Violent Pro-Israel Counter-Protester At UCLA CAUGHT ON CAMERA Beating Student
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 тра 2024
- Briahna Joy Gray and Robby Soave discuss an investigation into protests at UCLA. #ucla #counterprotest
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
it's time to end dual citizenship
Well we should at least make it illegal to hold public office when you have dual loyalties.
His allegiance is towards another country and not the US. He is also joining another foreign army and not the US. How is this okay??. Anyone else would be deported!! Which is what should happen if your allegiance is not with the United States!!!
@@Dan-xx5jq Yes, and it's worth comparing and contrasting with the US policy during the Spanish Civil War, in which it was actually a prosecutable offense for US citizens to travel to Spain. The 1794 Neutrality Act first established the prohibition on US citizens particpating as mercenaries and made it a "high misdemeanor" to even prepare, on US soil, to engage in a foreign conflict as a mercenary or in other non-state capacity. 18 USC section 22 prohibits US citizens from fighting under another flag.
Yes indeed
Unless they are Israeli
“Let’s be clear… Every single person I know who has posted, marched, and campaigned against ongoing Israeli atrocities and for Palestinian rights would unequivocally do so if Jews were the target. This isn’t about race or religion. It’s about human rights violations.” - Red Collective
Don't see anyone marching for any of the atrocities committed by any of the Arab nations
The only difference would be that we not be called antisemitic, have our jobs threatened, out lives threatened, and our voices censored on every single controlled platform.
Have you seen the attacks on October 7,2023??? Or do you choose to be ignorant. If you seen what happened you would never ever defend Hamas or any protesters again.
Cope
@@daintydalmatian Yourself
Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable- John F Kennedy
yeah but one side cant figure out what bathroom or pro noun to use. not really going to put up much of a fight
@@jasonwalker2150 egging on violence to trap the peaceful protesters. They are too smart to take the bait.
@@jasonwalker2150 Well, you guys like calling people like that crazy or mental ill, and last time I checked fighting a crazy person is a very bad idea, so try it and let me know how well that went for you 😏
AIPAC turned JFK’s head into a zipper after he wanted them to register as foreign agents
@@jasonwalker2150 I believe you're assuming that all those in opposition to Israel's atrocities are left-wing liberals, when I know a good number of right wing conservatives who are waking up to the disparity and injustice of the crises. While they may not agree with the protester's methods or delivery of their message, they are seeing that there is a real issue ...even if they are just tired of seeing their tax dollars go over seas to support the "deletion" of innocents.
I hate to say it Robbie, but your silence on this speaks volume. I love you brother but it's okay to say that those people were wrong without using that broad stroking about "all of those people that might..." Come on. You've got eyes dude. Yours're better than that.
Robbie comes across as a Neocon posing as a capital L Libertarian.
I expected better from Robbie in the past also, but this Zionism has exposed everyone for their moral failures.
Actually I don't know don't think he is better than this. This seems to be him.
Is Robbie 'Chosen'? What ties does he have?
Remember that Maga's kid, who was allegedly smirking at the native American, only later found out it was the old man getting in his face being loud and obnoxious?
I noticed how Robby tried to Bothsides violence against peaceful protesters.
Why so many citizens of America belong to another country??? Their allegiance is not to America!! This is very disturbing!! They join othet foreign armies and not the US. How is this okay??. Any other country men would have been deported.....how is this different???
He gets $ from the lobby
"Peaceful" "protesters". lol
@@jameseversole6118 Where did you see aggression from protesters here?
@@lawrencehubbell9397it wasn't shown here conveniently. There's plenty of footage of the hamastinians instigating violence. Nevermind the fact that they set up an illegal encampment and were stopping Jewish students from crossing the campus. But yeah, they're the good guys here 🙄
Robbie seems so miserable. Why doesn't he quit and find a job he enjoys. I'm sure AIPAC would hire him
He's playing the long game. He's at less risk of being fired than Bri. I don't even think he cares about this conflict one way or the other. But his agency and the network does, so he's taking the "smart" position to further his career.
