How War in Ukraine is Destroying Russia
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 жов 2022
- Watch the full companion video covering Russia's Invasion of Ukraine here: nebula.tv/videos/reallifelore...
Please subscribe: / @reallifelore
RealLifeLore on Spotify: spoti.fi/47yMfzp
RealLifeLore on Facebook: / reallifelore
Select video clips courtesy of Getty Images
Select video clips courtesy of the AP Archive
Special thanks to MapTiler / OpenStreetMap Contributors and GEOlayers 3
www.maptiler.com/copyright/
www.openstreetmap.org/copyright
aescripts.com/geolayers/
"1923. The worst time in history to have ever been born a male."
Holy shit. Those death rate numbers are mind boggling !
Can't wait to go die in ether Asia or Europe. Hopefully I get turned into a shitty Netflix movie
Considering who was in charge of the Bolshevik Revolution, it's no surprise.
Blame Communism. If the Russian Empire had never collapsed and instead become a constitutional monarchy like the UK, they'd be boasting a much larger population today, plus Russia and Ukraine wouldn't be separate countries either.
I'd say one of the worst, considering how horrific Chinese history is.
I knew that the eastern front during WWII was an absolute bloodbath, but I didn't realize it was that bad. During World War I there were towns in Great Britain that lost their entire population of young men, as they were assigned to the same unit and would all die during the same charge. It's frightening to think of every town and city losing most of its young men. Looking at some population pyramids from 1950, it looks like a number of women died too, but there was still 1.5-2 women for every man above the age of 25. That sort of hollowing out scars a nation for a long time.
It’s WILD how you can see the rippling effects of WW2 through their demographics. Population charts can say a lot about a nations past and future.
@Cultured Anime Waifu [Russian Waifu] he's just stating a fact relax
Tell me about it. 😂
@@sandraleiva1633 i mean it wasn’t only ww2 that made this 50 million. Most of it was Stalin and they would have died nonetheless
@@sandraleiva1633 fuck that noise. Russia could guarantee its peace by *checks notes* not invading peaceful countries.
@@sandraleiva1633 Russia killed most of it's own citizens.
The majority weren't lost in war, they were lost from communism & tyranny.
FYI: The Norway Border crossing is for commercial transport only. There is one exception: People with historic ties to both sides of the border, most of which are Sami. So yeah, no escape route for people trying to avoid mobilization unless they live up there anyways.
So now russians are gonna take lessons from Illegal mexican immagrants and hitch rides on or in vehicles
9 months later everything's fine, here's a new video about how Russia's actually not collapsing guys. Completely ignores anything brought up during this video. 🤔
:D
😂😂😂
I was quite surprised too :D Obviously, no one really knows how the Russia is doing.
Hes a hypocrite😂
Because russia menaged the problems
the fact that russia more or less shares a border with norway and the US is actually mind boggling and gives you an idea about their massive scale.
And they're big enough to invade our waters in Canada because they want our Arctic oil >:(
And the road from St Petersburg to Norway's border is still 1000 miles. Thinking now it's easier to flee by a boat
What’s the boarder’s name? Is it Zachary? Zachary loves to backpack around the world. He is a famous boarder.
He is a boarder who likes to cross borders, where he surf boards, he is not bored.
If you count Pluto as a planet, Russia is as big, or bigger than the surface radius of Pluto
In essence, bigger than a planet
Also all this land is controled by a bunch of insanely rich people from Moscov. Russia will shater into many new nations as it should
As someone who lived in Sakha Republic until recently I would add that the so called autonomy of republics in Russia is in name only, in practice no region of Russia has any autonomy. Almost all the money from taxes goes directly to federal government and then is distributed to the country's regions from top (federal government) to bottom (municipalities). Obviously you can't go against the federal government when they determine how much money you get to function.
In Finland there has been a longstanding policy of funding even the smaller municipalities so that the whole country stays developed
It’s almost the same system as in EU.
Basically every countries in the world.
@@whitegoose2017 yes and finland have less population than lives in only Moscow, when Russia have extremly hard to get to and make logistic, and villages accesible only by helicopters or only in warm\cold seasons by land. So develop this regions just EXTREMLY expensive and nearly unreal
@@choosenundead4428 It's not that hard to make a road, keep it maintained and have snow trucks constantly keeping the roads clear during winter.
Nah the problem is that there's barely any real political will to do anything for these distant regions. Vast majority of Russians live in Moscow and western Russia anyway. That's why they get the most resources from the government. It's funny looking at the ethnic composition of Russia. Only about 80-90 million can really call themselves Slavic Russians or really Russian.
So it is understandable they are not willing to keep the regions developed.
Ну как успехи, Нострадамусы?
😂😂😂😂
В России всё хорошо
So I wasn’t crazy thinking you made this video and now you making the opposite one 😂😂😂
At least he is admitting his mistake 😂😂😂
This Video is about long term collapse (10-20 years)
@@sehu1291 Yeah yeah nobody can predict the future in 20 years but a random youtuber can
@@helelpichon Demographic change is a fact that can be easily calculated. The majority of Russians in 20 years will be old. However, almost all European countries have the same problem.
All countries have this problem bro, except Africa, some countries like Pakistan @@sehu1291 and maybe USA because it's become an hispanic country and whites are replaced but all over the word there demographic decrease, nobody want childrens in Asia, Europe etc...
As a Russian who fled the country one month ago, I want to add that there's also a significant rise in rent prices in all countries where most Russians go. In Kazakhstan it's about 50%, in Kyrgyzstan it's 21%, in Georgia it has doubled etc. The demand for housing has increased several times. So staying somewhere in a country that used to be cheaper for us is no longer cheap, even for those who have above-average wages.
Nowadays, some people may return because of the latest announcements about the end of mobilization, however, nothing shows that there will be no second wave of it. This is why our stay abroad extends for an indefinite time.
Don't worry. By May 2023, war will be over and almost nothing will be left from Ukraine. Russia will additionally take Kharkov, while Romania and Poland will take Odessa and Lvov respectively. When the war is over, then US will make Taiwan the new Ukraine and start a new war with China. They need to laundry their money somewhere, you know, now that Afghanistan's laundromat is closed.
That is obvious side effect. Buy a house in a village. Take care and stop it.
