The fact that he actually shares it with Jack after he says “I want one of those.” is rather sweet. And Jack promising him to get the chance for shared revenge was also rather nice.
Well they are actually friends, they compete over a lot of things, mostly the Pearl, but when they're not, they're buddies, they must know each other quite well after all, been through some adventures together, and I think, when you are a pirate, you have to learn not to hold grudges over everything. :)
@@shadowsteed15 - I wouldn't go so far as to call them "friends". More like "frenemies". Although in the final film, Jack seems both shocked and saddened by Barbossa's death.
What Blackbeard did to the Pearl was unforgivable to both jack and barbossa. The latter dealt the fatal blow the former ensured that it would stay fatal
I imagine he tried, but with the kind of control Blackbeard had over his Sword, they probably wrapped right back around. Plus, it was likely squeezing it to the point of uselessness
The look Hector gives Jack after Jack gets his hands free very clearly says: "I have no idea how in the blazing fires of Hell you did that, but I've known you long enough not to question it."
They went from “first mate betrayed me, let me kill him” To “our hatred is wasted on old, scarred veterans of life like us. Let the young have their burning hatred...but we can still get under each other’s skin. For...old times sake, yes??”
@@Demaad it came to me. Something I might say if I had an old rival and we both had matured and having a “truce meal sit down”. Then a clink of our glasses would “seal the deal”, so to speak.
*Clink* I'll drink to that mate, I've found hatred too bitter a spice to liberally spread through my life. *Gulp* *Glass slamming on the oak the table is made from.* Now tell me, that time we made port in Tortuga and I saw you trundling that scarlet haired wench with the particular large...cannonshot off to that wonderful little pub...
You can see it in the third movie as well, when they are walking around the corpse of the Kraken and having a heart to heart. I think they both realized that the only way to survive was to respect each other. Barbossa: The world used to be a bigger place, lad. Jack: (shakes head) The world's still the same, there's just less in it.
That's why I love these two. On the surface, they're rivals that are always trying to outdo each other, but deep down they have great respect for the other.
@@HumblePaysan but that would make it 5, he said 4 of you tried to kill me in the past 1 of YOU succeeded which means he meant 1 of the 4 people he pointed out
"Our own ship turned against us." He sounds so heartbroken when he says that. He loved the Pearl as much as Jack and for her to betray him, even if she was forced to by Blackbeard's magic, cuts deeper and sharper than even the loss of his leg.
This has got to be my favorite part in the entire movie. Barbossa's story -- how he lost his leg and his ship -- sends chills up and down my spine every time I hear it. The ghost sounds in the background, the expression in his voice and on his face, the look on Jack's own face as he puts things together...all that together, plus the story itself of course, makes for an intensity unrivaled by any other scene. And I love it.
I think what made the scene work so well, is the fact there was no flashback. All you could do was listen to the voice of the character, to emotions he spewed as he told it, and see the expressions on his face, like the terror in his eyes when said: "Our own ship turned against us!", and the determination when he said: "I'm the master of my fate, not Blackbeard. I'm the master of my fate, NOT Blackbeard. So I did what needed done! I survived."
I love Barbosa’s face when Jack was climbing the coconut tree he was thinking obviously how the flying fuck does he do this shit he always has the weirdest escape attempts and they always work
What I admire about Barbossa is that he always stood as his own man, a true pirate, and a true captain all by himself apart from characters like Will and Elizabeth who seemed to constantly need Jack to save their asses at the end of the day. Even tho he betrayed Jack multiple times, Jack has a lot of mutual respect for him, enough so that he made him his first mate all those years ago. Even now, he knows Barbossa is fully capable & willing to get his revenge on his own but he’s still willing to help due to that mutual respect. Both these men are great characters.
Yes to all of that, but a true captain? He would go down with the ship if he was. I wouldn’t blame him for being hesitant, or if he managed to get everyone to safety first (at least I think that is the exception for captains). But if it’s not, or if he gets over that hesitation, he would go down with that ship as Jack did. “If that ship be sunk properly, you’d be sunk with it.” - Captain Jack Sparrow
@@kieriencrabtree right it didn’t, but Jack didn’t know that yet. Also, I could make the argument that even though it did not sunk, it was defeated still. So, wouldn’t it have been more honorable as a captain to be defeated alongside his ship? I think even in that case, the phrase “the Captain goes down with his ship” would still apply to him.
@@theresedavis2526 I’m sure if Jack lived he would also want to take revenge on Davy Jones for sinking, or taking, his ship in DMC. But Jack was more of a captain by going down with it. It’s not that I don’t like Barbosa, I just think that Jack is the better captain
Barbossa cut off his own leg to escape the ropes, managed to escape and not bleed to death, join the british navy despite being a renowned pirate who had a massive hand in taking down Cutler Beckett, managed to lead an expedition to the fountain of youth in order to kill Blackbeard with one leg and a poisoned blade and proceeded to steal Blackbeard’s sword, crew and ship and use the vessel and magic that previously started this plot of revenge. What an actual legend
@@fancyhat6505true but mind you he was the one who destroyed beckett who was running a rogue operation using the EITC company not the British navy itself barbossa would of been accepted by the British army despite being a pirate he makes a good privateer clever skills with ships ect. The British government was like beckett was a bit of a idiot for taking over port Royal overthrowing swan and other things beckett controlled davy jones but didn't use it fully to his advantage he could of attacked England with the EITC and davey Jones crew why didn't beckett spend lots of money for a invasion of the UK overthrowing the king. Imagine king beckett of the British empire then davey Jones would be like "you know I helped invade England now give me back my ship"
barbossa was introduced as a walking cursed skeleton pirate. He was a legit monster. The fact that he can spin a story that chilling even though the audience has seen him as a monster too is impressive.
