Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month. ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
Why this weaving of layers and layers BS on Kashmir issue Kashmir is Islamic Supermacist Racist intolerance and Islamic Bigotry issue ...its clear as Night and day read Quran chapter 9 fully Stop conflation of Kashmiri issue to incongruent and insignificant things Peace in Kashmir is directly proportional to Unrest & turmoil in Pakistan ....keep Pakistan on tenter hooks for peaceful Kashmir Strictly enforce law & order ...putting shakira law to shame ....Kashmir will no longer complain
@@gulzarahmadganie8587 How is it Jagmohan's fault when he came a day after the calls for Pandits to leave Kashmir had been given? 19/1/1990 Pandits were warned to leave and Jagmohan assumed office on 20/1/1990. How is it Jagmohan's fault? And even if what you say about the army's indiscriminate killings is true to the last word, horrible as it is, it only happened after the genocide of the Pandits. It was a reactionary measure.
It is a fact in recent history that a religion faced such hardship.................and I fell helpless as a Indian that we did not stand by them. In this moment as we are talking about a film, it is only to drive home the fact that this atrocities happened and happened when India was free. We must be cognizant of the fact and its occurrence and see to it that this never happens again. Terrorists are always Terrorists, there are no good Terrorists or bad terrorists.
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition) 2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala 3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
This movie is not against Muslims but radicalised Muslims and those who are against this movie are not pro Muslims but pro radicalised Muslims! The truth is, this movie shows the perspective of the victims which was suppressed till now, that’s why it’s making people cry 😭 which makes other people even more curious! This is a must-watch movie for those who support the victims! Although, all political parties are responsible in some way or the other but primarily religiously radicalised terrorists with AK 47 on the ground were responsible for this!
I would argue that there is no such thing as a radicalized muslim..these were so called moderate muslims..teachers, neighbors, colleagues..thus there is no such thing as a moderate muslim ..muslims show their true colors when in majority
There is a place cslled bhatkal in karnataka where muslims are in majority, there women are not allowed to wesr jeans(including hindu women) , men are not allowed to wear bernudas nd shorts(including hindu men). Azan is on loud speaker 5 times a day everyday, but hindu temples not allowed to play anything on loud speaker. It has the only engineering college in India, which is a men only college. It does not have an equivalent girls only eng college. Weekends in that college is on friday and not saturday. Terrorist yasin bhatkal is from here. Anyone who stands against these restrictions faces death. Hindus live in fear there because they are usually the target. Bottomline is whereever muslims are in majority, it becomes another kashmir. West bengal and kerala are facing this already and heading that way.
@@sm734 Hindus should unite and raise their voice, file court cases, protest 🪧 on every issue, and do whatever you can do to bring your culture back there, that’s the only way!
@@themeta_human Jammu is Hindu/Sikh majority. The Valley is overwhelmingly Muslim majority. The reason we kept stating for our moral right to hold J&K was that we don't recognize the Two Nation Theory. Now, on what basis will we split J&K into Jammu and Kashmir? And even if we give some rationale like administrative ease, this will be projected as partitioning the state along the religious lines. It will be terrible optics and bad messaging. That must be the reason why the Modi government didn't trifurcate the state in the first place.
Kashmir is classic Huntington's clash of civilization. Hindus haven't done proselytizing and area expansion for many centuries and Islam went through a rapid, bloody and violent expansion where it cannabalized many civilization. Iranian/Persian, Yazidis, Eastern Orthodox Christianity of Egypt, Turkey were wiped away. It's the same in Kashmir. If one ignores this basic truth in discussion about instable Kashmir, it's absolutely dishonest.
It is indeed amazing why NO Media guys anywhere in the world want to touch on this obvious History.... Hear a lot of preaching and virtue signaling about Islamophobia ... This whitewashing is really mystifying and scary....
@@hke.4475 you left burma, cambodia and many more asian coutrues that have Hinduism. Hinduism is not a religion, it’s civilisation and it’s not spread by sword
The sea behind Mr Gupta is symbolic of the sea of mistakes done by previous govts,mostly by Congress as far as Kashmir is concerned in their policies and clearly they lacked vision.
Hope a mathematical calculation can be made from the first exodus to the seventh exodus of Kashmiri Hindus. That much equivalent Hindus need to be rehabilitated in Kashmir. Then only we can have a true plebiscite in Kashmir.
Do you feel safe as a Hindu/non-muslim in Kashmir valley? I don’t feel safe as a non-muslim in most of the muslim majority places around world. Call me an Islamophobe if you want, but it’s better be cautious than losing your life or dignity. I don’t expect Indian government to protect me and I believe police are hands in gloves in such places with muslims.
@@the69prophet47 that's true my friend. Leave living in the valley, I had a weird sense of insecurity even as a tourist in Srinagar. Ladakh was completely different. It was home.
Nah, you need a figure from 1947, and pak has infiltrated several hundred thousands of Shias from its Punjab province to PoK and PoGB, that needs to be reversed as well
@@jak6872 you know what you or me or anyone can make a wikipedia page and write whatever we want to write I don't doubt you but give some credible source.
It's not fair to say that 1996 was the first fair election ,in fact it was 1977 when in the history of Kashmir a fair election was held thanks to Morar ji Desai,a God fearing honest man in essence.
In one of the news channels a kashmiri young girl was crying and said two heart wrenching sentences 1. Please don’t call it exodus it was a genocide and 2. Even if you are secular please watch this movie. Kashmir files is not a movie , it’s not chronicles of events ,and it’s not only about kashmiri hindus. 1. it’s a reminder of 1921 , 1947 , 1984 and 1990 to every indian who believes in Tri colour. 2. It’s a reminder that a mighty army can be tamed if there is a weak political will to take right n harsh decisions. 3. It’s a reminder to all of us that seeds of Ghazva e Hind exist in this country. 4. These seeds are being spread and carriers are among us , they are visible but we ignore n tolerate them. 5. This ignorance has resulted in ETHINIC CLEANSING n territorial losses. 6. One can make a Sikh Bengal and keral files now itself , as scripts are already ready 7. and if corrective steps are not taken then in coming 75 years there will a movie called INDIA FILES 8. And it will be made in USA as there will be no one left to producer this in India.
its only a "CERTAIN" chronicle of events. its not the entire thing & any opinion based on just the movie is wrong. It tries to portray that every Pandit was just slaughtered in the valley, which is not true. Yes most Pundits fled but those who did stay back most were not harmed. Ofcourse this does not change the fact that such an inhumane act happened & displacement of around 10000 families is a tragedy in itself. But the region was unstable to say the least & militants used it to their advantage. Also it never even mentions that there were Muslim families which helped the pandits. The movie also portraits that everyone in JNU is just dumb & is a woke liberal. Yes many are liberal but they are not just blind to all the facts & know exactly what has happened in Kashmir & what is happening in Kashmir. Also the movie just portraits Muslims to be just blind with hatred, there are definitely issues but to portray an entire community in just propaganda. Of course no movie can show the entire thing but this movie has definitely cherry picked certain facts to show a narrative. My main issue is that the movie is presented like its a documentary & is portrayed to be a be all & end all of all that is to be known of what happened during the exodus.
@@PK-tt5kk sir every movie on holocaust till date has only one side of narrative , that’s what movie making is all about , all fictional movies on kashmir from fanna to haider to mission kashmir what did they show ? hear vivek Agnihotri explaining this day n night on various news channels.
Why is Jammu and Ladakh ignored? The people in these areas are not muslim, and are treated as if they do not exist. Just as other states have been reorganized into separate states, the center should give these areas autonomy. Krishna Menon almost ruined the Indian Army.
