centuries their birth rates can keep up. I happen to know many Jewish couples who can't conceive children because those children die of defects. Any arguments of yours to the contrary state that Jews are higher quality people than Muslims and should be given extra-representative exception. From my Anglo Saxon point of view, it's ludicrous to be Jewish and to think you're a higher quality human being than Muslims. Ludicrous. You're equal, believe me.
Aeschlimann1 When you get democracy working in ANY Islamic country, you can talk about how you think it works. You are confusing democracy with tyranny of the majority. Functional democracies operate on the principle that rule of the majority is balanced against rights of the minority. In point of fact, the cultural inability to comprehend that principle is why Islamic countries and Arab ones especially struggle with democracy and have never gotten it to work properly.
@@joemagnets9940 he is saying it wasn't a nation they were ottoman Turks witch also committed genocide in ww1 so they have to pay war reparations as the law states
They were unarmed in Europe. They came with arms to Israel. Every human being was under the forces of State level mobilization during the Second World War. Where they ended up was in large part a matter of personal luck when it came to top-level strategies and government official discretion.
How come the Palestine Arabs did not protest the British arbitrary creation of what is known as JORDAN, out of almost EIGHTY PER CENT OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS PALESTINIAN MANDATE...!!!!!!!!
alright at the same time Israel was voted a state by the west ,so were arab nations invented by the same western nation ,only Israel was compensation for Christian and muslim atrocities ,while arab lands were invented in exchange of oil
+Compact Jam All so-called Palestinians are Arab. The Palestinian Liberation Organization killed about 500,000 Arab Christians during their bloody takeover of Lebanon. The purpose of the term "Palestine" is to delegitimize Israel and the Jewish people, and that is also why the term was invented by the Romans and later used by the British who had no legitimate claim on the region either.
Compact Jam According to the agreement you are citing, Palestine was to be the Jewish half of Transjordan. The other half of Transjordan, the Kingdom of Jordan, had a charter banning Jews from entering the country. Israel is Palestine. Palestine is Israel. The Arab "Palestine" is Jordan.
+Compact Jam The McMahon - Hussein correspondences were quite clear that the land promised to the Hashemites did not include land west of the Syria vilayet. Palestine that is located south west was not included. Hussein contested this interpretation and the issue was resolved by the British white paper that was acceptable to all parties. Palestine was not promised to thhe Arabs ever!!!
+Compact Jam STFU???? well I won't. The Zionists accepted the UN partition and declared independence of the state of Israel withni those borders. They (we) were grateful. The Arabs were also offered statehood within the remainder of the land west of the Jordan river. They gambled on it and lost. They had to learn the hard way that war is indeed a gamble.... a game of poker. When you loose money on the hand that you are holding, no one can take you seriously if you start shouting that you were robbed.
Compact Jam You said in another post that I need historical facts rammed down my throat.... so show me some historic facts in the nonsense that you brought here. 1. Citizens of Palestine..... since up to 1948 Palestine is the name that The UN gave to the British and French mandate, Jews were also citizens of Palestine. Now this is a non-debatable historic fact. 2. According to the British census in Palestine in 1947, there were 630 thousand Jews, 123 thousand Christians and 1080 thousand Muslims. I don't know where info comes from but it is not based on anything factual and historically viable source. 3. Christians were massacred and driven off!!!! Your turn to show me some sound historic evidence. No one was massacred!!! Any one who took arms against the Jewish population in Palestine risked and sometimes got his aggression rammed down his throat. Those who did not get involved in aggression are still living honorably in Israel today as full citizens. In 1929 hundreds of Jews (mostly uninvolved and defenseless people who lived in Safed and Hebron were massacred by Arabs (christians included). Jews hit back and some Arabs (Christians included) were hit. In 1948 following Israel's declaration of independence, Arabs declared a war of attrition on Israel. Christians sided with their Muslim "brothers" and shared the same fate of defeat. 4. Jewish communities were murdered by Zionists???? show me where your sources are for this obnoxious claim or shut up fool. If brain is what you have then thank God I don't have one. What you have is mental diarrhea.
Israel is the land of the Hebrews, the Jews, The Israelies, The Cananites. It is not a land of Palestenians. Go and find out where did these peoples originally come from which they call them Palestenians?
Prophecy throughout the Bible proves both God's divinity and the divine origin of His Word. We dont devote our lives as Christians to nicey nice things, hoping in blind faith.
Also if anyone is interested, Al Jeezra made an excellent and from i could tell wholly truthful 3 part documentary on the October war. Aka Yom Kippur war/ Ramadan war
The atrocities mentioned in this particular clip have been carried out on the 7th of October every item mentioned in this documentary was perpetrated against the Jews I'm wondering if in fact truth was ever disclosed amongst these people. I'm wondering whether or not the Palestinians were actually notified about the deception and the lie that was perpetrated by the powers that be in the Palestinian government and that's the reason why it's been carried in the hearts and minds of the Palestinians for 70+ years. To be a Avenged now?
Going political. If asked in 1948, I would say Israel was an Illegal state. If asked today I would say it is not. History and time forces sovereignty. There is no discussion today if the American colonies have a right to self governance.
Lol Illegal? The only Jewish majority country in the world (There are 50+ Muslim majority countries. Israel was put to a vote by the entire United Nations, who voted FOR the establishment of a Jewish State. The United States was completely "illegal" in breaking off from British rule and in ethnically cleansing the native population.
Say the Jews had historical ties to Bavaria, what right does the UN have to succeed one of 50+ German provinces to another people? It does not matter that hundreds of thousands of Jews recently immigrated back to Bavaria. It is still Bavaria.
The UN has no right to dictate to the sovereign nation of Israel anything. The UN is the Beast system. The US needs to get out and stop funding it. It is an antisemite satanic establishment.
