Reports: 55 Sailors Dead as China's Nuclear Submarine "Caught in Trap" | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Вставка
- Опубліковано 3 жов 2023
- Reports: 55 Sailors Dead as China's Nuclear Submarine "Caught in Trap" | Vantage with Palki Sharma
Reports say 55 sailors are feared dead after China's nuclear submarine got "caught in a trap".
The accident is said to have taken place in August in the Yellow Sea. UK's intelligence report said the submarine suffered a "catastrophic failure" that poisoned the crew.
China has denied the incident, calling the information false. Palki Sharma tells you more.
---
China | Nuclear Submarine | Sailors | Death | Yellow Sea | Firstpost | World News | Vantage | Palki Sharma
#china #nuclearsubmarine #sailors #death #yellowsea #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
#Firstpost2Million: Thank you viewers for your trust!
Leave a comment and let us know what more would you like to see on the channel.
A nuclear powered submarine has unlimited electricity supply to power the oxygen generator.
Suspicious about the submarine getting caught by their own trap ?
@@peekaboopeekaboo1165 Unlimited? 🤣 There is no technology that provides unlimited electricity till now chinese bot 😂 If you want to counter statements, at least make sense.
The report is full of craps. Yellow sea is too damn shallow for a nuclear submarine to have an accident.
Don’t be empire of lies just start another allegation
The only problem is this is the 2nd time this very channel repeat the fake news. The same piece was already put to rest by Taiwan's military on 24/8 and that was 6 weeks ago. Palki came up with this 3 weeks after TW military spoke in public about this alleged accident.
there could be truth to this matter coz it is very strange that the defense minister was suddenly sacked.
Its a completely fake story 🤣... Anchor and Chain story ... 🤣🤣
@@zakjuly6721 Are you CCP?
@@Daniel-S1 It's more like you are anti CCP. CCP then what? At least they care about their own people unlike the west, drugs, guns and rock'en roll.
@zakjuly6721 China has a very bad habit of saving face to the detriment of its own people. It’s part of why pride is referred to as the cardinal sin and it is a bad habit that everyone should learn to overcome.
A 6000 ton nuclear sub runs out of oxygen in 6 hours ???
Even a 500 ton mini sub has more on board oxygen than that
Something is fishy
The real story is diff
Was thinking along the same line.
My opinion is the response time stated is most probably missing a 0 behind the 6.
That would make sense
This is a routine statement given by authorities all over the world.... Blame it on oxygen or some other 'mechanical' failure instead of 'our espionage submarine destroyed'.
This also gives them a cushion to use against their enemies once they do the same to any enemy vessel.
These subs all carry emergency oxygen candles to burn if the main generating system malfunctions. They should have a few days emergency oxygen supply with just the candles. Perhaps CO2 scrubbers malfunctioned and that buildup poisoned them.
If all people could think intelligently or know how to analyze things properly, this kind of propaganda wouldn't be so successful. 😌
They would have days of air and options just another mystery as more fuel depots, food pants, trains and viruses Blow up Just a coincidence
Am a Filipino, what China are doing to my country is very serious and very dangerous but hearing this news, makes me sad. Maybe this is one of the Karma they will have. May their soul rest in peace and condolences to the all families too.
Contrast Chinas' present activities in your country with what went on when Japan occupied. And then study the history of the Marcos regime, which was imposed on your country by the US. You have had it worse...
Your country is been used by the US and has no independence
@@johnbuckles1344 - The US did not do anything to opress the Philippines and when they wanted their independence, we gave it to them unlike the ccp also known as "West Taiwan(the home of the legitimate chinese government in exile)" who continues to oppress and enslave Mongolia and Tibet. Philippines is a free sovereign country which USA fought to free from the Japanese only to turn it over to its people in 48 after the war. But the ccp killed and enslaved all Chinese people on the mainland in 47. Philippines need subs to sing ccp boats harassing their fishing vessels operating in their economic zone. The ccp is a bully and a thief.
@@johnbuckles1344that's was the past,just erase it in your mind,if you can't erase how much more the covid virus that scattered in your brain man?be smart now a days is different Chinese are worst that Japanese,So i think their karmas are starting,who knows that's karma with their fellow Chinese who died because of covid virus...😅😅😅😅
China needs to be stopped or they will take over sadly
Excellent report! She laid this situation and China’s reactions out perfectly! I heard the sub had sent a diver out to see what was wrong and he triggered something that shut off the auxiliary oxygen. I’ve also heard it was a failed torpedo test.
I heard that it was a leaky periscope or possibly a faulty torpedo tube
If divers outside Chinese submarines have abilities to shut off internal oxygen supply... you may have just revolutionized Modern undersea warfare. OR don't believe EVERYTHING you read, especially on the interwebs tubes
I heard someone snuck a bean burrito onboard, farted and asphyxiated the crew... @@specialandroid1603
I heard it was an accident 🤔
An accident that needs to be covered from the rest of the world incase they look STUPID!😅 because China is still conniving and still wants to take over the world, especially US😂😂😂
As a Navy Vet my heart goes out to any sailor who dies at sea. May your souls find Fair Winds & Following Seas.
this fake news btw western propaganda
Indian media lies about china submarine incident. Chinese officials are more credible。
@@LOLLOL-kg4dzyour the only fake around here little wee boy everyone is laughing at you.
