Magna FG Review | VIVOBAREFOOT Shoes

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 83

  • @Voidrunner01
    @Voidrunner01 2 роки тому +20

    I took these, basically right out of the box, and went on an 8+ mile hike in Bryce Canyon last August and had zero issues. Some of the most comfortable boots I've ever had.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Absolutely mate. I find, if they feel pretty good with first impressions then you’re going to get on with them pretty well. Sometimes things can come up but in general they’re pretty consistent.

    • @smellybearc7411
      @smellybearc7411 2 роки тому

      That’s a lie. Those shoes have a learning curve.

    • @Voidrunner01
      @Voidrunner01 2 роки тому +4

      @@smellybearc7411 I can assure you, it is not. But they're also not the first minimalist shoes that I've worn. I've been using minimalist shoes since 2008.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +2

      I don’t think he means they’re the first minimalist shoes he’s worn. Otherwise he’d likely be in pieces for weeks after it 😅

  • @techno31
    @techno31 2 роки тому +1

    Thanks for this video! I've been eyeing these for a while, and the website has a pair in my size in clearance. Your review showing how they've worn and also about the revivo is very helpful, thank you! Super excited to try them!!

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Awesome, glad I could help. Yeah they’ve been great for me so I hope you enjoy them. And you’ve saved a bit off the full price too. Nice 👌🏻

    • @techno31
      @techno31 2 роки тому +1

      Hey again, I just got mine in the mail today! On your first video you mentioned snugness across the top of the foot, I noticed that immediately when I put them on too. Would you say you don't notice that anymore, has it softened up or stretched a bit? I'm hoping it won't be a problem going forward. Thanks!

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Hey dude! I’ll be honest I do still notice it but they have softened up. It hasn’t gone completely but I think I just notice it less.
      I’ve worn them for very long days and done a lot of walking though and it’s never been an issue.
      Your experience may differ but I kept mine so hopefully it won’t be too much of a concern for you. 👌🏻

  • @katkat4700
    @katkat4700 2 роки тому +2

    Thanks for the video. I have already one pair of those shoes in vegan version which I bought 2 years ago and they have been my favourite shoes but after watching your video decided to buy another one in leather. I have used your discount code, thanks for it, 20% off is good 🙏👍🙂

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Amazing! Yeah they’re definitely one of my all round favourites too. Glad I could help with the discount 👌🏻

  • @michrisoft
    @michrisoft Рік тому +1

    Just a small note on the Revivo point, that service is only available in the UK apparently. Something to note if anyone is factoring the ability to do that into their choice to buy these.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому

      Yes this is correct. Unfortunately only in the UK right now. I didn’t realise at time of recording but I’ll certainly try to remember in the future

  • @OptiRaz
    @OptiRaz 2 роки тому +2

    Great review! Would you say these shoes are also suitable for a rainy scandinavian during autumn and early spring as we have lots of rain/slush and cold days?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Thanks 😊 they are made with waterproof and water resistant materials and I have got them wet and they were fine. BUT they haven’t been soaked for extended periods in slush or anything like that so can’t say for sure. The wool ankles will likely get soaked.
      If you want a more ‘hardcore’ and waterproof boot I’d recommend the Tracker boots. More of a hiking style boot but I have them and they survived extreme cold, wet, dirt etc. you name it they handled it.
      But they are a slightly heavier duty boot though so I’d understand if you’re looking for an alternative.
      Remember you can always buy them, try for 100 days and return if you’re not happy.

    • @OptiRaz
      @OptiRaz 2 роки тому +1

      @@harrisonmudge that’s awesome, thanks!
      I’m just at my first pair of vivo primus lite 3 but I’ll definitely look into the tracker boots as harsher weather is coming up!

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Nice! Yeah the Tracker is a great all rounder in my opinion.
      They do usually come out with another winter / extreme weather style boot but they can be a bit too specific of a use case. The tracker is a perfect hybrid 👌🏻

  • @Kasparovvvvv
    @Kasparovvvvv 27 днів тому

    100% my favorite shoe in the world 🦶and I would love to add this color if it was available

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  27 днів тому

      They’re always cycling new colours through the seasons so it’s just a case of keeping your eye on the site. I still love mine too 👌🏻

  • @madebyape
    @madebyape 2 роки тому +1

    Many thanks for the discount code 🎉

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      No problem. Glad I could help 👊🏻

  • @tokemonmaster9231
    @tokemonmaster9231 Місяць тому

    What were your thoughts for these as a festival shoe?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Місяць тому +1

      Yeah they’re decent. They’ve got the thicker sole for any of the random terrain you may be dancing across and just a generally rugged shoe in my opinion for a festival 👌🏻

