soojung is still the original visual up to this day for me. she radiates a chic, classy, elegant, expensive, and sophisticated aura with cold personality, great body proportions, and versatile talent. she’s just intimidating and beyond perfection.
@@ashketchum302 that's definitely true but she clearly states that it's "FOR ME". I hope you wholly understand and respect someone's OWN preferences and opinion 😁
No one can top Krystal as visual in kpop, not to mention her charisma and presence on stage. Ive been a kpop fan since 2009 and when F(x) debuted Krystal caught my eye the most. Up to now 2021, theres nobody who can top her, and be as iconic as her tbh. She's just on another level
We're already in 2021 and in 4th generation of KPOP but still up to this day, no one still top Krystal's visual for me. It's not even just her beauty, it's her vibe and aura. Like cold, chic and elegant. There's just something about her that others doesn't have. Her visual is eternal and unchanging.
@@老公-d5p Wrong. I agree to her too. Krystal is just purely beautiful, inside and out. One of the top beauty kpop ever had. I love blackpink, I love those three you mentioned but nah, not even close
yeh just basically overall 2015 MAMA was one of the best mama's and basically 2015 was one of the best music era's like most of the older groups made a comeback, and tbh 2016 MAMA was rather shitty not because of yg no just overall it wasnt as good as last year.....
f(x) is truly such a superior group. They're so classy, chic and elegant, and each of them are so distinct. SM really let this one go to waste. Criminally underrated.
no matter how many times i watch this my eyes stright goes to luna even tho her style not that good here but she's so pretty and a very good performer, I enjoy watching her on the stage the most.I really hope ppl apperacite her more often and give her more love ❤
No SANA No LIFE !!!!!! It's so hard for me to find a luna stan or any mention of her under each f(x) video so I'm glad to see there are others who love her as well! thank you :)
After watching New jeans came to see Min Hee Jins's previous girl groups. And it's iconic.. F(x) is iconic they all have different vibe from traditional kpop groups..
2021 and I'm still here for this amazing group. Krystal's visual, Ma'am didn't even let me fall inlove again the same way I did to her. Been stanning 3rd and 4th but no one comes close...
Tell me im selfish but no one can really top krystal's visual. Ever since fx stop promoting ive been a fan of many new gg like rv, bp, izone, twice, itzy, aespa, loona and others. They are all beautiful but really i think no one comes close to krystal's visual. Her visual and her vibes just hit different and yahh u know i fucking miss fx
The girl in the palazzo pants dances so gracefully and she looks like a goddess, I couldn't take my eyes off her. And Amber is so beautiful too like, these girls look like dolls or goddesses. Also, the girl with the darkerst hair, I like her voice
the finest group in kpop. from the member's vocals, visuals, dance skills, stage presence and charisma to the group's music and mind-blowing art direction. they, for me was the peak of kpop. if only sm treated them like a real fixed group instead of a disposable and experimental one, imagine all the songs they would've released.
Why amazing groups like f(x) had just like 3 minutes to perform while IKON, a rookie group had more than 10 minutes? that doesn't make any sense. After my rant, f(x) slayed, I love 4 walls and Krystal's outfit was super pretty! I hope this is the last time they perform as 3, I wish SM let Victoria focus more on f(x) than acting and other stuff.
The best way to meet everyone's requirements is to let f(x) perform the whole album !! Nah just kidding . I'm really looking forward for their first concert :)
+ja lon lin Yeah, exactly. Any songs from the album would be just fineeee. No, actually, all :')) They really need to do their first concert reeeaaallly fast and give their fans a name. :)
![f(x) - Diamond / 4 Walls [Music Bank COMBACK / 2015.10.30]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/N-vfBtaMvKM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2NE1-Fire + I AM THE BEST] KPOP Concert MAMA 2015 | EP.2](/img/n.gif)
f(x) WILL ALWAYS BE THE MOST AESTHETIC GROUP
YES
Forever
(༎ຶ‿༎ຶ)♥️♥️🖤♥️♥️🖤♥️♥️...
Yes absolutely
THEY INVENTED IT
soojung is still the original visual up to this day for me. she radiates a chic, classy, elegant, expensive, and sophisticated aura with cold personality, great body proportions, and versatile talent. she’s just intimidating and beyond perfection.
Samee
If we'll talk about who really the original visual is, it's Eugene from SES, followed by Yoona, Krystal, Irene and Winter.
