Seeking solutions for Somalia
Вставка
- Опубліковано 4 жов 2024
- On April 6, the Africa Security Initiative in the Foreign Policy program at Brookings hosted a discussion on Somalia. Ambassador Stephen Schwartz discussed the internal and external challenges to restoration. Dr. Felbab-Brown and Dr. Signé joined with their comments on security, governance, and economic challenges in Somalia.
www.brookings.... (transcript available)
Subscribe! www.youtube.com...
Follow Brookings on social media!
Facebook: / brookings
Twitter: / brookingsinst
Instagram: / brookingsinst
LinkedIn: / the-brookings-institution
Discussing Somalia without the presence of Somali intellectual. Fake and void of any ideal practical truth to Somalia’s problem
+Mohamed farah what a stupid thing to say
Stupid is Hawiye donkeys who looted and plundered Mogadishu on an industrial scale.
You guys don't get it, this not about Somalia, this is about making a narrative, Somalis are present here, listent to the guy at 53:40 who tells them about Somalia but that's not what they want to hear. The narrative they want to sent is Somalis support Al-shabaab and therefore US military presence is needed, that lady Dr. Felbab-Brown is an expert who goes around the world documenting illicit criminal activities and underground markets and she has not said one single word about Al shabaab finances but she's able to remember a woman who told her Al-shabaab is good, Pakistan supports the Taliban, Saudis support ISIS and they're saying Somali people support Al shabaab, that's why at 59:00 he signals to that Jareer to bring the charcoals stats, the NSA is able to track untraceable Bitcoins so if they wanted to help Somalia they could seize every penny Al shabaab has and that organisation would collapse but that's not what they want. The people do not support Al shabaab they know it's a terrorist organisation funded by Gulf states that uses violence and food to keep its power and the US is aware of that like they are aware the Saudis are involved in Yemen but US interest comes before Somalis interest.
Mohamed farah LAX baa tahay...car luuqataada Ku calaacal. Noocaago kale aye Ina shegta
Mohamed farah dabaal luuqataada intaa car kuso qor. Shaley aa dhalatey wax aad ka ogtahay dagaalkii sookeeye majirto. But keep on self hating, Somali's are one Tribe, just numerous clans. So whatever hawiye is, so are you doqonyahoow...
If you need to know what is really happening in Somalia you have to invite Somali scholars . I am sure some of them are few miles away from where this talk was held.
As Somali, listening to these so called pseudo experts makes me vomit.
Ibrahim Somali
Their agenda will never work in Somalia. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Geesi Gun Rifayso All the trashes that Europe refuse are coming to our country and playing upper class for us. Damn I vomit when I see them being obsess with our country. Hands off!!!
I hope Somalian realize what westren Arab Emirates want somalia
Why? Aim somali and I think everything they said were true.
What the woman says is true and you have nor given argument why what they say is not right.
as a somali i think that the first problem we have i somalia is the Qaabil without that problem somalia would be a peaceful Land i think If you agree please like this answer🌸
Isn't qabiil is intervention of other governments
We found our solution and we are happy. We don’t need your solutions or opinions thank you.
You are not talking about The truth. The truth is that. Somalia need. To built up their own Army not fucking Amizon. Or peace keepers ,stop interverance. Allah will make Somalia greate again
Am I the only one who think the African guy added NOTHING to the conversation. I think the people who were organising this panel thought "Let's just add black guy into mix so no one would say white people discussing about african country".
The ambassador (which is more interested in US interest in Somalia than Somalia it self) and the lady have more complex view on Somalia, although I personally liked the points in which the Lady put forward and I want to answer her question.
The reason that clan discrimination largely isn't found in Alshabab is because the biggest identification and the most important identity marker in Alshabab is muslim identity.
I must quickly add that I am very much against Alshabab brutality, but there are somethings that we can learn about them.
In my humble opinion Somalia problems can not be solved unless we incorporate our Islamic values in to our goverment, only then we can get rid of corruption and clan discrimination.
Raqiya Ahmed Jibriil
Well said
Darood Power.
Jajaja!
