Star Wars died the second George Lucas sold the rights to Disney. Look, I’m all for a strong female lead. But that requires time and very good character development. But when you forcefully make a movie based on and for political agenda and purposes, that’s when things go to crap.
We just need good stories! Stay away from the gender politics and just tell good stories with people who appreciate the world they’re diving into. I agree with you 💯
No....we are in the era of politics. Everything must be made with social justice as the priority always. Story telling and entertainment value have no place here
Right. Now anytime it's a black person or a woman lead in a disney movie I assume its gonna be bad. Is it because I'm sexist or racist? No. Its because they cant make movies with those leads without focusing solely on their identity and having a terrible story. Specifically Falcon I was so excited for him to be captain america until i saw the show :(
@@Nodnarb69 I thought Falcon was actually really good. Could’ve landed a lil better, but that show is underrated. It set up falc’s transition well, revealed the OG cap, and set winter soldier up for his redemption path.
@@Micah-Woods yeah i mean it did good in those areas. I espeically loved how they showed how special captain america was and how someone like wyatt russels character cant measure up to him. But they took his shield and misrepresented just to talk about kneeling during the anthem. It was so disrespectful
As a woman this makes me angry. I totally agree with what ur saying. A woman should not be given this opportunity just because of her gender. It just makes us look bad. The job should go to the person with the best story.
That was a problem with the books as well, some authors told amazing stories with the characters, while others gave us Splinter Of The Minds Eye and other books that didn't get the personalities of the characters even close.
No way! awesome we have been loving Percy its such a fun show! Also love how honest and thoughtful you were in this video it was great! Gotta have ya on the channel for an interview one day!@@CosmicPopTalk
This is the problem with all of Disney and what's funny is most women don't even support these projects because maybe it's bad writing bad acting or just bad storyline. Regardless of your mission people still want just good movies
Love it that you have a channel to voice your opinions now! Everything you said here is 100% true. What exacerbates everything you said is when the industry ignores the customers. Rotten Tomatoes removed the dislike button for Captain Marvel.Star Wars labeled fans as racists, bigots, or extreme right, some as incels. All Star Wars fans and Marvel fans want is good movies. We don’t need gender/race swapping or OP women. We need great stories ie black panther
The actress who plays Ray would be smart to be vocal. If I were her, I would not want to be attached to any KK does. She's destroying the franchise and I wouldn't want to be part of the destruction she leaves in her wake.
Yes, they are. They keep forgeting that character need to be written well, and that story need to come first. Much of what you covered in about the she hulk cancellation video stand for Star Wars as well.
Kathleen Kennedy has got to go. I honestly feel bad for this director. She is obviously a poor choice for this job and has been given this position for the wrong reasons, being pushed into it with a directive that was completely tone deaf to what the fans want...she is probably a very impassioned and courageous film maker who really has her heart in the right place but it was doomed before she even got the job. The reason that Favreau was able to do such a great job with the first 2 seasons of Mando is that he understands what the broader appeal of this ip is. Filoni is a bit to much of a fantasy nerd to get that, Abrams is too much of a hack to have any vision, Kennedy is a suit without a clue..maybe even Favreau isnt enough to save this ship with all that surrounding him. Idk. Sad to say but it may just be better if starwars goes away for 5-10 years and waits for the right person to guide it. But lets face it...thats not going to happen.
I had to let go of my adoring love of Star Wars when Lucas sold it and the story group destroyed the EU. I still watch, but through my fingers with my anus puckered tight enough to produce Glitterstim Spice
Ugh. “it’s about time we had a woman to shape the story” massive red flag right there. That just tells me she’s not interested in the whole Star Wars storytelling but is more interested in making a name for herself. To her she comes first not the story. George Lucas became who he was because he wanted to tell a story rather than get famous. We loved Wonder Woman because it was Gal Gadot 😏😉 but yeah the story was good compared to the 2nd
Rey was terrible in the last trilogy from the very beginning she knew how to fight without training she KNEW how to fly the falcon without training she knew how to use the force without training they pretty much made her the best in everything so they just gave her everything. And the most ridiculous thing that they did was not have luke Leia and Han in the same scene together which was disgraceful
I’m ok with a strong female characters but I agree. It’s all about the story. We have not had a good story since Rogue 1. Some may disagree but well that’s my opinion. The Rey trilogy sucked. Some parts were ok but for the most part it sucked. Poor directing, horrible script and the Rey character was over powered from the opening shot. I’m sorry but true Star Wars fans and lovers of the franchise have had enough of the trash. Favraugh is making a Grogu and Mando film. That to me will be EPIC in every way. John loves Star Wars and knows the fans and the lore so those are the kind of people , whether male or female i truly don't care, that we want to make Star Wars films. As always just my opinion.
