In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful. 1. Say, “He is God, the One. 2. God, the Absolute. 3. He begets not, nor was He begotten. 4. And there is nothing comparable to Him.”
"Put on the full armor of God, so that you can take your stand against the devil's schemes. For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. Therefore put on the full armor of God, so that when the day of evil comes, you may be able to stand your ground, and after you have done everything, to stand. Stand firm then, with the belt of truth buckled around your waist, with the breastplate of righteousness in place, and with your feet fitted with the readiness that comes from the gospel of peace. In addition to all this, take up the shield of faith, with which you can extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one. Take the helmet of salvation and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God." Eph. 6:11-17🕊✝️🙏 Jesus Christ loves you and all will bow ✝️🕊🙏
@Hadi Asadullah if Allah is the creator and “the most merciful”, as Muslim’s claims than why would he tell his followers not to have any mercy on his other creations (animals)? Either Allah is not merciful or he’s not a god! He can’t be both!
I am a widow. I was married to my Sikh husband for 31 years. I miss him. He died in 2021. I love listening to the teachings and debates I find them calming to me. Satnam Waheguru ji
Jugular cutting is less painful & more quicker a death & drains all the blood. FYI.😒 And if you are so concerned about pain don't eat animals in the first place! 🤷
Bro I went to a halal restaurant and I swear majority of the ppl eating in there with their families were Sikhs lol they guys hate us just for the sake of hating us lol. This goes to show you that they have no light in their hearts
Guru Gobind Sahab wanted a painless method.From common sense of that time it seemed jatka is quick method,but we now know spinal cord has sensory nerves.Brain is alive for 5 minutes even after head is cut off and animal feels great pain of cut nerves of spinal cord.In halal 1st pain centers are made numb by cutting main blood vessels of brain carotid arteries quickly and then after 5 minuted spinal cord is cut.
@@whitetiger9974 what about the pain and sensation in the rest of the body? Jhatka cuts off any communication between the brain and the rest of the nervous system, including pain receptors.
@@lwolfer5170 Bro that is laymans knowledge of brain and spinal cord.Spinal cord has pain reflex arc without involving brain.Spinal cord is very rich in sensory nerves.
Muslims should ask themselves if someone offers you a choice of any kind of death for yourself would you want a quick death a Sikh way or a slow painful death a Muslim way? Just be honest what death would you choose? Just try this easy experiment at home to help you choose especially if you have really hairy arms, put bandage on your arm then peel it off slowly feel the pain, now peel it off quickly see the difference now be honest with yourself what’s more painful 😖
So you are comparing decapitation with hair removal. Head decapitation done swiftly is more painful because the animal still fills pain with whatever nerve he has left plus his head is rolling on the cold hard ground, is it humane? Have you seen a head decapitation like that? See both of them and tell me which is more honored.
When a lion catches it's prey it holds the animal from the bottom of neck not from top. Being a Christian I found Halal is healthy and delicious food 👍
nonsense ! The back neck cut ensures that the spinal cord is cut and the nervous system is instantly impaired so that the animal doesn't suffer long at all
Wrong absolutely incorrect because ur jugular vain is the main vein that keeps u alive if u cut that first it’s the quickest way of dying u guys go the opposite direction and don’t even cut the jugular vein till last that causes maximum pain and that’s beyreham
Thats the point, but they dont see. Its better for them to have their own food certificate for sikh...then no issues. We muslims just need ourselves aware of our religion knowledge so we know what, why things like that.
@@Sidhu.7.9 Go and watch DR . ZAKIR NAIK'S video of halal vs haram meat ....he has explained very well that how the halal way proceeds to cause minimal or no pain to the animal ...have a look at that beautiful video.
no mercy? the way its supposed to be is that the animals neck is slit slightly and one of the veins is cut in this, not allowing it to feel as much pain. The blood drained causes it to become unconscious so the animal doesn't feel pain again
Abdullah dont bother they no the truth and deny it lol they no halal is the only way but they deny thats why Allah told us only the ppl of the books thats quran Bible and torah who can relate to our way of thinking for Sikhs our halal is there haram and are haram is there halal lol wtf?
@@hullie7529 give your head a wobble hullie thats just hate talk and bullshit and you know it is scientifically proven halal is better and healthier for you but you ignore the truth because you want stuff your face with a bacon barm lol you are wat you eat have you ever heard of that saying ?
@@iqrarhussain1122 I'm actually vegetarian but thank you for your concern. It's not hate talk it's just common sense; the most humane way to kill an animal is to stunt it first so they don't feel pain, the same way you'd ask for anesthesia if you were going to have a surgical procedure. Halal sacrifice is full of pain and it doesn't care about the suffering of the animal, and since we have an alternative I oppose it, but I don't care if it's Muslims or Jews or Christians, it's about mercy and compassion to other living beings.
Why are they even considering halal meat? What about all the other forms of meat- kosher, factory slaughtered, etc.. It sounds like a sikh should only eat the meat they slaughter themselves, which again begs the question, why are they even talking about halal meat?
@@unknownranger250 Because it's very fashionable right now to be anti-Muslim! If they talk against kosher, they would find themselves in big trouble. So they pick a weak target. Oh! The Sikhs know which side their bread is buttered!
Main misconception with slaughtering for halal meat is that the throat of the animal is cut. This is incorrect. The jugular vein is what needs to be cut. This is a swift action that renders the animal unconscious with minimal pain in milliseconds.
Most Bravest and peace loving Community in world, nothing more and nothing less than what Guru Saahib told. I really feel proud Indian that Sikhism originated from our country and love them all , Jo Bole So Nihaal, Sat shree Akaal
@@mrahmat7555 Wo to koi Quran naa padhe to bhi nihal hota hai...... Aur rahi baat Hindu hone ki to wo 1500 saal pahle tum bhi the Islam to 600 something me aaya thaa.... Main kya karu isme. Jaise tum khush ho Muslim ban ke, hum bhi khush hain Hindu aur Sikh ban ke.....
@@mrahmat7555 Muhammad jo ek isaayi privaar me pedaa hua tha usnay saari kahaaniya bible aur torah se uthaakr bol diya k islam dharm hai usko kya kahega. aur ram jiski biwi kaun le gya usay khud nhi pta tha aur vo bhagwaan tha aur shivji jo saap ltkaaye ghoomta tha aur saand pr betha hota tha uski biwi jungle me haathi se thikwaake aagyi aur chamatkaar ho gya k ganesh aagya 😂. Bhagwaan tha 😂😂😂. Kmaal haathi ne kiya aur lund poojan shiv ka hota hai. Mahaan ho pooray mahaan. 😂😂
When slaughtering halal the knife will be placed below the larynx on the neck of the animal and with a rapid, uninterrupted cutting motion, the trachea, esophagus, carotids and both jugular veins are completely severed in less than a second. This affects the blood and thus the Oxygen supply to the brain is interrupted, but there is also an instantaneous drop in blood pressure in the brain, and thus the animal's immediate unconsciousness.
Lol your a clown! Go read some books or something! And before you say something, the number one terrorist are the United States. Nobody has as much blood on there hands like the US Armee.
@@Lion_Hamza i am not american and i dont support america. i am from asia and lots of Christians are being slaughtered by isis than america. isis follow islam, america doesnt follow christianity. gladly be a clown than follow islam/isis
We do not consider them Sikhs of the Khalsa, they are lost souls. Just like there are alot of muslims that drink and smoke ruthlessly. They are all just lost people to this physical world and are in need of critical guidance.
@@bbginc694 I cant deny. When I tell people (under circumstances, not proactively) that I dont eat any meat or drink, i hear "what kind of punjabi/sardar(turbaned sikh) are you". And thats sad for me to hear. Sad on the state of how sikhism is being followed or interpreted and what image are we creating.
Dude I am Hindu and I don’t really mind halal food. But if it goes back to serve religious institutions then I am not too fond of it. Religion is a personal thing and no one should be profiting out of it
@Sabito are you dumb? Most Hindus in India eat meat. The vegetarians are in the minority. There are many schools of thought in sanatan dharma. And I am a nastik.
not only Sikhs all Hindus should stop eating Halal meat... all of my non vegetarian friends have switched to Jhatka, and they are convincing others to do so now. Waheguru ji da Khalsa, Waheguru ji di fateh
Halal slaughter kills the animal's brain instantly. Even if the animal's body is responding to the cut, it can't perceive or feel anything because their brain isn't functioning.
@@nialldean9791 I am not for halal but he is right breaking the spin isn't spot on death also it depends on which animal goat has a broken spine might live vs a chicken.. neck jatka is spot in death
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims. The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case. m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@Pathe where's the evidence, I've provided the evidence to prove you otherwise, backed by science and research conducted by Hindus, Atheist and Christians. If you're going to refute then provide credible recent scientific evidence
@@salsabila786 are u serious, all of the scientific evidence (studies) points to it being a painful method. with all animal rights organisations banning it . due to all of the studies, the whole of europe has banned traditional halal, and have replaced it with stunning the animal first.
@@a..d2062 first of all that is not Jhatka, secondly I live in UK and contract across Europe, most countries have not banned it. Kosher does not allow stunning either, however that's not the point. The point is severing from back of animal's neck or front. Understand the comment, video and responses before commenting. Read my initial comment and the link towards the studies, educate yourself before commenting
No disrespect to you bro but all my Sikh friends who I grew up with are practising Sikhs and all wear the 5 ks but they all drink alchol and they all eat halaal meat.
I'm hindu..as I'm frm Punjab as other punjabi hindus I love sikhism.. Je mere guru ji ne keha NO means no.... I wld nvr go to restaurant that serves halal meat.. Wahegur ji
@@prabhleensin sir, do you know that the way islam prescribed to kill an animal is the least painful way that is scientifically proven. You may not believe me but you can search some journals on internet.
@@tasnimshahid3286 I would really love to read any journal that you refer. Please give me links. So far the nervous system theory stays logical to me. Indian cultural system has come out from hit and trial methods and that is why it is most logical to a normal brain which questions everything. Vegetarian diet by Ancient Rishi muni were promoted for us to live a conscious life.
What is Halal Food ??? Do you hate Halal food ? Watch this videos : ua-cam.com/video/n-qRWNXdIBE/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/z7uiEI6ywws/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/gA7-7igGU1I/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/IG6UXKho1b0/v-deo.html ua-cam.com/video/uBQBtLaYOYQ/v-deo.html
Hasan Bahadur Sikhs aren’t supposed to eat meat anyway. Only in time of dire need are we to consume meat, literally in times of death and life. Also, I can’t imagine slitting an animals throat is compassionate, not that killing animal is, but slittings something’s throat means the blood drains out whilst the animal is still alive and doesn’t die instantly.
Are they allowed any meat? Are they allowed to eat meat with blood in it? And the kill method. Depwnda on the butcher. I am Muslim. 1 - no blood 2 - Certain sections of meat cannot be eaten. 3 - praying to show sorrow? Sadness and respect. But thank Allah most important. The killing method depends on the person. So if we change the killing method. Why can you not eat it
People are commenting on which way of killing them is better,from front or back of the neck! The reality is none of them is better when the animal doesn't want to die 🙄💯
@Curtis Jefferson Dude see,you can find millions of these illogical reasons to kill them. No fucking person in the world can stop you from eating /killing them. It's all in your hands, just would ask you to read and research more about what you just said about plants feel pain and circle of Cruelty! Noone on the internet like me can force you,the day you put yourself in their shoes,you'll understand the compassion,you may grow your heart! Best of luck!
@@JesusSaves349 The law basically says that animals should be unconscious as the time of being killed for food. In effect, this law imposes a ban on kosher and halal slaughter of animals. ... Now, the European Union Court of Justice has upheld the law, rejecting the objections of religious groups.
Muhammad died and is in hell for being a false prophet preaching a false god, not the same God of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, or Moses. The true Prophets of God said: Leviticus 26:1 “Do not make idols or set up an image or a sacred stone for yourselves, and do not place a carved stone in your land to bow down before it. I am the LORD your God.” And what did Muhammad do? He took the same exact black stone that the pagans kissed and worshiped in Arabia before him, and now every Muslim bows down to it or the direction it is in! The true Prophets such as Moses would have stoned Muhammad to death. Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 2, Book 26, Num 667 “Umar came near the Black Stone and kissed it and said "No doubt, I know that you are a stone and can neither benefit anyone nor harm anyone. Had I not seen Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) kissing you, I would not have kissed you.”
@@GreekOrthodox7 lol Muhammad PBUH used to pray towards jersualem until he moved to Medina smh. Youre very dull if you think muhammad PBUH used to worship a stone. To become a Muslim you literally have to recite that "there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is his messenger". Literally one of the corner stones of Islam is to worship only God. If he wanted to worship anything else he would not have destroyed the soo many idols that used to surround mecca.
@@GreekOrthodox7 yes of course he died peace and blessings be on him and his entire family. We don’t worship him. It’s hard for you to understand because you worship a man. “ it’s not that the eyes are blind it’s the heart”. Allah hu akbar.
We consider karma as universal law. We have to perform karma, and to attend mukti, we need to abstain from bad karma, thus a Guru only tells us *what to abstain from*
@@HKM-28 not at all bro Whatever Allah nothing to with Allah .i am saying that rise of Shikism was very need of that time of Persicution of Hindus in Mughal Eara.I am saying if you have exprinced any kind of hurt after reading my comment.
@@otakusan005 www.google.com/amp/s/www.britannica.com/amp/story/do-plants-feel-pain BTW lots of Hindu, jain , buddhist do not eat seed , root . And seasonal grain plant die within six months so that we don't have to kill. There is a thing called "Jada Buddhi" in day time pants don't feel pain as night.(it doesn't mean that I should kill big plant If u still doubt it remember it was Hindu who told to world that plant has life. "Jagadish Chandra Bose" Plant perception en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_perception_(paranormal)#:~:text=Indian%20scientist%20Jagadish%20Chandra%20Bose,of%20life%20for%20a%20plant.
If Sikhism is all about compassion, as indeed mentioned in the video, then eating in fast foods should be considered more prohibited than Halal meat. The real concern that Sikhs have is not about Halal meat per se, but rather if there was a *ritual slaughter* involved, which apparently he did not mention in the video. Regarding the topic of animal cruelty, the EEG recorded severe pain after stunning, as opposed to the ventral neck incision (halal). The retention of more blood in the meat after stunning results in unhygienic meat for the consumer, as opposed to VNI, which also makes it fresh for a longer period of time. One thing he also forgot to adress are animals with BSE (mad cow desease)... "For this reason, the USDA requires that all *brain and spinal cord materials* be removed from high-risk cattle " This isn't quite the case when stunning animals may lead to the scattering of brain tissue.
Lmao we sikhs and hindus and all dharmic people dont eat cows . Plus yeah sure studies show . Imma show you videos of them suffering due to halal bullshit .
The animals, such as cows, are mammals...and this would make no difference, but this makes no sense. The halal method involves stunning the animal, so it won't feel pain
Then ban lions and tigers to hunt as well.....and put all these animals in cages along with urselves .phew didn't think wud be so easy. BTW keep hate comments to urselves same to you anytime 😊
i saw a video of yurs. saying do not meat at all. so why here differentiating between halal and jhatka? and why also so much stress on not smoking but not much on not drinking?
I'm Muslim but i only follow what's in my heart bc i know that's God's guidance for me but i only eat chicken n beef meat halal of course but i feel guilty eating it. Something in my heart tells me to stop eating meat but not being able to. This is my journey to figure it out in the future if i should or continue eating those 2 meat only. May God guide me to the right path. Ameen!