@@LOLLOL-kg4dz It could be, but my statement still stands. Even if this is a fake story. Somewhere, someday, a sailor in a Navy will die at sea and I will be sad for their loss.
@@LOLLOL-kg4dz You're right. I've heard of you. You're the notable and highly reputed naval expert Mr @LOLLOL-kg4dz.
Not knowing the status of the reactor, wasn't this about the time China started throwing out bad press about Japan irradiating the waters by releasing Fukoshima water known to be far below acceptable limits. China wanted to blame their potential nuclear 'oops' on Japan.
It is not China that throw out bad press on Japan's release of contaminated water but it is Tokyo electric that release data to IEAE is a Japanese government owned company with a known history of 200+ incidents of lies and fabricated reports in its operations between 1977-1997, it was also known for its safety breach and negligence in 2004 that resulted in shut down of its 17 reactors and mass resignation in the company. If there is an accident with a nuclear sub we would have know it by now as Japan or Korea would know it with their sonar system and we would also saw massive testing of radiation level of the sea near by. We would have heard news about high radiation level much much higher than 18000 time than accepted level, that was the radiation level 50km near fukushima.
China did it in purpose to throw away the toxic waste they think it can harm Japan water.
But you see
if there are flood in China the toxic waste Chinese Communist throw away also return to China and poison China itself.
Not to mention China polluting the oceans with the bodies of 55 sailors... They cause most of the world's pollution and have the nerve to make up stories about Japan, which is the cleanest country on earth. It's hilarious coming from China, where even the hospitals don't have soap in their bathrooms...
False news. The 093 nuclear submarine cannot have only 55 people. The Soviet Type 971 nuclear submarine has a crew of 100 people. The U.S. Seawolf-class nuclear submarine has a crew of 133 people.
@@user-dd2bl8rx4b😂😂
As a retired Navy man, it is sad to see such loss, but China does not care, their people are expendable and replaceable.
That's the communist version of so-called "morality" for you.
That's USA. Not china
@@LeeSuKwang-ol5oy LOL... Nice try! China could care less about it's people other than sucking the blood out of them. When I visited Jining City, Shanghai, and Xi’an City on a business trip to the companies I work for, the people were nice and friendly, BUT, they DID NOT like their government and their leaders.
As a retired Navy man, would you have a sub in Taiwan Strait when the depth of the entire strait is 150m, the shallowest area in the strait is about 20m.
@@jliang70 I have no idea what a Sub Commander would do other than what is requested of him by his Command Logistics team...
My brother in law almost died in a submarine during WWII and he was left with a bad stutter and became an alcoholic due to untreated PTSD for these veterans.
Yet another example of how the Political Class uses, abuses and casts aside men better than themselves - that would be American soldiers.
So
@@garymuhlenforth7251So keep you mouth shut if you don't have anything nice to say.
I'm a former US submariner... *I will pray for these souls.* Imagine the failures that led up to this tragedy, in _how many ways_ could this have been prevented?
Heard of a chart?!
You ask yourself: _A quick death through decompression or explosion, or to die slowly in the dark, coughing and gasping for your last breath_
My hope is that they truly believed in what they were doing, that they died feeling noble and accomplished. Some sort of purpose...
Because from where I'm sitting, it looks like the world lost 55 sailors to a game of cloak and dagger, of which only China is playing anymore.
The souls released from the organic bodies will not suffer any guilt. They just did their job. I expect they did believe their job was important, either way it no longer matters. They are free now.
It's all about saving face to the expense of citizens lives, what about EV, and aircraft if they make aircraft, most humane societies would reach out
Considering how much China suffered from Britain, Europe, Japan and US during their century of humiliation, they feel very strongly that their cause is just and noble. I can't say the same for our government which has since WW2: invaded Iraq on WMD lies, bombed Cambodia, bombed Loas, Marshall Islands Nuclear Testing, Japanese Internment, Vietnam War, tortured prisoners in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, assassinated thousands of foreign leaders (democratically elected ones too), 24 countries invaded since WW2, 800+ bases in 70+ countries, countless embargos and sanctions that led to starvation and death of innocent civilians, armed and trained separatists factions in numerous countries, made 72 attempts at regime changes that led to decades of instabilities in numerous countries (Honduras, El Salvador, Libya, and Guatemala just to name a few) and so much more.
Bravo...100% agree. What China has managed in one century, going from feudal agrarian state to present day economic powerhouse is simply astounding. Hats off to them. The 21st century is theirs, like the 20th was the US's. @@neilbohrs5990
Either u are a fake former US submariner or a real current Braindeader.
As a former Combat US Army Infantryman, I have always been aware of the USS Indianapolis incident during WWII. I have always admired miners' and submariners' bravery, even if it be for the other side. I hope they found peace. 11bravo CIB '04 mosul
Thank you for doing what others publicly judge you for but secretly loves you for.
i'm missing the point here, remy. you mention an incident involving a surface-travelling heavy cruiser that got torpedo'd by the japanese navy. what happened to the CA-35 crew in 1945 was negligence and incompetence by the Navy specifically to inform McVay of Japanese presence in hostile waters, and furthermore, the incompetence of 3 station commanders who failed to answer the distress call.
this 2023 incident was a chinese submarine hitting a chinese anchor. it was an entire link, all the way up the chain, knowingly sacrificing lives to allegedly protect national security and avoid political scrutiny.