The UN, with all its authority does not always have the moral high-ground. It was just an agreement between states and many were missing in 1947. Not to mention the unfortunate artificial construct of states to come. Considering that Jews and Europe have a integrated history, they should be allowed to live across the whole continent unmolested. What justification is there to create a minority state in Europe today. For a said people who would not even be a majority there? What do you tell the native people? Though luck? As for Palestine then, not now. Just because the population demography experienced recent change and the land had not seen self-rule for centuries. Does not give a minority rights to create a new state based on ancient land-rights and scripture. Such silly notions taken seriously would give almost any nation on the planet a moral casus-belli for land grabs. Chaos. And we have seen it come to be. As for those who say that the oppressors owe the oppressed. I would agree, but not to the expense of an entire unrelated people.
I'm wondering why since the danger in Germany was over they didn't just leave them in Germany.That's where they had chosen to live before the shit hit the fan. Putting them down in a desert wasteland doesn't seem to make a lot of sense at this point in history.
@@markmcelroy1872 That was a good answer. Your peoples experience seems to parallel those of black people in America. I remember my mother who was in NY telling me that there were beaches and other places closed off to Jews. This was in the 1920's. America was also that prejudice toward the Irish and Catholics. You may onto something. I also had a college instructor who did his Phd. work on the topic of anti-antisemitism in European Folk Tales.which does give some indication to me of the long held prejudice against Jews.in Europe and in the U.S. I am in favor of welcoming anyone until they harm me. At that point I am prejudiced against the individual in the future. But I do not become prejudice against all of his family or tribe. That would not make sense. Likewise it does not make sense to trust someone who has done you wrong. That's stupid. Thanks for talking to me, God bless and I wish you the best, but I wish that for everyone.
@@markmcelroy1872 Your decision is one of forgiveness. Forgiveness is sometimes the only thing that can open up the possibility of a cooperative future. It is true on personal levels and we are all in the end just 'people' and we experience things personally. If we, as the human race, understood this and forgave each other can you imagine what would happen? There's a scene in a Clint Eastwood movie, "The Unforgiven" The conversation had been about injustice an one actor mentioned that 'they had it coming'. The reply was 'We all have it coming'? I accept that because I know I have hurt people by being a shit head. I cringe sometimes when I remember, But I'm glad I remember because I don't want to do it again. That's why we need to forgive each other because we all have it coming. And what is coming is the harvest of our Karma. Thank you again.
The land you claim "belongs to the Palestinians" is the land of Judea, the original land of the Jews thousands of years ago. The entire Palestinian "cause" is flawed from the outset. There is no land to "return" to. There is no lost homeland, We call them “Palestinians”, a loose term for a collection of Arabs that squatted upon the land of Canaan in the 19th and 20th centuries. The Palestinian as a singular nationality is incorrect; "Palestinians" are in fact of Lebanese, Syrian, Egyptian, Jordanian, Turkish and probably Kurdish origins if their ancestry is traced back several generations. The name itself, "Palestine", is simply a British term denoting the region under British control during that time and stems from the Roman term “Syria Palaestina”, which originates with Herodotus’ The Histories. The region was formerly known as Judea. Thus, the identity of a Palestinian is itself a misnomer.
Yeah that’s why Al-Aqsa has been standing for 1400 years yet I don’t see a temple. There were barely over 20-30 thousands Jews in Palestine before the corrupt Balfour declaration.
You could say the same thing about most nation states. Germany was just a confederation of Germanic tribes prior to 1871. Heck, America was just a landing place for various European imagrants fused with ensalved Africans and marginalized natives. It's flawed to say that that a nation state isn't legitimate because its inhabitants don't have a common ancestry dating back to some benchmarked timeline.
Better tell the Americans who fund Israel that they aren't Americans and that America is just an invention of the squatters. The Native American tribes being the true indigenous people will need to help Israel instead. Oh wait, they have nothing, as the settlers/squatters in USA took everything from them. What you describe as squatting happens all over the world and is part of history for hundreds and thousands of years.
This is a fair documentary, I see a lot of Jewish folks can not handle the real truth, personally I could care a less a bout both sides, one is as bad as the other as far as I have seen in my 55 year life, there is just one thing that can not be denied, all the jewish people came from European Countries, when you say that , they love quoting scripture as if that condones what they have done, you immigrated to a Country, and yes it is a Country, people have lived there forever, and you simply took it by force, that is it in a nut shell, if you would have shared power with your Arab brothers, and yes you are weather you like it or not, you would not be in the mess for the last 70 years, you all lived together in peace in the old days of the lord, what seems to be the problem now. Oh ! I know, it is called apartheid Jewish style for the Arabs that once ran the place, if it was reversed, you would understand real fast why they blow shit up all the time, I would be a little angry myself. If this is how Gods chosen people behaves toward its fellow man, I am sure glad I am not a chosen people, I know I am going to heaven. as for you guys, well ! I guess you will find out when its your time, shit ,what would you do if you died and there is no God ! man did you guys fuck up big time. lol Oh and by the way, the Jewish people were the first terrorists, that is why the British left, another fact,The first P.M of Israel blew up the King David Hotel killing hundreds, another fact, but it worked for you guys, but when Arabs do it, holy shit! you guys act like this is new, lol, you people invented terrorism, so stop the with the hypocrisy and own up to it, just once, admit it. but I have never herd one of you to do that, to me that is a fanatical people. who did the exact same thing as the PLO to gain there objective, also has the lord returned ? according to scripture which you love to quote Israel should not exist until the lord returns, I must have missed the news. peace to all. again, I am on no ones side, I am merely stating fact. I love all races who are peaceful and go by the LAW ! not the Bible which was written by men, not God.
They shouldn't have been brought to Palestina in the first place. You should've shipped them to somewhere more empty, like the westcoast of Austrialia. Back then almost nobody lived there, and you wouldn't have pissed any religion off.