This philosophy is contrary to Islamic beliefs and the Sunnah. Whoever adopts it or calls to it has opposed the Qur’an and Sunnah. Allah (the Most High) stated: يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ كُلُوا مِمَّا فِي الْأَرْضِ حَلَالًا طَيِّبًا وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا خُطُوَاتِ الشَّيْطَانِ ۚ إِنَّهُ لَكُمْ عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ “O mankind! Eat of that which is lawful and good on the earth, and follow not the footsteps of Shaitan. Verily, he is to you an open enemy.” (Al-Baqarah: 168) Allah has permitted all food that He made lawful and good for people. Vegans adopt a totally animal-free lifestyle which opposes this and other Quranic verses. Allah (the Most High) also stated: يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا أَوْفُوا بِالْعُقُودِ ۚ أُحِلَّتْ لَكُم بَهِيمَةُ الْأَنْعَامِ إِلَّا مَا يُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ غَيْرَ مُحِلِّي الصَّيْدِ وَأَنتُمْ حُرُمٌ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ يَحْكُمُ مَا يُرِيدُ “Lawful to you for food are all the beasts of cattle except that which will be announced to you herein―and game is unlawful when you assume Ihram for Hajj or ‘Umrah. Verily, Allah commands that which He wills.” (Al-Mā’idah: 1) Based on this it is harām (prohibited) for a Muslim to adopt a vegan way of life out of choice. It is also impermissible to adopt a vegan diet (due to its underlying philosophy) unless a person is diagnosed with allergies or finds his body is intolerant to all animal products such as milk, eggs, cheese, meat, fish, honey, etc and becomes sick when he eats them. That is because veganism is predicated on saving animals from “human cruelty” and from “usurping their possessions” such as milk, eggs, meat and hide. Allah allowed meat from cattle, game and the produce of the sea: يَسْأَلُونَكَ مَاذَا أُحِلَّ لَهُمْ ۖ قُلْ أُحِلَّ لَكُمُ الطَّيِّبَاتُ ۙ وَمَا عَلَّمْتُم مِّنَ الْجَوَارِحِ مُكَلِّبِينَ تُعَلِّمُونَهُنَّ مِمَّا عَلَّمَكُمُ اللَّهُ ۖ فَكُلُوا مِمَّا أَمْسَكْنَ عَلَيْكُمْ وَاذْكُرُوا اسْمَ اللَّهِ عَلَيْهِ ۖ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ سَرِيعُ الْحِسَابِ - 5:4 “They ask you, O Prophet, what has been made lawful for them. Say, ‘Lawful for you are all good foods and game animals caught by your trained hunting animals which you train as Allah has taught you. So eat of what they catch for you, and mention the name of Allah upon it, and fear Allah…” (Al-Mā’idah: 4)
@@parthdixit7058 When you cut it off from the tree?? Does it not hurt and a lot of vegetables are cut alive in way or the other so it is the same cutting animals!!!!
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you then let them die of hunger as they slowly grow weak and miserable out of scarcity of food or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
nowhere in any gurudwara will you see non veg being served...meat is only allowed if you have to hunt...and you have to hunt only in extreme conditions when there is nothing available...when baba banda singh bahadur was under an eight month long seige then they say even the bark off trees had been consumed and finally they cut their horses to eat..
Cutting through jugular vein cuts the nerve endings connected to brain. This is least painful. It also allows blood to completely drain. Cutting from back of neck spinal cord is harder, slower and the animal feels most pain.
@@harpritsingh9359 He said at 2:52 that the pain sensors are in the neck: so that basically means if you hit the animal in the pain sensor it will cause it pain. Kosher and orthodox Christians also require the animal to be killed via Juglar vein for the same reason.
@@saimshaikh5424 my grandfather owns a farm land and he has many goats. I've seen him performing Jhatka, goats body freeze when head is removed. He also did jhatka on thick neck of boar several times and i also tried once but my sword got stuck in midway from that day on I'm using nail gun. It's easiest and best possible way to give death. And there's really no Sikh way of killing animal written in Sikh Holy book. Sikh holy book says against those who kill animal for taste, fun and for sacrifice or on the name of God. And we use best possible method to give instant death to animal as told by last guru(it's not written in Sikh Holy book, the message was just verbal). And reason behind we avoid Halal, because Halal is slow death. It's suffering for animal. Jhatka is quickest method. Nail gun is even quicker. Nail Gun is so quick that when goat eyes are open they stay open when they're closed they stay close it's like you switched off the running computer. And I'm always open to the newer and best methods.
@@harpritsingh9359 Offcourse bro, and I respect all opinions in all honesty. :) I do believe if a person wants to cause the least amount of suffering to an animal the best way would be to consume them less all together: Or abstain: Today industrialization of meat and high amount of production has lead to us creating an imbalance in ecosystem and overconsumtion of meat: If I want to eat meat on a particular day I don't really think about pain to the animal because I would have been a vegan if that were the case ... because in the natural world when a lion/tiger/alligator is hungry and wants to eat a zebra .... It won't be thinking how that animal gets pain: It goes and eats whether the animal gets pain or not, it will brutally attack and eat what it needs to eat
I love this guy ! I have lot of love for Sikhs as they are honest and brave. 2 of their great gurus have laid their lives for Hindus without even thinking twice ! Hindus will forever be indebted to their Gurus ! Long live Guru Nanak Dev Ji's choosen path !
@Paldeep Singh the Sikhs enemies were never mughals.the sikhs enemy was injustice.today injustice is happening in Jammu Kashmir so the Sikhs have united with the Muslims. The mughals were just Mongols who excepted Islam.
@Paldeep Singh Khalsa Raj will probably end up just like any other country or constitution. It is not the indian constitution which has harmed sikhs, but it is the people who have done. There will always be wicked people around regardless of their faith. I hope you will understand my perspective.
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims. The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case. m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 say hi to all missionaries but guess what nobody's interested so don't copy paste your comment again and again. I dont know what you are trying to prove but you will never succeed following the wrong path.
There are many restrictions in halal way example knife should be shard so that we dont have to put lot of force on animal and so that it doesn't take long time. It should be done at once so that animal doesn't feel pain for long time One animal should not be cut infront of other animal and many more.
Cause LESS pain if causing no pain is not an option for you. Most of the Sikhs are vegetarians. I even know many muslims who are veg. I can even show you quotes in Quran saying muslims should be compassionate too.
@@prabhleensin I feel like his argumentation is built on a youtube video which he uses to judge all halal meat. First of all you don't need to use a small knife, most of the time I saw it, it is done with a huge knife. And it is done to cause the least harm
@@AnimatedIslamicHistory23 No offence but this video is for Sikhs to not eat halal meat and you can continue with your traditions. Though Guru Nanak Sahib said Muslims should follow Prophet Muhammed. And I'm pretty sure Prophet was more compassionate than muslims portray. As a Science student, I know nervous system is right through the spine and cutting that off first leaves no signals reach the brain to feel the pain. So knife size doesnt matter but the reflex. Having said that, it is better not to cause harm to these creatures and opt for a vegetarian diet whenever we can. Allah Rehmat kare.
To be honest, he's right about the halal part. But the fact is we don't know whether cutting the spine in one go causes pain or not. Slitting the throat during halal must cause pain irrespective of whether jugular veins are cut or not because pain receptors still work for few minutes and the brain still works for few minutes before it goes dead. Few moments of oxygen or blood cut to the brain won't cause the brain to stop functioning immediately. Neither the neuro receptors and neurons in our brain would stop working suddenly. So, yeah it's bound to cause pain to the animal. But jhatka probably should also cause pain. How that pain would work is a bit hard to comprehend. So, the best is to abstain from meat consumption if you're really concerned about pain to animals. And it's actually hypocrisy to talk about how Halal is a humane way. You follow halal because it's been written in your books, that's it.
I agree with you: I don't personally don't think there is a right or wrong way to kill an animal and the best way is abstinence: I do think that halal, kosher, and jhatka all cause some level of pain and we can argue on which causes most pain all day long and the end argument will always be that going vegan is the most humane. If I want to eat meat on a particular day I don't really think about pain to the animal because I would have been a vegan if that were the case ... because in the natural world when a lion/tiger/alligator is hungry and wants to eat a zebra... It won't be thinking how that animal gets pain and could care less. : I personally do eat Kosher only since the blood gets fully removed and that is the only reason
😂😂😂 showing a chart of human nervous system. And we do not use small churii btw the knife is big andits sharp not blunt like ur describing to cause minimum pain.
This was allowed back in the time of the Gurus as food wasn't as available as today but is still allowed by the Akal Takt, most Sikhs today are vegetarian as there is no longer a need to eat meat as there is plenty of other food choices.
Brother their were plenty of vegetarian food at that time also, we are talking about 300 years ago..... not about the time of stome age ? And i am sorry to sar brother but today also, most of the sikh i meet are non veg. Even i have found many amrit dhari non veg sikhs, most of them claim that they have taken amrit from HAZUR SAHIB, amd their panj pyaras gives permission to have jhatka meet ... Now according to me this is total violation of our guri's teachings.
Brother have you heard about the story of when Guru Nanak Ji had met a hunter in a forest who had no food, this hunter had asked Guru Nanak Ji if he would allow him to kill and eat an animal in the forest and if Guru Nanak Ji would help him, Guru Nanak Ji allowed him to kill and eat the animal but would not help him in doing so. This is where I found that Guru Nanak is not against eating but also not for eating meat.
+Harmeet Singh I agree with you completely brother today all meat is ate by some Sikhs for taste it is similar to addiction to alcohol, I was saying that the only time when an animal is to be killed and eaten is when there is nothing else. And that story was one of many bedtime stories of Guru Nanak Ji when he was traveling around Asia spreading message of Waheguru. Another story would be when Guru Nanak Ji gave his companion Mardana some berries of a plant but said do not take any more, but Mardana felt he would need some for the rest of the journey however Guru Nanak Ji said not to take them as they were poisonous. Meaning you should not show greed.
+bobby singh so you are also saying that jhatka is to be eaten only as last resort... just for survival... but this is not what sikhs do today. i have seen amritdhari sikhs eating meat and giving excuses that its jhatka and we have permission from panj pyaras. and it is with most of the sikhs now days. people ask me why i am a veg even after being a sardar,,, and they laugh when i say that sikhs are not allowed to eat meat... common image of a sardar in today's world is: non veg amd a tanker(drinker)
I just wanted to say that pain receptors are located in the skin, not only the spinal cord. It's true that with jhatka the animal dies quickly, and this would be merciful as it saves the animal pain. However the blood is not allowed to be drained fully before it dies. Most diseases are carried by blood, and consumption of blood can cause sickness even if properly cooked, so it's vital to get the blood out while at the same time having mercy on the animal, which is the aim of halal. Peace!
Killing an animal by slashing their throat is not painless and consumption of blood DOES not cause sickness in the way you seem to be suggesting it. Halal is brutal and shows a lack of mercy for the animal. No human being, Sikh or otherwise, should touch halal because it's so cruel for the animal involved. I eat meat BUT I will never touch a halal meat if I can avoid it. We stun the animals in Western countries for a reason yet Halal slaughter does not approve of stunning. That's unacceptable!
@@ghaah No, the pain receptors on the skin send it back through the spinal cord to the brain, but technically there are some reflexes that occur in the spinal cord itself without going to the brain so cutting it won't matter there One would also argue cutting both the cartoid arteries would technically cut the blood supply to the brain and causes the animal to lose conciousness while going thru the spinal cord might cause loss of pain but the animal is still aware, and loss of pain is tricky because it depends on which level do you cut, you could possibly lose sensation only in the lower body/chest and still have pain in your neck
Cutting the jugular vein and oesophagus stops the blood/oxygen supply to the brain and with the loss of blood the animal ceases to feel pain and dies. Cutting through the nerves and spinal cord which is far more difficult and therefore likely be slower would cause even more pain felt by the animal as your are cutting thru the ‘pain receptors’.
Exactly... It’s scientific fact. Also cutting through the throat allows maximum release of all the blood. All the toxins and bacteria in blood gets completely drained out. Halal meat is proven to be fresher, tastier and have longer shelf life.
@@masyaf897 nope . Cutting through the spine results in immediate death . Plus in halal the heart loses energy to pump. Leaving in blood instead in jhatka where the carcass is hanged and gravity does the job . Plus brain takes 5 minutes to die in some cases . In halal there is no immediate stoppage of blood therefore it suffers longer compared to jhatka where it goes through . Bruh scientist
Loss of oxygen supply to the brain when nervous system is still fully functional *LITERALLY* causes the animal to suffer from pain until it dies.......... from that pain.... Jhatka is a way more humane way of slaughtering the animal, atleast if not exactly ethical, but still the Jhatka system can manage to put forth arguments supporting itself while Halal and Koshur can only cite pseudo science born out of their desperate mental gymnastics
I Honastly HATE it when someone is talking about a very sensitive topic and some random person does a Jakara and Disrupts the Train of Thought, Jakaras are fine but they also have a time and place where they must be used.
He should not have said "...to cause maximum pain." "...which could cause more pain than other methods..." would be better. But its unfair to pick through someones extemperaneous words and accuse them of dehumanizing Muslims.
I feel like although jatka is allowed a Sikh shouldn't eat it unless it's a matter of life and death... Mahraj allowed jatka but times were different in anandpur.. Food was limited and I felt like jatka of the animals was done to end their misery instead of starving them and making them suffer.. Again these are my views so it's up to you
Brahmjot Singh I'm npot sure if Guru Maharaj exactly allowed meat but when the singhs were fighting in the jungles and in the battles, sometimes they would starve. The Singhs would eat Jhatka meat under the worst case life or death scenarios. Even after they ate the meat, they would feel terrible for doing it. But they were fighting for us so they had to survive. Now this is just what I have heard so it might not be entirely true.
Uncle Bernie Just stop talking before you hurt yourself thinking too hard lol. Stop getting your info off the internet and actually get it from a legit source... Like Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
+Uncle Bernie It is the order of the 10th living Guru to follow Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj as our Guru after him and so we do so. No questions asked. Any living 'guru' or individual is in circumstances prone to corruption of mind, thoughts, actions and money so why follow someone who has all these shortcomings? Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj is a compilation of the shabads( wordings ) of 10 Sikh Guru's and 36 other saints and poets who were obvio alive when they wrote it ( duh ), and their wordings were written down for future generations- uncorrupted. That is- Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj is writings containing true knowledge and we pray to our Guru. What does that tell you? A religion that promotes praying to Knowledge over a person. That's how modern and uncorrupted Sikhi is. Would your living Guru let his own children die to save you? My Guru did. He let his 4 children, young in age than you or me die to save us. That's enough a reason for me to owe my life to him. And if he tells me to bow down to only Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj then may the axis of the Earth tilt or shift but my faith in him and Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj will never shake. Ciao.
Why are there so many mad Muslims? Sikhs are just not permitted to eat meat that was slaughtered in a ritual. This includes halal and kosher. It’s a difference in the religions not an attack on your religion. Move on.
s a muslim we can eat jew kosher meat cause halal and kosher same principle which is makeing the blood shed..I mean if you cant shed the blood that makes people harm and from the trought animals feels less pain actually but maybe the most smart way is not to eat meat at all like me:=)) I love my all sikh friends ,love and respect
actual Fact is Hormones are released a lot more in halal slaughter than Jhatka slaughter. Because when an Animal is witnessing it's life slowly fading away, it panicks & Tries to Breathe & in doing so; Chokes on it's own blood.
Does this also apply to normal slaughtered meat where sometimes the meat is slaughtered in more of an inhumane process such as ringing them up by the legs and stunning them with electricity (in which the animal feels everything but cannot respond)? What would the sikh opinion be on this type of meat being eaten or is just Halal meat that is forbidden?