Everyone is a majority or a minority depending on how you think of yourself. A Muslim becomes a minority if he only thinks of himself as a muslim, whereas he becomes a majority when he thinks of himself as a citizen. Similarly I become a minority if I only think of myself as a brahmin, whereas I become a majority when I think of myself as a Hindu, and I become an overwhelming majority when I think of myself as a citizen.
Jagmohan was not an IAS Officer. He was 1953 batch PCS Officer. He resigned from the State Civil Service and joined the Delhi Development Authority in 1968. He was more like a Public Servant than a Civil Service. I worked with Jagmohan from October 1961 to January 1966 when he Deputy Hosing Commissioner and I was Assistant Housing Commissioner in the Land and Housing Department of the Delhi Administration.
@@puneetmishra4726 Very hard working, thoroughly honest , compassionate but strict disciplinarian and like all bureaucrats ambitious. I think he was the only person who started his career as a member of the Punjab Civil Service, became Vice Chairman of the Delhi Development Authority, became Lt. Governor of Delhi, then Governor of J& K and then Cabinet Minister in the Vajpayee Government. Delhi will always be indebted to him for its planned development and beautification. A gem of a person.
Pandits of Kashmir ought to be rehabilitated in Kashmir at all costs and set a historic wrong corrected . Demographic balance ought to be restored at the earliest . Pandits ought to be armed this time .
armed ?? then whats the point. would u like to live in a place where ur constantly living in fear. Yes rehabilitation is required but that has to happen in a way where everyone feels part of the community. This will only happen if general sense of peace is restored in the valley. A democratic state needs to be returned & the separatists need to be dealt with. Giving them a choice to get into politics (like how it happened in north east), or they must be jailed.
More like on the lines of Israeli settlements in Palestine and Gaza. That's the only way. Peace is IMPOSSIBLE with brainwashed people. Let them join terrorism and die with an Indian bullet. Otherwise, China's Uyghur solution is also an option but Hindu leaders won't pursue it.
Look at the mess P. V. Narasimha Rao was bequeathed! Rajiv's assassination and the LTTE running riot, the economy, the Punjab & Kashmir mess and a minority government! And see what he delivered! The Congress never have him his due!
PM Nehru stumbled and bumbled with regard to the Policies on Kashmir! Sheikh Abdullah was a friend and Antagonistic of the National Congress and crafty enough to show the Kashmiri’s the dream of a Plebiscite that Nehru had created out of lack of a clear sense of his own aspirations of being an international figure/ vs Just a Strong leader! I am merely looking at the Clash of Psyches and personalities.
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition) 2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala 3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
India should have accepted for population exchange during independence. That would have stopped so many problems. Yes, we will miss people like Abdul Kalam, but we also won’t be having people like Zakir Naik, Dawood, owaisis and so many self proclaimed peacefuls.
Thanks to Gandhi for this mess. Ambedkar was supporting this decision but Gandhi didn't. Ambedkar knew that India may go through the same fate again after many years.
Population exchange is not a possibility , pakistan is not big enough land to accomodate entire subcontinent muslim population , what do you do with rural tamilnadu or Kerala muslims who doesn't know any language other than native language and transportation so weak those days , sending out muslims from each corner of country will be a big mess and it's not feasible and impractical
The whole problem is because Indian partition was not 100%. 35% land ended with islamists but Islam remained split. The split should have been absolute.
Is that not "The idea of India" that every leftie keeps yapping about ?? India was not to be a " nation state" but a " self sufficient commune" of villages living in universal brotherhood ... And you know who we can Thank for that.....
But for that then u would have to give J&K to Pakistan as it is a Muslim majority region?? ar u ready for that ? This aside Of course i dont agree with u, I see people before their religion, People following islam are from this land are also Indian & they need not go to any other country as this is their home.
@@PK-tt5kk isn't that a wrong claim? Princely states were untouched by the British during partition. Just a choice was given to be independent or join either india or pak..so its more choice of the monarch ruler at that time...isn't it?
1. Shekhar is blaming Congress rule in Delhi for all the mess in Kashmir (including that of Pandit genocide) since 1947. This is a major statement from him! Is it an attempt to let Abdullah go scot free, now that Congress is not power, no PMs of that period are now alive but Abdullahs are still around? 2. This proves clearly that Congress could not protect interests of the minorities in Jammu and Kashmir; in fact, minorities like Pandits suffered genocide at the hand of religious fanatics and anti national elements. 3. What a colossal mistake by Nehru that even after 75 years, we cannot rectify it and yet not sure when we can rectify it as well- whether it is J&K or Ladakh- Tibet issue!
If Pakistan claims Kashmir on the grounds of muslim majority population, then India has to claim Sindh province of Pakistan as it had a hindu majority before partition. Pakistan cities like Karachi, Lahore, Rawalpindi were all built by Hindus. The problem was Indian leaders like Nehru were weak in negotiations with Pakistan. Meanwhile, Pakistan leaders like Jinnah were strong in what they wanted for muslims. Jinnah said in 1946 " we wanted a divided India or a destroyed India "
I was initially disheartened to see the lack of coverage on kashmir from you post the kashmir files release, but you have made multiple videos on kashmir since the movie became the wildfire that it did. I appreciate this ability to take stalk of the situation and continue to deliver editorials and news 🌸
Shekhar ji has opted to remain silent about contents in kashmir file, the flash point for recent discussions on Kashmir. The movie depicts that kashmiri musllims had themselves massacred kashmiri pandits, it was no exodus but simply a genocide of Kashmiri Hindus . It seems that Shekhar ji is behaving like press people of 1989-1990s who also remained silent at that time and did not report the actual happenings. On the contrary, he is trying to create narratives that kashmir was governed most of times by central government after 1952 and hence fingers should not be raised against kashmiri Muslims for the situation. Whereas he is expected to speak explicitly on points raised in Kashmir Files.
he did talk about it in previous CTC. oN the specific movie, he may when he watches it. But please dont make an opinion based on just the movie. It only shows one part of the story.
@@PK-tt5kk he also talked about every other riot in India in the same breath. He for once can not blame any muslim for any crime without equating it with some other crime of Hindu. That is secularism in India.
If you believe everything that they show in movies, then nothing can be done. You should read about what events unfolded. But looking at your comment, you seem to be a young guy who decided to take a movie as a documentary. That too from Bollywood. What can I say.
@@junii741 are you suggesting the movie over showed the plight of ko or underplayed it? Because I belive the movie did not show many horrific acts. You going to belive Indian history books? If so, you are not reading anything better than fiction and propaganda. So let's agree, if you can't acknowledge horrors of kp, how would you feel if horrors of muslims are not acknowledged. If that's a problem to you, it's a good sign you are brainwashed, does not matter how old you are, or how many degrees you have or how much of a libral intellectual you claim to be.
@@Rajan112358 1) no one is denying any of the horrific acts done to the pandits, in fact on accounts of many pandits horrific acts happened well before 1990. only issue i have with the movie is that the movie does not show that there were muslims that did help, it portraits that all muslims are just blood hungry of others & lust for woman. Now of course no one movie can show the entire situation. My main issue is that the movie is being sold as a documentary that is all one needs to watch to know what happened in Kashmir. Also I am not denying that there are serious issues which the Muslim community needs to tackle. The Quran needs to be reformed . words like kafirs & other primitive thinking texts need to be removed. 2) Now ofcourse the Quran itself cannot be changed but most dont directly read the Quran & they read books of interpretation of Quran: those can be reformed. Also I absolutely agree with ur anger on secular people like me who in the garb of secularism tolerated the issues in Islam & on the other side fought for reforming all the issues in Hinduism. I am a Hindu & i am blessed to be born as one in which I can openly challenge many beliefs. 3) But where I would totally disagree with many people is that to solve this problem is to remove Islam all together, Its going to be tough but through education many people in the muslim community will slowly reform. I know many well learned Muslims who openly say that they just follow the religion as a spiritual thing but say that many things in Quran is wrong. People are born on Earth with no religion. it is taught to them, through good education people in the Muslim community will themselves challenge the fundamentalists Muslim beliefs just like in Christianity. What we as a nation need to do is give support to these modern Muslims who can change the thought process rather than just attack the entire community like many are currently doing.