What makes you think he’s not in their employee currently?
@@scratchpenny Some call it the smart position some accurately call it the cowardly position
@@syashadeed7552 Yeah, that's why I said that in quotations. Careerist types in any field often shirk moral responsibility and go with authority.
I would call it, not a real journalist, and that's ok and enlightening
Robby playing dumb out US authoritarianism on behalf of Israel.
He's protecting his career. Bri operates in a different political space where taking the positions she takes is acceptable. However, Robbie must contend with the people in his space, and he recognizes that going along with Bri will limit his career options. It's what a lot of people in the media are doing. And it's why most politicians are on board with the status quo. Everyone has something to lose.
@@scratchpenny follow the money... and who controls it. Its not a trope.
@@scratchpennyso he’s a coward. Agreed
Now, in defense of Robbie, he might ACTUALLY be dumb . . . very dumb as he has demonstrated on multiple occasions!
Robbie's Bubble: Robbie reads the NYT, the WSJ and Atlantic Monthly and watches the History Channel. He goes to the movies. That's it.
You send police to hurt me, you tell lies about me, you erase my comments, you call me names and you try to destroy my career because I ask for peace.
"From the river to the sea" ain't peace.....it's erasing of a nation ..... that God gave the descendants of Abraham over 6000 years ago
Keep fighting righteously without letting up, God is on the side of truth freedom and liberty
Very sad
"...will be going to Israel to join the IDF." -- murderous sociopath!
He already was in the IDF,it’s been proven……..
CNN does investigations? Who knew?
Shocking I must say
It is becoming more and more apparent that both Democratic and Republican mainstream media officially support IL and lie for it, but it seems that there are a lot more people in the Dem media who really don't believe the pro-IL propaganda that they are paid to say, and are leaking through their real feelings until they are reprimanded.
Pre OJ cnn cred done ran out, time to be a real news org again for a minute xD
You mean the Corrupt News Network?
Why is it not posted on UA-cam tho
Brie is really forcing Robbie to expose himself.
Great job.
yes Bri was right on here !
assault and battery is a felony and these people have been identified and they have not been charged
this is so reveling
is the LAPD being financed by Zionist to chill over obvious felonies as Robbie is unable to comprehend assault with a deadly weapon as a crime punishable by law ?
That's one of the reasons I watch this....She knows all his buttons to press, and then he gets over excited and she's sitting there as cool as a cucumber looking at her nails!
Robbie just sinks deeper and deeper. It's a sad thing to see--He's sounds like one of those folks from the State Department.
Why did UCLA and LAPD want to cover up?
Zionists have infiltrated a lot of institutions it seems…..even the police…..sickening.
Because they are envious of the counter protesters, and maybe some of them were there off duty.
For the same reason the USS Liberty, lavon affair, 83 beirut attack, cheering mossad agents on 9-11, NUMEC affair, and reality about WWII are covered up. Look who is in charge. The "eternal victims"
because its israel
The Israel Lobby is a fierce, arguably mafia-like organization.
Robbie: "If anyone did anything illegal, at any time. Any person should be arrested and placed in any jail and await any given court date to face any given justice. That's my view."
I agree
So much for due process in a timely manner. Right?
Amazing that the Jewish students who have been attacked can't find their attackers.. Hamas supporters get a free pass 🙄
Nerd @@thedecider1984
Thats definitely a thing to say
Some award-winning both sides-ism from RS. Gold medal.
Why is the guy with the pole not in jail???!!???
Probably because he wasn't the instigator
Because he got hit 1st.. it was a 5 on 1.. I wonder if you'd want the protesters arrested if you found out
It's shocking that Robbie still manages to walk straight with all the bending and twisting he does to defend the indefensible. This is exactly why he should be replaced by a right-leaning or centrist journalist with integrity. He demonstrates a complete lack of ethical journalistic skills and ability.
He's flummoxed every day trying to rebutt Briana's constantantly changinging flimsy narratives and lies
So you want an agreeable echo chamber with someone who is leaning a bit right on subjects rarely covered? Maybe just go watch mainstream media?
