BATTLE SPIRITS SAGA (Tales from the Bargain Bin 2023)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 30 жов 2023
  • It's that time of year again! Time to look at another game that failed to achieve its ambitions, but this time, things are a little different...
    Join my Patreon!: / kohdok
    Follow me on Twitter!: / kohdok
    #tcg #tradingcardgame #gamedev #battlespirits #battlespiritssaga #bsstcg
  • Ігри

КОМЕНТАРІ • 253

  • @orchidmantis125
    @orchidmantis125 7 місяців тому +44

    I really like BSS so I will still hold out hope

  • @colinbrown7190
    @colinbrown7190 7 місяців тому +69

    My locals was incredibly hyped for this game (the owners at least) and the loyal vanguard players there where willing to buy into it, myself included, the product came out most of us got a box and 1-2 decks, started to build, draft, trade, and learn the game, in prep for the first tournament the store would host, 1 tournament in. And everyone was not happy, most players (myself included) switched back to CFV because we had more fun, and now my locals has almost 3 cases worth of decks and sealed boxes that they can’t move anymore because no one plays, I’ve been tempted to buy it off them just to try and move it myself as singles/premade decks, but unfortunately the demand I have seen online has puttered away to nonexistent and now there just stuck and might have to cancel other games coming out because they can’t risk it being as big as a flop at this, grand archive, and shadowverse has been

    • @VelvetCrowe734
      @VelvetCrowe734 7 місяців тому +1

      CFV requiires luck because of the triggers. There isn't big strategy in this card game...

    • @Vonboon11dy
      @Vonboon11dy 6 місяців тому +3

      ​@@VelvetCrowe734but it's fun homie. Ppl can play whatever they like.

    • @VelvetCrowe734
      @VelvetCrowe734 6 місяців тому

      ​@@Vonboon11dycongratulations, what you wrote has nothing to do with what I posted. Thanks for your stupidity.

    • @lordxmugen
      @lordxmugen 6 місяців тому +3

      Shadowverse Evolve was AWFUL! So many of the cards changed from their original forms and even complete archetypes were just gutted or didnt work as intended. I dont know what Bushiroad was thinking, but if i had to guess, this was them just making a game for a client and then funneling the dough into CFV and Weiss Schwarz. Why else make the game that terrible?

    • @elin111
      @elin111 4 місяці тому

      @@VelvetCrowe734 Just like Pokemon totally is a coin flip simulator. As in, that is the argument that you'll only ever hear from someone who has never played VG a single time in their entire lives.

  • @MonkeyFightTCG
    @MonkeyFightTCG 7 місяців тому +8

    Thanks for mentioning my video! This was a wonderful breakdown of how battle spirits saga was handled. It's sad see such a good property mismanaged in the west.

  • @A88mph
    @A88mph 7 місяців тому +17

    It also doesn't help that the One Piece TCG was launched about half a year earlier, and was having supply issue: being sold out, and hard to come by until only recently. Everyone was buying that, and didn't want to focus on two new TCG's at once.
    They should have waited till next year to launch.

    • @marvelsandals4228
      @marvelsandals4228 4 місяці тому +1

      Its wild to think that Bandai, one company, has at least 4 card games (Dragon Ball Super, Digimon, One Piece, and BSS) all running at the same time in English speaking countries. I mean at this point they are competing with themselves more than their actual competitors. Die hard fans of MTG and Yugioh aren't going to flock to BSS in droves, the people who picked up Bandai games already found a game to get excited about in one of the last 3 nostalgic franchises. By undertaking this endeavor they've tried to convince their own players to stop playing the games they play to drop money on a new one. What if they're so disappointed by how lousy the game turned out that they decide to take a break from Bandai games in general? They spent money to alienate their own fans who were previously dropping money on their games. Their only hope of success was capitalizing on the nostalgic appeal of having many different crossover franchises all in the same game, since people were already expecting that. The fact that the first sets had almost no crossover characters is a huge missed opportunity and immediately makes the game seem far blander than the 3 that preceded it.

    • @mendithebeast4851
      @mendithebeast4851 3 місяці тому

      @@marvelsandals4228Bandai is bringing Union Arena to the US too lol

  • @berzerk130
    @berzerk130 7 місяців тому +13

    the funny thing about sending this kit to MatPat of all people is that he HAS played games on hia live channel that have CCG mechanics, and he said specifically that he doesn't play card games because he's bad at them. which is faur enough, but if the BSS team had actually checked, they'd know that

    • @NeroVingian40
      @NeroVingian40 7 місяців тому

      I’m still trying to piece together how of all people, Avril Lavigne also got swept in with all this? Like, why Avril? How did that even happened?

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      ​@@NeroVingian40they're popular

  • @JadeHex
    @JadeHex 7 місяців тому +90

    I will say Moist isn't completely agnostic to card games, He's an avid Yu-Gi-Oh! Collector and has been on Yugitubing channels with relative frequency

    • @Nocturne989
      @Nocturne989 7 місяців тому +21

      True, but he's basically just a collector. The only YGO he knows how to play is Gren Maju, so he isn't really in the competitive space. And for Pokemon he's literally just a collector.
      BSS had its biggest selling point be the competitive scene, which even for the games he enjoys Critikal is essentially entirely divorced from the competitive side.

    • @G004Morning
      @G004Morning 5 місяців тому +2

      Very true but he doesn't really advertise it on his channel, which is what Kohdok pointed out. Like he didn't even notify anyone on his social media about appearing on Duel Night lol. But yeah like you said he does have tangential knowledge in card games in general so he could've given some great input on Battle Spirits Saga.