Captain Marvel technically had limits to Her powers in the first film because She was kept from achieving Her full potential. For the record, The Force Awakens was really good because it gave us something familiar after the Prequels spoiled The Empire Strikes Back for New Comers. While Rey was a gifted young student, You could argue Her struggle lied with Spiritual/Heroic Identity, not necessarily physical ability, ask Yourself Why else would She be grappling between the dark and the light? This video is sort of a breath of fresh air because it does not all seem one-sided, It is hard to talk about Film without getting into the social political because both of those go hand in hand.
Thanks for this comment! I ALWAYS hope to love whatever I'm watching, and the movies I don't love, I wish I did. I don't see any point on really bashing things too much, and I like to approach things from different angles. I am actually a fan of the Rey trilogy even though the fandom hates it haha
@CosmicPopTalk Nothing wrong with that, I am there with You! I like The Sequel Trilogy alot! Especially VII, I am mixed on VIII & IX, but still find entertainment value in Them, I own all of Them on Digital and DVD. While it seems like alot, not all of the Star Wars fandom hates the Sequel Trilogy, if You look for them You will find them, I have found a few communities that do like/love the Sequels, some are completely dedicated to it! The Rey Skywalker Spin-Off Film is the one I am most excited to see and where it will take Her Character towards Episode X when a fouth Skywalker Trilogy is inevitably made. You don't have to love/hate everything put in front of You, You can like whatever You want! No opinion is definitive, don't let anyone tell You otherwise. 🙂
I had the same question actually. Maybe the didn’t want it? Since they directed Star Wars already, I want to say they would take the opportunity but maybe we’ll never know. Would have loved for either to direct.
I’m here for a strong female lead, shit I love it when it’s done right actually from arcane to the recent predator movie even all the way back to the OG alien movie, some of my favorite characters in movies, but it’s as you said I will never be happy with pushing an agenda before a good story and it’s so sad that Star Wars is being handled by a dictator right now that doesn’t like Star Wars I genuinely don’t know how you get this lady out that chair at this point. Now personally I’ll never like Rey, I was iffy with the last Jedi but then the rise of skywalker came and I was just completely over any story that has to do with that character , I’m personally not watching anything I don’t want to anymore because these companies take our views as ‘oh they love it 😊’ when it’s more so like we are trying to see if they’re listening to us when we say ‘please stop destroying Star Wars’ i hope for the best in daisy Ridley’s career in the future but as long as she’s the face of Star Wars they can honestly keep it, I’ll watch these 7/10 tv shows before I touch her movies
I totally feel you. Makes sense. I think the studio and studios in general are realizing people just really don’t care about their attempts to pander. Maybe change will come sometime. Fingers crossed! Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment!
I really really like Rey Skywalker but you like I like you said you have to learn first how to you have to learn how to walk first then run I know her and I know where by Heart that you can accomplish this but it's like I said you cannot jump from One 10 Alex bigoton like Star Wars direct in the Star Wars movie I a person of colour to make a Star Wars movie but it is like I said you have to learn how to walk first before you can run that's all that's life that's Marvel Studios en Disney learns this it's all because of storytelling if you can make good stories the audience will follow if you it's just like a leader if a leader makes a good plan the rest will follow but if a plan of a script over of a storytelling isn't good people cannot follow with you and the fans in the audience are going to boycott you and say you can be this you can be that it's all because because the industry doesn't listen to us to the audience to the viewers and that's it that's in life like that I hope hope youthis comment and do this message that I'm sending to you cosmic wonders and yeah I am also a Marvel fan by heart and I want to become a Marvel actor and I want to play Marvel Studios reptile movie and that's what I Call that is my goal because dreams without I just dreams and it's my dream and my heartburn desire to become an actor at Marvel Studios and I hope you read this I say Sean is Sean is a I'm 18 years old and I live in Belgian that's I hope you read this message and yeah for all of them May the Force be
Hey Sean! Thanks for taking the time to write this, I really appreciate it! It’s true, they need focus on good script writing. I also hope you become a successful actor one day! Best of luck buddy!
