Nice video Overall, I would consider this a bad ending for America (though admittedly still better than a Totalist CSA, American Caesar USA, or an AUS where Huey Long is overthrown). The MacArthur dictatorship sets a bad precedent for authoritarianism, military interference, and violent suppression of dissent in American politics. The fact that democracy "triumphed" in the end only makes this worse. America may have gotten a Cincinnatus this time, but what's to stop an American Caesar from seizing power and keeping it tomorrow? Even MacArthur himself might change his mind come 1944 or 1948. As for the defeated rebels, those who fought for the CSA or AUS have had everything they fought for stripped away. There will be no relief for the workers of America, who are suffering even worse now due to the war and its aftermath. As for the supporters of the PSA, insult has been added to injury by MacArthur's political shenanigans, and as stated above, they may be proven right in the end. Worse, by abusing the 1917 Sedition Act, voices for reform will have no legal outlet, and as a result, the country will be plagued by terrorism, guerilla insurgencies, and political violence for years to come. Unless conditions dramatically improve in the near future, a third civil war is all but inevitable. Internationally, the situation is no better. The U.S. has made a permanent and spiteful enemy of the Entente, and likely the Internationale as well. Relations with Japan and the Co-Prosperity Sphere are sour, not only because of their support for the PSA, but also because they are in direct competition with the U.S for hegemony in the Pacific. And on top of that, Hawaii joined the Reichspakt, meaning the U.S. can't retake the islands without making an enemy of Germany. No matter how the Second Weltkrieg plays out, the U.S. will find itself facing powerful enemies who would be all too happy to exploit America's political extremism and instability. MacArthur's own aggressive personality will only add fuel to the fire. In short, America faces a dark and troubled future. It is not a matter of if the nation finds itself embroiled in another devastating war, but when. Anyway, these are just my thoughts.
"As you probably know, as a result of the german and their allies victory in the war," He said this so casually I forgot I was watching a kaiserrich video and I had a natural reaction as a WW1 fanatic
I’ve been looking for a constant like this I’m glad somebody is making it. By the way how did you make it? I know you played as the Feds and use observation mode for now Union State and the PSA but did you move the CSA troops onto Long Island or did the AI do that itself?
It's ironic how the Kasierreich timeline almost parallels our very own timeline (likely delaying a potential Civil War by nearly a century), seeing how divided the US has become from 2016 to the present (2023 into 2024). We were close during the 1912 election, seeing how divided the GOP was under Taft & Teddy Roosevelt and how the Far-Left under Wilson led the rise of progressivism (Syndicalism, etc.) that would dominate US politics for most of the 20s to the 30s through WW2 until FDR's agenda showcased how close the US was to transforming the country and voiding the US Constitution.
Not gonna lie, the background music at 19:39 onwards is very subtle compared to your sound that it's almost drive me crazy! Please don't bully your background music like that :(
How much comparison I am seeing between this scenario and my modern country is NOT making me feel secure! (Also, I had no idea you were based out of Ukraine, I hope you're doing well!)
Could we see a AI only playthrough of Kairreich? I think that could be interesting if possible. I'd also be interested in something like that with the New Order: Last Days of Europe, but I would hate to force you to spend money for content.
As great as your narration is, I have a hard time believing the Federalist division wins considering their weak geographic location, with only a small land bridge between the eastern and western halves. It'd be paramount to both the CSA and AUS to cut that off immediately, immediately kneecapping the USA. I know you controlled them to cause them to win, but if I had to guess, it'd either be the AUS and PSA teaming up to take out the CSA after the fall of the USA, or the CSA using their crazy industry and ideological warfare to win via propaganda to working class folks in the other territories.
There have often been unbelievable events in history, but you're right here - as far as I remember my idea in making this video was to make it as absurd as possible within a sort of realistic narrative.
![The Divided States [e01] ~ 'Not in Kansas Anymore' (Stories from the Second American Civil War)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QDCTBDpGCtc/mqdefault.jpg)
We must know more about socialist Iranians, that fought Pacific traitors! Also great video, now I want to experience Kaiserreich yet again
23:55
Socialist Iran declared war on the Dominion of India.
Yes
dude you have such a strong Slavic accent that it makes me smile and the video is really good
Nice video
Overall, I would consider this a bad ending for America (though admittedly still better than a Totalist CSA, American Caesar USA, or an AUS where Huey Long is overthrown).
The MacArthur dictatorship sets a bad precedent for authoritarianism, military interference, and violent suppression of dissent in American politics. The fact that democracy "triumphed" in the end only makes this worse. America may have gotten a Cincinnatus this time, but what's to stop an American Caesar from seizing power and keeping it tomorrow? Even MacArthur himself might change his mind come 1944 or 1948.
As for the defeated rebels, those who fought for the CSA or AUS have had everything they fought for stripped away. There will be no relief for the workers of America, who are suffering even worse now due to the war and its aftermath. As for the supporters of the PSA, insult has been added to injury by MacArthur's political shenanigans, and as stated above, they may be proven right in the end. Worse, by abusing the 1917 Sedition Act, voices for reform will have no legal outlet, and as a result, the country will be plagued by terrorism, guerilla insurgencies, and political violence for years to come. Unless conditions dramatically improve in the near future, a third civil war is all but inevitable.
