Yes, im getting ditches on my cheeks from the tears..... Malone looked in total exctasy playing especially the lion's roar... from that to an extreme sadness, pain, despair.... sending hug waves wherever his spirit is... Rest In Power, Master of Low Frequencies...
@@theHumanBryno definitely he was unique. I mean, any musician (not only drummers - I am a bass player) who grew up listening to Human and Cynic (his other stuff as well like the first Gordian Knot album) know that it was a whole different ball game. I know a lot of people that mention Gene Hoglan as THE greatest drummer in Death, but for me it was always Reinert. I know, this is no competition. But... Anyway, true giant, a musical genius.
@@andredelemosfreixo1975 It's weird, it's never occurred to me to rank the Death drummers, they're all awesome and bring different things to the table. I think Sean embodied what it means to play musically.
@@andredelemosfreixo1975 Sean, Gene and Richard are/were all insanely good drummers, each with his own style, but yeah, Sean was Sean. Absolutely nobody sounds like him.
"Saddened by the death of a bass brother. Without any hyperbole; a true legend. Sean Malone is basically responsible for an entire genre of metal bass playing. Very influential and definitively ahead of the rest of us". Steve Di Giorgio - 10/12/20
Same here. I was a teenager, and never heard of or even seen some of the words/terms they were using in their lyrics, like Uroboric, Maya, Cosmic Mother, Sri Cosmic Sea, etc. And that's not saying anything about the actual compositions... This band literally changed my life, without hyperbole.
Fuck. RIP Reinert, and now RIP Malone. Malone's basslines touched my heart. Can't believe these two genius are not with us. Sean Malone Forever! Sean Reinert Forever! CYNIC Forever!
RIP Sean and Sean. This video is especially tragic and bittersweet. It was the last time that Reinert and Malone would play together in Cynic but also Sean Reinert and Paul were mere days away from a contentious breakup that they would never recover from. 😪
RIP Sean Malone. Your music and fretless bass technique will remain forever in our memory and heart, you were, are and will be a great influence for fretless bassists
I still can’t believe I’ll be commenting this, in the same year when Sean Reinert also passed away... RIP Sean Malone. Hoping this was just a bad dream I could wake up to.
I'll say this - Reinert and Malone were the best rhythm section ever. I cannot fathom the amount of talent and knowledge they possessed. It seems so unbelievable that both of them are not with us anymore. It just can't be
@@mrdeathamore Очень знакомое ощущение, к сожалению... Они для меня эталон ритм-секции в прогрессивной музыке. Везде, где бы они ни играли вместе, создавалось нечто магическое. Они столько всего сказали своим талантом и музыкой, но этого никогда не будет достаточно. Теперь уже точно
I saw them live with Sean in Madrid with my band...what a great musicians, awesome energy. Before them where playing other prog metal bands but when Cynic started, the whole atmosphere changed, they begun with a pray, all of them on their knee, the stage was cleaned, with no amps, only with their fractal fx, in ear, Sean had a methacrylate (transparent plastic for the acoustics, isolate the drum kit). Great memories...unique Band! Greetings from Santiago de Chile
If only the Seans could know the positive reverberations they helped to create in my life with Cynic... Btw I am really grateful for all of their music. R.I.P What a year...
It's incredibly sad to think we don't have two of these musicians with us, and that a performance like this is no longer a possibility. Makes me treasure this performance even more. RIP Sean Malone and Sean Reinert. Paul, please keep doing music forever. We need it.
its simply unbelievable how come this set of musicians dont have the deserved magnitude of recognition. in 100 years these songs will be actual and timeless, not to mention the artistic and technical level displayed. I had the privilege of seeing them live. one of a kind band
honestly i always thought no one can share the "death growl" throne with Chuck( for me), until I listened to Focus. always wondered why didnt you continue with music?