You are a traitor.
@@dr.embersfield1551 I hope Ukraine will save its independence. We can't make any predictions, however, there is a chance that this will eventually happen.
Yeah, Taiwan is another potential hotspot. And according to what we see in media, it may blow up any time. The strategy of army development by 2027 implemented by China is a big sign that things are going to get worse.
@@simonmeszaros2770 I have no money for buying any type of real estate as well as 90% of those who left the country
My 92 year old grandfather said in February, when the Russian convoy formed in Belarus, that he'd have fleed Russia (and Ukraine) back then. Even without money or resources, it beats the alternative. You can always come back, but you can't always leave.
Hopefully I'll never be faced with that decision, but if I am, I'll take his advice!
Ok bot
You should have asked your grandfather how he leaves without money or resources because that is literally what matters most in terms of ones ability to flee from war.
@@akshaykhandve1122 that was unnecessary
That's called cowardice
@@the180degreerule3 so the potential risk of DYING is better than being a coward?
This video aged like a fine milk :'D
😁
А теперь представьте автомобильную пробку если Украина разрешит выезд из страны для своих мужчин😅
The problem stated is clearly in reference to problems which will come to fruition in 10 - 20 years, which was stated multiple times.
There is a historically unique downward trend in birth rates in the modern era which has rarely been seen except in times of plague as modernization has lowered birth rates markedly and this problem is affecting Eastern Europe more than other regions because it not only has low birth rates but also high migration rates. Whereas somewhere like Sub-saharan Africa has high migration rates but high birth rates; or, on the opposite scale, Japan has a low birth rate but low migration rate.
By the way, in Japan the long standing low birth rate has long been considered a problem and it is projected that it will soon start having a big negative impact on the social security net (less people to pay national retirement benefits) and the economy (less labourers to work jobs).
It is definitely interesting to see what will happen to Eastern Europe due to the loss of population not only from migration and low birth rates, but also now from a bloody war. Yeah, it's clear the place is going to change dramatically VERY soon (but certainly not in 1 or 2 years) and not in a good way.
I would say I would give you the benefit of the doubt because of your screen name that you're not a dumbass, but just being politically biased. But actually, given your Slav name, I'm going to go ahead and assume you're ALSO a dumbass.
This video aged well......
as an alaskan, it completely boggled my mind to hear about the siberian men taking such a small boat across the bering sea just to escape the possibility of being drafted. it is hard to adequately emphasize how dangerous such a journey is in the best of weather, let alone in october! i'm happy that they made it to my hometown of anchorage and i hope they gain asylum and can build good lives for themselves in alaska.
Alaska is a great state, I've been there before.
Seems like they would rather die out in the waters then deal with the draft and fighting on land.
Can't really blame them.
Sometimes humans do crazy ass things that are absurd and somehow pull it off.
It’s how Indians came from Asia long ago )
They're economic refugees of course. Now they have a reason to remain. Thank you uncle Sam.
Hey alaskan, do you know that during vietnam war 2 million of Americans refused to be drafted "to fight for freedom" there?
“War is where the young and stupid are tricked by the old and bitter into killing each other.” Niko Bellic
Фу, коммуняга.
circle of life. one day simba would go into battle for his dad too and that crazy old monkey.
Niko is one of my favorite characters in the gta series
And then, the young and stupid become the old and bitter, who in-turn trick the next generation into killing each other.
@@NewNicator and so the cycle continues anew.
Russia is FAR from collapsing 🤣🤦♂
Now I will never take any videos from this channel seriously, even if he says the Earth is not flat. I can't trust channels like this.
It's like the weather🤦🏼♀️ they predict trends not see the future 💀
I am a Turkish guy from Antalya, the tourism capital of Turkey. And dude EVERYWHERE IS FULL OF UKRAINIANS AND RUSSIANS. They are buying and renting houses and actually living with us here. We haven't seen any mass migration like this since the syrian civil war. Its like Russian became a official language in Antalya man, when i leave the house and walk around i always hear some russians/ukrainans talking, swearing, laughing. Damn bro we are going to Internet cafes to play some games with our friends and even these places are full of russians. Yesterday, i became friends with one russian group in there and we played CSGO together. World is a strange place. I dont want to be misundrestood i am not complaining guys we love our slav bros. Only bad thing is house prices are going insane because of this situation but also there is some advantages, like russian tourists always come here in summer but they must already have been gone now. This winter, they stayed and people like hotel workers and market owners even house owners etc. are still earning money from them. Whatever. Love your videos. Respect to all from Turkey.
turkey best country 🪳💪💪💪
Good luck, in a few years those Russians in Turkey are 'victims' from Turkish nazis and you will be 'liberated from nazis' as well!
Turkey got homies that’ll ride for em so 🤷♂️🤣
Sounds like the Turkish people are pretty hospitable.
May I ask, What is the general stance of Turkish people to immigrantion and immigrants such as Syrians and Slavs? Is there any backlash?
Finally someone explaining the WWII echoes in demography. Most other youtubers that even mention the population pyramids overlook this huge and recurring factor.
Excellent video.
Why do the echos happen?
@@Rhezoloution less people of certain generation age group making less children ...
if 10mil people of same age goes missing, and you dont patch this hole in population, this generation will result in less addition than compared to previous (full) generation and their addition.
and once these fewer kids age into parents there will less kids, when compared to new children of (full) generation
@@Rhezoloution Because a generation barely had any kids, while those shortly after did again. So whenever a generation descendant of the one born during WW2 comes during the time they are most likely to have kids, birth rates decline because there are just fewer people to have kids than there would have been otherwise. TL;DR: Dead people didnt have kids so their unborn kids didnt have kids.
@@Rhezoloution When people in age of giving birth die in mass, then the child they should have had do not exist hence those "not existing child" will in turn not give birth 25 years later. That create ripple in the pyramid that take a few generations to damper.
@@Rhezoloution After 20 or so years babies grow up and reach childbearing age. The massive loss of life in WWII resulted in fewer people to have kids. Their fewer number of kids reach childbearing age and have fewer kids because there are fewer parents. Then their fewer kids grow up and so on. The parts of the population that missed serving in WWII due to being too young or old at the time have regular birth rates, so their descendants have normal birthrates, explaining why the drops come in waves.