@@ashketchum302 that's definitely true but she clearly states that it's "FOR ME". I hope you wholly understand and respect someone's OWN preferences and opinion 😁
and up to this day Krystal remains as my favorite visual. not only is she gorgeous but her presence is just on another level of chic but elegant
Mr. Jung Jaehyun can step on me agree, and not all visuals can be elegant as krystal
yes she has this aura that no one else can have😭
I will never understand the hype for her,she have big nose big forehead small eyes and she is so skinny
@@pinkvelvet1511 gee thanks karen, have a great day!
@@KayKayshaw isn't that considered unattractive?
함수 그리워 죽겠다 진짜... 음방에서 한 번만이라도 완전체로 보면 소원이 없을 것 같음...ㅠㅠ 그리고 이날 착장 레전드ㅠㅠㅠ 너무 예뻐 함수 사랑해 꼭 다시 완전체로 컴백하자
왜 이렇게 방치를 했을까요.. 아쉽네요
I think this is the most sophisticated and most elegant MAMA stage ever.
idk how many times I watched this :
OMG sameee I keep coming back here. The performance is so magical I can't even describe
Umm how can i ask you a QUESTION? But where is SULLI?in their PERFORMANCE?
@@vernettec.3516 she left the group the end of 2014
@@zora2152 how about Victoria?
@@eeeeeeeeeeeeehhhh7418 she didn't leave but she was busy in china
Ambers rap at the beginning
Darcei 💜
Very amazing cool ^^
F(x) and SHINee is the best groups for me i loveeeeeeee all 5 of them in these two group
Are you here? Omg
Omg darcei why u here? HAHAHAHA
No one can top Krystal as visual in kpop, not to mention her charisma and presence on stage. Ive been a kpop fan since 2009 and when F(x) debuted Krystal caught my eye the most. Up to now 2021, theres nobody who can top her, and be as iconic as her tbh. She's just on another level
Valid!!!!
superior
是的
she remains superior
Blackpink laughed reading this comment.
Think they don't exist
We're already in 2021 and in 4th generation of KPOP but still up to this day, no one still top Krystal's visual for me. It's not even just her beauty, it's her vibe and aura. Like cold, chic and elegant. There's just something about her that others doesn't have. Her visual is eternal and unchanging.
No one in new gg generation can win over krystal's visual for real. LOOK AT HER PERFECTION FROM HEAD TO TOE
AL B erm still nope krystal is on another level of beauty. Its YoonA level of beauty. A goddess level
@@老公-d5p Wrong. I agree to her too. Krystal is just purely beautiful, inside and out. One of the top beauty kpop ever had. I love blackpink, I love those three you mentioned but nah, not even close
KylieDee ikr!!! I also big fan to alot of 3rd gen gg like twice, blackpink, gfriend, red velvet and many more but no one yet can surpass her level
@@kdcl5597 yes I agreee
@@老公-d5p oh no, I'm a blink too but I agree no one can surpass SM visuals especially Krystal
4walls가 앞으로 계속 활동할거라는 신호탄일줄 알았지..마지막 명곡일줄은 ㅠㅜ
새롭게 보이는 신기루
The most underrated group in SMENT..
Traxx is the most underrated 😣 group of SM
@@ari1core what is trax
@@jessicaarmy-animegirl9454 traxx is a k-rock band under SM due to SM not giving them proper promotion people don't even know them
OT12forever We Are one in the whole kpop industry to be accurate
Traxx and CSJH the grace is the most underrated
Amber can be prettygorgousbeautifulsexy and handsome and the same time . even her body is goals af
Niken D.I AND cute! so attractive 😍
Niken D.I is she tomboy???
blackjack x vip yes
HOW TO BE KRYSTAL HOW TO BE JUNG SOO JUNG HOW TO HAVE THAT HAIR HOW TO GET THOSE ABS HOW TO BE THAT PRETTY HOW TO BE THAT SHIRT
your profile picture is the best 😂
+yehet trashaf what's best about you is your profile picture. please don't ever change that. lol
How to have that face... Suga's face😂
how to have that suga's face 😂
+tina postrado lol
이 날 진짜 분위기도 그렇고 인어공주 같았어.. 그래서 f(x) 컴백 언제라고...?
