MODERN ANTI-AIR VS WW2 TANKS - How Well Can They Do? - WAR THUNDER

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 140

  • @danilstepanchenko9296
    @danilstepanchenko9296 Рік тому +264

    Respect for the BM-13 guy

  • @doge_sevens
    @doge_sevens Рік тому +56

    it was so much fun being included in this one, if anyones wondering i was that m113 adats hiding from the ww2 team in the last day round, i was absolutely terrified the entire time lmao

  • @seasuper3402
    @seasuper3402 Рік тому +114

    I'd loved to have been in this event
    My OTOMATIC would shred everything
    Edit: with the rules you put in place for round 2 there's one vehicle I can think of that would be horrific - T72M2 Moderna since it was developed with the dual role in mind

    • @Pankajn43
      @Pankajn43 Рік тому +4

      how many days before this event happened?

    • @minelo
      @minelo Рік тому

      @@Pankajn43 last Friday

    • @tianhaoju4634
      @tianhaoju4634 Рік тому +9

      The 2S38 too, but I doubt it would do well against filler rounds, since the armor is enough to trigger their fuse

  • @Jojotheowl1
    @Jojotheowl1 Рік тому +24

    That Katyusha player was so surprisingly effective

  • @MPdude237
    @MPdude237 Рік тому +28

    Surprised nobody brought the 2S38. 220mm pen dart rounds would be capable of frontally penetrating most WW2 tanks and the APHE round would also be quite deadly.
    Would also like to Modern vs WW2 SPAA, although I am sure that it will be mostly Wirbelwind, Ostwind, and Kugelblitz on the WW2 side.

    • @lordwintertown8284
      @lordwintertown8284 Рік тому +4

      G'day,
      I'd say that the probable reasoning is they were going by in game classifications which do tend to fail in some regards as the 2S38 is indeed a SPAAG that can also perform the role of a LT.
      Similar could be said for duels with torpedo boats as I don't think I've seen anyone bring a Raubtier class (Type 1924), Elbing class (Type 1939), Chidori class or Uragan class (as designed also known as a Pr.2).
      For the first two are classed as destroyers in game, the third a gunboat & ironically a destroyer in the tutorial while the fourth a patrol ship (although time period wise it's correct).
      Anyway for this event I'm surprised nobody brought a Centurion as it was a 1944 tank design with the Mk.1 entering service one month after VE Day.

  • @ks6487
    @ks6487 Рік тому +10

    The night battle looked like a space battle with all the lasers and missiles flying around

  • @Hamfish2809
    @Hamfish2809 Рік тому +8

    11:53 Maus with panther air defense

  • @Nativeat1YT
    @Nativeat1YT Рік тому +7

    1:55 - Well done Comrade o7

  • @richardgurney100
    @richardgurney100 Рік тому +14

    Imagine the dude who's meant to be out of the hatch controlling that 50 at 10:50...

  • @Proximous-01
    @Proximous-01 Рік тому +5

    11:00 must have been a terrifyingly experience

  • @Add12pack
    @Add12pack Рік тому +22

    Why did I immediately think of the gapard. Things a beast at 8.0

  • @thomashyde9208
    @thomashyde9208 Рік тому +16

    Can we see WW2 spaa vs modern Spaa battle

  • @sa-lp7xd
    @sa-lp7xd Рік тому +1

    3:36
    Wow bro really mastered tanks

  • @thewarroom1944
    @thewarroom1944 Рік тому +2

    Thanks for the opportunity to participate!! Loved the event!
    Edit: Thanks for the shoutout about how I was utilizing angled armor! Kinda just happened without me realizing, lol.

  • @walkerblock6059
    @walkerblock6059 Рік тому +4

    You should have a bunch of type 93s driving around a track while airplanes try and take them out

  • @ericmarsha2103
    @ericmarsha2103 Рік тому +9

    Hard to compete against a missle.. awsome video, great work guys

  • @dumpsterfire42
    @dumpsterfire42 Рік тому +16

    Love your vids really original and fun to watch and participate

  • @metex0019
    @metex0019 Рік тому +2

    11:52 the Maus has some problem whit the phanter XD

    • @Green-aider
      @Green-aider 25 днів тому

      Someone doesn’t know how to spell

  • @bibleman8958
    @bibleman8958 Рік тому +3

    AAAAAA I fucking love the dusk sound track andrew hulshult is amazing an amazing artist reflection of violence is a banger I loved finding it in the wild in the intro. Although I'm more of an endless enjoyer my self.

