@@yesssboss2219 So you're enjoying watching women and children get bombed on a scale earth hasn't seen since ww2? Is that what you're telling us? Thankfully the Azeris aren't as barbaric as you and didn't behave that way in victory.
This is absurd! Armenia (regardless of religion) occupied 20% of the neighboring country, kicked out 700k native population and held it illegally for 30 years! After 30 years of patience and fruitless diplomatic efforts Azerbaijan freed its internationally recognized territories. What else is there to discuss?
@@danbaltic9678что делает тоже самое? Что Азербайджан окупировал 20% территории армении? Или провёл этнические чистки как сделали это армяне? Наоборот армянам предложили интегрироватся и принять гражданство Азербайджана, до сих пор можно подать заявку, но в армении этот сайт блокируют, есть много видео кадров как они уходили и как им предлагали остатся, и кто им сказал уходить.
Can u provide ur source of their "diplomatic efforts" that don't include full Azeri integration or taking land? Because that wouldn't be diplomatic efforts that would just be conquest of lands that the natives don't want taken from them. Nobody in Karabakh wanted to be part of Azerbaijan and u can see from the 2 referendums held in karabakh
despite I'm neutral in this conflict, I have to say Arte is very biased. using "the FORCED repopulation policy" regarding the refuges returning back is more than funny. those people had been dreaming about this moment for decades.
What are you rambling about? From 9:94 onward the refugees themselves express dissatisfaction and one of them ask: "why did you bring us here?", the govt. official just laughs at them. Does them wanting to return for decades mean that they are willing to return under less than satisfactory conditions, and not on their own terms? I think not.
@@PrebaaaaaaaaaaaaaaYou don't know the language, She asks why did they bring them while not everything is fully finished and ready. They were not forsed. You are also biased.
@@oguzb.7033 I can only conclude based on the translation I see, and I sure as hell aint gonna trust the translation of some random person over the translation of the people who actually made the documentary. I am biased... why? Because i pointed out something I saw in the doc? In a sense, I am biased - but so are you, and so is everybody else.
@@Prebaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Yes so you believe they are forsed to go, really interesting, i see people freely talking about their ideas and asking for better situation from their government. These areas were destroyed by Armenians for 30 years, of course it will take some time for better situations. Azerbaijan did great job in very short time.
I think this documentary is a little bit biased . I dont think its fair to say these people were forced to live there . I dont believe any Azerbaijani can be forced to live somewhere. Its not North Korea. These people are definitely hard core encouraged to move there but by no means they are forced.
Brining up your children to hate Armenians - is not OK. It is cultivating and spreading hate. It is crime against humanity. No hate is good for any society for any country on any base!!
Armenians have been bringing their children to hate us during Soviet time even when no nationalism was in Azerbaijan. You see it as hate we see it as focusing nation to survive. Armenians shouldn’t have started war. It’s normal that people you attack will hate you
I am Pakistani and I know how it feels to lose of life especially your beloved one. I am also currently living in Azerbaijan which is prospering very rapidly and at a fast pace. I somewhere encourage Azerbaijani and Armenians to have reconciliation, I know it would be super difficult but it would be important for both to reconcile as there's a quote "Revenge only brings revenge." Hence, forgiveness and respect for both countries should go on and wish Azerbaijan more prosperity
Azerbaijanis are not rational people at all. The idea of reconciling with Armenians is completely taboo for them. Maybe the next generation of Azerbaijanis could bring hope but I've lost all faith for the current generation.
If that were true why weren't the civilians slaughtered during this conflict. The Azeris literally behaved in the exact opposite fashion to how the Armenians behaved when they conquered this region in the 1990s and ethnically cleansed 850,000 civilians, brutally so. Facts>Your feelings. What is sad is your detachment from reality.
@@williamdavis9562there are literal footages of Azeris targeting Karabakh civilians and children, wheres your footage? Stop lying when u dont have proof to back those lies up
Azerbaijan just returned their own native lands, n never told armenians in Karabakh to leave Karabakh part, armenians of Karabakh may return whenever they want, only under Azerbaijani passports
🤣🤣🤣🤣@@tryyourselff there is a reason why Azeri Turks are SHIA instead of the usual SUNNI and that is no accident, which is proof religion and linguistic realities cannot be faked like the fabricated statehood that is known as "azerbaijan" is really is a PERSIAN province and it belongs there. If we learned anything in 2023, that militarily solutions can n restore the northern province back to IRAN proper.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Armenians have been a big majority in that area for over a thousand years (longer then the Turks). Maybe you should look up Turkish history (which is the same as Azeri since they are the same people). Then you will find out that the Turks came from the steppe of which is now South East Russia, and conquered their way to Anatolia. Armenians have lived in that area long before the Turks even thought of going West. About international recognized territories you're right, about fairness totally not.
@@Sandor7698 You should realize that international law doesn't recognize your subjective view of who should own what based on events from 1000s of years ago. If international law worked like that 90% of the planet would have to relocate. There was a point in time where everyone decided that these borders are the internationally recognized borders, any nation which is part of the UN signed on that dotted line so these ridiculous wars of "oh this land is mine because of 1000 years ago" and people slaughtering each other non stop would end. The fact is you can't simply start invading another nation's internationally recognized territory, ethnically cleanse 850,000 civilians and then pretend to be the side of morality. It doesn't work like that.
@@williamdavis9562 the Armenians in Nagorno Karabakh didn't invade the region, they simply have always lived there, and were always a majority. Now they have been successfully ethnically cleansed out of the region by Azerbaijan, just like the Turks ethnicly cleansed Greeks and Armenians out of Anatolia.
Then tell me, if 98.8% voted for independance from the authoritarian regime of Azerbaijan would it then be called liberation? If 100 procent of the people don't want Azeri government there how could u call it liberation and reoccupation when the people actively ran away from aliyev, it's like a murder victim running away from a murderer, but the murderer catches him and murders him, but then he is called a hero for saving the victims life? When he is litterly dead on the ground. That's what's happening with the nagarno Karabakh situation rn, I'd suggest doing independant research and to not look at Armenian or Azeri (biased) (made) stories but rather at independant studies from for example Americans or British or Dutch or German. A lot of them will teach u about the real history
@@Sandor7698okay about karabakh but why didn't armenia returned the regions around karabakh for 30 years? they wanted the status quo to remain forever
I am sad seeing how people cannot live together, and this leading to people being dislocated from their homes and suffering hardships. The Azris fled many years ago, now the Armenians fled. A lot of suffering for both communities and inter-ethnic hate that will lead to further conflicts. The only solution to peace would be the promotion of understanding between the two communities.
Не надо было окупировать территории Азербайджана, и все жили бы счастливо, а армян никто не выгонял они сами ушли, наоборот им предлагали остатся и принять гражданство Азербайджана, но они отказались, может они испугались того что много гадостей натворили.
@@ayaz11288 how do u explain the 99.8% referendum then? Why would sooo many people want independance if nothing was going on? I doubt that 99.8% were ultra Armenian nationalists that wanted to topple the Azeri government.
@@ayaz11288 the progroms you comitted said differently. The people of Karabakh voted. twice. They wanted to join their ethnic homeland to Armenia. You refused, and carried out progroms. We revolted. Simple as that.
It's a tragedy the Armenian government sat and watched Azerbaijan grow strong militarily not doing anything. Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh got sold out by their fellow Armenians.
Corruption, corruption, my friend. Before our current PM, all of them were Russophiles and oligarchs, filling up their pockets with the country's money.
What a condescending bias tearfilled jealous so-called report….congratulations to the victorious Azerbaijanis, Allah has blessed you to come back to your rightful home and it’s now your responsibility to take care of both Azeris and the remaining Armenian civilians as one exemplary community Inshallah. Peace and love from Somalia 🇸🇴
Of course ARTE has to be biased. They called it “territorial conquest”!! It’s not a conquest it’s reclaiming their territory and returning back! Come on now!