    • @pascalsimioli6777
      @pascalsimioli6777 5 місяців тому +2

      He's a collector of one card game. That's just like saying that he's somewhat of a car guy because he needs a vehicle to go around.

    • @rokmare
      @rokmare 5 місяців тому +2

      Dude lack enthusiasm for anything even if he plays card games he is terrible playing the role of promoter

    • @TheSaint780
      @TheSaint780 4 місяці тому

      If they sent it out to like teamsamuraix1 or cimooo who have a huge YuGiOh following they probably would have done better. As a YuGiOh and BSS player I really love the game and think it to be one of the better more skill based games out that I have played

  • @e1iteLime
    @e1iteLime 7 місяців тому +31

    Shaman King needs to be next in this series.

    • @iamcup7356
      @iamcup7356 7 місяців тому +3

      It could form an unbreakable bond

    • @e1iteLime
      @e1iteLime 7 місяців тому +1

      I mean the world you is not what it seems

    • @iamcup7356
      @iamcup7356 7 місяців тому +1

      We might have to go beyond our wildest dreams

    • @jonathan-6958
      @jonathan-6958 7 місяців тому +1

      If your spirit is strong, you could be the ONE.

  • @Wslasher
    @Wslasher 7 місяців тому +18

    Would love to see you do this series for Vanguard. I know you hate the franchise but would be nice to see your take.

  • @RarecuisineGaming
    @RarecuisineGaming 7 місяців тому +12

    also with how BSS did nobody can tell me their one piece game isnt being carried by the IP

    • @21quepasa
      @21quepasa 7 місяців тому +1

      I wouldn't say carried but the IP is definitely the reason tournaments and sets are selling out so fast.

    • @smokinasnivy
      @smokinasnivy 7 місяців тому

      Doubt it, the tournament sell out because it’s a much deeper game than people think

    • @trinityassassinz9195
      @trinityassassinz9195 7 місяців тому +1

      one piece will fall off and lose steam just like all bandai card games eventually.

  • @Rowrin
    @Rowrin 7 місяців тому +19

    18:29 - This was saturday / day 1, there were plenty of people playing (415 or so). Day 0 / friday was product pickup and there were still a ton of people building decks and making trades to prepare for day 1. There were probably more people day 0 than day 1 since the amount of product you could buy was limited, so people brought friends to get more product to sell / trade singles. A lot of it were vendors coming in groups to get product to sell early. Something like only half of the people that bought product day 0 participated in day 1.
    18:33 was day 2. There wasn't really anything for the non-top cut players to do so no one showed up for day 2. There were like 20-30 of us watching the projector screen of the feature match but that was it.

    • @Kohdok
      @Kohdok  7 місяців тому +4

      So me pointing out lack of side-events and all that was still apt?
      Also ~400 is less than half the attendance they were expecting; the ticketing website was estimating at least 1000 people.

    • @Rowrin
      @Rowrin 7 місяців тому +2

      @@Kohdok yeah the event definitely under performed. There were"technically" side events, but it was like $30-40, single elim win a box that fired off one pod before people were like, "this ain't worth it." There was no official draft format at this time either. It was really weird, like someone from the late 90's or early 2000's who never saw a card game expo before, time traveled to 2023 and was put in charge of hosting the event.

  • @Zizzac
    @Zizzac 7 місяців тому +30

    I'm in this video a couple times. Never thought I'd get to say that about a Kohdok video! 🤣🤣 (I worked the Launch Event in Vegas.)
    Honestly, I love the game, and I'm actually a tiny bit happy they are winding it back a bit. Now the people playing it are actually the people who enjoy the game, not the no-lifers who are just in it for the money and flipping and couldn't care less about the game.
    Really informative video! Don't quite agree on every single point, but I'm just happy someone is finally talking about this,

  • @jaydens8331
    @jaydens8331 7 місяців тому +20

    "I don't care that it's what one piece did" excellent rebuttal.

  • @brendalee1215
    @brendalee1215 7 місяців тому +6

    Its an original IP so it's kinda hard for it to grow outside of Japan

  • @YamiAtomsk
    @YamiAtomsk 7 місяців тому +15

    FYI Hasbro has the Power Rangers rights now so they'd have to go through them to do anything outside of Asia.

    • @jonathan-6958
      @jonathan-6958 7 місяців тому +4

      Yup. People dont get that different countries may have different license holders.

    • @marxxplaysgames
      @marxxplaysgames 7 місяців тому

      Could have called it Super Sentai, especially considering it's the source material

    • @YamiAtomsk
      @YamiAtomsk 7 місяців тому

      @@marxxplaysgames nope still falls under hasbro. They basically have the master license for everywhere outside Asia.
      So even when Shout Factory directly licenses Sentai shows from Toei they still need the approval from Hasbro. That's why you see the Hasbro or Eone logos on the back of the DVD boxes.

    • @Mirrikat45
      @Mirrikat45 7 місяців тому +1

      @@marxxplaysgames I thought this at first, but I would bet that the rights to distribute "Super Sentai" were bought by Saban at the time. You wouldn't want a competitor licensing the same show, film different custom scenes than power rangers did, and release it while its called, "Mega Rangers" or something. So I don't think they'll be able to do Super Sentai for any run that was licensed out already.

    • @ShadowEclipex
      @ShadowEclipex 4 місяці тому

      ​@YamiAtomsk I'm not sure if Hasbro has worldwide ownership of Power Rangers/Super Sentai outside of Japan. Since South Korea has their own version of Power Rangers. Mostly just Super Sentai dubs, but also including some original seaons.