  • @chasenelson5586
    @chasenelson5586 Рік тому +7

    Liked the video.
    But I domt the rules you set entirely.didn't think belenzpanzer or the Italian 60/80 as spaa, always thought they were light tanks with spaa capacity. Lavs are in the same boat as above. Was expecting sgt York's, falcons, 2s6's, adats, atomatics, gepards and anything thats primary role was by design air defence. The all-purpose platforms that do everything I tend to put into ifv territory generally.

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +3

      Thank you and yeah makes sense. It was hard to figure out if it would make sense to include vehicles that served in a duel role capacity or not

  • @kanyewestlover.223
    @kanyewestlover.223 Рік тому +4

    It’s interesting why nobody used the otomatic because it’s 75mm cannon

  • @Eyeless_Camper
    @Eyeless_Camper Рік тому +12

    Modern Anti air? Seeing plenty of ADATS tank destroyers sneaking in there. :P

    • @E.hexzor
      @E.hexzor Рік тому

      It literally stands for Air Defence Anti Tank so really shouldn't have been included.

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +6

      From what I understand is that some vehicles are classified and served in both SPAA and ground. These were only allowed in certain rounds to test them out.

    • @Eyeless_Camper
      @Eyeless_Camper Рік тому

      @@ThunderWithMuffin saw them in the round 1 footage.

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +4

      @@Eyeless_Camper oh I see what happened. Gaijin has the ADATS classified as an SPAA and the rules I told the participants for round one is that it has to be classified as an SPAA

    • @robertharris6092
      @robertharris6092 Рік тому +4

      Well its just a SAM missile first that was given the ability to destroy tanks incase of an enemergency second.

  • @Chaffee_
    @Chaffee_ Рік тому +4

    Truly one of the battles of all time

  • @NotTheBomb
    @NotTheBomb Рік тому +2

    Sturmtiger! Represent! 10/10 to that chad

  • @anoob1000
    @anoob1000 Рік тому +1

    The otomatic would be overpowered because it has an apfsds that pens 300mm of armor and can fire every 0.5 seconds

  • @realityhits8099
    @realityhits8099 Рік тому +1

    This was so fun to watch good job guys!

  • @hugorodin4780
    @hugorodin4780 Рік тому +3

    Great work love your vids…

  • @TheOreoOverlord
    @TheOreoOverlord Рік тому +2

    I'm thinking the AMX-30 DCA would have been a beast. Although it lacks a STAB, the 110 pen APDS it shoots would be devastating I bet

  • @merafirewing6591
    @merafirewing6591 Рік тому +1

    Perfect amount of chaos.

  • @ericdoesstuff7568
    @ericdoesstuff7568 Рік тому

    The "Respawning to watch" was more than likely a hindrance than anything, it 100% seemed like people respawned multiple times

  • @LogI_Bear
    @LogI_Bear Рік тому +2

    I love the night battles there always chaotic

  • @zanstyled5185
    @zanstyled5185 Рік тому

    6:38 nice decal dude

  • @johnjeremiahpuno2359
    @johnjeremiahpuno2359 Рік тому +2

    Imagine taking all those spaa rounds and your GPU dies.

  • @HUNDIRO-main
    @HUNDIRO-main Рік тому +1

    the last round really iss chaoss

  • @MichaelRosenblum_Emp500
    @MichaelRosenblum_Emp500 Рік тому +2

    LOL THE BM13 PLAYER getting 4 kills 😂

  • @BaseSerpentMessmer
    @BaseSerpentMessmer Рік тому +2

    Rematch of modern jets v.s. ww2 prop planes (f-16 and mig-29)

  • @Geniusinventor
    @Geniusinventor Рік тому +2

    I think maus will do the best because 200 mm armour all round.