Abdulla’s cannot go scot-free here. History says Shiekh Abdullah was arrested as per IB information that he was again supporting separatists in the late 1950’s. The next gen of Abdullah’s were also seen in meetings with terrorists, photographs are easily available. Every regional political leader of Kashmir is associated with separatists and terrorists there. This association needs to be brought out and the politicians punished for acting anti-nationals.
This chamcha SG forgot to mention one key point that governors had no power over CM in J&K because of article 370. And just think, then CM resigned on 18th January, 1990 (why he resigned no body knows) and during 18th night anti-hindu announcements were made from mosques and hindus were attacked in all over valley in some coordinated way. That was not a knee jerk reaction but a well planned attack
I've been a Cut The Clutter viewer right from the beginning, I would really love it if Shakhar ji would recommend books more often. I want to read more on the Indian partition and I could do with some recommendations. Peace, and keep up the great work!
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition) 2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala 3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
On Kashmir’s history right from 1947-48 I would suggest War and Diplomacy In Kashmir 1947-48 by Chandrasekhar Dasgupta. It is the best book which provides a complete story of why India went to UN and how it messed up our claims in Kashmir. A story that is known to less than 1% of Indians.
Great presentation Sekhar Ji , it just reminds us an old proverb : “Too many Cooks Spoil the Soup “. A failed governance model over a few decades of insecurity created a monster that inflicted heavy toll on its own ethnic population. The purpose which is to keep the region stable and flourished was never met either by successive governments or by the terrorists . It’s evident that One sided approaches never succeed . Both people as well as governments shall shed their toxic baggage behind and restart their politics with a fresh and open view. Stubbornness on both sides will only complicates the matter .
SG,it's worth watching/listening you than 📚 or even a 🎬 !It's very interesting to listen to a completely sequenced ,well knit way of telling truths and facts like a story.Also it matters a lot you were really part of these historic events...J&K remains a big mystery for all Indians..Hopefully all that it has undergone more than any part of 🇮🇳, is worth it...
Excellent Analysis as usual Shekhar. But no matter how much analysis, decluttering you do, one important fact remains that any region where Demography changes against the Hindus, the region is bound to experience conflicts, violence, terrorism etc. It has been proved by the creation of Pakistan & Bangladesh as well as Kashmir issue. If we ignore this fact just to sound politically correct, West Bengal & Kerala will face the same in future.
There is a Question in my Mind For Gupta G Howe can u trust local if the shout in support of Pakistan ? And Majority Does that in Kashmir. Please do reply
Bakshi Ghulam Muhammad was one and only nationalist CM of J&K who delt with insurgents and anti nationalists with the way they should be, it's so depressing being a resident of J&K, that he is being termed as "Brutus" qnd terror sympathisers being honoured as "Sahab"
Beware! Whoever is cruel and harsh to a non-Muslim minority,curtailing their rights,overburdening them,or stealing from them,i will complain (to Allah/Creator) about that person on the Day of Judgement." - Prophet Muhammad{pbuh} (Abu Dawud,3052)
I'm a kashmiri here, not gonna mention hindu or muslim. The history of Kashmir dispute starts in 1947 .. then it got aggravated when shiekh abdulla was jailed for nothing. Jailing Abdullah put the seeds of separatism in the hearts of people. Whether you agree with me or not , that is the turning point.
I wish I knew you were here in my city Mumbai ! I would have come and given you a BIG HUG ! And say THANK YOU ! for all your hard work and some lifetimes of learning , Thank you Shekhar 🙏
I have no idea how history is taught in high school or college these days. I would think someone should start document and evidence based history and CTC as the course material. History is beautiful and how history is taught in India used to be most boring and rote-learning-of-mostly-set-question set based - at least when I learnt in grade 10 way back in 1983. These CTC videos should not just be for the achieves - but actually used by students to stimulate their brain cells.
Roshini Act of Jammu and Kashmir was enacted to change the demography of Jammu and Kashmir against the Hindus and to legalise the grabbing of properties of Kashmiri Pandits Who enacted the Roshni Act ?. A full investigation should be held into the Roshni Act. / //
Sekar ji how many articles you wrote at that time expose this genocide? Or you are also one of the impacted journalists as it’s been portrayed in the movie?
Shekhar This is a brilliant summary of the recent governance of JK. Do you agree that if blame for the mess we are in has to be placed in one group of people it is the intelligence agencies.Why has responsibility not been fixed on them. Instead we continue to rely on them.They exercise power without accountability.
The blame should be on the political class for not acting on time. The intel agencies have always provided warnings. High time we keep our leaders accountable.
History has shown that our political leaders have always been lethargic on decision making and Kashmir has always suffered because of this and the misleading views from the separatists supported by paks.
I was genuinely heart wrenched watching Kashmir Files but Ab bass karo yaar Kashmir Kashmir. I’ll stop eating Kashmiri apples out of annoyance with overdose of information/narratives/agendas.
Genocide of Hindus completed - beginning 13th century completed in 1990. Genocide of Hindus in Pakistan - Completed. Genocide of Hindus in Bangladesh - almost complete. Which state next and where will Hindus flee next ?
शेखर जी कुछ आपके अन्दाज़ में कहता हूँ - ‘शेखर गए मुंबई वहाँ देर से किया हैं Cut the clutter। शेखर की खबरों की याद सताती है…..’ ईसी बात पे एक National Interest आपके पसंदीदा हिंदी ग़ानो पे हों जाए। 🤗😁
Corruption was very rampant in Kashmir during the Chief Minister ship of Bakshi Gulam Mohammad - Years 1953 to 1964..Those associated with transport business had their trucks etc registered with Numbers starting with letters JKP .These truckers remarked that JKP in Kashmir stood / gave licence to for Jaayo - Khaao - Piyo.
@ThePrint & @ShekarGupta - Appreciate the timeline of political turmoil in #Kashmir. But, the current focus is on the #KashmiriPandit #Genocide #Exodus + #Terrorism. While it might move with weak political system - there must be a timeline for that also. What is that needs a charting. Then we can place Poltics-timeline Terror-timeline to see the pattern! Thanks
Please go ahead with all aspects and history as well...we would like to hear your perspective as well. By the way history of Kashmir must go back upto Rishi Kashyap till date..may be in nut shell. Chronological history from all aspects.. culture and religion
You have traveled to Mumbau but you say you are not physically fit enough to watch Kashmir Files, watch it in Mumbai Shekharji and talk about the genocide because these are based on facts.
Would like to read your articles on the issue in that period in IX; context is important to know the fact -in-issue of your perception or analysis ;otherwise your present presentation may be amounted to lacked historicity. Please give reference as requested above. Thank you.
A Muslim Majority region in non Muslim majority country Like North Nigeria, South Philippines, Rakhine, Chechnya, Parts of Thailand, West Bank, Xinjiang etc etc And Kashmir. Can never really be stable can it.