  • @Genowhirl910
    @Genowhirl910 7 місяців тому +4

    Never heard of this game in my life but your little fake trailer for it at the end there genuinely got me kinda hyped up ngl

  • @damonbeacham
    @damonbeacham 7 місяців тому +7

    There were over 400 people in vegas...

  • @KevinLYT1
    @KevinLYT1 7 місяців тому +8

    technically they cannot do the power rangers since Bandai no longer owns the franchise. Its a Hasbro franchise now

    • @nohrianscum9791
      @nohrianscum9791 7 місяців тому +4

      That would be really entertaining if merchandise started showing up of Super Sentai teams that were never adapted as Rangers.

  • @SuperKhorne
    @SuperKhorne 7 місяців тому +5

    Will keep playing no matter what, love the game, the interaction, and the ressource management, so we will see

  • @Koko-ti
    @Koko-ti 7 місяців тому +3

    I think the highest amount of players we had at locals was 6 or 8 for this game. Now none have shown in a month. In a decent size city. Too much competition in the card game space. Heard the other store groups basically failed at launch and we became the only store hosting active tournies

  • @eliascsjunior
    @eliascsjunior 7 місяців тому +7

    "Traps work like the Secrets in Hearthstone" - You really decided not to state the obvious 😂

  • @user-bf7qh7pw9x
    @user-bf7qh7pw9x 7 місяців тому +11

    it seems IP's hold so much weight in tcgs at this point truly a shame.

    • @anab0lic
      @anab0lic 7 місяців тому +7

      yup, one piece is a much worse game, yet selling significantly better...

    • @Vanyminator
      @Vanyminator 7 місяців тому +6

      @@anab0licDisney's Lorcana as well. Seems like no one's playing the game, they just want to make a quick buck by reselling :/

    • @EmperorPylades
      @EmperorPylades 7 місяців тому

      ​@@anab0liccomparing anything to One Piece is hardly a fair comparison. One Piece is a juggernaut like few other IPs in existence.

    • @PetrygaLiades-mn6ro
      @PetrygaLiades-mn6ro 7 місяців тому +1

      I mean look at pokemon tcg. I can't remember how many collector showcase videos there is where the collectors themself admit that they don't play the game at all. Heck the largest pkm tcg chanel maxmoefoe don't even play the game.

  • @JohnSpeezy88
    @JohnSpeezy88 7 місяців тому +20

    Honestly I'm a fan of the game. Even though there isn't really a player base where i am, i still buy into it. I'm hoping to play online or find a way to drum up support.

  • @Coolkidz-de3wm
    @Coolkidz-de3wm 7 місяців тому +4

    The funny part about the Critikal part is that he's more into YGO, to the point he could actually be a brand ambassador if he or Konami wanted to (and not that antoine guy)

  • @ivandekad7249
    @ivandekad7249 5 місяців тому +5

    It's almost bafflingly impressive how many of the lessons from Seven Deadly TCG Sins, Errata Text and many of Kohdok's other videos culminate to show just how atrocious Battle Spirits Saga's launch year was.

    • @elin111
      @elin111 2 місяці тому

      There was a Seven Deadly Sins TCG? That's proof that literally anything can be turned into a tcg.

    • @Silver_Chivalry
      @Silver_Chivalry Місяць тому

      ​@@elin111 Well, there was a Seven Deadly Sins expansion for Weiß Schwarz.

  • @kingvire
    @kingvire 7 місяців тому +22

    As both a judge and a player I’m very hopeful and I’m very happy to even be given the chance to be a part of the game like I have been.
    Set 3 is awesome but the pricing is yeah, and I am excited for set 4 cause of new mechanics.
    Genuinely idk if it will keep going but I know we have 2 years of support past that idk I’m just gonna remain hopeful.

    • @Rayquaza894
      @Rayquaza894 7 місяців тому

      They always just can it. 2 years of support if its profitable

    • @kingvire
      @kingvire 7 місяців тому +4

      @@Rayquaza894we already know we have up to set 6 from a bunch of dev and marketing talks but nothing past that is known or expected atm. Set 6 would bring us to the end of year 2 and the end of the second worlds season.

  • @KamenRiderDragoon
    @KamenRiderDragoon 7 місяців тому +6

    Wait i know you dont like vanguard but you said me no like to buddyfight which you seemed to be super into before darkness dragon world came out

  • @twarnold14
    @twarnold14 7 місяців тому +2

    Slight correction: Digimon has 6 primary colors (and a 7th for the uncategorized). Also, with the exception of the 1 set where they experimented with adding more foils and the reprint set, Digimon always has 2 rares. They continued that past the first 2 sets (the ones that were the first 3 Japanese sets combined).

  • @AutisticBoardGamer
    @AutisticBoardGamer 7 місяців тому +5

    Also what's up with saying "tolkienest" does Kohdok not realize that fantasy genre existed before Tolkien?

    • @elitemagikarp4822
      @elitemagikarp4822 7 місяців тому +2

      not really

    • @AutisticBoardGamer
      @AutisticBoardGamer 7 місяців тому +1

      @@elitemagikarp4822 Are you saying he didn't know or are you saying fantasy didn't exist before tolkien?

  • @ianhentges6614
    @ianhentges6614 7 місяців тому +17

    I feel they needed a show to go along with it.

    • @webbowser8834
      @webbowser8834 7 місяців тому +6

      Funny thing is that the original Battle Spirits *did* have a show, and a pretty good one at that. You can find it with English subs right here on UA-cam.

