Ukraine claims success in Kharkiv as Russian offensive slows | DW News
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 чер 2024
- Ukraine's second biggest city Kharkiv is coming under near constant bombardment, as Russia presses ahead with a new offensive. Kyiv has accused Russia of targeting civilians after a wave of Russian drone and missile strikes swept across the region. Moscow has consistantly denied targeting civilians deliberately, but many are coming under fire regardless.
00:00 Intro and report
02:28 DW speaks with Marina Miron of the War Studies Department at King's College London
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutsche...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#Ukraine #Russia #Kharkiv
no one can deny that ukraine is winning on reddit
Dont forget arma 3 😂😂😂
Yeah, and on a social media platform called "Wankology"
BS
😂😂😂
And in DW😂😢😂
M.s. Marina is the best analysist on this Russia Ukraine war. Thank you Madam.
So, why is she on air?
she has no idea what she is talking about
Naming the "best" seems moot. On DW she's the only one ever invited and for western media in generally i have noticed that they are practically all from King's College London. Can't have a favorite when they are all part of the same university, use the same sources and arrive at the same conclusions.
I feel like we need an analyst analyzing the analysis.
bot
Dr
"Is the West hobbling Ukraine?" Well d'uuuuhh. Of course it is. The way the West has been reacting to Putin could arguably be lifted right out of Chamberlain's play book of appeasement and self delusion.
Well said
The timidity of the American and German governments has been depressing
Could'nt agree with you more
@@simonblack8384 Europe has only given half of what is promised. You'd think they would be more giving since the war is right on their doorstep. The US can't babysit forever.
Putin must be 3 steps ahead of the west
And people below laughing at other people's suffering. Psychopaths!
Marina Miron is the best DW analyst
"Claims success" on reddit and UA-cam.
Привет родной, 98ой! Мы в плену у Кракена.
Bot
special military comment?
@@Melrose51653 Dolt.
Russia winning said by bots Iran president is now dead next is your beloved putin
lots of victoria nuland's cookies enjoyers coping and whining 🤭
War is a crime when the first non-combatant is a casualty.
Offensive with 2000 soldiers at their first war experience conquered 350 kmq in seven days...
recycled shovels and washing machine components makes a deadly missile
Russia has help from Iran and China, ignorant
@@Rod732these were your own words😂
@@Rod732 And Ukraine got help from NATO, Australia, Japan and many other.😂
@@Rod732 But ukraine has nato japan and must of the world
@@monumentaltravel3745 Then you need glasses !
I noticed that your analyst is clueless
Realist, factual and unbias
Two children is sad in Ukraine as war crime , and 20000 children killed intentionally in plastena also sad but not war crimes , Hope one day all children have equal rights to speak for them
The titel was about Ukraine claiming success in Kharkiv, but the entire video was about wether or not Russia commits war crimes and restrictions on western weapons. Such effing clickbait.
titel? Russian BOT spelling is bad
Learn spelling, ffs...
@@alex-fs5bl Hello Alex, I'm sorry that you were so bothered reading my comment. Sounds like a tough life.
@@Prowlerook English is not my first language. Also, more importantly, DW news should act like a serious news organisation and not post such blatant clickbait.
If you're clicking because you believe they have a chance at success, then you deserve being fooled!
Vovchansk looks 20 times better than Gaza
Who believes u anyway 😆😅🤣
When uk is not succesful😅
sad & sorry to see the hardship on people. war need to stop 🛑🛑
While I feel sorry for the civilians here, they were asked to evacuate but refused? So basically, if you receive a Tsunami warning, but chose to ignore it and got swept away. Then, who is to be blamed? War is a disaster. Treat it seriously like any other disaster.
They are able to use the Storm shadow.
You all see that guy can’t even do a push up, the one in the middle of the video. This is over save the people.
Fine, we’ll stop sending funds
Restrictions placed on the use of drones. Are you kidding me ? 😅😅😅.