47:53 Seeing all of them together, looking for each other, sharing this frecuency of feeling and being part of one living moment, truly breaks my heart thinking about this was one of the last times that they were together as a band mates... they really inspires me to grow in music. Thank you guys; Paul here in this 3D experience and both Seans on the eternity
Goddamn that's a powerful bass tone from Sean Malone and the beats and fills from Sean Reinert just makes it all sound so perfect😮 Flawless even. I hope they're both resting in power and jamming it up somewhere in the spirit world💟
“The lion’s roar” is especially poignant here. They all seem to be enjoying it so much. RIP to the best Seans in the business, may their beautiful music live on forever.
Had I become Cynic's fan only a few months earlier, I would definitely have seen them there in Tokyo or Osaka where this video was recorded. Missing that opportunity will be one of the most regrettable things in my life. Rest in peace, Sean Reinert and Sean Malone. I will always remember the sounds you created.
I'm so glad this video exists. It's very sad to think that the two Seans ore gone now. But at least here we can see them playing like the kings they were in life.
A beautiful sound of an amazing band performing incredibly live note for note, R.i.P the Legend that Sean Malony was and always will be....my heart go to his all his family amd friend and fans, what a great musician and a great band they truly are....
None has topped these guys. Thing is that despite the complexity and difficulty of their chops they DO NOT OVERPLAY. It's a very natural fluid expression that serves feeling. I've been to a small gig of Cynic (was a luxury) mostly filled with musicians in audience, all jaw dropped and you can try fixed on the double pedal and hat, the fretless, the crazy legatto... but in the end you get drowned by the beautiful music, which I might add was like a tornado of love and hate, sadness and joy, peace and war... all mixed together in such a natural way. What an amazing experience.
I get it...you want it to be "really" live....but as a life long Cynic fan...I am truly grateful to have visuals to go with the incredible songs. You can see the chord changes and solos...Sean R being a fugging Maestro....Sean M showing why he is the most unique bass player I have ever seen. I too have seen this band when they toured with Cannibal Corpse back in the day and 3 times with Robin and Tymon and ALL of those live shows were amazing. There are many live shows from the Traced in Air tour on youtube, but I LOVE that this one features the original core. Thank you Pudding Broadcast for sharing. I loved every minute.
I agree with everything you said...I wish I had seen them with the original lineup, but I got to see them w/ Tymon and Robin three times. And the vocals on Integral Birth are unlistenable, his in ears must have been off or something :|
@@ukman9698 The Integral vocals weren't bad, they were just the only ones that were actually live. Everything else is clearly miming to the studio vocals.
Cynic Live Osaka Japan 00:00 Veil of Maya 06:00 Adam's Murmur 10:30 True Hallucination Speak 16:45 Elves Beam Out 21:42 Moon Heart Sun Head 29:10 The Space for This 36:30 Integral 42:20 Carbon-Based Anatomy 50:20 The Lion's Roar 57:05 Kindly Bent to Free Us
I've watched this so many times in the last couple of weeks. hurts so much that both Sean's are gone. this really was a special collection of amazing people. Very fortunate to still have you around Paul. ❤️❤️❤️
I don't think there has ever been a duo so locked in with each other in all of the history of music, as Sean and Sean were with each other. It's a mind blowing thing to witness. Neither of them makes a single move without the other.
I saw Cynic play in Belfast during their Traced In Air tour. they booked a small venue, the Limelight, which has a maximum capacity of 750 people. me and my buddy arrived to find the venue completely EMPTY save for a handful of fans. when Cynic took the stage, there couldn't have been more than 30 people in the audience. I felt really bad for the band... but it was awesome to hear them play in such an intimate setting. despite the extremely sparse crowd, they gave it their all 100% and played the full 2 hour set. really humble, down-to-earth guys and awesome talent
RIP Sean Malone and Sean Reinert, hope you guys are jamming wherever you are.
two, without any hyperbole, greatest musicians in their game. I doubt someone can argue with that, I will miss both of them with all my heavy heart.
So sad!!
I still can't believe it 😔
Without a doubt, 2020 has been a terrible year for music
RIP, both, Reinert and Malone
😭😭🧡
@@alceled and Neil Peart being one of the first huge musicians of the prog scene who died this year...