There should be a moment of silence for victims of the Kashmir genocide. The victims should be immortalized. Their stories should be told all over India and the world. I am not Indian but I am deeply pained by what I watched We have witnessed countless genocide committed against Hindus, Christians, Sikhs in any country where Muslims are majority. I don't want to hear that silly excuses that this was performed by radicalized Muslims. Where were the non radicalized Muslims? What were they doing when their brothers and sisters carried out these evils? A small minority within the Muslim community goes on a murderous spree in the name of Islam/Allah and you stand by and watch, you do nothing, you say nothing, afterward you offer apologies. People of other religions have been almost wiped out in Muslim majority countries like Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Yemen, Somalia, Indonesia, Malaysia etc... But this particular genocide is painful because it happened in the 90s, in a free, democratic India, it happened under the watch of the government of India. It was done by a minority Muslims that can't stand a majority powerful India, even If the whole bangladesh and Pakistan and Afghanistan were combined to fight India. I think it's time for Real Indians, Hindus and people of other religions to stand up and say boldly that they're not cowards. Being civil doesn't mean you are cowards. These evils done in the name of Islam must stop. Muslims must be forced to understand that they alone do not have the exclusive right to violence. And that other people can also be violent. Imagine if everyone adopted this approach as Muslims, just imagine it.
Kindly make CTC on international politics, Japan - India recent meet. And some back channel dialogue b/w India & China. There seems to be talk that PM Modi may visit Beijing & meet President Xi Xingping.
2 things 1. In both previous and this video you said elections were rigged. We heard of booth looting but complete election rigged is unheard of if you can plz explain how or source some videos. 2. In both video you gave us chronology of governors and politicians but not of how event folded and how were events unfolded which political mis steps were taken and by whom how pakistan meddle in this and since when.
Entire Kashmir was purchased , in 1846 ,by Maharaja Gulab Singh Dogra of Jammu for Rs. 75 lakh---------------- Pakistan , if it wants Kashmir , should pay current market price.
When next time Jammu and Kashmir is covered it would be good to point to its geopolitics ( geography affecting politics ) just as Black Sea geopolitics was covered. Jammu and Kashmir is the meeting point of multiple civilisations Indian, Tibetan, Chinese and Islamic Central Asia. Now China hosts Dugin who believes that to control the world you need to have control over Islamic Central Asia which will help to build economy through trade.
Complexities are always their -then and now .. and these newspaper headlines in ur video just shows how poorly the matter is been strategised to be distorted ..
Lets look a bit at history of his series of videos on Kashmir. It all started with a video which he put after the release of movie Shikara. There he praised the movie even though it was a complete whitewash of the fact. He termed it healthy knowing that the facts were not true in that movie. Now he is making videos after videos to justify his statement on Shikara. In these videos1 its evident that he is messing up things. He is also commenting on The Kashmir Files movie without even watching it. These are few facts about his series of videos on Kashmir. I am not concluding anything. Here are the fact. People can conclude
Jai Hind sir, you had been informative as earlier but again we are compelled to raise that can Delhi be called Del only or Punjab as Pun, my reply is no. Sir, many a time sorry not many a time but maximum time, print,electronic n social medial is mentioning Jammu & Kashmir as Kashmir only. Why, unable understand to find any answer on any one. If , i allege then have right to allege that this is also the reason for this problem. Requested to do CTC on this, if no logical reply the convey us to move out of Jammu to make it more easy for you all. Jai hind- Jai Jammu and Kashmir
One indecisive King caused this mess and the history will never forgive him. It is a shame that two neighbours can’t get along and move on the path of development.
Speak about Pandit File in valley since Ranjit Singh days. This version is with Arensai tamil social media by Comrade MARITHAIYAN 2 days before. It is pandits who played the spoil game from Delhi now Sathbhawa from Nagpur Indian peace thro divided enemies in democracy. After PAK SRILANKA may be India Union will end in catasthrophy.
Let shekhar enjoy his mumbai background and treat pandit tragedy in a mechanical way,while nt ruffling secular feathers, we d rest of hindus have to show empathy and make efforts to achieve d tough task of pandit rehabilitation.. Only bjp has shown d intent to do dis
Early access, exclusive content, special privileges - Discover the great benefits of being a Member of ThePrint’s UA-cam channel. Take a Paid Membership today. It costs just Rs 159/month.
ua-cam.com/channels/uyRsHZILrU7ZDIAbGASHdA.htmljoin
Why this weaving of layers and layers BS on Kashmir issue
Kashmir is Islamic Supermacist Racist intolerance and Islamic Bigotry issue ...its clear as Night and day read Quran chapter 9 fully
Stop conflation of Kashmiri issue to incongruent and insignificant things
Peace in Kashmir is directly proportional to Unrest & turmoil in Pakistan ....keep Pakistan on tenter hooks for peaceful Kashmir
Strictly enforce law & order ...putting shakira law to shame ....Kashmir will no longer complain
GggGgggggho
@@gulzarahmadganie8587 aur kitna joot bologe Bsdiwale ?
Saale kya regressive victimhood chumtiye community hai ..
This is better than star plus if you compare the material. Cheaper too 👍🏽
@@gulzarahmadganie8587 How is it Jagmohan's fault when he came a day after the calls for Pandits to leave Kashmir had been given? 19/1/1990 Pandits were warned to leave and Jagmohan assumed office on 20/1/1990. How is it Jagmohan's fault? And even if what you say about the army's indiscriminate killings is true to the last word, horrible as it is, it only happened after the genocide of the Pandits. It was a reactionary measure.
It is a fact in recent history that a religion faced such hardship.................and I fell helpless as a Indian that we did not stand by them. In this moment as we are talking about a film, it is only to drive home the fact that this atrocities happened and happened when India was free. We must be cognizant of the fact and its occurrence and see to it that this never happens again. Terrorists are always Terrorists, there are no good Terrorists or bad terrorists.
@@kitnanaai is this sarcasm??
@@mukuljain1312 its apologist..
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition)
2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala
3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
Exodus was always public knowledge
This movie is not against Muslims but radicalised Muslims and those who are against this movie are not pro Muslims but pro radicalised Muslims!
The truth is, this movie shows the perspective of the victims which was suppressed till now, that’s why it’s making people cry 😭 which makes other people even more curious!
This is a must-watch movie for those who support the victims!
Although, all political parties are responsible in some way or the other but primarily religiously radicalised terrorists with AK 47 on the ground were responsible for this!
ur right but unfortunately there are many who are just painting the entire population as radicalized.
I would argue that there is no such thing as a radicalized muslim..these were so called moderate muslims..teachers, neighbors, colleagues..thus there is no such thing as a moderate muslim ..muslims show their true colors when in majority
@@pragya7654 agree. When did the non radicalized ones stood up and fought against the radicals.
There is a place cslled bhatkal in karnataka where muslims are in majority, there women are not allowed to wesr jeans(including hindu women) , men are not allowed to wear bernudas nd shorts(including hindu men). Azan is on loud speaker 5 times a day everyday, but hindu temples not allowed to play anything on loud speaker. It has the only engineering college in India, which is a men only college. It does not have an equivalent girls only eng college. Weekends in that college is on friday and not saturday. Terrorist yasin bhatkal is from here. Anyone who stands against these restrictions faces death. Hindus live in fear there because they are usually the target. Bottomline is whereever muslims are in majority, it becomes another kashmir. West bengal and kerala are facing this already and heading that way.
@@sm734 Hindus should unite and raise their voice, file court cases, protest 🪧 on every issue, and do whatever you can do to bring your culture back there, that’s the only way!
statehood should not be given until insurgency ends in Kashmir.
That would be basically endorsing the Two Nation Theory.
@iTs Felon yeah but insurgency must end, the molvis must compromise on jihad.
@@patmclaughlin107 how ??
