Exactly. That's why she was put in a group like f(x), which welcomes individuality and uniqueness! :) It's literally their concept, so it wouldn't be odd
+Joylee true true...but they must've practiced for months...so she probably is more used to them now. but I get your concern...though Luna had an ankle injury too before and they always let her perform in killer heals...
this was such a moment. releasing a music video with no choreography, and having the world wait until the comeback stage to see this masterpiece of a dance. Iconic isn’t the word!! This group was peak kpop excellence, the world needs a comeback
@@amelie7325 They weren't blindfolded, I thought so too. It's just mesh materials that they can see through. If they were blindfolded there would be way too much room for error but the performance was still amazing. At least f(x) basically ended on an amazing note.
rainy_season 3 of the 4 members had their contract expired. I mean it would be best if SM just announced that they disbanded but they can’t make a comeback if there isn’t the whole group. There is literally only Krystal who is “in the group”
Because in 2014 red velvet debuted and probably SM wanted all attention to ıts new group so they didnt give any song to fx ..cause all of their songs went to red velvet
@Justin Thiadi from what I read, she probably is not under sm rn, but a Chinese company that is still related with sm. Im not sure cause SM said they made a deal already with Victoria. (But her contract with SM has expired)
@@tatianahorn_ SM never announces disbandments. Even if all members left I'm sure they could just put new people in and continue with it. I mean, TRAX had a comeback 1 year ago after 8 year hiatus and SM hasn't disbanded them either.
Not following up with another comeback after 4 Walls is one of SM's biggest mistake. These girls represent so much in the music industry, and f(x) as a group has evolved in a unique way that it makes me wonder how much more impact they would have made if they were not so badly managed.
Agreed, F(x) should have gotten at the very least one more album before everything went down, F(x), 2ne1 and Brown Eyed Girls proved that you don't have to do Cute or Sexy to be successful in the Kpop industry, F(x) music from debut right up till this album are still setting standards and breaking boundary's in the Korean entertainment industry, F(x) and SHINee proved time and time again that music can cross many different genres and still be successful in a industry that is so cut throat and has set preferences for what is considered popular. F(x) discography is simply put the best in the Kpop industry I am happy that this group of successful girls got put together, despite everything that has happened over the last 2 or 3 years to F(x) there music still hold up well even by todays standards, and on the critical side F(x) has the most cohesive Kpop albums in the industry which is pink tape.
SM only has 2 problems promotion: a mess, lack of touch with reality, they are overconfident in their idols mass appealing (which is also above any other in the industry, but they could do even more in a less tiring way for their idols) Also SM missed the america opportunity when it got the chance. Missed a lot of opportunities with: Fx, Shinee, Suju M, EXO, NCT, WayV. care of idols: Yes we got the brightest gems, the most beautiful and talented diamonds BUT sm is know to be the company that force them to extreme the most, and most cases. SM idols are usually broken inside because of the actual traumatic experience of being their idols and trainees. also a lot of injuries not being taken care of
SM lost golden groups and members when the new ceo KYM stepped in 2010. Literally, jess leaves SNSD, soon tiff, seo, and soo left SM but not SNSD, FX Disband, Jonghyun suicide, Sulli suicide, Taeyeon depression cuz of hate. The new CEO is bad and everyone can agree. SM fam lovers want LSM back as CEO, he may not be good but atleast his artist respect him and treats them as a friend and a father. New CEO is literally bringing SM downhill, from being the top marketing company down to 2nd(not bad but still) against YG... Yes YG is a good company but SM never let YG beat them in terms of sale because of suju and snsd. The only way they can be top again is OT9 comeback and SUJU OT13. Literally just those two would be enough to bring them to 1st again. But nooo, New CEO will and always be the biggest mistake of SM and that's FACTS
@@flosanggalang6439 to be fair SM is still number one however I agree that since that ceo came in sm got money hungry and lost uncountable opportunities
@@STALKER777LK oh rlly? I thought they was number 2 now and YG was number 1 with their multiple comeback. But yeah, SM lost not just opportunities but idols/members that were assets to them. When jessica left stocks dropped tremendously by 15%, JUST her leaving, then SM didn't take care of the depressed causing jonghyun to go bye bye, causing the entire kpop community to be sad. SM went from perfect to average once the new CEO came.
Omg I noticed that too. Lol especially her back. She has that really pretty line, ya know what I, walking about? Lol idk but she's always had a nice figure
Still don’t understand how SM drops a group after they release one of their most interesting albums with a lead single that brought in thousands of new fans. Make it make sense????
sm sucks lol but f(x) was thriving during 4 walls era though, they even got their 1st japanese album and 1st concert in 2016 but yeah sm fucked them up real bad
Mausey Villalon they look more beautiful and mature. I thought Luna was always so pretty but sadly she lacked a good style and a propper makeup glad they are styling her more nicely now.