The more I watch the news, the more I realize that we are all living in a messed up world
So much injustice for Ukraine people, from media misreporting.ukraine people are suffering while the media is cashing on the suffering of.....
You must be for Bizarro world.
Instead of caring about what Russia is doing, you're blaming people reporting on it
Why isn't there any peace talks 🤔 😢
Because there's no deadlock.
There's no peace from Russia because they want Ukraine and have a larger military and see no reason to offer anything. There's no peace talks from Ukraine because they want to exist.
"Believe It Or Not!"
Yes. When a beggar demands and gets $25 every day…it’s my fault when when one day I tell him that they I won’t him anymore unless he stops wasting it on drugs.
The only thing I believe Ukrainians is the news that big bad volf swaloved little girl, but she was miracleously saved by young hunter who exctracted her from volf's belly.
Those slavics should be more concerned about food and school
Ursula Von der Leyen must go!
Why? What about NATO leader? He needs to go. Someone who has courage to lead is needed.
"It's very early to reach conclusions that this is not collateral damage" thank you for the honesty. Also worth noting that any structure left standing is shelter for troops or camouflage for military assets. This is not a morality thing just a bleak reality of war.
Very good comments from this military woman analyst. She is always actual and impartial!
No reports since 2014 why hmm 🤔
Peace hurts the wepons trade.
Very detailed info but map needed to show positions.
If I had a nickel for every time some trollnik said Russia was going to win "with washing machines and shovels" I'd have more money than Musk. But yet again the Russians are getting pushed back 😂
Pushed back, deep into Ukraine. Lol
@@alexanderjdivic4784your imaginary trollnik world sounds nice, Ivan 😊
As the lion paused to ponder which deer to take next, the deer felt they had pinned the lion down.
When did you suffer head trauma?
They also claim they lost only 31K soldiers. So their claims are worthless.
What in the world are they still doing there?? They have been told to leave.. its an ACTIVE WAR ZONE!!
Is Europe willing to repeat its mistakes of WW 1 & WW2?
They already are.
The air defense is working, and missiles knocked off course are flying into houses and gardens
Ukraine heroicly retreats while Russia desperately advance
We already know from the western media that Russia's will be a pyrrhic victory)))
Everything destroyed = success ? Can someone explain that to me ?
Let’s get real Ms Marina, Russia hasn’t exactly been handing out flowers in Ukraine!
german arms are being send to israel. where is your compassion there?
the ukrainians will soon understand who really devastated their country!
remember Victoria Nuland? what was her job in ukraine again?
Politics is like watching a poorly written cartoon, and all you can do is observe the trainwreck. Gawd international politics must be insainly complex.
Imagine if Ukraine was shelling civilian population in Donetsk constantly for 10 years ..... oh wait - they did .
No, they didn't, fool.
@@kimweaver1252 Yes, they did.
True 😢
@@kimweaver1252 They surely did and your media didnt told you about that at all.Sheep.
Imagine if Russia supplied Donetsk with soldiers and weapons, prolonging a war that should have just been a domestic issue... oh wait, they did.
I think UA-cam has gone over the top. I've just watched 3 minutes of adds for a 7 minute video.
Thank God, the kids aren't dead!
Russia meet its goal and just walked in . Now they are set up to get a good counter for artilery range for karkiv .
they will get kicked out , just like 2 years ago
@@mabuhayproductionltd3627 with what ? Ukraine has no men ! You do know ukraine has a men problem not arms problem right?
@@KlodianHysi Both Russia and Ukraine needs more men, more ammo, more weapons. Ukraine just don´t have as much money to offer Soldiers, so they can´t get as many from outside world (like Russia does), Ukraine also don´t have very poor remote area like Sibiria where Russia can lure unemployed poor Men to join the Army. But with the new conspriction law, it will be better.
@@mabuhayproductionltd3627 i like what you are thinking but at some point the rubber meets the road .