Internationally, the situation is no better. The U.S. has made a permanent and spiteful enemy of the Entente, and likely the Internationale as well. Relations with Japan and the Co-Prosperity Sphere are sour, not only because of their support for the PSA, but also because they are in direct competition with the U.S for hegemony in the Pacific. And on top of that, Hawaii joined the Reichspakt, meaning the U.S. can't retake the islands without making an enemy of Germany. No matter how the Second Weltkrieg plays out, the U.S. will find itself facing powerful enemies who would be all too happy to exploit America's political extremism and instability. MacArthur's own aggressive personality will only add fuel to the fire.
In short, America faces a dark and troubled future. It is not a matter of if the nation finds itself embroiled in another devastating war, but when.
Anyway, these are just my thoughts.
blah blah blah sthu traitor
Hence why Syndicalists is best ending.
@@flyingsquirrell6953MacArthur stepping down after winning is the best ending
@@BrainrotLover1yes.
im so glad to see your videos getting so many views because you are such a good content creator
Keep up the great work! Your videos are of such a high quality.
This is so uncanny, your game went exactly like mine that I just finished yesterday! Almost everything happened exactly as you described 😀
"As you probably know, as a result of the german and their allies victory in the war," He said this so casually I forgot I was watching a kaiserrich video and I had a natural reaction as a WW1 fanatic
Hallelujah 🎉 🥳 keep it up bro 👍🏻 really hope for part 2
This is a really cool video concept. Maybe make one on how garner saved the Union? Or one of those paths.
Great video man
This will be goo- I already watched it and it was good
Love this type of videos
I will spam "E" so the algorithm picks this amazing video !
I really enjoyed the video!
Love your vids
Keep doing this videos its preety good
Chad mcarthur, saving the US and being a gigachad by resigning his power, truly the most chad US leader ever.
I’ve been looking for a constant like this I’m glad somebody is making it.
By the way how did you make it? I know you played as the Feds and use observation mode for now Union State and the PSA but did you move the CSA troops onto Long Island or did the AI do that itself?
The best video on the civil war we currently have, but only 18k views somehow
It's ironic how the Kasierreich timeline almost parallels our very own timeline (likely delaying a potential Civil War by nearly a century), seeing how divided the US has become from 2016 to the present (2023 into 2024). We were close during the 1912 election, seeing how divided the GOP was under Taft & Teddy Roosevelt and how the Far-Left under Wilson led the rise of progressivism (Syndicalism, etc.) that would dominate US politics for most of the 20s to the 30s through WW2 until FDR's agenda showcased how close the US was to transforming the country and voiding the US Constitution.
no it isn't
Great video as always!
I love alternate history, and you have earned a subscriber today. May I suggest Victoria 3 for more economic scenarios?
Cant believe you let the Canadians get off that easy
Not gonna lie, the background music at 19:39 onwards is very subtle compared to your sound that it's almost drive me crazy! Please don't bully your background music like that :(
IMHO one of the best parties in America, seriously these guys are capable of creating a strong America
You're so underrated
1:10 Is the guy on the far left of the picture mosley?
Get your popcorn!!! 🍿
How much comparison I am seeing between this scenario and my modern country is NOT making me feel secure!
(Also, I had no idea you were based out of Ukraine, I hope you're doing well!)
I definitely see Ireland supporting the federalists and even send in volunteers to fight 21:01 😉🤔
Lore of Second American Civil War in Hoi4 / Kaiserreich / RP storytelling momentum 100
may you tell me where you found the graphs of UK and US exports and imports at the front of the video?
Could we see a AI only playthrough of Kairreich? I think that could be interesting if possible. I'd also be interested in something like that with the New Order: Last Days of Europe, but I would hate to force you to spend money for content.
tno is free?
Man the algorithm is weird he has so few views
Long live General MacArthur
Personally I always prefer Huey Long’s version in these kaiserreich second American civil war.
Down with the traitors, up with the stars🫡
Hey, wait, I remember the thumbnail was different before.
Can you do other factions, 🙏
Of course the syndicalist would have Ohio as their capital
Japanese interventions is nice
Bruh what the hell was the war for?
As great as your narration is, I have a hard time believing the Federalist division wins considering their weak geographic location, with only a small land bridge between the eastern and western halves. It'd be paramount to both the CSA and AUS to cut that off immediately, immediately kneecapping the USA. I know you controlled them to cause them to win, but if I had to guess, it'd either be the AUS and PSA teaming up to take out the CSA after the fall of the USA, or the CSA using their crazy industry and ideological warfare to win via propaganda to working class folks in the other territories.
There have often been unbelievable events in history, but you're right here - as far as I remember my idea in making this video was to make it as absurd as possible within a sort of realistic narrative.
17:50
Seems like the boring option
I prefer the 4 way meat grinder
MacArthur is the best.
PART 2
AUS best faction
E
E
Вери гуд инглиш
Bad video no independent New England
Lore of Second American Civil War in Hoi4 / Kaiserreich / RP storytelling momentum 100
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E
E