Marilia F Franco And u know that for sure cuz ur an expert? Look we don't know that for sure ok and as long there is no confirmation all what is beening shared is nothing but asumptions can be either true or false. Sorry if this takes longer I just wanna clear up some things. First, tho I'm not a big ps fan but do not look at the ppl who tend to do it that way neither do dare degrade them that low, u don't know what's their story? Calling them names is very rude and superficial of u. Do u enjoy judjing ppl based on their appearances as if it's the only thing that matters! Second, aware that not only ps that changes ppl right! There are other factors such as weight loss, Makeup, pupirity etc. Luna through the 7 years lost weight excessively, she's not16 y.o anymore. Her hall style has changed into more feminine look. Third, her makeup is so much different and skin lighter. Alterd her eyebrows, wears eye contact and use lots of countering if u cared to follow her makeup routine,fixed her hairline and botox. Fourth, she's sick in the kidney causing her face to bloat at times. All of these are possibilities why only stick to ps option? Lastly, supposedly she did then when was that? Ps dosnt work like that. She has to stay low-key at least 2weeks but she didn't disappear. In 2014 it was proven she's ps free. From 2015 till today she managed to update daily and has so much puplic appearance and solo works. Littetely she was seen almost daily so how can she do it? It does not make sence!!!
Totally agree. Other people says that Luna looks more like a Main dancer than Vic, yeahh Luna's move is sharp and on time but Victoria's moves are incomparable it always give me that Slow and Graceful vibe. And now she also do Hip-hop and jazz She's a Queen love her so much, all of themm
Victoria is more of a clean dancer. She executes moves clearly. Luna is more up beat and has tons of energy in her dance. Like what the person above me has said, Victoria is like Mina in terms of dancing. They also did ballet so there's that.
tbh the amount of love that i have for f(x) is no joke. everytime i see a girlgroup i may think that they're nice but then i will miss f(x)'s performance. i miss them so much i know they wont be coming back this year and the fact that they're not disbanding made me super happy :')
+Esmeralda de Vries pretty she has claimed multiple times that she is straight and qualifies herself as a girl, she only likes short hair and boyish clothes that honestly are not boyish at all
Im glad Ambers outfit matches more this time, I hate how different they usually make her clothes. I understand she wears more boyish outfits, but they should at least make the outfit similar in vibe. Usually its too different. Good job this time.
F(x) birthed the 'aesthetically pleasing' style in kpop, 4walls was already an out of this world comeback, what more if they were given more years to evolve their craft and music 😭🖤
+Angel N. I think it's ok though cause she kinda lost it over a span of comebacks. And like I think she said herself she exercises more so atleast she's losing in a good way
Emily Wang that's what I heard somewhere that she's healthy and eats and exercises so that's good if so then I aspire to look like that ahha she looks fabulous
No Kpop without f(x)! SM has to open his eyes and see that f(x) has a huge impact on Kpop girl group concept. They introduced so many concepts and all the members are multi talented! This is such a waste! They have a good fanbase too! We, MeUs need f(x) to make a comeback! SM please!
me too her body is so beautiful so sexy IM JEALOUS I WANT THIS TOO and I want to weigh as much as Sulli Im 14 shes 25 and she weighs 41 then theres me with .. ;((((
It's really satisfying cause all of them giving dominant aura at the freakin same time. You can't even focus to one member cause all of them are catchy and aesthetic.
4 walls is really a great maze concept. This is totally different from their past songs and this literally gives me goosebumps. Ohhhh!!! F(x) slay slay slay
They gonna do the same with red velvet, this happens every time SM deputes a new group, we have to do something, I can't stand there and watch those iconic artists being neglected that way, that company is burying them alive it ruined their dreams .. BoA, super junior, shinee, fx, snsd ,exo,red velvet,nct those great artists don't deserve this. We need to do something for them as they did a lot and gave us great songs and made us happy.. Let's save them guys, please 🥺
The visuals, the talent, the music, the choreography, the aesthetics. They have everything that is to offer and still . There are now many hot girlgroups with extreme popularity but they are no where near this level. Kpop has not been ready for f(x).
+Chisi A Xiong They have Four to be exact. Hello f(x), Amazing f(x), and Koala f(x) (which doesn't have Amber :( She was on hiatus at the time :( ), and Go! f(x)
It's been 5 years. But this song, this performance, still could fit into the current generation. I mean if I didn't know enough and people said this is a current comeback, I would believe them.
I'm Krystal biased but damn.. couldn't stop staring at Vic here, she looks flawless. Also, it's been 84 years, when are f(x) gonna make another comeback?
I just realised how strong of a comeback this was, statement vice. They are trying to show how strong fx is even when Sulli left the group. Lyrics and the choreo, especially with how teamwork based it is.
This comment might be out of place, but f(x) might be one of the only groups that can pull off unique fashion(like, weird in a good way kind of clothes). Not saying that their outfits here was awful, in fact they looked really good here.
f(x) and their concept are sooo extra... they pulled it off! It's not easy. Not so many idols doing this kind of concept.. awww miss this group so much. Sigh
다른 여 아이돌들은 무대를 보면 그들의 피눈물 나는 노력이 겹쳐 보이는데, 함수 무대보면 천재성이 보이면서 자연스럽게 무대를 장악함. 크리스탈은 이름이 크리스탈 아니랄까봐 얼굴에 하이라이트 조명킨거 마냥 무대할때 반짝 반짝 빛남... 빅토리아는 긴팔다리 춤선 예술이고 , 루나 목소리 미쳤고, 앰버 랩 너무 세련되고.... 컴백 기다리는 언니팬이얌 !!! 한명한명 너무 소중해 설리포함 💜
Backupdancer : "I just bought new mascara and eyeliner for f(x) stage tomorrow" SM : Here blindfolded your eyes for your performance. Backupdancer : But...