Yo, ....darkiepoo@@darkiepoo8949 As a US Army ground pounder, he is acknowledging the sacrifices of those who fight at sea. Example #1, the story above. Example #2 the terrible experiences of the crew of CA-35 after being torpedoed by the IJN submarine. Lighten up a little....darkiepoo....
Maybe he’s referring to mariners sacrificing their lives for duty.
A hull rupture caused by an underwater collision might have allowed sea water to make contact with the batteries that power the back-up systems. Conventional batteries would emit deadly chlorine gas and lithium batteries would have started a runaway fire. In either case the crew was doomed.
China’s amazing plan. “ Close your eyes and the world can’t see you.” 😂😂😂
Don't make fun.
Fake news stories for Indian media 😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂 karma at its finest.
Now we know those chain traps work.
At least against subs made out of chinesium.
Close your eyes, and smell your smelly mom.. 😂😂😂
A nuclear sub is one of a nation's most treasured and secreted war instruments . Obviously they wont ask for outside help, its like when the Russian Kursk submarine sank back in 2000, there was enough time for them to launch a rescue operation or get outside help, which they were offered, but the sub's secrets outweighed the 112 crew lives.
Sure if you value a death and a machine made for death over life then yes.
How silly! Does China think they have something that the Free World doesn’t have? The USA has machines that can make oxygen; evidently China doesn’t have this ability. I can guarantee you that the USA would have loaned or given the evil Chinese, one of these devices if ONE LIFE COULD BE SAVED! That’s how much difference there is between the atheistic CCP and the USA; ONE NATION UNDER GOD! How come the Chinese as a whole see how lost and soulless their “government” is; a horrible bunch!
this fake news btw
For one of Russia's most treasured and secreted war instruments the Kursk was in pretty bad condition.
it wasn't secrets but pride...Russians didn't want to admit their naval rescue ability poverty.
Sad. I’m an American 🇺🇸 and I wish they (China) would have sucked it up and asked us and/or the UK for assistance. Our navies have the best training and ability to provide undersea rescue operations. It’s not foolproof but we possibly could have saved the lives of those sailors. Condolences to the the families and friends of those lost in the accident.
What a world it would be if everyone helped each other and let go of all of the hostility and plans to destroy each other.
Yeah , helping a group of sailors in a nuclear submarine made specifically to destroy us would make sense . 🤦🏻♂️
If this is true, as a former Submarine sailor, it is devastating. That is an awful small crew though.
Chinese technology poor quality
ridiculous. Chinese high speed trains are the best in the world. Chinese nuclear submarines are on par with the west. China is the only country with a space station. China leads 5g and 6g. China leads the world in solar, electric batteries and electric cars. The list is endless.
Many Boeing 737 Max suffered accidents. The US has just started to build bullet trains, far behind China, Japan, and Europe. Do these mean that the US technology has poor quality? Perhaps.
Can't imaging a more horrible end.
I toured the old WWII sub in San Francisco bay, you walk from end to end internally and it is frightening even with the sub doing nothing, I could not wait to get out of there.
Poor guys. Hope the families are OK as well.
this fake news btw western propaganda
I would likely not be able to go there at all. I'm not claustrophobic, but I'm too scared of a malfunction. Drowning is not a great way to go! 🐳 🐠 🦈 🐙 🦐 🦀 🐡 🐟 🐬 🐋
@@cattymajiv We would not be able to to id for all the above reasons and more.
Stay well...
I also toured the panpaneto ww2 sub. It commanded 73 men, half would sleep while the others would man the ship. They actually rescued over 70 men at sea and brought them safely to port. Can one imagine the clostophobic situation that must have been
Modern US subs are not like their WWII counterparts.
The same basic principles are still valid but the structure is much different.
I served onboard the USS Permit (Permit class) and the USS Houston (Los Angeles class) and toured the USS North Dakota (Virginia class) at her commissioning.
Modern subs are much more comfortable and relatively spacious compared to the WWII subs.
I definitely wouldn’t recommend volunteering for sub duty if your claustrophobic however.
BTW, the likelihood of drowning on a sub is very low. You’d be much more likely to die from a fire onboard or from the sub imploding which is thought to be painless because it happens so fast you’re brain doesn’t register it.
It doesn’t matter what their political mission was…but just knowing that these men died in this manner is horrific. When it comes down to it..people are people and I’m sending encouragement and sincere “CONDOLENCES” to their loved ones and friends. 😢❤🙆🏻♀️ I felt devastated when this type of situation happened with the Indonesian Submarine as well. I know other countries used resources to look for them but they did not survive. May GOD help all of us have compassion for one another no matter WHO it is. 🙇🏻♀️🙏🏽🇺🇸
China is evil. The government probably let them die
Nope. They are now a good communist.
A nuclear sub isn't powered by batteries. The reactor doesn't stop working if the sub is entangled. This "report" is dubious.
29 officers and 26 enlisted? That's a heck of a way to run a railroad. RIP to the crew on eternal patrol. DBF
Sounds like a crew setup for the National Health Service here in the UK - All managers and a few staff - that's what was wrong! Also if the story came from a British newspaper I would treat it with the disrespect it probably deserves.
Probably just this reporter and her network , they don't like the Chinese.
Sounds like a Walmart to me. Or a Radio Shack store.
Too many Chiefs and not enough Indians!
Like a saying from when I was a kid, "Too many chiefs and not enough Indians."