I love how Barbossa has wronged Jack so many times yet they still chat here like old friends catching up. I guess when Jack shot and killed him in the first movie he let all his anger and vengeance go in that one bullet.
It's more of a friendly rivalry since he got even with Barbossa in the first film, and fir Barbossa he's had his own lease on life again after being brought back and while he did steal Jack's boat he was still rather cordial in his own way by not leaving him to die like the first time.
@@JTruong3rd Well, from what I remember of At World's End, Jack was one of the Pirate Lords who held one of the nine Pieces of Eight and as Barbossa said, he failed to pass it along to a successor before he died hence why he didn't leave Jack to die when he took the Pearl (again), but I do agree that Jack and Barbossa's relationship is more of a friendly rivalry than outright hatred of each other.
Fun fact : when Jack killed Salazar and killed him one of the crew looks exactly like barbossa but without the beard So jack and hector are first mate because jacks captain likes jack more than barbossa so the captain gave his compass to jack and made him the captain
I love that at 2:01 you can hear the 'Underwater March" song from the first movie (albeit an altered version that ive yet to find); a little callback to the pearl with barbossa's arc.
For me it’s there to signal that while he’s now seemingly weakened (one leg) and has spent two movies as an anti hero he’s still deep down the terrifying, ruthless and deadly pirate from the first movie and that when pushed such as by his desire for revenge that monstrous/villainous side can come back with a-vengeance.
Just shows how truthful and epic Barbossa was. Like seriously, taking one's leg just to survive is absolutely nuts! It also gave this character even more history and character!
Hector and Jack have this sort of relationship kind of similar to Goku and Vegeta, or Xavier and Magneto. They are rivals, and they do have different views in which counter act each other but they don't necessarily want to see the other dead.
@@AbysmalGaming well, death in Dbz is a joke anyway so it hardly matters. besides vegeta kinda dropped that whole thing after years of getting used to goku and eventually accepting him as his rival. you can't get stronger yourself if you have no motivation to get stronger.
@@nubreed13 Barbosa betrayed him and stole his ship, so Jack killed him. The debt was paid and they were even after that. Barbosa just happened to have been resurrected, same as Jack himself. As far as Jack is concerned, they're even.
Barbossa (AWE): "Aye. Isla De Muerta, remember? You shot me." Barbossa (OST) "...including the brutal theft of one used, twisted, hairy right leg!" I like it that Barbossa never held true grudge against Jack for killing him (as if he has a sense of honor to recognize his defeat as a fair one in the fair one-on-one combat) unlike what he felt for Blackbeard for his victory in much more less honorable and fair fight, which cost him Pearl, his crew, his leg, his life of piracy and so on.
"TAKEN not lost" I like how Barbosa emphasize on that because if the pearl was lost, he definitely would've gone down with her as stated by jack earlier in the film
It's scenes like this that simultaneously make you understand why Jack made Barbosa his first mate all those years back........and yet, question that decision all the more! They are shown to share a certain kindred spirit, level-headedness and intelligence, and, under the right circumstances, work well together! But, at the same time, it's their similarities that work against them, and usually wind up driving a wedge between them. They're both proud, ambitious men, and in spite of their level heads, intelligence and abilities to solve and get out of the problems that plague them with relative ease......and that causes them to butt heads.......They both, in spite of their friendship, or at least, mutual respect, past or present, feel that need to outdo the other......the need to be on top, no matter the cost......Which, really, when you think about it, is the root of their problems.......
It feels almost subtle how they put genuine fear in Barbossa’s face and eyes when he recounts the taking of the Pearl. If I didn’t know any better I’d think they wanted him to suffer from ptsd
"I am master of my fate" - true Captain, true mentallity. Also all that love-hate bromance between Hector and Jack, and honestly pegleg being coolest object in the series (not Heart, not Pearl, not Trident, not calices, but pegleg) really makes this scene stand out, and for me one of the best in the series, despite Stranger Tides being weakest of the films
Geoffrey Rush's acting in this scene is top notch. This man has been an undead skeleton, gone to hell and back twice, fought a sea battle in the heart of a maelstrom and committed countless merciless crimes as a pirate. And in all that time, nothing scared him like Blackbeard did.
1:18 Man Jack's face alone says so much He knows exactly what Barbossa has seen and knows all about Blackbeard's powers, but he can't even imagine how hard it would be for him and Barbossa to watch the Black Pearl turn against them.
It's a great piece of chemistry. Granted, they've tried to kill each other multiple times before, (one of them even succeeded), but when a third party starts to take away their beloved ship, they always team up. Because no one takes away their Black Pearl.