Actually, this was already expected. During performances without Victoria, they had two backup dancers who wore similar things. I think it's a really nice touch, not just because it helps you focus on f(x). Also because it looks super cool on stage and no one else does it like this. Makes it look mysterious.
Tha fact that this performance reached 7 million proves that us MeU's are soooooo thirsty for a comeback loooool. It could also be the fact that Llamaber looks so hawt here XD
4 walls is way ahead of its release. i mean, this kind of song could've achieved more impact if it is released around this time. like it's really a bop. AND SM GIVE THEM A FREAKIN COMEBACK ALREADY.
It was right but ofcourse koreans won't really have this if it weren't for f(x). They are trendsetters and they introduced a lot of stuff and contributed to the music industry. That's why they're underrated that time because they were so ahead that they are the ones who have to introduce this kind of music to koreans.
f(x) is probably one of the best things that happened in the kpop industry. these ladies are oozing with talents and visuals. nothing compares to them. no matter what happens, they are legends.
+audia putrika kecil i hope they make a dance mv or a dance practice... but mv dance ver is better (huehehehehe) like shinee's married to the music. i recommend that to you too :)
omg im another YGstan here!! i never really liked other groups until Fx.. this is surely a great comback. im waiting for 2ne1. it makes me expecting for them tho haha
+audia putrika kecil yh, first sm does electronic and dubsteppy kinda stuff and now they're bringin' it back in time with 90's house and other genres lol
![[F (x)]] red light red light @ popular Inkigayo 140713](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vdnB00ogSD0/mqdefault.jpg)
![[F (x)]] red light red light @ popular Inkigayo 140713](/img/tr.png)
*You will never find a group like them.*
NEVER
Agree
NEVER EVER
TRUE
Will never
This is still one of the most iconic comebacks in kpop history.
I agree 100% 👌🏽👍🏽👍🏽💕
Yes
say it louder for the ppl in the back
Preach👏👏👏
the facts!!!
I love how they dress Amber according to her style and don’t force her to wear girly clothing like the other members
Exactly. That's why she was put in a group like f(x), which welcomes individuality and uniqueness! :)
It's literally their concept, so it wouldn't be odd
She looks really cool, iike her
bec she has tattoo lol
달빛 Not just that.
@@mooniemayhem8960 I think SM wanted to hide her tattoos since idols get critsize for having tattoos some people thing that only gangs have tattoos
私の魂はここに置いてある永遠に
i wonder how fast amber removed the heels after this performance
I kinda worry her ankle, as we all know Amber injured before. At least not dance in heels.
+Citaah hahah i know right?
+Joylee true true...but they must've practiced for months...so she probably is more used to them now. but I get your concern...though Luna had an ankle injury too before and they always let her perform in killer heals...
+Citaah I just saw that now =p
+Stephanie van Zuidam
because Luna is so short she has no other choice :(
One of the most unique kpop groups ever
songbird1030 yeees 😍😍
especially with this song, havent seen anything like this ever or at least in a while - can't wait until they comeback
facts.
@@songbird1030 give try puzzle moon GWSN
@@songbird1030 GWSN are trying but the charm of f(x) is that they were so rare and unique. I like them though.
I'll just pretend this is their new comeback stage...
Same
Me too.
Huhu we will nvr see them again....
Miss f(x)
Love f(x)
It's 2024 now and i'm still here for f(x) 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Same dude, I've been waiting for a reunion at least for Victoria and Amber since ber was active in china now🤧
me tooooo i miss f(x) sm
i know we re in a middle of pandemic.. but i miss them
accurate
Neixheje :
Marina Tiwol Fr
Same
🥺
this was such a moment. releasing a music video with no choreography, and having the world wait until the comeback stage to see this masterpiece of a dance. Iconic isn’t the word!! This group was peak kpop excellence, the world needs a comeback
Imma just take a moment to appreciate the backup dancers. They were blindfolded the whole time.SM screwed up big time by freezing f(x)
@@amelie7325 They weren't blindfolded, I thought so too. It's just mesh materials that they can see through. If they were blindfolded there would be way too much room for error but the performance was still amazing. At least f(x) basically ended on an amazing note.
Even becomes one of the most viewed comeback stage way back 2015. Haha
I JUST realised there was no choreo in the mv... Bruh moment! 😂🤦🌚
@@carlbenjaminolano8349 it is? I thought there r many big stages bop on 2015 too
Girls played my choreography! Great job f(x)!!!!!!! Proud of you girls!
+KYLE HANAGAMI it's really awesome,THANK YOU so much.I replay so many times :)
So you're the choreographer :O Thank you for giving them those awesome moves!
+KYLE HANAGAMI thank you so much!!!!! they fit it so well :D
+KYLE HANAGAMI Your choreography is so fucking good!
omg, i love ur videos!
it's been 6 years and this song still slaps and doesn't sound outdated at all huhu i really miss f(x)
I feel the same. Let me cry with you 😢 I miss them!
house music
f(x)'s music has always been considered timeless
2024 here and this still doesn’t sound outdated at all, I really thought so while watching this again and then I saw your comment 💜
I love how f(x) not really bother to catch the camera with their eyes. Instead of that, the cameraman is trying to follow their eyes. Legends only.