This aged well.
This one didn't age all that well huh?
A person in my home town in Minnesota, escaped the Czar's army by the fishing boat to Alaska route.
Minnesota represent
Timberwolves Arrrooooo
A boat was involved so this may qualify as a fisherman's tale
@@anitapodsudek8041 idk man but i think he wasnt fishing tho
That actually crazy for they managed that since the cold will catch up to you and plus there was not the infrastructure in Alaska or a trans continental highway system
One important thing to keep in mind: There were a few interviews with Ukrainian citizens in other countries and stay stated they want to return to Ukraine when the war is over. I'm not sure if the same applies to those who fled from Russia.
They won't be returning until there is a regime change, and everyone involved in the current one is dead/imprisoned.
(Edited for spelling)
Ukraine is definitely looking at this situation in long term, at least in some areas, as countries like Finland who took in Ukrainian orphans was made to give an agreement that they will send the kids back home once the war is over. Not to mention that huge chunk of the refugees are wives and children of the Ukrainian men and women who are fighting right now to secure their homes, they will return.
As an European I like to think that once the war blows over we are indebted to help Ukraine to reconstruct its infrastructure, the U.S will probably help too with a modern version of the Marshall plan. I can see a lot of potential for improvement and foreign investment once the situation stabilizes.
On the other hand they share border with the most unpredictable country in the world so nothing can be said for sure, but at least for now I can feel some gentle optimism for the future.
No ukrainian men who fled will go to jail after going back to ukrainian
Make VODKA Great Again 💯
@@kunmppari6674 There's already been some early discussion of Ukrainian reconstruction after the war. Nothing close to as formalized as the Mashall plan, of course - it's too early for that - but there's definitely people making early discussions. I'd be very surprised if we don't see a considerable reconstruction effort if this war ends in the next few years. (As with many modern wars, there's always the possibility that things will just fizzle out into sporadic border skirmishes, in which case I could see a lot of people being wary of signing on to a major civilian reconstruction effort.)
This one aged like milk
It's more about long term collapsing (10-20 years)
How about now? lol
Didnt age well this video..
It id age well, Russia's population now a year later it's almost parallel to Ukraine's which is a much smaller country, There won't be a russia in the coming decades.
@@DaGo314 what the f*ck?
@@DaGo314 What are you talking about? It still 144 mil.
I thought you were about to say that 700,000 military aged men subsequently showed up in hospitals with broken arms. I was going to be simultaneously impressed, shocked, and sickened.
lol, i thought he was going to say that myself.
Lmao I’m not the only one
I know a lot of people out of a million who have left, but no one knows at least one case with a broken arm. I am sure that the figure of 700,000 is greatly exaggerated to show great desperation
Откуда взята цифра 700 000 человек??? Если при мобилизации призвали 300 000, но на данный момент проходят обучение 150 000 из них
@@user-yu2cl1hc7d тут имеются ввиду "уклонисты", специально ломающие себе руки. Понятно, что цифра завышена жутко
Obviously people hate conflicts and senseless death. We've seen the horrors of World Wars 1 and 2, and we still suffer losses and the world move on. We value life more than ever, especially in a war like that where you are not fighting for your country but rather a small group of powerful individuals.
Iraq Invasion
Like most of wars
If any Russian wishing to flee via the small strip in Norway, might I suggest you contract David Keith, and bring along a sandwich....just in case. [oh, and watch the movie "Gulag" for other tips]
no sympathy for russians.
Then tell Biden and the West to discuss peace like Putin has offered many times, even though it was NATO aggression that triggered this invasion, when it could of been avoided. Europe is literally collapsing, and commited echonomical suicide whitch is in fact true. Putin is winning, he is sitting with the mineral uranium that is critical for energy. USA and the West has zero hands in Uranium production, but none of this critical facts appear in the mainstream media.. Good luck with running the world on waterfall and wind. It literally won’t happen because that is what powers every society.
wow, look how it's collapsing... anytime now... just a few minutes now
he said years. It's weird how people ignore the now collapsing population, A year ago over 1M men left Russia, What do you think the number of it now?
@@DaGo314like no other country has this problem
@@opelastra7798 are any of those other countries shredding their men like pasta so that thr enemy runs out first? Remember during WW2 over 20M russian men got obliterated by the Nazis, ans that's without adding the horror of Stalin ans crew.
The Gender of male to female on Russia is skewed towards females outnumbered men.
@@DaGo314 ~500k, half returned back to Russia.
@@DaGo314 btw, 6M left Ukraine, does it mean Ukraine is collapsing?
Man I’m so worried. My friend lives in Ukraine. I really really hope he stays safe
Lol he probably dead. 😂 That's war for ya, don't be expecting much.
@@AlesAmazigh he’s still alive man
@@AlesAmazigh bet that comment made ya feel better huh?, big boy
@@diegomanosperti8682 did hurt you, little boi? Truth often does that to people. :/ Can't imagine how you'll take it when you find out Santa's fake.
@@AlesAmazigh spoken like a true edgelord, only thoose who didn't suffer speak this way
"the war in Ukraine is amongst the darkest chapters of 21st century history *so far*" Thanks for the 'so far'. Really ties the video together.
I guess he forgot mentioning about the wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria🤣 Remarkably deceptive
Хорошая западная пропаганда
@@crybigfan 'amongst the darkest chapter(s)' implies there are other dark chapters, not just this one
@@crybigfan you really expect him to state every single one of the bad events that has happened in the 21st century? What a goofy ahh ☠️
@@crybigfan why would he talk about that when he specifically talk about ukraine war and its consequences. they are irrelevant because without them ukraine war would still happen
There is also another problem: violence (domestic, etc.). Many children will lose their parents and many returning soldiers will be traumatized. Without proper care this is the recipe for disaster. This can trigger several waves of violence that will hit these societies hard and destablilize them further when the war is over and that even decades later.
Here (Germany) this was one factor for a radical left wave in the late 60s. And by radical I mean bombs and abductions.
Which will not happen becuase there is welfare for veterans and a great amount of money is paid to family and especialy widows, as well the fact that school in eastern europe in general arent the social nightmare that are those in the west
@@Silver_Prussian In theory yes, but in practice I doubt every veteran would benefit from these promises.