Very sorry for the sailors. They should be all honored for their service to their country, not swept away because their painful deaths might embarrass the dictator.
Karma of chinese government
😂😅😂😅😂😂😅
UK is from the 5 Eyes Alliance.
They shared intelligence among US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand.
What when they claimed that Indian Government is involved in Overseas Assignation. The Indians jump up and down.
But the British press printed some unverified news abot China. The Indians tabloid start spreading around 😅😂😂😅😂😅
they have test their own medicine,,, 😂
This will go same as Galwan valley incident. China will honour top tier 3 soldiers 😢
😂 its fake news
22 officers, 7 officer cadets, 9 petty officers and 17 sailors. Out of ignorance, is this ratio of officers to sailors typical for submarines? I too am sorry for the loss of these men.
Russia did the same thing, years ago. The USA offered to help, but they were too proud.😞😞😞
He Who Digs A Pit For Others Falls In Himself
This is a good wisdom.
Ahh yes, every time there is a massive failure by the Chinese it must be fake. Just like all their military jet crashes and their rockets exploding during take off. It must be fake even though there is video of it😆😁 Everyone knows Chinese equipment is known for their quality😆. It's impossible for them to fail.😂🤣@CPHR-df4ff
False news. The 093 nuclear submarine cannot have only 55 people. The Soviet Type 971 nuclear submarine has a crew of 100 people. The U.S. Seawolf-class nuclear submarine has a crew of 133 people.
Ahh a new youtube account. You must be one of those 50 cent warriors sent to post propaganda on western sites. How's it going in China? My friends tell me the economy is collapsing. Business has never been so bad in China. @@user-dd2bl8rx4b
So India get
Call into hell
I am in USA and I really appreciate Indian perspectives on China. I learn a lot here.
un learn immediately
Yes the US media tows the Chinese line too often as they take money from China.
This media tells the truth that China hides
@@DippsYou lack perspicacity
😂😅😂😅😂😂😅
UK is from the 5 Eyes Alliance.
They shared intelligence among US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand.
What when they claimed that Indian Government is involved in Overseas Assignation. The Indians jump up and down.
But the British press printed some unverified news abot China. The Indians tabloid start spreading around 😅😂😂😅😂😅
Palki is paid by the CIA to spread anti China propaganda among Indians! CIA has chosen a woman with a thick Indian accent, reasonably good looking (for an Indian) woman, and she never makes fun of Senile Biden or Hunter Biden. That gives their secret away.
Is it working? Are Indians now hating China and Russia?
As a U.S.N.Submarine Veteran, I am deeply saddened for the men who lost their lives and their families, too,!
My heart bleeds NOT. Think about the reason they had this trap set and for whom. Us.
Palki Sharma , you are a star ahead of the packs in your industry, you are greatly appreciated. Keep it up.
Because she hate china you support it what kind of people are you jealous because China made it to the world I love China bro look at America is dying do you talk about it shame
She has a beautiful speaking voice.
Palki is a frustrated cheap propaganda puppet... 😊
Needs to check facts, clearly didn't
American lackey.
Hard to feel sorry for them considering they were setting a murder trap for others. However I do feel bad for their familys
I feel sorry for the soldiers. They are under the orders of a totalitarian government.
Ditto
You can still feel sorry for the sailors; they wouldn't be the ones that laid the trap. Have scorn for their naval command that didn't make the position of the trap clear to them, and the political leadership that has decided to lay such obstacles in international waters, and sacrificed them to save face.
BAD KARMA ! = sew and reap your own bitter harvest !
Same thing happened to that darn Chinese made RC submarine I bought on Ebay it sank with all twenty some rand new batteries still on board... I mean too bad they was all new batteries... it worked better in the You Tube videos than it did for me...
Imagine the treatment of enemies of a regime that treats its own soldiers with zero humanity.
To be fair, if the crew died within 6 hours of the Chinese trying to deal with the situation, it's unlikely any foreign help would have changed the outcome.
PLA should never hesitate to ask for international help as lives of humans are precious.
There's a reason they are called Chinese mainlanders..🤷♂️🤷♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️
not Taiwanese or Cantonese
They did ask for India's help when one of their ships broke in the Indian Ocean. This was some 3-4 years ago
@@rajumadduri6254 that's because they are stinking stuck with India desperate despite their hounding India.
Because CCP knows only too well West is already anti China and soon enough, Russia will strangle and trample China mainland if CCP don't disintegrate soon. Something to watch out for ☺️
I won't be holding my breath.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The dictator and his ego first 😅
The CCP *NEVER* regarded human lives as precious.
You should know.
This has always been a nightmare scenario for me. I've always hated those submarine movies where they can't surface and the air is running out.
Same with that Titan bathysphere a few months ago. Yikes!
this fake news btw western propaganda
@@LOLLOL-kg4dz The bathysphere really did implode, on the way down to visit the Titanic.
If it's nuclear powered, it should be able to make it's own o2 and clean it's internal atmosphere like every western nuke submarine does. Makes no sense. China may have lost a boat, but not like this.
On a nuclear sub they always have power to run the oxygen generator
@@protorhinocerator142 The Titanic expedition is true but the Chinese nuclear sub claim is false. Nuclear subs can stay submerged for weeks as they are equipped with oxygen generating systems.