No one can ever surpass Krystal's authentic elegance and beauty. Not even in this kpop new generation
YES. COULDNT MORE AGREE
She's not even trying hard. Just breathing elegance hahaha
she doesnt have to try. Bare face or not. She is a true godess
not only YG.. but I also miss SM sunbaenims :'( watching 2015 mama coz, I feel empty this year T_T
yeh just basically overall 2015 MAMA was one of the best mama's and basically 2015 was one of the best music era's like most of the older groups made a comeback, and tbh 2016 MAMA was rather shitty not because of yg no just overall it wasnt as good as last year.....
I love this group
And now mama becomes trash ! 😕😢'
also 2011
EXID T-ARA SNSD YAS. 2011 was the best:(
진짜 수정이는 연기할때도 예쁘지만 무대 위에서는 더 예쁜 듯.. 그런 의미에서 슴아 제발 에프엑스 컴백 좀
연기도 좋은데 크리스탈언니도 솔로 앨범 냈으면 좋겠네요. 노래도 잘부르고 목소리도 좋은데..
f(x) is truly such a superior group. They're so classy, chic and elegant, and each of them are so distinct. SM really let this one go to waste. Criminally underrated.
yall dont agree that Krystal's visual is no joke but literally if you watch fancams of idol reacting to her beauty they're all shook.
Yo give me linke pls😢
The iconic blue eyes in red light 🫶
5분 전이라고 해도 믿겠다 세상에
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ?
Krystal is really so pretty.
Like her sister Jessica ❤️
Krystal looks so gorgeous here... Never thought she could get that gorg.. it's true that the right outfit and makeup can make you really stand out
2024 anyone?
🙋🏻♀️
Me💖
❤
hereee
me❤
it’s been 6 years and this song still slaps and doesn’t sound outdated at all huhu i really miss f(x)
스엠이 다시 이런 분위기의 걸그룹을 런칭할까.. 스엠 특유의 세련됨 쩐다
ㅇㅈ
Luna is like the sweetest person ever why do the stylists hate her
willy wonka IKR😂😂
willy wonka
Either way Luna slays though.
Make up and hair is 🔥🔥🔥 she still pulled off the bra thing tho ...if only they took off the extra fabric at the sides 😩😩 it would’ve been cute
It’s actually a serve
I really like her outfit here 🤷♀️
이 날 개빡쳤었는데 7년차 함수는 반곡하고 신인이었던 yg ㅇㅇㅋ은 3곡인가 하고.. 아니 4walls 얼마나 길다고 그걸 잘라;;
사랑했다는 그룹이요??
방탄은항상 옳다ᅡᅡ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
에프엑스 SM인데 왜 짤린거지?
@@kmk7872 그러게요...그만큼 슴이 안밀어줬다는 거 아닐까요?
개빡칠만하다 진짜
0:22 아니 엠버 분위기 어쩔;;
루나 이때 진짜 너무 이뻤다 ㅠㅠ
오랜만에 아이돌 수정보니 넘 좋고 ㅠㅠ
초반 리믹스 부분 신비로운 분위기가 에프엑스랑 너무 잘어울리고 엠버랩도 너무 좋음…
그리고 곡 들어갈 때 도입부도 너무 좋고 ㅠㅠ 내기준 베스트 무대인거같아 거의 매일 보러옴
너무 그립다 삼함수…
실력이 있으니 세명이지만 꽉찬 무대…
음색퀸 수정 보컬 루나 개성래퍼 엠버…
Krystal one of the best visuals of kpop, totally a natural beauty and talented
no matter how many times i watch this my eyes stright goes to luna even tho her style not that good here but she's so pretty and a very good performer, I enjoy watching her on the stage the most.I really hope ppl apperacite her more often and give her more love ❤
Luna is my bias
No SANA No LIFE !!!!!! It's so hard for me to find a luna stan or any mention of her under each f(x) video so I'm glad to see there are others who love her as well! thank you :)
No SANA No LIFE !!!!!!
I always thought she was the star. Years later and people dont pay attention to her solo releases
I really like the remix at the start like seriously.
Me too! I hope sm will upload this remix ^^
+chriss KA i think they already did you can search it up "f(x) 4 walls frnk remix" :D
Geum Juyun Tks!! (^o^)
Thank you so much! (^~^)
포월즈가 10년전이라니 믿기지도 않는다 10분전 같음 함수 너무 보고싶다 너무 그리워 너무예쁘다 진짜
Older kpop really hits different
MAMA it's messed up, 1 song for f (x) and Shinee and 3 songs for rookie groups. lmao wtf.
honestly, f(x) did not even have a full song for the 4 Walls MAMA performance...so sad so unfair
and yet thet slayed unlike rookie's perfs
MAMA is trash honestly
fvsko which rookie?