@@pyroblaster2476 there is already a welfare system in russia for veterans not like in some other places which lets its men rot on the streets anyways, veterant from the current conflict will also recieve veteran bonuses.
@@Silver_Prussian It's wishful thinking that everyone will get that, America has welfare as well and look at them. Russia is not doing better than them. But I do hope veterans will get the help they need
Долго еще ждать-то?
This didn't age well. Go figure
Your graph on the population echoes of past tragedies is great. Really attracted to content like that
I agree, I think its a demographic pyramid..
Have a look at china's it's way worse.
Asia in general will lose half of population mid-century..
Fascinating subject.
See Peter zihon for more.
Hi from the uk 🇬🇧
I can’t blame Russia it’s the Ukraines fault
Attracted to tragedies….WOW…
For additional context, you can learn more about "population pyramids"
Peter Zeihan!
The phrase "since the Second World War" came up a lot in this video
Since the Second World War there was no bigger shame on Russia or tragedy of it like this.
Which also didn't happen.. since the second world war.
Crimean war hardly gets a mention. At anytime.....since The Second World War.
*since the second world war*
Were getting to the end game of the people who lost that second world war. I consider myself a speciest. Really don't give a shit what happens on this rock. We need to use all our resources making surviving in the universe possible. Doesn't matter how hard you try, this planet is finite. The entire universe as we understand it is finite. Should probably try to figure out as a species how use those resources to gain more resources. 🤔
remember kids, this is uncensored, unreviewed UA-cam videos. Take everything with a grain of salt.
Something that would be worth mentioning is the collapse of the educational system of the Soviet Union. Allegedly the system that replaced it was of much lower quality. Dying age of the average Russian is somewhere around 55-60 years old, meaning the people that graduated before the fall of the Soviet Union, aged ~25 are now starting to die out and are taking a vast amounts of knowledge with them. Not being able to replenish that knowledge might prove to be yet another nail in the coffin.
Very true. My parents born in Moscow in 1967 are both extremely well educated. My cousins born in the 90s - not so much.
Not to mention that a lot of Russians with the education and means have already left the country to seek opportunity elsewhere. Brain drains can have a devastating impact on countries in the long term.
This comment won't get the likes it deserves.
@@shaunstakiw2722 fr
what kind of bullshit are you saying my dude? 1) people in russia live 70-75 years on average and then start dying. 2) the school education system here seems to be way better than in the us… just look at how terrible US kids are at geography and other BASIC subjects. yes, i have talked to russian and us people and i can freely compare them.
I've been telling people for a decade now that Russia has not yet recovered from the effects of WWII. Most people have no clue what happened back then
They got what they deserved for siding with the nazis in the first place.
How can you recover when Russia has been constantly invaded over the centuries by
Sweden,France,Italy,Germany, Greece,finland,Hungary,Romania, Poland, UK,Serbia,Japan????
westerns can't even comprehend the devastation the germans brought to russia. Entire generations wiped out. There's a good reason russia is abosuletly terrified of western expansion. They've been invaded on multiple occasions. Ww2 shaped the russian foreign policy.
it's interesting how in most countries (including mine) ww2 has already mostyl been forgotten whilst the memory is still fresh in many russians eyes
@@itsfinnickbitch63 and germany
2 more weeks and Russia is done right??? This is their worst propaganda video to date. LOL
This channel is so fascinating
All four of my grand parents made it out of Ukraine and Lithuania in the late 1890s when they where in their late teens. They ended up in Detroit. Both grandfathers worked at Ford Motor Company before and after the $5 day and before and after the UAW. They never really talked about their Magnificat journey. They did teach their children and grand children (me) to work hard and treat people fairly. Thanks grandma and grandpa.
We’re happy you’re here
My family came from Scotland
UAW?
@@Garbeaux. United Auto Workers, as a salaried employee, whatever they got (UAW) every 3 years at new contract negotiations we got plus a few points to stay non unionized. It usually worked except in the building I worked where the designers unionized and Henry Ford the II went nuts. He said that the next unit that got unionized in the salaried workforce , he would personally fire every member of the management team up to an including a direct report to him. As far as I know that fixed the problem.
my great grandfather made it out of Russia around that same time he traveled with his mom and younger sister and he worked New York and New Jersey at GE.
I've been to that border between Russia and Norway. It's tiny and the road is incredibly narrow. I'm surprised it hasn't been closed
no point, they are not crossing it
Good opportunity, take a chance dude
did you escape the gulag, and bring a sandwich? are you David Keith?!
Those with valid travel papers can cross if not on foot. The control has been increased, and the border can be closed on short notice. It’s a Schengen border, so it’s likely that all information about travelers is passed on to other EU countries. Norway’s intelligence agency in cooperation with some other western nation’s intelligence agencies caught an illegalist (spy with the identity of an ordinary citizen) in Norway about a couple of weeks ago. He posed as a citizen from Chile, and a researcher
not ww 2 any longer foot soldiers are thing past used as pawns ,,, two advisors in viet nam killed next month ten thousand soldiers came, first loss battle another 100 thousand came escalated to 500 thousand , then draft lotto u did not want to win ,
thank you for your video
Bro not pay enough by CIA
Keep up the great videos
Nice
Nice
Superb
Hi
Nicr
One difference could be that Ukraine, once the war is over, will likely heavily incentivize its displaced people to return. Russian displaced people know they'll only face punishment if they return.
Russians will only face punishment if the current regime stands. Btw most of them will not get punished anyway, they fled before they were put on the wanted list.
oh, Russians will only return after the regime is over, and that can take quite some time happen. Yet I still believe it's bound to happen sooner or later, with dethroning the tyrant or actual collapse.
Hopefully, if Ukraine somehow after this conflict joins NATO or heck even the EU, I can see their population seeing very positive growth. I’m not to familiar with the cultural implications cause Ukraine is more similar to Russia than it is to the west.
The will need western help though as billions of dollars worth of infrastructure will need to be rebuilt.
@@bayanzabihiyan7465 why would eu need another subsidized member? only NATO membership is probable.
@@bayanzabihiyan7465 trillions*
Great video, thanks!!
It's great to live in a world where rich people at the top of society get to decide the fate of millions of people that just want to live a decent life and find happiness.