@@manotenkerian When Cyprus declared its independence from Britain, Britain, Turkiye and Greece were granted guarantorship of the Island. These three were given the responsibility to maintain the equality between two societies. Cyprus was founded as a binational state where president was Greek and the prime minister was Turkish. The state mechanism was equally shared by two ethnicities. However, with a coup d'etat, Greeks tried enosis (annexation) with Greece. Without consent of Turks, they tried capture the state, cast out all Turks in the state mechanism and made it into a Hellenic state. Greeks tried to downgrade Turks from equal owners of the state to a minority. That was illegal. Since then Greeks never accepted a shared state, they proposed a minority status for Turks. Turks will not accept minority status, they will not let Cyprus to be turned into a Greek state and live under Greek authority. Turkish intervention and military presence in the island is to protect Turks of the island. Those who talk about Solution in Cyprus should stop supporting Greek side unilaterally, surrender rights of Turks as founders and equal owners of the state. Otherwise, nothing will be solved. Eventually isolated and unrecognized Turks will have to unite with Turkiye. Look, Turks wait for recognition for forty years. If Turks did not really look forward to solution and a real reunification of the island, they could unite with Turkiye long time ago. In any case Turkiye is seen as "occupant", in one way or another. Cyrpiot Turks would have get rid of isolation by uniting Turkiye. But they still wait. Three options: 1-Recognize Turks as equal owners of the state, share power and go on as a binational federative state. 2-Recognize Turkish state internationally.That will strengthen Turkish hands in bargaining for powersharing and federation, if not possible, they will go on as an independent state. 3-After so many years of isolation and sanctions, Turks'only remedy will be annexed by Turkiye. Reminder: As an Armenian you are no way entitled to form a view on Cyprus, especially after your nation invaded 20% of another country and while you have no idea about Cyprus issue. Do not poke your Armenian nose into things you do not know about. Just work for Armenia to develop and prosper. Armenia will not develop with anti-Turk stance and expansionism.
@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 as a turk you have no opinion on Armenian affairs. Look what you wrote : "armenians occupied 20 percent of azeri land" meanwhile , turks occupying 20 percent of greek cyprus land is okay? Did you know nagarno karabach in soviet times was an oblast ? Did you know after armenia gained independence from usssr, nagarno karabach followed ? If it was apart of Azerbaijan then why did nagarno karabach leave user before Azerbaijan succeeded? Don't be a hypocrite
@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 also, why doesnt any of your turkic brother nations or your fellow Islamic nations recognize north cyprus? It's seems like your anti Christian
At 7:26, You meant taken back by the Azeri. And I am not sure why you keep refering to the Aeri Governmebt as the "Regime"!!!. The Azeri goverment is using the OIL and Gas money to REBUILD the Liberated towns and Cities...
Because the world is on the side of the native inhabitants. From USA. Dont know a single Armenian or your people but its riduculous you get nakchavan and Armenia can't have a smaller closer to their border ancient land
Do u think the Armenian inhabitants destroyed the region for 30 years straight when THEY LIVE THERE? Seems kinda like a dumb move if I was an Armenian living there, in contrast Azerbaijan did destroy Armenian historical sites that were thousands of years old in nakhijevan. Seems kind of strange that Azeris are willing to hide that fact tho. Azeris are hypocrites and the sooner they realise that the sooner they will realise the truth. Also Azerbaijan is on fact an authoritarian regime it is proven by multiple sources and the way their government is handled is an autocracy, handled by an autocrat / close to a dictator
Especially for those illiterate people who think that Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) or Nakhichevan is azerbaijan it is not true, these regions were transferred to azerbaijan during the time of lenin and stalin, but in fact this had been Armenian land since the beginning of time🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲 azerbaijan is artificial country created on Armenian and Persian lands
Azerbaijan has Guranteed protection and equality under the law to the Armenian population of Azerbaijan. They rejected it and left for Armenia. No ethnic cleansing or Genocide. Civilians were not harmed. President Aliev is a mature and balanced humanitarian leader in the region. I hope my Iranian family in Tehran will not fuel tensions in this volatile area of the world.
I definitely support Azerbaijan on this conflict BUT why would any Armenian trust the promise of protection and equality claims of Azerbaijan? Same would apply if the sides switched. They have done both to each other in this conflict (even though ultimately azeri side was right) to never trust a member of their nations ever again. Both nations are fully capable of doing the lip service and continue oppressing the other because the level of animosity between the nations is very high. Also, Azerbaijan for sure would populate the land with Azeris to diminish any future war and revolt and those people could also very well harass Armenians. If this was the start of the conflict, peaceful coexistence could have worked but honestly it is all too late for that, so I understand why they feel compelled to leave.
The UN states that Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast is a disputed region that has the right to self-determination, the surrounding regions are considered occupied. The UN states there is no military solution to this conflict and the OSCE Minsk Group Protocol Protocol will be used for negotiations and a resolution to this conflict. Now don't try to start quoting outdated UN resolutions before the war ended, weren't binding, or had little votes supporting the resolutions. If the surrounding regions were very important, then Azerbaijan could have recognized the independence of NKAO with a corridor to Armenia for them returned
The whole point of Azerbaijan is the erdication of Armenia. We can see it everyday by its unfriendly attitude against Armenia, eventhough they took the whole Karabakh region.
You're must be a real genius. Those lands are internationally recognized by Azerbaijan and except the Karabagh, the Azerbaijani majority lived in all other 7 territories. They buy weapons from multiple countries, such as Russia, Turkey, Pakistan etc... NOT just Israel. And Israel support for Azerbaijan is because of common threat of Iran.
@@INeatFreak All 7 territories, not Karabakh. The Armenians offered numerous times to cede these 7 regions, in exchange for the recognition of the Karabakh people's right to decide for themselves. These people voted twice to be independant, you refused this vote twice, and carried out progroms. Those 7 territories are not Karabakh.
Two things that make me so happy, one is to see Azeris start going back to their homes and the other is to see Aliyev walk over and step on the fascist Armenian/Arztak flag 🙂
Can u explain to me what fascism is? Because if u call a country fascist without even knowing what it is then I don't think u should have the mental capacity to enter debates
I remember our family always going to karabakh every summer. Now its all just a memory. I know ill never go back, but im glad i got a glimpse of its views...
Obviously and apparently clear that narrator espressing his Anti-Azerbaijanian position by saying "Azeri Regime" it sounds like he is comparing our country with Saddam's Regime, hypocrites...
@@nadirhikmetkuleli no, they aren't, like they quite literally aren't i dont know how ur brain came to that conclusion. Like what have u been reading to come to that conclusion, I know it wasn't actual non biased research. Like man how does one even believe such a thing
What is a lie? The fact that nearly a million Azerbaijanis were forcibly expelled from their homeland? That Karabakh, which is Azerbaijani territory according to international law, remained under Armenian occupation for 30 years? Khojaly massacre?
You will run out of people before you realize that irredentism will get you nowhere. We both got our internationally recognized territories, how about we finally live in peace for our kids?
You are silent that for 30 years Armenia and the separate regime in Karabakh occupied Azerbaijani lands, we returned ours at the cost of our blood and the lives of our soldiers
Good side is that Azerbaijan didn't kill any Armenian civilians and didn't do any Genocide 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 So ,,,do you guys belive it ? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 I guess both sides did what they could to kill each other,, When people will learn to live in peace ✌️
I am glad that Azerbaijan regains it national territory of Ngorno-Karabakh. I was all on the side of Azerbaijan during its war to regain Nagorno Karabakh. Karabakh is an internationally recognized part of Azaerbaijan & should be reintegrated into Azerbaijan. However, I will immediately side wit Armenia if Azerbaijan launches a war to seize even an inch of territory that belong2 to Armenia proper. I will be on the side of Armenia if Azerbaijan tries to seize Syunik province from Armenia to create the Zangezour Corridor with Nakhichevan. I am Muslim, just like Azerbaijan, but I do not judge based on religion but on justice. ! will not accept injustice by non-Muslims on Muslims, and I will not accept injustice by Muslims on non-Muslims.
There is no big difference between Nazi Germany capturing Sudetenland and Armenia capturing Karabakh. German aggression was punished by land loss and contribution payments, but Armenian aggression remains unpunished. Azerbaijan has all rights to enforce Armenian commitment signed on November 9, 2020 to ensure unobstructed communication from Azerbaijan to Azerbaijan (Nakchivan) through Armenian territory.
Congrats you are on the side of terrorism. Nagorno-Karabakh was always Armenian majority and the people wanted to live there peacefully. You support the side that didn't let this happen!
Even though i side with Armenia and Artsakg in this conflict I respect your opinion, You are a lot better than the Azeris that are hypocrites saying that Armenia cant have an inch of their land but Azerbaijan can. And for that I respect your opinion 🤝
@@i.k.8868you turkish??just because you got turkish passport??first be human and if you young and dont know what happend before...watch HOXALI ,and see what they (armenians)did to them!!
I don't think so. If in 50 years armenians decide to reconquer lands internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, they will need to officially attack from the territory of the republic of Armenia, which in this case will be international conflict. Till now it was defacto war was between Azerbaijan and Armenia, but on the paper it was an internal conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenian backed separatist of Nagorno Karabakh. Something similiar what was happening in Ukraine till 2022, defacto Ukraine was at war with Russia from 2014, but on the paper till 2022 it was an internal conflict, Ukraine fought against Russian backed separatists in Donetsk and Lugansk.
as was commented that would now be an international conflict and would be valid grounds for Turkey to also active partake in this war. Armenians should focus on developing their country and economy to attract the Armenian diaspora to repatriate if they want to have any future in the region, instead of chasing after impossible dreams in the region and yelling war crime every single time it doesn't go the way they want in a conflict they themselves have started.