IDONTGETTHEPOINT what you and others here don't realize is that "Palestine/Israel" was not only a refuge for European Jews. There were hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees, if I remember correctly-it was over 3/4 million-who were forced from Arab lands and were only allowed in Israel. The situation historically and presently is so much more complex a picture than most people know, unless they've specifically researched the issue.
Nasser had rub the Jews from their properties and monies. The same as the ancient Egyptians kings had done to the Hebrews around Moses time. Please read the bible.
The only objective, balanced, and well researched documentary on the Israel-Palestinian conflict and i am not surprised it was made in the 90s by PBS when I was not even born. to find a documentary like this in current year is almost impossible.
When journalism was real.
Best documentary out there! Thanks for uploading
50:00 part 2?
Thank you for making this excellent documentary available!
''"our airfields are being attacked!"
"what the hell are you talking about?"
"our airfields are being attacked!"
"our airfields?"
"the airfields in the sinai are being attacked"
"all the sinai airfields?"
"believe me, all the airfields are being attacked"
*hangs up*
*phone rings again*
*picks up*
”our airfields are beings attacked!"
So then i said to myself, well, something must be going on."''
that is how i imagine trumps presidency
*ring ring*
The CIA: "The Russians have invaded Lithuania."
Trump: "The Russians have invaded Lithuania?"
The CIA: "Yes they've invaded Lithuania."
...
...
Trump: "Maybe it was CHINA"
*Trump hangs up phone*
Joshua Brooks Love this Lol
😂. Reminds me of ‘the monster that ate everybody’ from the Simpsons.
"But I was all alone"
This is one of the best documentaries I have ever seen about the subject.
King Hussein of Jordan seems like a pretty laid back kind of guy...
LOL that was both an unintended pun by kletterhase and a play on it with the truth by Popeye, funny. Abdullah II is the king of Jordan since 1999.
King Hussein of Jordan was a Fucking Swine Bastard. His SON is just like him (HIS DAD) & ALL THE ARAB KINGS & THE EMIRATES TOO!!!!
King Hussein wanted peace and probably would have recognized Israel when Israel was found ,he was a great leader
@@heyila Relax
King Hussein is king of hearts
I am not a Jew or a supporter but if the Arabs went to the UN meeting in 1947 and did not attack them it would not be a problem today.. they would be living together in peace..
I am an Arab and the Western world against us because I am Muslims, America, Britain, our religion, and ignited wars, we have the foundations in Palestine, our holy sites, the Mosque of Al-Qasi in Palestine, 1400 years old.
How do we know that you're telling the truth. You see when your religion lets you lie. Non-Muslims never know what games you're playing. Big problem my friend.سعود العتيبي
Respect yourself Religion of Islam does not lie Islam is a religion tolerant of all religions and for fun Shi Hua
سعود العتيبي Islam doesn't lie? Perhaps you should look at the doctrine of Taqiyya. Who do you think you're kidding?
Respect yourself
1:18 "our cars had gone, we had to hire taxis." Beautiful.
Oh poor HRH King Hussein constantly shafted and lied to, always arguably losing the most in the Six day war and October war. Real shame. May he rest in peace
Pray for the Peace of Israel
fuck phalestine!
Long live ISRAEL
True descendants of Abraham wouldn’t kill and pillar like the so called Jews of today. You are all fake and ARE NOT SEMITES!!!
These Europeans are NOT Jews. They’re are NOT Semites. Palestine belongs to Palestinians.
This aged
Can you imagine being the general of an army that was exponentially superior in almost every regard and yet suffed a humiliating obliteration because ofa brilliantly executed stealth attack ?!? That has to be one of the most tragic emotions a person could ever face in their lifetime.
Ya but that stealth attack was largely funded by the world's largest super power
I'm not sure it was superior in every regard. Didn't American intelligence tell the Israelis that, even if the Egyptians attacked first, the Israelis would win in "a bit longer than 7 days"? I think the implication was that the Israelis had a superior fighting force that, regardless of the actual order of events, would come out on top.
The Israelis didn't receive any help from the US in 1967. The Americans told them, if you go it alone (which they did), "you're on your own." The US was selling Israel arms from a few years before, but active military support (i.e. financial support to purchase weapons) and intelligence-sharing didn't start until a few years later. I think everyone was a bit surprised at how Israel decided to just go ahead and do the thing itself, as the film shows.
@@t33nyplaysp0p If you check history records re aid given to both sides since Israel was granted their rightful land, it's just about the same. One group became self sufficient an created a meaningful, desirable democracy...the other spaffed their aid up the wall on weapons, tunnels, bombs and acts of terror
The problem with this documentary is not so much that the information is inaccurate as the gentleman below claims, but that it lacks context. The seeds for today's conflict in Israel and indeed the entire Middle East lie in the post-WW1 settlement. That's the starting point, not the end of WW2. For those interested, Google these three terms: 'McMahon Correspondence' 1915, 'Sykes-Picot Agreement' 1916 and 'Balfour Declaration' 1917.
ISRAELI BELONGS TO THE ISRAELI! GET THAT TO YOUR SKULL.
I'm amazed at all of the various pressures King Hussein of Jordan faced in his life, and all of the different interests he had to juggle. It's obvious that at a lot of points he did things he didn't want to do, and that he thought were incredibly misguided or even foolish, because he had to -- mostly to maintain credibility with fellow Arab leaders and to satisfy the "Arab street."
1:47:09
Interesting to show King Hussein as a young man, start the story, and then cut to him many years older, finishing the story.
1:36:30 no peace
Wow best documentary 👏🏿
Dude, it slants left hard come come on the little research
So, the Palestinians broadcaster was not upset with the lie at 15.20. He was upset that the lie had the opposite effect.
Why did this documentary leave out the '73 war?
Have you seen part 2?
Есть хоть где то перевод этой документалки?
seriously interesting stuff, cant wait for part 2!