Nope, only Halal. If there's pork or alcohol being served at the restaurant or meat where the animal was sacrificed to idols or killed by shooting in the face or tortured, it's cool. Just halal. Why? Because Guru said so. That's why.
Firstly halal slaughtering is very merciful brothers. You may watch any informative video on it. Halal meat is healthy too. And as for the method: First you must give the Animal water. Second: separate it from the other animals as to prevent the other animals from witnessing the slaughtering. 3rd; calm the animal, cover its eyes. Use a sharp and fine knife so it won't hurt. And starting from the front causes an immediate death. It severs the jugular and let's the blood completely drain.
@Imposter Among us You mean with out that prayer it is not Halal. You mean the recitment by a muslim is more important than the way the animal was killed! Basically you r saying that even if an animal is killed by slitting it's throat and letting the blood doesn't make it Halal because some verses are recited by a muslim. And because of that it will become Haram for u.
All muslims commenting here doesnt know shit about science. I am a med student and will try to explain using human anatomy. Pain reception is function of different tracts of spinal cord . When you just destroy the spinal cord, a being dies of stoppage of body functions controlled by ans and pns. For example in complete or in complete transverse section of spine at level of cervical vertebrae mostly results in death in humans or cesation of stimuli preception in part of body lower to injury. For a layman, what will be any easy death your throat slit or decapitated. Don't just believe what your imam says.
Scientists say this : The speed and precision of the incision ensures the lack of stimulation of the severed structures and results in the immediate loss of consciousness. Blood flow to the brain is completely halted. In addition, blood empties rapidly from the brain. Irreversible cessation of consciousness and insensibility to pain are achieved, providing the most effective stun.
There are sects within Sikhism . The Most conservative is of the amritdhari Sikhs who don't smoke and drink . They compulsorily have beards and turbans . They are also compulsorily 100% vegetarian . You are baptised in that sect formally . But all others who are not in the sect have a lot of freedom like eating nonveg , drinking , smoking , drugs , no compulsion of facial hair .
M Kashif yes . That's not the problem. The issue is the fact he makes it sound like muslims toture the animal by doing it the halal way. Also by saying we use small knife , making it sound we cause maximum pain deliberately! ! Free to do what they want, but don't lie about other religion! !
I agree with the starting part of the video where he says 'you do it or you don't because the Guru said so', because that's what faith is all about. Unfortunately he doesn't stop there and goes into the science of it and quite evidently without the right knowledge saying things like pain sensors, bereham etc. I respect his religious knowledge but science should be left for the people of science. Saying such things as a spiritual leader is extremely ignorant and misleading. As a doctor I can confirm that from a purely scientific standpoint halaal meat is by far the most clean and consumable form of meat(even kosher is similar). Keep all preconceived notions aside and think about it for a second. When we are ill what is the first laboratory test we do? A simple blood test. Since that's where we can find all the toxins and bacteria in our body. By doing jhatka you are transecting the spinal cord there by eliminating the ability of the animal's muscles to contract. The blood stagnates within in the meat making it toxic. Even if we assume that the blood of the animal is clean and the animal is healthy, we're still drastically reducing the shelf life and consuming meat high in cholesterol. Even my non Muslim colleagues in the hospital prefer halaal meat any day. As far as pain is considered, firstly we cannot make that a criteria for animal slaughter because then we would be contradicting our selves as meat consumers. However, when this respectful guru says 'pain sensors' and points it to the back of the neck, it's absolute nonsense. When you're doing jhatka you're breaking/snapping the neck of the animal. The animal goes into a state of paralysis so there's no way you can guage the pain being felt, just because the animal is not moving doesn't mean it's not feeling the pain. On the other hand though, a small sharp knife is used for halaal because it allows you to slit the major blood vessels of the animal keeping the neck and the spinal cord intact, allowing for twitching of the muscles draining most of the blood, sending the animal into a state of fainting and eventual death, giving you clean meat. I respect my Sikh brothers and their practices but it's my sincere request to the religious leaders to abstain from saying things without knowledge that put people of a certain faith in bad light. An ordinary sikh without any scientific background listening to this lecture would blindly believe that Muslims are 'bereham'.
Yeah, I agree with you 100%. It should've been left at because the Guru says we can't. That's it. That's what Sikhi is about, following the Guru's order. As someone who has grown up in a Sikh family, I've raised this question quite a lot. I have done extensive research on why halal or kosher, etc., and can say yes, it is the best form of meat you can consume. Meat without blood/very minimal blood, is the best form of meat for human consumption. Also, what humans see as muscle contraction after a halal slit of the throat, doesn't necessarily equate to pain in the animal. Also agree with the point that if you're eating meat, you can't be called rehamy just because you kill an animal a certain way and call someone else berehamy for killing an animal another way. Killing an animal is still killing an animal. In my point of view, you're either going to not consume meat or you are. And if you are, you shouldn't justify why you're eating meat slaughtered in a specific way vs another. Just eat and don't judge. Also, my last sentence should be taken lightly as I do not mean to offend anyone or their religious justifications. Just do you and enjoy this life God has blessed us with.
Lovely friend,of you want ti really take care of your health,cut out meat from diet,you are doctor,u know how really bad is. He Is right from my point of way and guys,animal eats not halal meat and they not have all these problems,this doctor Is saying truth,maybe its clean,but believe me for human body isnt that problem. Dont think human body is that weak! If i have to eat meat,i prefer not halal for sure. MacDonald,kfc and other serve only that type 😘
@ apologies for a late addition to the comment section. The video is not going into science, it basically states it’s an order, it then mentions about the format of the kill and how compassionate it is. Generally vegetarian is the order of the day but no one is talking about science or clean meat. It’s the method that is the point to debate!
Just imagine pain and suffering an animal goes through just to satisfy our tounges . This isn't about religion but about humanity in us which has power to reduce someone's suffering no other creature can do that only we can. I know it's hard to leave meat but at least we must have an intent slowly our intent will manifest in action.
I don't agree with your logic.. It's scientifically proved that animal felt no pain while done Islamic slaughter.... Must watch a video I'm sharing the link.. ua-cam.com/video/982culi7rpw/v-deo.html
@@DrRazwanZafar come on it is a common sense that even if a thick needle pricks in you feel pain what about an animal who is butchered animals are sensitive they have a nervous system it is not about religion just humanity your identity is religious mine is humanity . Studies can be easily manipulated everyone knows it but pain and agony we see can't be manipulated animals can't fake emotions. It is like saying murdering by slicing throat is very humane.
Sikhs are my favorite people in the world. I believe Sikhs follow the teachings of Guru Sahab better than us Muslims follow the teachings of Prophet Muhammad. That said, I still believe that Halal meat is better for human consumption than Jhatka even though the latter is less cruel to the animal. But again, killing an animal is cruel in itself. If one is concerned about this, they can always go vegan, Prophet Muhammad himself was a very seldom meat eater. Should you choose to eat meat, why not go Halal and make sure that all the blood (containing toxins) drains out. Either way, I appreciate the Sikh philosophy of people kind to animals. Sat Sri Akaal. Jai Hind.
Guru nanak ne bhi Arab me jakr Prophet Muhammad Saw PBUH ki hi shikhai baton pr Amal Kiya. Or Jo sich panj shanana krte he could bhi vuzu ko badal kr or name bdlkr bataya he ...so name badal kr tum ese galat Mt bolo (abhi to tume halal krna bhi nhi pta Kya hota he tum log sirf Jan bujh kr ye kehte ho k chhuri Aram Aram se gle pr ferte he)jhatke se to lakh jga acha he qk blood k sath toxins bahar aa jate he Jo jhatka krne se nahi ate😏
@@gggg-qp5vz How do you know that Guru Nanak Sahib talked about your prophet stop living in fantasy. Guru Nanak Sahib knew God so he did not have to know about your Prophet.
@Chan Chan Man when a butcher is slautering an animal in the halal way the butcher will say allah is the one and only god and god is greatest so when the butcher says that the almighty god makes the animal feel no pain and the animal surrenders to the almighty god so the butcher could slaughter the animal in piece and animal will be relaxed and feel no pain
but his claims are false Islam began in the 7th century whereas Sikhism began in the 17th century. If Islam was FALSE then why are there many more Muslims around the world than Sikhs?
@@syedlife1571 whether a religion is false or true has nothing to do with how old a religion is. Islam has more followers because its older...Sikhi is a relatively new religion, how do you expect it to have just as many followers as islam or christianity?
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims. The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case. m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 is ur scientific evidence the koran? -_- any person with basic science knowledge will tell u that any method of killing that doesnt iNSTANTLY kill causes suffering to an animal! so stop with this bullshit
Either Jhatka or halal ...u r killing any animal 🦒...I don’t think sikhi allow us to have meat 🥩 unless situation is worse .. might be video is not edited so well ... half knowledge _____ might be ... ( personal comment )
So plants r known to be alive and if humans just eat veg there won't be food left for animals .....also if killing a life is ur concern why not cage up all meat eating animals they r killers too......hope the sharp teeth in ur mouth make some logic to understand meat is imp
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you let then die or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
No disrespect intended but bro you got it twisted. A key function behind the Halal slaughtering method is to minimize the suffering of the slaughtered animal. To the point that the meat of the animal becomes haram (forbidden) to eat once it reaches a specified threshold of suffering. I dont believe the Guru you are referring to actually advised his followers to stay away from halal meat.
Eating any meat is Bajar kurehat... if someone thinks it's not, then go and try to start preaching at Darbar Sahib. .if our Holiest shrine doesn't cook any meat then it makes it clear that We should be vegetarians
Where is the compassion in killing jhatka also? Real compassion is in loving animals and protecting them. We are here on earth with animals. They are not here for us to eat.
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you let then die or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
Don’t drink water as well as that is Halal. By the way, halal means permissible, so anything that is allowed and lawful, for example wearing clothing which you rightfully earned and is not stolen. Therefore, we should take our clothes of as well to follow guru
@@CEarthling please explain why do humans have canine teeth? Why can humans digest meat and not rocks? God made us omnivores for a reason. To answer your question the way he talks is inspirational and his words have logic. You can watch his other videos as well. And btw I’m a vegetarian
@@unlockedaccount3902 Carnivores don't have a choice but you as a Human have. You don't need animal products to survive. Plants don't feel pain neither they suffer but Animals do. To feel pain one needs Receptors,Central Nervous System & a Brain which Plants lack but Animals have. So be kind to Animals be #Vegan
@@CEarthling I agree animals do feel pain mentally and physically if they are slaughtered but when we harvest a field for crops we kill uncountable amount of worms, bugs, insects flies etc so vegetarians and vegans ain’t that clean or pure. It’s like debating over petrol cars vs electric cars one May think electric cars are clean but where does electricity come from? You can’t force anyone to be a carnivore and you can’t force anyone to be a vegan or vegetarian we are made by the creator the way we else he would’ve made us a vegetarian like cows
I am a orthodox christian but Ranjeet Sinkh (who was a Sikh) from 1977 show ”Mind your language” brought me here. Before him i had no idea that this religion exists. Learned many things about it.
Halal slaughter does not cause pain. Once slaughter happens blood is out from Carotid artery, jugular veins which stops the brain and heart immediately so basically it's dead and feels no pain. Cutting from the back is wrong the animal is still alive the heart and brain are still active because the blood is mostly still there it's just dying a slow painful death. Halal is the only humane and clean way. ua-cam.com/video/n-qRWNXdIBE/v-deo.html
Before knowing the reasons of why guru ji ate that jhatka .... don't temd to put any question.. No one can match what he has done ... at least respect if u can but fo not oppose 🙏 if anyone can dare to sacrifice their father mothér and children .... then only they are eligible to question up... 🙏
Torture induced animal's emotions & trauma stay or pass of to its DNA enable or making it adversely affect our behaviour to indulge in sadistic behaviour when we consume such meat that's why animal is distracted so that it doesn't undergo stress.
@Murad Ahmad in halal meat you don't snap the spinal cord instantaneously and the animal feels pain. By the way I am a vegetarian . If at all one has to eat meat , jhatka is always better. Thank you.
Brother halal is the safest way to eat food.. If the vein is cut blood doesn't remains in the body of the animal, blood has so many toxins which are harmful to the health, in jhatka procedure blood remains in the body only and you will consume that.. When it comes to vegetables, they are also living things, it is scientifically proven. So if you see in that way, then by cutting 10 plants one can fill his stomach but by cutting 1 goat 10 people can fill their stomach....So brother please believe on facts...
I'm a vegetarian, it is said that prophet Mohammed hardly eat any meat, in fact I believe that he use to fast most of the time. I enjoy watching your videos, thank you for sharing your knowledge.
@@akshayemaithani1541 if you are a veg you know just as well as I... But ok, here are a few reasons: Arguably the meat industry may be even worse, more disgusting and criminal than the arms industry. "We" (humanity) kill around 80 billion land animals every year... This means 80 billion last year, 80 billion this year, and 80 next year etc... This is the worse tragedy of human history - the result of this is a humanitarian (animal) tragedy as well as an ecological tragedy not to mention a spiritual tragedy of the highest order. I won't even mention here the torture of the animals from birth to slaughter... And we don't even need to eat meat, today some of the best athletes in the world are vegan. There are no doubt many more reasons, please share your thoughts.
@@lokeshjain4278 I know a few Muslims who are vegetarians and many Hindus who eat all kinds of meat. The meaning of the word "muslim" is a person who submits to the will of God and I heard that one of the descendants of Emperor Akbar said that Hinduism and Islam are like two hairs on the same head.
@@faisalhussein1028 That's great to hear from you,actually why I said muslims is bcs most I mean most of muslims are blind followers of a book and they don't dare to think about that,Since eating meat is sunnah,the pain and suffering of a billion animals becomes sunaah for them too,this is ehy it is surprising! And most of the hindus don't follow their religions that's why they do eat it. And even if a hindu youth who follows their religion,if you would speak up with logic ,they would listen but muslims never!
Most videos on UA-cam show wrong videos it's not from our religion but tradition because most people don't practise their faith.And how does the cutting of the throat create pain towards the back of the neck and cutting from the back of the neck does not ?.Thats a stupid thing to say you just asked the question answered it and the rejected it for Guru.
In 'jhatka' way of slaughter the animal's neck need to be cut in one go i.e the neck along with the spine is severed within a second or two. When the nerves of the body don't have any connection with the brain the animal can't sense any pain and dies quickly. Where as in 'halal' way of killing animal's windpipe and major arteires in the the neck are slit open while the nerves are still active. The animal suffers for a long time and dies of blood loss or heart attack due to extreme pain. This is the worst form of torture anyone can bring upon an animal. Because the animal is scared and suffering in 'halal' his body produces so many harmones which are bad for human body. Halal meat is one of the big reason why muslims have so many diseases and are slower. No western scientists have ever said 'halal' is a good way of slaughter. Even western butchers stun the animal before killing them so that they don't feel much pain.
@@magicmusic2077 which Guru Granth Sahib are you reading? No Guru told us to eat meat How can Gurubani allow us to eat it? We should be Vegetarian Or Vegan
how amazing one of the reasons we dont eat harm meat is becoz the slaughtering is done mercilessly and the anmial killed dies becoz of pain. but u r saying something that is totaly opposit, i think science should be bring into judgment. anyway not a big issue.
@@m.ibrahimkhalid6078 there is logic in islam? You have got to be kidding me! For one to be a muslim you have to give up logic and rational thinking and believe the prophet blindly.
