This is actually a pretty pleasant discussion, I love Pretty Hate Machine, Broken, the Downward spiral, and the Fragile, With Teeth and Year Zero are solid albums. The slip is all over the place. Ghosts though is wonderful. Trent is at his best when manically depressed. But He always puts out good music.
In terms of having something relevant to say, I may be a fan yes but he's always had something to say, the Fragile was critically acclaimed its commercial success didn't do as well as The downward spiral but that's what happens when You take five years between each album. I think You're looking at it from the confines of someone who is not a fan, money is a byproduct of music, effecting people is a byproduct of art. It all depends on how You look at it, admittedly we're both a little biased.
You think incorrectly if you feel I am not a fan. I am critical, but I am also realistic. Money is not a byproduct of any music. Selling music in this age is not what it used to be in the early 90s. It takes more then a big label or good art to become successful. Its political, for some its the luck of the draw. Being in the right place at the right time and talking about relevant things. The world has not stopped producing great musicians its simply the way they are heard that's changed.
I assumed You weren't a fan after You described his singing as "whiny blathering" and maybe not immediately or directly, perhaps You have to play live shows to make a single dime, but money CAN surely be a byproduct of music making. I agree about the right place right time and relevancy. When You sing about How You feel how can you determine relevance? The only song He has made that has lost relevance is Capital G. Musicians are born daily, whether or not they'll be heard is a different story.
[Verse 1: Kanye West] I can make shit rhyme I can make shit rhyme if I'm... feel like And if I, don't... So I just might not, cause I, don't want And i'm just gonna, freestyle for the first time With a freestyle, that don't even go together Ough No rhymes that's my new shit! Nothing rhyme! How that sound! Uh ohh! Wap! You ain't got the answers Sway! I could sing all, night!
thanks now I don't have to spend hours looking for the perfect "{ CLOSER } { SPED UP } /// 💐🏵️🌾🥀🌿🌺🌿🌾🌹🌱🌸💐🌸💐💮🥀💮🍂🏵️🌹🌷💐🏵️🍂🌾🌹🏵️🥀🌼 ⛓️⛓️🔪🔪🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸\\\ #spedup #song #songnamegohavev #idk #gacha #gachagachagachagachagachagachagacha #meme #spedupsongs #spedupsongsforjwgehpeople \\\"
Remember Fast Times at Ridgemont High when that geek is taking that chick out. They’re in the car and what blasting? Kashmir. In a remake of the movie, during that part, I would choose this song to play. I know, shave butter. A recent Fast Times.
its debatable though arguably Id say really the best work came from Pretty Hate Machine / Downward Spiral. After that, many of the great producers and musicians working with Trent that made it all possible had left for one reason or another...even in a decent album like the fragile...its missing a huge amount of soul and though its good...its not groundbreaking. Its absurd to expect an artist to produce more then 1 great album though possible its rare yet expected of them.
your perception is obviously within the confines of being a fan...and thats perfectly fine man however with the exception of "the fragile" all of those albums were commercial failures, they also failed to achieve critical acclaim. Money is a byproduct of success in the music industry and make no mistake about it my little buddy...trent is playing the game no differently then Justin Bieber.
Profit is a product of success as a businessman... he had plenty of it but also has had years of management battles his own label and sales that sky rocketed on opening week of his previous albums which just like any other performer sales plateu after a while because promotions is onto the next thing coming out as well as radio. Yes while true he is playing the same game as bieber... he is doing it with old and new school promoting methods. You may look at him now but he come up from the muck a few times... had he still had NOTHING (his old label) and caught malm decades ago... he'd be in a different place, eventhough there is evidence in his work especially during WITH TEETH and BROKEN EP regarding TVT records and steve gotlieb about the trials and tribulations with both managers and production labels during his career.
![Nine Inch Nails - Closer [Instrumental]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ST3pYx0q_Ow/mqdefault.jpg)
![Nine Inch Nails - Closer [Instrumental]](/img/tr.png)
![Nine Inch Nails - Reptile [Instrumental Version]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zORPz3LWGOU/mqdefault.jpg)
2:30 is the best part
Definitely
mhm
THATS WHAT I WAS GONNA SAY!