This has always been the case, just the population numbers have changed. Not saying we shouldn't change it, it's just nothing new.
I mean responsibility is ours though
-dont vote them in
-dont let them pass laws that take away your freedom (anti guns etc)
-dont spend your money on them (buy local and small business goods as much as you can)
YESSSSSS
@@fungunsun1 how weapons are related to your freedom?
You can't use them against the government even if you disagree with it. Just dare to point the gun at the police. You'd be shot on sight.
Leaders represent their people, like it or not.
“I don’t believe ads should be shown alongside suffering and tragedy”, literally one of the reasons why you’re among the best UA-camrs. I listen to true crime sometimes and hearing an ad play while someone is telling a story about the loss of lives is devastating and only causes people to become more desensitized to violence and tragedy.
That’s how you know he’s not doing it for money but to spread awareness!
@@franksinatra3494 exactly! Something that is unfortunately not that common these days
I was getting UA-cam ads throughout the video...
Yo, I got like two ads while watching this video 🤣
@@LukeTowan i heard that apparently if you dont add your own adds, youtube does it for you. also i think they were talking about nebula.
This is top drawer stuff , a blessing ,The real deal ,learnable
Comprehensive, important reporting.
My best friend growing up was from Kyiv Ukraine. She still has family there and my heart is breaking
When I was little, my neighbour's family were Ukrainians from Donbas. They had three daughters, and they were my first real friends.
We baked cakes together, we learned to read Cyrillic letters together (yes, I was able to read Ukrainian and Russian before I could read the Latin alphabet - and I'm neither), we played piano together, we sang together, we watched Russian and Ukrainian children series together.
In 2014 I saw them again, coincidentally, and they told me about how their grandfather lived in war-torn Donbas all by himself with tears in their eyes.
He said that he's too old and stubborn to leave, that his father survived Hitler and he'll survive the Russians too. He died last year, and while I'm a non-believer, may the just God he always faithfully believed in bless his soul and give him rest.
The three Ukrainian girls, now refined young women, also told me that they were sad and if they are going to have children, there would be no more Russian children books for them. We remembered how we enjoyed them, and a great sadness overcame us.
The Russians call themselves "brothers" and "friends" of Ukrainians, but they kill them out of pride and greed.
The band is cut, and both the Ukrainians and those who are not cry out to them now: "Cain, where is your brother?"
I don't understand, and it breaks my heart.
It’s sad times for sure. But trust me. Russia is getting their asses kicked and Ukrainian is putting up probably the best fight this side of the millennium.
@@Wackoart1995 Kind of unrelated, but there's a certain tragedy in the fact that people seem to be able to only be able to think of one thing at once.
My younger brother volunteered to fight with the Kurds and I served as humanitarian worker in Ukraine for a few years.
If you think about it, the Kurds and the Irish, the Ukrainians and Armenians, don't they all suffer from a not too dissimilar fate of oppression, subjugation and genocide?
And yet - the Ukrainians throw the Kurds under the bus for a few Bayraktar and NATO membership of Sweden and Finland.
The Kurds abandoned the Irish, because many Brits volunteered.
The Irish (Republicans) betrayed Ukraine, because Russia hates Britain and they do as well.
Despite Kurds historically genociding Armenians and the Soviet Union ethnically cleansing Kurds from Armenia, those are actually two of the only groups so far properly supporting one another.
But then, the Armenians still backstabbed Ukraine, because the former are Moskali dick suckers.
I do believe that the fight in Ukraine today is the greatest of our time, for it's by far the largest of all and the one threatening the "West", i.e. our way of life, the most.
...and like the Irish in eight hundred years, the Kurds in several hundreds, the Armenians since 1890 - the Ukrainians showed the same valour in the last eight months!
Many people don't know this, but the original answer to: Glory of Ukraine! is Glory on all of earth! („По всій землі слава“):
May the name of free Ukraine resound on all of earth the same way all democratic people realize their self-rule should!
@@kurteisner67 the Ukrainian military was the ones bombing Donbas!
@@kurteisner67 Cool story bro, now take your medication.
As to the people who have left Ukraine and Russia in the past year, the big issue is how many of them will return when the war ends. Obviously many will return, but I suspect more Ukrainians will return than Russians. And if Ukraine enters the EU and NATO, they may find that they see net positive migration going forward. I don't see a realistic scenario where Russia would have positive migration.
Ukrainians even now returning, not everyone but at least half
We love our country but economic situation right now sucks hard
Have you ever been in Ukraine or Russia?
Because it looks like you don’t actually understand what you are comparing
I emigrated from Ukraine 25 years ago. I never gave up my Ukrainian citizenship and never accepted any other, although I could have. I'm arranging a return though this will take a few more years. I do believe many of those Ukrainians settled across the globe are considering the same. It's now the first time in all this time that I'm exceptionally proud and hopeful of my country and want to actively help rebuild it and make it better.
Russians though? They must not be feeling the same at all.
@@user-bh3lf1ct6b Instead of just telling me I'm wrong, why don't you explain your perspective?
I can see how families of soldiers would return after, but the military-age men who fled Ukraine will not return after the war. Neither will the Russian men who fled.
This reminds me of that thing in Stratego where you have one last soldier left to defeat, but its the highest rank and your highest rank already died.
Good video. I've been thinking the same thing.
Searching "how to break the arm at home" for staying alive is one of the scariest things that I've seen in a while.
Totally different story tho..
This is fake news that was posted on pro Ukrainian polish channel.
It was a common practice in Iraq during the Iraq-Iran war
If only that story is true... Russian laws predict that, and is punishable by law... And Russians use Yandex, not Google... So brutal lie invented by ukro nazis and NATO think tanks.
@@ngrey5092
yeah, this fake story is originated from Nexta, pro-nazi polish channel
Seeing this made me feel grateful to live in a peaceful country.
Security doesn't exist in the world. Only different degrees of insecurity.
Peace doesn't exist in the world. Only cease-fires.
Name your country, to see how "peaceful" it is.
Peaceful?
What country?
Asian here. I haven't experienced a "war" in my entire live (yet?)
@@e_is_for_existential_crisis I live in Malaysia
Really, in you own dream.