  • @RagnarHoff
    @RagnarHoff 2 роки тому

    The wool upper that surrounds the ankles and under the laces. Is that the only upper material? Im looking for something to keep my feet dry during the fall season in Norway, but if the wool is it, it wouldn't stand the test of raining would it?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Good question. I can’t say ive properly tested to see its water resistance but assuming you don’t have shorts on it shouldn’t be an issue.
      However if they’re exposed to a lot of water for a long time they could get a bit soaked after a while

    • @Filantrops
      @Filantrops Рік тому +1

      I have been using them in Norway for the last year all year round. In winter I just put wool socks and thermal insole. Otherwise they have been through swampy areas, riverbed travels, gravel roads, fishing trips, rocky terrains, tree climbing, in the deep snow, etc. The leather part keeps water at bay nicely for a long time. If you have trousers with long sleeves, the rain is not the issue.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому

      Nice! 👌🏻 yeah I still love these. Every time I put them on they spark joy 🤩

  • @Barefoot_Everything
    @Barefoot_Everything Рік тому +1

    Have you experienced any drawbacks with the shoes so far?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому +2

      One thing that’s a bit of a challenge in general is that since going all barefoot in my shoes my feet have naturally gotten slightly bigger in both directions.
      With the magna specifically it means these, after a long day of wearing when my feet get hot and swell slightly, start to feel a bit tighter.
      So if you do have really wide feet they can get snug after a long day of wearing

    • @vincaslt
      @vincaslt Рік тому

      @@harrisonmudge Thank you!

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому

      @vincaslt no problem 👌🏻

  • @ritahartono2645
    @ritahartono2645 2 роки тому

    Do you think it is suitable for tropical country because it has wool lining? And if we take off the insole ,would it be bigger space in the toes? Thanks

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      I think they would be, yes. Taking the thermal insole out will help keep them cooler and yes it gives a little more space in them too 👍🏻
      They will still be a warm pair of shoes but, personally, I find sometimes wearing ‘more’ shoe can help as they wick / soak the sweat away. 👍🏻

    • @ritahartono2645
      @ritahartono2645 2 роки тому

      @@harrisonmudge thanks. I get worried to buy the Magna since some reviews said not comfortable

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Interesting. I personally think they’re really comfortable. I just bought a second pair (video coming soon) so for me at least, they’re great.
      Remember you can always try them for 100 days and return them if you’re not happy 👍🏻

    • @ritahartono2645
      @ritahartono2645 2 роки тому

      1 more question which from the 3 , magna forest esc, magna trail fg,magna fg is the most comfortable?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      I’ve only got the Magna FG’s but my assumption is they’d feel pretty similar. I can say for certain though, but that’s what I’d assume.
      I know the escape is your usual leather rather than suede though which could mean they feel a bit stiffer initially. That’s just a guess though.

  • @runerennemo6614
    @runerennemo6614 8 місяців тому

    What happens with the wool sock in the rain? Does it soak?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  8 місяців тому

      Good question. I’ve actually not got it soaked before. When I’ve worn them I usually have jeans that go over the top so they’re never directly affected by the water.
      I’ve literally just tested them though as never thought about it so I just ran the knit bit under a tap. The do absorb the water but nowhere near as quick as you’d expect. Directly under the tap, water pouring on to it for a few seconds and I don’t believe it’s treated out the box but it does seem you have some sort of resistance to the water and definitely does not soak straight through.
      So I’d say, so long as you’re not exposed to heavy rain for extended periods of time then they’ll be fine. It’s definitely not like a wool jumper that’s for sure!

  • @d.robertshaw
    @d.robertshaw 2 роки тому

    How do you decide to wear these or the trackers on a given day? I have the trackers and tempted by these but not sure when I’d use them.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Great question Daniel. So for me I wear these as a daily shoe. They’re ideal for walking though towns and cities in the winter, OR if you’re going walking / hiking I’d use these for dry weather and terrain.
      For me personally though my Trackers are my go to if I ever go for any type of off road walks wet or dry. Trackers have the ankle padding and are basically waterproof so they’re the better all rounder. I wouldn’t wear my Trackers as a daily wear round town for example.
      Hope that helps mate

    • @d.robertshaw
      @d.robertshaw 2 роки тому +1

      @@harrisonmudge thanks really helpful. Based on that I think I’ll go for a pair of their trainers. I do want a daily/town pair but see myself more likely wearing trainers for that. Keep my trackers for all my walking activities. I live in North Yorkshire so waking conditions tend be boots or trainers and not much in between.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Nice mate. Yeah good choice then. I like their Geo Racer for a lightweight trainer 👌🏻