Hector and Edward were contrast and complements at the same time. They both had daughters, they both came back from the death, and they both controlled the power of Triton as well as command of the Queen Anne Revenge. That being said there was a major difference, while Edward would happily sacrifice his own daughter to the fountain for immortality...Hector sacrificed himself to save his own daughter, getting swallowed by the sea.
God knows Barbossa's lucky 2 be alive, to survive that I tell Ya, That's 1 heck of Pirate right there ladies and gentlemen, if not the best, then most certainly one of the Best.
I think he cut of his leg due to the rope being "alive". So even if he did cut off the rope, it would still wrap around him and cut off the blood circulation to his leg... it's literally the same thing as having no limb if you have a cursed rope stuck on you for life... (until you meet Blackbeard again)
@@Blokewood3 Perhaps the rope couldn't tell the leg was no longer attached to his body. Whereas if the rope was cut, it'd realize that and wrap around him again.
@@Blokewood3 Because the rope doesnt have eyes and it will only react if black beard commands it too. From what I see blackbeard wasnt looking too barbossa thats why he had his chance to his leg only leaving the leg just be sure that rope still think its him.
1:25 "Our own ship turned against us." In truth that does actually make sense. Think of everything the Black Pearl has been through throughout the entirety of it's story: Being sunken then resurfaced by Davy Jones, becoming cursed because the pirates she was carrying were to greedy for their own good, having been broken and damaged by the kraken then dragged back into the depths by it because Jack tried to run from his debt with Jones, was stuck down in Davy Jones' locker for a while, came back then shortly after had to fight the Flying Dutchman in a typhoon, and then it was finally given a conscience by Black Beard and with the realization of everything that had happened to itself over the years she turned on her crew for everything those pirates had done to her.
"But I'd give my left arm for a chance at blackbeard". "Not your right?" "I need my good arm to drive my poisoned blade through his heart". Barbosa: ambitious but practical Not many people have that combo.
What i love about this scene is that it doesn't take away from Geoffrey Rush's performance at all. It allows Barbossa's story to play out in our own mind, imagining the terror the crew must have felt. A lesser filmmaker would have cut away to a flashback.
@@theresedavis2526 i was about to say, they hated the curse, immortality isn't worth a piece of eight if you can't even enjoy even the basic feelings of life like taste or feel
You know this scene would make a great flashback of what had transpired as the movie lacked a ship-to-ship battle this would be the perfect time to show it as a flashback while Hector narrates culminating in his escape from Blackbeard and his crew.
I’ve heard a lot of people ask, why didn’t Barbosa just cut the rope around his leg instead of his leg itself? My theory is that, the enchantment or black magic of Black Beards sword strengthened the the ropes so they couldn’t be cut.
"I'd give me left arm for a chance at Blackbeard" "not your right?" "I need me good arm to drive me poisoned blade into him" it's like he actually thought it through like "I'd give me right-no wait, need that one."
He sunk the ship that Barbossa and Jack fought over for 3 movies, presumably killed the Pearls crew, and put Barbossa in a situation where he was left with two options. 1.) Go down with the ship as a good captain would, or 2.) Take his leg and live to have revenge for his legs, his ship, and his crew. Like a good Pirate would. It's plenty personal.
The best part upon this whole sequence is the soundtrack behind the tale of how the pearl was lost. It's amazing that they made a sence of feel like as thought you were back in the first film
2:09 That gave me goosebumps. I realized that even after the Aztec curse was removed, Barbossa would never be able to die due to his smarts. This is what made me think why this music always played during a scene with barbossa. PTS: Poor ragetti and pintel :(
We don’t know what happened to Ragetti and Pintel i hope they escaped blackbeards ship or they jumped off the ship before the ropes got all of the crew
@@magnusbendiksen1423judging by how they never show up in the 5th movie which is supposed to be the last, i'd say they're fate was the same as the rest of Barbossa's crew :,(
I love how he talks of the pearl as if it was a person you can clearly see that barbossa cared more about it. He even went head to head with black beard just to avenge it
Goes to show that if these two were always trying to one-up, betray or kill each other, they’d be unstoppable. When they work together, they’re literally unbeatable.
That's the amazing thing about these two. With every little interaction, you can tell these two have had a long history as rivals that enjoy outwitting the other and getting under each other's skin. So from interactions like this where they start to bond, you know that it's been a very long, endless cycle for them and they know each other better than anybody else.
Captain Barbossa with his peg leg makes him even more like a real true pirate. Love how he has developed and his relationship with Captain Jack Sparrow.
He was fortunate to amputate his leg low enough (probably below the knee) to be able to use a peg. I have no left leg and do a "Long John Silver" using a single crutch which would severely limit my abilities on a pirate ship.
So... Jack not only performs slight of hand, but he and Barbosa have a nice little heart to heart. Proof that they were, at least once upon a time, good friends. And then of course the eye-roll as Jack is climbing up the tree just seals it. XD
![Jack Sparrow Escape from the King | Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger Tides [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JgWJUKzgvR4/mqdefault.jpg)
The fact that he actually shares it with Jack after he says “I want one of those.” is rather sweet.
And Jack promising him to get the chance for shared revenge was also rather nice.