Wow, the satellite imagery at 3:30 is incredibly detailed.
😂 The "new Era journalists" don't give a damn about what they are saying, here is $$$, here is a script, go make a video and pretend to be smurt.
@@alexflayz3600 should I assume smurt is a joke and not a missspelling?
@@chrischeng9145 ofc, have I become so old, that I am using dated slang? 😅
@@alexflayz3600 yep
lol YEAH... thats some high res stuff.
I never knew how serious the population issues in Ukraine and Russia were before. This definitely doesn't make the war look any less worse.
the problem is, that population in these countries is not considered as asset. It is considered as liability, as mouths to be fed from country's incomes.
@@reimuhakurei9409 All populations in every country are viewed the exact same by the elite! Wake up!
@@reimuhakurei9409 but they can use the population as soldiers right? without people there is no way to defend their borders and there is nobody that works for them
@@PadsterX they got ethnic Russians who live outside Russia, like in Kazakhstan. They lived there before the Soviet Union fell and now are citizens of Kazakhstan. So if they really need bodies they’d probably annex those areas or see them as a asset because of the CSTO. The smart idea would be to incentivize them through nationalism to come back to Russia tho.
@@reimuhakurei9409 as long a they are able to work population is always good u must not have a good movement if u can't use numbers in ur favor
AGED BADLY INNIT
Not really though is it pal
@@SenorPenor1337 Ukraine is worse off than Russia rn
April 2023 now and we're still fine, lmao.
Speant the summer in Kyrgyzstan/Kazakhstan. The amount of Russians that moved to Bishkek while I was there was insane. Each week, there were noticably more and more Russians
That is actually genius. In a few years, there will be referendums for those countries to join Russia.
@@FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_ Russians are hated wherever they go. There will be no more fake Russian "referendums" ever again.
@@FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_ yeah that's the main fear in the countries that have closed their borders. The Soviet Union was notorious for its population transfer policies that removed "subversive" natives and shuffled them around the SSRs, replacing them with other ethnicities, most often Russians as they were the most populous and least insurrectionist. Today it's these expatriated Russians that are the most nostalgic of the USSR and are the base of support for Russia in these countries.
@@FakeAssHandsomeMcGee_ Russia will still be busy fighting Ukraine in a few years. Russia couldn’t even spare troops to secure the border of CSTO member Armenia against Azerbaijan.
Maybe you can learn that during summer something called tourism exists... After west blocked Russians from traveling they went to other places.
When your soldiers don't have the will to fight, you've already lost the war.
Nothing good comes from war, I thought humans learned those lessons a long long time ago, but no, it seems we never learn.
Yeah I don’t think Russia is struggling
fantastic video. I really appreciate content creators like you. You actually make legitimate content. Too many people make money just "reacting" to videos. This is excellent.
this is so stupid and propaganda video Are you robot?
I agree makes no sense how people like those kinds of videos.
Technically anyone can make those kinds of videos.
I could care less about other peoples reactions to things.
Same with the cover pictures of videos.
They are all starting to seem the same a persons face on there with wording and then you have the misleading titles.
Guess people love it
It's just more NATO bullcrap and Russophobic propaganda
My Ashkenazi jewish great grandfather escaped germany with his mom at a very young age to inmigrate to Chile, this brave woman (that was also a widow) that left everything behind is the reason I exist and enjoy this great life, thank you, Oma Frieda
Que bacan
Ashkenazi jewish is faith or bloodline?
Mafia
Wow
thats very interesting story, immigrate from europe to Chile.
One remark - Russia is not eager to mobilize ethnic Russian men (it could change in next months), because they are the social base for regime's power and economic stability. They in first place mobilized men from Dagestan, Buriatia and other regions, so yes - they are using war also to decrease the number of men in those regions, as they are not prepare for war in any shape or form.
Что за бред?
@@dmike3358 Куча это сколько? С Бурятии забрали больше чем с Урала, МО?
@@dmike3358 Бред. Я понимаю, когда ты это иностранцам пишешь, они могут и поверить, но я то тут живу.
@@Tovarish2121 сжв разноняют мульку про злых русских н4цистов, которые уничтожают Дагестан и Бурятию (это при том что 75% п0гибших на СВОйне это русские).
@@posetitel-Storozhevoy-Bashni Я просто не понимаю зачем они это делают? Почему именно буряты и дагестанцы, а не лезгины, якуты, татары. тувинцы? Да и в чем профит, что американцы будут так думать?
These episodes are amazing.. incredibly well produced, detailed and topical. Lol I didn't even know that Kalingrad was a Russian enclave and I consider myself relatively well informed on global politics. I just signed up to your NebulaTV channel and its filled with even more great content.
Former capital of Germany, Königsberg. They destroyed the vast majority of german history there and there was some important germanic history there that we willnever get back.. What Russia did to the germans post-WW2 is horrifying.
@@ronnytotten9292 totally deserved.
@@ronnytotten9292 russia takes only a one city while Poland stole whole prussia but it's ok. Lol, didn't Germans do bad things to soviets?)) Around 15 mil. Humans of Soviet republics was murdered by Germans. Is this also ok?
@@xapiuss5876 Stalin killed more of his own soviets than the Germans did. Regardless its horrifying on all accounts. But I am never a fan of destroying important history. The Russians deliberately destroyed ANYTHING that resembled Germany or Prussia just as a fuck you to the country. Both genocides were horrible but the innocent civilians are not the ones who cause them but rather die for them.
It is Kaliningrad and it is an exclave.
You mention Ethic minorities in Russia having population gains. But what you don't mention is how a lot of soldiers we are seeing sent to Ukriane are Minority soldiers. I think we will see this effect them
That is a great point. It could amount to ethnic cleansing.
@@TheChodax exactly. They are using the conflict to kill not only Ukrainians, but ethnic minorities inside Russia. You don't see young Russians in Moscow being mobilized
Giving minories military grade training and weaponry with orders to fight and possibly die for the Russian people may not go down flawlessly.
I'll be keeping a close eye on the Chechen people if I were Putin.
@@TheChodax It is mostly because of volunteers, sadly. To dumb it down, anyone who's not leaving in the western part of Russia would have generally lesser education and access to the internet/media outside of television. So they are very easy to manipulate with propaganda.