Best comment
The power
This comment deserve daesang! So true, QUEEN INDEED👏
They were doing so well with 4 walls. I can’t believe SM just froze them for 4 years. One of the kind GG.
rainy_season 3 of the 4 members had their contract expired. I mean it would be best if SM just announced that they disbanded but they can’t make a comeback if there isn’t the whole group. There is literally only Krystal who is “in the group”
Because in 2014 red velvet debuted and probably SM wanted all attention to ıts new group so they didnt give any song to fx ..cause all of their songs went to red velvet
@Justin Thiadi she became an actress in China and is doing very well
@Justin Thiadi from what I read, she probably is not under sm rn, but a Chinese company that is still related with sm. Im not sure cause SM said they made a deal already with Victoria. (But her contract with SM has expired)
@@tatianahorn_ SM never announces disbandments. Even if all members left I'm sure they could just put new people in and continue with it. I mean, TRAX had a comeback 1 year ago after 8 year hiatus and SM hasn't disbanded them either.
this choreography is artwork
Made by Kyle Hanagami ^^
literally
Jelly can i get the video of the cheo he made?
Is it me or f(x) is the most luxurious and elegant girlgroup ever? I just feel that from this performance. And aesthetic hehe.
i know right no other girl group can exude such elegance like how they did.
SM girl groups do have that kind of trademark. Elegance, powerful, majestic.
The music video in 4 Walls is way ahead of their era, the aesthetics there is on point. Every frame is a wallpaper.
I agree 🥺🥺
Krystal + Sulli + Victoria = one of top visual trinity in kpop
is no one gonna talk about how fucking great vic looks bc DAMN MOM
Victoria is my one and only queen and I think she looks stunning as usual ! 😍😍😍
+God Josh I was just thinking that!
+mar 0127 i love that hand thing she does and that kick at the end idk why but i like it
+God Josh oh I wasn't the only one!
+mar 0127 Victoria always stunning like a goddes btw
Not following up with another comeback after 4 Walls is one of SM's biggest mistake. These girls represent so much in the music industry, and f(x) as a group has evolved in a unique way that it makes me wonder how much more impact they would have made if they were not so badly managed.
Agreed, F(x) should have gotten at the very least one more album before everything went down, F(x), 2ne1 and Brown Eyed Girls proved that you don't have to do Cute or Sexy to be successful in the Kpop industry, F(x) music from debut right up till this album are still setting standards and breaking boundary's in the Korean entertainment industry, F(x) and SHINee proved time and time again that music can cross many different genres and still be successful in a industry that is so cut throat and has set preferences for what is considered popular. F(x) discography is simply put the best in the Kpop industry I am happy that this group of successful girls got put together, despite everything that has happened over the last 2 or 3 years to F(x) there music still hold up well even by todays standards, and on the critical side F(x) has the most cohesive Kpop albums in the industry which is pink tape.
SM only has 2 problems
promotion: a mess, lack of touch with reality, they are overconfident in their idols mass appealing (which is also above any other in the industry, but they could do even more in a less tiring way for their idols) Also SM missed the america opportunity when it got the chance. Missed a lot of opportunities with: Fx, Shinee, Suju M, EXO, NCT, WayV.
care of idols: Yes we got the brightest gems, the most beautiful and talented diamonds BUT sm is know to be the company that force them to extreme the most, and most cases. SM idols are usually broken inside because of the actual traumatic experience of being their idols and trainees. also a lot of injuries not being taken care of
SM lost golden groups and members when the new ceo KYM stepped in 2010. Literally, jess leaves SNSD, soon tiff, seo, and soo left SM but not SNSD, FX Disband, Jonghyun suicide, Sulli suicide, Taeyeon depression cuz of hate. The new CEO is bad and everyone can agree. SM fam lovers want LSM back as CEO, he may not be good but atleast his artist respect him and treats them as a friend and a father. New CEO is literally bringing SM downhill, from being the top marketing company down to 2nd(not bad but still) against YG... Yes YG is a good company but SM never let YG beat them in terms of sale because of suju and snsd. The only way they can be top again is OT9 comeback and SUJU OT13. Literally just those two would be enough to bring them to 1st again. But nooo, New CEO will and always be the biggest mistake of SM and that's FACTS
@@flosanggalang6439 to be fair SM is still number one however I agree that since that ceo came in sm got money hungry and lost uncountable opportunities
@@STALKER777LK oh rlly? I thought they was number 2 now and YG was number 1 with their multiple comeback. But yeah, SM lost not just opportunities but idols/members that were assets to them. When jessica left stocks dropped tremendously by 15%, JUST her leaving, then SM didn't take care of the depressed causing jonghyun to go bye bye, causing the entire kpop community to be sad. SM went from perfect to average once the new CEO came.
I still come here to cry because SM is letting one of the most talented and unique groups in kpop die. ;;_______;;
They'll end up like morning musume after started debuting mediocre singers and will have to start from rock bottom
Amber and Luna have left SM, Victoria and Krystal will do that too for sure soon :( hope for a reunion
and the former member is now dead
@@ellebon2445 Wow that comes off as rude even though I know you didn't intend it that way.