@@themeta_human Jammu is Hindu/Sikh majority. The Valley is overwhelmingly Muslim majority.
The reason we kept stating for our moral right to hold J&K was that we don't recognize the Two Nation Theory. Now, on what basis will we split J&K into Jammu and Kashmir? And even if we give some rationale like administrative ease, this will be projected as partitioning the state along the religious lines. It will be terrible optics and bad messaging.
That must be the reason why the Modi government didn't trifurcate the state in the first place.
Exactly, UT status is good for Kashmir's development
Kashmir is classic Huntington's clash of civilization. Hindus haven't done proselytizing and area expansion for many centuries and Islam went through a rapid, bloody and violent expansion where it cannabalized many civilization. Iranian/Persian, Yazidis, Eastern Orthodox Christianity of Egypt, Turkey were wiped away. It's the same in Kashmir. If one ignores this basic truth in discussion about instable Kashmir, it's absolutely dishonest.
It is indeed amazing why NO Media guys anywhere in the world want to touch on this obvious History.... Hear a lot of preaching and virtue signaling about Islamophobia ... This whitewashing is really mystifying and scary....
Hindus haven’t expanded 😂 i wonder how did bali east java and Malaysia suddenly become hindu after they came under chola dynasty
@@hke.4475 tamilian and Malaya not Hindu
@@hke.4475 you left burma, cambodia and many more asian coutrues that have Hinduism. Hinduism is not a religion, it’s civilisation and it’s not spread by sword
When was Egypt Christian? I t had it's own Civilisation?
The sea behind Mr Gupta is symbolic of the sea of mistakes done by previous govts,mostly by Congress as far as Kashmir is concerned in their policies and clearly they lacked vision.
Hope a mathematical calculation can be made from the first exodus to the seventh exodus of Kashmiri Hindus. That much equivalent Hindus need to be rehabilitated in Kashmir. Then only we can have a true plebiscite in Kashmir.
Do you feel safe as a Hindu/non-muslim in Kashmir valley? I don’t feel safe as a non-muslim in most of the muslim majority places around world. Call me an Islamophobe if you want, but it’s better be cautious than losing your life or dignity. I don’t expect Indian government to protect me and I believe police are hands in gloves in such places with muslims.
@@the69prophet47 that's true my friend. Leave living in the valley, I had a weird sense of insecurity even as a tourist in Srinagar. Ladakh was completely different. It was home.
Nah, you need a figure from 1947, and pak has infiltrated several hundred thousands of Shias from its Punjab province to PoK and PoGB, that needs to be reversed as well
@@jak6872 You have many Hindus friends? Lmao, that itself gives out your atrocious lie (there are barely any Hindus left in Kashmir).
@@jak6872 you know what you or me or anyone can make a wikipedia page and write whatever we want to write I don't doubt you but give some credible source.
It's not fair to say that 1996 was the first fair election ,in fact it was 1977 when in the history of Kashmir a fair election was held thanks to Morar ji Desai,a God fearing honest man in essence.
In one of the news channels a kashmiri young girl was crying and said two heart wrenching sentences
1. Please don’t call it exodus it was a genocide and
2. Even if you are secular please watch this movie.
Kashmir files is not a movie , it’s not chronicles of events ,and it’s not only about kashmiri hindus.
1. it’s a reminder of 1921 , 1947 , 1984 and 1990 to every indian who believes in Tri colour.
2. It’s a reminder that a mighty army can be tamed if there is a weak political will to take right n harsh decisions.
3. It’s a reminder to all of us that seeds of Ghazva e Hind exist in this country.
4. These seeds are being spread and carriers are among us , they are visible but we ignore n tolerate them.
5. This ignorance has resulted in ETHINIC CLEANSING n territorial losses.
6. One can make a Sikh Bengal and keral files now itself , as scripts are already ready
7. and if corrective steps are not taken then in coming 75 years there will a movie called INDIA FILES
8. And it will be made in USA as there will be no one left to producer this in India.
its only a "CERTAIN" chronicle of events. its not the entire thing & any opinion based on just the movie is wrong. It tries to portray that every Pandit was just slaughtered in the valley, which is not true. Yes most Pundits fled but those who did stay back most were not harmed.
Ofcourse this does not change the fact that such an inhumane act happened & displacement of around 10000 families is a tragedy in itself.
But the region was unstable to say the least & militants used it to their advantage.
Also it never even mentions that there were Muslim families which helped the pandits.
The movie also portraits that everyone in JNU is just dumb & is a woke liberal. Yes many are liberal but they are not just blind to all the facts & know exactly what has happened in Kashmir & what is happening in Kashmir.
Also the movie just portraits Muslims to be just blind with hatred, there are definitely issues but to portray an entire community in just propaganda.
Of course no movie can show the entire thing but this movie has definitely cherry picked certain facts to show a narrative. My main issue is that the movie is presented like its a documentary & is portrayed to be a be all & end all of all that is to be known of what happened during the exodus.
@@PK-tt5kk sir every movie on holocaust till date has only one side of narrative , that’s what movie making is all about , all fictional movies on kashmir from fanna to haider to mission kashmir what did they show ?
hear vivek Agnihotri explaining this day n night on various news channels.
Why is Jammu and Ladakh ignored? The people in these areas are not muslim, and are treated as if they do not exist. Just as other states have been reorganized into separate states, the center should give these areas autonomy. Krishna Menon almost ruined the Indian Army.
Jammu and Ladhak lives in peace while Kashmir is violent. Nobody cares those who live in peace.
Everyone is a majority or a minority depending on how you think of yourself. A Muslim becomes a minority if he only thinks of himself as a muslim, whereas he becomes a majority when he thinks of himself as a citizen. Similarly I become a minority if I only think of myself as a brahmin, whereas I become a majority when I think of myself as a Hindu, and I become an overwhelming majority when I think of myself as a citizen.
There are lots of Muslims in Jammu and kargil
5 districts of Jammu region are Muslim majority out of 10 districts.
Congress crimes haunt India even when its not in power.
Oh is it..stop joking dude.
@@dr.harshamssportsrehab.9151 What joke congress agenda anti hindu.
@@dr.harshamssportsrehab.9151 Today congress itself is a joke
@@themeta_human not cruel as bjp
@@dr.harshamssportsrehab.9151 yes it's BJP who made Congress a "joke".
Jagmohan was not an IAS Officer. He was 1953 batch PCS Officer. He resigned from the State Civil Service and joined the Delhi Development Authority in 1968. He was more like a Public Servant than a Civil Service. I worked with Jagmohan from October 1961 to January 1966 when he Deputy Hosing Commissioner and I was Assistant Housing Commissioner in the Land and Housing Department of the Delhi Administration.
How was he as a person?
@@puneetmishra4726 Very hard working, thoroughly honest , compassionate but strict disciplinarian and like all bureaucrats ambitious. I think he was the only person who started his career as a member of the Punjab Civil Service, became Vice Chairman of the Delhi Development Authority, became Lt. Governor of Delhi, then Governor of J& K and then Cabinet Minister in the Vajpayee Government. Delhi will always be indebted to him for its planned development and beautification. A gem of a person.
Pandits of Kashmir ought to be rehabilitated in Kashmir at all costs and set a historic wrong corrected . Demographic balance ought to be restored at the earliest .
Pandits ought to be armed this time .
armed ?? then whats the point. would u like to live in a place where ur constantly living in fear. Yes rehabilitation is required but that has to happen in a way where everyone feels part of the community.
This will only happen if general sense of peace is restored in the valley. A democratic state needs to be returned & the separatists need to be dealt with. Giving them a choice to get into politics (like how it happened in north east), or they must be jailed.