And the thing is, I believe him, considering all those character arcs they've gone through together...
Well they are actually friends, they compete over a lot of things, mostly the Pearl, but when they're not, they're buddies, they must know each other quite well after all, been through some adventures together, and I think, when you are a pirate, you have to learn not to hold grudges over everything. :)
shadowsteed15 pirates life hector
“But why is the rum gone?” 😵
@@shadowsteed15 - I wouldn't go so far as to call them "friends". More like "frenemies". Although in the final film, Jack seems both shocked and saddened by Barbossa's death.
"oh you'd got a knife that's great "
"better "
you've
I want one of those.
Bet-eh.
i want one of those , hahaha
I wish I had that for a leg
"I'm the master of my ship, not Blackbeard. I'm the master of my fate, not Blackbeard!"
I absolutely love this line
“So I did what needed done, I survived.”
@@joaquinvigara1356 he could’ve cut the rope instead of cutting his leg off
@@Rayapt_ I don't think the ropes could be cut especially Blackbeards
@@Rayapt_ They're magic ropes, not possible
@@LordVader1094 he didn't cut the rob he cut his leg off
I love the chemistry these two developed over time.
“Ah Hector! It’s been too long, hasn’t it?”
“Aye. Ile de Muerte remember, yeh shot me.”
Grotto
No i didn't
@Marcelo Firpo Idiot
@@Grotto76 it's Isla...
It may not be the most popular opinion, but On Stranger Tides these two have the best chemistry with each other than any of the other films.
The fact they don’t show a flashback of the fight for this is actually great the viewer creates a excellent visual in their head
It really does.
I love how you hear the sound effects to enhance the story
Defently wasn't done because of budget restraints
It shows what a great story teller Geoffrey Rush is.
@@darby2956 this was the most expensive movie ever made definitely wasn’t budget
Barbosa betrayed Jack so Jack shot him for it. Even. Now, strenuous friends with respect.
"I'll see you get the chance at revenge mate."
What Blackbeard did to the Pearl was unforgivable to both jack and barbossa. The latter dealt the fatal blow the former ensured that it would stay fatal
Because Jack, wronged by Barbosa as he was, knows the value of revenge.
Jack got his revenge
Its only fair right
I mean once the debt is set then that good
And I mean, they were crewmates before the first betrayal. They sailed together well before they were foes. They've history.
Barbossa: but me arms were free and me sword was stand, so I did what needed done.
Jack: you cut the ropes?
Barbossa: (O)-(O)....
HAHAHAHAHA OMG I'm dead
Franken Stein - I don't know why they didn't address that in the film?
The ropes were magic and couldn’t be cut
I imagine he tried, but with the kind of control Blackbeard had over his Sword, they probably wrapped right back around. Plus, it was likely squeezing it to the point of uselessness
was t'hand*
The look Hector gives Jack after Jack gets his hands free very clearly says: "I have no idea how in the blazing fires of Hell you did that, but I've known you long enough not to question it."
Another legendary escape by captain Jack sparrow
It’s funny, I actually read your comment in Hectors voice, at it was perfect.
They went from “first mate betrayed me, let me kill him”
To “our hatred is wasted on old, scarred veterans of life like us. Let the young have their burning hatred...but we can still get under each other’s skin. For...old times sake, yes??”
Did you make that last line up yourself or is it a quote from somewhere
@@Demaad it came to me. Something I might say if I had an old rival and we both had matured and having a “truce meal sit down”.
Then a clink of our glasses would “seal the deal”, so to speak.
Brothers
*Clink* I'll drink to that mate, I've found hatred too bitter a spice to liberally spread through my life. *Gulp* *Glass slamming on the oak the table is made from.* Now tell me, that time we made port in Tortuga and I saw you trundling that scarlet haired wench with the particular large...cannonshot off to that wonderful little pub...
You can see it in the third movie as well, when they are walking around the corpse of the Kraken and having a heart to heart. I think they both realized that the only way to survive was to respect each other.
Barbossa: The world used to be a bigger place, lad.
Jack: (shakes head) The world's still the same, there's just less in it.
That's why I love these two. On the surface, they're rivals that are always trying to outdo each other, but deep down they have great respect for the other.
And to think Barbosa was Jack’s first mate.
@@jmsg_PR First mate ayy? 😳
@tit recek You haven’t seen it yet?
@tit recek Got it. Awesome
@@blank888 you know first mate.
Barbosa tells the best stories ghost stories lol
He should tell this story to a group of kids around a fire
Of course Barbossa tells good ghost stories - after all, he was one.
And you best be believing them
I know right. I would never get tired of his stories
Venox Mr Gibbs also does a pretty good job.
Barbossa's storytelling makes imagination look real that i dont even need a flashback to see it
Same
"Why should I? Four of you tried to kill me, one of you succeeded"
Four.
@@Governor2310 Who were the 4, all I remembered were Barbossa, Will, and Elizabeth?
@@jasonle9596 Will, Tia Dalma Barbossa and Elizabeth.
The 4 are Barbossa, Will, Pintel & Ragetti. Elizabeth is the one who succeeded.