Absolutely I agree all due respect to sikh brothers, but there is no reasoning in your comment. If you gave the reason why Guruji said so then ppl will follow it more especially the younger generation. Satsriyakal Guruji
they do feel pain but do you have any other least painful alternative? you make a way from which we can process nutrients and minerals required by human body from stones or solid lifeless matter then we will stop eating plants also.
no plants don't have a soul nor the ability to feel pain, I'm sure if you learned about biology you would know (no biology teacher i've met thinks plants have a soul or can feel pain).
@@kaurageouswarrior1496 Souls are indefinable, however plants don't experience pain like other living beings. They don't have the sensory system to sense pain unlike animals.
This is absolutely false. And for those arguing about this in the comment section, please do some serious research on this topic. RIP sir, but unfortunately you have conveyed inaccurate information. See, it is better to show both sides of the story other than “because the guru said so, we follow it”. That seems out of context and I have many Sikh friends who watched this video and laughed. All respect to this great guru’s, but please realize that we drain the blood and without doing so, you have stuff like mad cow disease, bird flu etc..you will never hear of halal meat being tainted or a recall on it due to salmonella or any other illnesses. In fact, speaking with my Sikh brothers, they have admitted that they would eat halal meat over any other meat, any day! Please do an unbiased research and see the benefits of eating halal meat versus non halal. Open up your minds and stop thinking narrow. It disgust me how people come here talking trash about Muslims, Hindu’s or even Sikhs. And whoever does, you are nothing less than a scum and are the reason why there is hatred and animosity today. Please be mature about the subject and if anyone says anything idiotic, then honestly, your mom has failed society in raising a piece of garbage son or daughter! MK out!
Nope Sikhism developed in water abundant place where meat can be washed unlike Arabia with hot weather. Torture induced animal's emotions & trauma stay or pass of to its DNA enable or making it adversely affect our behaviour to indulge in sadistic behaviour when we consume such meat that's why animal is distracted so that it doesn't undergo stress.
It is the sikh guy who 1st faught for jhatka certification in India. In Maharashtra they have maratha punjab meat centre who only has jhatka meat. It runs well there
True sikhs don't eat meat....but when guru sahib went to Nanded in Maharashtra, India many of the local people became sikhs.. However they didn't give up the practice of eating meat... That's why some Sikhs eat meat otherwise IT is COMPLETELY PROHIBITED IN SIKHISM TO EAT ANY KIND OF MEAT
hallal has been misunderstood a lot and true hallal isnt practised anymore painful or painless killing is totally depending upon location to location world has come to a brutal end may the god save us all
I being a hindu love the way how sikh people are so so soooooo much compassionate..... We all have common things within us the above all common traits lies humanity and some religions in the name of their followers give prefence to giving pain and suffering to others ratger than love and affection..
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims. The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case. m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 Halal is less painful? Are you having a laugh mate? Watch an animal getting slaughtered in the halal fashion and come and say that again. You're blinded with hatred my friend. Wake up.
@@BallyBoy95 read before commenting, did you read the independent research conducted by Christian, Hindu and Atheist Drs in their field. I guess not and you're just ignorant, what else can we expect of Kim Jong Un. Stop being ignorant and watch the video, the comments and what the response is stating. It's scientific fact that Jhatkha method is more cruel and painful for an animal that halal method
The slaughter process has two stages: Stunning, when performed correctly, causes an animal to lose consciousness, so the animal can't feel pain. The law states that, with few exemptions, all animals must be stunned before 'sticking' (neck cutting) is carried out
I think you are not uneducated when it comes to Halal meat. Here are some simple/general rules of Halal meat that you may missed when you never did the research. 1) the knife that is used must be Sharp and big enough for the slaughter of the animal. 2) the animal that is slaughtered must not thirsty. 3) the animal must not be slaughtered in front of the other animal. 4) the animals head must be chopped off/cut as soon as you can to minimize the pain. 5) the animals being slaughtered must be blessed by reading the special prayer 6) Ones slaughtered, the each part of the animal must be cleaned thoroughly and the blood must be drained out from the system. 7) Pregnant animals must not be slaughtered And the list goes on.... You big great " NoNo" comes from lack of knowledge my friend. How can you expect people to accept a religion who's fundamentals cannot be questioned just because someone (i.e Guru) said so? Peace
Hey stupid … any kind of meat is prohibited in sikhism.. you people r so dumb to understand anything that is why i would rather talk to the walls instead of making muslims understand anything… waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
You have your religion and we have ours and we respect your views, if only you would try your best not shine a bad light upon our views same way we do not on yours... Saying “they do it this way to cause maximum pain” makes it look like Muslims are terrible people, but the reality is that, you kill the animal and eat it and so do we. We all kill the animal and eat it. Just because the methods different it does not mean it should taken out of context. You kill the animal your own way and leave the blood within the animal, which causes LESS pain for the animal but cause MORE harm to yourself, we kill the animal our own way and drain the blood from the animal, which causes the animal the SAME pain but for a little longer and May God make it easy for them, and it causes NO HARM to ourselves, now please ask yourself are we doing better or for worse? The animal leaves the earth, not us, so which one would be the lesser of 2 evils? Causing harm to yourself AND the animal or causing harm to animal BUT no harm to yourself...?
By not questioning the reasons we do things, and simply accepting Guru's teachings, we are falling under the same traps that Guru Nanak Dev Ji warned others against in his lifetime. We would be blindly following rituals like sheep, not understanding the deeper meanings and logic behind whatever we do. We would be like the Hindus offering water that Guru Ji condemned blind ritualism to. I believe in attempting to become a good Gursikh, you have begun to adopt fanaticism along the way and that your influence over many other (mostly younger) Sikhs is giving them false impressions of the truer understanding of the Gurus' teachings.
In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful.
1. Say, “He is God, the One.
2. God, the Absolute.
3. He begets not, nor was He begotten.
4. And there is nothing comparable to Him.”
Sikhism is the true path...seek it.
@@wisergreener7394
Who is your creator.
@@NAKK786 Allah and you will
Meet Allah on the day of judgment
@@kiezasosa3173
No doubt.
If u dont know who ur creator is then ....u know
"Put on the full armor of God, so that you can take your stand against the devil's schemes. For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. Therefore put on the full armor of God, so that when the day of evil comes, you may be able to stand your ground, and after you have done everything, to stand. Stand firm then, with the belt of truth buckled around your waist, with the breastplate of righteousness in place, and with your feet fitted with the readiness that comes from the gospel of peace. In addition to all this, take up the shield of faith, with which you can extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one. Take the helmet of salvation and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God." Eph. 6:11-17🕊✝️🙏 Jesus Christ loves you and all will bow ✝️🕊🙏
Respect from a muslim no problem its your belief
but is he right
@Itz Facts why is he not right
@Hadi Asadullah if Allah is the creator and “the most merciful”, as Muslim’s claims than why would he tell his followers not to have any mercy on his other creations (animals)? Either Allah is not merciful or he’s not a god! He can’t be both!
Hi bro
If sallallahu ale he wasallam said that a muslim may not eat meat then why don't muslims skip meat eating I am confused
@Hadi Asadullah thank you for a balanced respected comment
I am a widow. I was married to my Sikh husband for 31 years. I miss him. He died in 2021. I love listening to the teachings and debates I find them calming to me. Satnam Waheguru ji
God bless u with all the happiness in the world ❤
Sat Sri Akaal
My brain says killing animal is cruelty, opposite of daya.
A man who has compassion can never eat meat.
Your brain isn’t guru
@Memes-150 Is taste that much important, that somebody has to suffer and die?
@@bhavkiratmavi5964 does guru says, don't use your brain?
@Memes-150 thankgod that somebody powerful than you don't think the same.
@@mycodingproject43 what about animal rights
Jugular cutting is less painful & more quicker a death & drains all the blood. FYI.😒 And if you are so concerned about pain don't eat animals in the first place! 🤷
What's funny they ate it before partition of hindustan
Bro I went to a halal restaurant and I swear majority of the ppl eating in there with their families were Sikhs lol they guys hate us just for the sake of hating us lol. This goes to show you that they have no light in their hearts
@@Noname-od5zy we shouldnt generalize may be that guy hates us but not all sikhs do.
@@Noname-od5zy tends to happen when u put their gurus in boiling water to death, on the basis of religion, peaceful way to kill
@@Noname-od5zy good one bro🤣🤣
Jhatka Guys: Our way is better
Halal Guys: Our way is better
Vegetarians: Hold my Lettuce 😎
Guru Gobind Sahab wanted a painless method.From common sense of that time it seemed jatka is quick method,but we now know spinal cord has sensory nerves.Brain is alive for 5 minutes even after head is cut off and animal feels great pain of cut nerves of spinal cord.In halal 1st pain centers are made numb by cutting main blood vessels of brain carotid arteries quickly and then after 5 minuted spinal cord is cut.
@@whitetiger9974 bullshit.
You cannot talk for another living creature.
Why not stop killing animals in the name of religion.
@@whitetiger9974 what about the pain and sensation in the rest of the body? Jhatka cuts off any communication between the brain and the rest of the nervous system, including pain receptors.
@@lwolfer5170 Bro that is laymans knowledge of brain and spinal cord.Spinal cord has pain reflex arc without involving brain.Spinal cord is very rich in sensory nerves.
@MOVIE Mines 🤣 yeah true that is why pig is forbidden to eat in islam.
Muslims should ask themselves if someone offers you a choice of any kind of death for yourself would you want a quick death a Sikh way or a slow painful death a Muslim way? Just be honest what death would you choose? Just try this easy experiment at home to help you choose especially if you have really hairy arms, put bandage on your arm then peel it off slowly feel the pain, now peel it off quickly see the difference now be honest with yourself what’s more painful 😖
100% Truth
So you are comparing decapitation with hair removal. Head decapitation done swiftly is more painful because the animal still fills pain with whatever nerve he has left plus his head is rolling on the cold hard ground, is it humane? Have you seen a head decapitation like that? See both of them and tell me which is more honored.
Muslims in the comments section thinking that slitting the throat of an animal is painless…clueless
I mean even dumbest know it's far more painful than Jhatka way.
should not eat mean anyway.
When a lion catches it's prey it holds the animal from the bottom of neck not from top.
Being a Christian I found Halal is healthy and delicious food 👍
So cutt!ng a nerve is less painful or cut!ng the whole system with 1 blow ??
@@AmandeepSingh-lr1br Halal is humane
@@samuelwilliams6171 how do you want to get K1lld ?
Cuttng a N€RV€?
Or FLASH k1ll??
@@samuelwilliams6171 humane way lolz😂😂ua-cam.com/video/K3YE2b45gFk/v-deo.html
@@AmandeepSingh-lr1br Humane jhatka slaughter 😂😂😂😂 ua-cam.com/video/Scsc2s81J3g/v-deo.html
I am a Christian,but I have a lot of respect for your religion.
Thx hw r u after 5 years
The jugular veins are closer from the front. It's worse for the animal if you slice from the back
@Arjun Mane yes with no blood/oxygen going to the brain the animal ceases to feel pain
One thing alot of people dont understand is that in Islam, Allah takes away the animals pain and suffering during the slaughter
nonsense ! The back neck cut ensures that the spinal cord is cut and the nervous system is instantly impaired so that the animal doesn't suffer long at all
@@kivouhsdelinski5311 if you cut spinal cord, the heart stops pumping the blood out of the body, which makes the meat uncleaned.
@Infidel . if I sat here for a whole day and try to explain it all to you, unfortunately you don't have the brain capacity to understand.
Wrong absolutely incorrect because ur jugular vain is the main vein that keeps u alive if u cut that first it’s the quickest way of dying u guys go the opposite direction and don’t even cut the jugular vein till last that causes maximum pain and that’s beyreham
Thats the point, but they dont see. Its better for them to have their own food certificate for sikh...then no issues. We muslims just need ourselves aware of our religion knowledge so we know what, why things like that.
What else would a “halal lettuce say” 🙃 Allah Bless you Sr/br
All the pain sensors are in the spinal cord, not the jugular vein, cutting that just means the animal bleeds out, they still feel pain
Idiot in jhatka everything is cut within a second including jugular vein
@@Sidhu.7.9 Go and watch DR . ZAKIR NAIK'S video of halal vs haram meat ....he has explained very well that how the halal way proceeds to cause minimal or no pain to the animal ...have a look at that beautiful video.
no mercy? the way its supposed to be is that the animals neck is slit slightly and one of the veins is cut in this, not allowing it to feel as much pain. The blood drained causes it to become unconscious so the animal doesn't feel pain again
Abdullah dont bother they no the truth and deny it lol they no halal is the only way but they deny thats why Allah told us only the ppl of the books thats quran Bible and torah who can relate to our way of thinking for Sikhs our halal is there haram and are haram is there halal lol wtf?
It is more merciful to stunt the animal first, but Muslims don't do that, because in the end it's not about mercy and they don't care about it.
@@hullie7529 give your head a wobble hullie thats just hate talk and bullshit and you know it is scientifically proven halal is better and healthier for you but you ignore the truth because you want stuff your face with a bacon barm lol you are wat you eat have you ever heard of that saying ?
@@iqrarhussain1122 I'm actually vegetarian but thank you for your concern. It's not hate talk it's just common sense; the most humane way to kill an animal is to stunt it first so they don't feel pain, the same way you'd ask for anesthesia if you were going to have a surgical procedure. Halal sacrifice is full of pain and it doesn't care about the suffering of the animal, and since we have an alternative I oppose it, but I don't care if it's Muslims or Jews or Christians, it's about mercy and compassion to other living beings.
@UCVPxYuR5eVDfqTEZN9_XcwQ there is still time get aware of everything and start being a better individual daily.
Why are they even considering halal meat? What about all the other forms of meat- kosher, factory slaughtered, etc.. It sounds like a sikh should only eat the meat they slaughter themselves, which again begs the question, why are they even talking about halal meat?
I agree with you! Kosher is slaughtered the exact same why, so why just talk about halal meat?
@@unknownranger250 Because it's very fashionable right now to be anti-Muslim!
If they talk against kosher, they would find themselves in big trouble.
So they pick a weak target.
Oh! The Sikhs know which side their bread is buttered!
@@kumar7586 Well said
Its because muslims live rent free in their heads and they just hate so they can get clout 🤷♂️
@Choudhry Ali dude learn English
Seriously
Main misconception with slaughtering for halal meat is that the throat of the animal is cut. This is incorrect. The jugular vein is what needs to be cut. This is a swift action that renders the animal unconscious with minimal pain in milliseconds.
First do reaserch...cuting jugular vein will cause pain and won't kill animal for long time...and you mummad pruphit enjoy animal struggling for life
Most Bravest and peace loving Community in world, nothing more and nothing less than what Guru Saahib told. I really feel proud Indian that Sikhism originated from our country and love them all , Jo Bole So Nihaal, Sat shree Akaal
@@mrahmat7555
Wo to koi Quran naa padhe to bhi nihal hota hai...... Aur rahi baat Hindu hone ki to wo 1500 saal pahle tum bhi the Islam to 600 something me aaya thaa.... Main kya karu isme. Jaise tum khush ho Muslim ban ke, hum bhi khush hain Hindu aur Sikh ban ke.....
@@mrahmat7555 Muhammad jo ek isaayi privaar me pedaa hua tha usnay saari kahaaniya bible aur torah se uthaakr bol diya k islam dharm hai usko kya kahega. aur ram jiski biwi kaun le gya usay khud nhi pta tha aur vo bhagwaan tha aur shivji jo saap ltkaaye ghoomta tha aur saand pr betha hota tha uski biwi jungle me haathi se thikwaake aagyi aur chamatkaar ho gya k ganesh aagya 😂. Bhagwaan tha 😂😂😂. Kmaal haathi ne kiya aur lund poojan shiv ka hota hai. Mahaan ho pooray mahaan. 😂😂
islam must be banned
Why are you showing a human body as a diagram if you are describing and animal?