Raqiya, I think you got it wrong, the reason the Al shabaab terrorists are not fighting over clan issues is because they are getting paid and getting sex slaves. Clan squabbles are usually over resources and these terrorists get huge resources from Gulf countries. Terrorist organisations don't run on "faith" only they also run on money and as long as they have money they will keep terrorizing people and sadly this conference never addressed that issue. As for incorporating "Islamic" values in the government to solve Somalia's problems I totally disagree. Look how fucked up the Middle East is, all those countries fighting have 'Islamic" values and it has not stopped them from killing each other. Believing that without Islam we cannot govern ourselves properly is totally rubbish, this is like saying we were savages before islam came to our shores, many Somali fanatics call that the jahiliyya period as if we were slaughtering ourselves back then like they do in the Middle East, in fact it's the opposite, we were more peaceful and prosperous back then before islam got us all twisted and clannish with Arab genealogy. Saying that we need Islamic values is like saying we need Western values, both of them are not our values, they are the values of foreigners. What we need is our own values, we're people with a very old history who live in the place they found Dinkinesh, we cannot just erase our history and believe instead in some plagiarized religious stories with talking animals and flying unicorns. We need to reclaim our history and our heritage otherwise we're no different than slaves who have been given their masters history and heritage.
Maleh Farah, I am disappointed to hear that you think Islam is arab religion . It is true that prophet Muhammad (c.s) was Arab man but Islam was very revolutionary religion that came to challenge the tribalism and the horrible in justice that Arabs and non Arabs were in it. It is a way of life not culture. Islam is religion for all human being. If you know anything about Islam you would have known that what is happening in the middle east has very little to do with Islam it self.
What is happening today in the middle East is caused by (to but it simply) Iraq invasion and powerful countries using the middle East to fight proxy wars.
As for the western values, I don't think they are invaluable and I think we can learn so many good things from them.
Somali culture has many good things and I think we need to preserve that, but it also has bad things and we need to get rid of it.
I am not a person who just get rids of culture or religion because I think it's not mine, I like to evaluate it by it's merits. For me whatever Wisdom given to humanity is mine because I am a human being.
Although I am a born Muslim but I chose Islam because of it's merits.
Thank you.
Raqiya, what "horrible" injustices were the Somali people in that Islam liberated us from? If you have proof that in the 7th century we were under an horrible oppression and some Arab saviors come to liberate us, please post your links so that we can go read them because from historical records the Arabs came to trade with us and then later on they brought their religion but they never came to liberate us. Even when the Arabs invaded Egypt where they could have liberated some of our Cushite cousins from Roman Byzantine occupation all they did was become the new colonizers and loot the place dry. I know you believe in their made up stories they plagiarized from the Jews and the Christians but to believe they freed us from some horrible plight is exactly the mindset of slaves who believe they were freed from some horrible plight when they were enslaved. As for the Middle East conflicts, yes Western powers are involved but these powers exploit preexisting animus and the Sunnis Shiites hate existed before these Western power got there. Islam had it's time and it's high times we start moving on to rebuild our identity back otherwise it will be too late as you gals turn very hairy under those sheets and we'll have no choice but to ship y'all to south east asia.
Maleh Farah, it very discouraging to hear you say such intolerant things like how you will "ship" me to south "South east asia", and because I am a female how you describe me as "hairy" " under those sheets". The truth is I like having dialogue with people who have different views than me but I don't tolerate and will not tolerate any disrespectful comments.
Now to answer your question I never said that "arabs liberated us" and if you look back at my previous answer you will see that. I am very aware of how Islam came to my land and my people and they like many other muslims living or dead choose this religion because of it's values.
As for Sunni and Shia conflict, if you read it up you Will see that they have been living together in peace for many centuries.
You can of course build your own identity if you wish but for many of us we already have identity which we are very proud of.
The thing is am not that intrested in blood lines, I think that is why we killed each other and we still kill each other because we imagine that some people are "closer" to us than others. I have no interest in tribalism.
I think you should learn Islam from its scholars so you at least understand it is core values. I think it's important to support your self with correct information in this age of "alternative facts"
So here is a website that belongs to amazing institution that could answer some of your questions about Islam.
yaqeeninstitute.org/en/research/publications/
P.S you will appreciate if you read the Qur'an in English translation if you don't know arabic. It is a very intresting book.
A garbled voice recording and lack of Somali representation in your panel made your discussion unworthy of noting, Sorry.
Who the hell do they think they are to come up with a "solution" for us?
Local Dealer Right Baffles the mind...they think too highly of themselves and who is that African dude? What does he know about our country lol...I swear this world has gone to the dogs.
Bilan Mohamed It in furiates me hearing them talk their nonsense, in'sha'Allah their plot against us will fail
Local Dealer it always does...