    • @jonathan-6958
      @jonathan-6958 7 місяців тому

      Depends on tone. If it were something like yugioh 7s it would be where it is now. But if its tone was more like yugioh 5Ds, then it couldve worked.

    • @dreadlord8628
      @dreadlord8628 7 місяців тому +4

      ​​@@jonathan-6958they already did that, Battle Spirits Gallet's Revolution then Battle Spirits Mirage.
      5D's can't even compare when it comes to tone and themes the story is lit.
      It's the final 2 entries in Otherworld Records Saga.

  • @AutisticBoardGamer
    @AutisticBoardGamer 7 місяців тому +4

    When he described the digimon tcg booster... So what you're saying is the closer the tcg/ccg gets to an ecg/xcg the better.

  • @TheBearNecessiTCG
    @TheBearNecessiTCG 7 місяців тому +3

    So far I'm enjoying it at the local casual level. My main concern is that booster boxes are too cheap, yeah I like the price but it doesn't help the game long term. As for the card design/text box, it bothered me a lot in the beginning but now I don't even notice it and have no problem playing the game. My main issues with the game is that I don't like the overall style, I'd prefer different artwork but that can change in time. The reskins for Gundam, I'm on the fence about because I don't mind them being reskins BUT! I do sell on tcgplayer so if they were unique then it would drive the price up of the cards and boxes.

  • @tysnow9524
    @tysnow9524 7 місяців тому +2

    It honestly feels like it's going the way of d spirits.

  • @ArtisanWarriorMX
    @ArtisanWarriorMX 7 місяців тому +11

    Jesus christ, I thought I was the only one who thought the text boxes for Saga looked absolutely horrible!!
    I wanted to give the game a chance since it was probably the cheapest way I could get Siegwurm, a character I've grown attached to by watching the anime by seeing how cool the character was since buying from the first run of Battle Spirits cards would have been way too pricey. I knew that it wasn't going to go well once it was announced last year, but it's sad to know that Bandai treated a well-respected game from its native country so dirtily when rebooting it worldwide, especially since I was genuinely looking forward to finally learning how to play the game years after it was deemed irrelevant.
    Speaking of the anime, although I want to nitpick that the Battle Spirits anime you referred to at the start was actually its second series I can't blame you for using it as the "main season" since the very first season didn't even bother explaining the game's rules or show how a full game plays out until a couple of episodes in the season.

  • @InsomniaticVampire
    @InsomniaticVampire 7 місяців тому +2

    Love the Crypt keeper reference. I had forgotten this game even came out this year. Nothing about it seemed interesting during the ad campaign and then i just never heard about it after it released.

  • @businessfox1582
    @businessfox1582 Місяць тому

    I was all for it, but one thing i noticed was the cards were just hard to find. You couldnt walk into a Wal-Mart and find sets when one pice and digimon were plentiful.

  • @Juanjo.vanegas21
    @Juanjo.vanegas21 7 місяців тому +19

    I absolutely love this game. The game mechanic is fantastic. Set 3 has fixed a lot of what players were complaining about! So Bandai is willing to listen to feedback and make the game better for everyone. Also set 4 will have a collab with Evangelion, so that is something to look forward too.

  • @thoughtprism2963
    @thoughtprism2963 7 місяців тому +6

    I HEAR WIXOSS MUSIC LET'S GO

    • @Sorria31
      @Sorria31 7 місяців тому

      Speaking of Wixoss, I wonder what Kohdok thinks about the Servant # being a 4-off must have in every deck.
      Sharp is pretty cheap and has tons of alt-arts, but still are a 4-off.

  • @Jscallen13
    @Jscallen13 2 місяці тому

    They just came out with a statement that the next couple of events won’t have cash prizing. They will have travel and hotel vouchers.

  • @dumpling3198
    @dumpling3198 7 місяців тому +3

    Please make a video of your thoughts on Star Wars unlimited right now.

  • @ashenfox3535
    @ashenfox3535 Місяць тому

    Yeah I remember seeing a mail in card for the 2009 release in Shonen Jump. I got my free deck but saw nothing else for it later

  • @thomaskunz8553
    @thomaskunz8553 7 місяців тому +2

    Critikal is an avid YuGiOH Player tbf, but you need to be in the right circles to find those videos.

  • @tcgmetaslayer4202
    @tcgmetaslayer4202 5 місяців тому +4

    I was one of the first who predicted the battlespirits fail, why? Because players need to play games to have FUN! Not bribed by tournament prizes. I still think Dragon Ball Masters is the best new iteration of the Japanese anime card game in theme, mechanics, strategy, deck building, and FUN. My only gripe is that The DB masters community got too obsessed with “meta” decks and this led to them slamming many leaders and colors, and abusing any hyped deck that won a tourney, which led to too many unecessary bans. BUT, if you play like my group and locals, we have our own tiny ban list and we also play casual formats of Dragon Ball Masters. Our competitive meta is so healthy and unpredicatble, almost any deck old or new can win an event and tourney! That being said, instead of Battle Spirits, like you said, the generic fantasy theme is done. Players will always choose MtG or YuGiOh. I chooese MtG.

    • @CatManThree
      @CatManThree 4 місяці тому +2

      MTG isnt exactly generic fantasy though. Its really varied and can be very outlandish depending on the plane.
      Yugioh on the other hand is known for its extremely inconsistent and varied aesthetics. One archetype could be a cross between Resident Evil and Spawn where spawn is zombie slaughtering other zombies, and another could be centered around otome boy dream spirits in a dream world a little girl travels to each night as she sleeps.