@@HumblePaysan but that would make it 5, he said 4 of you tried to kill me in the past 1 of YOU succeeded which means he meant 1 of the 4 people he pointed out
After Barbossa cuts off his leg...
"Ya know, I probably should have just cut the rope."
Barbo-SaW
I'm guessing he was held upside down with multiple layers of rope around his ankle, that'd be hard to get to
@@tardwrangler As opposed to slicing through his leg bone?
Other rope will hold him, immediately after he cut one rope. Leave a piece there , so it does not know the captured is freed.
@@catfacepoetry3211 exactly why do people not realize this
"Our own ship turned against us."
He sounds so heartbroken when he says that. He loved the Pearl as much as Jack and for her to betray him, even if she was forced to by Blackbeard's magic, cuts deeper and sharper than even the loss of his leg.
If I ever get a prostetic leg I am def gonna store something in it
Whatever you say general
Store the death sticks
@@jacksentertainmentsystem3190 go home and rethink your life
@@ryangd05 I'm going to go home and rethink my life
Yeah, rum
This has got to be my favorite part in the entire movie. Barbossa's story -- how he lost his leg and his ship -- sends chills up and down my spine every time I hear it. The ghost sounds in the background, the expression in his voice and on his face, the look on Jack's own face as he puts things together...all that together, plus the story itself of course, makes for an intensity unrivaled by any other scene. And I love it.
promusicality Imagine if it was like a flashback. The moment and the story itself would’ve been impressive.
I think what made the scene work so well, is the fact there was no flashback. All you could do was listen to the voice of the character, to emotions he spewed as he told it, and see the expressions on his face, like the terror in his eyes when said: "Our own ship turned against us!", and the determination when he said: "I'm the master of my fate, not Blackbeard. I'm the master of my fate, NOT Blackbeard. So I did what needed done! I survived."
taken, not lost
at 2:45 barbossa was like "not this again".
Hello
looks more like "i'm not even surprised at this point"
also love the way Barbossa starts looking around like "i hope no one is watching" Jack just went for it without checking if the coast is clear
I love Barbosa’s face when Jack was climbing the coconut tree he was thinking obviously how the flying fuck does he do this shit he always has the weirdest escape attempts and they always work
If he weren’t mad, it probably wouldn’t work 😂
Barbosa looks like he's done with Jack's shit. He knew why Jack can always escapes successfully.
What I admire about Barbossa is that he always stood as his own man, a true pirate, and a true captain all by himself apart from characters like Will and Elizabeth who seemed to constantly need Jack to save their asses at the end of the day. Even tho he betrayed Jack multiple times, Jack has a lot of mutual respect for him, enough so that he made him his first mate all those years ago. Even now, he knows Barbossa is fully capable & willing to get his revenge on his own but he’s still willing to help due to that mutual respect. Both these men are great characters.
Yes to all of that, but a true captain? He would go down with the ship if he was. I wouldn’t blame him for being hesitant, or if he managed to get everyone to safety first (at least I think that is the exception for captains). But if it’s not, or if he gets over that hesitation, he would go down with that ship as Jack did.
“If that ship be sunk properly, you’d be sunk with it.” - Captain Jack Sparrow
@@sweetlifealley but the pearl didn't sink tho lol.
@@kieriencrabtree right it didn’t, but Jack didn’t know that yet. Also, I could make the argument that even though it did not sunk, it was defeated still. So, wouldn’t it have been more honorable as a captain to be defeated alongside his ship? I think even in that case, the phrase “the Captain goes down with his ship” would still apply to him.
@@sweetlifealley Barbossa was determined to exterminate Black Beard and retrieve the Pearl. He couldn't do that if he died.
@@theresedavis2526 I’m sure if Jack lived he would also want to take revenge on Davy Jones for sinking, or taking, his ship in DMC. But Jack was more of a captain by going down with it. It’s not that I don’t like Barbosa, I just think that Jack is the better captain
Barbossa cut off his own leg to escape the ropes, managed to escape and not bleed to death, join the british navy despite being a renowned pirate who had a massive hand in taking down Cutler Beckett, managed to lead an expedition to the fountain of youth in order to kill Blackbeard with one leg and a poisoned blade and proceeded to steal Blackbeard’s sword, crew and ship and use the vessel and magic that previously started this plot of revenge. What an actual legend
And he's not even the main character!
@@fancyhat6505true but mind you he was the one who destroyed beckett who was running a rogue operation using the EITC company not the British navy itself barbossa would of been accepted by the British army despite being a pirate he makes a good privateer clever skills with ships ect. The British government was like beckett was a bit of a idiot for taking over port Royal overthrowing swan and other things beckett controlled davy jones but didn't use it fully to his advantage he could of attacked England with the EITC and davey Jones crew why didn't beckett spend lots of money for a invasion of the UK overthrowing the king. Imagine king beckett of the British empire then davey Jones would be like "you know I helped invade England now give me back my ship"
@@declangaming24It takes more than just a navy to become King of England
@@leiferickson1494 true
barbossa was introduced as a walking cursed skeleton pirate. He was a legit monster. The fact that he can spin a story that chilling even though the audience has seen him as a monster too is impressive.
I love how Barbossa has wronged Jack so many times yet they still chat here like old friends catching up. I guess when Jack shot and killed him in the first movie he let all his anger and vengeance go in that one bullet.