"We don't want any additional territory"
With Egypt and Jordan defeated, Israel then turned its attention to Syria and the Golan heights
You can’t be that big a simpleton! It’s border buffers not land grabs.
@mikealvord55 well if you keep grabbing more land then you can extend your 'border buffers'
I guess Poland was a 'border buffer' for Germany. See how asinine that sounds?
Israel was attacked! They have a right to advance. That's what happens in war!
@mikealvordif if you want proper border buffers ask certain zones to be demilitarized and allow the UN to occupy them like they have before. That way if one side attacks through the dmz the other has ample time for a counter that would disable their opponent. It's that's simple, yet Israel consistently refuses to do that.
Almost like they want more land lol
If only Israelis acted like real Jews and Palestinians like real Muslims both religions condemn this atrocities ..
Read the Hadith re rocks and trees calling out to Mulsims, there is a Jew hiding behind me, come and kill him - not an atrocity? basis for peace? brotherly love?
Long live Israel.
With love from Iranian ex-muslims.
Why? WHY do we fight?! This is a heartbreaking doco 😔😢
Any way to watch this in better quality?
The rivalry between Jacob and Esau will never end till the God of Jacob returns to make all things right. Esau's god, the false idol of Islam & his false prophet of hate will fall and must kneel and acknowledge the God of Israel as God.
yes, it is sad but true.
Everythings will be Ok when Moseheyah come. In 200 and some years when the 3rd beith hamekdash will be rebuild.
The narrator has an amazing voice
I wonder if this documentary was aired on BBC (or perhaps an Arab language station that could've been pirated in England, sans voiceover) as I recognize a lot of clips from this used as samples by Manchester musician Bryn Jones alias Muslimgauze
1:45:34 for example
1:51:03 this clip of Habash speaking is used at the end of Muslimgauze track "State of Palestine" (ua-cam.com/video/BIEMU7OJ7QQ/v-deo.html) WITHOUT the English voiceover, very interesting! I wonder where Mr. Jones could have sourced such a thing
great Doco ...
Is there a better documentary? This one lacks a lot?
Go see the sequel. And listen to Frank Wilderson
God Bless Israel!!!
Egypt and Jordan controlled Gaza and the West Bank for 20 yrs prior to 1967. Why didn't they grant Palestinians independence then? Meanwhile Israel is supposed to give land to a people who murdered their athletes, even handicapped hostages like Leon KLINGHOFFER.. a people who rejected the initial partition and tried everything to destroy Israel and pursue a vicious propaganda even though Jews technically never left Israel since the time of Jesus. Yes, the Romans exiled most Jews but there was always a presence there, even when the Crusaders arrived there.
Why don't you smoke a joint and stay out of things above your IQ.
@@warriorsrule9350 my IQ is 150, moron. Keep smoking joints, kook.
Thanks for this.. was unaware of this 1985 incident
How dare PLO was attempting to assassinate king Huseim but they were kicked out of Jordan too!
1:42:10 what attack?
What an excellent review.
Кто от Миши?
Вы не нашли с переводом или субтитрами на русский?
@alaindelon7595 russia is nothing nut corruption, failure, honophobia, misinformation and oppression
Is it me or did they skip the whole Yom Kippur War?
😂😂😂
what is it about?
@@ziyadburzan6208there is a next phase. Listen to the context of white supremacy radio broadcast
"The British washed their hands of it." Hysterical. Considering the Brits promised a free Palestine while announcing the Balfour Declaration at the same time.
See what was written to Rhodes in 1902
Palestinian Arabs is the right term, if not simply Arabs, almost all of them descendants of the Conquests of Islam that invaded and occupied East Roman and Persian territory.
So true Yitzhak. Never lose sight of the historical truth. "Palestinians" have NO history as a people.
Says the Ashkenazi bitch who came from Poland
What the IDF is engaged in is exactly what Nazi troops were doing in the early days of the notorious Warsaw Ghetto, when Jews from captured Poland were herded into a walled-off part of the city and left to starve in its confines. If the captive Jews in that ghetto in the early days of its existence had chosen to mass in protest at their wall, they would have been mowed down in the same way that the IDF is slaughtering Palestinian protesters. Instead they tried to survive as best as they could by paying to have food smuggled in to them. Only later, as their captivity dragged on and as the Nazi mass extermination campaign began, did some organize a heroic campaign of armed resistance against their captors.
any proof of ur claims, the ones in galillee look more like phillistine greeks than a-rabs
and what makes it persian or roman territory? ur always on the side of the invader but british and romans khazars etc belong in europe! lol
Can you tell me how many wars egypt had won since the 48 with Israel the Land?
ZERO
@@andrewalligood31211:43:30 what happened there ?
Egypt made some suprising strikes on Israel,as they outnumber Jewishmilitary by about 10-1,However,Israel always prevails,according to God's Promise.early in the 40's[before my time]the Egyptians reported[en masse]about seeing thousands of soldiers on Jewish side.This was a supernatural act.Missionaries and schoolchildren have re[ported similiar visions of armies "in white"No army has ever worn white uniforms.Consider the 4 jet strike on Saddams reactor.Similiar experiences by Filipino terrorists in their jungle /hostages.There's SO many.google and read about many more.This isnt sensationalisms,but facts.Genesis 12:3 holds true forever@@omalone1169
Arabs have still not accepted the existence of Israel on 26.000 km2, even if themselves have occupied some 10 million km2 outside the Arab peninsula that covers 3 million km2.
the EU is
Arabs never occupied lands, they spread God's message. U must be blind, how desert man can occupy lands
Arafat accepted Israeli during Oslo Accords. Israel never complied with their end of the bargain. And who cares how big or small it is? It was stolen. Why should Palestinians pay for the Holocaust? That’s the question we should all be asking.
@@CosmoNova.Read Islam Christianity and the Negro race
Have they overlooked the war 1973 in this account?