@@Aszod96 another tragedy against indigenous people. 😔
As a Kazakh 🇰🇿, I am fascinated by this and seeing why both of their people are leaving their Country, by the way, Ruzzians are Zombie Chauvinists.
They want to escape the draft and I feel bad for them 😢
@@Woodlock970 more like we lost hope to change stuff here
@@Woodlock970 Nah I know this, come on, let's exclude Mobilization, why are they leaving although there is no war in Ruzzia?
@@Woodlock970 you feel bad for people, who are okay with war and genocide of ukrainians, bot not okay with draft?
@@shaycormac3219 Their government is okay with war and genocide. They are just following orders and I guarantee a majority of them just want to go home and be with their families. Pretty small minded take..
Interesting and informative. Thanks for posting.
Иностранцы так много говорят о конце России, но пока что держали его только за щекой
As someone who studies history, most Russian “collapses”(Russian revolution, fall of the Soviet Union) coincided with economic woes and a war that was deeply unpopular. Historically speaking, it seems more likely than not that Russia is going to collapse. Again.
I do not see how a war that brings only losses can remain popular
@@user-wm5rt9pw5l I've watched a lot of videos by people interviewing Russians - it appears to me like a whole lot of people just block it all out of their minds (in Russia).
@@user-wm5rt9pw5l propaganda machine is really strong
people are used to having a great good tsar who leads them everywhere, it's almost in our genetics now (metaphor)
first it was the tsar of course, then it was the emperor, then it was lenin, then it wad stalin, now it's president
there's a load of old people here who had never seen anything better and are used to believing anything that government says since ussr
The Kremlin within should collapse
@@petertattersall6419 the kremlin is a nice piece of architecture (tho i would prefer if it wasn't colored like blood of all the people killed in countless repressions and wars), rather putin's (and all of his associates) whole body should collapse hard down some slippery marble stairs
I googled my country's (Georgia) population pyramid and noticed the similar pattern, which now I understand, what it means. We, as part of the USSR also took heavy loses, compared to our total population in WW2.
Гижо траки!
And your country doesn't even manage the economic upswing like Ukraine and is therefore clinging to EU accession to cover up its own inadequacy with money. Perhaps it has always been, and always will be, that a country's poor are disproportionately sent to war, like blacks or Hispanics in the US Army.
@@janestones323 Он, должно быть, забыл, что Сталин из Грузии. 😅
Also the collapse of the USSR was brutal for demographics. Many young people left their home countries for good and many who stayed behind had one child and much of the time it was a single mother household. The countries with the highest divorce rates are post Soviet countries like Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan.
@@janestones323
Hey, greetings from Russia) Didn't collapsed as you said. Your little ukrop offensive not going well, funny to see how you're going to release a new cope video after that haha. Bye now, and thanks for the laugh)
It will die one day world will be saved if Russia collapses from inner mongol (china State
@@eternalmongolwhy russia? Why not usa or china?
Superb, informative video.
Thanks!
Understanding birth rates and population grown/contraction is a great barometer for an economic impact on a country (helped me get into Carnegie Melon) . I love the stats used in understanding this conflict, another great piece!
What’s your thoughts on China? A lot of people expect China to become the world’s biggest economy and the next superpower. But their demographics look very bad and recent economic slowdowns might seriously slow that trend or maybe never reach that goal.
@@kev792 I think they’ll probably buy the new Mario game
@@MrHomelessHobos 😂
@@kev792 A lot of Chinas growth was borrowed
Borrowed from the west
Borrowed from their own people
It was all smoke and mirrors to begin with
@@ironspaghett I agree somewhat. I think China overall benefited from globalism and the west being already developed and them needing cheaper labor than their home population. The Chinese people overall love how China has grown, and they lifted the most people out of poverty, and seen one of the fastest growths of any country. But now I think the chickens have come to roost, with the stupid one child policy messing up demographics, Mao’s idiotic genocide and culture war, higher labor costs than their surrounding neighbors, and Xi the (not that bright) ideologue.
Sorry, can't see any destruction in Russia, LOL
Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland did not fully close the borders with Russia and actually they are still open till this moment for holders of visas that have work, humanitarian (refugees) or family reasons (some relatives from countries mentioned above invite you for visits).
What is true, that all the tourist valid visas were annulled. This is the most simple to get and the most popular type of visa. And and it has the least control over whom it was given out to. The last is the main reason for not letting the holders of tourist visas in.
bullshit
As far as I know Estonia also closed entry for relatives late September. They're also not giving working visas or new temporal residence permits for workers with Russian citizenship. A friends of mine had to relocate to Germany, because their working visa was near to an end, and Estonia won't nether prolong their visas, neither give them TRP. Thankfully they're working for a big company with departments in different countries, so it just moved them.
Latvia closed entry (at least for Riga area) even for Russians with residence permits in other EU countries - there was incident recently, when Russian people, living in Estonia by TRP, had to book a new flights from Turkey, because their original flight was supposed to make stop in Riga and they just weren't allowed to board.
@@antonvoloshin9833
Thanks! Maybe already changed then.
Had some relatives coming to Estonia in September, had no issues then.
Also had some friends with Russian citizenship and Estonian PRP traveling in October between Estonia and Russia back and forth with no issues at the border.
This video is to tickle the senses a bit....providing info to make you giggle if you are pro Ukraine.
@@kaybee1025 yes. It’s walking the line of US govt paid advertising
Keep this video up.
Sounds like wishful thinking to me. I figure that they are saying the same about us.
Okay, now I have a reason to get nebula. Fantastic video. Keep it up.
Take a shot every time he says
"Since WW2"
By far the worst thing that happened to Russia due to the war, Mcdonalds left Russia.
I personally know Russians who in the last couple months have flown to Brazil and from there the USA to expatriate from Russia. Besides these lately, there are big communities of Russian ex-pats from the last few years who were already escaping before this all came to a boil.
These are not real Russians, the state does not even take into account the loss of such people. They are cowards and traitors to the Motherland
Just because you know single digit Russians who leave the country doesn't mean the country is collapsing. Your comment adds literally zero value.
So basically Putin was like "The risk I took was calculated but man...am I bad at math." love to see it.
Then he still continue on...