Agree! "Butt out"!!
discussing Somalia without a Somalian present to add their perspective... Feels so colonial
Whom Can We Trust If No One Is Trustworthy? One of my favorite quips from Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is when Tom is defined as “a glittering hero…the pet of the old, the envy of the young,” and there were “some that believed that he would be President, yet, if he escaped hanging.” With these few words, Twain captured the essence of leadership in our world. Those who get to the top are the fiercest, most determined, and most ruthless. Today, the latter quality has become so intense that we can no longer believe our leaders, and certainly not trust them to have our best interest in mind. I am not accusing any leader in particular, or even leaders as a whole. It is simply that in an egoistic world, where people vie to topple one another on their way to the top, the one at the top is clearly the one who trampled over and knocked down more people than anyone else. Concisely, to get to the top in an egoistic world you have to be the biggest egoist. So how do we know whom to trust? We don’t know and we cannot know. All we know is that we are in the dark. In a culture of unhinged selfishness, any conspiracy theory seems reasonable, while truth is nowhere to be found. When every person who says or writes something is trying to promote some hidden agenda, you have no way of knowing who is right, what really happened, or if anything happened at all. The only way to get some clarity in the news and goodwill from our leaders is to say “Enough!” to our current system and build something entirely independent. The guiding principle of such a system should be “information only,” no commentary. Commentary means that information has already been skewed. Information means saying only what happened, as much as possible, not why, and not who is to blame and who we should praise. Concurrently, we must begin a comprehensive process of self-teaching. We have to know not only what is happening, but why we skew and distort everything. In other words, we have to know about human nature and how it inherently presents matters according to its own subjective view, which caters to one’s own interest. To “clear” ourselves from that deformity, we must learn how to rise above our personal interest and develop an equally favorable attitude toward others. This is our only guarantee that our interpretation of things will be even and correct. Once we achieve such an attitude, we will discover that the bad things we see in our world reflect our own, internal wickedness. Our ill-will toward others creates a world where ill-will governs, and so the world is filled with wickedness and cruelty. Therefore, all we need in order to create positive leadership-and to generally eliminate ill-will from the world-is to generate goodwill within us. When we nurture goodwill toward others, we will fill the world with goodwill. As a result, the world will fill with kindness and compassion. By changing ourselves, we will create a world that is opposite from the world we have created through our desires to govern, patronize, and often destroy other people...
X
Hgv
lĺ🎉❤
Is it April fools day!!!!!!!!!!! A talk about Somalia without a single Somali person in the dialogue. This is gotta be just like black hack down actors.
It's a travesty you couldn't find a somali intellectual amongs't your guest to discuss Somalia.
+Mohamed farah there are many to speak they use didn't want to hear from a somali since they don't want to actually help somalia
Isnot shog wallahi
Isnot shog wallhi mi i am somali
Isnot shigsowaal ok tobe falcopin naw
Mi abdi i am mugadhisho
Seeking a solution for Somalia by meddling in internal affairs and bringing a new type of colonisation well done! It’s a hot topic because each one wants a slice of the pie( natural resources).
Alyasssa Ilyas vibranium Wakanda = Wadanka
You are right 100%
If only Somalia listens to Somaliland we told you keep all foreigners away from your internal political affairs, starting from 1991 at least 14 conferences were held for Somalia all of them where outside of Somalia in the hands of foreigners.
Yeah, you don't need "help" from these meddlers!
Kkkk garac ba tahay ictiraafka idinko radiniya bee dunida idinku dhaman
This is the reality of our country that we are all remaining deaf and blind about. Every one says the solution to Somalia’s problems lies with the Somalis. But no one is leaving Somali people to solve their problems. There is interference from every where.
I see bunch of con artist pedaling the message of whoever is lining their pockets. Brookings is a joke. Somalia Ha Noolaato 🇸🇴.....if you ain't got no haters, you ain't Poppin! Keep analyzing, we keep on moving ----⏩➡
right
"Baadidia ninbaa kula daydaya oo daalna kaa badan eh,oo hadana aan doonahayn in aad heshaaa daa'in abibkaaa"
This is bullish!!! Discuss Somalia affairs without a representation of a single Somali individual.
Seeking "how to steal" from Somalia
🇸🇴Somalia🇸🇴💙🇸🇴2️⃣0️⃣2️⃣0️⃣✔🌻
think tank groups from Washington and london should. Stop drafting policies that are meant to create conflicts and to continue the holistic rope of their natural resources.i commend the somali people 4 their patience and iam optimistic for the future
Long live somalia
I think somalia doesn’t need just speech but it needs action and that action must come from somlia people. International communities can help you for material
Western are there ajenda in somalia we don’t want even there help please just leave a lone
Soomaalidu waligeed iyo waqood heshiin mayaan
We known our solution it is just Taken Quraan and sunnah and leaving democracy for the sake of God(Allah).
Be like us really muslims have the best happiness in the world.