There is a sequel. No go listen to Amos N Wilson
back in the day Yasser Arafat looked a hell of a lot like Ringo Starr come to think of it I've never seen them together I wonder why that is and could Arafat keep the beat or could Ringo field strip an ak-47 man I gotta lay off the plant vapors starting to get squirrely
Today's PSA: *From the river to the sea, Israel is Yehudi*
God is with Israel, they'll never be conquered again!
Don’t you just love how this documentary started... Palestine!!!
Just because Arafat started calling u palyyys doesn’t make u one. You are Arabs. U always where Arabs
mightyyehuda hey idiot... go read a book or two.
@@mightyyehuda2:07:50 Gemayel ?
@@mightyyehuda what do you mean ?
the Palestinians recurrently attacking Israel would be like if the Confederate Army lost the war, and then kept on attacking the Union Army for the next 100 years, and many Union soldiers were off-the-boat Europeans who basically weren't even American, they were technically foreign fighters fighting for the Union cause.
Worst analogy ever
@Danielesalsa543 you're correct, because the confederacy was never supplied with massive amount of arms from the UK, the leading super power at the time.
That's like saying that Britain can come into the US and say hey we used to own you so we want the country back. People are so ignorant
except it wasn't an arab country... britain owned it
God is with you Israel.....
+rondadoolin, 'god' must really be with israel, he abandoned everyone else.
Joe Magnets
Lmmfao
The problem is that everyone that is religious believes that god is with them. What will hold you all together when you realize there is no such thing as god?
What a douche comment.
Roosje Keizer
Typical western christian behavior.calling Allah as"moon god"?dumb ass do you even know basic of islam so stfu.stupid people of trinity.you all cant even prove trinity.
1+1+1=1 like wtf.bible is a corrupt book
God bless Israel
40 million vs half million lol don't underestimate Israeli army. Egypt Lebanon know better now day's to invade
Why not explain the San Remo Resolution which gave the Jews their Jewish state along with all the Arabs their own countries in the middle east? Unless you understand this important piece of international law then you make assumptions and mistakes in thinking the Arabs have a right to any Israeli land.
I am an Arab and Palestine will live in spite of the Jews and America, and we will liberate the mosque
I realize there are strong feelings but the two state solution was for the Arabs to move to Jordan. That was the original deal that was not honoured. The Arabs that remained were to fully integrate into Israeli society. Seems simple enough.
News flash.....Israel became a nation under international law in 1948. It used to be a nation prior then Rome spread the Jews to the wind after the revolt around 70 AD. There has never been a country called Palestine. The Roman Emperor Hadrian changed the name of the region from "Judea" to "Syria Palestinia" in the 2nd century to insult the Jews. Israel is a Jewish state among 50 plus Muslim states. What is your problem? You hate freedom and the rights of a country to defend and develop itself? Israel existed before Rome and Greek empires. They were a country, had a monarchy and made their own money. Archaeology has long proved this as fact. I guess you just hate Jews and facts.
Stupid logic ! I want your house because its stand on a land where my great great grand father owned it 3000 years ago.
The land belongs to the Jews just as the land belongs to Iraq, Syria, Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan and others. If Israel cannot exist neither can these others because the same international law implemented the right to exist for all of these countries.
With American ,British, Canadian,Russian and free French forces.
mcfctid2 City fan? Good lad.
Science Magazine "Modern Jews may traditionally trace their ancestry to the Holy Land, but a new genetic study finds otherwise. A detailed look at thousands of genomes finds that Ashkenazim-who make up roughly 80% of the world’s Jews, including 90% of those in America and half of those in Israel-ultimately came not from the Middle East, but from Western Europe, perhaps Italy."
your point? Are the Italians of today genetically related to the ancient Romans and Etruscans? Are the current day Japanese people genetically related to the original Jomon people who lived in the archipelago before? Are any of the Bantu people in central and sub-saharan Africa related to the non-bantu inhabitants they displaced?
@@hafsaisam141 Oh, I agree. The Palestinians are basically Arabs. Arabs and Jews are Semitic peoples from the middle east. So, quite frankly all sides have some claim there but so far, Israel is the only one who can actually back it up with not just genetics but economic and military force. This whole war is just nothing but a long-standing blood/tribal feud between various native tribes😒😒Nothing new for the Middle East.
This is factually incorrect. 60% of Jews worldwide are of Middle Eastern origin. The Jews who lived in Europe all came from expulsions from the Roman Empire and spread all over Europe.
If both side haven't done such dirty things and kept small but true efforts to make peace would have led to peace ..may be not in a day but in few years ..
And you disregard the Word of God at your own risk.
An Indian movie at 1:34:20 ?
Hate to see this war again .. so embarrassing.
Although clearly pro-israel, still very accurate. One only has to look at history to see that Israel has the right to the land. From a Biblical perspective there is no doubt.
Not just from a biblical perspective but from a Roman view of history -- Masada.
Truly, these showed who's the devil and instigators . The bad and the good.. Sadly, it's the people who suffered the most . Worst of all , there won't be peace because of hate and pride of these leaders and the negative propaganda .
Agreed. Terrible terror.
Ever heard of Judea
Basa could have agreed to recognise Israel and when Israel left the Sinai he could have said "You know when I said I agree to recognise Israel well I actually LAID."
laid what ?
Video is ludicrously biased.
1) The video announces its bias right off the bat by referring to the region as "Palestine". There is no such thing as "Palestine". The term was invented by the Romans and used by the British Crusaders to remove the Jewish connection with the region and delegitimize Judaism and the Jewish state.
2) The Arabs do not and have never seen Palestine as "a home". They see it as land that was ruled by Muslims at some point and must remain so. When the State of Israel was formed, the Arabs already living there were offered to stay on under Jewish majority rule. Those who accepted are now the happiest and wealthiest Arabs in the entire Middle East because they live as citizens in a Western democracy. The issue at stake was not their "home" but Arab rule over it.