@@mapachepataki5013 Dude? Do you know how many countries the British colonized and killed hundreds of millions of people? It's Christian. Before the Armenians, there were people who were killed by the Armenians in the same way as the Jews of the Canaanites. Armenia recouped this territory by expelling Azerbaijanis, hundreds of thousands, women and children walked through the snow in winter for a thousand kilometers and died. Now these children have returned and not to say that they have taken revenge for what they did.
see history of Artsakh (Karabakh). Artsakh was never part of Azerbaijan Nakhijevan. During the USSR they signed and gave it to Azerbaijan. Now there is no USSR, it has been destroyed and these signatures have also been destroyed! Azerbaijan History as a State 100 years! I do not accept this decision, supposedly Artsakh is part of Azerbaijan if it is part of Azerbaijan and Azerbaijan is part of Iran!!!!
Then why does International Law recognize Karabakh as Azerbaijani territory? Don't you think it matters? For example, why don't you say what you said about Abkhazia, Ossetia and other regions?
@@Khacmaz_edits For example!!!!? I repeat once again Azerbaijan There is no such Nation and in general there was no Country and in general you will not find it anywhere! Azerbaijan is a province of Iran!!! Tatars became Azeris!!? Is this what you wanted to hear? Even now Azerbaijan as a country is in question! You are also a Tatar, your grandfather was also a Tatar, what kind of Azeris??? And about Karabakh, this has no connection with Azerbaijan! Karabakh is purely Armenian land up to the border of Syria, you live in those lands that have no spiritual or cultural connection with you!
@@artconstructioncorp.7261 we aren't tatar. Russian empire was calling "Caucasian Tatars" to us. Did u search about this conflict with pro-armenian propaganda media?
@ The history of Azerbaijan is understood as the history of the region now forming the Republic of Azerbaijan. Topographically, the land is contained by the southern slopes of the Caucasus Mountains in the north, the Caspian Sea in the east, and the Armenian Highlands in the west. In the south, its natural boundaries are less distinct, and here the country merges with the Iranian Plateau.[1] The entity of Caucasian Albania was established on its soil in ancient times. The Caucasian Albanian language spoken by the founders of Caucasian Albania was most likely a predecessor of the now endangered Udi language spoken by the Udi people. From the time of the Medes and the Achaemenid Empire, until the coming of the Russians in the 19th century, the territories of the republic of Azerbaijan and Iran have usually shared the same history.[2][1][3] Azerbaijan retained its Iranian character even after the Arab conquest of Iran and the conversion of the area's inhabitants to Islam.[1] Some four centuries later, Oghuz Turkic tribes under the Seljuq dynasty entered the area, and Azerbaijan gained a large amount of Turkic inhabitants.[1] Over the centuries, as the original population mingled with the immigrant Turkic nomads, the number of native Persian speakers gradually diminished, and a Turkic dialect nowadays known as Azerbaijani (or Azeri Turkic) gained hold.[1]
@@artetvdocumentary Thanks and if it's possible another documentary about the Alegerean genecide which was done by the French. I am sure they know more than 1 million people were killed by French. Please forward my second message to then. Merci et bon nuit mon amie 🤣👍
Fransız mediyası siz Afrikadakı teroriziminzdən, genosiddən danışın!!! Siz Aqressor ölkəsisiz.!!! ARTE-tv fransanın afrikadakı qenosidindən reportaj hazırlasa yaxşı olardı!!! YAŞASIN AZƏRBAYCAN 🇦🇿
I think it will be hard for Azerbaijan to convince Azeris to leave where they live now and go to the rural mountainous region of Nagorno-Karabakh. They will invest a lot of their petro-money there, but wait 20 years and we will see, that few people will really permanently go to live there. Why, because they prefer urban live along the coast of the Caspian Sea than living as goat herders somewhere far away in the mountains. The whole Nagorno-Karabakh thing is more a national propaganda myth than a real social movement. The same is true for a lot of revisionist myths around the world. Just imagine that Germany would suddenly get back East Prussia. Do you think a lot of Germans would cherfully move there to make it a German populated region once again? I don't think so.
Don't try to put a religious view on this issue. Religion has always been an excuse to carry out the dirty politics of some states. You should talk about fascism against Azerbaijanis in 1980-90s.
We learned our lessons in the past 30 years that we should be strong and depend on only ourselves to bring justice. All western states failed to bring peace to the region by supporting Armenia. Türkün Türkden başqa dostu yoxdur 🇦🇿🇹🇷
Pakistan, Bangladeş te Azarbaycan'ı destekledi. Ama onlar Türk değil. Ama Türk olan Kazakistan ve diğer Türki Cumhuriyetler Pakistan gibi açıktan destek veremediler. O nedenle "Türkün Türkten başka dostu yoktur" cümlesi gerçek değil. Gerçek olan Müslüman kardeşliğidir.
I was interested in watching this until the narrator said "propaganda or reality it's impossible to verify" pertaining to the Marijauna fields. All the plants and fields are right there, verifying would be quite easy. Just walk over and look at them, smell them lol WTF is this.
Don't compare Azerbaijanis with Armenia. It was Armenia that occupied Karabakh and after that 7 regions of Azerbaijan, and claimed that those 7 regions, which was equal to the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh itself, as buffer territory so called "Security belt" and then Armenia added these regions later to the so-called "NKR" along with ethnic cleansing of the 700 thousands of Azerbaijanis. Now Armenia expects that Azerbaijan will do the same. Azerbaijanis are not Armenians. Azerbaijanis don't barbarically loot territories, do not still personal belongings of Armenians, instead Azerbaijanis offered Armenia peace, economic cooperation, and rebuild Karabakh. Armenians proved that they are failed state. They only capable to steel houses of the Azerbaijanis.
Anti armenian policy? I case you forgot, let me remind you how Armenians kicked out the Azeris from Karabakh back in 1992? How you stole Azeri homes and belongings? You should be happy that they at least allow you to evacuate and take your belongings, when Armenian land occupiers, are running from the sinking boat.
@user-xs8vr5yr4z yes, and Azeris didnt steal houses of Armenians in Nakhchivan? Lol That failed state Armenia, without petrol, still has a higher GDP per capita PPP than Azerbaijan.
What revolution? Like revolution Armenians have ? Did it help you? Did you end occupation? It was Armenians who started this war and people remember that.its not matter of goverment
@@user-xs8vr5yr4zcompletely untrue. Artsakh has been historically Armenian, but legally it belongs to Azerbaijan only because Stalin drew the borders that way. You can think of it as a gift. The same happened with Nakhchivan, which also has always been Armenian historically, but was gifted to Azerbaijan during USSR
Arte has made a very biased report. This news does not comply with ethical standards. I condemn Arte for this biased coverage. The people are justifiably very happy about this victory. The pains experienced have not been forgotten for 30 years. It remains as a trauma in the memory of those people. May Azerbaijan’s victory be blessed. May they live in peace forever.
No that isn't why. People forgot because in this conflict civilians weren't being massacred and nothing insane was going on like in Palestine. These two nations fought HUGEEE war and something like 27 civilians died. More civilians than that die in Gaza every 12 seconds. Hell in the time it took me to write this post probably 40 kids have been murdered in Gaza. That gets people's attention.
@@manotenkerian Since 1050 Selcuklu time your nation have been living under Great Turkish Nation . Selcuklu, Ottoman, Timurid, Akkoyunlu, Karakoyunlu Safavid, Afshar , Qacar
@empirehistory4055 what does that have to do with my statement of turkey illegally occupying cyprus? Yes I'm aware of the ottoman empire and Azerbaijan was iranian /persian province
Be back for illegal invasions and the brutal ethnic cleansing of 850,000 civilians again? Is that what you're getting at? A promise of genocide and war crimes? When are you guys going to learn how to get along with your neighbors and stop fantasizing about murdering them?
You will run out of people if you keep dreaming about occupying other people’s land. How about you take 2020 and 2023 as a sign that maybe you should focus on your own borders?
Hidup Azerbaijan 🇦🇿. Jangan biarkan pencuri mengambil tanah anda. Dunia internasional mengakui Nagorno Karabakh adalah milik kalian, selamanya. Selamat.
When Azerbaijanians speak, there was no translation or wrong. Speaking like that is double standarts from Europe to Azerbaijan. As an Azerbaijani i did not like this reportage
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
There are no good guys in this story. Armenia, Azerbaijan, Russia and Turkey are all WITHOUT EXCEPTION far-right fascist regimes. They are all light-years away from being normal countries. That said, the civilian ethnic Armenians are the ONLY indigenous population in this entire region. The modern-day ethnic Armenian civilians are the last remaining survivors of centuries of attempts to eradicate them. And yet, miraculously, some of them are still alive and still having babies. And in a tiny, remote corner of their ancestral homeland, they even have tiny independent rump state (de facto a Russian colony). But obviously no fascist regime is ever gonna care about the plight of any indigenous peoples. And since the Armenians sided with fascist Putin, nobody in the Democratic World is gonna support them. So the Armenians are left to fend for themselves. It's a situation very similar to the civilans trapped inside Gaza right now.