@@ChunC204 ikon
Mama please invite f(x) to perform in 2016 ^^ and this time, let's they sing 5 songs =))
agreed!
Yes please
👍👍
Agree (Y)
Agree :)
Luna is sooo prettyy and her voice isa daebakkkk!
Krystal was insane here. her visual is truly astronomical
fx 노래 들을때면 항상 생각나는 무대ㅠㅠ 세명인데도 꽉꽉찬 무대는 대단했다 정말..
and the best outfit goes to krystal
+tomaa al mbark yes its always the best for krystal and the worst for amber
totally true.
true...krystal look so beautiful and stunning
+soph v totally agree
they can rock every thing
+soph v Yeah I like Amber's the best
얼마나 앞서 간거야 너무 좋다
luna with this outfit and this kind of hair reminds me of Princess Jasmine (aladdin)
After watching New jeans came to see Min Hee Jins's previous girl groups.
And it's iconic..
F(x) is iconic
they all have different vibe from traditional kpop groups..
아이돌 수정이 보고싶어서 왔네.......
아이돌 수정이 너무 그립다ㅠㅠㅠ
언제 솔로라도 한 번만 내주길 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
크리스탈 진짜 존나 이쁘다
Say whatever you want but no one can win over Krystal's visual. Yeah, there are other potential female idols but Krystal is unbeatable.
OUR QUEEN
THE MOST LEGEND AESTHETIC PERFORMANCE EVER!!! I MISS THEM SM :(
엪엑스는 ㄹㅇ 그냥 예쁨의 정석같음.. 뭔가 예뻐 모든게
2021 and I'm still here for this amazing group. Krystal's visual, Ma'am didn't even let me fall inlove again the same way I did to her. Been stanning 3rd and 4th but no one comes close...
ha.. how many times have i been here?... im not even tired nor bored to watch this... krystal looks so freaking iconic legend beauty...goddess..
Tell me im selfish but no one can really top krystal's visual. Ever since fx stop promoting ive been a fan of many new gg like rv, bp, izone, twice, itzy, aespa, loona and others. They are all beautiful but really i think no one comes close to krystal's visual. Her visual and her vibes just hit different and yahh u know i fucking miss fx
Agreee
YES
No one comes close to Krystal's visuals, tbh
💯
excusme, but where is victoria, i'm not meu
@@maksudimaksudi5600 im pretty sure she was promoting in China
Irene
Irene ♥️
너무 안타까운 그룹이다 정말루... 에스엠 좀만 더 신경써주지..
진짜
8 years ago but still feel like yesterday. I miss them so much 🥺🥺
빅토리아 중국 활동 떄문에 힘들면 세명 조합도 괜춘한데.. ㅠㅠ ses 비내츄럴 느낌나게 한번 해줬어도 쩔었을 거 같은데 ㅠ
오 ㄹㅇ
who’s whatching in the beginning of 2020
Im from Indonesian And im Meu
@@klavsmeu5790 me too
@@yourfuture4220 Ahihi Salken Ching
me from france ! 🥺❤️
eren’s wife same😭
2021 and still mesmerized by Krystal’s visual here.
와 알고리즘 이거까지 꺼내주는구나.. 정수정 레전드 헤메코로 저장했었는데.. 인어 그자체
I've been a kpop from more that 10 yrs already and in my eyes, krystall is still the most beautiful idol I've seen.
Same here
The girl in the palazzo pants dances so gracefully and she looks like a goddess, I couldn't take my eyes off her. And Amber is so beautiful too like, these girls look like dolls or goddesses. Also, the girl with the darkerst hair, I like her voice
+Ellie Vélez I just noticed they're all wearing palazzo pants how dumb. But I was talking about Krystal.
OMGGG LETS BE FRIENDS!!!
존버는 아직 끝나지 않았어..