3) *It's a complete and total LIE to say that the Arabs "wanted nothing to do with the Jews".* The reality is that the Quran says that Jews and other "unbelievers" must live under Islamic rule with no rights and pay a special Jizya tax, just for being of a different religion (Surah 9:29).
This was the relationship a million Jews living in Arab lands had to endure and that the Arabs sought to keep. This is why the Arabs found the prospect of a free Israel - and also a free Kurdistan, Lebanon, Armenia, etc - so offensive...they wanted Kurds, Druze, Christians, Jews, and everyone else who wasn't Arab Muslim to have no rights and accept total domination by Sunni Islam.
4) "The innocent" by and large did not "suffer with the guilty". The British were attacked because they had no business being in the region in the first place. The Arabs were attacked because they attacked Jewish children and anyone else they thought couldn't fight back, and that is why Jewish schoolbuses of the time had to have wire mesh windows, and why Arab villages ultimately had to be removed - they wouldn't stop attacking Jewish settlements. The goal here is to bring Jewish activities into the region down to the level of Hamas and the PLO that deliberately killed as many innocent people as possible and for the purpose of causing as much terror and mayhem as possible, in an effort to turn a bad cause into a good one.
5) The "illegal immigrants" were travelling to a region that their ancestors were from, for the reason they were being mass-murdered in Europe because...wait for it...they were perceived as "Orientals"! You're really going to have to explain to me how a colonial power with no legitimate claim on the region and a bunch of Arabs who migrated there after the Mohammedean conquests in the 10th century get to decide who is "legal" and who is not.
The conflict is not about land or peace or what have you. The conflict is mostly about Arab Muslim bigotry and their insistence on blaming Israel for everything from poverty to the weather to shark attacks off the coast of Egypt. Israel as a country the size of New Hampshire existing in a region several times the size of the continental US is only controversial because of the Jews living on it and no other reason.
This video is Stockholm Syndrome garbage of presuming the Arab claims are something other than lies and bigotry because there's 500 million of them, they have oil, and they're willing to use terrorism against civilians to achieve their goals.
Compact Jam I didn't "deny" anything. All my assertions were positive.
+Ethan Farber 17 million Jews < 1,600,000,000 Muslims. Why shouldn't it be biased, Farber?
Aeschlimann1 Might doesn't make right. Neither do raw numbers. In spite of the fact those Muslims do nothing but make babies then try to pass this off as a basis to make demands.
Ethan Farber Actually majority rules, that's what democracy is. Maybe if Jews hadn't been inbred for 7 centuries their birth rates can keep up. I happen to know many Jewish couples who can't conceive children because those children die of defects.
Any arguments of yours to the contrary state that Jews are higher quality people than Muslims and should be given extra-representative exception. From my Anglo Saxon point of view, it's ludicrous to be Jewish and to think you're a higher quality human being than Muslims. Ludicrous. You're equal, believe me.
Aeschlimann1 When you get democracy working in ANY Islamic country, you can talk about how you think it works.
You are confusing democracy with tyranny of the majority. Functional democracies operate on the principle that rule of the majority is balanced against rights of the minority.
In point of fact, the cultural inability to comprehend that principle is why Islamic countries and Arab ones especially struggle with democracy and have never gotten it to work properly.
when will we ever stop fighting
When these European leave for Europe. These Europeans are NOT Semites.
that is the question of the ages
@@andrewalligood3121when the Africans seize the northern region ?
why do people intentionally call Israel "palestine"??!"#? better read history and find out wen was named as such...
+Demolicioes de Mexico, Before the JEWS took the land from the Philistines, was it called 'israel'?
Joe Magnets
Joe Magnets you're special kind of stupid.
@@joemagnets9940 he is saying it wasn't a nation they were ottoman Turks witch also committed genocide in ww1 so they have to pay war reparations as the law states
You see?Even Mexico knows the truth!!AMEN!
Jordan is Arab Palestine and Israel is Jewish Palestine. Palestinians and Jews should be able to live in both parts.
They were unarmed in Europe. They came with arms to Israel. Every human being was under the forces of State level mobilization during the Second World War. Where they ended up was in large part a matter of personal luck when it came to top-level strategies and government official discretion.
Part I: Land Divided 1947-56 - Part II: The Six Day War 1967 - Part III: Palestinian Exiles 1970-82.
1:37:00 is part III
Liberty still hasn't been answered for!
How come the Palestine Arabs did not protest the British arbitrary creation of what is known as JORDAN, out of almost EIGHTY PER CENT OF THE LEAGUE OF NATIONS PALESTINIAN MANDATE...!!!!!!!!
Where is proof this happened?
alright at the same time Israel was voted a state by the west ,so were arab nations invented by the same western nation ,only Israel was compensation for Christian and muslim atrocities ,while arab lands were invented in exchange of oil
So weird they call the Israelis "Palastinian Jews"
since when is phalestine an arab word ?
+Compact Jam All so-called Palestinians are Arab. The Palestinian Liberation Organization killed about 500,000 Arab Christians during their bloody takeover of Lebanon.
The purpose of the term "Palestine" is to delegitimize Israel and the Jewish people, and that is also why the term was invented by the Romans and later used by the British who had no legitimate claim on the region either.
Compact Jam According to the agreement you are citing, Palestine was to be the Jewish half of Transjordan. The other half of Transjordan, the Kingdom of Jordan, had a charter banning Jews from entering the country.
Israel is Palestine. Palestine is Israel. The Arab "Palestine" is Jordan.
+Compact Jam The McMahon - Hussein correspondences were quite clear that the land promised to the Hashemites did not include land west of the Syria vilayet. Palestine that is located south west was not included. Hussein contested this interpretation and the issue was resolved by the British white paper that was acceptable to all parties. Palestine was not promised to thhe Arabs ever!!!