*Tries not to cry, cries a lot*
RIP to the best duo of Seans in history.
😭😭😭
😔😔😔
So hard to listen to this performance of integral rn
Yes, im getting ditches on my cheeks from the tears..... Malone looked in total exctasy playing especially the lion's roar... from that to an extreme sadness, pain, despair.... sending hug waves wherever his spirit is... Rest In Power, Master of Low Frequencies...
NO CAP. NOT EVER.
CYNIC FOREVER. AMEN!🙏❤🙌
RIP Sean Reinert. His music will live forever.
Yeah, he pioneered a style that I think a lot of people are still catching up on. He was a very musical player.
@@theHumanBryno definitely he was unique. I mean, any musician (not only drummers - I am a bass player) who grew up listening to Human and Cynic (his other stuff as well like the first Gordian Knot album) know that it was a whole different ball game. I know a lot of people that mention Gene Hoglan as THE greatest drummer in Death, but for me it was always Reinert. I know, this is no competition. But... Anyway, true giant, a musical genius.
@@andredelemosfreixo1975 It's weird, it's never occurred to me to rank the Death drummers, they're all awesome and bring different things to the table. I think Sean embodied what it means to play musically.
@@theHumanBryno some people do. I also like them all, they were all great.
@@andredelemosfreixo1975 Sean, Gene and Richard are/were all insanely good drummers, each with his own style, but yeah, Sean was Sean. Absolutely nobody sounds like him.
"Saddened by the death of a bass brother. Without any hyperbole; a true legend. Sean Malone is basically responsible for an entire genre of metal bass playing. Very influential and definitively ahead of the rest of us". Steve Di Giorgio - 10/12/20
I would have never found my way to Buddhism without Cynic. I owe them BIG TIME.
Same here. I was a teenager, and never heard of or even seen some of the words/terms they were using in their lyrics, like Uroboric, Maya, Cosmic Mother, Sri Cosmic Sea, etc.
And that's not saying anything about the actual compositions...
This band literally changed my life, without hyperbole.
Sean Malone is amazing.
I think is the best fretless player with Gary Willis
have you ever hear about dominic "forest" lapointe¿¿
+oscar cz yeah, i listen and appreciate beyond creation too :)
Michael Manring.
Does anybody know the model of the bass he uses on Carbon based anatomy?
Fuck. RIP Reinert, and now RIP Malone. Malone's basslines touched my heart. Can't believe these two genius are not with us.
Sean Malone Forever!
Sean Reinert Forever!
CYNIC Forever!
RIP Sean and Sean. This video is especially tragic and bittersweet. It was the last time that Reinert and Malone would play together in Cynic but also Sean Reinert and Paul were mere days away from a contentious breakup that they would never recover from. 😪
I would pay thousands of dollars to see them live one last time...
The greatest rhythm section of all time and they are gone. It sucks, man. Glad we have the music and live videos to remember them by.
Best rhythmic session I ever heard. Sean Malone and Sean Reinert playing together are just a indescribable pleasure.
beautifully said
Beautifully sad 😭 RIP
Malone is in bass exctasy during the lion's roar!!
Amen!
RIP Sean Malone. I can't believe the rhythm section of Cynic has passed away this year. Truly the worst year ever :(
God dude it hurts so bad. Childhood heroes
@@evanrobbins5915 I think Paul was doing new Cynic album and Malone played for it.
omg i just found out, hasn't been even 10 days since he passed, that's so sad
@@dekipopica right now he is in a recording process! Sean also played on couple of Paul's solo album songs!
@@Alex-yq2uy It has been long time since Cynic has done new album, can't wait to hear it!
last show ever of Cynic with Reinert :( Thanks for All Sean, RIP
And the second last with Malone.
@@Omnatten9 :(
RIP Sean Malone and Sean Reinert, brilliant musicians!
I still cannot belive this, great musicians is in heaven, hope, Death, after Cynic... Sean Reinert, my favourite drummer....