Ukraine has manny poor areas .
Ukranian men are cowarding in Prague .
100,000 fighting age men are hiding there also .
Fact colborated by DW and abc US .
Ukranian subscription law its a mess . Look at their truckers protesting this forcing men to the front .
@@mabuhayproductionltd3627 Ukraine is losing their Country its sickening that the main excuse from you is “ ukraine does not have so much money “ when their houses and towns are owned by Russia now .
Ukraine has a big corruption problem and their people are not willing to fight but party in KIEV . Matter of fact the life in Kiev is so normal people forget the country is fighting a war until electricity goes out .
Ukraine successfully lost a handfull of villages and the most part of Volchansk in the last few days. With successes like these, who needs failures.
Lol 😂😂😂
Compare that to 2 years of Russian failure. Oh, you forgot that
@@Melrose51653still holding 20% of the country can’t call that a failure
@@Melrose51653 Lovely failure, that. Russia is still holding 20% of the enemy land and gaining new swathes of land daily.
@@Melrose51653 and now?
They are successfully retreating. Indeed.
It will get nasty!!’
If my neighbor, or even my blood relative, is aiding and collaborating with my enemy to kill me, how should I reasonably see the neighbor or blood relative?
0:40 Kharkiv is the big city. if this is kharkiv than it is not central part of it. what actualy DW showing us as "central" Kharkiv?
Time for negotiations and peace!
KNOCK KNOCK!
Helloooo, UN, are you there?
You know, the very organization formed with it's principle role to prevent conflicts.
@@BRUCE_the_MOOSE_ You know quite well that UN cannot do anything as long as US want the war go on
You’re a little late.
@@Davidwasghostedbyutube Yes, it should have been much earlier, but it's never too late !
@@BRUCE_the_MOOSE_ Exactly and that nobody respects anymore or does have any authority for that matter:(
KNOCK KNOCK!
Helloooo, UN, are you there?
You know, the very organization formed with it's principle role to prevent conflicts.
UN is as good as the League of Nations was ...
@@alexc3493
They seem more interested in easy hanging fruit such as climate change proposals.
Russia sits on the Security Counsel and started the conflict. They vote in accordance with Putin belligerent plans.
End War In Ukraine and in Gaza
The single biggest problem Ukraine has had, and has today, is manpower.
Still a Stalemate in war
If success means losing many villages and small cities and running away, i can't wait to see what failures would look like in the upcoming months .
Does DW report on the deaths and injuries of people in Gaza?
It is a taboo subject for them.
@@papatoomey595 The donor class who owns them won't allow it
They do.
They do. They reported how Hamas is hiding behind Palestinian children
NO but FOX news does red hat
Praying for the peace of 🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦
Russia marches forward while the west dithers about rules.
Germany should reclaim their lost cities of Stettin, Breslau, Posen, Danzig, and Koenigsberg.
Please let the civilians be evaluated 😢
there are millions of this type of incident in gaza, where is the Dw and other western reporterz?
He’s a liar
Where does DW get its news? Indiia
ruzzia
He can’t take the heat no more for listening to you know who
What does Russia expect to gain by this war?
Or maybe it wasn’t such a massive offensive after all. No one can tell. All you provide us with is anecdotes, never data. Oh, and how about interviewing some of the young men being drafted next time to get their thoughts? It’s called journalism.
Who can save the World from this mess
Why don't you all admit Ukraine is loosing the battle Instead of trying to pretty up things
What's about Gaza ? No any international laws apply on Israel and company.
Israel is the owner of USA and Europe.
Alla take care of Gaza .
Ukrainian supporters are having a moment now. do you mind to not bring this up?
@@bestdy8778 Ukraine and Israel are two birds of a feather
@@user-un3ru6dt3w whaaaattt. defender and invader..