Somalia, is a project
teach students
tomorrow, they
explain us
as you did
I appreciate for Brookings Institute for organizing this session. The reality is far from what some panel members talked about. That is not the Somalia I worked in for five years. Some panel members have visited by going to a small isolated island built by the so called international community. Basing your judgement on what you heard from those people in the Island is not who Somalis are and the country in general. They are challenges and as well progresses towards good governance and peaceful Somalia! Diversify your panel next time!
Question about
4223
q
What do you appreciate for? Sit back and picture what you are watching, these are not somalis and they sit there saying we will try to get solutions for Somalia without having one single somali person.
It is just propaganda and that is how they make money to run their institution.
Your mentality is exactly how African leaders behave by seeking African problems from European leaders. When African leaders is called in Europe to discuss African problems.
And you happy that someone else find a solution for your problem?
Have a respect for yourself and seek somali problems from inside not outside.
99o99òóiój
Tackou
Ex Nigerian ambassador to US, Ugandan lady who did surveys in US and Chilean guy from South America. now let's ask the political problems in America
Ma filayo hadii aad samaysan, barnaamijyo, doodo, heshiisyo, iyo wada hadal dhamaantood inaydu u heli kartaan idinku; sababtuna dad isku diin ah, isku qiyam ah, isku mabda ah, darafyada nolosha dacal uun iskaga dhaw baa isu hela xal iyo waan waan. Don't let your time, to lose.
We want our solution to reach the Somali people.
You discussed Somali issues and their is no Somalis in the panel!
I believe that if the International Communities keep their nose out of it then, the Somalians will find their own solution. The Somalians need to go back to basics, which means going back to the old Somalian tradition negotiation instead of someone else are dictating them for how to run a government.
the notion of a unified Somali state that encompasses all Somalis, regardless of their clan or where they live, is, in itself an idea that was imported from Europe and has no intellectual roots, as far as I am aware, in Somali history. Somalis have always been separated into small groups mainly on the grounds of clan allegiances.
So I really don't know what you mean when you say going back to "old school"
Somalia Panels could make the best contribution for your search.
The same old nefarious caravan of the 'international community' ie: Europe and the USA. Somalia's problem is easily solved and needs strong national leadership.
Why?
give me a break. how come you guys are talking Somalia and none of these people on the stage is Somali.
Stop lie Because al-shabab and AMISOM are friends and you say al-Shabaab is estimated at 2000 solider also AMISOM is estimated at 22,000 which proves where they are not sure.
Did you find the solution yet?
They didn’t bother to invite a Somali who really knows the reality of Somalia instead of this people on here 🤦🏾♂️
We have 3333 kilometres ocean ambassador got it wrong
🇸🇴Somalia 21 ml pp🇸🇴 is doing better slowly now in 2018 compared to last 25 years, big thanks & love for USA, EU, African troops their efforts & help to poor Somalis. the lady is miss. Somalia, she said exactly true about Somalia's unfortunate satuation. thanks Ambassador & Camoroon man for info. good discuss. Somalia needs long time to return peacefull nation that only happens when all Somalis & regions work.
🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
🍀SOMALIA Federal Republic🍀
🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴🇸🇴
🌳🌳🌳🌱🌱🌱🌴🌴🌴🌳🌳🌳
Ragan yaa shaqadan u dirsaday tolow 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Soomaaliya
Ha noolaato
Soomaaliya
Ha waarto
Hawiye
Dameer kaada la tasho
Soomaaliland
Waligaaba marqaan qaldaanyohow
og2me somalia waa hawiye , calanka iyaga waligiod uu dhimaneyey
War maxey ka hadlayaan kuwaan dusheena ku shiraaya
Where did you get that 11miljan statistik number?
Cadaanku Somaliland iyo Somalia waxba uma ogala mid walba wuu xaqirayaa waa in aynu hadaynu nahay reer Somaliland wax loo qabto ✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾
Not good to talk about a country solution without including your discussion with its officials.
Somalia is a legal fiction , not a state.
I would like to remind you that the somaliland isn't,t trouble country but it needs international recognition
Solution for Somalia is to free jigjiga and garissa 🇸🇴
Ma fahmayo wax ka hadlaayo 🇸🇴🏪🛖⚠️↗️🚰↘️🔙🔝🛐🎭🖼🖼🖼🖼🕹🎰🍖🍗🍗🍗🍻🍻🍻🚱
How many of you Somalis here are actually living in Somalia? How many of you are actually doing something to fix Somalia? and yet, you complain about these caadans for trying help our country. If it means losing some of our resources let them have it because we don't even capitalise on it.
This is why the country isn't progressing. Majority of you have big mouth and little action and the ones who are trying are the ones in government and the ones who actually want to do something ends up joining al shabib thinking he's doing something great for the Somali people. Either bring something to the table or shut up.