アンバ、唯一無二だよ
後にも先にもこんなかっこいいヨジャドル出てこんだろ
まだえぷが活動してるときにもっと大人だったら現場にも行きたかったよ
悔やまれる
KFC ain't got shit on them. Their choreography and synchronization was extra crispy.
Hahaha best comment of all
lol love this
+Jonathan Morrison Check this #CRISPY Vid. 😂😂😂
ha was confused where this was going but when I got to the end I was very satisfied xD
this comment is life jajajaja👏👏👏
Luna's waistline is really really pretty. Girl has shape.
Omg I noticed that too. Lol especially her back. She has that really pretty line, ya know what I, walking about? Lol idk but she's always had a nice figure
US ARMY omg even Krystal too like they are all beautiful
US ARMY
To bad she was really unhealthy in this era half she’s in her natural shape now
Luna is ambers girlfriend right?
Victoria is queen, krystal is goddess, amber invented beautiful and luna is perfection. All hail f(x)!
Still don’t understand how SM drops a group after they release one of their most interesting albums with a lead single that brought in thousands of new fans. Make it make sense????
sm sucks lol but f(x) was thriving during 4 walls era though, they even got their 1st japanese album and 1st concert in 2016 but yeah sm fucked them up real bad
SME bites more than it can chew, too many IP's to manage.
F(X) deserves a comeback so bad why SM sleepin on them so hard smfh
IS AMBER IN HEELS
yes she is
She's a bit clunky in them...
+Lexii K I was so surprised
high wedges
+Lexii K i suprise too
Victoria doing "mirror mirror" is so satisfying to watch lol
定期的に摂取しなければならないfxの美🥹🫶🏻最近の世代には無い華やかさと儚さ、凛々しさ全て兼ね備えてる😭🩷
everyone blossomed in this era.. especially Luna.. they all became goddesses.. 😍
♡♡♡♡
Mausey Villalon they look more beautiful and mature. I thought Luna was always so pretty but sadly she lacked a good style and a propper makeup glad they are styling her more nicely now.
+선영이 _ its pretty obvious shes had couple of plastic surguries... I dont know where is she anymore.. I miss Luna... She look soo fcking plastic now
+Marilia F Franco yea i miss the old luna. that's why i dont like fx as much as i like then before. but, i still like them anyway
Marilia F Franco And u know that for sure cuz ur an expert? Look we don't know that for sure ok and as long there is no confirmation all what is beening shared is nothing but asumptions can be either true or false. Sorry if this takes longer I just wanna clear up some things. First, tho I'm not a big ps fan but do not look at the ppl who tend to do it that way neither do dare degrade them that low, u don't know what's their story? Calling them names is very rude and superficial of u. Do u enjoy judjing ppl based on their appearances as if it's the only thing that matters! Second, aware that not only ps that changes ppl right! There are other factors such as weight loss, Makeup, pupirity etc. Luna through the 7 years lost weight excessively, she's not16 y.o anymore. Her hall style has changed into more feminine look. Third, her makeup is so much different and skin lighter. Alterd her eyebrows, wears eye contact and use lots of countering if u cared to follow her makeup routine,fixed her hairline and botox. Fourth, she's sick in the kidney causing her face to bloat at times. All of these are possibilities why only stick to ps option? Lastly, supposedly she did then when was that? Ps dosnt work like that. She has to stay low-key at least 2weeks but she didn't disappear. In 2014 it was proven she's ps free. From 2015 till today she managed to update daily and has so much puplic appearance and solo works. Littetely she was seen almost daily so how can she do it? It does not make sence!!!
ITS BEEN 4 YEARS BUT I SWEAR, VICTORIA'S HANDS IN "MIRROR MIRROR" WERE BEAUTIFUL~
exactly
Totally agree. Other people says that Luna looks more like a Main dancer than Vic, yeahh Luna's move is sharp and on time but Victoria's moves are incomparable it always give me that Slow and Graceful vibe. And now she also do Hip-hop and jazz She's a Queen love her so much, all of themm
@@rly_11166 she moves like Mina of Twice. A main dancer thing
Victoria is more of a clean dancer. She executes moves clearly. Luna is more up beat and has tons of energy in her dance. Like what the person above me has said, Victoria is like Mina in terms of dancing. They also did ballet so there's that.
tbh the amount of love that i have for f(x) is no joke. everytime i see a girlgroup i may think that they're nice but then i will miss f(x)'s performance. i miss them so much i know they wont be coming back this year and the fact that they're not disbanding made me super happy :')
ikr
Tsundere Suga sameee
BE POSITIVE! I THINK THEY'RE COMING BACK 4TH QUARTER THIS YEAR. AFTER VIC'S SHOW IN CHINA AND KYSTAL'S NEW DRAMA IN TVN
Its almost the end of November & still no comeback..do we have an official f(x) fans site?
I feel you girl 💖
派手な髪色、派手なカラコンやメイクをしなくても十分に美しくステージで輝けるこのコンセプトがとても好きです。 そしてそれがにあうf(x)が好きです。
confirmed fx stopped promotion for 4 walls early on because krystal blowing a kiss during the bridge was deemed too fatal to broadcast
+Kaylee Nguyen (kaylechips) lol!