Look, I'm no communist, but as a former USN sailor myself, sincerely my heart goes out to my fellow seaman and their families.
Firstly, thank you so much for your service to our great nation. You have a wonderful, empathetic heart, and, no doubt, your condolences are felt by those affected by this awful tragedy. God Bless You and Your’s.
Thank you for the info
It was first the chinese woman in west..who is a refugee who through her sources in china talked and proved that all these sailors are dead.
Only, later on British Intelligence confirmed this.
The particular Chinese submarine is missing and has not been detected for long. Other of same category have been.
Now, people can make their own assessment.
Ok, name this Chinese woman, her source of info and how it was verified, who in UK military is backing up the claim. When.and where was this uk intelligence spoke person confirmed the incident. I actually watched the Taiwan's defense ministry spoke person dismissing this report in a publicised press conference on 24/8.
those subs were... Made in China
And they are all active and good. None has sank. Even the British who came up with this story can not verify it meaning its a made up lie.
lol
@indiancretinvirusesterrori3918 At least India has guts to accept it and its media can report it. What about china? Their media will not say a word because xi is too scared to admit 🤣😏
@indiancretinvirusesterrori3918
Flying subs?
Wtf...?
Lol 😁
Brilliant Reporting!!!!
Always sad to lose people doing a job. Especially, doing something nefarious.
The report doesn’t make sense. The 55 men died of hypoxia? How so? This is a nuclear powered submarine which means power is available to produce to power to generate oxygen regardless if they are trapped or stuck. In other words, the reactor may have been damaged when the sub was trapped or a haul breach occurred leaving the chinese man to drown Or the oxygen reactor was damaged. Hence, the hypoxia. I would say a haul breached may have occurred damaging the reactor if it’s really is the caused by hypoxia. That means - reactor maybe leaking in that part of that area. Either way, my sympathy for their families. .
Hull
These subs carry emergency oxygen generating chlorate candles that they can burn if the main generator malfunctions. They should have a few days supply with just the candles. Something doesn't add up.
When the bully get killed by his own trap.
Can India manage to bully any other Super powers even Pakistan? China can manage to bully right, if China can't manage then it is not a bully
l'intimidateur ? les sous -marin et bateaux guerre occitentales qui tourne autour est c'est eux l'intimidateur 🤔ont ta bien lavé le serveaux
Bien essaye! PLA chinese Troll, welcome back after pandemic. @@xexperiencedx6717
absolute right ,
55 lives that were attached to loving families. Sad. Pride goeth before the fall.
22 officers out of a crew of 55 ....something sounds wrong there
This reminds me of Chernobyl where the Communist Soviets did the same
Choose Pride over Compassion
The "help" offered would have been nothing more than condescending propaganda.
Wake up.
Also the Kursk submarine accident during exercises.
@@user-lb8bg6kj9m "as if the world is always always against you"
Most every country would have done the same.
No country with a competitive military, would ask their greatest adversary for assistance, if it meant exposing military secrets.
Good soldiers, and intelligence agents, are expected protect their national secrets with their lives,
and take lives to protect those secrets.
It's the unfortunate reality of the military.
False news. The 093 nuclear submarine cannot have only 55 people. The Soviet Type 971 nuclear submarine has a crew of 100 people. The U.S. Seawolf-class nuclear submarine has a crew of 133 people.
My deepest sympathies to their loved ones.
Communist sympathizer
What a joke😂😂😂
Why? They were setting those traps to kill other submariners from South Korea and the USA for no reason. China's bullying backfired.
@@jasondiggs6740cry
一点证据没有就招摇不愧是印度哈哈
The irony is strong in this story.... maybe China's military gear needs to be designed and built elsewhere since they choose to "leave that part out, we won't need it," leads to disastrous consequences.
Or, maybe we just let them continue on that learning curve...
Never disturb the enemy when they are making a mistake.
The mighty idiot loses, because he waiting his enemy doing mistake.🙂
@@nostradamus2029agreed USA lost
You are a sad person
@@JonySmith-bb4gx: He talking about Napoleon.
What goes around comes around! Deepest condolences to the family. A well deserved for their greedy government ☹️
Because of your arrogance, you sound America. Do you know what the U.S. has done since WW2? It has: invaded Iraq on WMD lies, bombed Cambodia, bombed Loas, Marshall Islands Nuclear Testing, Japanese Internment, Vietnam War, tortured prisoners in Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo, assassinated thousands of foreign leaders (democratically elected ones too), 24 countries invaded since WW2, 800+ bases in 70+ countries, countless embargos and sanctions that led to starvation and death of innocent civilians, armed and trained separatists factions in numerous countries, made 72 attempts at regime changes that led to decades of instabilities in numerous countries (Honduras, El Salvador, Libya, and Guatemala just to name a few) and so much more.
The whole point of nuclear subs is to stay underwater for prolonged periods. If they ran out of air, it must have been a diesel or their oxygen generators failed.
She is a clear and competent newscaster. Thank you.
Im American, I love this news lady! She's my favorite!
Good reporting. Concise and to the point.
Reminds me of the russian sub and the crew died because russia would not take any assistance. It is just so sad and heartbreaking for the families.
How did you find out about this? This would be VERY top secret!