Your comparison of the situation to Gazza is completely incorrect aside from your lack of knowledge of the regional history. If anything, it’s comparable to Israel actually. Because Karabakh was an occupied Azeri land which was mainly supported by Armenian diaspora financially and emotionally. It’s not my opinion. Armenians were always talking about their ambition for having an Israel look alike statehood in Karabakh.
Who???WORLD WAR1..WORLD WAR 2 who started it??yes,SO CALLED CIVILISATE EUROPE!!who did HOLOCOUST?yes,so called DEMOCRATIC EUROPE!!who killed innocint people in bosnia SBRENITA??yes,so called democratic europe!!who is killing innocint people in gaza??yes,same europe!! Because the MEDIA is in the hands of western countries,so keep lying and doing propagani for them(europe!!) So called civilisate EUROPEAN COUNTRIES GOT BLOOD ON THEIRE HANDS!!!
Don't fall for the propaganda. Armenians have lived in that land for thousands of years until Turkish Ottoman forces invaded their lands... what happened here was ethnic cleansing
@@ianwatson194 european blablabla propaganda!!armenian diaspora lives in health(france-usa)and they are puppets of tbat countries!!but armenians are suffering!!all because they follow france-usa intres politics!!
ethnic cleansing happened when hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis were forced out of their lands by Armenian separatists. What is happening now is called justice.@@ianwatson194
Do you want to know the most ridiculous thing? A 100 year old country claims this is all Azerbaijani. Again , a 100 year old atficial state created by Vladimir Lenin claims a 2000 years old Armenia occupied Azerbaijani territory.
So this is how you justify one nation illegally invading their neighbor's internationally recognized territory and ethnically cleansing 850,000 civilians? Good luck with that argument anywhere outside of an echo chamber.
@suleymantagiyev6175 ok, I know that. It is only a PART of history. How long did that last? 89 years. Only 89 years! It's a drop in the ocean of the history of the region.
I have only begun watching the documentary but let me say that Nagorno Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan, entirely. Just as Israel belongs to Palestine entirely. And no, am not a Muslim. And I dislike Islam with a passion.
@@bobbybannerjee5156 Yes the dictator Stalin gave them the land but the Armenian's was the indegenes people there and the Azeri Turks tried to ethnically cleans the region many times. But in September they managed to force the Indigenes Armenians away. The Armenians have been there for 1000s of years and It's only Azerbaijan who deny this. To bad for Azebaijan that the Armenian presence is documented by both the Persian, Greek, Arabs and of caurse the European's.
Heartiest congratulations from Bangladesh to Azerbaijan for historic victory and restoration of sovereignty over Karabakh.
Palestin is not stopped yet it will continue ... U have to continue crying after few days
Thank you!
Chank you
@@yesssboss2219 So you're enjoying watching women and children get bombed on a scale earth hasn't seen since ww2?
Is that what you're telling us?
Thankfully the Azeris aren't as barbaric as you and didn't behave that way in victory.
Alhamdulilah.
Palestina children world human people save help. 😪💔😔
This is absurd! Armenia (regardless of religion) occupied 20% of the neighboring country, kicked out 700k native population and held it illegally for 30 years! After 30 years of patience and fruitless diplomatic efforts Azerbaijan freed its internationally recognized territories. What else is there to discuss?
I mean now Azerbaijan doing the same so?
@@danbaltic9678что делает тоже самое? Что Азербайджан окупировал 20% территории армении? Или провёл этнические чистки как сделали это армяне? Наоборот армянам предложили интегрироватся и принять гражданство Азербайджана, до сих пор можно подать заявку, но в армении этот сайт блокируют, есть много видео кадров как они уходили и как им предлагали остатся, и кто им сказал уходить.
@@danbaltic9678 Nope.
Can u provide ur source of their "diplomatic efforts" that don't include full Azeri integration or taking land? Because that wouldn't be diplomatic efforts that would just be conquest of lands that the natives don't want taken from them. Nobody in Karabakh wanted to be part of Azerbaijan and u can see from the 2 referendums held in karabakh
despite I'm neutral in this conflict, I have to say Arte is very biased. using "the FORCED repopulation policy" regarding the refuges returning back is more than funny. those people had been dreaming about this moment for decades.
Absolutely biased. Werstern media is always like this against any nonewestern country. They are now supporting the genocide against the Palestinians.
What are you rambling about? From 9:94 onward the refugees themselves express dissatisfaction and one of them ask: "why did you bring us here?", the govt. official just laughs at them. Does them wanting to return for decades mean that they are willing to return under less than satisfactory conditions, and not on their own terms? I think not.
@@PrebaaaaaaaaaaaaaaYou don't know the language, She asks why did they bring them while not everything is fully finished and ready. They were not forsed. You are also biased.
@@oguzb.7033 I can only conclude based on the translation I see, and I sure as hell aint gonna trust the translation of some random person over the translation of the people who actually made the documentary. I am biased... why? Because i pointed out something I saw in the doc? In a sense, I am biased - but so are you, and so is everybody else.
@@Prebaaaaaaaaaaaaaa Yes so you believe they are forsed to go, really interesting, i see people freely talking about their ideas and asking for better situation from their government. These areas were destroyed by Armenians for 30 years, of course it will take some time for better situations. Azerbaijan did great job in very short time.
South Azerbaijan is behind you. Love you all from Zanjan 🇦🇿❤️
Azerabadegan jane iran♥️🇮🇷
@@melvinalvandiann nope, we are Turks
@@mahfi-iturki2090 originial turks looks mongoloid
I think this documentary is a little bit biased . I dont think its fair to say these people were forced to live there . I dont believe any Azerbaijani can be forced to live somewhere. Its not North Korea. These people are definitely hard core encouraged to move there but by no means they are forced.
There is nativeland for magrants. They backed their own home
Love for Azerbaijan, From Bangladesh🇧🇩🤝🇦🇿
Thank you
Brining up your children to hate Armenians - is not OK. It is cultivating and spreading hate. It is crime against humanity. No hate is good for any society for any country on any base!!
Armenians have been bringing their children to hate us during Soviet time even when no nationalism was in Azerbaijan. You see it as hate we see it as focusing nation to survive. Armenians shouldn’t have started war. It’s normal that people you attack will hate you
Do you want to say the same about the video that the Jews record against the Palestinians?
@@siroliver9889 I applaud you my friend. It is hilarious that people just judge a book by its cover.
Lol azerbaijanis are pro Palestinian @siroliver9889
@@manotenkerianAzerbaijanis are mostly pro- Israel, actually
Stealing land from the byzantine christians of Anatolia is an old art for the nomads Turks from the steppes of Central Asia
Dude Christians Stole whole continents of Australia and North America , you will conviniently forget that ?
Kamu mecuri tanah Amerika san Australia bqngsat
@@LondonPower Anatolia was occupied by Greeks too. Greeks aren't ethnic in Anatolia
All the best to Azerbaijan. They've suffered a lot. Sending Love from Bangladesh to my Azeri Brothers 🇧🇩♥️🇦🇿.
2 terrorist states are all the same
❤❤❤❤
🇮🇱 🇦🇿
@@TimeisntgoodDon't put our flag next to children k*ller' flag!!
Azerbaijan ain't supporting war and genocide!!
send more love to Azeris because now they are helping Israelis in their fight against Palestine
I am Pakistani and I know how it feels to lose of life especially your beloved one. I am also currently living in Azerbaijan which is prospering very rapidly and at a fast pace. I somewhere encourage Azerbaijani and Armenians to have reconciliation, I know it would be super difficult but it would be important for both to reconcile as there's a quote "Revenge only brings revenge." Hence, forgiveness and respect for both countries should go on and wish Azerbaijan more prosperity
Azerbaijanis are not rational people at all. The idea of reconciling with Armenians is completely taboo for them. Maybe the next generation of Azerbaijanis could bring hope but I've lost all faith for the current generation.
The children are thought to ‚kill Armenians‘. Sad…
If that were true why weren't the civilians slaughtered during this conflict. The Azeris literally behaved in the exact opposite fashion to how the Armenians behaved when they conquered this region in the 1990s and ethnically cleansed 850,000 civilians, brutally so.
Facts>Your feelings. What is sad is your detachment from reality.
@@williamdavis9562there are literal footages of Azeris targeting Karabakh civilians and children, wheres your footage? Stop lying when u dont have proof to back those lies up
Preschool Videos in Azerbaijan, show Azeri children being taught to hate Armenians.