More like on the lines of Israeli settlements in Palestine and Gaza. That's the only way. Peace is IMPOSSIBLE with brainwashed people. Let them join terrorism and die with an Indian bullet. Otherwise, China's Uyghur solution is also an option but Hindu leaders won't pursue it.
@NICK y do u want to change demography of kmr
Btw u have right to dream
@@PK-tt5kk the problem with north east was the lack of attention and development. Very real things. Not some illusion like religion.
@NICK neither r u sunny deol nor is it Bollywood
Wake up
Matters what the ground reality is
N I think u r very unaware of it
This is Kashmir not up
Look at the mess P. V. Narasimha Rao was bequeathed! Rajiv's assassination and the LTTE running riot, the economy, the Punjab & Kashmir mess and a minority government!
And see what he delivered!
The Congress never have him his due!
PM Nehru stumbled and bumbled with regard to the Policies on Kashmir! Sheikh Abdullah was a friend and Antagonistic of the National Congress and crafty enough to show the Kashmiri’s the dream of a Plebiscite that Nehru had created out of lack of a clear sense of his own aspirations of being an international figure/ vs Just a Strong leader! I am merely looking at the Clash of Psyches and personalities.
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition)
2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala
3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
India should have accepted for population exchange during independence. That would have stopped so many problems. Yes, we will miss people like Abdul Kalam, but we also won’t be having people like Zakir Naik, Dawood, owaisis and so many self proclaimed peacefuls.
Thanks to Gandhi for this mess. Ambedkar was supporting this decision but Gandhi didn't. Ambedkar knew that India may go through the same fate again after many years.
population exchange ?? u just cant force people to leave their land. Both muslims & hindus have lived in India for centuries.
@@PK-tt5kk That's true but Hindus have been forced to leave their land in both Pakistan and Bangladesh.
@@nihalpathak3407 leave, convert or die something like that.???
Population exchange is not a possibility , pakistan is not big enough land to accomodate entire subcontinent muslim population , what do you do with rural tamilnadu or Kerala muslims who doesn't know any language other than native language and transportation so weak those days , sending out muslims from each corner of country will be a big mess and it's not feasible and impractical
The whole problem is because Indian partition was not 100%. 35% land ended with islamists but Islam remained split. The split should have been absolute.
Is that not "The idea of India" that every leftie keeps yapping about ?? India was not to be a " nation state" but a " self sufficient commune" of villages living in universal brotherhood ... And you know who we can Thank for that.....
True
But for that then u would have to give J&K to Pakistan as it is a Muslim majority region?? ar u ready for that ?
This aside Of course i dont agree with u, I see people before their religion, People following islam are from this land are also Indian & they need not go to any other country as this is their home.
@@PK-tt5kk they are of this land but they rejected it and separated with 35% of land mass.
@@PK-tt5kk isn't that a wrong claim? Princely states were untouched by the British during partition. Just a choice was given to be independent or join either india or pak..so its more choice of the monarch ruler at that time...isn't it?
1. Shekhar is blaming Congress rule in Delhi for all the mess in Kashmir (including that of Pandit genocide) since 1947. This is a major statement from him! Is it an attempt to let Abdullah go scot free, now that Congress is not power, no PMs of that period are now alive but Abdullahs are still around?
2. This proves clearly that Congress could not protect interests of the minorities in Jammu and Kashmir; in fact, minorities like Pandits suffered genocide at the hand of religious fanatics and anti national elements.
3. What a colossal mistake by Nehru that even after 75 years, we cannot rectify it and yet not sure when we can rectify it as well- whether it is J&K or Ladakh- Tibet issue!
True
I am also kashmiri Bhatt of Kashyap gotra but we were driven out centuries ago and now we don't even speak the language.
If Pakistan claims Kashmir on the grounds of muslim majority population, then India has to claim Sindh province of Pakistan as it had a hindu majority before partition. Pakistan cities like Karachi, Lahore, Rawalpindi were all built by Hindus.
The problem was Indian leaders like Nehru were weak in negotiations with Pakistan. Meanwhile, Pakistan leaders like Jinnah were strong in what they wanted for muslims. Jinnah said in 1946 " we wanted a divided India or a destroyed India "
People who have nothing to lose can drive great advantage from those who are fearful of losing.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Farooq Abdullah was responsible, because such a coordinated action to cleanse Kashmir of its minorities was not possible so quick.
Then why was he in Vajpayee government
I was initially disheartened to see the lack of coverage on kashmir from you post the kashmir files release, but you have made multiple videos on kashmir since the movie became the wildfire that it did. I appreciate this ability to take stalk of the situation and continue to deliver editorials and news 🌸
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
We could have read the governor list from Wikipedia. No new insights here. This is not cut the clutter - just reading the clutter
Actually Dr Rizwan Ahmed has done best analysis of Kashmir recently much more informative
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Shekhar ji has opted to remain silent about contents in kashmir file, the flash point for recent discussions on Kashmir. The movie depicts that kashmiri musllims had themselves massacred kashmiri pandits, it was no exodus but simply a genocide of Kashmiri Hindus . It seems that Shekhar ji is behaving like press people of 1989-1990s who also remained silent at that time and did not report the actual happenings. On the contrary, he is trying to create narratives that kashmir was governed most of times by central government after 1952 and hence fingers should not be raised against kashmiri Muslims for the situation. Whereas he is expected to speak explicitly on points raised in Kashmir Files.
he did talk about it in previous CTC. oN the specific movie, he may when he watches it. But please dont make an opinion based on just the movie. It only shows one part of the story.
@@PK-tt5kk he also talked about every other riot in India in the same breath.
He for once can not blame any muslim for any crime without equating it with some other crime of Hindu.
That is secularism in India.
If you believe everything that they show in movies, then nothing can be done. You should read about what events unfolded. But looking at your comment, you seem to be a young guy who decided to take a movie as a documentary. That too from Bollywood. What can I say.
@@junii741 are you suggesting the movie over showed the plight of ko or underplayed it?
Because I belive the movie did not show many horrific acts.
You going to belive Indian history books?
If so, you are not reading anything better than fiction and propaganda.
So let's agree, if you can't acknowledge horrors of kp, how would you feel if horrors of muslims are not acknowledged.
If that's a problem to you, it's a good sign you are brainwashed, does not matter how old you are, or how many degrees you have or how much of a libral intellectual you claim to be.
@@Rajan112358
1)
no one is denying any of the horrific acts done to the pandits, in fact on accounts of many pandits horrific acts happened well before 1990.
only issue i have with the movie is that the movie does not show that there were muslims that did help, it portraits that all muslims are just blood hungry of others & lust for woman.
Now of course no one movie can show the entire situation. My main issue is that the movie is being sold as a documentary that is all one needs to watch to know what happened in Kashmir.
Also I am not denying that there are serious issues which the Muslim community needs to tackle. The Quran needs to be reformed . words like kafirs & other primitive thinking texts need to be removed.
2)
Now ofcourse the Quran itself cannot be changed but most dont directly read the Quran & they read books of interpretation of Quran: those can be reformed.
Also I absolutely agree with ur anger on secular people like me who in the garb of secularism tolerated the issues in Islam & on the other side fought for reforming all the issues in Hinduism.
I am a Hindu & i am blessed to be born as one in which I can openly challenge many beliefs.
3)
But where I would totally disagree with many people is that to solve this problem is to remove Islam all together, Its going to be tough but through education many people in the muslim community will slowly reform.
I know many well learned Muslims who openly say that they just follow the religion as a spiritual thing but say that many things in Quran is wrong.