@Val_Smith what main stream media is right wing? Fox kind if is but still founded by drug companies
He didn’t defend anything. Stop lying.
@@markfregly4148 That's an interesting stance you've taken. Do enlighten us further-I'm eager to hear some concrete examples of her "flimsy narratives and lies." Please, indulge us.
The United States of Israel🤦♂
It is illegal to support terrorist groups in the United States.
[Insert Voltaire quote here]
Better than the United States of palistine... Israel all the way baby
@@RH_Collective🤨
Why so many citizens of America belong to another country??? Their allegiance is not to America!! This is very disturbing!! They join othet foreign armies and not the US. How is this okay??. Any other country men would have been deported.....how is this different???
😂 Robbie's lack of interest in the story because there's no plausible defense for the violence is astounding 😂 he can't even feign it. Bri comes with enthusiasm, and Robbie's retorts in a monotonous tone, "as i said before, it's both sides this and that blah blah blah"
Do you want him to compete in sanctimonious cheerleading?
@@leviashanken2506 Whom are you accusing of sanctimonious cheerleading, and about what specifically?
Robby STILL trying to equate violent weapon-based assault with students barring obvious agitators from the area! He finds some way to shoehorn his argument in every time they cover a story like this. Give it up, man!
Its pathetic
I don't think he cares at all. He's just a careerist who realizes his career will go much further by staying on a specific side of this debate.
Students don't have the right to "bar" anyone from the area. IT'S NOT THEIR PROPERTY.
@@jameseversole6118 sometimes you gotta go beyond your “rights” to keep the situation from escalating at the hands of dangerous agitators.
@@scratchpennyYour absolutely right. He's hitched his wagon to the side with money. Hoping for future gain.
The audicity of that mother saying he was defending himself.
Let me correct that for you: unlike where you are this is America and we have freedom of speech as long as we're violent, disingenuous, and support the ruling parties who don't want any change. And we'd look darn good in brownshirts or any other fascist uniform, casual or formal, we can find to identify with, regardless of the cognitive dissonance.
Normal Israeli lies.
@GadzonkaZonka is that so? Type anything with Jenna side and see just how free you think you are.
@GadzonkaZonkaOP said audacity, but that might be too big a word for you.
He was though. Do you guys guys think the video started where they played it? The guy he hit had just tackled someone and was threatening to throw things at people. Are you actually pretending like the pro Hamas freaks weren't engaging in violence? You guys really do live in an alternate version of reality
RS says being forced to walk around is equal to VIOLENCE 🤣🤣🤣
It's not violence it's just something protesters don't have the right to make people do.
@@drowningpooralice5505what’s that? What’s that boy? The peanut allergy table says there’s violence against because they have to walk 100 yards and then another 100 yards around a protest? Oh my god!!!!
@@drowningpooralice5505Having to walk around a protest you don’t agree with? That’s a terrorism.
Hey, misgendering is considered violence these days.
They are outright intimidating students and shouting horrible things at them. It's not violence but it is unacceptable
How come that American citizens are allowed to join armies of another country? Does this make sense? What if an American decides to join the Taliban army? I am guessing that they would be jailed, and parents won't be bragging about it.
Americans have joined the taliban... and other organizations...
It is not illegal to join the Army of another nation. People have done it for centuries.
However, if it is a military that is the enemy of this one, like the Taliban, you can be tried for treason, which makes you eligible for the death penalty, potentially.
But Israel is not in that category.
@@milascave2 If they happen to become prisoners, Which country will be responsible to secure their fair treatment and release? The country of which they are a citizen, or the army that they chose to join? I am just curious to know why we have to divide the world in 2 camps: Friends or enemies. Or you are with us or you are against us. Can a country be neutral?
Mercenaries
@@joonjoon818 And unlike Americans serving in the IDF, those Americans lost their citizenship for it.
Robby would have also been both-sidesing the Nazis.
You would have been loudly supporting them because 'the experts' say said to.