Hhaahahahhahahha niceeeee
really??
Diora Erskine a joke. twas a joke.
WHY DOES AMBER LOOK SO GOOD HERE?
Her hair and her clothes. She's just pretty (or handsome, I do not know how to call her). I think I'm bisexual.
+Esmeralda de Vries & i think im straight
omgg yea Amber noona looks really sexy here
Amber is always good looking XD
+Esmeralda de Vries pretty she has claimed multiple times that she is straight and qualifies herself as a girl, she only likes short hair and boyish clothes that honestly are not boyish at all
Im glad Ambers outfit matches more this time, I hate how different they usually make her clothes. I understand she wears more boyish outfits, but they should at least make the outfit similar in vibe. Usually its too different. Good job this time.
7年経ってるなんて信じられないくらい音楽もスタイリングもダンスもいつみても洗練されてる…一生好きf(x)😢❤
💜💜💜💜💜
Amber tomboy look + heels > my life
same
whoever dresses f(x) deserves a raise. totally accentuates each members charm
I STILL CAN'T GET OVER HOW PERFECT THIS CHOREO IS 😭
F(x) birthed the 'aesthetically pleasing' style in kpop, 4walls was already an out of this world comeback, what more if they were given more years to evolve their craft and music 😭🖤
OMG! They freaking slayed!! They all looked perfect and gorgeous! Can we just talk about Luna's body? And the choreo...absolute PERFECTION!!
Ikr omg Luna looks freaking amazing #bodygoals
tho I might be a little concerned she looks like she lost a lot of weight even if she looks so beautiful
+Angel N. I think it's ok though cause she kinda lost it over a span of comebacks. And like I think she said herself she exercises more so atleast she's losing in a good way
Emily Wang that's what I heard somewhere that she's healthy and eats and exercises so that's good if so then I aspire to look like that ahha she looks fabulous
Yea! Literally I would want to lose weight like her. And become just as fabulous
Still one of the best Kpop Girl Group Songs. There's something about f(x) that just screams "class" and "elegance". Will forever love them.
No Kpop without f(x)! SM has to open his eyes and see that f(x) has a huge impact on Kpop girl group concept. They introduced so many concepts and all the members are multi talented! This is such a waste! They have a good fanbase too! We, MeUs need f(x) to make a comeback! SM please!
Krystal will always be THAT center. Girlie is unmatched.
The ice princess remains supreme
Up till now ❤
@@regitad.p.4789 oop
Agreed, she's so cool and elegant
let's take a moment and appreciate this piece of art
BRILLIANT choreography!
Lunas body is my goals
same I miss f(x)
myjunghoseok IM JEALOUS
me too her body is so beautiful so sexy IM JEALOUS I WANT THIS TOO and I want to weigh as much as Sulli Im 14 shes 25 and she weighs 41 then theres me with .. ;((((
how can I sneeze like Sowon?
omg you're 14?? I thought you were a lot older lol
"myjunghoseok"
He's mine too but I love your username
Vic is just so effortlessly graceful.
Years passed and there's no one like Krystal. She's effortlessly cool and elegant, best it girl Kpop ever had.
I agree with all my heart. Hyomin as well was something else.
Krystal's aura is cool and attractive
No one is gonna be on her level.
No need for wink and other extra expressions, her aura alone is strong. ❤️
@@pinkbloodedmultistan i’ve been looking for this comment 💘
It's really satisfying cause all of them giving dominant aura at the freakin same time. You can't even focus to one member cause all of them are catchy and aesthetic.
4 walls is really a great maze concept. This is totally different from their past songs and this literally gives me goosebumps. Ohhhh!!!
F(x) slay slay slay
Ikr!
+Eya toot TOTALLYYYYY
+Eya toot nu abo era is back haha
+Jerico Maglasang i think rude love would be cool also papi, that song is a party
I feel u all.. let them have their first concert and it will be a boom
can yall believe krystal was only 21 here!? and 21 was the last time she released an album with her group. sm really wasting their youth!
IKR!
So true
They really did and i havent seen any solos if they dont do that for her then shes just wasting time not leaving sm
@@cliavrei she's leaving now, SM dont have all of the f(x) member anymore,
They gonna do the same with red velvet, this happens every time SM deputes a new group, we have to do something, I can't stand there and watch those iconic artists being neglected that way, that company is burying them alive it ruined their dreams ..
BoA, super junior, shinee, fx, snsd ,exo,red velvet,nct those great artists don't deserve this.
We need to do something for them as they did a lot and gave us great songs and made us happy..
Let's save them guys, please 🥺
This choreography still remains as one of the most graceful, elegant and powerful dance in the kpop industry
SM WHEN ARE YOU GOING TO GIVE THEM A COMEBACK JEBALYO!!!! 💔
joaandayao I'm still waiting...
Did they disband?