사년째 ㄷㄷ
음악도 실력도 외모도 스타일도
심지어 유니크함도. 완벽했던 그룹
너무 아까움
A level of slay was served here that has yet to be replicated
다시봐도 sm에 레전드로 남을 정말 아까운 걸그룹 •••
이 셋이어도 좋으니까 다시 돌아왔으면... 여름인데 함수 계절인데 휴
This performance is so clean, the dance, the vocals, the outfit, the beuty, I MISS FX SO BAAADDD 😭
I love Luna way too much
Krystal visual is something... like the visual can’t make you stop looking at her
the finest group in kpop. from the member's vocals, visuals, dance skills, stage presence and charisma to the group's music and mind-blowing art direction. they, for me was the peak of kpop. if only sm treated them like a real fixed group instead of a disposable and experimental one, imagine all the songs they would've released.
is it just me or f(x) made button-down long sleeve shirts cool again? 😀
Why amazing groups like f(x) had just like 3 minutes to perform while IKON, a rookie group had more than 10 minutes? that doesn't make any sense.
After my rant, f(x) slayed, I love 4 walls and Krystal's outfit was super pretty!
I hope this is the last time they perform as 3, I wish SM let Victoria focus more on f(x) than acting and other stuff.
so true! fx is so underrated. 😡
+ileana ochoa There is more people want to see ikon then fx that's normal.
+ileana ochoa iKON debut had a big impact you know ...
+ileana ochoa i like f(x) but people prefer iKON more
Just a guess but other SM groups had long performance durations. Mnet may have requested it or SM might've decided it. Who knows?
와 크리스탈 목소리 음색 사람 미치게 만드네.......저 목소리로 앨범 좀 내줘요..ㅠㅜ
This stage is ethereal. I'm still re-watching to this day.
에프엑스도 컴백해주라 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅠㅠㅠㅠ
You know, they should perform Diamond too :(
Or Papi would've been great
+Ariana Lani i love papi too! lol, that sounds weird...since papi means father in my mother language.
The best way to meet everyone's requirements is to let f(x) perform the whole album !! Nah just kidding . I'm really looking forward for their first concert :)
+ja lon lin Yeah, exactly. Any songs from the album would be just fineeee. No, actually, all :')) They really need to do their first concert reeeaaallly fast and give their fans a name. :)
+Ariana Lani Yeah, papi is one of the best song in the album. No, actually all :'))
f(x) is perfect💕💕💕💕👌👌
But it's a shame that their entertainment company isn't
4 walls has to be one of the best kpop's songs of all time. it's just so good!
MAMA 2015 is the most legendary MAMA for me, f(x) showed us their cool intro! Just rewatching it in 2022
진짜 너무 이뻐ㅠㅜㅠ이영상 몆번을 봐도 볼때마다 그저 감탄함 하..언니들ㅠㅜㅠ그립다 에프엑스 그리구 그시절 케이팝
With already having this kind of beauty, imagine having that kind of vocal and dance ability. Wow wow Krystal. You’re one of a kind
Krystal so gorgeous, her beauty is breathtaking, I hope can see her at stage again ❤
its already 2022 and here i am coming back to watch this amazing performance
I so miss f(x) that I’ve come to rewatch their performances huhuhu
이무대 클쓰 루나 다 너무 이뿨,,,,엠버컨셉도 독보적이고 너무 좋음 ㅜㅜ
Amber so pretty here 🙈😊
ikr!!
Ikr!! T_T
+Onika Pink she reminds me of luhan :(
oh my deer
Dian NurmalitaS
ikr
+Onika Pink I just want to ask if Amber is a lesbian or she just want that kind of haircut?
f(x), my girls, my flowers.. you are still my fav group. i miss f(x) music so much.
Every year I always come back to watch this iconic performance. THESE OUTFITS!!
1:53 this is the most perfect thing of 2015
I love this performance so much, their outfit, the stage, the aransement and ofc the member made it so classy and elegant
Luna is so beautiful ... please support for her !
It's 2022 and I still hope they'll reunite one day
노래를 자른다는게 진짜 믿기지가 않다 .. 나는 열이 받는다 ..
진짜 이 날 크리스탈 미친듯이 너무 예뻤음,,,,, 편곡도 난 맘에 들긴 했는데 분량 적어서 진짜 얼탱이없었던,,,,,,
One of the best K-Pop songs of all time
KRYSTAL IS JUST SO BEAUTIFUL. I want her back on kpop to show what a queen really is ugh
imo Amber is the best SM female rapper so far, she’s very talented attractive and open minded
she’s always been one of my favourite kpop female idols
F(X) IS REALLY AHEAD OF THEIR TIME I BET THEY WILL BE BIG IN THIS GENERATION.
Every time i see this performance i just realize how much i miss f(x) so so much
Their perfomances, their vocal, their style, ICONIC
I miss fx so much :'