    • @tcgmetaslayer4202
      @tcgmetaslayer4202 4 місяці тому

      @@CatManThree i agree! Which is why I also passed on yugioh, great comment 🙌🏻

    • @MuseHope
      @MuseHope 4 місяці тому

      ​@@tcgmetaslayer4202 I like how you use dbs masters as an example when by all means it wouldn't exist without the money Bandai made for several years from battle spirits jp and still going. This is why you don't make kohdok gospel. If anything, anime fantasy is untapped. Which is why a game like fire emblem cipher should have gone international. Anyways, as someone who digs Saga, and believe that Bandai wouldn't let their baby die internationally a second time, I will enjoy it and hope Bandai turns it around and prove you wrong

    • @tcgmetaslayer4202
      @tcgmetaslayer4202 4 місяці тому

      @@MuseHope theres nothing wrong with enjoying saga, I hope you do keep playing what you like! 👍🏻🙌🏻 and these are my own opinions and perspectives as someone who plays and works in the gaming industry, im just glad other youtubers share my observations. But you are wrong about masters. Masters would easily exist even if saga never existed. DB is one of the world’s largest IPs and generates enormous revenus from manga, anime, movies, action figures, other cards and games, clothes, posters, you name it-- saga will never achieve a fraction of that. And I understand, its tough when you enjoy a game and want it to succeed. Just like you, i’ll keep playing the ones I like even if they arent popular. Cheers!

    • @MuseHope
      @MuseHope 4 місяці тому

      ​​@@tcgmetaslayer4202 I didn't say Saga. I mean actual JP Battle Spirits. Which has been going on for 15 years. DBS exists as the new reigning DB card game under bandai, and Bandais card games started with battle spirits. Digimon, Union arena, DBS, one piece, they all owe themselves to battle spirits

  • @redx3204
    @redx3204 7 місяців тому +3

    I think the main thing with Bandai games right now is that they do not emphasize locals and smaller communities. Like with battle spirits, they have these big competitive tournaments but barely any stores do locals for them because the cards don’t sell. I hope one day Bandai realizes that locals are what makes most players buy cards consistently. Why do I buy Pokémon and yugioh cards when they online clients? Because my lgs has locals every week and I like getting new cards to use/trade in the events. And no, promos themselves do not count as advertising locals.Bandai has got to work with lgs’ better in order to grow their games and give each game an equal amount of attention

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      And....one important thing...THERE'S TO MANY GAMES. No one cares bandi. We got Flesh and blood now. Digimon is dead in the west. Kids want digital games and teens want booby anime women. Old people like us have TOO many tcgs, TTRPGs, and CCGs. The market is full. Only the porn games are left unless you make something weird like Simcity TCG or fueries the card game.

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      Meta Zoo is getting a backrooms set. You can't beat that Bandi. Fix your dot hack games first.

  • @thunderstruck560
    @thunderstruck560 4 місяці тому

    I honestly dont know why youtube stopped recommending me your videos because they are so well done. I love learning about dead card game and what went wrong.

  • @torondin
    @torondin 7 місяців тому +7

    They never even did a release for Trickster in BSS... Note to self: If I get my own game into production, have cute anime girls in it.
    Oddly enough I thought the cash prizes for tournaments would be a major selling point, since a friend of mine keeps telling me how he stopped going most regional and world tournaments for Yugioh since he can't even break even if he wins the whole thing... Just gets product he already has and a rare card which is extremely hard to offload.
    I'll be honest, seeing what happened to BSS has kinda sent me into all the stages of grief, and I finally accept it's probably dead as a doornail. Either that or I'm still partially stuck in the depression state. But lesson learned, don't do what BSS did, including updating the card frame for the west, yet make the text far harder to read.

    • @Medic11
      @Medic11 7 місяців тому

      Well play Bandai 🤡

  • @kimahris_1155
    @kimahris_1155 7 місяців тому +4

    Yeesh, I thought the Gundam Collab is going to bounce back BSS but they fumbled it so hard as they're just a reskin. I hope that the Evangelion Collab will turn things around. Although given that Gundam Collab already burnt people, why engage in a second burn?
    I agree most parts of what you mentioned, though wanna add on that Core papers still irk me. I don't see that this game will last that long, given that Discord channel that I'm in having discourse about LGSes dropping the game because of the low turnouts of the set 1.
    I expect Bandai to close this game out to save back cost. I'm gonna warm up my seat and sit down to see it's sunset.

  • @legend258471b
    @legend258471b 7 місяців тому +3

    I really liked this video (despite being a BSS enjoyer). Seems the bag was fumbled by corporate decisions. I love playing the game and the cards speak to my lizard brain so I'm going to keep playing until it either gets cancelled or my locals die (at least that part I know won't happen). The thing's they are doing in set 4 should have been done in set 1 and things might be different. Regardless I hope the game finds traction again as it really is a blast to play.

  • @j.m.3600
    @j.m.3600 7 місяців тому +4

    I’d be into BSS if it didn’t stretch my budget from One Piece cards which is taken from my budget for Digimon cards

  • @ericslingerland5472
    @ericslingerland5472 29 днів тому

    I has never familiar with the original game, and was really excited for BSS when i heard about it. I think the mechanics are really interesting. I moved states the week it was released it it died locally before i had a chance to visit a lgs in my new city =/
    To this day I have played 2 games with the demo deck to learn, and 3 games with the starter decks to try teaching people

  • @AStarkSnow
    @AStarkSnow 7 місяців тому +1

    Where did Critical Penguin do the Battle Spirit video? For some reason I can't find it anywhere. Did he take it down?