  • @PvpSniper656
    @PvpSniper656 Рік тому +2

    the maus who angled today

  • @TheQuax83
    @TheQuax83 Рік тому

    wow the night one looks like a Terminator Film👍

  • @PlayerAfricanChieften
    @PlayerAfricanChieften Рік тому +1

    what kind of level 23 participants you got there on the ww2 tank side 🤣😂😂

  • @SHEEPS_123
    @SHEEPS_123 Рік тому +2

    the beglight and the puma are not anti air, they a IFVs

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому

      Yeah I wasn’t sure if I should or shouldn’t incorporate them since they have duel roles

  • @AdeptusAmogus
    @AdeptusAmogus Рік тому +2

    Yknow, I'm surprised no one mentioned how map design played a key role in this. On wide open maps, SPAA is gonna suffer from lack of range, and they slow speed of missiles. On the close quarters maps, they can use their speed, stabilizers, and turret rotation to absolutely body the slower WW2 tanks.

  • @socksfrog1713
    @socksfrog1713 Рік тому +1

    Bean dip is ham burgered

  • @Thunder_Fun1
    @Thunder_Fun1 Рік тому

    Dang bro i have nothing to say because you're all videos are amazing and cool
    Stay cool dude we love you

  • @_GODSFIGHTER
    @_GODSFIGHTER Рік тому +1

    Respects to the katyusha player

  • @math1ass10
    @math1ass10 Рік тому

    Was that a cover of "wach auf" in the intro? Sounded very familiar.

  • @sdaniel7621
    @sdaniel7621 5 місяців тому

    the one that rocco re was using round 3 16:12

  • @sdaniel7621
    @sdaniel7621 5 місяців тому

    what is the name of the fast firing 6 missile tank that is shown in round 2?

  • @jayp.8360
    @jayp.8360 Рік тому

    what was the heavy tank SPAA in the second game? You can see that blue has a heavy tank but I can't think of any that would qualify

  • @4EPT_yroJIbHblU
    @4EPT_yroJIbHblU Рік тому

    What about pulkzestörer and reserve bi-planes?

  • @coffeenator3219
    @coffeenator3219 Рік тому +1

    Incoming!

  • @LettuceGayming
    @LettuceGayming 9 місяців тому

    Technically the Ystervark was on the table (made in 1980s)

  • @allenliu8820
    @allenliu8820 Рік тому

    Not gonna lie i sorta expected people to use the bmp 2m which does have anti heli missiles

  • @TheNoirag
    @TheNoirag Рік тому

    Kinda surprised i didnt see any LVKV9040 in there

  • @thomashyde9208
    @thomashyde9208 Рік тому +3

    Anyone else notice the phlydaily decal

  • @willgamesbr138
    @willgamesbr138 4 місяці тому

    i didn´t know bradley was a spaa, for me it´s a light tank

  • @the_jingo
    @the_jingo Рік тому

    You should do ww2 vs autocannon only IFV or spaa is fine

  • @Vipixz109
    @Vipixz109 Рік тому

    Im surprised I didn't see any IS-5s

  • @olivierrheaume7186
    @olivierrheaume7186 Рік тому

    I find the spaa that was hiding at the 3rd round in the A or B point

  • @vuksanvucko
    @vuksanvucko Місяць тому

    ww2 tanks seeing ifvs on spaa team:
    Look at what they need to just match OUR POWER

  • @Sol103-06
    @Sol103-06 Рік тому

    Wonder if he saw my suggestion, or if it was just a coincidence

  • @Vladimir-fr8le
    @Vladimir-fr8le Рік тому

    I once shot and destroyed a T-80 tank with a tiger 2 (battle rating was like 11.0) so fun xd

  • @gojigameplay3665
    @gojigameplay3665 Рік тому

    Respect to the begleitpanzers

  • @castro619a
    @castro619a Рік тому +4

    Bradley and BMP shouldn’t be allowed. Those destroy modern tanks lol

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +1

      From what I understand is they serve both as a classified SPAA and ground with mixed roles as a vehicle. These types were only allowed in certain rounds.