@@alphaace7181 islam is & will only grow bigger & stronger 💪
When slaughtering halal the knife will be placed below the larynx on the neck of the animal and with a rapid, uninterrupted cutting motion, the trachea, esophagus, carotids and both jugular veins are completely severed in less than a second. This affects the blood and thus the Oxygen supply to the brain is interrupted, but there is also an instantaneous drop in blood pressure in the brain, and thus the animal's immediate unconsciousness.
Thanks
@@allahhunoorussamaawaateewa383 Your welcome 🙏👍🏻
does isis kill the same way?
Lol your a clown! Go read some books or something! And before you say something, the number one terrorist are the United States. Nobody has as much blood on there hands like the US Armee.
@@Lion_Hamza i am not american and i dont support america. i am from asia and lots of Christians are being slaughtered by isis than america. isis follow islam, america doesnt follow christianity. gladly be a clown than follow islam/isis
Sikhi says no meat, fish, fowl etc. No question of Jhatka or Halaal. All other interpretations are for sake of taste buds and convenience. Peace !
@@shanipost That also No, No.
sukhvir singh
So no halal meat , but every Sikh I know drinks alcohol excessively. Why is that ,?
We do not consider them Sikhs of the Khalsa, they are lost souls. Just like there are alot of muslims that drink and smoke ruthlessly. They are all just lost people to this physical world and are in need of critical guidance.
@@bbginc694 I cant deny. When I tell people (under circumstances, not proactively) that I dont eat any meat or drink, i hear "what kind of punjabi/sardar(turbaned sikh) are you". And thats sad for me to hear. Sad on the state of how sikhism is being followed or interpreted and what image are we creating.
Why eggs?
So basically our halal is your haraam.. that’s weird.😂
Anyways khush raho.
Dude I am Hindu and I don’t really mind halal food. But if it goes back to serve religious institutions then I am not too fond of it. Religion is a personal thing and no one should be profiting out of it
@Sabito dude I am talking about halal meat not beef. Are you dumb or do you have a hard time understanding English.
@Sabito are you dumb? Most Hindus in India eat meat. The vegetarians are in the minority. There are many schools of thought in sanatan dharma. And I am a nastik.
@Sabito Hindus are not compelled to follow anything. We are not an abrahamic religion. We need not do anything by the book.
@Sabito do u know Hinduism is not a religion name....its a geographical name....then question is...what is your religion name?...
not only Sikhs all Hindus should stop eating Halal meat...
all of my non vegetarian friends have switched to Jhatka, and they are convincing others to do so now.
Waheguru ji da Khalsa,
Waheguru ji di fateh
Breaking of the spine = spot death
Halal = time for the animal to think it is dying , stress, blackout, excruciating pain , painful death
Halal slaughter kills the animal's brain instantly. Even if the animal's body is responding to the cut, it can't perceive or feel anything because their brain isn't functioning.
@@Panjabijs because breaking of the spine isn't spot death. It's alive when it happens as depicted by science (ECG-heart readings).
@@nialldean9791 I am not for halal but he is right breaking the spin isn't spot on death also it depends on which animal goat has a broken spine might live vs a chicken.. neck jatka is spot in death
Ankit saha ur wrong... Bro...
Let's have chat....
Breaking of spine give more pain in halal we cut that nerve which responsible for pain
Cutting through spine is tough... the poor animal would be in agony if start cutting from the back neck
its decapitated with 1 blow while animal is looking in the other direction , there is no sawing just 1 clean swipe
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims.
The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case.
m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@Pathe where's the evidence, I've provided the evidence to prove you otherwise, backed by science and research conducted by Hindus, Atheist and Christians.
If you're going to refute then provide credible recent scientific evidence
@@salsabila786 are u serious, all of the scientific evidence (studies) points to it being a painful method. with all animal rights organisations banning it . due to all of the studies, the whole of europe has banned traditional halal, and have replaced it with stunning the animal first.
@@a..d2062 first of all that is not Jhatka, secondly I live in UK and contract across Europe, most countries have not banned it.
Kosher does not allow stunning either, however that's not the point. The point is severing from back of animal's neck or front. Understand the comment, video and responses before commenting. Read my initial comment and the link towards the studies, educate yourself before commenting
No disrespect to you bro but all my Sikh friends who I grew up with are practising Sikhs and all wear the 5 ks but they all drink alchol and they all eat halaal meat.
😅🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Meat is meat bruh I don’t really care.
@@suhridguha2560 exactly top man
No disrespect to you but my muslim friends eat Haram meat 🥩 and some of them drink alcohol too.
Joy Sarkar that's cool. Ain't nobody here to judge anybody else😂❤️
I'm hindu..as I'm frm Punjab as other punjabi hindus I love sikhism.. Je mere guru ji ne keha NO means no.... I wld nvr go to restaurant that serves halal meat.. Wahegur ji
Yeah! As hindus, jains and sikhs we cannot eat halal. ❤
Why didnt the guru say "Dont kill, its bereham"
Guruji did say that, even Kabir ji said so. BUT if you may have to eat with not much options, show some compassion to your fellow creatures.
@@prabhleensin sir, do you know that the way islam prescribed to kill an animal is the least painful way that is scientifically proven. You may not believe me but you can search some journals on internet.
@@tasnimshahid3286 you are killing and eating it and then discussing about the pain ? What kind of hypocrite you are ? 🤪😜
@@tasnimshahid3286 I would really love to read any journal that you refer. Please give me links. So far the nervous system theory stays logical to me. Indian cultural system has come out from hit and trial methods and that is why it is most logical to a normal brain which questions everything. Vegetarian diet by Ancient Rishi muni were promoted for us to live a conscious life.
islam must be banned
I agree 100% percent. I refuse to eat at any Pakistani or muslim restaurant or enter their shops.
So fuck off then. Simples
Racist fuck when we go to your ducking bullshit stores the smell omg
What is Halal Food ???
Do you hate Halal food ?
Watch this videos :
ua-cam.com/video/n-qRWNXdIBE/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/z7uiEI6ywws/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/gA7-7igGU1I/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/IG6UXKho1b0/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/uBQBtLaYOYQ/v-deo.html
Wat if they are Pakistani Sikhs???
thats absolutely ignorant, you think we like eating at your reaky turkha smelling restaurants?
I love all Sikhs. I lived in New Mexico and had many Sikh friends.
Thank you so much for your love for Sikh peoples
Hasan Bahadur Sikhs aren’t supposed to eat meat anyway. Only in time of dire need are we to consume meat, literally in times of death and life.
Also, I can’t imagine slitting an animals throat is compassionate, not that killing animal is, but slittings something’s throat means the blood drains out whilst the animal is still alive and doesn’t die instantly.
I like sikhs too.
Are they allowed any meat? Are they allowed to eat meat with blood in it?
And the kill method. Depwnda on the butcher. I am Muslim.
1 - no blood
2 - Certain sections of meat cannot be eaten.
3 - praying to show sorrow? Sadness and respect. But thank Allah most important.
The killing method depends on the person. So if we change the killing method. Why can you not eat it
@@talvindersingh2354 I agree
People are commenting on which way of killing them is better,from front or back of the neck!
The reality is none of them is better when the animal doesn't want to die 🙄💯
Lol
What did the animal say to you?
@@abubakrrauf1691 So since they don't speak human languages they don't feel pain and are willing to get their neck slit for your taste?
@Curtis Jefferson Dude see,you can find millions of these illogical reasons to kill them. No fucking person in the world can stop you from eating /killing them. It's all in your hands, just would ask you to read and research more about what you just said about plants feel pain and circle of Cruelty! Noone on the internet like me can force you,the day you put yourself in their shoes,you'll understand the compassion,you may grow your heart! Best of luck!
@@jasrajsingh24 You should do some research differences between plants and animals then you should come!
Satsriakal....i left islam for Sikhism last year.
Ali Khan you poor poor soul
I hope it helps you in your spiritual journey.
You foolish.
Ali Khan very good,I invite every muslim to accept sikhi 🙏🙏🙏
@@iftakharmohammed8293 If they find more peace in a certain religion, then not necessarily a poor choice
Even today, science considers the halal method, but not jhatka 😂😂😀
Halal meat is banned in many parts of Europe
@@JesusSaves349 The law basically says that animals should be unconscious as the time of being killed for food. In effect, this law imposes a ban on kosher and halal slaughter of animals. ... Now, the European Union Court of Justice has upheld the law, rejecting the objections of religious groups.
@@JesusSaves349 the hijab is banned also what's your point
@@m0nk__mind : We Muslims have better knowledge of science than you Hindus/sikhs
@@theguidancecounsellor2948 : Without Hijab islam can survive.... It is not obligatory to wear hijab
Gru died had a soul like all of us. Allah is one and only. May you get guided to the truth.
Muhammad died and is in hell for being a false prophet preaching a false god, not the same God of Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, or Moses. The true Prophets of God said:
Leviticus 26:1
“Do not make idols or set up an image or a sacred stone for yourselves, and do not place a carved stone in your land to bow down before it. I am the LORD your God.”
And what did Muhammad do? He took the same exact black stone that the pagans kissed and worshiped in Arabia before him, and now every Muslim bows down to it or the direction it is in! The true Prophets such as Moses would have stoned Muhammad to death.
Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 2, Book 26, Num 667
“Umar came near the Black Stone and kissed it and said "No doubt, I know that you are a stone and can neither benefit anyone nor harm anyone. Had I not seen Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) kissing you, I would not have kissed you.”
@@GreekOrthodox7 lol Muhammad PBUH used to pray towards jersualem until he moved to Medina smh. Youre very dull if you think muhammad PBUH used to worship a stone. To become a Muslim you literally have to recite that "there is no god but Allah and Muhammad is his messenger". Literally one of the corner stones of Islam is to worship only God. If he wanted to worship anything else he would not have destroyed the soo many idols that used to surround mecca.
@@GreekOrthodox7 yes of course he died peace and blessings be on him and his entire family. We don’t worship him. It’s hard for you to understand because you worship a man. “ it’s not that the eyes are blind it’s the heart”. Allah hu akbar.
No problem guru.
More halal meat for me🌺💕
@@koushik8858 says a coward!
@@koushik8858 Ignorant coward
And which guru said eat meat in the first place? Lol
Guru Gobind singh was a hunter. So was guru har Gobind sahib.
@@HKM-28 yeah He was hunter but not like jesus or Allah he was above all who always hunted internal evil and external persicuters of Humanity
We consider karma as universal law.
We have to perform karma, and to attend mukti, we need to abstain from bad karma, thus a Guru only tells us *what to abstain from*
@@inmyopinion3843 bro allah is just the name for god. Watch basic of sikhi. I don't think jesus was a hunter.
@@HKM-28 not at all bro Whatever Allah nothing to with Allah .i am saying that rise of Shikism was very need of that time of Persicution of Hindus in Mughal Eara.I am saying if you have exprinced any kind of hurt after reading my comment.
i am a hindu and i am a pure vegetarian.. i have never been the cause of pain to any living creature...so i a near to ek omkar...the almighty.
Plants are also living creature 🙂bhruhhh
@@otakusan005 They don't have CNS so they don't get pain
@@omgupta9301 who said dat they aren't sensitive?????
@@otakusan005 www.google.com/amp/s/www.britannica.com/amp/story/do-plants-feel-pain
BTW lots of Hindu, jain , buddhist do not eat seed , root . And seasonal grain plant die within six months so that we don't have to kill.
There is a thing called "Jada Buddhi" in day time pants don't feel pain as night.(it doesn't mean that I should kill big plant If u still doubt it remember it was Hindu who told to world that plant has life. "Jagadish Chandra Bose"
Plant perception
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plant_perception_(paranormal)#:~:text=Indian%20scientist%20Jagadish%20Chandra%20Bose,of%20life%20for%20a%20plant.
Veer ' Ek_Omkaar' nhi...
Vaise sab 'Ek_Onkaar' Bolde..
BUT
Real One Meaning is ___ 'Ik_ OH'
{ God is One }
Why do lions don’t kill from the back lol
Yes you are like violent lions, killing everyone.
Coz lion is animal and we are not!
@@romulus1136 'singh' symbolizes being a king.... Not literally the animal bro! Lol
They don't.
They attack the jugular.
Lol they Kill from the neck Stupid
If Sikhism is all about compassion, as indeed mentioned in the video, then eating in fast foods should be considered more prohibited than Halal meat. The real concern that Sikhs have is not about Halal meat per se, but rather if there was a *ritual slaughter* involved, which apparently he did not mention in the video.
Regarding the topic of animal cruelty, the EEG recorded severe pain after stunning, as opposed to the ventral neck incision (halal). The retention of more blood in the meat after stunning results in unhygienic meat for the consumer, as opposed to VNI, which also makes it fresh for a longer period of time.
One thing he also forgot to adress are animals with BSE (mad cow desease)...
"For this reason, the USDA requires that all *brain and spinal cord materials* be removed from high-risk cattle " This isn't quite the case when stunning animals may lead to the scattering of brain tissue.
When u feet meat to the cows... Doesn't matter wat part u remove it's bound to happen
Lmao we sikhs and hindus and all dharmic people dont eat cows . Plus yeah sure studies show . Imma show you videos of them suffering due to halal bullshit .
I’m Sikh and I’m vegan 💖
If u whatch the other video's he goes I to why we shouldn't eat any meat as its not compassionate but its up to interpretation
How can you say that "the real concern that Sikhs have is not halal meat " ? How can u know what is or isn't the concern?
At 2:50 he talks about animal slaughter and pain spots and use a human body map lol
😂
The animals, such as cows, are mammals...and this would make no difference, but this makes no sense. The halal method involves stunning the animal, so it won't feel pain
🤣🤣 that is epic 😂😂😂😂
What a sharp mind!😂 Subhan'Allah, May Allah (SWT) bless you with more knowledge beneficial for our ummah !
We are animals too known as human
As far as I know ... there is no meat allowed ..halal/zhatka/whatever
Coz killing is offence
Weapons are there to protect&defend not to kill
Yeah
Then ban lions and tigers to hunt as well.....and put all these animals in cages along with urselves .phew didn't think wud be so easy. BTW keep hate comments to urselves same to you anytime 😊
look further into the reasoning why jhatka was allowed, its quite deep
@barry its a question of necessity and objective. It's quite deep
Do your research, and then come back and ask.
@@READ-cj3us lions are designed to eat meat....humans are designed for vegetarianism.
i saw a video of yurs. saying do not meat at all. so why here differentiating between halal and jhatka? and why also so much stress on not smoking but not much on not drinking?
Mir Jalal don't ask why just do because guru said it. I mean how can you do something without questioning it? how are you meant to find the truth?
UknownAssassin Sikhs can eat meat but only if they need to do!
UknownAssassin jhatka is only way to be mercy with the animal if you are going to kill it.
Mir Jalal you’ve made a very valid point. Sikhs love drinking more than any other living specie
Donnie Darko are you a Sikh?
I'm Muslim but i only follow what's in my heart bc i know that's God's guidance for me but i only eat chicken n beef meat halal of course but i feel guilty eating it. Something in my heart tells me to stop eating meat but not being able to. This is my journey to figure it out in the future if i should or continue eating those 2 meat only. May God guide me to the right path. Ameen!