+Compact Jam STFU???? well I won't. The Zionists accepted the UN partition and declared independence of the state of Israel withni those borders. They (we) were grateful. The Arabs were also offered statehood within the remainder of the land west of the Jordan river. They gambled on it and lost. They had to learn the hard way that war is indeed a gamble.... a game of poker. When you loose money on the hand that you are holding, no one can take you seriously if you start shouting that you were robbed.
Compact Jam You said in another post that I need historical facts rammed down my throat.... so show me some historic facts in the nonsense that you brought here.
1. Citizens of Palestine..... since up to 1948 Palestine is the name that The UN gave to the British and French mandate, Jews were also citizens of Palestine. Now this is a non-debatable historic fact.
2. According to the British census in Palestine in 1947, there were 630 thousand Jews, 123 thousand Christians and 1080 thousand Muslims. I don't know where info comes from but it is not based on anything factual and historically viable source.
3. Christians were massacred and driven off!!!! Your turn to show me some sound historic evidence. No one was massacred!!! Any one who took arms against the Jewish population in Palestine risked and sometimes got his aggression rammed down his throat. Those who did not get involved in aggression are still living honorably in Israel today as full citizens. In 1929 hundreds of Jews (mostly uninvolved and defenseless people who lived in Safed and Hebron were massacred by Arabs (christians included). Jews hit back and some Arabs (Christians included) were hit.
In 1948 following Israel's declaration of independence, Arabs declared a war of attrition on Israel. Christians sided with their Muslim "brothers" and shared the same fate of defeat.
4. Jewish communities were murdered by Zionists???? show me where your sources are for this obnoxious claim or shut up fool.
If brain is what you have then thank God I don't have one. What you have is mental diarrhea.
Israel is the land of the Hebrews, the Jews, The Israelies, The Cananites. It is not a land of Palestenians. Go and find out where did these peoples originally come from which they call them Palestenians?
Cananites?
Prophecy throughout the Bible proves both God's divinity and the divine origin of His Word. We dont devote our lives as Christians to nicey nice things, hoping in blind faith.
Guys guys guys you say Jewish extremist blew the place up come on the Arabs were sniping low-key attacks all through 47 and 48
Also if anyone is interested, Al Jeezra made an excellent and from i could tell wholly truthful 3 part documentary on the October war. Aka Yom Kippur war/ Ramadan war
Abba Eban, Mr Marshall was RIGHT. This vid has several other misrepresentation
The atrocities mentioned in this particular clip have been carried out on the 7th of October every item mentioned in this documentary was perpetrated against the Jews I'm wondering if in fact truth was ever disclosed amongst these people. I'm wondering whether or not the Palestinians were actually notified about the deception and the lie that was perpetrated by the powers that be in the Palestinian government and that's the reason why it's been carried in the hearts and minds of the Palestinians for 70+ years. To be a Avenged now?
But before that Hebrews were there before they were driven away by Invaders
King Hussein king of hearts
Sabra and Shatila
Going political. If asked in 1948, I would say Israel was an Illegal state. If asked today I would say it is not. History and time forces sovereignty. There is no discussion today if the American colonies have a right to self governance.
Lol
Illegal?
The only Jewish majority country in the world
(There are 50+ Muslim majority countries. Israel was put to a vote by the entire United Nations, who voted FOR the establishment of a Jewish State.
The United States was completely "illegal" in breaking off from British rule and in ethnically cleansing the native population.
Say the Jews had historical ties to Bavaria, what right does the UN have to succeed one of 50+ German provinces to another people? It does not matter that hundreds of thousands of Jews recently immigrated back to Bavaria. It is still Bavaria.
The UN has no right to dictate to the sovereign nation of Israel anything. The UN is the Beast system. The US needs to get out and stop funding it. It is an antisemite satanic establishment.
The UN, with all its authority does not always have the moral high-ground. It was just an agreement between states and many were missing in 1947. Not to mention the unfortunate artificial construct of states to come.
Considering that Jews and Europe have a integrated history, they should be allowed to live across the whole continent unmolested. What justification is there to create a minority state in Europe today. For a said people who would not even be a majority there? What do you tell the native people? Though luck?
As for Palestine then, not now. Just because the population demography experienced recent change and the land had not seen self-rule for centuries. Does not give a minority rights to create a new state based on ancient land-rights and scripture. Such silly notions taken seriously would give almost any nation on the planet a moral casus-belli for land grabs. Chaos. And we have seen it come to be.
As for those who say that the oppressors owe the oppressed. I would agree, but not to the expense of an entire unrelated people.
Anomaly just like Hindus. We r with our Israeli brothers
see the misaarable end of Islam by the hand of God Jesus Christ
Islam is forever!
5 min in I smelled the HORSESHIT and this is why this WAR win NEVER END~
I'm wondering why since the danger in Germany was over they didn't just leave them in Germany.That's where they had chosen to live before the shit hit the fan. Putting them down in a desert wasteland doesn't seem to make a lot of sense at this point in history.
@@markmcelroy1872 That was a good answer. Your peoples experience seems to parallel those of black people in America.
I remember my mother who was in NY telling me that there were beaches and other places closed off to Jews. This was in the 1920's. America was also that prejudice toward the Irish and Catholics. You may onto something.
I also had a college instructor who did his Phd. work on the topic of anti-antisemitism in European Folk Tales.which does give some indication to me of the long held prejudice against Jews.in Europe and in the U.S.
I am in favor of welcoming anyone until they harm me. At that point I am prejudiced against the individual in the future. But I do not become prejudice against all of his family or tribe. That would not make sense. Likewise it does not make sense to trust someone who has done you wrong. That's stupid.
Thanks for talking to me, God bless and I wish you the best, but I wish that for everyone.
@@markmcelroy1872 Your decision is one of forgiveness.
Forgiveness is sometimes the only thing that can open up the possibility of a cooperative future.