Pretty much. Jack killed him, the debt was paid. When Barbossa came back, as far as Jack was concerned, they were even.
@@VegetaLF7 I think they have both wronged each other multiple times
It's more of a friendly rivalry since he got even with Barbossa in the first film, and fir Barbossa he's had his own lease on life again after being brought back and while he did steal Jack's boat he was still rather cordial in his own way by not leaving him to die like the first time.
@@JTruong3rd Well, from what I remember of At World's End, Jack was one of the Pirate Lords who held one of the nine Pieces of Eight and as Barbossa said, he failed to pass it along to a successor before he died hence why he didn't leave Jack to die when he took the Pearl (again), but I do agree that Jack and Barbossa's relationship is more of a friendly rivalry than outright hatred of each other.
Fun fact : when Jack killed Salazar and killed him one of the crew looks exactly like barbossa but without the beard
So jack and hector are first mate because jacks captain likes jack more than barbossa so the captain gave his compass to jack and made him the captain
I love that at 2:01 you can hear the 'Underwater March" song from the first movie (albeit an altered version that ive yet to find); a little callback to the pearl with barbossa's arc.
You could hear it throughout the scene it just becomes more noticeable there
Yeah and sound effects during the story
You can BARELY hear those pipes…
So cool
For me it’s there to signal that while he’s now seemingly weakened (one leg) and has spent two movies as an anti hero he’s still deep down the terrifying, ruthless and deadly pirate from the first movie and that when pushed such as by his desire for revenge that monstrous/villainous side can come back with a-vengeance.
It’s the one that plays at the the start of the first movie when they’re in the fog but a bit enhanced
"I survived."
Love the music that plays along with the quote.
Lol Same
Barbossa is a badass
D A R K L O R D but he didn't cut the rope
No he is a BarBOSSa
Good man good pirate
@@deshawnjohnson1106 No he's not a good man, he became a good man but in this movie he's not, Jack is a good man
I love how barbossa shares his peg leg drink with Jack they were enemies now their more frenemies
0:19
OOOOH SO THATS WHY PIRATES HAVE PEG LEGS, I never would have guessed?
Idk I wouldn't be surprised
Barbossa is so awesome :O "IM the master of me ship, NOT Blackbear. IM the master of me fate, NOT Blackbeard." he even cut of his own leg to prove it
"I survived" BADASS. Man says he'd give another limb just to kill him. God he's so amazing
Just shows how truthful and epic Barbossa was. Like seriously, taking one's leg just to survive is absolutely nuts! It also gave this character even more history and character!
Hector and Jack have this sort of relationship kind of similar to Goku and Vegeta, or Xavier and Magneto. They are rivals, and they do have different views in which counter act each other but they don't necessarily want to see the other dead.
Vegeta:
“Nobody’s killing that clown expect me.”
@@AbysmalGaming well, death in Dbz is a joke anyway so it hardly matters. besides vegeta kinda dropped that whole thing after years of getting used to goku and eventually accepting him as his rival. you can't get stronger yourself if you have no motivation to get stronger.
Except jack did kill him once.....
@@nubreed13 Barbosa betrayed him and stole his ship, so Jack killed him. The debt was paid and they were even after that. Barbosa just happened to have been resurrected, same as Jack himself. As far as Jack is concerned, they're even.
I’d say it’s it’s own thing
And all while he was telling his story, Jack was removing his binds. Also the look of amazement on Barbossa's face when he saw Jack freed.
Jack: "Why didn't you just cut the rope, why did you sever your own leg?"
Barbosa: "Hindsight be 2020 Jack."
Ther respects between them two of the great Captains of all time!
Captain Barbossa has a way with words. His speeches are always mesmerizing
I have to agree with you. When Jack says, "I want one of those," it's hilarious!
Truly a precious moment. Treasure
Barbossa (AWE): "Aye. Isla De Muerta, remember? You shot me."
Barbossa (OST) "...including the brutal theft of one used, twisted, hairy right leg!"
I like it that Barbossa never held true grudge against Jack for killing him (as if he has a sense of honor to recognize his defeat as a fair one in the fair one-on-one combat) unlike what he felt for Blackbeard for his victory in much more less honorable and fair fight, which cost him Pearl, his crew, his leg, his life of piracy and so on.
"TAKEN not lost"
I like how Barbosa emphasize on that because if the pearl was lost, he definitely would've gone down with her as stated by jack earlier in the film
It's scenes like this that simultaneously make you understand why Jack made Barbosa his first mate all those years back........and yet, question that decision all the more! They are shown to share a certain kindred spirit, level-headedness and intelligence, and, under the right circumstances, work well together! But, at the same time, it's their similarities that work against them, and usually wind up driving a wedge between them. They're both proud, ambitious men, and in spite of their level heads, intelligence and abilities to solve and get out of the problems that plague them with relative ease......and that causes them to butt heads.......They both, in spite of their friendship, or at least, mutual respect, past or present, feel that need to outdo the other......the need to be on top, no matter the cost......Which, really, when you think about it, is the root of their problems.......