    • @Kohdok
      @Kohdok  7 місяців тому +1

      Complete Pizza Tier list, or something

    • @Dunsparce99
      @Dunsparce99 7 місяців тому +2

      @@Kohdokso a sponsor segment in a much bigger video that everyone who watched it probably skipped. Just goes to show how much of a failure this game was.

  • @tomforge614
    @tomforge614 6 місяців тому +1

    They hd six or so anime they could casually localize as either subs or dubs, and cash tournaments was the strategy?
    Card games were bought because they were attached to tv series. And with so much of a back catalog, this should have coasted as a casual franchise akin to Duel Masters, its original rival.
    I mean, there was Rush Duel and Shadowverse on the Switch. Online/video game version probably would have exploded.

  • @cincogus
    @cincogus 2 місяці тому

    Either way, I bought every single starter deck, a few promo extras and boosters just to collect. Game is fun and Evangelion collab is coming.

  • @heinousrat9019
    @heinousrat9019 Місяць тому

    the gundam cards are just skins of saga cards in the set, with art of japan original cards that are flavorful to products they come from. the gundam exia is literally a face card for the japanese starter deck.

  • @PicketPolecat
    @PicketPolecat 7 місяців тому +1

    13:30 Hey, give Raid SOME credit: at least everyone knew from the get-go that they were shilling youtubers, people just tolerated the ads because they paid their creators better than youtube themselves ever did (a fact that apparently was lost on Raid's own Marketing department, but still). I only heard of this card game today, and I _follow_ some of those youtubers!

  • @elin111
    @elin111 7 місяців тому +1

    The tcg communities in my area jumping ship from Yugioh and Magic jumped to....
    Shadowverse and One Piece.
    There's not even a Battle Spirits poster on the walls of any locals in this country.

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      They are FFFFF FUCKED.
      Meta Zoo
      Flesh & Blood
      Bakugon G2
      Sorcery
      Yugioh Ruah
      Shadowverse Evolved
      Gem Blasters
      Chaotic G2
      Force if Will
      Wix Cross
      Lorcona
      VIllanous

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      No space for this game.

    • @elin111
      @elin111 4 місяці тому

      @@TempoLOOKING No interest in this game

  • @type3771
    @type3771 7 місяців тому +10

    Bandai certainly fumbled with this game in the early going, but not everything in this video is a fair representation. I think a collab with your channel would have been a better choice.

  • @ccggenius
    @ccggenius 7 місяців тому +2

    I mean... FWIW, there being literally NOTHING to go off on on Tilestone is COMPLETELY congruous with the character. Being a member of Galley-La in Water 7 is about as far as his character is developed.
    Well, if there's a silver lining to BSS shitting the bed so hard, maybe this'll push up the timeline for taking Re:birth for You global? Bandai has all those sweet, sweet licenses that they aren't gonna let into Weiss Schwarz, might as well give us Kirkland brand Weiss Schwarz.

    • @KreuzDrache
      @KreuzDrache 7 місяців тому

      Isn't that what Union Arena is, or is that different game entirely?

  • @firecrest3325
    @firecrest3325 4 місяці тому +1

    This promo was like when MTG used Patton Oswald like.... wow..

  • @thehomelander1146
    @thehomelander1146 7 місяців тому +2

    I don't care about the game, I like the card artwork tho, so I'm happy that I can buy them for cheap lol

  • @tamska
    @tamska 7 місяців тому

    I wonder what marketing agency did they use to do the launch? I feel like this wasn’t done inhouse.

  • @Nocturne989
    @Nocturne989 7 місяців тому +12

    I would literally love the Kamen Rider Battle Spirits stuff it looks so great, especially compared to the BSS cards

    • @marxxplaysgames
      @marxxplaysgames 7 місяців тому

      What archetypes are there?

    • @Nocturne989
      @Nocturne989 7 місяців тому

      @@marxxplaysgames not sure about actual deck archetypes, but basically every rider has gotten at least one card over the years, if not multiple.

  • @merccc1
    @merccc1 7 місяців тому +2

    It really tried a bit too hard to be competitive. Personally I am a casual player in loving to try out all the different play styles and not just tunneling in on the meta. The very core of the marketing for tournaments did nothing but worry me. The gameplay seemed like that kicked off straight into an already fully mature and mechanically saturated tcg instead of gradually working up into it a tad slower. Although I'm fine with it, some friends were turned off by the deep competitive "OP" cards and swingy nature of them was a bit much. This was done for that dumb competitive and tournaments focusd reason, but it ended up being alienating. For some players it would probably be like jumping into modern day yugioh. At least that seems to be what I noticed others reacting to it like. It just seems they have no idea how to bring this one over properly... they fk it up every time... I kinda hoped they would just bring it over 1 for 1, but with some special sets that introduce staples and such that you may need or want to mix with the modern sets. I liked the original card designs as well... They made it darker and more monotone with grays and such... Even just the text box area is darker for no reason... I know I didn't care for the original attempt because of the foils. They were terrible, but I seen them do solidly with their modern foils. Wish they kept to them...
    Our locals also got unlucky with players that show up only for big events and then every other local being just 3-5 people at BEST... Alt art gundams was dumb... The moment we realized they were just different art for basic cards.... Lost that interest too. They have nearly just disappointed over and over...
    Should have just made a good casuals friendly game that isn't too simple or too complex and introduce different IP's as full sets instead of the half assing alt arts that make you wonder and beg for it not to be the full extent we will be getting different IP's...