I don't think anyone will believe your crocodile tears after remaining silent about the deaths of tens of thousands of children in Palestine.
armenians children also say "kill Azerbaijanians"
Azerbaijan just returned their own native lands, n never told armenians in Karabakh to leave Karabakh part, armenians of Karabakh may return whenever they want, only under Azerbaijani passports
ARMENIA: occupies, ethnically cleanses and destroys Azerbaijani territories.
ALSO ARMENIA: "Why does Azerbaijan hate us? "
Azerbaijan is a Persian territory that needs to be returned to Persia. Artsakh is Armenian. these are historical facts.
@@tryyourselff 🤣🤣🤣 are you trying to divorce Azerbaijan from Persian history🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣@@tryyourselff 🤣🤣🤣🤣 how can i search the non existant history of Azerbaijan. My Family Bible from 1896 is older.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣@@tryyourselff there is a reason why Azeri Turks are SHIA instead of the usual SUNNI and that is no accident, which is proof religion and linguistic realities cannot be faked like the fabricated statehood that is known as "azerbaijan" is really is a PERSIAN province and it belongs there. If we learned anything in 2023, that militarily solutions can n restore the northern province back to IRAN proper.🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@eric6616 I have no horse in this race but it is a lot easier to make the argument that North Iran is actually South Azerbaijan.
Good job Azerbaijan!
100%
Territorial conquest? it is called the liberation and deoccupation by the international law, by the logic and a common sense.
Armenians have been a big majority in that area for over a thousand years (longer then the Turks). Maybe you should look up Turkish history (which is the same as Azeri since they are the same people). Then you will find out that the Turks came from the steppe of which is now South East Russia, and conquered their way to Anatolia. Armenians have lived in that area long before the Turks even thought of going West. About international recognized territories you're right, about fairness totally not.
@@Sandor7698 You should realize that international law doesn't recognize your subjective view of who should own what based on events from 1000s of years ago.
If international law worked like that 90% of the planet would have to relocate. There was a point in time where everyone decided that these borders are the internationally recognized borders, any nation which is part of the UN signed on that dotted line so these ridiculous wars of "oh this land is mine because of 1000 years ago" and people slaughtering each other non stop would end.
The fact is you can't simply start invading another nation's internationally recognized territory, ethnically cleanse 850,000 civilians and then pretend to be the side of morality. It doesn't work like that.
@@williamdavis9562 the Armenians in Nagorno Karabakh didn't invade the region, they simply have always lived there, and were always a majority. Now they have been successfully ethnically cleansed out of the region by Azerbaijan, just like the Turks ethnicly cleansed Greeks and Armenians out of Anatolia.
Then tell me, if 98.8% voted for independance from the authoritarian regime of Azerbaijan would it then be called liberation? If 100 procent of the people don't want Azeri government there how could u call it liberation and reoccupation when the people actively ran away from aliyev, it's like a murder victim running away from a murderer, but the murderer catches him and murders him, but then he is called a hero for saving the victims life? When he is litterly dead on the ground. That's what's happening with the nagarno Karabakh situation rn, I'd suggest doing independant research and to not look at Armenian or Azeri (biased) (made) stories but rather at independant studies from for example Americans or British or Dutch or German. A lot of them will teach u about the real history
@@Sandor7698okay about karabakh but why didn't armenia returned the regions around karabakh for 30 years? they wanted the status quo to remain forever
I am sad seeing how people cannot live together, and this leading to people being dislocated from their homes and suffering hardships. The Azris fled many years ago, now the Armenians fled. A lot of suffering for both communities and inter-ethnic hate that will lead to further conflicts. The only solution to peace would be the promotion of understanding between the two communities.
Не надо было окупировать территории Азербайджана, и все жили бы счастливо, а армян никто не выгонял они сами ушли, наоборот им предлагали остатся и принять гражданство Азербайджана, но они отказались, может они испугались того что много гадостей натворили.
@@ayaz11288 how do u explain the 99.8% referendum then? Why would sooo many people want independance if nothing was going on? I doubt that 99.8% were ultra Armenian nationalists that wanted to topple the Azeri government.
@@ayaz11288 the progroms you comitted said differently. The people of Karabakh voted. twice. They wanted to join their ethnic homeland to Armenia. You refused, and carried out progroms. We revolted. Simple as that.
Viva Azerbaijan 🇦🇿
It's a tragedy the Armenian government sat and watched Azerbaijan grow strong militarily not doing anything. Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh got sold out by their fellow Armenians.
and Russia
Corruption, corruption, my friend. Before our current PM, all of them were Russophiles and oligarchs, filling up their pockets with the country's money.
7:24 .. just checking Wikipedia-- looks like it was taken back by AZERBAIJAN in 2020, they said it wrong
What a condescending bias tearfilled jealous so-called report….congratulations to the victorious Azerbaijanis, Allah has blessed you to come back to your rightful home and it’s now your responsibility to take care of both Azeris and the remaining Armenian civilians as one exemplary community Inshallah.
Peace and love from Somalia 🇸🇴
Of course ARTE has to be biased. They called it “territorial conquest”!! It’s not a conquest it’s reclaiming their territory and returning back! Come on now!
I agree that's why northern cyprus is illegal
@@manotenkerian When Cyprus declared its independence from Britain, Britain, Turkiye and Greece were granted guarantorship of the Island. These three were given the responsibility to maintain the equality between two societies. Cyprus was founded as a binational state where president was Greek and the prime minister was Turkish. The state mechanism was equally shared by two ethnicities. However, with a coup d'etat, Greeks tried enosis (annexation) with Greece. Without consent of Turks, they tried capture the state, cast out all Turks in the state mechanism and made it into a Hellenic state. Greeks tried to downgrade Turks from equal owners of the state to a minority. That was illegal.
Since then Greeks never accepted a shared state, they proposed a minority status for Turks. Turks will not accept minority status, they will not let Cyprus to be turned into a Greek state and live under Greek authority. Turkish intervention and military presence in the island is to protect Turks of the island. Those who talk about Solution in Cyprus should stop supporting Greek side unilaterally, surrender rights of Turks as founders and equal owners of the state. Otherwise, nothing will be solved. Eventually isolated and unrecognized Turks will have to unite with Turkiye. Look, Turks wait for recognition for forty years. If Turks did not really look forward to solution and a real reunification of the island, they could unite with Turkiye long time ago. In any case Turkiye is seen as "occupant", in one way or another. Cyrpiot Turks would have get rid of isolation by uniting Turkiye. But they still wait.
Three options:
1-Recognize Turks as equal owners of the state, share power and go on as a binational federative state.
2-Recognize Turkish state internationally.That will strengthen Turkish hands in bargaining for powersharing and federation, if not possible, they will go on as an independent state.
3-After so many years of isolation and sanctions, Turks'only remedy will be annexed by Turkiye.
Reminder: As an Armenian you are no way entitled to form a view on Cyprus, especially after your nation invaded 20% of another country and while you have no idea about Cyprus issue. Do not poke your Armenian nose into things you do not know about. Just work for Armenia to develop and prosper. Armenia will not develop with anti-Turk stance and expansionism.
@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 as a turk you have no opinion on Armenian affairs. Look what you wrote : "armenians occupied 20 percent of azeri land" meanwhile , turks occupying 20 percent of greek cyprus land is okay?
Did you know nagarno karabach in soviet times was an oblast ?
Did you know after armenia gained independence from usssr, nagarno karabach followed ? If it was apart of Azerbaijan then why did nagarno karabach leave user before Azerbaijan succeeded? Don't be a hypocrite
@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 also, why doesnt any of your turkic brother nations or your fellow Islamic nations recognize north cyprus? It's seems like your anti Christian
@nadirhikmetkuleli7335 one last thing! FREE KURDISTAN
It's horrible, and worse, it's forgotten
At 7:26, You meant taken back by the Azeri. And I am not sure why you keep refering to the Aeri Governmebt as the "Regime"!!!. The Azeri goverment is using the OIL and Gas money to REBUILD the Liberated towns and Cities...
They are Western. Of course, they are our enemies.
Because the world is on the side of the native inhabitants. From USA. Dont know a single Armenian or your people but its riduculous you get nakchavan and Armenia can't have a smaller closer to their border ancient land
Do u think the Armenian inhabitants destroyed the region for 30 years straight when THEY LIVE THERE? Seems kinda like a dumb move if I was an Armenian living there, in contrast Azerbaijan did destroy Armenian historical sites that were thousands of years old in nakhijevan. Seems kind of strange that Azeris are willing to hide that fact tho.
Azeris are hypocrites and the sooner they realise that the sooner they will realise the truth.
Also Azerbaijan is on fact an authoritarian regime it is proven by multiple sources and the way their government is handled is an autocracy, handled by an autocrat / close to a dictator
Especially for those illiterate people who think that Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) or Nakhichevan is azerbaijan it is not true, these regions were transferred to azerbaijan during the time of lenin and stalin, but in fact this had been Armenian land since the beginning of time🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲 azerbaijan is artificial country created on Armenian and Persian lands
No one cares who or when it was transferred. Azerbaijan won, either accept it or continue living in your own bubble.
