Losing the Nobel Prize: Cosmology and Ambition

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 чер 2024
  • Nov. 14, 2018
    Dr. Brian Keating (University of California, San Diego)
    What would it have been like to be an eyewitness to the Big Bang? In 2014, astronomers using the powerful BICEP2 telescope at the South Pole thought they’d glimpsed evidence of the period of cosmic inflation at the beginning of time. But had these scientists been deceived by a galactic mirage? In this popular-level talk, cosmologist Brian Keating tells the inside story of BICEP2’s detection and the ensuing scientific drama. (Dr. Keating's popular book, "Losing the Nobel Prize" was selected for several lists of the best science books of the year.)
  • Наука та технологія

КОМЕНТАРІ • 31

  • @Jablicek
    @Jablicek 5 років тому +8

    2:32, just so's you can avoid the intro.

  • @ebswolfpack
    @ebswolfpack 5 років тому +2

    Professor Keating, with the bandwidth of a galaxy, delivers a riveting talk that takes you from dust, to Antarctica (who knew penguins were shmucks!), to the building of his telescope BICEP and how he has been tracking the source code of the universe since forever. He's remarkably self-effacing, and has the ability to sacrifice himself for the sake of a a nobler cause- science and discovery. What a fabulous way to spend an hour. Highly recommend! His assessment of the Nobel Prize brings light- maybe even polarized light- to the heavyweight matter. (E.g. omissions of women, tendency for laureates to nominate people they know, the way science has changed since the 1800s) It's clear he's got a mission within a mission. And his jokes are so funny! Best way to learn about the universe right here.

  • @CorvidLove
    @CorvidLove 5 років тому +1

    Thank you for sharing again!!!!

  • @christianmunson
    @christianmunson 5 років тому +2

    An excellent summary of the current state of knowledge about the beginning of the Universe, and how we are trying to characterize the effects of the Big Bang. Also, how the quest for the Nobel Prize influences research, and not always in a good way.

  • @robbiejames1466
    @robbiejames1466 5 років тому +8

    I always think "I've seen this video before", Andrew Fraknoi's intros always start the same 😂

    • @marklewis4793
      @marklewis4793 5 років тому

      thanx,..i almost skipped it,for the same reason,..lol

    • @SVAstronomyLectures
      @SVAstronomyLectures  5 років тому +2

      We always have new people joining us, either in person or on the Web, and so I try to introduce each talk with the same basic information. Just skip ahead a bit if you are impatient with those basics.

    • @robbiejames1466
      @robbiejames1466 5 років тому

      @Star Trek Theory ok

    • @clevelandmilton8942
      @clevelandmilton8942 3 роки тому

      ...

  • @nicholasgalitzki3992
    @nicholasgalitzki3992 5 років тому +1

    An enjoyable talk with a good mix of history, both local and cosmic, and some exciting new experimental prospects. I also look forward to seeing where the discussion on Nobel reform goes in the next few years.

  • @andynilipour3156
    @andynilipour3156 5 років тому +3

    Very interesting and informative about both research in cosmology as well as the Nobel Prize. It will be interesting to see the progression of the Nobel Prize in the future. Reveals how our system of rewarding people for their contributions may be flawed and how it impacts scientific discovery.

  • @stuartvolkow9286
    @stuartvolkow9286 5 років тому

    Articulate overview of cosmology, it's history and fundamental concepts, with the story of your, book Losing The Nobel Prize, woven in. Excited to read the book and get into more details. Timely, since the Nobel Prizes were awarded yesterday. Interesting perspective on how science works and sometimes doesn't from someone in the saddle.

  • @mikeborrello2336
    @mikeborrello2336 5 років тому +2

    "We are stardust
    We are golden
    We are billion year old carbon"
    Artists like Crosby , Stills, Nash recognize, celebrate their existence by song. Very few like Keating dedicate their life to discovering, understanding the details. That should be celebrated, rewarded accordingly. If you read the book, Keating learned a lesson. Integrity, family above all. Specious comments obviously from those that didn't read the book.

    • @ebswolfpack
      @ebswolfpack 5 років тому

      Ha except that song is by Joni Mitchell! What a prime example of a woman being ignored for her contribution as her authorship is attributed to men. Although I do LOVE their version.

    • @mikeborrello2336
      @mikeborrello2336 5 років тому +1

      @@ebswolfpack yes I learned that rather recently but after posting this comment. No dissing women intended on my part.

  • @barbarakeating23
    @barbarakeating23 5 років тому +2

    great

  • @kevinslater4126
    @kevinslater4126 3 роки тому

    Good luck changing the world without a computer, good luck building a computer without copper, silicon, and plastic. Good luck getting copper, silicon and plastic without a geologist.
    No Nobel Prize in geology ... :'(

  • @Kamil_O
    @Kamil_O 5 років тому

    I am not sure what this talk is about

  • @user-ch2sh4rm9d
    @user-ch2sh4rm9d 5 років тому +1

    العناصر الكيميائيه
    Iron is the twenty-sixth element in the periodic table
    The question is how many elements were formed inside the stars before the big bang of the stars?
    What is the full number of those elements within the stars before they explode?
    We ask you to send the first question and the second question to the cosmologists
    .

  • @Mrfailstandstil
    @Mrfailstandstil 5 років тому

    so wtf with static noise in the background?

  • @TheDudeKicker
    @TheDudeKicker 5 років тому +2

    Oh... the comedy!! Not

  • @3rdrock
    @3rdrock 5 років тому +3

    Jeez to all the posters whinging about this talk. Wash the sand out of your cracks and get over yourselves.

    • @M12Howitzer
      @M12Howitzer 5 років тому +1

      No way, this guy is terrible

    • @Kalumbatsch
      @Kalumbatsch 5 років тому

      @Star Drek
      Go back to your electrical crackpot nonsense and leave the adults alone.

    • @3rdrock
      @3rdrock 5 років тому

      @Star Trek Theory I take it that you suffer from Alpha delusions.
      Is that why you felt the need to correct me, tiger?

  • @keybutnolock
    @keybutnolock 5 років тому

    No, just no .