    • @ALherodra
      @ALherodra 6 місяців тому

      Yeah. Some cards are only playable in casual format but bandai just tried too hard toward the competitive side.

  • @seyproductions
    @seyproductions 7 місяців тому

    I love the skit at beginning.

  • @IMissBionix
    @IMissBionix 6 місяців тому +1

    Bandai America hasn't held any rights to Power Rangers for several years now. It was a licensed brand, and the rights holder sold it outright to Hasbro.
    I'm mixed on doing crossover sets. Yes, it brings more eyes to the game, but that doesn't necessarily translate into players. It's also kind of an admission that your own lore isn't enough to carry the brand. I know there are TCGs that are built on the concept, but for pre-existing games? It kind of comes across as desperate. The crossover push was literally Bushiroad's last attempt to save Buddyfight.

  • @Acidonia150reborn
    @Acidonia150reborn 7 місяців тому +1

    Bandai in UK are weird, recently theve been on their own getting Gunpla Kits into UK stores yet they put out some Kamen Rider ones too despite the fact.They is no Legal way to watch that series in UK or buy any Video games on it even though the most recent one has english in it but only sold in Asia and thats including the PC steam version.

  • @tysnow9524
    @tysnow9524 7 місяців тому

    Also about the only having a portion of the playability with the first re release of battle saga didn't flesh and blood do the same thing with bright lights by only having one hero class

  • @corvusblackfeather456
    @corvusblackfeather456 7 місяців тому

    I would love to play this game, but was crushed when they weren't printing the Sengoku Set

  • @NeroVingian40
    @NeroVingian40 7 місяців тому +1

    It still baffles me how Avril Lavigne, of all people, would also get swept into all this. Like, Avril is the most random thing in this whole “saga”. Matpat, Moist, and especially ProZD have all made card games content before, but Avril? Why Avril?

  • @xbot02
    @xbot02 7 місяців тому +1

    Man, I've been a fan of Battle Spirits for years. Never got to play the old english version. And I was super excited when BSS was announced. And I hate that Kodok is right about this game, cuz I had had a lot of hopes. If set 4 having Eva cards included, and the guaranteed Eva dedicated set later next year, dont manage to bring back proper interest, the game is dead.

  • @zaktilton1680
    @zaktilton1680 5 місяців тому

    All six colors are available now with starter decks for each one and a 4th set supposed to be launching in February with a collab with Evangelion.
    The did a ... meh one with Gundam in set 2.

  • @StigmaKRL
    @StigmaKRL 7 місяців тому +1

    Funnily enough Digimon was what killed BS (the japanese one) at my locals, and then One Piece came in and did the same to Digimon

  • @ShadowEclipex
    @ShadowEclipex 4 місяці тому

    Might be seeing a Tales from the Bargin Bin for Metazoo in the next couple months.

  • @Neias93
    @Neias93 7 місяців тому +1

    It also kinda came out around the same time one piece did

  • @Shoelid
    @Shoelid 7 місяців тому +9

    I’m an avid BSS fan, and a lot of this is right on point (the game is failing for a reason) but much more of it isn’t a fair representation of what’s going on.
    The first set actually had tons of complexity for how little cards were available, with more archetype variety in set 1 than OPTCG had in 3 sets.
    And on your comment about the banlist at the very end: the ban came around after very quickly after a degenerate meta was forming, and was extremely positively received. Nobody invested in the game has been asking for ice shield to be banned.
    Set 4 is looking to have tons of evangelion inserts and was delayed a month to get things right, which is a good sign that Bandai is ready to keep investing in the game after the poor launch.

    • @Mirrikat45
      @Mirrikat45 7 місяців тому

      Yeah, set 4 will also allow you to get Eva cards that are more common, so you don't have to be lucky enough to score a $50-$100 card just to see a crossover card. Then those cards themselves will rarely come in an upgraded premium version with texturing and foiling.

  • @G004Morning
    @G004Morning 7 місяців тому

    Does anyone know where to find MoistCritical's sponsership of Battle Spirits? I cant seem to find it anywhere

    • @Kohdok
      @Kohdok  7 місяців тому +2

      Complete Pizza Tier List

  • @brcienpartin5462
    @brcienpartin5462 7 місяців тому +1

    I followed the pack on this one. I would have bought in if others did first. If Chaotic or Duel Masters/Kaijudo comes back, I'm all in.

    • @nmr7203
      @nmr7203 6 місяців тому

      Chaotic desperately needs a reboot.

  • @trickyplays240
    @trickyplays240 7 місяців тому

    Omg Kohdok said the game that shall not be spoken 👀

  • @nathanvig4401
    @nathanvig4401 7 місяців тому

    So I have been hearing about box break downs on how many of each type of card you can get for each game, but I'm wondering if there is an easy way to find out what your own card game box break down would be like before releasing to market. Because something I have been struggling with my card game right now is a faction based game (you can mix and match freely, but me making the set ideas goes for theme) where there is 4 colors to the game and 4 main factions, but my main issue is I want each faction to feel big and like you can make them any color of deck you want, but my set size for the first set might be about 280 and I'm wondering if that would be too big for casual people to want to get into.
    Also just on a side note I wanna know if the first 8 factions are too sword and sorcery type. In blue we have Mages and Aliens, in Green we have Demons and Spirits, in Red we have Knights and Goblins and in yellow we have Egypt and a western casino

  • @557deadpool
    @557deadpool 6 місяців тому

    The cards are fine to read and you don't need flavor text, that's just a petty complaint

  • @MaxxMinton
    @MaxxMinton 2 місяці тому

    Game Grumps did a crossover!? Wow! I'm throwing my cards away.