Fake information. Absolutely
Azerbaijan has Guranteed protection and equality under the law to the Armenian population of Azerbaijan. They rejected it and left for Armenia. No ethnic cleansing or Genocide. Civilians were not harmed. President Aliev is a mature and balanced humanitarian leader in the region. I hope my Iranian family in Tehran will not fuel tensions in this volatile area of the world.
I definitely support Azerbaijan on this conflict BUT why would any Armenian trust the promise of protection and equality claims of Azerbaijan? Same would apply if the sides switched. They have done both to each other in this conflict (even though ultimately azeri side was right) to never trust a member of their nations ever again. Both nations are fully capable of doing the lip service and continue oppressing the other because the level of animosity between the nations is very high.
Also, Azerbaijan for sure would populate the land with Azeris to diminish any future war and revolt and those people could also very well harass Armenians. If this was the start of the conflict, peaceful coexistence could have worked but honestly it is all too late for that, so I understand why they feel compelled to leave.
Biased and unprofessional reporting .
Aliev is a dicator he often said that armenia ist west azerbaidjan
@@Phantom-xw1hu Correct He is a dictator, karabakh is Azerbaijan. Armenian population must live under Azerbaijani rule in karabakh or go to Armenia.
@@NewDayMedia.And Azerbaijan is just northern iran
The UN states that Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast is a disputed region that has the right to self-determination, the surrounding regions are considered occupied. The UN states there is no military solution to this conflict and the OSCE Minsk Group Protocol Protocol will be used for negotiations and a resolution to this conflict.
Now don't try to start quoting outdated UN resolutions before the war ended, weren't binding, or had little votes supporting the resolutions.
If the surrounding regions were very important, then Azerbaijan could have recognized the independence of NKAO with a corridor to Armenia for them returned
The whole point of Azerbaijan is the erdication of Armenia. We can see it everyday by its unfriendly attitude against Armenia, eventhough they took the whole Karabakh region.
Azeris "reclaimed" their land with weapons brought from Israel 😂😂 settlers recognise settlers
We got there by our Army you a..hole
You're must be a real genius. Those lands are internationally recognized by Azerbaijan and except the Karabagh, the Azerbaijani majority lived in all other 7 territories. They buy weapons from multiple countries, such as Russia, Turkey, Pakistan etc... NOT just Israel. And Israel support for Azerbaijan is because of common threat of Iran.
We stay winning and you stay hatin‼️🗣️
@@INeatFreak All 7 territories, not Karabakh. The Armenians offered numerous times to cede these 7 regions, in exchange for the recognition of the Karabakh people's right to decide for themselves. These people voted twice to be independant, you refused this vote twice, and carried out progroms. Those 7 territories are not Karabakh.
@@ArmeniaMikoand Azerbaijan still won the conflict. Do you have a point to make? It's all recognized as Azerbaijani territory.
Two things that make me so happy, one is to see Azeris start going back to their homes and the other is to see Aliyev walk over and step on the fascist Armenian/Arztak flag 🙂
Can u explain to me what fascism is? Because if u call a country fascist without even knowing what it is then I don't think u should have the mental capacity to enter debates
@@somerandomduud4086 he is a retarded turk, what do you expect of him
@@somerandomduud4086 armenians had fascist organization "tsekhakron" which commited unimaginable genocides against jews and azerbaijanis
Nagorno Karabah🇦🇲🇦🇲🇦🇲
@@ilas9385 COPE
God bless Azerbaijan
Bais report even from the language. “Armenian forces advanced” but “Azeris occupied” total rubbish
The land returned to its owners with ease. Why are you sad about it?
Bceuase it was never Azeri
@@sta255_give it back to Russia then, it was never Armenian either.
Translating & subitres from azerbaijani wrong seems like proarmenian reportage. Shame on you!!!!!
I remember our family always going to karabakh every summer. Now its all just a memory. I know ill never go back, but im glad i got a glimpse of its views...
nice propganda which politic you follow^^
@@leienhartbo3377 propaganda is armenians' job
Unacceptable. The Azerbaijan has no right to invade
@@AYYILDIZ1912 that's the past. Worry about the now beside Azerbaijan also has blood on their hand I'm history as well
Lol what karabakh is Azerbaijan
"Unacceptable"? The world can only tell you to know your place.
@@sphyxiation careful, that could cause an uprising
Armenia has no right to invade. It's azerbaijani land
Obviously and apparently clear that narrator espressing his Anti-Azerbaijanian position by saying "Azeri Regime" it sounds like he is comparing our country with Saddam's Regime, hypocrites...
Azeri lies are limitless……..
They are closer to the truth more than Armenian lies.
@@nadirhikmetkulelihow exactly?
That Right: Azeri lies are proven to be limitless, repeatedly ...
@@nadirhikmetkuleli no, they aren't, like they quite literally aren't i dont know how ur brain came to that conclusion. Like what have u been reading to come to that conclusion, I know it wasn't actual non biased research. Like man how does one even believe such a thing
What is a lie? The fact that nearly a million Azerbaijanis were forcibly expelled from their homeland? That Karabakh, which is Azerbaijani territory according to international law, remained under Armenian occupation for 30 years? Khojaly massacre?
Karabakh, Shaumyan, Gandzak, Naxchevan is Armenian Land 🇦🇲
You will run out of people before you realize that irredentism will get you nowhere. We both got our internationally recognized territories, how about we finally live in peace for our kids?
You are silent that for 30 years Armenia and the separate regime in Karabakh occupied Azerbaijani lands, we returned ours at the cost of our blood and the lives of our soldiers
Good side is that Azerbaijan didn't kill any Armenian civilians and didn't do any Genocide 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
So ,,,do you guys belive it ? 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I guess both sides did what they could to kill each other,,
When people will learn to live in peace ✌️
Red cross organization visited to Azerbaijan there was not any genocide and dead civilian
Azerbajian is a wealthy country. Why did they let refugees live in deplorable conditions for 30 years.
There were around 900000 refugee after war. Azerbaijan started selling oil and gas from 2000 approximately. You can't imagine how hard times it was.
Long live Azerbaijani 🇦🇿
I am glad that Azerbaijan regains it national territory of Ngorno-Karabakh. I was all on the side of Azerbaijan during its war to regain Nagorno Karabakh. Karabakh is an internationally recognized part of Azaerbaijan & should be reintegrated into Azerbaijan. However, I will immediately side wit Armenia if Azerbaijan launches a war to seize even an inch of territory that belong2 to Armenia proper. I will be on the side of Armenia if Azerbaijan tries to seize Syunik province from Armenia to create the Zangezour Corridor with Nakhichevan. I am Muslim, just like Azerbaijan, but I do not judge based on religion but on justice. ! will not accept injustice by non-Muslims on Muslims, and I will not accept injustice by Muslims on non-Muslims.
There is no big difference between Nazi Germany capturing Sudetenland and Armenia capturing Karabakh. German aggression was punished by land loss and contribution payments, but Armenian aggression remains unpunished. Azerbaijan has all rights to enforce Armenian commitment signed on November 9, 2020 to ensure unobstructed communication from Azerbaijan to Azerbaijan (Nakchivan) through Armenian territory.
Why isn't armenia or Azerbaijan doing anything?
Congrats you are on the side of terrorism. Nagorno-Karabakh was always Armenian majority and the people wanted to live there peacefully. You support the side that didn't let this happen!
Even though i side with Armenia and Artsakg in this conflict I respect your opinion,
You are a lot better than the Azeris that are hypocrites saying that Armenia cant have an inch of their land but Azerbaijan can. And for that I respect your opinion
🤝
We restored our historical lands. Thats it. No one can claim this lands are belong to armenia.
6:48 Such barbarism :((
He is saying I will kill my enemies, they translated wrong
@@Kafeinsiz_Kahve Don't lie. I'm Turkish. And no child should ever say something like that anyway.
@@i.k.8868you turkish??just because you got turkish passport??first be human and if you young and dont know what happend before...watch HOXALI ,and see what they (armenians)did to them!!
Turkey will pay for it heavily ... I dont how but it will be worst they can imagine ... Its already cursed by god
@@i.k.8868senin gibi türkün ben amk
Thanks Azerbaijan forces for liberating the land and handover to real owner.
Artsakh is Armenian
In 50 years Armenians will say the same. Its a wheel that turns.
I don't think so. If in 50 years armenians decide to reconquer lands internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan, they will need to officially attack from the territory of the republic of Armenia, which in this case will be international conflict. Till now it was defacto war was between Azerbaijan and Armenia, but on the paper it was an internal conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenian backed separatist of Nagorno Karabakh. Something similiar what was happening in Ukraine till 2022, defacto Ukraine was at war with Russia from 2014, but on the paper till 2022 it was an internal conflict, Ukraine fought against Russian backed separatists in Donetsk and Lugansk.