It is true on personal levels and we are all in the end just 'people' and we experience things personally.
If we, as the human race, understood this and forgave each other can you imagine what would happen?
There's a scene in a Clint Eastwood movie, "The Unforgiven" The conversation had been about injustice an one actor mentioned that 'they had it coming'. The reply was 'We all have it coming'?
I accept that because I know I have hurt people by being a shit head. I cringe sometimes when I remember, But I'm glad I remember because I don't want to do it again.
That's why we need to forgive each other because we all have it coming. And what is coming is the harvest of our Karma.
Thank you again.
Christianity\Judaism vs Islam.
The land you claim "belongs to the Palestinians" is the land of Judea, the original land of the Jews thousands of years ago. The entire Palestinian "cause" is flawed from the outset. There is no land to "return" to. There is no lost homeland, We call them “Palestinians”, a loose term for a collection of Arabs that squatted upon the land of Canaan in the 19th and 20th centuries. The Palestinian as a singular nationality is incorrect; "Palestinians" are in fact of Lebanese, Syrian, Egyptian, Jordanian, Turkish and probably Kurdish origins if their ancestry is traced back several generations. The name itself, "Palestine", is simply a British term denoting the region under British control during that time and stems from the Roman term “Syria Palaestina”, which originates with Herodotus’ The Histories. The region was formerly known as Judea. Thus, the identity of a Palestinian is itself a misnomer.
Yeah that’s why Al-Aqsa has been standing for 1400 years yet I don’t see a temple. There were barely over 20-30 thousands Jews in Palestine before the corrupt Balfour declaration.
You could say the same thing about most nation states. Germany was just a confederation of Germanic tribes prior to 1871. Heck, America was just a landing place for various European imagrants fused with ensalved Africans and marginalized natives. It's flawed to say that that a nation state isn't legitimate because its inhabitants don't have a common ancestry dating back to some benchmarked timeline.
Better tell the Americans who fund Israel that they aren't Americans and that America is just an invention of the squatters. The Native American tribes being the true indigenous people will need to help Israel instead. Oh wait, they have nothing, as the settlers/squatters in USA took everything from them. What you describe as squatting happens all over the world and is part of history for hundreds and thousands of years.
History man, tell you what.
all of Arabia was nameless till the jews returned to Israel
Long live Israel!
ITS SAID ALL ROADS LEAD TO ROME.....IF TRUE; ALL ROADES LEED OUTA ROME [ AHND ISREAL
2023
This is a fair documentary, I see a lot of Jewish folks can not handle the real truth, personally I could care a less a bout both sides, one is as bad as the other as far as I have seen in my 55 year life, there is just one thing that can not be denied, all the jewish people came from European Countries, when you say that , they love quoting scripture as if that condones what they have done, you immigrated to a Country, and yes it is a Country, people have lived there forever, and you simply took it by force, that is it in a nut shell, if you would have shared power with your Arab brothers, and yes you are weather you like it or not, you would not be in the mess for the last 70 years, you all lived together in peace in the old days of the lord, what seems to be the problem now. Oh ! I know, it is called apartheid Jewish style for the Arabs that once ran the place, if it was reversed, you would understand real fast why they blow shit up all the time, I would be a little angry myself. If this is how Gods chosen people behaves toward its fellow man, I am sure glad I am not a chosen people, I know I am going to heaven. as for you guys, well ! I guess you will find out when its your time, shit ,what would you do if you died and there is no God ! man did you guys fuck up big time. lol Oh and by the way, the Jewish people were the first terrorists, that is why the British left, another fact,The first P.M of Israel blew up the King David Hotel killing hundreds, another fact, but it worked for you guys, but when Arabs do it, holy shit! you guys act like this is new, lol, you people invented terrorism, so stop the with the hypocrisy and own up to it, just once, admit it. but I have never herd one of you to do that, to me that is a fanatical people. who did the exact same thing as the PLO to gain there objective, also has the lord returned ? according to scripture which you love to quote Israel should not exist until the lord returns, I must have missed the news. peace to all. again, I am on no ones side, I am merely stating fact. I love all races who are peaceful and go by the LAW ! not the Bible which was written by men, not God.
arrow64 64 anti Semite
" i couldn't care less about both sides"
Starts to write a whole essay trashing Jews and defending Arabs' point of view
Hilarious
A short history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict: tristans-expeditions.blog/2018/02/16/the-israeli-palestinian-conflict-in-a-nutshell/
They shouldn't have been brought to Palestina in the first place. You should've shipped them to somewhere more empty, like the westcoast of Austrialia. Back then almost nobody lived there, and you wouldn't have pissed any religion off.
IDONTGETTHEPOINT There were very few people living in Palestine at the times as well when European Jews started immigrating. Just under a million.
IDONTGETTHEPOINT what you and others here don't realize is that "Palestine/Israel" was not only a refuge for European Jews. There were hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees, if I remember correctly-it was over 3/4 million-who were forced from Arab lands and were only allowed in Israel. The situation historically and presently is so much more complex a picture than most people know, unless they've specifically researched the issue.
Kangaroos would have been upset!
They are pain everywhere, thousands of Prophets could not put them into right path. Nobody will!
or maybe the bottom pit of a volcano!
0:50:20-1:12:23
Thanks this really helped me find what section I had to watch for history homework :) XD
No problem I commented that so I could easily find what portion I needed for the history homework XD
WOW its like we are in the same class XD
i think we are actually we shoudl hand some time isabella
No
U.N. fact finders. What an oxymoron.
35:30
if you dd not lie you would have your homes
Nasser had rub the Jews from their properties and monies. The same as the ancient Egyptians kings had done to the Hebrews around Moses time. Please read the bible.
Jews were never slaves in Egypt. www.google.com/amp/s/www.haaretz.com/amp/jewish/were-jews-ever-really-slaves-in-egypt-1.5208519
No