Ironic comment given what Hamas has stated that Pro_Palestinians are backing...
And how many arrests have taken place?
Robby feels that he has to say something even when it adds nothing to the discourse.
He has to do something to get a check.
I think a lobby has done a pretty good job in causing public opinion to consider anything anti-Israel is anti-Semitic, which is flat out wrong.
It will soon be memed into reality though
So being anti-black isn’t racist? Good to know.
Who are you to decide what’s anti semitic. Is it anti Irish to say you want the Irish and Ireland to be wiped out? Let me guess you have a quick yes with thae
@@Tal-xg6lq The definition of antiSemetic, according to the dictionary is “hostile to or prejudiced against Jewish people.” So, yeah…genius. 🤦♀️
Video of this has been available for weeks now, why is this only just now becoming a story?
Using cnn as a example is the worse decision anyone could do
Nope, almost all Western Main stream media are Toxic Israeli mouthpiece & its getting really Hard for them to Defend the indefensible. the Western media must try cover some story to stay Relevant esp after the students Protests
That CNN report on criminals attacking the peaceful pro Palestinian protests was illuminating and spot on. Just because it's contrary to your views does not make it wrong. That was the first time I saw that reporter, but then, I don't watch CNN. She certainly wasn't one of their usual stumps.
The most amazing part of the story is the FBI is actually looking into these protesters. wow!
Sure they are,a rug doesn’t lie either…….
Crickets from Robbie. 🦗 🦗
Robbie: "I like to equate a criminal violent act with someone preventing someones freedom of movement.", what a tool.
That is a criminal act, and a hate crime if specifically targeting Jewish students... like they were. But that's fine, right?
@jameseversole6118 Are u saying Jewish anti genocide students are gaslighting Pro genocide Jew students 🤔....lying is nothing to those who think slaughter of 15,000 kids is OK!
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Robbie does not look like he enjoyed reading the teleprompter. He hates that the bad side is the zionist side.
plot twist: there is never a good side
It's his "are we the baddies?" moment, lasting 7 months now....
@@TurdFergusen so the jews in the holocaust were also villains or the slaves born generation after generation into slavery were someone baddies too?
To learn who rulers over you, simply find out who you are not allowed to criticize.
Voltaire
The people you imply are above criticism are being criticized in this video, and lots of other people.
Logic really isn't your strong point, is it?
Repost this every hour on every big company site
Muslims? Black people?
Yeah. The religion of peace( by force to convert or die).
we learned that during the pandemic
Hasbara AIPAC has set its sights on this comment section. They are so easy to spot. Been running the same skit for decades even after their playbook was published online.
Sure has.
I'm not aipac. I just point out the biases
@@june52005 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@june52005the biases? You mean the truth.
Have those trouble makers been identified and recorded for later legal actions?
Or any investigation who's behind those trouble makers?
Robbie sucks.
He sure does.
Defund Isntreal
Isn'treal? Nice.
@@Kazekoge101 i prefer SHITrael or israHELL
Montreal?
Yes so where exactly is "Palestine" found?
@@geniaeren3757 where the U.S. Taxpayer funded occupying force is
"Libertarian" Robbie continually shows his contempt for free speech. Civic protests are right, just, and constitutionally protected wether conservative reactionaries believe in the 1st amendment or not.
Harassing innocent Jewish students is not “free speech.”
Says the facsist who cheered on the incarceration of peaceful J6 protesters.
@@randolphkoch2267 Amen, not only should these protesters not be protected, they should be jailed. Protesting doesn't suddenly give one the right to break the law.
Conservatives believe in free speech more than liberals do, anyday of the week. Go asked J. Seinfeld, he quit doing standup at schools because he was constantly harrassed by liberals.
But spitting on Christian’s in East Jerusalem is completely fine according to your logic ……..
Time to maybe 🤔 let Robbie go. Can’t stand to watch the show with him anymore.
Why because he doesn’t support lies
No--Because he's a Hasbara Bot.