Civillians are the suffering this war
This is just reckoshet from Belgorod
We expect WWII, but this is more like Iran Iraq war or WWI where frontlines will barely move a few Miled back and fourth in a matter of years.
Well, Iraq capital was taken in what, 100 hours?
Latvia Belarus Azerbaijan
On 17 May, as part of his state visit to Azerbaijan, Belarusian President Aleksandr Lukashenko together with Azerbaijan President Ilham Aliyev visited the country’s territories, being rebuilt after the conflict
The delegation led by the Speaker of the Parliament of the Republic of Latvia Daiga Mierina arrived in Shusha, Azernews reports.
It should be noted that the delegation visited the city of Fuzuli before,
during the visit, the delegation got acquainted with the destruction caused in Fuzuli,
Yall get what i was trying to say
How is the "West" hobbling Ukraine?
She always has an opinion against these heroic people of Ukraine and is always back-to-back with the criminal activity of Putin.
start negotiations to stop the war
Ukraine needs permission from USA to start negotiations.
@@oberleutnant4013 Which will not be granted
Ukraine had made its proposal, Russia redraw from all Ukraines land, then we can talk about payment for destroyed Life/People/houses/property ect. That would be expensive for Russia
All this vofling about war crimes is totally pointless with a Terrorist State.
yep ukraine's criminal regime shouldn't have attacked civilians in belgrod
Learn what a terrorist state means please
@@kensuzRussia literally is a terrorist state.
What you mean Ukraine? Last time I checked they are the ones responsible for all the numerous car/truck bombings on Civilians.
@@kensuz It means putins russia
i thought the ukrainians were good at guiding the bomb the wrong direction that is towards civilians.!
.... what?! 🤣🤣🤣
@@DarxKiesHe's a Russian mitlaufer. No big deal.
New episode of Kings colledge from London .
Deception
To remove poverty we most living senter of people
Restrictions on weapons supplied is a little silly.
Ukraine soldiers is running
Learn grammar, ffs....
Western media 😂😂😂😂
Imbeciles....
just as bad as the news from the east
I didn’t like this commentator she’s supporting Russia.
Putin are we ignoring this
Yeah. Kharkiv offensive slowed because Russian forces center of mass is in Chasiv Yar. Face palm. Multiple front warfare is as playing Where is Waldo.
Please EU and USA let Ukraine use all weapons also offensivly in Russia.. I am a Sweden and I think it is just madness how the west is holding Ukraine back when they are the ones defending their lives from this totally horrendous and unprovoked attack from Russia
Where are f16 🤔
There's Lugenpresse and then there's DW - absolute drivel.
*Lügenpresse ("Lie-Press")
Some tough women in this video
They fight is for freedom, democrazy, and western values. Such as human right and freedom of speech. ( hope utube dosent delete this one) 🌞
What success means - larger bill from r US tax payers, and more money to dump into a losing cause..🗑️🚮
We have tons of money and this isn't costing us hardly anything. We are giving older materiel and are spending to build new stuff for ourselves. We have more than a thousand Abrams retired and in storage we can give, a couple thousand each of Bradley FVs and F-16s. All about to be replaced anyway. No loss to us, and not an expense.
@@kimweaver1252 q
@@kimweaver1252To replace something is an expense, genius. Because when Ukraine loses they will not be able to pay us back all the Billions of dollars worth of equipment we sent. You obviously have no experience in the military, so I'm not surprised you have no idea how the statistics work for military equipment but just stop pretending that you do because obviously from your comment you don't have a clue.
@@kimweaver1252 Ukraine war is an investment for the US, nothing more nothing less
@@kimweaver1252 Yes. You should be ashamed of what you just said @BigG1691. Helping Ukraine defeat the big bully russia is obviously the right thing to do. Giving military support saves innocent Ukrainian lives. So stop whining like a baby!
I think its time to invite Mearsheimer and some decent military analyst, like Ryan McBeth or Robert C Castell from the Realist side to your news, so there would be an actual debate.