People are born on Earth with no religion. it is taught to them, through good education people in the Muslim community will themselves challenge the fundamentalists Muslim beliefs just like in Christianity.
What we as a nation need to do is give support to these modern Muslims who can change the thought process rather than just attack the entire community like many are currently doing.
Abdulla’s cannot go scot-free here. History says Shiekh Abdullah was arrested as per IB information that he was again supporting separatists in the late 1950’s. The next gen of Abdullah’s were also seen in meetings with terrorists, photographs are easily available. Every regional political leader of Kashmir is associated with separatists and terrorists there. This association needs to be brought out and the politicians punished for acting anti-nationals.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
SG, to answer your question on why Malik is not removed as a governer, can you count how many governers were removed in 2014. That would answer
This chamcha SG forgot to mention one key point that governors had no power over CM in J&K because of article 370. And just think, then CM resigned on 18th January, 1990 (why he resigned no body knows) and during 18th night anti-hindu announcements were made from mosques and hindus were attacked in all over valley in some coordinated way. That was not a knee jerk reaction but a well planned attack
I've been a Cut The Clutter viewer right from the beginning, I would really love it if Shakhar ji would recommend books more often. I want to read more on the Indian partition and I could do with some recommendations. Peace, and keep up the great work!
Read india after Gandhi
1. Pakistan of the partition of India - Dr B R Ambedkar .(uncut version 1946 edition)
2. Creating a new Medina - venkat dhulipala
3. Books by Ishtiaq Ahmed - JINNAH , garrison state.
On Kashmir’s history right from 1947-48 I would suggest War and Diplomacy In Kashmir 1947-48 by Chandrasekhar Dasgupta. It is the best book which provides a complete story of why India went to UN and how it messed up our claims in Kashmir. A story that is known to less than 1% of Indians.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
@@harisundar8698 So summarize it for us here!
Gandhi family treated Governors like their peons. How did this result in Hindu Genocide in the valley?
People were fed up of democracy and took up militancy instead just like Punjab. If u mess with democracy of a state all u get is blood.
@@alpharomeo86
Please elaborate.
Congress party has done similar things in several other states. I wonder why that theory works only in Kashmir..
Great presentation Sekhar Ji , it just reminds us an old proverb : “Too many Cooks Spoil the Soup “. A failed governance model over a few decades of insecurity created a monster that inflicted heavy toll on its own ethnic population.
The purpose which is to keep the region stable and flourished was never met either by successive governments or by the terrorists .
It’s evident that One sided approaches never succeed . Both people as well as governments shall shed their toxic baggage behind and restart their politics with a fresh and open view. Stubbornness on both sides will only complicates the matter .
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
SG,it's worth watching/listening you than 📚 or even a 🎬 !It's very interesting to listen to a completely sequenced ,well knit way of telling truths and facts like a story.Also it matters a lot you were really part of these historic events...J&K remains a big mystery for all Indians..Hopefully all that it has undergone more than any part of 🇮🇳, is worth it...
Excellent Analysis as usual Shekhar. But no matter how much analysis, decluttering you do, one important fact remains that any region where Demography changes against the Hindus, the region is bound to experience conflicts, violence, terrorism etc. It has been proved by the creation of Pakistan & Bangladesh as well as Kashmir issue. If we ignore this fact just to sound politically correct, West Bengal & Kerala will face the same in future.
There is a Question in my Mind For Gupta G
Howe can u trust local if the shout in support of Pakistan ?
And Majority Does that in Kashmir.
Please do reply
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
This current government did an excellent work by repealing art 370
Bakshi Ghulam Muhammad was one and only nationalist CM of J&K who delt with insurgents and anti nationalists with the way they should be, it's so depressing being a resident of J&K, that he is being termed as "Brutus" qnd terror sympathisers being honoured as "Sahab"
Beware! Whoever is cruel and harsh to a non-Muslim minority,curtailing their rights,overburdening them,or stealing from them,i will complain (to Allah/Creator) about that person on the Day of Judgement."
- Prophet Muhammad{pbuh} (Abu Dawud,3052)
Shekhar uncle this is not done. It's time for me to sleep. Please try to release the CTC by 10. 🥲
Absolutely love the way you narrate history. A very informative episode 😎👍🏻
Benazir got what she wanted to give.
I'm a kashmiri here, not gonna mention hindu or muslim. The history of Kashmir dispute starts in 1947 .. then it got aggravated when shiekh abdulla was jailed for nothing.
Jailing Abdullah put the seeds of separatism in the hearts of people. Whether you agree with me or not , that is the turning point.
Sounds strange that Abdullah, a friend of Nehru, was all of a sudden removed and jailed for no apparent reason. There must be some reason.
When
China sent its army on the Ladakh border in 2020 Farooq Adullah was
delighted . Farooq Abdullah remarked that Chinese help would be sought .
I wish I knew you were here in my city Mumbai !
I would have come and given you a BIG HUG ! And say THANK YOU !
for all your hard work and some lifetimes of learning , Thank you Shekhar 🙏
I have no idea how history is taught in high school or college these days. I would think someone should start document and evidence based history and CTC as the course material. History is beautiful and how history is taught in India used to be most boring and rote-learning-of-mostly-set-question set based - at least when I learnt in grade 10 way back in 1983. These CTC videos should not just be for the achieves - but actually used by students to stimulate their brain cells.
ua-cam.com/video/2RaFHzasJe0/v-deo.html
Roshini Act of Jammu and Kashmir was enacted to change the demography of Jammu and Kashmir against the Hindus and to legalise the grabbing of properties of Kashmiri Pandits Who enacted the Roshni Act ?. A full investigation should be held into the Roshni Act.
/ //
It was GC Murmu who replaced Satya Pal Malik to become the first Lt Governor of J&K. He was then replaced by Manoj Sinha, the current Lt Governor.
India got kashmir, kashmir acceded to India (we still have the instrument of accession), we got it fair and square, we got the evidence, that's it!
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Tnx ..
Not able pay my subscription from gpay .. any issues??
Sekar ji how many articles you wrote at that time expose this genocide?
Or you are also one of the impacted journalists as it’s been portrayed in the movie?
Shekhar This is a brilliant summary of the recent governance of JK. Do you agree that if blame for the mess we are in has to be placed in one group of people it is the intelligence agencies.Why has responsibility not been fixed on them. Instead we continue to rely on them.They exercise power without accountability.
The blame should be on the political class for not acting on time. The intel agencies have always provided warnings. High time we keep our leaders accountable.
History has shown that our political leaders have always been lethargic on decision making and Kashmir has always suffered because of this and the misleading views from the separatists supported by paks.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
I was genuinely heart wrenched watching Kashmir Files but Ab bass karo yaar Kashmir Kashmir.
I’ll stop eating Kashmiri apples out of annoyance with overdose of information/narratives/agendas.
Kashmiri pandits cannot be rehabilitated unless they feel safe there.
They will need to eliminate all the militants there first.
Exodus of Kashmiri pandits happened just on the day Farooq Abdullah resigned. As if on a cue. And he goes away to London. Plausible deniability?
Sri Meher Chand Mahajan, became a Judge of the Supreme court and the Chief Justice of India.
Genocide of Hindus completed - beginning 13th century completed in 1990. Genocide of Hindus in Pakistan - Completed. Genocide of Hindus in Bangladesh - almost complete. Which state next and where will Hindus flee next ?