This philosophy is contrary to Islamic beliefs and the Sunnah. Whoever adopts it or calls to it has opposed the Qur’an and Sunnah. Allah (the Most High) stated:
يَا أَيُّهَا النَّاسُ كُلُوا مِمَّا فِي الْأَرْضِ حَلَالًا طَيِّبًا وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا خُطُوَاتِ الشَّيْطَانِ ۚ إِنَّهُ لَكُمْ عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ
“O mankind! Eat of that which is lawful and good on the earth, and follow not the footsteps of Shaitan. Verily, he is to you an open enemy.” (Al-Baqarah: 168)
Allah has permitted all food that He made lawful and good for people. Vegans adopt a totally animal-free lifestyle which opposes this and other Quranic verses. Allah (the Most High) also stated:
يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا أَوْفُوا بِالْعُقُودِ ۚ أُحِلَّتْ لَكُم بَهِيمَةُ الْأَنْعَامِ إِلَّا مَا يُتْلَىٰ عَلَيْكُمْ غَيْرَ مُحِلِّي الصَّيْدِ وَأَنتُمْ حُرُمٌ ۗ إِنَّ اللَّهَ يَحْكُمُ مَا يُرِيدُ
“Lawful to you for food are all the beasts of cattle except that which will be announced to you herein―and game is unlawful when you assume Ihram for Hajj or ‘Umrah. Verily, Allah commands that which He wills.” (Al-Mā’idah: 1)
Based on this it is harām (prohibited) for a Muslim to adopt a vegan way of life out of choice. It is also impermissible to adopt a vegan diet (due to its underlying philosophy) unless a person is diagnosed with allergies or finds his body is intolerant to all animal products such as milk, eggs, cheese, meat, fish, honey, etc and becomes sick when he eats them. That is because veganism is predicated on saving animals from “human cruelty” and from “usurping their possessions” such as milk, eggs, meat and hide.
Allah allowed meat from cattle, game and the produce of the sea:
يَسْأَلُونَكَ مَاذَا أُحِلَّ لَهُمْ ۖ قُلْ أُحِلَّ لَكُمُ الطَّيِّبَاتُ ۙ وَمَا عَلَّمْتُم مِّنَ الْجَوَارِحِ مُكَلِّبِينَ تُعَلِّمُونَهُنَّ مِمَّا عَلَّمَكُمُ اللَّهُ ۖ فَكُلُوا مِمَّا أَمْسَكْنَ عَلَيْكُمْ وَاذْكُرُوا اسْمَ اللَّهِ عَلَيْهِ ۖ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ ۚ إِنَّ اللَّهَ سَرِيعُ الْحِسَابِ - 5:4
“They ask you, O Prophet, what has been made lawful for them. Say, ‘Lawful for you are all good foods and game animals caught by your trained hunting animals which you train as Allah has taught you. So eat of what they catch for you, and mention the name of Allah upon it, and fear Allah…” (Al-Mā’idah: 4)
No disrespect, but the explanations he gave regarding slaughtering is utter nonsense.
May his soul RIP
Can you pls explain.what is your point of view.
@@SID-ug6mt the way slaughtering in islam is accepted by much of the scientists and zoologists throughout the world. Try google
The way slaughter an animal looks very unhumen.the animal feel more pain while halal for a long . Im against jhatka.better become vegetarion.
@@SID-ug6mt
You know that plants have feelings!!!
Yes they do!! So tell me on what bases do you eat plants!!!
@@parthdixit7058
When you cut it off from the tree?? Does it not hurt and a lot of vegetables are cut alive in way or the other so it is the same cutting animals!!!!
Lakum diinukum wa liyadiin...
Ye badiya hai😉
🤘🤘🤘👍😇😇
But ultimately, eating an animal is cruelty.
How does the way of killing matters?
extra cruelty vs quick painless.
how can u even ask this?
true, however the warriors path sometimes requires the consumption of meat. this should only be done for strength and not for taste.
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you then let them die of hunger as they slowly grow weak and miserable out of scarcity of food or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
nowhere in any gurudwara will you see non veg being served...meat is only allowed if you have to hunt...and you have to hunt only in extreme conditions when there is nothing available...when baba banda singh bahadur was under an eight month long seige then they say even the bark off trees had been consumed and finally they cut their horses to eat..
Cutting through jugular vein cuts the nerve endings connected to brain. This is least painful. It also allows blood to completely drain.
Cutting from back of neck spinal cord is harder, slower and the animal feels most pain.
It takes less than 1 second to disconnect the head from body with Jhatka method.
That's anatomically incorrect. Killing via neck bleeding out is horrendous. The nerve is in the spine, obviously
@@harpritsingh9359 He said at 2:52 that the pain sensors are in the neck: so that basically means if you hit the animal in the pain sensor it will cause it pain. Kosher and orthodox Christians also require the animal to be killed via Juglar vein for the same reason.
@@saimshaikh5424 my grandfather owns a farm land and he has many goats. I've seen him performing Jhatka, goats body freeze when head is removed.
He also did jhatka on thick neck of boar several times and i also tried once but my sword got stuck in midway from that day on I'm using nail gun. It's easiest and best possible way to give death.
And there's really no Sikh way of killing animal written in Sikh Holy book. Sikh holy book says against those who kill animal for taste, fun and for sacrifice or on the name of God.
And we use best possible method to give instant death to animal as told by last guru(it's not written in Sikh Holy book, the message was just verbal).
And reason behind we avoid Halal, because Halal is slow death. It's suffering for animal.
Jhatka is quickest method.
Nail gun is even quicker.
Nail Gun is so quick that when goat eyes are open they stay open when they're closed they stay close it's like you switched off the running computer.
And I'm always open to the newer and best methods.
@@harpritsingh9359 Offcourse bro, and I respect all opinions in all honesty. :) I do believe if a person wants to cause the least amount of suffering to an animal the best way would be to consume them less all together: Or abstain: Today industrialization of meat and high amount of production has lead to us creating an imbalance in ecosystem and overconsumtion of meat: If I want to eat meat on a particular day I don't really think about pain to the animal because I would have been a vegan if that were the case ... because in the natural world when a lion/tiger/alligator is hungry and wants to eat a zebra .... It won't be thinking how that animal gets pain: It goes and eats whether the animal gets pain or not, it will brutally attack and eat what it needs to eat
I love this guy ! I have lot of love for Sikhs as they are honest and brave. 2 of their great gurus have laid their lives for Hindus without even thinking twice ! Hindus will forever be indebted to their Gurus ! Long live Guru Nanak Dev Ji's choosen path !
@Paldeep Singh the Sikhs enemies were never mughals.the sikhs enemy was injustice.today injustice is happening in Jammu Kashmir so the Sikhs have united with the Muslims. The mughals were just Mongols who excepted Islam.
@Paldeep Singh Khalsa Raj will probably end up just like any other country or constitution. It is not the indian constitution which has harmed sikhs, but it is the people who have done. There will always be wicked people around regardless of their faith. I hope you will understand my perspective.
Just Random Human Sikhs don’t belong to something called India hope you understand this aswell ..
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims.
The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case.
m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 say hi to all missionaries but guess what nobody's interested so don't copy paste your comment again and again. I dont know what you are trying to prove but you will never succeed following the wrong path.
There are many restrictions in halal way example knife should be shard so that we dont have to put lot of force on animal and so that it doesn't take long time.
It should be done at once so that animal doesn't feel pain for long time
One animal should not be cut infront of other animal and many more.
It's still a crueler way to die.
karpetcabin What about electricution??
@@tanzimi5518 what about it?
karpetcabin Isn’t it way worse
@@tanzimi5518 to kill an animal? Don't know.
Sikhs is all abt compassion
To show compassion to animal ...
Cut them with jhatka😁
What a compassion 👏👏
Cause LESS pain if causing no pain is not an option for you. Most of the Sikhs are vegetarians. I even know many muslims who are veg. I can even show you quotes in Quran saying muslims should be compassionate too.
@@prabhleensin I feel like his argumentation is built on a youtube video which he uses to judge all halal meat.
First of all you don't need to use a small knife, most of the time I saw it, it is done with a huge knife.
And it is done to cause the least harm
@@AnimatedIslamicHistory23 No offence but this video is for Sikhs to not eat halal meat and you can continue with your traditions. Though Guru Nanak Sahib said Muslims should follow Prophet Muhammed. And I'm pretty sure Prophet was more compassionate than muslims portray.
As a Science student, I know nervous system is right through the spine and cutting that off first leaves no signals reach the brain to feel the pain. So knife size doesnt matter but the reflex.
Having said that, it is better not to cause harm to these creatures and opt for a vegetarian diet whenever we can. Allah Rehmat kare.
islam must be banned
@@alphaace7181 You are desperate.
To be honest, he's right about the halal part. But the fact is we don't know whether cutting the spine in one go causes pain or not. Slitting the throat during halal must cause pain irrespective of whether jugular veins are cut or not because pain receptors still work for few minutes and the brain still works for few minutes before it goes dead. Few moments of oxygen or blood cut to the brain won't cause the brain to stop functioning immediately. Neither the neuro receptors and neurons in our brain would stop working suddenly. So, yeah it's bound to cause pain to the animal. But jhatka probably should also cause pain. How that pain would work is a bit hard to comprehend. So, the best is to abstain from meat consumption if you're really concerned about pain to animals. And it's actually hypocrisy to talk about how Halal is a humane way. You follow halal because it's been written in your books, that's it.
I agree with you: I don't personally don't think there is a right or wrong way to kill an animal and the best way is abstinence: I do think that halal, kosher, and jhatka all cause some level of pain and we can argue on which causes most pain all day long and the end argument will always be that going vegan is the most humane. If I want to eat meat on a particular day I don't really think about pain to the animal because I would have been a vegan if that were the case ... because in the natural world when a lion/tiger/alligator is hungry and wants to eat a zebra... It won't be thinking how that animal gets pain and could care less. : I personally do eat Kosher only since the blood gets fully removed and that is the only reason
😂😂😂 showing a chart of human nervous system. And we do not use small churii btw the knife is big andits sharp not blunt like ur describing to cause minimum pain.
islam must be banned
@@alphaace7181 brother whatever religion u belong to does it say to say bad about other religions. pls keep calm and think before u speak
so, according to you jhatka meat is allowed ? but why ? why nihang singh needs to eat jhatka when all vegetarian food is available everywhere..
This was allowed back in the time of the Gurus as food wasn't as available as today but is still allowed by the Akal Takt, most Sikhs today are vegetarian as there is no longer a need to eat meat as there is plenty of other food choices.
Brother their were plenty of vegetarian food at that time also, we are talking about 300 years ago..... not about the time of stome age ?
And i am sorry to sar brother but today also, most of the sikh i meet are non veg. Even i have found many amrit dhari non veg sikhs, most of them claim that they have taken amrit from HAZUR SAHIB, amd their panj pyaras gives permission to have jhatka meet ...
Now according to me this is total violation of our guri's teachings.
Brother have you heard about the story of when Guru Nanak Ji had met a hunter in a forest who had no food, this hunter had asked Guru Nanak Ji if he would allow him to kill and eat an animal in the forest and if Guru Nanak Ji would help him, Guru Nanak Ji allowed him to kill and eat the animal but would not help him in doing so. This is where I found that Guru Nanak is not against eating but also not for eating meat.
+Harmeet Singh I agree with you completely brother today all meat is ate by some Sikhs for taste it is similar to addiction to alcohol, I was saying that the only time when an animal is to be killed and eaten is when there is nothing else. And that story was one of many bedtime stories of Guru Nanak Ji when he was traveling around Asia spreading message of Waheguru. Another story would be when Guru Nanak Ji gave his companion Mardana some berries of a plant but said do not take any more, but Mardana felt he would need some for the rest of the journey however Guru Nanak Ji said not to take them as they were poisonous. Meaning you should not show greed.
+bobby singh so you are also saying that jhatka is to be eaten only as last resort... just for survival...
but this is not what sikhs do today. i have seen amritdhari sikhs eating meat and giving excuses that its jhatka and we have permission from panj pyaras.
and it is with most of the sikhs now days.
people ask me why i am a veg even after being a sardar,,, and they laugh when i say that sikhs are not allowed to eat meat...
common image of a sardar in today's world is: non veg amd a tanker(drinker)
I just wanted to say that pain receptors are located in the skin, not only the spinal cord. It's true that with jhatka the animal dies quickly, and this would be merciful as it saves the animal pain. However the blood is not allowed to be drained fully before it dies. Most diseases are carried by blood, and consumption of blood can cause sickness even if properly cooked, so it's vital to get the blood out while at the same time having mercy on the animal, which is the aim of halal. Peace!
If your spines behind your neck are cut do you feel pain?
Stop torturing animals would you . People have been eating jhatka and pork over a long century and they don't get sick so stfu
Killing an animal by slashing their throat is not painless and consumption of blood DOES not cause sickness in the way you seem to be suggesting it. Halal is brutal and shows a lack of mercy for the animal. No human being, Sikh or otherwise, should touch halal because it's so cruel for the animal involved. I eat meat BUT I will never touch a halal meat if I can avoid it. We stun the animals in Western countries for a reason yet Halal slaughter does not approve of stunning. That's unacceptable!
@@ghaah No, the pain receptors on the skin send it back through the spinal cord to the brain, but technically there are some reflexes that occur in the spinal cord itself without going to the brain so cutting it won't matter there
One would also argue cutting both the cartoid arteries would technically cut the blood supply to the brain and causes the animal to lose conciousness while going thru the spinal cord might cause loss of pain but the animal is still aware, and loss of pain is tricky because it depends on which level do you cut, you could possibly lose sensation only in the lower body/chest and still have pain in your neck
Cutting the jugular vein and oesophagus stops the blood/oxygen supply to the brain and with the loss of blood the animal ceases to feel pain and dies. Cutting through the nerves and spinal cord which is far more difficult and therefore likely be slower would cause even more pain felt by the animal as your are cutting thru the ‘pain receptors’.
Exactly...
It’s scientific fact.
Also cutting through the throat allows maximum release of all the blood.
All the toxins and bacteria in blood gets completely drained out.
Halal meat is proven to be fresher, tastier and have longer shelf life.
@@masyaf897 nope . Cutting through the spine results in immediate death . Plus in halal the heart loses energy to pump. Leaving in blood instead in jhatka where the carcass is hanged and gravity does the job . Plus brain takes 5 minutes to die in some cases . In halal there is no immediate stoppage of blood therefore it suffers longer compared to jhatka where it goes through . Bruh scientist
@@rambogambo5525 in no way dying slowly is better than a jhatka . Torture vs almost instantaneous death
Loss of oxygen supply to the brain when nervous system is still fully functional *LITERALLY* causes the animal to suffer from pain until it dies.......... from that pain....
Jhatka is a way more humane way of slaughtering the animal, atleast if not exactly ethical, but still the Jhatka system can manage to put forth arguments supporting itself while Halal and Koshur can only cite pseudo science born out of their desperate mental gymnastics
@@rambogambo5525 cut someone on jugular vein then, and then decapitate someone through spinal cord till the neck in one blow and watch them both
I Honastly HATE it when someone is talking about a very sensitive topic and some random person does a Jakara and Disrupts the Train of Thought, Jakaras are fine but they also have a time and place where they must be used.
He really said they cause maximum pain intentionally , this is how far he dehumanizes Muslims
he's right though, their method of killing animals is horrendous and cruel
He should not have said "...to cause maximum pain." "...which could cause more pain than other methods..." would be better. But its unfair to pick through someones extemperaneous words and accuse them of dehumanizing Muslims.
ua-cam.com/video/TSvWrkedwyo/v-deo.html
Siri lanka , poland , belgian and many more banned halal
@P Atwal Science will tell you otherwise, perhaps you do your own research not accept what a man said hundreds of years ago.