Pro-Gaza is not the same as Pro-Peace, stop the gaslighting
Lol as if cnn or msnbc has any credibility
Does the videos they showed have any credibility 🤣smh🤦Brainwashed to oblivion I guess🤷.
If someone's son is going to Israel to join the IDF they should stay there. Revoke their passports and citizenship.
No, make them choose. I'm sick of dual citizenship. US or them, you cannot have the same creed as me, if you cannot accept people of other religions as your equal.
Why? If they want to spend part of their life defending the country where their family lives, whats wrong with that. Im Filipino, if China attacked the Phil. and Phil. had to defend itself, whats wrong with me going to help out? And if I want to buy a vacation property in Phil. I need to maintain my Phil. citizenship in order to legally own land there.
@@ThatsMrPencilneck2U As far as I can see the son already chose. He chose the IDF. Would everyone support him if he ran off and joined the Russian army?
@@_TheLONEwolf The Philippines fit in the US system of alliances in a way that is easily understood. Americans died in large numbers against a foreign enemy along side the Philippine people. It's not like we don't owe the Philippine people, for all we've taken from them. Israel, just takes. Then, Israel tried to get us into one of their wars by sinking the USS Liberty and blaming it on Egypt. Only an act of God saved that ship and most of her crew.
He was already in the IDF to begin with,you’re only getting half the truth……
I can’t anymore. Her choice of words says it all. Goodbye Robby
Funny how this altercation gets attention but not any other within the same campus.
My thoughts exactly.
Why are USA citizens joining the army of another country? So if the US fights the other country which side would this person be on?
Sending their son to join the IDF... Isn't this treason??? Why you still live here???
No apparently if it's Israel U can serve on the IDF then be elected to Congress
Treason is aiding an enemy of the nation, my man.
Israel is an ally of the US and many Jewish Americans have duel citizenship. This is not controversial.
not really, a lot of American boys went to fight for England and France in WW1 and WW2 before American joined.
Isn't supporting hamas tresion ? Move to Gaza do your thing...
S#$ rob is here I am out.
N lover
This Bri is the reason I rarely watch the Hill anymore
Bri is so animated and excited by this report. Her mood sinks or elevates depending on how the politics shake out.
Robby's both sidesism is the textbook example of the "banality of evil".
💯
It doesn't matter how overwhelming the evidence is, Robbie will clownishly try to both sides it.
50-years-go Robbie would have been in "Nazis for Nixon".
Right, only HAMAS supporters are allowed to protest.
Robby flapping his jaws again about “violence on both sides.”
If Islam was good then why would the Pakistani's name their city Isamisbad?
If Judaism was good, why do they call their capital Tellahebetogetouttahere?
Robbie - the difference between the two sides- is that the Jewish students feeling unsafe is due from their interpretation of certain chants and their insecurities versus people who were mostly not even students engaging in actual violence that actually led to people getting hurt. It’s the actual violence versus the interpreted fear and insecurities.
In exactly the same way that Israel says Hamas vous to commit Oct 7 over and over and that is a real genocide when it actually hasn’t happened yet nor do they even have the means to do it, all while Israel is actually doing the bombing and the killing of so many innocent civilians.
Again one is fear of.. the other is actual committing the action.
See the problem?
Thanks for stating that fact. Imaginary vs real. Politicians and MSM having taken the imaginary and conflated it into a real crime. Meanwhile a jenocide continues.
They need to go to jail.
This the result of USA ignoring jenny side & israeli impunity.
Is ROBBY been unmasked?? 😂😂😂
Had to quit watching at 3:15, can't stomach Bri's lies.
There is a socialogical reason these outsiders act in this manner.
Thanks for this very important coverage!
It looks like Robbie will be giving his 2 weeks' notice or will be fired, just based on his attitude and behavior on the show... just saying. Im really surprise they even have him on anymore. No passion, talking like he doesn't want to be there anymore. I like Robbie, he brings a different perspective. Now he is just dull, bland uninterested.
No one is going to tune in to watch Bri so there is that.