Please let them alone
as we are somali people around in the world we can solve our problems this is a long history since 1991 upto now United nation of America and international community are interesting what is going in Somalia we are not tried to talk about Somalia and we can do nothing. you people have you ever asked a question. why the world organisations focus on Somalia
Who Gave a right those Colonizers to Discuss Somali Issues
Somalia's problem need to be solve a solution comes from the Somali people. I wonder why such forum was not invited a panelist from Somalia who deeply know the ground situations exist in Somalia.
All Somali recognized of the world's
Somalia is definitely more that
Somalia population are more than 20 million
WHAT HAS SOMEONE CAMEROON GOT TO SAY ABOUT SOMALIA.
We don’t need any events for Somalia hands off please.
2021 Somalian pupolation 62 milyan.
Lmfao
somali once the lions of africa
Somalia has more oil than Saudi Arabia
11 million ❓ Somali regional state us 12.5 million.. so don't insult our INTILIGENCE... Due to last election and censuses Somaliland alone is 7.5 million that alone can give us a projection of 20 million 12.5 SRS nfd 3 million jabouti and Yemen 1.4 million plus 37 other countries
I'm from Somaliland, Somaliland is maximum 4m maybe 3.5m, somali state is not part of somalia in anyway it is part of Ethiopia
this was actually depressing, very similar to Afghanistan. talaiban and shabab are both more honest than the goverment
C’est étonnant qu’on parle de la Somalie (et pas la Somaliland car elle est marche )aucun somalien n’est présent à cette conférence .
Inid shid pas ilag pas
Honestly, none of them is talking about the problems, like.
1. Who is funding Alshabab?
2. Tribal issues.
3. No genuine support.
4. No one supports Alshabab but people are afraid.
5. You guys are really dishonest.
This is conspiracy theory!! I watched it and it is one side story. If you want to talk about Somalia's problem it most parts Somali intellectual. The ambassador's story is not bad it based on his work experience.
This were really apprecoiate Debate for elections of Somaliland.o
What a shame. Talking about Somali without inviting somali scholars in America. This is the hallmark of imperialism.
Ok i nid chanid
اتمنى ان تزورو اللاجئين بجورجيا تبيليسي مارتكوبي وتشوفو اوضاعهم ومعاناتهم والتميز لبعض وعدم الاهتمام للبعض الاخر وكيف مرضى الكورونا الشباب معزولين دون علاج او اكل او اي اهتمام وعائلات يهتم بها ويدعمو اكثر من الغير عائلات وين العدل هنا صورو معاناتنا نحن اللاجئين اتمنى ان تصل رسالتي لكم وللامم المتحدة ؟!؟!؟!؟!
No
Ok sorry tidan
Mi inid halegare god
War waxbo mataraayo wax qabat👍👍👍👍👍👍☺
Its very hard to get solution for somalia
Not with any Somali person that’s lived there on the panel
Halow way minitateri africa
We are 15 million not 11 million
Somaliland isn't part of the failed state of Somalia
There's one thing they never talk about who financial so call Al shabab, some people who hired African union force
Yes iniid no hash naw allah
same on who organized this !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!????????????????
Ok
Ye
I am somalia
ROMINIA
Theres no point of having a conversation when theres no Somali present.
how about leaving them alone
Mi i am somali
I totally agree with the woman's statement. Our government is corrupted and there's still a lot of discrimination and clan rival s in our country.we won't get true peace till we eradicate tribalism and corruption.lets put aside tribalism and clan system as the Rwandans did post civil war..let us just be somalis instead of being divided by clan.
Listening this makes my day hardly disturbing.
Useless comments
I am wondering why or how people who are not somalis are looking for solutions for somalia!!!!
Why don't you focus your internal problems instead of something which is not your concern any more??
Is boyon mey
I wonder why there's no al-shabab or al qaeda like groups in the Gulf region
Because Sharia Law has already been implemented on the Gulf region (almost all GCC countries )
This conversation on Somalia is disrespectifull to say the least to Somalis and Somalia. No one single Somali on the members panel yet the topic is "seeking solution for Somalia"..clearly the thinking here is part of the problem and far from "solution" for Somalia.
Waa shir laayba
SOMALIA FOR SOMALIS. FOREIGN INTERVENTION WILL NOT BE TOLERATED. NO TO COLONISM NO TO DEGREDATION. FOREIGNERS YOU ARE NOT WELCOME!
somalis are 20 millions not 11 millions.
leave us alone and we will be alright. our problem is neighbouring countries, african forces and the so-called international community.