  • @raquelsierra6646
    @raquelsierra6646 2 роки тому

    Hi great review. I'm very new in barefoot world and visiting the U.S west coast in November. I'm looking for a very versital shoe, something i can use in the city concrete but also something i can use when I visit Yosemite. Do you think this is a good option or should i go for something like Lems primal 2? Thanks

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      I think something like this would be ideal. The slightly thicker sole paired with the insole will make the transition easier for sure. And they’re going to be suitable for both terrains.
      My first pair of Vivo were the Primus lite with no insoles. Did 3 weeks in Japan with them and while I did manage, they were brutal on my feet. Not because they were uncomfortable but because they really made your feet work and the muscles in my feet were having to work for the first time!
      Having insoles and this slightly thicker sole should help the transition and save you from some extreme muscle soreness 😅 👌🏻👌🏻

  • @jeroenvanderhorst1513
    @jeroenvanderhorst1513 2 роки тому +1

    I just bought these (the brown/tan ones) and walked three evenings for some hours. The shoes are hurting my upper feet at the place beneath the lowest lace strain. In the inside of the shoes there is a seam /ridge that is hurting me a lot. Did you experienced that too? What to do about that?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Hey mate, I didn’t have that issue although they did initially feel a bit snug/ tight in the area you mentioned. It hasn’t caused me any issues though.
      Regarding the seam you’re feeling, that sounds like it could be a bit of a manufacturing ’defect’ if it’s causing pain? If you feel it through socks I’d say there’s not much you can do other than return them. Maybe try getting a replacement if possible.
      Their customer support is great so if you get in touch with them, explain that you think it’s something to do with the quality of the shoe that’s causing an issue they may offer a replacement rather than having to do a return, wait for a refund then re buy them.
      Hope that helps mate

    • @jeroenvanderhorst1513
      @jeroenvanderhorst1513 2 роки тому

      @@harrisonmudge Hey thanks for your reply. Maybe because this is a new model (color acorn) they made some adjustments (like the laces) and there is something changed in the manufactering proces? The hurt is on the middle of my instep. I can feel it at the inside of the shoe there is a ridge. Can you try for me of this is also in your model? I bought the shoes in a barefoot shop (Netherlands) so I must go there for my complaint.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Hey mate. Double checked mine and unless they’ve drastically changed how they’re made it sounds like it could be a defect. Mine are super smooth across all the internal seams etc. Nothing that would cause any abrasive feelings on my feet. I can wear them without socks and they’re still good.
      I saw someone else get the acorn colour and their pair had very poor finish. Excessive glue and all sorts so I think it could be the run of that new colour that’s had issues

    • @jeroenvanderhorst1513
      @jeroenvanderhorst1513 2 роки тому +1

      @@harrisonmudge I think this is it: When I bend the shoe when walking the new unbendy leather creates a sturdy ridge pointing downwards on my feet. I can feel it with my hand if i simulate the bending. I think it is the new sturdy leather. I walk every day and yesterday I sensed that only the right Manga was still a little hurtful. So I continue walking and I think / hope it is a case of smoothing the leather by wearing. But it was a little too painful the first days.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Ah right ok mate. Yeah hopefully it softens up for you and gets comfortable 👌🏻

  • @dmgcaster904
    @dmgcaster904 Рік тому

    Hi! I talked to you before about these boots but I didn't ask you' What kind of products do you use one your Magna FG boots? I use shoe brushes and even thought they have been picked on for being "scammy" use the full range of Pink Miracle shoe products, The Original Shoe Cleaner, The Protector Water and Stain Repellent as well as the Fresh Foot Miracle that keeps them smelling like Forest Fresh Pine instead of Old Dead Catfish!🤣

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому +1

      Great question. I actually haven't been using anything at all until recently! Recently bought a set of the Liquiproof Labs stuff to try out. Natural ingredients etc so currently seeing how that goes on a pair of Honey Suede RA III and some Primus Lite Knit.
      I've also been recommended some other stuff for my Tracker boots, so waiting for that to arrive and test out next.

  • @txtualyt
    @txtualyt 9 місяців тому

    Can you wear these in warmer weather?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  9 місяців тому

      Yeah you definitely can. Personally I’d take the thermal insole out in warmer weather but in or out it’s still fine. 👌🏻

    • @txtualyt
      @txtualyt 9 місяців тому

      @@harrisonmudge Thanks for the reply. On another note, just learned they do a thing called "Old new stock" where products over 6 months old get discounted to make room for new ones. Sadly, the old ones aren't available in my size but are nearly half off currently.