@@CosmicPopTalk thank you to reply to my message I appreciate it yes it's my dream my how to become an actor in Marvel Studios and I watch always your videos on UA-cam and you're a big experiment to me thank you thank you
Star Wars died the second George Lucas sold the rights to Disney. Look, I’m all for a strong female lead. But that requires time and very good character development. But when you forcefully make a movie based on and for political agenda and purposes, that’s when things go to crap.
Agreed
I totally agree
💯 neo-marxism, oppressor oppressed mentality destroying everything deliberately.
You acting like Force Awakens, hell Last Jedi, Rogue One, Mando and Andor aint good? Enough buddy
@CB0915
Ok force awakens and last jedi sucked hard, mando was great as was rogue one but those apear to be the exception not the rule
We just need good stories! Stay away from the gender politics and just tell good stories with people who appreciate the world they’re diving into. I agree with you 💯
No....we are in the era of politics. Everything must be made with social justice as the priority always. Story telling and entertainment value have no place here
@@apoc5000 😂😭
Right. Now anytime it's a black person or a woman lead in a disney movie I assume its gonna be bad. Is it because I'm sexist or racist? No. Its because they cant make movies with those leads without focusing solely on their identity and having a terrible story. Specifically Falcon I was so excited for him to be captain america until i saw the show :(
@@Nodnarb69 I thought Falcon was actually really good. Could’ve landed a lil better, but that show is underrated. It set up falc’s transition well, revealed the OG cap, and set winter soldier up for his redemption path.
@@Micah-Woods yeah i mean it did good in those areas. I espeically loved how they showed how special captain america was and how someone like wyatt russels character cant measure up to him. But they took his shield and misrepresented just to talk about kneeling during the anthem. It was so disrespectful
As a woman this makes me angry. I totally agree with what ur saying. A woman should not be given this opportunity just because of her gender. It just makes us look bad. The job should go to the person with the best story.
Definitely. I feel it takes away from women who genuinely care about the movies and is used to pander as some kinda weapon.
Why didn’t they hire Bryce Dallas Howard? She checks the woman box and also directed some of the best Mandalorian episodes
That’s an amazing question I would love an answer to
Because she’s not a minority 👍 All the media companies are making a big show and dance about the new director being a minority
That was a problem with the books as well, some authors told amazing stories with the characters, while others gave us Splinter Of The Minds Eye and other books that didn't get the personalities of the characters even close.
That’s really the problem. Until they focus on good storytelling, I fear we won’t get good content.
I missed George Lucas writing good stories and creating new characters in Star Wars
Me too but me too
RIP star wars
This is great! Love that you have started a new channel to be able to express your thoughts this is awesome! Love this!
Thanks so much! I enjoy yall's Percy Jackson ep 1 reaction!
No way! awesome we have been loving Percy its such a fun show! Also love how honest and thoughtful you were in this video it was great! Gotta have ya on the channel for an interview one day!@@CosmicPopTalk
Short answer? Yes. . . Yes they are.
Same thing with MARVEL
Bro, you hit the nail right in the head with EVERYTHING you said on this video!!!! 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💪💪💪💪💪💪💪
George Lucas was a genius. I feel like there are a ton of other writers who would make more sense.
Regardless of how the franchise is managed, I'll always look forward to seeing the Star Wars universe expand, especially new planets!
Exactly
Of course that destroy Star Wars Luckett who is a god
You nailed it, I absolutely agree.
YES! This is what I’ve been saying for years. Story MUST come first. And the majority of the time it’s not first.
This is the problem with all of Disney and what's funny is most women don't even support these projects because maybe it's bad writing bad acting or just bad storyline. Regardless of your mission people still want just good movies
Love it that you have a channel to voice your opinions now! Everything you said here is 100% true. What exacerbates everything you said is when the industry ignores the customers. Rotten Tomatoes removed the dislike button for Captain Marvel.Star Wars labeled fans as racists, bigots, or extreme right, some as incels.
All Star Wars fans and Marvel fans want is good movies. We don’t need gender/race swapping or OP women. We need great stories ie black panther
Love the marvel channel had to follow your journey over here, best of luck 🙏
Thanks so much I SUPER appreciate your support!
The actress who plays Ray would be smart to be vocal. If I were her, I would not want to be attached to any KK does. She's destroying the franchise and I wouldn't want to be part of the destruction she leaves in her wake.
Nope will not watch another star wars project...any project until sith lord K. K. IS NO LONGER employed by Lucas film.