It feels almost subtle how they put genuine fear in Barbossa’s face and eyes when he recounts the taking of the Pearl. If I didn’t know any better I’d think they wanted him to suffer from ptsd
"I am master of my fate" - true Captain, true mentallity. Also all that love-hate bromance between Hector and Jack, and honestly pegleg being coolest object in the series (not Heart, not Pearl, not Trident, not calices, but pegleg) really makes this scene stand out, and for me one of the best in the series, despite Stranger Tides being weakest of the films
I personally think Dead Man Tells No Tales was the weakest, I thought stranger tides slapped. watched it the other day with my friend in fact.
Geoffrey Rush's acting in this scene is top notch. This man has been an undead skeleton, gone to hell and back twice, fought a sea battle in the heart of a maelstrom and committed countless merciless crimes as a pirate. And in all that time, nothing scared him like Blackbeard did.
1:18 Man Jack's face alone says so much
He knows exactly what Barbossa has seen and knows all about Blackbeard's powers, but he can't even imagine how hard it would be for him and Barbossa to watch the Black Pearl turn against them.
This managed to become one of my favourite scenes. I mean just look at how worried Barbossa looks like in the end. They care about each other
Love how jack knew barbossa was pretending from the beginning
It's a great piece of chemistry. Granted, they've tried to kill each other multiple times before, (one of them even succeeded), but when a third party starts to take away their beloved ship, they always team up. Because no one takes away their Black Pearl.
Barbossa will always and forever be the greatest thing to come from the Pirates series.
Hector and Edward were contrast and complements at the same time. They both had daughters, they both came back from the death, and they both controlled the power of Triton as well as command of the Queen Anne Revenge. That being said there was a major difference, while Edward would happily sacrifice his own daughter to the fountain for immortality...Hector sacrificed himself to save his own daughter, getting swallowed by the sea.
What’s interesting is that this film shows a side of Barbossa and jacks rapport that was likely how they were when they first set out with the Pearl.
God knows Barbossa's lucky 2 be alive, to survive that I tell Ya, That's 1 heck of Pirate right there ladies and gentlemen, if not the best, then most certainly one of the Best.
I think he cut of his leg due to the rope being "alive".
So even if he did cut off the rope, it would still wrap around him and cut off the blood circulation to his leg... it's literally the same thing as having no limb if you have a cursed rope stuck on you for life... (until you meet Blackbeard again)
But even then, what's to stop the rope from wrapping around his other limbs?
@@Blokewood3 Perhaps the rope couldn't tell the leg was no longer attached to his body. Whereas if the rope was cut, it'd realize that and wrap around him again.
@@Blokewood3 Because the rope doesnt have eyes and it will only react if black beard commands it too. From what I see blackbeard wasnt looking too barbossa thats why he had his chance to his leg only leaving the leg just be sure that rope still think its him.
@@NICSU667 in that case, blackbeard wouldn't have known if he cut the rope, which is what Barbossa should have done.
After considering everything, I agree with this
Jack Sparrow and Hector Barbossa are my favorite characters ever.
Damn I want Captain Barbossa telling pirate horror stories. I'm glad it didn't cut his tale by cutting into a scene of how the Pearl was taken.
0:28 he cant even lift it high enough for the drink to come out lol
When Barbossa and Jack put their differences aside, they actually make a pretty good team.
I love how when Jack's climbing the tree it pans down to show his legs,and Barbossa just looks away like "fuck"
1:25 "Our own ship turned against us." In truth that does actually make sense. Think of everything the Black Pearl has been through throughout the entirety of it's story: Being sunken then resurfaced by Davy Jones, becoming cursed because the pirates she was carrying were to greedy for their own good, having been broken and damaged by the kraken then dragged back into the depths by it because Jack tried to run from his debt with Jones, was stuck down in Davy Jones' locker for a while, came back then shortly after had to fight the Flying Dutchman in a typhoon, and then it was finally given a conscience by Black Beard and with the realization of everything that had happened to itself over the years she turned on her crew for everything those pirates had done to her.
If I was that ship, I'd be ticked too! Of course, being controlled by Blackbeard to being shrunk to fit into a bottle is no picnic, either!
Damn.... I never thought of that, you'd make a great story out if that mate!
Not true blackbeard turnedthe black pearl against barrbosa
Blackbeard has a magic sword that controls ships. Watch the movie lol
it was more a case of mind control that unleashing the chains
"But I'd give my left arm for a chance at blackbeard".
"Not your right?"
"I need my good arm to drive my poisoned blade through his heart".
Barbosa: ambitious but practical
Not many people have that combo.
What i love about this scene is that it doesn't take away from Geoffrey Rush's performance at all. It allows Barbossa's story to play out in our own mind, imagining the terror the crew must have felt. A lesser filmmaker would have cut away to a flashback.
I love how when Hecter is telling the story you hear canon fires and and sword clashing sounds. Makes it wayy more dramatic! XD
Oh god, this scene was such a masterpiece. And the way Barbossa says "poisoned" just crowns the sentence :D
I’ve always thought if Barbossa and his crew never had the curse removed they would still be one of the most dangerous pirates ever.
lol imagine davy jones running in to them.one fellow cursed crew to another.terriozing the seas.