    • @castro619a
      @castro619a Рік тому

      @@ThunderWithMuffin but those are too OP even against MBT

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому +1

      @@castro619a yeah it was hard to figure out since they serve as a duel role whether to include them. I asked the participants if we should and if I remember they voted to have them included since they said it make sense

  • @robertharris6092
    @robertharris6092 Рік тому

    Why would anyone take the is2 over the is2 1944

  • @armorist_8712
    @armorist_8712 Рік тому

    Whats the intro song

  • @achmadj7151
    @achmadj7151 Рік тому

    ATGM carrier vs Maus maybe🤔

  • @shikikanaz4624
    @shikikanaz4624 Рік тому

    Id be so sure that spaa team would main adats for the rockets

  • @scottloader5985
    @scottloader5985 Рік тому

    do WW1 vs WW2

  • @noahhyman7450
    @noahhyman7450 Рік тому

    bi planes vs modern MBT

  • @Sanchizes
    @Sanchizes Рік тому

    why didn’t you add to anti-aircraft guns 2с38?

  • @microraptor1155
    @microraptor1155 Рік тому +1

    Am I the only one to find that they spelt infinite wrong?

  • @GRAT28
    @GRAT28 Рік тому

    The Welsh flag decal

  • @D4rk3mperor
    @D4rk3mperor Рік тому +1

    How about modern heli vs ww2 planes?

  • @vigge8274
    @vigge8274 Рік тому

    I would have taken the lvkv9040c it’s just a strf that thinks it’s spaa

  • @johnloewinbagano4796
    @johnloewinbagano4796 Рік тому

    Object 279 vs Object 279
    THE 279 WAR

  • @aminyashed10
    @aminyashed10 Рік тому

    Surprised there is no 2S38

  • @coolusername56284
    @coolusername56284 Рік тому

    Please do ww2 light tanks vs ww2 hea y tanks

  • @ertreno2415
    @ertreno2415 Рік тому

    Oh yea

  • @JESUS-airsoft_
    @JESUS-airsoft_ Рік тому

    Why there was a puma with aa team?

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому

      From what I understand it also has AA capabilities/weaponry and qualifies as a vehicle that can also serve in an SPAA role. The second round included these types

  • @lotzi1534
    @lotzi1534 Рік тому

    song in in the intro? :)

    • @locke5264
      @locke5264 Рік тому

      You know it finally? Looking for it too

  • @MASTERGAMINGLEVEL100
    @MASTERGAMINGLEVEL100 Рік тому

    i was the t34 in the 2nd battle that got bulled lol

  • @n1co2017
    @n1co2017 Рік тому

    modern spaa: falcon or za-35 go brrrrrrrr

  • @Jojotheowl1
    @Jojotheowl1 Рік тому

    The bagel is not an SPAA…

  • @Jojotheowl1
    @Jojotheowl1 Рік тому

    Neither is the TAM…

  • @ronaljhernandezramirez4565
    @ronaljhernandezramirez4565 Рік тому

    saca mas contenido de esto

  • @armymanaka360
    @armymanaka360 Рік тому

    Falcon go brrr

  • @ladanielbennett4606
    @ladanielbennett4606 Рік тому

    Yes I made it here early

  • @conalmacfarlane2037
    @conalmacfarlane2037 Рік тому

    OTOMATIC would dominate

  • @vehhckwwyt
    @vehhckwwyt Рік тому

    the is-3 was produced during 1945, but had no battle record in 1945, it is still a WWII tank

  • @genericgermangamer4177
    @genericgermangamer4177 Рік тому

    Ww2 tanks then there is a m41

  • @kaitotara734
    @kaitotara734 Рік тому

    What, chi idk destroyer Japan survive more than t34.....

  • @Prisoner4245
    @Prisoner4245 Рік тому +1

    Muffin DADDY REPLY PLEASE

  • @call_me_chanka5258
    @call_me_chanka5258 Рік тому

    IFV=/=spaa

    • @ThunderWithMuffin
      @ThunderWithMuffin  Рік тому

      Yeah I wasn’t sure if I should or shouldn’t incorporate them since they have duel roles

  • @nick230699
    @nick230699 Рік тому

    Half the ww2 is not ww2

  • @niceneasyraps
    @niceneasyraps Рік тому +1

    “Much more easier” “Most Highest Tier” Is English not your first language? Are you Doge? I love your videos but seriously the grammar irks me