Robby and his “both sides”! BS. 🤦♂️
“Anti war protestors”… sure Jan
On one side people are locked in an enclosure being beaten by an armed opposing side. Not even remotely coincidental
Are these people supposed fo be reporting news? Or giving opinions on events? What is this thing? Its not news.
How do people watch this stuff?
Y’all are really pushing the crazy narrative.
Wow, check out some of the comments here still crying wolf about imaginary anti-semitism.
It's not imaginary
They cry out in pain as they strike you
I know, reminds me of Jan 6th conspiracy theoriests believing protesters taking selfies at the Capital during visiting hours amounts to a coup
@@ruthietreselan Okay. Not completely "imaginary." But certainly overstated in the current context, and used to deflect away from any sober analysis of what is actually happening.
@@straightup7upthey got those people arrested too lol
Robbery thinks he is doing a favor to us by doing this show .
1:25 "It is dangerous to be right in matters on which the established authorities are wrong."
-Voltaire
1:38 "If Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy."
-James Madison
Amazed at how energized Bri is on this when it didn't seem like she was nearly as energized about the violence of mostly peaceful protesting of 2020. On average I'd say the pro Israeli demonstrators have been at least as peaceful by any objective measure. And of course she casually disregards the rights of Jewish students and others to move freely on campus and attend the classes they paid for.🤔 Bottom line, if we want to avoid violence, everyone's rights need to be respected and defended by government. When you allow lesser transgressions against some because you support the cause, it will lead to bigger conflict as people lose their faith in the law.
YT is not letting ppl see the cnn interview btw.
Ilan Pappe is a left wing Israeli scholar, writes very proPalestinian history books. I'm not sure that was made explicit but it makes a difference in why he was interrogated.
Robby you are so lame.
Robbie is sus👀👀
Anti-genocide is not pro-Palestine.
Interesting. Good report
The irony of the people who support the side that starts the war being labeled as “anti-war”
76 years of occupation and land theft and settler colonialism...
To everyone here: this is what happens when your "protest" becomes so personal that it morphs into anti-Jew hatred. I'm surprised by any of this, or the rampant antisemitic rhetoric seeping on this board. Disgusting.
It's hard to claim anti-Jew when there are actual Jews protesting against the war and Jenna Side. So I guess that makes you Pro Jenna Side then.
Bobby is a wicked person
Like mother, like son......
Robbie calling people wierdos is hilarious to me.
Imagine if cnn did thid to blm! Lol
Briahna: "It is disorienting to say at the least to think that someone who would engage in this kind of vigilante violence is now trying to do it in safe, state sanctioned way."
Disorienting? I would be surprised to see any other result. Oh Pleeeze--Could you get that guy from Belfast back on? He adds so much gravitas to your dialogue. All Robbie
needs is a top hat, a monocle and a butterfly to sartorially express his world view.
Anti-LGBTQ events, trump supporter, and antisemitism. Brie of course ties those 3 things together....
What ties all three of those events?
Wow CNN I don’t recognize you and your newly found talent of journalistic investigation!
weird is an understatement
no images, nothing caught on camera
The allegation of being violent fanatics is a correct one but it should be directed at the Zionists, not the Palestinian supporters.
Why is Robbie back!?? Nooo!
If you don't like this country just leave
WAIT so the parents are signing up their child to the IDF, that sounds like child abuse frankly
Also Illan being detained and asked to resolve the conflict is ABSURD
I wonder which will give up first?
Yasher Koach Edan! And best wishes for a nesiah tovah!! IY"H you will continue to do all of us here in the BH, etc. communities proud (even if we don't know you!)!
*OMG!!! They detained Ilan Pappe?????*
An assault occurs when a person is in fear of being in unwanted contact. That means getting in someone’s face and forcing them to move around is NOT bullying it is an assault.
Robbie is on rising to represent a right wing view but as this crisis continues to unfold, I see him struggling to contribute anything substantial to the conversation. I like to imagine that, inside, his perspective is changing but he must stay 'in character' for the sake of the show. A boy can dream.
Wide Woke Briana continues