In 50 years the will be no Armenia.
as was commented that would now be an international conflict and would be valid grounds for Turkey to also active partake in this war. Armenians should focus on developing their country and economy to attract the Armenian diaspora to repatriate if they want to have any future in the region, instead of chasing after impossible dreams in the region and yelling war crime every single time it doesn't go the way they want in a conflict they themselves have started.
@@Ceylin_Kurtbogan Between now and 60 years, a lot will change...even the strengths of the strong and the weaknesses of the weak might change...
The few marijuana plants were a serious border security risk to Azerbaijan.
Best soldiers are Turk soldiers. Not targetting civilians. 🇦🇿🇹🇷
with this logic Crimea and other areas returned to Russia, kudos to Russia and Kosovo is Serbia !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Разве кто-то сомневается, что Крым не принадлежит России? ☝☝☝
good to see border problem is solved, wish to see Palestine get their independent
you praised the muslim genocide over the oldest christian population
@@mapachepataki5013 Dude? Do you know how many countries the British colonized and killed hundreds of millions of people? It's Christian. Before the Armenians, there were people who were killed by the Armenians in the same way as the Jews of the Canaanites. Armenia recouped this territory by expelling Azerbaijanis, hundreds of thousands, women and children walked through the snow in winter for a thousand kilometers and died. Now these children have returned and not to say that they have taken revenge for what they did.
Ironic you support Armenian genocide then claim Palestinians being genocide 😂
That land belongs to Armenians
Ni
No
Land mines are biggest problems after wars.
Since a reporter is French his negative attitude to Azerbaijan is obvious.
Long live Azerbaijan you are hero!!!
You say that because otherwise you get in trouble with daddy Aliyev
@@dutchskyrimgamer.youtube2748 why ?? )) i dont have any problem!! )
Позор, все азербайджанцы возвращаются на земли исконно армянские, армян жить с головорезами не будут
When EU will stop buying gas and oil from Azers...?
Never, the EU do not care
EU is depend on Azerbaijani gas and oil.
see history of Artsakh (Karabakh). Artsakh was never part of Azerbaijan Nakhijevan. During the USSR they signed and gave it to Azerbaijan. Now there is no USSR, it has been destroyed and these signatures have also been destroyed! Azerbaijan History as a State 100 years! I do not accept this decision, supposedly Artsakh is part of Azerbaijan if it is part of Azerbaijan and Azerbaijan is part of Iran!!!!
Then why does International Law recognize Karabakh as Azerbaijani territory? Don't you think it matters? For example, why don't you say what you said about Abkhazia, Ossetia and other regions?
Fake lie informations.
@@Khacmaz_edits For example!!!!? I repeat once again Azerbaijan There is no such Nation and in general there was no Country and in general you will not find it anywhere! Azerbaijan is a province of Iran!!! Tatars became Azeris!!? Is this what you wanted to hear? Even now Azerbaijan as a country is in question! You are also a Tatar, your grandfather was also a Tatar, what kind of Azeris??? And about Karabakh, this has no connection with Azerbaijan! Karabakh is purely Armenian land up to the border of Syria, you live in those lands that have no spiritual or cultural connection with you!
@@artconstructioncorp.7261 we aren't tatar. Russian empire was calling "Caucasian Tatars" to us. Did u search about this conflict with pro-armenian propaganda media?
@ The history of Azerbaijan is understood as the history of the region now forming the Republic of Azerbaijan. Topographically, the land is contained by the southern slopes of the Caucasus Mountains in the north, the Caspian Sea in the east, and the Armenian Highlands in the west. In the south, its natural boundaries are less distinct, and here the country merges with the Iranian Plateau.[1]
The entity of Caucasian Albania was established on its soil in ancient times. The Caucasian Albanian language spoken by the founders of Caucasian Albania was most likely a predecessor of the now endangered Udi language spoken by the Udi people. From the time of the Medes and the Achaemenid Empire, until the coming of the Russians in the 19th century, the territories of the republic of Azerbaijan and Iran have usually shared the same history.[2][1][3] Azerbaijan retained its Iranian character even after the Arab conquest of Iran and the conversion of the area's inhabitants to Islam.[1] Some four centuries later, Oghuz Turkic tribes under the Seljuq dynasty entered the area, and Azerbaijan gained a large amount of Turkic inhabitants.[1] Over the centuries, as the original population mingled with the immigrant Turkic nomads, the number of native Persian speakers gradually diminished, and a Turkic dialect nowadays known as Azerbaijani (or Azeri Turkic) gained hold.[1]
7:26 taken by by the Azeris, you meant to say.
Это деоккупация и освобождение а не захват арела в Гарабаге автор !!
Please make a documentary about the Corse island where the majority of it's people don't like to be the part of France.
Yada Fransanın içinde amma fransanı sevmeyen Monako krallığı haqında bir film
We have forwarded your suggestion to our editorial team.
@@artetvdocumentary Thanks and if it's possible another documentary about the Alegerean genecide which was done by the French. I am sure they know more than 1 million people were killed by French. Please forward my second message to then.
Merci et bon nuit mon amie 🤣👍
@@novruzefendi-yev9753 Monaco bir ülkedir, çok da zengin amma Kors adası Fransanın bir parçasıdır.
Monako müstəqil ölkədir, lakin Korse adası Aralıq dənizində yerləşir və xalqı öz ölkəsinə sahib olmaq istəyir.
Fransız mediyası siz Afrikadakı teroriziminzdən, genosiddən danışın!!! Siz Aqressor ölkəsisiz.!!! ARTE-tv fransanın afrikadakı qenosidindən reportaj hazırlasa yaxşı olardı!!! YAŞASIN AZƏRBAYCAN 🇦🇿
Don't interview Azeris, that country is doing a 21st Century Armenian Genocide Project, a Century after the 20th Century Ottoman Armenian Genocide.
@@ArmenianBishop Red cross organization visited to Azerbaijan. There was no any genocide in Karabakh.
I think it will be hard for Azerbaijan to convince Azeris to leave where they live now and go to the rural mountainous region of Nagorno-Karabakh. They will invest a lot of their petro-money there, but wait 20 years and we will see, that few people will really permanently go to live there. Why, because they prefer urban live along the coast of the Caspian Sea than living as goat herders somewhere far away in the mountains.
The whole Nagorno-Karabakh thing is more a national propaganda myth than a real social movement. The same is true for a lot of revisionist myths around the world. Just imagine that Germany would suddenly get back East Prussia. Do you think a lot of Germans would cherfully move there to make it a German populated region once again? I don't think so.
Did you conduct a survey of Azerbaijani refugees in Baku and Sumqayit to come up with this conclusion?
Azerbaijan will pay the price for this war. We will see
Siktir
Ты кого пугаешь побежденный? Тебе статья светит
Azerbaijan is rightful.
Islamofascists everywhere ✝️
Don't try to put a religious view on this issue. Religion has always been an excuse to carry out the dirty politics of some states.
You should talk about fascism against Azerbaijanis in 1980-90s.
@believeme8614 is that why azerbaijanis cleansed nachchivan of aremnians and all of their churches and holy sites in the 80s?
@@manotenkerian turco propaganda
@@phk1959”A historic fact that does not align with my worldview MUST be Turkic propaganda”
Typical Armenian
There isn't islamofascism in Azerbaijan
We learned our lessons in the past 30 years that we should be strong and depend on only ourselves to bring justice. All western states failed to bring peace to the region by supporting Armenia.
Türkün Türkden başqa dostu yoxdur 🇦🇿🇹🇷
Pakistan, Bangladeş te Azarbaycan'ı destekledi. Ama onlar Türk değil. Ama Türk olan Kazakistan ve diğer Türki Cumhuriyetler Pakistan gibi açıktan destek veremediler. O nedenle "Türkün Türkten başka dostu yoktur" cümlesi gerçek değil. Gerçek olan Müslüman kardeşliğidir.
Good Job Azerbaijan. Greetz from Brotherstate Türkiye...
Free the illegal occupation of North cyprus
I love Armenia
I was interested in watching this until the narrator said "propaganda or reality it's impossible to verify" pertaining to the Marijauna fields.
All the plants and fields are right there, verifying would be quite easy. Just walk over and look at them, smell them lol
WTF is this.
Glad to see the Azeris who can now go back their home
Love from Bangladesh ❤
as an armenian i barely believe that azerbaijan will stop its ani-armenian policy. karabagh was the first step. i do hope for the revolution in baku.