I feel like although jatka is allowed a Sikh shouldn't eat it unless it's a matter of life and death... Mahraj allowed jatka but times were different in anandpur.. Food was limited and I felt like jatka of the animals was done to end their misery instead of starving them and making them suffer.. Again these are my views so it's up to you
Brahmjot Singh I'm npot sure if Guru Maharaj exactly allowed meat but when the singhs were fighting in the jungles and in the battles, sometimes they would starve. The Singhs would eat Jhatka meat under the worst case life or death scenarios. Even after they ate the meat, they would feel terrible for doing it. But they were fighting for us so they had to survive. Now this is just what I have heard so it might not be entirely true.
Sikhs can eat any meat but they can't eat kutha (meat made by rituals way like halal bali)
Sikhs allowed to eat meat if it's wrong in Sikhism then Sikh will never eat it any worst case don't listen to anybody just read gurbani
Uncle Bernie
Just stop talking before you hurt yourself thinking too hard lol. Stop getting your info off the internet and actually get it from a legit source... Like Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji.
+Uncle Bernie It is the order of the 10th living Guru to follow Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj as our Guru after him and so we do so. No questions asked.
Any living 'guru' or individual is in circumstances prone to corruption of mind, thoughts, actions and money so why follow someone who has all these shortcomings?
Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj is a compilation of the shabads( wordings ) of 10 Sikh Guru's and 36 other saints and poets who were obvio alive when they wrote it ( duh ), and their wordings were written down for future generations- uncorrupted. That is- Shri Guru Granth Sahib ji Maharaj is writings containing true knowledge and we pray to our Guru. What does that tell you? A religion that promotes praying to Knowledge over a person. That's how modern and uncorrupted Sikhi is.
Would your living Guru let his own children die to save you? My Guru did. He let his 4 children, young in age than you or me die to save us. That's enough a reason for me to owe my life to him. And if he tells me to bow down to only Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj then may the axis of the Earth tilt or shift but my faith in him and Shri Guru Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj will never shake. Ciao.
Why are there so many mad Muslims? Sikhs are just not permitted to eat meat that was slaughtered in a ritual. This includes halal and kosher. It’s a difference in the religions not an attack on your religion. Move on.
s a muslim we can eat jew kosher meat cause halal and kosher same principle which is makeing the blood shed..I mean if you cant shed the blood that makes people harm and from the trought animals feels less pain actually but maybe the most smart way is not to eat meat at all like me:=)) I love my all sikh friends ,love and respect
actual Fact is Hormones are released a lot more in halal slaughter than Jhatka slaughter. Because when an Animal is witnessing it's life slowly fading away, it panicks & Tries to Breathe & in doing so; Chokes on it's own blood.
Your life is boring. I live on chicken 🐔
Does this also apply to normal slaughtered meat where sometimes the meat is slaughtered in more of an inhumane process such as ringing them up by the legs and stunning them with electricity (in which the animal feels everything but cannot respond)? What would the sikh opinion be on this type of meat being eaten or is just Halal meat that is forbidden?
Nope, only Halal. If there's pork or alcohol being served at the restaurant or meat where the animal was sacrificed to idols or killed by shooting in the face or tortured, it's cool. Just halal. Why? Because Guru said so. That's why.
@@greentooth3097 lolz another SIKHPHOBE spotted😂😂
No koshar no halal ...just jhatka ...
Forbidden. Anything that causes pointless suffering is forbidden.
boiling them in hot asss water.
Firstly halal slaughtering is very merciful brothers. You may watch any informative video on it. Halal meat is healthy too. And as for the method:
First you must give the Animal water.
Second: separate it from the other animals as to prevent the other animals from witnessing the slaughtering.
3rd; calm the animal, cover its eyes. Use a sharp and fine knife so it won't hurt. And starting from the front causes an immediate death. It severs the jugular and let's the blood completely drain.
Which method would you prefer for yourself? Jhatka or halal?
But not that merciful. Because Halal also means Halal done by a muslim.
Why only muslim need to perform the Halal?
Stfu fuck off halal meat is not merciful the animals suffer
@Imposter Among us Halal meat is not at all healty.
@Imposter Among us You mean with out that prayer it is not Halal. You mean the recitment by a muslim is more important than the way the animal was killed!
Basically you r saying that even if an animal is killed by slitting it's throat and letting the blood doesn't make it Halal because some verses are recited by a muslim. And because of that it will become Haram for u.
All muslims commenting here doesnt know shit about science. I am a med student and will try to explain using human anatomy. Pain reception is function of different tracts of spinal cord . When you just destroy the spinal cord, a being dies of stoppage of body functions controlled by ans and pns. For example in complete or in complete transverse section of spine at level of cervical vertebrae mostly results in death in humans or cesation of stimuli preception in part of body lower to injury. For a layman, what will be any easy death your throat slit or decapitated. Don't just believe what your imam says.
Scientists say this :
The speed and precision of the incision ensures the lack of stimulation of the severed structures and results in the immediate loss of consciousness. Blood flow to the brain is completely halted.
In addition, blood empties rapidly from the brain. Irreversible cessation of consciousness and insensibility to pain are achieved, providing the most effective stun.
Halal way empties the blood from the body that's why it healthy. Blood is a Sea of germs and diseases.
@@mohdyounus8353 halal may be more healthy but it is more painful. And after cooking the meat properly most of germs get destroyed.
Every Sikh I know easy a heavy drinker I thought alcahol was apart of the religion seriously
Even I saw muslims smoking weeds.
I thought weeds were obligatory before prayers.
@@dipakkumardey7540 freshy
@@dipakkumardey7540 found the Pajeet
@@dipakkumardey7540 your confused with tajweed 😄
There are sects within Sikhism . The Most conservative is of the amritdhari Sikhs who don't smoke and drink . They compulsorily have beards and turbans . They are also compulsorily 100% vegetarian . You are baptised in that sect formally . But all others who are not in the sect have a lot of freedom like eating nonveg , drinking , smoking , drugs , no compulsion of facial hair .
Its not matter of halal or jhatka its really matters that sikh brothers are following their guru with honesty and firmly.
M Kashif yes . That's not the problem. The issue is the fact he makes it sound like muslims toture the animal by doing it the halal way. Also by saying we use small knife , making it sound we cause maximum pain deliberately! ! Free to do what they want, but don't lie about other religion! !
@@saiqhai9968 exactly
@@saiqhai9968 he's not wrong brother, you can say everything but the truth will prevail on it's own
@@insaan1234 he is wrong and the truth will indeed prevail, INSHA'ALLAH
I respect there religion, in return I want the same.
I agree with the starting part of the video where he says 'you do it or you don't because the Guru said so', because that's what faith is all about. Unfortunately he doesn't stop there and goes into the science of it and quite evidently without the right knowledge saying things like pain sensors, bereham etc. I respect his religious knowledge but science should be left for the people of science. Saying such things as a spiritual leader is extremely ignorant and misleading. As a doctor I can confirm that from a purely scientific standpoint halaal meat is by far the most clean and consumable form of meat(even kosher is similar). Keep all preconceived notions aside and think about it for a second. When we are ill what is the first laboratory test we do? A simple blood test. Since that's where we can find all the toxins and bacteria in our body. By doing jhatka you are transecting the spinal cord there by eliminating the ability of the animal's muscles to contract. The blood stagnates within in the meat making it toxic. Even if we assume that the blood of the animal is clean and the animal is healthy, we're still drastically reducing the shelf life and consuming meat high in cholesterol. Even my non Muslim colleagues in the hospital prefer halaal meat any day. As far as pain is considered, firstly we cannot make that a criteria for animal slaughter because then we would be contradicting our selves as meat consumers. However, when this respectful guru says 'pain sensors' and points it to the back of the neck, it's absolute nonsense. When you're doing jhatka you're breaking/snapping the neck of the animal. The animal goes into a state of paralysis so there's no way you can guage the pain being felt, just because the animal is not moving doesn't mean it's not feeling the pain. On the other hand though, a small sharp knife is used for halaal because it allows you to slit the major blood vessels of the animal keeping the neck and the spinal cord intact, allowing for twitching of the muscles draining most of the blood, sending the animal into a state of fainting and eventual death, giving you clean meat. I respect my Sikh brothers and their practices but it's my sincere request to the religious leaders to abstain from saying things without knowledge that put people of a certain faith in bad light. An ordinary sikh without any scientific background listening to this lecture would blindly believe that Muslims are 'bereham'.
An eye opener for our sikh brothers wh.wahe guru ji ka khalsa wshe guru ji ki fateh6
Yeah, I agree with you 100%. It should've been left at because the Guru says we can't. That's it. That's what Sikhi is about, following the Guru's order. As someone who has grown up in a Sikh family, I've raised this question quite a lot. I have done extensive research on why halal or kosher, etc., and can say yes, it is the best form of meat you can consume. Meat without blood/very minimal blood, is the best form of meat for human consumption. Also, what humans see as muscle contraction after a halal slit of the throat, doesn't necessarily equate to pain in the animal. Also agree with the point that if you're eating meat, you can't be called rehamy just because you kill an animal a certain way and call someone else berehamy for killing an animal another way. Killing an animal is still killing an animal. In my point of view, you're either going to not consume meat or you are. And if you are, you shouldn't justify why you're eating meat slaughtered in a specific way vs another. Just eat and don't judge. Also, my last sentence should be taken lightly as I do not mean to offend anyone or their religious justifications. Just do you and enjoy this life God has blessed us with.
Lovely friend,of you want ti really take care of your health,cut out meat from diet,you are doctor,u know how really bad is.
He Is right from my point of way and guys,animal eats not halal meat and they not have all these problems,this doctor Is saying truth,maybe its clean,but believe me for human body isnt that problem. Dont think human body is that weak!
If i have to eat meat,i prefer not halal for sure. MacDonald,kfc and other serve only that type 😘
@ apologies for a late addition to the comment section. The video is not going into science, it basically states it’s an order, it then mentions about the format of the kill and how compassionate it is.
Generally vegetarian is the order of the day but no one is talking about science or clean meat. It’s the method that is the point to debate!
Just imagine pain and suffering an animal goes through just to satisfy our tounges . This isn't about religion but about humanity in us which has power to reduce someone's suffering no other creature can do that only we can. I know it's hard to leave meat but at least we must have an intent slowly our intent will manifest in action.
I don't agree with your logic..
It's scientifically proved that animal felt no pain while done Islamic slaughter....
Must watch a video I'm sharing the link..
ua-cam.com/video/982culi7rpw/v-deo.html
@@DrRazwanZafar come on it is a common sense that even if a thick needle pricks in you feel pain what about an animal who is butchered animals are sensitive they have a nervous system it is not about religion just humanity your identity is religious mine is humanity . Studies can be easily manipulated everyone knows it but pain and agony we see can't be manipulated animals can't fake emotions. It is like saying murdering by slicing throat is very humane.
@MOVIE Mines that is a myth. Idiot
Vegetables and plants can also fell they're being cut or eaten and they definitely do release chemicals.
@@rejoanbary2155 plants doesn't have nervous system
if the guru says you cant use a lota to wash your bum, does this mean you have to follow him, even though its good for you?
Sikhs are my favorite people in the world. I believe Sikhs follow the teachings of Guru Sahab better than us Muslims follow the teachings of Prophet Muhammad. That said, I still believe that Halal meat is better for human consumption than Jhatka even though the latter is less cruel to the animal. But again, killing an animal is cruel in itself. If one is concerned about this, they can always go vegan, Prophet Muhammad himself was a very seldom meat eater. Should you choose to eat meat, why not go Halal and make sure that all the blood (containing toxins) drains out. Either way, I appreciate the Sikh philosophy of people kind to animals. Sat Sri Akaal. Jai Hind.
(:
Guru nanak ne bhi Arab me jakr Prophet Muhammad Saw PBUH ki hi shikhai baton pr Amal Kiya. Or Jo sich panj shanana krte he could bhi vuzu ko badal kr or name bdlkr bataya he ...so name badal kr tum ese galat Mt bolo (abhi to tume halal krna bhi nhi pta Kya hota he tum log sirf Jan bujh kr ye kehte ho k chhuri Aram Aram se gle pr ferte he)jhatke se to lakh jga acha he qk blood k sath toxins bahar aa jate he Jo jhatka krne se nahi ate😏
@@gggg-qp5vz How do you know that Guru Nanak Sahib talked about your prophet stop living in fantasy. Guru Nanak Sahib knew God so he did not have to know about your Prophet.
@Chan Chan Man when a butcher is slautering an animal in the halal way the butcher will say allah is the one and only god and god is greatest so when the butcher says that the almighty god makes the animal feel no pain and the animal surrenders to the almighty god so the butcher could slaughter the animal in piece and animal will be relaxed and feel no pain
@@faziahmed310 Doesn't sound like they feel no pain. What if the animal doesn't surrender to Allah, they feel pain?
I really appreciate these videos as someone trying to learn more about Sikhism. Excellent format and I like the info boxes at the top right
Express your religion but with facts! If you don't provide evidence how will others non-belivers follow your religion. Get my point brother
but his claims are false Islam began in the 7th century whereas Sikhism began in the 17th century. If Islam was FALSE then why are there many more Muslims around the world than Sikhs?
@@syedlife1571 whether a religion is false or true has nothing to do with how old a religion is. Islam has more followers because its older...Sikhi is a relatively new religion, how do you expect it to have just as many followers as islam or christianity?
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims.
The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case.
m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 is ur scientific evidence the koran? -_- any person with basic science knowledge will tell u that any method of killing that doesnt iNSTANTLY kill causes suffering to an animal! so stop with this bullshit
As a hindu i respect all Sikhs
Respect Sikhs but not their Cruel Act of Murdering innocent Animals.
Plants don't feel pain but Animals do.
Be #Vegan
@@CEarthling There are no other cruel people than Brahmins.....
@@CEarthling ua-cam.com/video/IH_AZ50Xn2g/v-deo.html
@@CEarthling nonsense
@@CEarthling I also believe in ahimsa
Either Jhatka or halal ...u r killing any animal 🦒...I don’t think sikhi allow us to have meat 🥩 unless situation is worse .. might be video is not edited so well ... half knowledge _____ might be ... ( personal comment )
you are right
So plants r known to be alive and if humans just eat veg there won't be food left for animals .....also if killing a life is ur concern why not cage up all meat eating animals they r killers too......hope the sharp teeth in ur mouth make some logic to understand meat is imp
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you let then die or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
No disrespect intended but bro you got it twisted. A key function behind the Halal slaughtering method is to minimize the suffering of the slaughtered animal. To the point that the meat of the animal becomes haram (forbidden) to eat once it reaches a specified threshold of suffering.
I dont believe the Guru you are referring to actually advised his followers to stay away from halal meat.
I know
Hindus & Sikhs also not want to eat halal meat but there is very less jhatka meat seller.
No sikhism doesn't allow meat at all
As a hindu I have so much respect for our gurus and our sikh brothers ❤
Waheguru ji da khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh! jai Shri Ram!
Too bad your ppl dont, your rapist genocidial govt dosnt
Your blue cross dresser statue doesn’t care about you lora
As a Sikh, I respect Hinduism too
All non MUSLIM follow guru saheb wahe guru ka KHALSHA
Eating any meat is Bajar kurehat... if someone thinks it's not, then go and try to start preaching at Darbar Sahib. .if our Holiest shrine doesn't cook any meat then it makes it clear that We should be vegetarians
Agreed
Where is the compassion in killing jhatka also? Real compassion is in loving animals and protecting them. We are here on earth with animals. They are not here for us to eat.
when you are a warrior and you are on the run from the persecution of the governments...then you dont live in permanent settlements where you can easily grow food in farms or get a regular supply from market...then you have to eat what ever is available in the forests because that is your hiding spot...ask some paramilitary personell they'll tell you what all they have to eat....there are special excersices where you have to keep a pup as a pet and then you are asked to one day kill it and eat it...at times duty and responsibility towards community are of greater importance...ill put you the same question today suppose you are faced with an apocalypse you have your daughter or children dying of hunger in front of you...will you let then die or feed them something...another question but what if you live for a greater cause you have chosen to raise an army against evil.. now while you are on a run in forests will you choose to survive and execute the task at hand or will you choose to grow weak out of scarcity of food....