It is interesting that there were more officers and cadets than enlisted on the boat. In US and British subs only about ten percent of the crew would be officers. Petty officers are so well trained that in an emergency they could operate the vessel. This is not the case in the Chinese navy. I speculate that the test of the Chinese navy and army are the same. Without officers they fall apart. They do not have a professionally trained NCO core to fall back on.
if you are professionally trained in the Chinese navy you are an officer and paid accordingly...not an under paid nco
@@andrewdavis6012 Do we know the comparative pay rates for all concerned?
In communist countries if you do a job that requires special training or skills you are an officer, enlisted guys are conscripts and do basic labor.
Obviously it was a training mission for cadets armchair admiral
@@oscarrlee18 You have a good point. That would explain the large number of cadets. It may also explain why some fatal error occurred.
They will never admit their faults
I'm surprised they didn't blame the CIA for this. That's usually their go-to. When anything goes wrong in China, just blame the U.S. and the CIA.
False news. The 093 nuclear submarine cannot have only 55 people. The Soviet Type 971 nuclear submarine has a crew of 100 people. The U.S. Seawolf-class nuclear submarine has a crew of 133 people.
@@user-dd2bl8rx4b Where did you get your news from.
If it is true they learn this from the Devil's in Washington after using an atomic bomb on innocent people in Hiroshima and Nagasaki they still have no regret so who are we to blame the Chinese if that did happen this is their own people it's nobody's business special India
When evil uncle Sam shutdown and Iranian civilian plane killing over 200 innocent people they never admit their fault instead the awarded this Devil who committed that crime with 🎖️🏆🏅🎖️🏆🏅 😊😊😊😊
Horrible fate!Sorry to hear their loss!Best regards from Spain!
Wow, that is horrible.
If it was nuclear powered, why was it relying on batteries ?
This nuclear catastrophe contaminated the water around that area, China was quick to blame Japan for releasing the water stored from the Fucuzhima disaster.
And do we hear any report on this from Japan or Korea.?
Where did you get this information
@@mabvutophiri5422 Nuclear Submarine? How did you miss the information.
@@jliang70 NO!, Because China, which is not a responsible country, did not immediately tell the whole world about the danger of leaking radioactive material from the damaged nuclear submarine.
@@ruhtra5602 well, i dont think you have the other nations in the surrounding area supporting your fake news. India is a known fake news hub in the world.
So....they dug a pit and then fell into it themselves? Perfect.
22 officers, 17 sailors. That's your problem, right there.
"22 officers, 7 officer cadets (officers in training), 9 petty officers (like a sergeant) but only 17 'sailors'. Tells you a LOT about how promotions are viewed in the Chinese navy.
Maby China Wanted Them Gone?
You know so detail. Good man
David, China did not reveal all those information. It was British Intelligence as per the Video. If true, how come the British knew about all this sitting 1000s of KMs away? Surely the Chinese did not tell the world about it.
Was thinking the same thing when I read it. Makes one wonder if senior enlisted in western navies hold the same position and responsibilities as junior officers in the chinese navy.
55 seems small number for a nuclear attack submarine.
I would think at least 100 men would be needed.
also, some other sources say there is no such sub numbered 093-417 in current Chinese Navy inventory.
China’s Navy: “This is why we can’t have nice things…”
If this is true and can be verified, this is a huge problem. Crimes against humanity.
ITS BATTERIES WENT FLAT? Wasn't it a nuclear submarien i.e. a submarine with a continu power supply as in: never having flat batteries?
Similar accidents happened with Russian subs during the cold war with the USA. Interesting contrast when the USS Thresher and the USS Scorpion were lost in the 60's. Served 23 years on the U. S. boats during and after that cold war. The Chinese Submariners on eternal patrol. I salute them for their valor and sacrifice.
There is more to the Scorpion story than we've been officially told. Check out "Red Star Rogue: The Untold Story of a Soviet Submarine's Nuclear Strike Attempt on the U.S." by Kenneth Sewell and then read "All Hands Down: The True Story of the Soviet Attack on the USS Scorpion" also by Kenneth Sewell. The first story, and the Soviet government's mistaken understanding of the incident, is the reason for the second incident. As an ex-boomer sailor, the stories are all too believable to me though I doubt we'll ever hear them verified by our government as both incidents would qualify as an act of war by the Soviet Union against the United States.
Good news that they will not get to attack Taiwan.
From 1955 to 1977 I served on 2 diesel boats, 1 nuclear fast attack and then three boomers. At the time of the Thresher loss we were in the Hunters point Naval shipyard for an overhaul. When the Scorpion went down I was at Comsubpac operations center in Honolulu. I was involved in the communications from Comsublant to Naval station Norfolk VA and Comsubpac. I saw enough communication traffic that convinced me the official story of Scorpions lose was mostly true. Later documents I read added info that they did not include in the original story. I can't buy the Soviet attack story. But then that is just my opinion based on what I saw in official reports. If it were happening now under the current administration I would believe a story that it was done on purpose so the big guy could get his 10%.@@lanpartyanimal5215
USN torpedo school has SOSUS recording of USS Scorpions demise. Worth noting in all this back and forth is the sinking of K129, the sub that Glomar Explorer went after. Good chance we intercepted that boat when it surfaced to do comms. We had tracked it all the way from Vlad, it surfaced at regular intervals, and we knew where it would be next. Velvet Glove photos show damage consistent with impact explosion. We will probably never know what really happened, but much circumstantial evidence indicates we deliberately sank the boat in order to effect the recovery of code machine(s) and weapons. Had the USSR called us on this it could have easily started WWIII. Sad for the brave men who crewed all 3 of those boats. @@lanpartyanimal5215
@@lanpartyanimal5215 Thanks for the info. I made a note of the book titles and I will read them.