  • @ybenzadon
    @ybenzadon 2 роки тому

    Did you order the same size for these and the georacer for example? I hear from others that the hightop vivo
    run small? thanks for the great review

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Hey mate, yes. I’m a size UK 14 which is the biggest size they sell (some of their range doesn’t go past a UK 12!) but their sizes are definitely more consistent now so I don’t have any issues with the length.
      Some can feel slightly wider or narrower than others but the length is usually spot on 👍🏻

    • @ybenzadon
      @ybenzadon 2 роки тому

      @@harrisonmudge thanks , same sizing as well with the new magna FG you've been teasing? they look nice.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Yes mate, will be sharing an impressions video of them very soon but yes, fit wise they’re the same. And yeah I think they look so cool! Love the black on white!

  • @ritahartono2645
    @ritahartono2645 2 роки тому

    Hi. Do you still have any discount code? Thanks

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Hey, if you check in any of the shoe review videos there should be a link / code there for 20% off your first order 👌🏻

  • @Adeem247
    @Adeem247 2 роки тому

    Could you use this as a gym shoe?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +3

      I’d probably say no. I mean you could if you really wanted to but I’d say something like the Primus Lite or the Geo Racer would be much better. They’re gonna be lighter on your feet and a bit better suited to gym based activities

  • @marcgreguoli7262
    @marcgreguoli7262 2 роки тому

    Tried using that code for 20% off and it said it was invalid. That sucks 😕

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Hey mate. Sorry to hear that, it should definitely work.
      Is it your first pair you’re trying to buy or have you had some before?

    • @marcgreguoli7262
      @marcgreguoli7262 2 роки тому

      @@harrisonmudge it's my first buying from their web site. I tried it a bunch of times and then I clicked on the chat icon which they gave me a different code to use. I tried

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      That’s annoying. I’ve reached out to them a few times about this as it seems to keep happening. The code hasn’t changed though so not sure why it’s happening!
      Hopefully you got what you wanted though mate?

    • @marcgreguoli7262
      @marcgreguoli7262 2 роки тому

      @@harrisonmudge thanks, I did. Appreciate the code, they still ended up giving me the 20%. I tried for ya

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому

      Thanks mate, glad you managed to get the discount. And I wish you luck on your barefoot journey. 👌🏻

  • @SpookyShaw94
    @SpookyShaw94 Рік тому

    Vivo needs to have a day off with the prices to be honest, its a bit of a joke. If they want more people wearing their shoes, special models should be around MAX £120, rest £100.
    If you wear them for literally everything like I do, they wont last longer than 6 months either. By 5 months my Magna FG soles were shot with no tread left, and the glue coming apart. For £150, I want them to last years. Good points? Im well adapted now to these and have done multiple 7+ hour hikes, and feet arent ruined after. That feeling you get taking your boots off after a long walk? I get that everytime I put my magnas on.
    Saving grace is they have a good returns policy, so theyre getting replaced for free.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому +1

      Pricing is very subjective in my opinion. It changes form person to person and even product to product from the same person! I agree their shoes do get eye wateringly expensive. But my experience is they seem to last a long time. I do have different shoes for different occasions though so it sounds like I rotate through my shoes more than you. I did have to re sole my RA II though but only after a year or two (i did a video that gives the right length of time!)
      I do agree though that there's sometimes quality issues that seem to slip through QA. I do expect better than that lack of consistency at their £100+ prices.
      Their returns and service overall is great though, agree there. And yes, there's no longer the 'good' feeling of taking shoes off, you're already getting that when you put Vivo's on! 👌🏻

  • @ekjellgren
    @ekjellgren 2 роки тому

    How warm are these? Suitable for winter?

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 роки тому +1

      Definitely warm enough if you have the thermal insole in them 👌🏻 it comes with the insole too 👍🏻👍🏻

  • @david.leikam
    @david.leikam Рік тому

    Using shoe trees help with shoe wear too.

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому +1

      What’s the benefit of them? Just to maintain their shape when storing or something else

    • @david.leikam
      @david.leikam Рік тому

      @@harrisonmudge / They help keep the overall shape of shoe, especially on the toe cap area and helps mild shoe odor, when they are used daily, wooden (cedar).

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  Рік тому +1

      @david.leikam might have to look into these then. However I currently have a storage issue 😅 not enough space for them as it is so some of them are being stuffed into a draw! 🙈

    • @david.leikam
      @david.leikam Рік тому

      @@harrisonmudge / Create space. Save Money. 🙏

  • @AB-nb2ic
    @AB-nb2ic 2 місяці тому

    Clearly NOT suede. Just a matte finish leather

    • @harrisonmudge
      @harrisonmudge  2 місяці тому

      What’s the difference? Pardon My lack of knowledge on leather