Adams murmur is a god damned masterpiece
RIP Sean Malone. Your music and fretless bass technique will remain forever in our memory and heart, you were, are and will be a great influence for fretless bassists
I still can’t believe I’ll be commenting this, in the same year when Sean Reinert also passed away... RIP Sean Malone. Hoping this was just a bad dream I could wake up to.
I'll say this - Reinert and Malone were the best rhythm section ever. I cannot fathom the amount of talent and knowledge they possessed. It seems so unbelievable that both of them are not with us anymore. It just can't be
Нам будет их не хватать... не чудо ли - никогда людей в жизни не встречал, а они успели стать родными.
@@mrdeathamore Очень знакомое ощущение, к сожалению... Они для меня эталон ритм-секции в прогрессивной музыке. Везде, где бы они ни играли вместе, создавалось нечто магическое. Они столько всего сказали своим талантом и музыкой, но этого никогда не будет достаточно. Теперь уже точно
The thing I love is that neither were into metal, they just played there own stuff together and it made this... Whew.
@@bullo247 Yeah, you're right! That is one of the countless reasons why they were so special. Their taste in phrasing was so perfect.
@@bullo247 When jazz musicians make metal, we get the best stuff.
RIP Sean Malone, youll never forgotten!
Legends Never Die.
I saw them live with Sean in Madrid with my band...what a great musicians, awesome energy. Before them where playing other prog metal bands but when Cynic started, the whole atmosphere changed, they begun with a pray, all of them on their knee, the stage was cleaned, with no amps, only with their fractal fx, in ear, Sean had a methacrylate (transparent plastic for the acoustics, isolate the drum kit). Great memories...unique Band! Greetings from Santiago de Chile
If only the Seans could know the positive reverberations they helped to create in my life with Cynic... Btw I am really grateful for all of their music. R.I.P
What a year...
It's incredibly sad to think we don't have two of these musicians with us, and that a performance like this is no longer a possibility.
Makes me treasure this performance even more. RIP Sean Malone and Sean Reinert.
Paul, please keep doing music forever. We need it.
I just love how the bassist mutes so adeptly. Adds a lot of depth to the instrument.
His stops are so fast. Like a robot bassist. Serious technique!
their musicianship is something to admire. I'm blown away
A band made entirely of Master Musicians, in the truest sense.
Truth. Integrity. Strength. Thanks a lot Cynic for the beautiful MUSIC you gave the whole world in the last 25 years.
Amen!
its simply unbelievable how come this set of musicians dont have the deserved magnitude of recognition. in 100 years these songs will be actual and timeless, not to mention the artistic and technical level displayed. I had the privilege of seeing them live. one of a kind band
Kinda cool to hear my voice made it to Japan 😂
Rest In Peace Sean and Sean
Hail Epitaph!
you should have went too!
honestly i always thought no one can share the "death growl" throne with Chuck( for me), until I listened to Focus. always wondered why didnt you continue with music?
Tony!!! That's sick dude! Surprised to see you here! - a fellow Travis Sago follower :)
Dynamo 1994 is still the concert that had the most impact of everything I have seen live since.
RIP Sean Malone fucking legend...half of Cynic gone in one year :(
47:53 Seeing all of them together, looking for each other, sharing this frecuency of feeling and being part of one living moment, truly breaks my heart thinking about this was one of the last times that they were together as a band mates... they really inspires me to grow in music.
Thank you guys; Paul here in this 3D experience and both Seans on the eternity
❤🩹🌎
Man, half of Cynic gone in 2020.... Malone and Reinert...R.I.P. thanks for the awesome music from both Cynic and Gordian Knot.. 😔
I truly felt how deep in the zone Malone was at Lion´s Roar, he became connected to his instrument.
How the hell are there downvotes????
Duelling Sean's of awesomeness. RIP 😪
What else can you rob us of 2020?
Rest In Peace ean Reinert. He was a genius. We lost a legend.
Goddamn that's a powerful bass tone from Sean Malone and the beats and fills from Sean Reinert just makes it all sound so perfect😮 Flawless even.
I hope they're both resting in power and jamming it up somewhere in the spirit world💟
RIP Sean Reinert.