Deepest Sympathies to the sailors and their families .
Even Taiwan has denied the rumours .. If China themselves denied it how can people know every detail .. its a sub . Palki has no ethics in reporting
@carmenvalmalaartaraz8260
Jan 2018
The Hindu reported that India’s only operational nuclear ballistic missile submarine, INS Arihant, was out of action for about 10 months last year due to an accident. The report raises more questions than it answers due to its glaring technical and operational inconsistencies. First, the news item stated that the Arihant’s propulsion compartment was damaged after water entered it, as a hatch on the rear side was left open by mistake.
@@wionporky9937fake news by bat 🦠
@@FC-vp9ejtofu bridge,tofu buildings,now tofu submarines,land of cheaters and fassad 😅
What families? These men are all orphans. In fact, PLA is an military of orphans.
Protecting tecnology at the expense of HUMAN life...Some people are beyond cruel...
Having 22 officers and 7 officer candidates out of a crew of 55 is a huge imbalance. That's VERY TOP HEAVY!
My deepest condolences to the families of all the lost lives.
I feel sorry for the poor fish & sharks. Probably got sick as hell on that whole mess....
this fake news btw western propaganda
Lives*
@@ChefKing-xp2vtcondolences to their families.
Condolences for our enemy. You must be a damn democrat. The Chinese Army would gut you like a fish in your bed. Are you Democrats so daft? An invading army would kill you or me without a second thought. Call your Counterfeit President and tell him that you don't want ww3.
What the hell was a submarine doing in the Yellow Sea, with ab average depth of 44m, bearly enough to submerge the thing. Sailors could have totally just come out and swim up at low 10s meter depth.
makes u think the story is bull if that's true. submarine crew would have known that.
Chinese sooopah pooowah full of incompetent buffoons military 😂😂
Too naïve and myopic to figure that out. It's unfair that one can view the ccp and its slaves through our more advanced, developed "Western" perspective
Well in China you rather die in a submarine than at the hands of CCP.
@@holboroman says the western neanderthal
I’m pretty sure some nation would find their sub is the same. They don’t make, they steal technology.
As a former sailor
I do feel sorry for the crew.
No one has confirmed the loss of a PLA Navy nuclear sub so far albeit I have read previous reported rumors. While I have read about anti-submarine nets and sea mines - I have never heard of any submarine booby traps involving anchors before. The tech to scrub CO2 from the air supply is common tech but it requires running an electric air pump through CO2 scrubbing filters. Most military submarine accidents I have read about involve crashing (into the sea floor, sea mountains, or another vessel) or a mechanical failure (failure to secure all hatches before diving, nuclear reactor failure, battery gas leak, pressure hull failure). Any submarine booby trap during peace time in international waters would be an illegal international navigational hazard and it would be a serious allegation - worse than creating artificial islands and illegally claiming these artificial islands to be sovereign territory. Russia, the USA, and the UK have submarine search and salvage military units/kits - PRC PLA Navy 093 subs are obsolete sub designs - the only thing worth saving would be the crew itself because training a good submarine crew is expensive, time consuming and challenging.
Just like Russia and the Kursks sub. They could have gotten help but let their soldiers die.
Such useless armies, right? Why the hell do we need to help the Ukrainians?!?
How dumb are people claiming this "ask for help" would have been a solution.
The only thing "ask for help" would have generated is condescending propaganda.
Countries will ask for help from their true and trusted allies behind the scenes -- not publicly from their enemies.
And rest assured if they did ask for help from their allies, you won't be hearing about it from them or their allies.
If you haven’t or can’t verify the story…why tell it like it’s the real? Bc the Daily Mail says it happened?😂😂 why is India is so obsessed with China?
When it comes to China real or surreal it doesn't matter. Why pass up a good chance to bash China.
Ma'am I love the way you tell the news, a lot of truth in your voice.
They didn't call Submarines as "Iron Coffin" for nothing... R I P Sailors !.....😪
rip to the crews and the sub
😢In India, there's a perception that Chinese products are often seen as low in quality and less reliable.
Indians depend on Chinese products, they don't see them as low quality. That is all they know.
Not just in India, this is a common perception in the rest of the world as well. 😂
It's not a perception, it's a fact.
Because rhe high-end Chinese products are produced for domestic consumption and export to selected wealthy countries.
@@yetao5801
Which products do you consider "high end"..?
Hang on… if the sub was nuclear powered, it should not have run out of air. Nuclear powered submarines don’t need to surface for air like diesel-electric subs do, they can stay submerged for months. Food is normally the only limiting factor, nuclear subs produce their own air and water.
Maybe the Chinese sub in this incident wasn’t nuclear powered,but a diesel-electric one?
If their ship construction is anything like their tofu-dregs.... I'd be afraid to go within 10 miles of those submarines.
Palki has been beaming towards China. Very appreciated. Keep going😊
Palki is paid by the CIA to spread anti China propaganda among Indians! CIA has chosen a woman with a thick Indian accent, reasonably good looking (for an Indian) woman, and she never makes fun of Senile Biden or Hunter Biden. That gives their secret away.
Is it working? Are Indians now hating China and Russia?