I think they messed up the sequel trilogy. Also, they have to stop relying on nostalgia to rest the franchise on.
Yes, they are. They keep forgeting that character need to be written well, and that story need to come first. Much of what you covered in about the she hulk cancellation video stand for Star Wars as well.
Supporting the homie ! 🤙🏻
Thanks so much! I really appreciate it!!!
Until Kathleen Kennedy is out, I’m out.
Just boycott Disney wake up people
I don't think anybody's qualified to write Star wars stories
Warren is our here speaking some FACTS!
I don't like Star Wars but I agree with this!
Warren said my thoughts the best! She's just not QUALIFIED for this franchise! BOOT HER OUT!
I don’t know how i feel about what’s next for star wars
Kathleen Kennedy has got to go. I honestly feel bad for this director. She is obviously a poor choice for this job and has been given this position for the wrong reasons, being pushed into it with a directive that was completely tone deaf to what the fans want...she is probably a very impassioned and courageous film maker who really has her heart in the right place but it was doomed before she even got the job. The reason that Favreau was able to do such a great job with the first 2 seasons of Mando is that he understands what the broader appeal of this ip is. Filoni is a bit to much of a fantasy nerd to get that, Abrams is too much of a hack to have any vision, Kennedy is a suit without a clue..maybe even Favreau isnt enough to save this ship with all that surrounding him. Idk. Sad to say but it may just be better if starwars goes away for 5-10 years and waits for the right person to guide it. But lets face it...thats not going to happen.
1000 % Agree with you..👍👍👍
Star Wars: it’s about time we have a woman come forward. Me and 90% of the casual and hardcore fans: who cares
Facts
I had to let go of my adoring love of Star Wars when Lucas sold it and the story group destroyed the EU. I still watch, but through my fingers with my anus puckered tight enough to produce Glitterstim Spice
Disney, marvel. Star Wars I hope you are watching this video. Please take notes so that we can no longer have anymore drama.
I watch every single one of your videos can’t wait for the echo show breakdown keep up the grind!
Thanks Ethan! You’re awesome and I really do appreciate the support!!!
Marvel yeah and has been messing up Star Wars it’s just a joke of a franchise
Hopefully they can get their act together and make good stuff again!
Simply put....Yes...
I mean, they killed Spiderman, why not star wars too
Agree 💯
Regardless of context, there are consequences about what you say.
Ugh. “it’s about time we had a woman to shape the story” massive red flag right there. That just tells me she’s not interested in the whole Star Wars storytelling but is more interested in making a name for herself. To her she comes first not the story. George Lucas became who he was because he wanted to tell a story rather than get famous.
We loved Wonder Woman because it was Gal Gadot 😏😉 but yeah the story was good compared to the 2nd
Star Wars is rogue one, a new hope, empire strikes back, return of the Jedi and the first two seasons of the Mandalorian. Just ignore the rest of it
I’ve always said just turn the legends books into movies and they’d save themselves
Rey was terrible in the last trilogy from the very beginning she knew how to fight without training she KNEW how to fly the falcon without training she knew how to use the force without training they pretty much made her the best in everything so they just gave her everything. And the most ridiculous thing that they did was not have luke Leia and Han in the same scene together which was disgraceful
Watched the video but don’t need to. The answer is yes and will always be yes.
100%
I’m ok with a strong female characters but I agree. It’s all about the story. We have not had a good story since Rogue 1. Some may disagree but well that’s my opinion. The Rey trilogy sucked. Some parts were ok but for the most part it sucked. Poor directing, horrible script and the Rey character was over powered from the opening shot. I’m sorry but true Star Wars fans and lovers of the franchise have had enough of the trash. Favraugh is making a Grogu and Mando film. That to me will be EPIC in every way. John loves Star Wars and knows the fans and the lore so those are the kind of people , whether male or female i truly don't care, that we want to make Star Wars films. As always just my opinion.
Yesss. You're right.
Captain Marvel technically had limits to Her powers in the first film because She was kept from achieving Her full potential.
For the record, The Force Awakens was really good because it gave us something familiar after the Prequels spoiled The Empire Strikes Back for New Comers.
While Rey was a gifted young student, You could argue Her struggle lied with Spiritual/Heroic Identity, not necessarily physical ability, ask Yourself Why else would She be grappling between the dark and the light?
This video is sort of a breath of fresh air because it does not all seem one-sided, It is hard to talk about Film without getting into the social political because both of those go hand in hand.