Lullabyo no
Lullabyo SM can be a bitch many times but at least she does not disband groups. No, they did not disband ☺️☺️
Sm doesnt give official announcements when groups disband (or at least thats what i heard) so they couldve actually disbanded
The visuals, the talent, the music, the choreography, the aesthetics. They have everything that is to offer and still . There are now many hot girlgroups with extreme popularity but they are no where near this level. Kpop has not been ready for f(x).
yeaaaaaah 🙌
I'm still not over how great this is... Not sure I ever will be ㅠㅠ
I've been watching the live performances every day haha
ikr me too I'm never tired of there songs and voices
don't be tired of them!!!
+nameless :/ don't worry, I'm not tired of them ^_^
+Awkward Luc Love your reaction for the MV and This perf ;)
Fx Fx
oh I'm glad you enjoyed it :)
ソシのカムバを知って、えぷの4人の並びもまた見たいな…と思って見にきました
Who's watch this in 2020??? Miss them😭 ( and now its 2021 already ) 😩
Desy Ekatama World Me...i really miss them
Me
I'm watching Victoria's drama "find yourself " and i just came here cuz it reminded me of f(x), and how so much things have changed and i miss them
me!
SM deleted f(x)’s stage video which get 10m view
I’m angry
this is so legendary. i never thought a live stage could be so lit yet aesthetic
Who else has a massive crush on Amber ?
lol meee
Idk why but i dont like her >_>
Bangtang Nightcore I will never understand you
+Bangtang Nightcore I didn't really like her too
meeeeeee
まだ4wallsに閉じ込められたままでいる
Me too
idk why but every time Luna is given a choreography, she completely slays in and makes it her own. Luna is a true performer!!!
HELL YEAH APPRECIATE LUNAAA
They should have a reality TV show of F(x)!!!!! love these ladies!
I think they have 2 ?
+aleciram TS AMAZING F(x) & F(x) KOALA
+Chisi A Xiong They have Four to be exact. Hello f(x), Amazing f(x), and Koala f(x) (which doesn't have Amber :( She was on hiatus at the time :( ), and Go! f(x)
+OkpOkpX2 SURE DID! :O Thank you!
+Kitty LissieGirl I meant have a new one!
It's been 5 years. But this song, this performance, still could fit into the current generation. I mean if I didn't know enough and people said this is a current comeback, I would believe them.
anyone 2024? this is still iconic!
Krystal's body tho 😍
yes
I'm Krystal biased but damn.. couldn't stop staring at Vic here, she looks flawless.
Also, it's been 84 years, when are f(x) gonna make another comeback?
no 86 nearly now.
♪（ｖ＾＿＾）ｖ ł
Josephine Gardner now 87 cause it’s 2019
Sm will never make a comeback for them... It's a shame
Nah it's 90 because this is 2022.
All of their body are goals. 💜 so proud of my queens. (rewatching since i miss them as a group)
Wait did they spilt up
+Helen Huynh no, no. they just haven't had a promotions as a group since theyre busy with individual projects and i miss them working as a group ^^
Marah Allen Bilang ikr
"4 walls" definitely inspired "naughty" to come out
Yea
Trueee
no.
@@joyfurry1803 Yes.
They've both go that uk garage sound, also thst sort of edm very prevalent in vogueing
I just realised how strong of a comeback this was, statement vice. They are trying to show how strong fx is even when Sulli left the group. Lyrics and the choreo, especially with how teamwork based it is.
2019?
*sm needs to give them a comeback*
Ikr
I've(We've) been waiting for 3 years and 3 months 👻 SM, where's f(x)'s comeback? 😧
*They need a mf Comeback*
ยังฟังอยู่
This comment might be out of place, but f(x) might be one of the only groups that can pull off unique fashion(like, weird in a good way kind of clothes). Not saying that their outfits here was awful, in fact they looked really good here.
That tennis skirt which literally every new girl group have worn? f(x) was the first to use it.
hellfakinaway I agree w f(x) being iconi but rv w their zzbm comeback & wendy’s cactus shirt 😳
@@aurora-sq8xx lmao cactus shirt 😂💀💀
highkeycrying it’s actually a bag🤩🤩🤩🤩
Can we talk of back-up dancers? They danced the whole song in a blindfold. That MUST have take skills and talent.
arent those blindfolds they wearing is transparent?
@@mirra_wan obv but it's still hard to dance in
I WISH THEY'D PERFORM THE WHOLE ALBUM. CAUSE ITS..... A M A Z I N G.
Lotte thats right.... and DEJA VU!
theyre finally getting their own concert so they can
YES....... A CONCERT MEAN OFFICIAL FANCLUB SOON!!! ^^
+ForeverAndAlways really? how can i have no idea bout this? gosh damn where
+Dita May can you give me recommendation song from the album ?
Victoria is so beautiful 😍😍😍
+1
🔝💯
+1
X4. A girlcrush.
Elegantly gougeous!
they make weird moves look so pretty
Ikr
+Yuu Willson yass, that swap hair move tho xD
that was just my point too...
xiaoten Victoria makes it looks FLAWLESS
I miss f(x) so much. Its such a pity that sm wasted their best girl group ever. The visuals, the talents no one can replace them.