Yupp
Yup
ngl nine inch nails got me goin 🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗🦟🦗
LMAO WHAT
This is probably my favorite comment on the entire platform
They got me goin 🐋🦈🐋🦈🐋🦈
😂😂😂😂
LOL HELP
I am using this song to walk down the aisle in two weeks!!
I know its been 7 years but congrats!
@@omega_8846 crazy right
It’s a beautiful ballad
@@budree4240 yes haha
@@budree4240 beautiful x's
My coworker played this at work and I PANICKED that it was the original and that the customers would report it😂😂😂😂
I know it’s late, but damn that’s funny! I’d be scrambling to turn it off too hahahaha
pffft-
Lmao-
2:27 is where the meme starts ig
@@whotao5854 Hu taoo
tyyyy
Perfect song for getting funky with a goth.
Goths can't keep it up...trust me...
true and im a goth
💀👍
I'm not goth but I love this song
@@Ifalvarado too much booze and coke
I forgot to add, never got sick of this song
2:30 is the part
I threw this in a dj set a few weeks ago with a drum n bass track and people went mental
i bet
as they should
2:29 is just gorgeous amazing spectacular beautiful and just great
@random edits is the is good I like it
2:25
I was first introduced to this when this was used over the chilling opening titles in David Fincher's SE7EN (1995).
This is actually a pretty pleasant discussion, I love Pretty Hate Machine, Broken, the Downward spiral, and the Fragile, With Teeth and Year Zero are solid albums. The slip is all over the place. Ghosts though is wonderful. Trent is at his best when manically depressed. But He always puts out good music.
what the fuck was the slip about, worst thing ever
How you been man
@@yaradragneel7296crazy seeing comments from this long ago wondering what life is like for them now lol
3:02
My favorite part
Nah 2:27
@@Yozhi2 yea
@@Yozhi2 shiver pfp checks out /pos
@@echothefreak9396 nice. Another splatoon fan
@@Yozhi2 now that I think about it I'll just say 3:02 is my favorite part Because My Comment Was Posted Before 2:27 Became A Meme
nice music to use as game boss music!
ABSOLUTELY
something in listeing to this song makes you feel like is in your hand and it wont turn without you.
It would be so sick if there was a marching band rendition of this
Woahh…
good idea
Ngl but this sounds like thomas the train is about to bomb your house
everytime youre not running...im only getting *closer*
Je l’écoute en boucle 🤪musicalement trop génial
Hits harder when you have headphones
In terms of having something relevant to say, I may be a fan yes but he's always had something to say, the Fragile was critically acclaimed its commercial success didn't do as well as The downward spiral but that's what happens when You take five years between each album. I think You're looking at it from the confines of someone who is not a fan, money is a byproduct of music, effecting people is a byproduct of art. It all depends on how You look at it, admittedly we're both a little biased.
2:23
So I can remember the good part
You think incorrectly if you feel I am not a fan. I am critical, but I am also realistic. Money is not a byproduct of any music. Selling music in this age is not what it used to be in the early 90s. It takes more then a big label or good art to become successful. Its political, for some its the luck of the draw. Being in the right place at the right time and talking about relevant things. The world has not stopped producing great musicians its simply the way they are heard that's changed.
Can I have a full remix of only the intro? Always loved that beat with those synths.
42nd like
You could just loop it in Audacity or similar audio editing software
hmm, this song... I remember when I used to play this intoxicating song OVER AND OVER the beat and the lyrics. Yeah back in my crazy days.
2:30 💓
family version
2:26 My Fav Part
I love this song❤
Same ❤️
also💙
i only like the music not the lyrics...thanks for sharing...so cool
0:54
this music gave a umbrella vibes!
Masterpiece
When it starts 1:04
The most sinister metal track ever produced...
Yes
You always slay 🥰👏
I assumed You weren't a fan after You described his singing as "whiny blathering" and maybe not immediately or directly, perhaps You have to play live shows to make a single dime, but money CAN surely be a byproduct of music making. I agree about the right place right time and relevancy. When You sing about How You feel how can you determine relevance? The only song He has made that has lost relevance is Capital G. Musicians are born daily, whether or not they'll be heard is a different story.
this is a legend 2:25
Doing 190 on highway listening to this
2:29 for those who want the best part
I think You're forgetting about the Fragile, With Teeth, and Year Zero.