Trust me even somebody blowing up the Moon Palki will accuse the Chinese😂😂😂😂😂😂
Why talk about it if you cannot verify it?
Exactly!
Giv'em a break. People need to feel better than others, even if imaginary. Otherwise how will those in charge keep them in check?
That is why we use sonar.
Only 55 crew? Over half officers? That is the strangest crew makeup I've ever heard of for a submarine that size. If lost, I honestly expect the number of dead to be double that. Same officer count, but over half of the crew is unaccounted for.
I really love and have a lot of respect for the incredible work of Palki Sharma's captivating reporting regarding, *How British looted 45 trillion from India* which unquestionably stands as a masterpiece of the highest quality. The content of the reporting is truly awe-inspiring, and I thoroughly enjoyed watching it. The dedication, talent and hard work poured into the video are greatly appreciated by many, she is the true hero in our story. Additionally, the Union Public Service Commission has delivered a remarkable report titled संघ लोक सेवा आयोग *How Britishers killed 1.8 billion Indians. Chronology of British Raj's exploitative policies* | UPSC," which is equally astounding. The commission consistently produces insightful and thought-provoking articles of the utmost caliber, and I sincerely hope they continue to produce such interesting exceptional work. Could it possibly even get any better than this? They truly They deserve an award.
The 45 trillion dollars that were taken mainly consist of natural resources. If you look at India's current mineral deposits, most are completely depleted (that's why India imports their minerals instead of producing them themselves; they have nothing left). The British forced Indians to mine and carry those minerals and resources to the sea port so they could be sent back to England every single day for 200 years. The U.S. and U.K. infrastructure was pretty much built from not only India's natural minerals but also India's blood, sweat, and even lives (countless Indians died working in the mines all day with less than a portion of grain in their stomachs).
1.8 Billion makes sense. India today on average loses 10 million people per year due to natural cause or illness. So in 200 years they would lose 10million x 200 years = 2 billion people. Imagine 1757 - 1947 times when India didn't have any healthcare like today and life expectancy was much much shorter with mass malnourish (Bengal Famine + 63 other major famines) and were forced to work to their very bones losing their lives in the process.
The British also made Indians work in agricultural and then transport all the crops to the UK.
they would rather have food rot in the UK than preventing the tens of millions that starved to death.
Items such as coal, iron ore, timber, cotton, and other natural resources are brought to the ports every day for the British to ship home to use in their factories.
Coal and iron ore can produce steel, which, along with wood, can be used to build houses, large buildings, halls, subways, trains, and factories. Iron ore can be used to build cars, machinery, weapons, ships, and jets. Both the U.K. and U.S. 1st and 2nd industrial revolutions were built with India's funds and India's free labour.
In India's history, there's a pattern of not actively resisting invaders; rather, they departed, like the British and others, when there were no more resources to exploit, leaving behind a population of a billion Indians struggling with poverty and lacking in education, a situation no one wished to confront.
After all It's made in china.😂
thank you for this . why do we not learn of these things in the US media?
Good!
Deepest condolences to the 55 sailor families
Deepest eh....
Thank u
Societies who are too coward to seek their own freedom does not deserve any sympathy in my humble opinion.
Karma of Chinese government
@@bangsarster
All society are ruled by tyrants be they banksters or corporate interests or dictators.
Some disguise it better than others. Some fool their citizens into thinking they are free and many are dumb enough to believe it.
Condolences To China, And Every Family Who Lost A Loved One. Strength And Love To You. ❤
No report from Chinese officials about the submarine disaster.
@@janewu3178Seems to be confusion about the narrative, it's all over the news in Europe and US.
@@ForexdailytradingsystemsCoZa Of course, have you ever heard any good news report about China in the west? Whenever China is stronger, they will never stop talk bad about China.
Prayers go out the 55 families who lost a loved one on that ill -fated sub.
@@peterbee129 Indian media cheated. Shame on them.
Great intonation from this news reader. A please to listen to her. Thank you.
Human life means nothing to China. It's sad that these sailors died due to pride.
Happy to hear this news.
🎉🎉🎉
Deepest condolences to the ocean and mother nature. :)
Don't worry . New York is under water .600 are fish food in USA
Enjoy your fake news steroids
@@JonySmith-bb4gxlol can't wait
U are a bad excuse for a human beeing.. where is your compassion for the sailors.. ugly desplay of racism.
@@JonySmith-bb4gx No deaths or injuries have been reported. Lay off the meth.
With almost 1.5 billion population, I don't believe China will ever worry much about losing 55 or even a few hundred. Mao once said in a nuclear attack, China would survive on sheer numbers. "We might loose 300 million or more but so what."
If you are CCP, such things never happen. If you are CIA, MI5, Misson accomplished. Reality is always in middle.
Who knows, maybe the CCP just wants to purge the Captain of the submarine?
CCP doesn't like to disclose some issues to the public.
There is no halfway for dead soldiers. Either they are dead or they are not.
No governments like doing so.
Sometimes it’s common sense or at can be at least understandable.
Other times it is something that is wilfully causing suffering and endangerment of the citizens they’re charged with the responsibility to govern, which is unforgivable.
It's scary being in a vessel that is under water in the ocean. I hope the sailors went peacefully.
You'll get used to it after so many years. US Submariner Retired, having a close encounter with K 19 ...
Drowning, or implosion.