Indeed, we should protect all living organisms human, animals, plans everything else.
with all due respect its not true what he said about halal meat scientificaly any one can check
Don’t drink water as well as that is Halal. By the way, halal means permissible, so anything that is allowed and lawful, for example wearing clothing which you rightfully earned and is not stolen. Therefore, we should take our clothes of as well to follow guru
Guru is not against everything halal, just eating meat that is halal... That's the point of this video!
sardarji is best ... till this day i have never seen a bad sikh ...
everyone is nice and honest ...
nepaliman facts
🙏🙏🙏 I'm a hindu this is my 3rd or 4 th video I've watched in your channel. Sikhism is so inspiring 🙏🙏
You are inspired by Murdering of Innocent Animals?
Are you a Sadist or what?
Meat is Murder.
Gurus spread Compassion. & Jhatka Or Halal, it's cruel.
@@CEarthling please explain why do humans have canine teeth? Why can humans digest meat and not rocks? God made us omnivores for a reason. To answer your question the way he talks is inspirational and his words have logic. You can watch his other videos as well. And btw I’m a vegetarian
@@unlockedaccount3902 Gorrillas & Hipposhave way more bigger canines than yours & are almost Vegan.
@@unlockedaccount3902 Carnivores don't have a choice but you as a Human have.
You don't need animal products to survive.
Plants don't feel pain neither they suffer but Animals do.
To feel pain one needs Receptors,Central Nervous System & a Brain which Plants lack but Animals have.
So be kind to Animals be #Vegan
@@CEarthling I agree animals do feel pain mentally and physically if they are slaughtered but when we harvest a field for crops we kill uncountable amount of worms, bugs, insects flies etc so vegetarians and vegans ain’t that clean or pure. It’s like debating over petrol cars vs electric cars one May think electric cars are clean but where does electricity come from? You can’t force anyone to be a carnivore and you can’t force anyone to be a vegan or vegetarian we are made by the creator the way we else he would’ve made us a vegetarian like cows
Excellent all sikhs follow this, no halal
I am a orthodox christian but Ranjeet Sinkh (who was a Sikh) from 1977 show ”Mind your language” brought me here. Before him i had no idea that this religion exists. Learned many things about it.
ua-cam.com/video/J429W7IhUwo/v-deo.html
Watch this about Hinduism
Halal slaughter does not cause pain. Once slaughter happens blood is out from Carotid artery, jugular veins which stops the brain and heart immediately so basically it's dead and feels no pain. Cutting from the back is wrong the animal is still alive the heart and brain are still active because the blood is mostly still there it's just dying a slow painful death. Halal is the only humane and clean way.
ua-cam.com/video/n-qRWNXdIBE/v-deo.html
Before knowing the reasons of why guru ji ate that jhatka .... don't temd to put any question..
No one can match what he has done ... at least respect if u can but fo not oppose 🙏 if anyone can dare to sacrifice their father mothér and children .... then only they are eligible to question up... 🙏
Very true. Never eat halal meat. Remember how tantric Madho Das became a Sikh. Wahe Guruji ka Khalsa Wahe Guruji ki Fateh. Halal has no mercy.
Torture induced animal's emotions & trauma stay or pass of to its DNA enable or making it adversely affect our behaviour to indulge in sadistic behaviour when we consume such meat that's why animal is distracted so that it doesn't undergo stress.
U look too jorjous Simran with beautiful smile.May Waheguru bless u🙏🙏
@Murad Ahmad in halal meat you don't snap the spinal cord instantaneously and the animal feels pain. By the way I am a vegetarian . If at all one has to eat meat , jhatka is always better. Thank you.
Brother halal is the safest way to eat food.. If the vein is cut blood doesn't remains in the body of the animal, blood has so many toxins which are harmful to the health, in jhatka procedure blood remains in the body only and you will consume that.. When it comes to vegetables, they are also living things, it is scientifically proven. So if you see in that way, then by cutting 10 plants one can fill his stomach but by cutting 1 goat 10 people can fill their stomach....So brother please believe on facts...
Stay away from halal meat!
I'm a vegetarian, it is said that prophet Mohammed hardly eat any meat, in fact I believe that he use to fast most of the time.
I enjoy watching your videos, thank you for sharing your knowledge.
How come u are veg
What muslim and Vegetarian? How come you feel empathy for animals? wow!
@@akshayemaithani1541 if you are a veg you know just as well as I... But ok, here are a few reasons: Arguably the meat industry may be even worse, more disgusting and criminal than the arms industry. "We" (humanity) kill around 80 billion land animals every year... This means 80 billion last year, 80 billion this year, and 80 next year etc... This is the worse tragedy of human history - the result of this is a humanitarian (animal) tragedy as well as an ecological tragedy not to mention a spiritual tragedy of the highest order. I won't even mention here the torture of the animals from birth to slaughter... And we don't even need to eat meat, today some of the best athletes in the world are vegan.
There are no doubt many more reasons, please share your thoughts.
@@lokeshjain4278 I know a few Muslims who are vegetarians and many Hindus who eat all kinds of meat. The meaning of the word "muslim" is a person who submits to the will of God and I heard that one of the descendants of Emperor Akbar said that Hinduism and Islam are like two hairs on the same head.
@@faisalhussein1028 That's great to hear from you,actually why I said muslims is bcs most I mean most of muslims are blind followers of a book and they don't dare to think about that,Since eating meat is sunnah,the pain and suffering of a billion animals becomes sunaah for them too,this is ehy it is surprising! And most of the hindus don't follow their religions that's why they do eat it. And even if a hindu youth who follows their religion,if you would speak up with logic ,they would listen but muslims never!
Most videos on UA-cam show wrong videos it's not from our religion but tradition because most people don't practise their faith.And how does the cutting of the throat create pain towards the back of the neck and cutting from the back of the neck does not ?.Thats a stupid thing to say you just asked the question answered it and the rejected it for Guru.
In 'jhatka' way of slaughter the animal's neck need to be cut in one go i.e the neck along with the spine is severed within a second or two. When the nerves of the body don't have any connection with the brain the animal can't sense any pain and dies quickly. Where as in 'halal' way of killing animal's windpipe and major arteires in the the neck are slit open while the nerves are still active. The animal suffers for a long time and dies of blood loss or heart attack due to extreme pain. This is the worst form of torture anyone can bring upon an animal. Because the animal is scared and suffering in 'halal' his body produces so many harmones which are bad for human body.
Halal meat is one of the big reason why muslims have so many diseases and are slower. No western scientists have ever said 'halal' is a good way of slaughter. Even western butchers stun the animal before killing them so that they don't feel much pain.
@@IWillKillSomeDay thank you. finally someone who provided some science.
Our Guru’s have never told us to eat meat. People like this guy manipulate guru’s words just because they want to eat it. Shame on them.
True brother
But
His teaching about Halal meat is genuine.
Wrong, read guru granth sahib. Half knowledge is dangerous
@@magicmusic2077 which Guru Granth Sahib are you reading?
No Guru told us to eat meat
How can Gurubani allow us to eat it?
We should be Vegetarian Or Vegan
how amazing one of the reasons we dont eat harm meat is becoz the slaughtering is done mercilessly and the anmial killed dies becoz of pain.
but u r saying something that is totaly opposit, i think science should be bring into judgment.
anyway not a big issue.
But there needs to be some logic behind certain questions.
There’s no logic behind just saying the guru said so
Brother, thats why islam is right, there is logic in islam.
I am not hatin sikhs, i love them. They are like brothers but with different belief.
@@m.ibrahimkhalid6078 there is logic in islam? You have got to be kidding me! For one to be a muslim you have to give up logic and rational thinking and believe the prophet blindly.
@@Brownpanda369 Don't be a fool. Ask any question and Islam gives the answer.
Absolutely I agree all due respect to sikh brothers, but there is no reasoning in your comment. If you gave the reason why Guruji said so then ppl will follow it more especially the younger generation. Satsriyakal Guruji
@@m.ibrahimkhalid6078 Islam.is way better ths these guru shit
as a sikh! is it anywhere mentioned to eat meat?
no it doesnt, guru ji said no to halal
I think a sikh cant eat even jhatka meat...but akal takht allowed this
It's mentioned somewhere that guru sahib said having quarrel upon eating meat or being vegi is the work of morons
So plants don't have soul they don't feel pain?... Is it more cruel to kill someone who can speak or someone who can't?... This is so ridiculous.
they do feel pain but do you have any other least painful alternative? you make a way from which we can process nutrients and minerals required by human body from stones or solid lifeless matter then we will stop eating plants also.
no plants don't have a soul nor the ability to feel pain, I'm sure if you learned about biology you would know (no biology teacher i've met thinks plants have a soul or can feel pain).
Plants don’t bleed
@@kaurageouswarrior1496 Souls are indefinable, however plants don't experience pain like other living beings. They don't have the sensory system to sense pain unlike animals.
Plants don't have a nervous system to feel pain
This is absolutely false. And for those arguing about this in the comment section, please do some serious research on this topic. RIP sir, but unfortunately you have conveyed inaccurate information. See, it is better to show both sides of the story other than “because the guru said so, we follow it”. That seems out of context and I have many Sikh friends who watched this video and laughed. All respect to this great guru’s, but please realize that we drain the blood and without doing so, you have stuff like mad cow disease, bird flu etc..you will never hear of halal meat being tainted or a recall on it due to salmonella or any other illnesses. In fact, speaking with my Sikh brothers, they have admitted that they would eat halal meat over any other meat, any day! Please do an unbiased research and see the benefits of eating halal meat versus non halal. Open up your minds and stop thinking narrow. It disgust me how people come here talking trash about Muslims, Hindu’s or even Sikhs. And whoever does, you are nothing less than a scum and are the reason why there is hatred and animosity today. Please be mature about the subject and if anyone says anything idiotic, then honestly, your mom has failed society in raising a piece of garbage son or daughter! MK out!
Aside from Halal and Kosher, there is virtually no difference between Sikh food and non-Sikh food, because blood is contained.
Not to say sikh food is specifically sikh food, Vegan foods is more the term.
Nope Sikhism developed in water abundant place where meat can be washed unlike Arabia with hot weather.
Torture induced animal's emotions & trauma stay or pass of to its DNA enable or making it adversely affect our behaviour to indulge in sadistic behaviour when we consume such meat that's why animal is distracted so that it doesn't undergo stress.
Then why is that u only eat halal meat if there no difference.. U make no sense
Sikh should start making jathke meat in Delhi also
It is the sikh guy who 1st faught for jhatka certification in India. In Maharashtra they have maratha punjab meat centre who only has jhatka meat. It runs well there
True sikhs don't eat meat....but when guru sahib went to Nanded in Maharashtra, India many of the local people became sikhs.. However they didn't give up the practice of eating meat... That's why some Sikhs eat meat otherwise IT is COMPLETELY PROHIBITED IN SIKHISM TO EAT ANY KIND OF MEAT
@@GS-ku2gz acha bhai
KING_87 where does it say that ?
@@simranmehtab3757 listen to gyani sant singh ji maskeen's katha on why sikhs shouldn't eat meat
EEG and ECG findings showed there's no pain when slaughtered in halal way
hallal has been misunderstood a lot and true hallal isnt practised anymore painful or painless killing is totally depending upon location to location world has come to a brutal end may the god save us all
It's not misunderstood its right away cruel.
I being a hindu love the way how sikh people are so so soooooo much compassionate..... We all have common things within us the above all common traits lies humanity and some religions in the name of their followers give prefence to giving pain and suffering to others ratger than love and affection..
Bulls*it from this guy and 20th century guru teaching. Scientific evidence shows that the halal method is less painful, keeps the meat fresher for longer and avoids clots in the blood. This is not my words but the studies of Indian doctors who are non-muslims.
The Sikhs in the 20th century cane out with the jhatka method to differentiate from Muslims but spectacularly failed by killing animals in a cruel fashion, read the article and I rest my case.
m.timesofindia.com/science-of-meat/articleshow/11672654.cms
@@salsabila786 Halal is less painful? Are you having a laugh mate? Watch an animal getting slaughtered in the halal fashion and come and say that again. You're blinded with hatred my friend. Wake up.
@@BallyBoy95 read before commenting, did you read the independent research conducted by Christian, Hindu and Atheist Drs in their field. I guess not and you're just ignorant, what else can we expect of Kim Jong Un.
Stop being ignorant and watch the video, the comments and what the response is stating. It's scientific fact that Jhatkha method is more cruel and painful for an animal that halal method
The slaughter process has two stages: Stunning, when performed correctly, causes an animal to lose consciousness, so the animal can't feel pain. The law states that, with few exemptions, all animals must be stunned before 'sticking' (neck cutting) is carried out
@@Abu-Yazid22 Good. I don't care how you kill it, if it's stunned, I'm happy.
Good day.
Ask the animal if it is happy dying with or without pain! Just justifying doesn't help them much or your own reasoning.
I think you are not uneducated when it comes to Halal meat. Here are some simple/general rules of Halal meat that you may missed when you never did the research.
1) the knife that is used must be Sharp and big enough for the slaughter of the animal.
2) the animal that is slaughtered must not thirsty.
3) the animal must not be slaughtered in front of the other animal.
4) the animals head must be chopped off/cut as soon as you can to minimize the pain.
5) the animals being slaughtered must be blessed by reading the special prayer
6) Ones slaughtered, the each part of the animal must be cleaned thoroughly and the blood must be drained out from the system.
7) Pregnant animals must not be slaughtered
And the list goes on....
You big great " NoNo" comes from lack of knowledge my friend.
How can you expect people to accept a religion who's fundamentals cannot be questioned just because someone (i.e Guru) said so?
Peace
Hey stupid … any kind of meat is prohibited in sikhism.. you people r so dumb to understand anything that is why i would rather talk to the walls instead of making muslims understand anything… waheguru ji ka khalsa waheguru ji ki fateh
You have your religion and we have ours and we respect your views, if only you would try your best not shine a bad light upon our views same way we do not on yours... Saying “they do it this way to cause maximum pain” makes it look like Muslims are terrible people, but the reality is that, you kill the animal and eat it and so do we. We all kill the animal and eat it. Just because the methods different it does not mean it should taken out of context. You kill the animal your own way and leave the blood within the animal, which causes LESS pain for the animal but cause MORE harm to yourself, we kill the animal our own way and drain the blood from the animal, which causes the animal the SAME pain but for a little longer and May God make it easy for them, and it causes NO HARM to ourselves, now please ask yourself are we doing better or for worse? The animal leaves the earth, not us, so which one would be the lesser of 2 evils? Causing harm to yourself AND the animal or causing harm to animal BUT no harm to yourself...?
By not questioning the reasons we do things, and simply accepting Guru's teachings, we are falling under the same traps that Guru Nanak Dev Ji warned others against in his lifetime. We would be blindly following rituals like sheep, not understanding the deeper meanings and logic behind whatever we do. We would be like the Hindus offering water that Guru Ji condemned blind ritualism to. I believe in attempting to become a good Gursikh, you have begun to adopt fanaticism along the way and that your influence over many other (mostly younger) Sikhs is giving them false impressions of the truer understanding of the Gurus' teachings.
i agree with you, its also the best way to learn, having a genuine interest, asking why and finding the answer, the lesson will stick with you forever