“The lion’s roar” is especially poignant here. They all seem to be enjoying it so much. RIP to the best Seans in the business, may their beautiful music live on forever.
Grande Sean Malone.... wonderful... RIP Sean Reinert incredeible drummer one of a kind.... without words..
Legendary trio. You'll never be forgotten.
we are so fortunate to have this footage of the seans playing together, playing some of the best music of our time
Didn't know Michael J Fox plays bass for Cynic! Great!
lmaooo
+Samuel Kremer He shakes things up a bit...
+Matt Beckman pack it in, boys. were done here.
Paul was the one playing like he had Parkinson's.
jejeje..
Best rhythmic session ever. Rip Sean Malone and Sean Reinert, you where both beyond compare...
Amen!
The world misses talent like the Sean's had. Paul's loving tribute to them was terrific. Love Cynic forever.
RIP Sean Malone, best bassist of my generation
15 years later I still can't get enough of Traced in Air.
That intro to Carbon-Based Anatomy struck something deep in me. Wow.
Man that performance was transcending. This video has to be preserved!
@@Jordy666sic Agreed!
Rest In Peace to the two best Seans I’ve ever known.
RIP Sean Malone. Your departure was really unexpected. Such a brilliant mind he was.
One of the greatest to ever sit behind the kit. RIP Sean
Had I become Cynic's fan only a few months earlier, I would definitely have seen them there in Tokyo or Osaka where this video was recorded. Missing that opportunity will be one of the most regrettable things in my life. Rest in peace, Sean Reinert and Sean Malone. I will always remember the sounds you created.
me too. i became their huge fan just weeks after they had their only gig in Belgrade (Euro tour for Traced in Air).
Imagine being in a musical school and you have Sean Malone as teacher.
Malone's playing here is 100% some of the best in music, ever.
Wow.
Maybe! this is the one and only best quality footage of Cynic :)
RIP both Seans 😢
I'm so glad this video exists. It's very sad to think that the two Seans ore gone now. But at least here we can see them playing like the kings they were in life.
Such an amazing band with 2 of them right here that passed before their time.
I'm really sad that my favorite drummer and favorite bassist passed away too soon. They will live on through their extraordinary musical works.
RIP to both legends. Masvidal has a big responsibility to humanity to keep this going somehow. Cynic is just so special.
A beautiful sound of an amazing band performing incredibly live note for note, R.i.P the Legend that Sean Malony was and always will be....my heart go to his all his family amd friend and fans, what a great musician and a great band they truly are....
rest in peace sean malone and sean reinhert, your music was life changing and timeless.
R.I.P. Sean Malone! What a sad year!
RIP Sean Malone and Sean Reinert...surelly both of you have trascend the veil of maya!
None has topped these guys.
Thing is that despite the complexity and difficulty of their chops they DO NOT OVERPLAY. It's a very natural fluid expression that serves feeling.
I've been to a small gig of Cynic (was a luxury) mostly filled with musicians in audience, all jaw dropped and you can try fixed on the double pedal and hat, the fretless, the crazy legatto... but in the end you get drowned by the beautiful music, which I might add was like a tornado of love and hate, sadness and joy, peace and war... all mixed together in such a natural way. What an amazing experience.
Words cannot explain how important this video is. Very grateful that it was posted. RIP Sean Malone and Reinert
RIP Sean, RIP Sean! Cynic 4ever!!!!!!!
Watching this beautiful show today with tears, how talented both Sean were, you are truly missed
I get it...you want it to be "really" live....but as a life long Cynic fan...I am truly grateful to have visuals to go with the incredible songs. You can see the chord changes and solos...Sean R being a fugging Maestro....Sean M showing why he is the most unique bass player I have ever seen. I too have seen this band when they toured with Cannibal Corpse back in the day and 3 times with Robin and Tymon and ALL of those live shows were amazing. There are many live shows from the Traced in Air tour on youtube, but I LOVE that this one features the original core. Thank you Pudding Broadcast for sharing. I loved every minute.