Don't compare Azerbaijanis with Armenia. It was Armenia that occupied Karabakh and after that 7 regions of Azerbaijan, and claimed that those 7 regions, which was equal to the territory of Nagorno-Karabakh itself, as buffer territory so called "Security belt" and then Armenia added these regions later to the so-called "NKR" along with ethnic cleansing of the 700 thousands of Azerbaijanis. Now Armenia expects that Azerbaijan will do the same. Azerbaijanis are not Armenians. Azerbaijanis don't barbarically loot territories, do not still personal belongings of Armenians, instead Azerbaijanis offered Armenia peace, economic cooperation, and rebuild Karabakh. Armenians proved that they are failed state. They only capable to steel houses of the Azerbaijanis.
Anti armenian policy? I case you forgot, let me remind you how Armenians kicked out the Azeris from Karabakh back in 1992? How you stole Azeri homes and belongings? You should be happy that they at least allow you to evacuate and take your belongings, when Armenian land occupiers, are running from the sinking boat.
@user-xs8vr5yr4z yes, and Azeris didnt steal houses of Armenians in Nakhchivan? Lol
That failed state Armenia, without petrol, still has a higher GDP per capita PPP than Azerbaijan.
What revolution? Like revolution Armenians have ? Did it help you? Did you end occupation? It was Armenians who started this war and people remember that.its not matter of goverment
@@user-xs8vr5yr4zcompletely untrue. Artsakh has been historically Armenian, but legally it belongs to Azerbaijan only because Stalin drew the borders that way. You can think of it as a gift. The same happened with Nakhchivan, which also has always been Armenian historically, but was gifted to Azerbaijan during USSR
Arte has made a very biased report. This news does not comply with ethical standards. I condemn Arte for this biased coverage. The people are justifiably very happy about this victory. The pains experienced have not been forgotten for 30 years. It remains as a trauma in the memory of those people. May Azerbaijan’s victory be blessed. May they live in peace forever.
At 10:05 she cracks me up with "what if it rains , it seems like the house will fall down " lol 😆 😅 😂
44
Safe return Azerbaijan
🇦🇿❤️🇹🇷
semoga bumi damai secepatnya. amin
remember them? guess the whole israeli palestinian thing made everyone forget.
No that isn't why.
People forgot because in this conflict civilians weren't being massacred and nothing insane was going on like in Palestine.
These two nations fought HUGEEE war and something like 27 civilians died.
More civilians than that die in Gaza every 12 seconds. Hell in the time it took me to write this post probably 40 kids have been murdered in Gaza. That gets people's attention.
i stand with armenia
No one cares your opinion 😂
that's fair.
you can stand, sit or squad with armenia, as much as you want, as long it is outside of internationally recognized Azerbaijani borders
@@rkn3zdesign yes you stand with armenia that recognise it as Azerbaijani land
Congratulations to Azerbaijani brothers from Kazakhstan!
🇦🇲
Azerbaiyan out of armenia!!!!!!!!!!!
KARABAGH is AZERBAIJAN : END OF THE STORY
Exactly and the northern turkish Republic of cyprus is all of greek cyprus
@@manotenkerian Since 1050 Selcuklu time your nation have been living under Great Turkish Nation . Selcuklu, Ottoman, Timurid, Akkoyunlu, Karakoyunlu Safavid, Afshar , Qacar
@empirehistory4055 what does that have to do with my statement of turkey illegally occupying cyprus? Yes I'm aware of the ottoman empire and Azerbaijan was iranian /persian province
Again the Kojaly lies. ? Azery lies They killed their ow people.
@@eddemian Prove it.
We will be back mongolian persians
Says the armenian terminator coming from the future
Be back for illegal invasions and the brutal ethnic cleansing of 850,000 civilians again?
Is that what you're getting at? A promise of genocide and war crimes? When are you guys going to learn how to get along with your neighbors and stop fantasizing about murdering them?
You will run out of people if you keep dreaming about occupying other people’s land. How about you take 2020 and 2023 as a sign that maybe you should focus on your own borders?
Hidup Azerbaijan 🇦🇿. Jangan biarkan pencuri mengambil tanah anda. Dunia internasional mengakui Nagorno Karabakh adalah milik kalian, selamanya. Selamat.
When Azerbaijanians speak, there was no translation or wrong. Speaking like that is double standarts from Europe to Azerbaijan. As an Azerbaijani i did not like this reportage
Thank you for your comment. We're constantly working to improve our translations, please do specify (with timestamps, if possible) any potential errors. Thank you!
@@artetvdocumentary thank you for feedback
There are no good guys in this story. Armenia, Azerbaijan, Russia and Turkey are all WITHOUT EXCEPTION far-right fascist regimes. They are all light-years away from being normal countries.
That said, the civilian ethnic Armenians are the ONLY indigenous population in this entire region. The modern-day ethnic Armenian civilians are the last remaining survivors of centuries of attempts to eradicate them. And yet, miraculously, some of them are still alive and still having babies. And in a tiny, remote corner of their ancestral homeland, they even have tiny independent rump state (de facto a Russian colony). But obviously no fascist regime is ever gonna care about the plight of any indigenous peoples. And since the Armenians sided with fascist Putin, nobody in the Democratic World is gonna support them. So the Armenians are left to fend for themselves. It's a situation very similar to the civilans trapped inside Gaza right now.
Your comparison of the situation to Gazza is completely incorrect aside from your lack of knowledge of the regional history. If anything, it’s comparable to Israel actually. Because Karabakh was an occupied Azeri land which was mainly supported by Armenian diaspora financially and emotionally. It’s not my opinion. Armenians were always talking about their ambition for having an Israel look alike statehood in Karabakh.
Who???WORLD WAR1..WORLD WAR 2 who started it??yes,SO CALLED CIVILISATE EUROPE!!who did HOLOCOUST?yes,so called DEMOCRATIC EUROPE!!who killed innocint people in bosnia SBRENITA??yes,so called democratic europe!!who is killing innocint people in gaza??yes,same europe!!
Because the MEDIA is in the hands of western countries,so keep lying and doing propagani for them(europe!!)
So called civilisate EUROPEAN COUNTRIES GOT BLOOD ON THEIRE HANDS!!!
Don't fall for the propaganda. Armenians have lived in that land for thousands of years until Turkish Ottoman forces invaded their lands... what happened here was ethnic cleansing
@@ianwatson194 european blablabla propaganda!!armenian diaspora lives in health(france-usa)and they are puppets of tbat countries!!but armenians are suffering!!all because they follow france-usa intres politics!!
ethnic cleansing happened when hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis were forced out of their lands by Armenian separatists. What is happening now is called justice.@@ianwatson194
Documentary by Armenian propoganda.
Сколько угодно говорите, пишите,( Халва) , сладко вам не Будет, Одно Вранье!
Are these turks or iranians ? They speak turkish but look persian . Even the name is azeri persian for fire
What is your point? Let's talk about lots of Arabic words in persian. Then Persians are probably Arabs by your logic.
Azerbaijanis are Turkified iranians yes.
@@plebonhomme6982 iranian is a citizenship name, lol.
Glory to Azerbaijan
Excellent documentary! Thank you
😂😂😂😂 a biased Arte rapportage....
Karabakh is Azerbaijan.
Stop armenian agressor
Do you want to know the most ridiculous thing? A 100 year old country claims this is all Azerbaijani. Again , a 100 year old atficial state created by Vladimir Lenin claims a 2000 years old Armenia occupied Azerbaijani territory.
So this is how you justify one nation illegally invading their neighbor's internationally recognized territory and ethnically cleansing 850,000 civilians?
Good luck with that argument anywhere outside of an echo chamber.
The most rediculous thing is when an ignorant imbecil like you write a BS in youtube, without even checking facts :)
Go and learn about Elguzids
@suleymantagiyev6175 ok, I know that. It is only a PART of history. How long did that last? 89 years. Only 89 years! It's a drop in the ocean of the history of the region.
@@MrOvchiyan how long does your independent armenia under Tigrane the Great Last? :)))
Probably You never heard of subject History
Update on karabakh. How it is now
I have only begun watching the documentary but let me say that Nagorno Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan, entirely. Just as Israel belongs to Palestine entirely.
And no, am not a Muslim. And I dislike Islam with a passion.
Now the Armenian's are native there. The Azeri turks invaded and killed the indegene's non muslim population there. Go read some history...
@@mrworldwide3679 rubbish. It's well inside Azerbaijani land.
Stop making up your history.
@@bobbybannerjee5156 Yes the dictator Stalin gave them the land but the Armenian's was the indegenes people there and the Azeri Turks tried to ethnically cleans the region many times. But in September they managed to force the Indigenes Armenians away. The Armenians have been there for 1000s of years and It's only Azerbaijan who deny this. To bad for Azebaijan that the Armenian presence is documented by both the Persian, Greek, Arabs and of caurse the European's.
Why was "palestine" called judea though?
@@mrworldwide3679 it's Azerbaijani land according to the UN