[Verse 1: Kanye West]
I can make shit rhyme
I can make shit rhyme if I'm... feel like
And if I, don't... So I just might not, cause I, don't want
And i'm just gonna, freestyle for the first time
With a freestyle, that don't even go together
Ough
No rhymes that's my new shit!
Nothing rhyme!
How that sound!
Uh ohh!
Wap!
You ain't got the answers Sway!
I could sing all, night!
2:30 do you remember? :)
1:40
so everyone is just here from tiktok
1.25x speed is exact to the meme
thanks now I don't have to spend hours looking for the perfect "{ CLOSER } { SPED UP } /// 💐🏵️🌾🥀🌿🌺🌿🌾🌹🌱🌸💐🌸💐💮🥀💮🍂🏵️🌹🌷💐🏵️🍂🌾🌹🏵️🥀🌼 ⛓️⛓️🔪🔪🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸🩸\\\ #spedup #song #songnamegohavev #idk #gacha #gachagachagachagachagachagachagacha #meme #spedupsongs #spedupsongsforjwgehpeople \\\"
im getting some command and conquer vibes
Overused in fnaf sb memes, noice
Olivia: 2:25
Y'know, as a NIN fan, I'm confused why there is so many anime fans here.
That’s just YT in general I think
🤣 "Closer" not fylaa . I should have known this before the request 😆
Come back legend
better than the one what the singing
i give voice to it every other time differently and i succeed on it. yo
l love llllllll looveeee
Remember Fast Times at Ridgemont High when that geek is taking that chick out. They’re in the car and what blasting? Kashmir. In a remake of the movie, during that part, I would choose this song to play. I know, shave butter. A recent Fast Times.
2:30 yup
I have been wondering what the song is called
a dislike ? , what a troll!
2
5
I'm curious as to how that turned out.
May I please use this in a mashup with Ariana Grande's Love Me Harder?
I mashed this up with Hit Me Baby One More Time. On my channel if you wanna check it out.
LXnavarro23 cries because i actually was curious to listen to and searched ur channel for it sjksksk
its debatable though arguably Id say really the best work came from Pretty Hate Machine / Downward Spiral. After that, many of the great producers and musicians working with Trent that made it all possible had left for one reason or another...even in a decent album like the fragile...its missing a huge amount of soul and though its good...its not groundbreaking. Its absurd to expect an artist to produce more then 1 great album though possible its rare yet expected of them.
I came because of the kanye freestyle on sway in the morning
send link
drivdr3 san,francisco
beau boulot je suppose
I love the instrumental but I do not like the lyrics
2:27
For the edits ❤
😂😂😂
........
.......
to make a clear case, where do You draw the line on "earlier work?"
Trent or Royksopp?????
Although I like Royksopp better, Trent Reznor is one of the most talented Electronic Musicians of ALL time.
your perception is obviously within the confines of being a fan...and thats perfectly fine man however with the exception of "the fragile" all of those albums were commercial failures, they also failed to achieve critical acclaim. Money is a byproduct of success in the music industry and make no mistake about it my little buddy...trent is playing the game no differently then Justin Bieber.
Profit is a product of success as a businessman... he had plenty of it but also has had years of management battles his own label and sales that sky rocketed on opening week of his previous albums which just like any other performer sales plateu after a while because promotions is onto the next thing coming out as well as radio. Yes while true he is playing the same game as bieber... he is doing it with old and new school promoting methods. You may look at him now but he come up from the muck a few times... had he still had NOTHING (his old label) and caught malm decades ago... he'd be in a different place, eventhough there is evidence in his work especially during WITH TEETH and BROKEN EP regarding TVT records and steve gotlieb about the trials and tribulations with both managers and production labels during his career.
No where near as good as the original.
2:27
1:25
1:04
2:20
2:25
2:28
2:28
2:24
2:23
THANK YOU
2:24
2:30
2:25
2:23