Thanks for this comment! I ALWAYS hope to love whatever I'm watching, and the movies I don't love, I wish I did. I don't see any point on really bashing things too much, and I like to approach things from different angles. I am actually a fan of the Rey trilogy even though the fandom hates it haha
@CosmicPopTalk Nothing wrong with that, I am there with You! I like The Sequel Trilogy alot! Especially VII, I am mixed on VIII & IX, but still find entertainment value in Them, I own all of Them on Digital and DVD.
While it seems like alot, not all of the Star Wars fandom hates the Sequel Trilogy, if You look for them You will find them, I have found a few communities that do like/love the Sequels, some are completely dedicated to it!
The Rey Skywalker Spin-Off Film is the one I am most excited to see and where it will take Her Character towards Episode X when a fouth Skywalker Trilogy is inevitably made.
You don't have to love/hate everything put in front of You, You can like whatever You want! No opinion is definitive, don't let anyone tell You otherwise. 🙂
Star wars is done to me. And will never watch anything..
Is Disney killing Star Wars? They’re pulling a John Wick on Star Wars!
Hahaha 😂
How does Howard and Chow feel about this when they put in the work in the SW universe on Mandolorian and getting leapfrogged over?🤔
I had the same question actually. Maybe the didn’t want it? Since they directed Star Wars already, I want to say they would take the opportunity but maybe we’ll never know. Would have loved for either to direct.
There's a chance they rejected the offer.
Im sad about the film but Im glad we still have star wars series and it's dying..
I’m here for a strong female lead, shit I love it when it’s done right actually from arcane to the recent predator movie even all the way back to the OG alien movie, some of my favorite characters in movies, but it’s as you said I will never be happy with pushing an agenda before a good story and it’s so sad that Star Wars is being handled by a dictator right now that doesn’t like Star Wars I genuinely don’t know how you get this lady out that chair at this point. Now personally I’ll never like Rey, I was iffy with the last Jedi but then the rise of skywalker came and I was just completely over any story that has to do with that character , I’m personally not watching anything I don’t want to anymore because these companies take our views as ‘oh they love it 😊’ when it’s more so like we are trying to see if they’re listening to us when we say ‘please stop destroying Star Wars’ i hope for the best in daisy Ridley’s career in the future but as long as she’s the face of Star Wars they can honestly keep it, I’ll watch these 7/10 tv shows before I touch her movies
I totally feel you. Makes sense. I think the studio and studios in general are realizing people just really don’t care about their attempts to pander. Maybe change will come sometime. Fingers crossed! Thanks for taking the time to watch and comment!
Here for you sir
You always are! You’re the best!
Nope
📚📃 stories 🙋
Did she not forget that we had a woman lead the whole sequel trilogy?! Lol
Evidently she did lol
What's star wars
you're too nice
Oh yea new channel!
Thanks for being here!!!
@@CosmicPopTalk fasure
Just subbed
I really really like Rey Skywalker but you like I like you said you have to learn first how to you have to learn how to walk first then run I know her and I know where by Heart that you can accomplish this but it's like I said you cannot jump from One 10 Alex bigoton like Star Wars direct in the Star Wars movie I a person of colour to make a Star Wars movie but it is like I said you have to learn how to walk first before you can run that's all that's life that's Marvel Studios en Disney learns this it's all because of storytelling if you can make good stories the audience will follow if you it's just like a leader if a leader makes a good plan the rest will follow but if a plan of a script over of a storytelling isn't good people cannot follow with you and the fans in the audience are going to boycott you and say you can be this you can be that it's all because because the industry doesn't listen to us to the audience to the viewers and that's it that's in life like that I hope hope youthis comment and do this message that I'm sending to you cosmic wonders and yeah I am also a Marvel fan by heart and I want to become a Marvel actor and I want to play Marvel Studios reptile movie and that's what I Call that is my goal because dreams without I just dreams and it's my dream and my heartburn desire to become an actor at Marvel Studios and I hope you read this I say Sean is Sean is a I'm 18 years old and I live in Belgian that's I hope you read this message and yeah for all of them May the Force be
Hey Sean! Thanks for taking the time to write this, I really appreciate it! It’s true, they need focus on good script writing. I also hope you become a successful actor one day! Best of luck buddy!
@@CosmicPopTalk thank you to reply to my message I appreciate it yes it's my dream my how to become an actor in Marvel Studios and I watch always your videos on UA-cam and you're a big experiment to me thank you thank you