शेखर जी कुछ आपके अन्दाज़ में कहता हूँ - ‘शेखर गए मुंबई वहाँ देर से किया हैं Cut the clutter। शेखर की खबरों की याद सताती है…..’ ईसी बात पे एक National Interest आपके पसंदीदा हिंदी ग़ानो पे हों जाए। 🤗😁
Corruption was very rampant in Kashmir during the Chief Minister ship of Bakshi Gulam Mohammad - Years 1953 to 1964..Those associated with transport business had their trucks etc registered with Numbers starting with letters JKP .These truckers remarked that JKP in Kashmir stood / gave licence to for Jaayo - Khaao - Piyo.
@ThePrint & @ShekarGupta - Appreciate the timeline of political turmoil in #Kashmir. But, the current focus is on the #KashmiriPandit #Genocide #Exodus + #Terrorism. While it might move with weak political system - there must be a timeline for that also. What is that needs a charting.
Then we can place Poltics-timeline Terror-timeline to see the pattern!
Thanks
So in final what are you trying to do give timelines
Welcome to Mumbai - shekhar saab
Please go ahead with all aspects and history as well...we would like to hear your perspective as well.
By the way history of Kashmir must go back upto Rishi Kashyap till date..may be in nut shell.
Chronological history from all aspects.. culture and religion
Reel Haider got overpowered by Indian army
Real Haider joined lashkar-e-toiba
Gupta Ji, plz let me know when you are going to shoot again at Marine lines so that I can try my luck and meet you if I am so much lucky 🍀
Excellent content and brilliant presentation!
Shekharji could you please help de clutter Russia’s performance in battlefield till now? Why is it stretching so long?
Please avoid outdoor CTC, too much background noise.
Sir ,why again apex ultima paint white wash for pseudo
Interview in Mumbai or what ?
You have traveled to Mumbau but you say you are not physically fit enough to watch Kashmir Files, watch it in Mumbai Shekharji and talk about the genocide because these are based on facts.
Would like to read your articles on the issue in that period in IX; context is important to know the fact -in-issue of your perception or analysis ;otherwise your present presentation may be amounted to lacked historicity. Please give reference as requested above. Thank you.
period in IX ??
A Muslim Majority region in non Muslim majority country Like North Nigeria, South Philippines, Rakhine, Chechnya, Parts of Thailand, West Bank, Xinjiang etc etc And Kashmir.
Can never really be stable can it.
True. Islam is the law of the land where Muslims reside.
There should be a moment of silence for victims of the Kashmir genocide. The victims should be immortalized. Their stories should be told all over India and the world. I am not Indian but I am deeply pained by what I watched We have witnessed countless genocide committed against Hindus, Christians, Sikhs in any country where Muslims are majority. I don't want to hear that silly excuses that this was performed by radicalized Muslims. Where were the non radicalized Muslims? What were they doing when their brothers and sisters carried out these evils? A small minority within the Muslim community goes on a murderous spree in the name of Islam/Allah and you stand by and watch, you do nothing, you say nothing, afterward you offer apologies. People of other religions have been almost wiped out in Muslim majority countries like Pakistan, Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Yemen, Somalia, Indonesia, Malaysia etc... But this particular genocide is painful because it happened in the 90s, in a free, democratic India, it happened under the watch of the government of India. It was done by a minority Muslims that can't stand a majority powerful India, even If the whole bangladesh and Pakistan and Afghanistan were combined to fight India. I think it's time for Real Indians, Hindus and people of other religions to stand up and say boldly that they're not cowards. Being civil doesn't mean you are cowards. These evils done in the name of Islam must stop. Muslims must be forced to understand that they alone do not have the exclusive right to violence. And that other people can also be violent. Imagine if everyone adopted this approach as Muslims, just imagine it.
Kindly make CTC on international politics, Japan - India recent meet. And some back channel dialogue b/w India & China. There seems to be talk that PM Modi may visit Beijing & meet President Xi Xingping.
Why the Media & Journalists, kept quiet. No discussion in Both houses of Parliament. Probably, holding on to power & minority votes.
2 things
1. In both previous and this video you said elections were rigged. We heard of booth looting but complete election rigged is unheard of if you can plz explain how or source some videos.
2. In both video you gave us chronology of governors and politicians but not of how event folded and how were events unfolded which political mis steps were taken and by whom how pakistan meddle in this and since when.
Entire Kashmir was purchased , in 1846 ,by Maharaja Gulab Singh Dogra of Jammu for Rs. 75 lakh----------------
Pakistan , if it wants Kashmir , should pay current market price.
Very good information thanks
Have you watched the movie?
Why TKF controversy is more about Muslims rather than KPs? That logic is beyond me.
When next time Jammu and Kashmir is covered it would be good to point to its geopolitics ( geography affecting politics ) just as Black Sea geopolitics was covered. Jammu and Kashmir is the meeting point of multiple civilisations Indian, Tibetan, Chinese and Islamic Central Asia. Now China hosts Dugin who believes that to control the world you need to have control over Islamic Central Asia which will help to build economy through trade.
Complexities are always their -then and now .. and these newspaper headlines in ur video just shows how poorly the matter is been strategised to be distorted ..
Every episode of CTC is a masterclass. I learn something new everyday.
Sir aap hi Bata do sahi number kya hai ...we are adding 00 it seems
Ye bc to bol dega 5-6
Wonderful CTC
Very crisp.
Why no mention of Dr M M Singh shaking hand with Killer !!!
Good history lesson !
Whats happening now ?
what is likely to emerge post kashmir files ?
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Lets look a bit at history of his series of videos on Kashmir. It all started with a video which he put after the release of movie Shikara. There he praised the movie even though it was a complete whitewash of the fact. He termed it healthy knowing that the facts were not true in that movie.
Now he is making videos after videos to justify his statement on Shikara. In these videos1 its evident that he is messing up things. He is also commenting on The Kashmir Files movie without even watching it.
These are few facts about his series of videos on Kashmir. I am not concluding anything. Here are the fact. People can conclude
Please tell the real story why INDIA gov not restored UK and Canada E-visa
I am from mumbai.🙂😀🤗👋🙏
Jai Hind sir, you had been informative as earlier but again we are compelled to raise that can Delhi be called Del only or Punjab as Pun, my reply is no.
Sir, many a time sorry not many a time but maximum time, print,electronic n social medial is mentioning Jammu & Kashmir as Kashmir only. Why, unable understand to find any answer on any one. If , i allege then have right to allege that this is also the reason for this problem.
Requested to do CTC on this, if no logical reply the convey us to move out of Jammu to make it more easy for you all. Jai hind- Jai Jammu and Kashmir
One of my favourite persons is at one of the best places, this combination doesn't happen oftern... love it :) :)
One indecisive King caused this mess and the history will never forgive him. It is a shame that two neighbours can’t get along and move on the path of development.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Welcome to Mumbai!
Most of the Kashmiri Hindus seem to be Brahmins. Is this because all other caste groups converted or were converted to Islam?
Speak about Pandit File in valley since Ranjit Singh days. This version is with Arensai tamil social media by Comrade MARITHAIYAN 2 days before. It is pandits who played the spoil game from Delhi now Sathbhawa from Nagpur Indian peace thro divided enemies in democracy. After PAK SRILANKA may be India Union will end in catasthrophy.
Dil behlanay ko khayal acha hai Ghalib. We’ll take Kashmir back, doesn’t matter, how u spin stories.
SG, please make a CTC on Sri Lankan economic crisis
Let shekhar enjoy his mumbai background and treat pandit tragedy in a mechanical way,while nt ruffling secular feathers, we d rest of hindus have to show empathy and make efforts to achieve d tough task of pandit rehabilitation.. Only bjp has shown d intent to do dis
How come no one talks about mr.rao.and who gonna tells us 1998 babies that he was great pm.
Watch Ni tish Rajput about missteps of government on u toob
Hi sir can you please do a episode on rally for rice or cauvery calling or save soil movement