True
Very agree
Luna is STUNNING!
so Stunning!❤
this is still one of the most iconic comebacks in kpop history, the fits, the song, too iconic
👏👏👏👏👏 THIS
f(x) and their concept are sooo extra... they pulled it off! It's not easy. Not so many idols doing this kind of concept.. awww miss this group so much. Sigh
다른 여 아이돌들은 무대를 보면 그들의 피눈물 나는 노력이 겹쳐 보이는데, 함수 무대보면 천재성이 보이면서 자연스럽게 무대를 장악함. 크리스탈은 이름이 크리스탈 아니랄까봐 얼굴에 하이라이트 조명킨거 마냥 무대할때 반짝 반짝 빛남... 빅토리아는 긴팔다리 춤선 예술이고 , 루나 목소리 미쳤고, 앰버 랩 너무 세련되고.... 컴백 기다리는 언니팬이얌 !!! 한명한명 너무 소중해 설리포함 💜
CAN WE TALK ABOUT HOW GORGEOUS MY BIAS LUNA IS? AND NO, SHE S ALWAYS BEEN MY BIAS SINCE 2012!
samesamesamesamesamesamesamesamesamesamesamesamesame
And when she was strutting at 0:29 got me like yO LUNA LUNAAAAA
I KNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOWWWWWWW
+XLKSLBCCDTKS 12 SHE'S OWNING THIS ERA
+ohohsehunnie YAS SHE IS! FINALLY IT'S HER TIME TO SHINE
Victoria tho! She looks stunning why does nobody mention that!!
MeganLeeslie yes, she's extremely beautiful. Don't be sad tho at least she gets rememberd and noticed more than Luna.
민창미 I see her
HOLY SHIT LUNA AND VICTORIA LOOK SO GORGEOUS
This was another level of k-pop. Legendary times
f(x) always have the most interesting and intricate choreo out of all the k-pop girls' groups... love them!
the moment f(x) saved K-pop last year.
No one gonna talk about how the backup dancers is wearing blindfolds
Edit: thanks for 1.2k likes ❤️
I literally command-f to see if there were any convos about the blindfolds, lol.
Bird Box
SAAndy they’re probably see through
the material's actually translucent, but it's probably still pretty hard to dance with those on lol
see thru blindfolds
この曲知って3年目だけどまじで飽きないずっっっっっっっと聞いてる
Backupdancer : "I just bought new mascara and eyeliner for f(x) stage tomorrow"
SM : Here blindfolded your eyes for your performance.
Backupdancer : But...
Actually, this was already expected. During performances without Victoria, they had two backup dancers who wore similar things. I think it's a really nice touch, not just because it helps you focus on f(x). Also because it looks super cool on stage and no one else does it like this. Makes it look mysterious.
They must be proud as fx backup dancers
+asy.rna28 I laughed so hard to this LOLL
Tha fact that this performance reached 7 million proves that us MeU's are soooooo thirsty for a comeback loooool.
It could also be the fact that Llamaber looks so hawt here XD
4 walls is way ahead of its release. i mean, this kind of song could've achieved more impact if it is released around this time. like it's really a bop. AND SM GIVE THEM A FREAKIN COMEBACK ALREADY.
It was right but ofcourse koreans won't really have this if it weren't for f(x). They are trendsetters and they introduced a lot of stuff and contributed to the music industry. That's why they're underrated that time because they were so ahead that they are the ones who have to introduce this kind of music to koreans.
I agree with you
Miss them everyday ): They were my first group
I wish f(x) were still a thing , these girlies had so much potential and uniqueness, i feel outraged that such a group have been wasted .
Amber's hair is look so fabulous
i must say, f(x) is the girl group who has the most awesome and hard choreographies
Agreee
agree!!
sorry my, dear what they mean is a flawless one..haha.. but i bet they had also that hard choreo..
Hann Clarke i stan f(x) but if you prefer harder choreos i recommend you watching gfriend's or red velvet's :)
Dreamcatcher..?
I literally died. I am typing this comment from the grave.
How's the wifi down there??
rest in peace
Omg I'm subscribed to you! You're a kpop fan asghasasad
hi darcei
I love uuuuuuu and I miss fx 🥺🥺
After seeing bunch of Y2K concepts, I always come back to this simplicity. I enjoy other concepts but this level of aesthetic is just surreal.
Can i just say that Victoria is such a goddess and a masterpiece she just makes my day and F(X) always slay us waiting for their comeback thé queens.
f(x) is probably one of the best things that happened in the kpop industry. these ladies are oozing with talents and visuals. nothing compares to them. no matter what happens, they are legends.
hi i'm YG stan, but objectively i really like this song after view from shinee. i hope SM have a lot of music like this. congrats SM and fighting fx
+audia putrika kecil and the choreography is absolutely great
+audia putrika kecil i hope they make a dance mv or a dance practice... but mv dance ver is better (huehehehehe) like shinee's married to the music. i recommend that to you too :)
omg im another YGstan here!! i never really liked other groups until Fx.. this is surely a great comback. im waiting for 2ne1. it makes me expecting for them tho haha
yeaaaaa ygstanNN but im still waiting for lee hi. like mai gad i miss her voice
+audia putrika kecil yh, first sm does electronic and dubsteppy kinda stuff and now they're bringin' it back in time with 90's house and other genres lol
I REALLY MISS THEM !!!!!! MISS F(X) SO MUCH!!!! NO ONE CAN MAKE THIS CONCEPT OF GIRLBAND BUT F(X) :" IM LITERALLY CRYING