That's if they hadn't gone mad. That curse was torture.
@@theresedavis2526 i was about to say, they hated the curse, immortality isn't worth a piece of eight if you can't even enjoy even the basic feelings of life like taste or feel
You know this scene would make a great flashback of what had transpired as the movie lacked a ship-to-ship battle this would be the perfect time to show it as a flashback while Hector narrates culminating in his escape from Blackbeard and his crew.
Yeah, it was weird not seeing a ship to ship battle here
If this film was a Jack and Barbossa Buddy movie it would have been incredible. This scene shows that
Its already an awesome movie just for Jack's character
I loved that he said "our own ship"
With all respect to Jack, Captain Barbossa is the best portrayal of a pirate in cinema history
I’ve heard a lot of people ask, why didn’t Barbosa just cut the rope around his leg instead of his leg itself? My theory is that, the enchantment or black magic of Black Beards sword strengthened the the ropes so they couldn’t be cut.
"I'd give me left arm for a chance at Blackbeard" "not your right?" "I need me good arm to drive me poisoned blade into him" it's like he actually thought it through like "I'd give me right-no wait, need that one."
He sunk the ship that Barbossa and Jack fought over for 3 movies, presumably killed the Pearls crew, and put Barbossa in a situation where he was left with two options. 1.) Go down with the ship as a good captain would, or 2.) Take his leg and live to have revenge for his legs, his ship, and his crew. Like a good Pirate would. It's plenty personal.
barbossa and jack are the backbones of these movies
The best part upon this whole sequence is the soundtrack behind the tale of how the pearl was lost. It's amazing that they made a sence of feel like as thought you were back in the first film
I like how they showed kind of support for each other.
It's that Captain/First Mate relationship still shining through after everything they've been through.
2:09
That gave me goosebumps. I realized that even after the Aztec curse was removed, Barbossa would never be able to die due to his smarts. This is what made me think why this music always played during a scene with barbossa.
PTS: Poor ragetti and pintel :(
We don’t know what happened to Ragetti and Pintel i hope they escaped blackbeards ship or they jumped off the ship before the ropes got all of the crew
@@magnusbendiksen1423judging by how they never show up in the 5th movie which is supposed to be the last, i'd say they're fate was the same as the rest of Barbossa's crew :,(
@@amandag.6186 how can you be sure that they died
" I need my good arm to drive me poisoned blade through his heart." DAMN! Now that is Piracy. 😂 Jack was motivated!
The fact that jack says "a knife!" and Hector replies "better" makes the whole scene more iconic
I love how he talks of the pearl as if it was a person you can clearly see that barbossa cared more about it. He even went head to head with black beard just to avenge it
Barbossa is definitely Geoffrey Rush's most famous role.
This scene show how badass Captain Barbossa is.
If you're gonna do a scene that involves "tell, don't show", having an actor as entertaining to watch as Geoffrey Rush is a good way to do it.
No kidding I randomly turned on the movie like 10 minutes ago and started watching this. They were synchronized nearly perfectly.
Complete accident.
Blackbeard: Hello Barbosa. I want to play a game.
is that a saw reference?
Brian Bernstein what like shrinking the black pearl and putting it a bottle
Barbosa is still one of the greatest Disney villains and a proper sympathetic one
Goes to show that if these two were always trying to one-up, betray or kill each other, they’d be unstoppable. When they work together, they’re literally unbeatable.
The breathless way he says "heart" always gives me chills
haha i love jacks voice and expression when he goes "i want one of those" x)
For some reason I’ve quoted the fate line so much after this movie aired
That's the amazing thing about these two. With every little interaction, you can tell these two have had a long history as rivals that enjoy outwitting the other and getting under each other's skin. So from interactions like this where they start to bond, you know that it's been a very long, endless cycle for them and they know each other better than anybody else.
I like everytime Black Beard says "our ship", he knows he couldn't do what Jack did for the Black Pearl
Absolutely no way jack got anything out of that leg when his tied arms prevented him from tipping it enough
Every escape scene by Cap. Jack Sparrow is just funny, amazing and mind blowing
What makes all the more awesome is you know it wasn't a clean cut. He had to saw it off and still survived
I’m honestly more disappointed that jack didn’t sneak into barbosa’s room while he’s sleeping and just steal his peg leg
"I survived" badass line
These two make Pirates of the Caribbean come alive in so many ways.
Scenes like this are what saved this movie for me. I also love in his fight against Blackbeard how after stabbing him he says, "For the Pearl."
Captain Barbossa with his peg leg makes him even more like a real true pirate. Love how he has developed and his relationship with Captain Jack Sparrow.
He was fortunate to amputate his leg low enough (probably below the knee) to be able to use a peg. I have no left leg and do a "Long John Silver" using a single crutch which would severely limit my abilities on a pirate ship.
They should make a barbossa spinoff. Also who loves their onscreen chemistry?
So... Jack not only performs slight of hand, but he and Barbosa have a nice little heart to heart. Proof that they were, at least once upon a time, good friends. And then of course the eye-roll as Jack is climbing up the tree just seals it. XD
At this point I’m convinced that Jack Sparrow uses rum the same way Popeye uses spinach: just needs to ingest some and he can do the impossible.