+William Cole ....also...don't get me wrong...would have loved a few more from Focus as well.... and Integral Birth vocals were pretty bad...lol
I agree with everything you said...I wish I had seen them with the original lineup, but I got to see them w/ Tymon and Robin three times. And the vocals on Integral Birth are unlistenable, his in ears must have been off or something :|
@@ukman9698 The Integral vocals weren't bad, they were just the only ones that were actually live. Everything else is clearly miming to the studio vocals.
the last few measures of Veil of Maya are pure magic
I learned the whole song on bass recently. The whole thing is magical, but yes that outro is just gorgeous
Such a clean version of Space for This, not the easiest tune to play live ^^ ... RIP Sean & Sean. And we love you Paul
One of the best rhythm section players are together again, jamming it out somewhere in the skies.
every thunder storm is their jams bro
Still can’t believe both Seans passed away in 2020. They were both musical titans.
Life sometimes is really ruthless. These two guys were master in their work, even so..
so sad they left too soon.
Reinert, Masvidal & Malone, really awesome gig. Thanks for all guys.
This is probably like one of the best live band videos ever to be honest
rip Sean and Sean. You'll never really die while I live and remember, and listen to these tunes. The most intense and important music ever to me.
I would give up a lot of things to travel back in time to see this
A priceless piece of recording. Thanks to you for making these guys immortal. RIP Sean & Sean.
Sean Reinert playing is amazing, love the mix of power and technical jazz elements.
Long live, Cynic. Truly masterful musicians.
Norway 2007 is hq too
Cynic Live Osaka Japan
00:00 Veil of Maya
06:00 Adam's Murmur
10:30 True Hallucination Speak
16:45 Elves Beam Out
21:42 Moon Heart Sun Head
29:10 The Space for This
36:30 Integral
42:20 Carbon-Based Anatomy
50:20 The Lion's Roar
57:05 Kindly Bent to Free Us
Andres Centellas Thanks.
Cuanto sae ❤️
@@felipeobregonochoa6654 mi legado
Where is "How Could I"???
Thanks
I've watched this so many times in the last couple of weeks. hurts so much that both Sean's are gone. this really was a special collection of amazing people. Very fortunate to still have you around Paul. ❤️❤️❤️
I don't think there has ever been a duo so locked in with each other in all of the history of music, as Sean and Sean were with each other. It's a mind blowing thing to witness. Neither of them makes a single move without the other.
holy shit, sean malone!!
32:52 on is one of my favorite moments from Cynic, Sean Malone and Sean Reinert were so so good together. RIP{ legends, Thanks for this vid!
These dudes are really good, the drummer is a badass
RIP SEAN MALONE . WHAT TALENT
RIP Sean Malone. So sad to see 2 of them already gone now.
Great live band! I saw them as support for Dream Theater and it was a blast. Far better than Dream Theater that evening.
Sean Reinert's playing was like a powerful and serene stream of pure musicality and grace
Rest in peace Sean Malone!
RIP Sean Malone. Una gran tristeza este año....
Feel very sad watching this, RIP Sean, & thx for the mind bending, beautiful music.
rest in peace. Sean and Sean ...
I saw Cynic play in Belfast during their Traced In Air tour. they booked a small venue, the Limelight, which has a maximum capacity of 750 people. me and my buddy arrived to find the venue completely EMPTY save for a handful of fans. when Cynic took the stage, there couldn't have been more than 30 people in the audience. I felt really bad for the band... but it was awesome to hear them play in such an intimate setting. despite the extremely sparse crowd, they gave it their all 100% and played the full 2 hour set. really humble, down-to-earth guys and awesome talent
We miss both Seans, we really do. This video must be preserved for the future generations.
rip sean and sean - i discovered your talent too late
So sad and yet so beautiful that they played at least together live in the end.
what a sound man! CHILL
I demand a Traced In Air remix with Malone's bass louder!
They can call it "Re-re-traced"
@@Sean-fv4wi Y'all are in luck cause that's comin out this month
cyniconline.bandcamp.com/album/traced-in-air-remixed
done!
One of the greatest and underrated rhythm sections ever.