@Cultured Anime Waifu [Russian Waifu] 😂😂😂
@Cultured Anime Waifu [Russian Waifu] POV:You have mentally 1lln3ss
Not quite. The risk he took was calculated, but the culculation hasn't run it's course yet. Everyone in the geopolitical game is currently hanging by a thread, Putin thinks he can hang on long enough to manage to get a edge in for the future.
Putin :I’m take a gamble
Ukraine:.Nah bro
The West:Get rekt
Putin:Can’t go back now!
It's wild to me that you can just "capture" people in real life, like in an RTS game.
Bless your heart darling. RTS games were founded on real life
Maybe the East Ukranians are half-Ukranian half-Russian?
Wild does not even describe it.....look up the Holocaust and the industrial extermination of masses of people in NAZI occupied Europe during World War 2. The bottom line is, when the global plutocrats at the head of the imperialist powers, decide that a re division of the planet is to their benefit, as happened during WW1 and WW2, there are no limits to the war atrocities that they will commit in pursuit of geopolitical hegemony.
@@alals6794 I meant more like in a day to day basis, and that once you are captured, you're considered part of that nation, you're headcounted as that nation.
@@sunabubus no, your nationality stays the same (How did you get this idea anyway? , had to save a screenshot of this comment), In your papers,it stays the same like your place of birth
И как?
Very good video, analytics, supported by facts and links to sources (no)
😂😂😂😂😂😂 This has got to be sarcasm
Good video, but I think there is one thing needs correcting. Russia's many regions and federations are not effectively autonomous anymore. They were once, before Putin's power vertical centralization effort. Most of the power these regional governors held has been eroded, especially in Moscow, Russia's nerve center. Further, individual provinces and municipalities are completely dependent on Moscow financially because a high degree of taxes collected are first sent to Moscow and then back to the regions to make up for any local shortfalls, further increasing dependence on the Russian center.
Putin is trying to kill off the ethnics through disproportionate mobilization.
@@annoyed707 Probably, but also other "undesireables" in Russia like criminals and political dissidents. Putin probably thought this a clever way to get rid of anybody who threatens his personal power.
This
Their autonomy is only that one on paper. In reality they are less autonomous than those of many unitary countries.
Maybe this is why Putin's mobilization has disproportionately targeted minorities. Autonomous entities no longer have the power to resist such abuses from Moscow.
He is "murican", he got money from sponsors and from the views. Why he would care about something like that... Most of his viewers will applaud him for anything at this point. Especially if he goes with the crowd. These american edutaiment channels are still making these stupid errors.
Also keep in mind the people leaving likely have a bias towards certain political views; which means the ones left do as well. This contributes further to politics swinging more and more extreme in Russia.
Good point, but disturbing.
For sure. The folks leaving have the means to do so and transportable skills like engineers. Aside from the general population loss, they are losing the folks needed to maintain a modern economy.
Not a good combination.
Only true for the middle class that has the means to flee and nothing tying them down. The vast majority of Russian population is poor. Not everyone is too poor to the point of living in the slums but clearly lacking the means to travel anywhere (aside from neighbouring cities) due to how expensive it is. A lot of people are in debt trying to pay for their mortgage and if you're in financial debt you simply are forbidden from leaving the country. So it's fairly young people trying to make it in life and leave away from their parents aside from those who have other tethers like sick family members.
A lot of people in this group despise the regime and Putin, and would be happy to see him gone, it's just they feel stuck in their tough life situation. The moment these people sense the wind of change or the weakness in the system, they won't be silent, and they'll do their best to fight for their future. And the opposition members who are in exile want to return as well, but only when it's safe to do so, not unlike the many Ukrainian refugees that had to evacuate until this war is over.
@@bloodymares That's very optimistic view. I'm not sure there's left any willpower to fight anymore. Maybe (probably) foreign intervention will help, but one can only dream.
@@aidarosullivan5269 no, unfortunately foreign intervention would not help but tamper with the evolution of Russia. Most of the European countries had to go through dictatorship phase and wars until they had enough and learned to fight for their freedoms, without help from the outside. Russia needs to do the same if it's to become a strong democratic country. Liberty is not given, it is taken. The Russians have been hoping for a magical savior figure throughout history, that kind of overreliance on someone who can make their problems disappear in exchange for loyalty is what led to a dictatorship over and over again. There must come a point of realization that the magical savior will never come, and that they're responsible for their own lives.
And about the willingness to fight - you must understand that Russians are doing it every day in their own way. They're not fighting openly, they're fighting discreetly. By resisting demands from the government, by sabotage that seems like laziness or incompetence. It's the Russian way of protesting born out of necessity to operate in a very dangerous environment where the opposing force is too strong for an open fight.
"Mutual destruction is never the preferred option." - Thrawn
Tell us more about how the country with no electricity is beating the Bear.
Ay on a real, we don’t know how lucky we are! The fact we can openly mock our politicians, pick and choose sides, move freely. Here’s hoping this senseless war comes to an end.
As a resident of Western Siberia myself...frankly, I don't think it's likely we'll outright collapse, but yeah, it all sucks
You’ll be fine. This video is paranoia. Also, start having some children.
@@josiahmorris5799 ok vlad. Lmao
@@spacemanx9595 Russian Bots are everywhere.... I am a US home grown russian bot who doesn't believe that trump was installed by putin...
You have to be an idiot to believe that. You have to be an idiot NOT to be a russian bot.
XantheSpace Sorry, you got the imperialist ruZZia flag as your background. I hope you change that and oust Putin
@@josiahmorris5799 no. I rather be alone than giving the children to Putin
confirm. we are so destroyed. writing this comment from destroyed laptop through destroyed internet
❤
This war can never destroy Russia, but Ukraine.
Aged like milk 😂😂😂
“Unlimited power in the hands of limited people always leads to cruelty.” “Violence can only be concealed by a lie, and the lie can only be maintained by violence.”
A state of war only serves as an excuse for domestic tyranny.”
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Are you talking about bloody clown zelenski?!
Very true. Now reverse the roles and you'll know who the good guys and the bad guys are this time. Don't be fooled by main stream propaganda.
He is a clown and a puppet. 100%
@@mewhoelse3554 who's the bad guy then?
@@mewhoelse3554 🤣🤭🤪