  • @cosmomage2166
    @cosmomage2166 7 місяців тому +1

    I don't think it failed yet though.

  • @andypandaman1607
    @andypandaman1607 3 місяці тому

    Man I want this game to be good they are having a cross over with kamen rider my favorite fabdom

  • @ribbontoast
    @ribbontoast 4 місяці тому

    literally didnt know this had anime tieins until watching your videos i only knew this as the game with prozd promos

  • @stocxt
    @stocxt 7 місяців тому +1

    ngl I was super into set 2 when I saw they were bringing over the gundam cards until I saw they were just parallel arts of other cards and then lost all interest. If they banked on crossover properties I'm sure it would have caught on way faster

  • @artherfrain6999
    @artherfrain6999 7 місяців тому +2

    Kohdok: You can't brute force the next big thing.
    MBA: Doubt.

  • @superbellchan
    @superbellchan 7 місяців тому +1

    My distributor hasforced me into ordering 16 boxes of set 3...and an undetermined number of set 4

    • @TempoLOOKING
      @TempoLOOKING 6 місяців тому

      Better get your money back.

  • @MrShinyObject
    @MrShinyObject 7 місяців тому +1

    Mechanically the game looks neat but it's got no flash to it. There's no hook to the world building (not that they ever tried) and everything I can glean from the art and names just look like every other Japanese tcg.

    • @MuseHope
      @MuseHope 7 місяців тому +4

      No flash? We literally have the Flash step, sir.

    • @Kohdok
      @Kohdok  7 місяців тому +2

      What is a Flash Window? A Mooserable little pile of secrets!

  • @isuwu1804
    @isuwu1804 7 місяців тому +4

    One Piece IP is way too strong

    • @UnoDosTres-qn4lm
      @UnoDosTres-qn4lm 7 місяців тому +6

      IP tcgs in general are more popular now then orginial stuff and low key it’s kinda destroying the tcg market you couldn’t release mtg yugioh today they wouldn’to be as popular or make it

  • @tipulsar85
    @tipulsar85 7 місяців тому

    I liked Brother's War Jumpstart.

    • @twarnold14
      @twarnold14 7 місяців тому

      Out of curiosity, how did you play it? Did you grab a booster box or did you just grab 4 packs for you and a buddy? (I ask because the negativity that I see toward set-tied Jumpstart boosters is that it’s not as diverse as a full Jumpstart set, but I always thought it was supposed to be playable theme boosters. And making more ways to play can’t be bad, right? So, I’m genuinely curious about your experience.)

    • @tipulsar85
      @tipulsar85 7 місяців тому

      I grabbed packs, and use them in a Jumpstart cube/archive. I still don't have all five themes.

  • @forthkun03
    @forthkun03 7 місяців тому

    that's why it has "BS" with an extra "S" at the back. it turned out to be lots of bull

  • @supremacyecg6815
    @supremacyecg6815 7 місяців тому

    21:50 suuuuper :D

  • @noahhayslip9270
    @noahhayslip9270 6 місяців тому

    Just bought two boxes and two starters for 70 bucks. We’ll try it out and see

  • @11guitarbro
    @11guitarbro 7 місяців тому +1

    Wow that short promo you made at the end was actually gas and made me super interested

  • @samuelharrison2048
    @samuelharrison2048 6 місяців тому

    Hey this is gonna sound kind aweird but I’m trying to rmember this toy from the early 2000s. I think it kinda had a samurai look to the actionigure and it came with these weird dice that had symbols on them. I think Inremmeber seeing it in a verynold video of your a while back and can’t remember the name.

  • @imposifle9792
    @imposifle9792 7 місяців тому

    9:45 wait what? What was this I had no idea about it

    • @Shoelid
      @Shoelid 7 місяців тому

      Pokémon Van Gogh collab. Buy something from the museum, get a limited edition pikachu promo card.

  • @VoltitanDev
    @VoltitanDev 7 місяців тому +2

    I get licensing issues when it comes to other properties but Bandai should have at least appealed to anime fans by using their own anime to promote Battle Spirits like they did with Vanguard it was the anime that got me into the latter since the anime unlike Yugi Oh follows the rule of the game.
    My reaction to BSS's flop in a nutshell;
    ua-cam.com/video/hNatmCHkI-Q/v-deo.htmlsi=juQB8aRrSs-bd5hW

  • @chinyang1200
    @chinyang1200 7 місяців тому

    Speaking of Getting people who had no interest on the game to Sponsor the game . Remember that episode in the Anime Gunpla Build Fighters ? 1 Word Kirara

  • @IdentityChrist
    @IdentityChrist 7 місяців тому +2

    The middle part feels like someone is mad they weren't chosen instead of people with tens of millions of followers

    • @Stinkoman87
      @Stinkoman87 7 місяців тому +3

      I don't think he would be so mad if they just gave it to TCC or something, as long as creators they were targeting were actual card game focused.

    • @ALherodra
      @ALherodra 6 місяців тому

      Tbf looking at the bandai's choice of influencers...It wouldn't be a surprise if BSS content creators want to black mouth bandai.

  • @casbalt7763
    @casbalt7763 7 місяців тому

    I wish gundaminfo actually did a good job of letting people watch the old series. They just stream the same few gundam series on arbitrary time limits over and over again. It wouldn't kill them to throw in some wild cards every once in a while.

  • @DougyisHere
    @DougyisHere 7 місяців тому

    Moist critical does actually play card game mostly just yugioh to my understanding and he's done a good amount of master duel streams